Actions

Work Header

Episodes from Middle Earth

Chapter 6: Groundhog Adventure

Summary:

Inspired by Groundhog Day. Kili dies in BotFA and wakes up in Bag End. And ends up waking there several times.

Notes:

One not written for the kink meme. Though I think there was a similar prompt out there, but I can't find it anymore.

Multiple character death, violence and bloodshed ahead. It does have a happy ending, though.

Chapter Text

There’s a sword buried in his chest. The pain doesn’t even register – he can only stare in disbelief. Somebody screams his name – it might be Fili, but really, he doesn’t even feel anything – and then the world goes dark.

***

When he comes to, he is asleep on an armchair in Bilbo Baggins’ living room. The entire scene is terribly familiar, and Kili feels frozen, out of touch for the reminder of the day. Around him life continues along a terribly familiar pattern.

They leave; Bilbo follows. There’s the incident with the handkerchief and they stop in the middle of a forest to spend the night. Kili doesn’t understand what is happening – did he dream the battle and everything else, is this a dream or what is it?

Nobody else notices.

Only Fili asks him if he’s alright, since he was acting out of it. Kili claims a bad dream the night before, and Fili tells him it’s his own fault for eating too much the night before. Lacking an idea of what to do, Kili plays along, but it sometimes feels as if he isn’t remembering the script.

And then things begin to change.

It is subtle at first. When Bofur says something unexpected, or Balin’s tales change. Bombur cooks something different, yet time flies by. Kili isn’t certain what to do – by now he thinks that this probably is no dream, and if the other events – including his own death – were merely a product of his mind, it was a terribly lucid one.

He does not dare to think of it as a vision.

And then they encounter the trolls. But instead of having a hale hobbit tossed at him, this one was injured. Kili knows it the moment he catches Bilbo’s weight and the hobbit makes a very odd sound. And then stays down instead of getting up.

Only after the battle is concluded – this time they manage to incapacitate the trolls long enough to escape – they have time to have closer look at their burglar. There’s blood on his lips now, and every breath rattles his chest.

Broken ribs, Oin diagnoses.

Later, when Bilbo has dosed off, he adds “and possibly internal injuries, too.”

The next day Bilbo is in no condition to walk, can barely speak and keeps coughing up blood. Kili feels terrible – how could this have happened? Couldn’t he, recognizing the situation, have done anything?

They march on, and in the afternoon Bilbo develops a fever. Gandalf urges them to head to Rivendell, and with Bilbo’s condition worsening fast, Thorin has no choice but to agree.

At least they are not being followed by orcs this time, Kili thinks.

And yet, when Rivendell is still half a day away, Bilbo dies quietly. It’s Dori who calls them to a stop, and once they all have turned he looks at the silent bundle in his arms. “He’s gone,” he announces.

Gandalf hurries over to confirm, but Kili has no reason to doubt Dori’s judgment. He also feels terrible. And responsible.

Thorin now sees no need to continue on to Rivendell. Gandalf furiously responds that he will take the hobbit there on his own – the least he deserves is a decent funeral, and from the shifting feet Kili knows many of the company agree with the wizard.

They split paths.

By nightfall, the orcs catch up with the dwarves.

This time Kili fails to block an arrow that tears right through his throat.

***

His first thought upon waking is that this was a horrible way to die, and he’ll make certain to avoid it from now on. The painful burn of blood in his lungs, tightness of his chest and taste of copper in his mouth. He shudders, and also thinks of Bilbo’s face, white and still in death.

Not again, he promises himself.

This time he takes extra care to be cheerful. And when they run into the trolls, he makes certain they inform Thorin first – even before the trolls can steal the ponies.

Nobody dies in this battle, but Fili receives a nasty cut on his arm. It bleeds heavily, but after changing the dressing three times during the night, it ultimately stops. After that the injury is hidden under long sleeves, and the flush Fili develops in Rivendell can be easily explained by the unfamiliar fare and the rich wine.

They’re half-way up the first mountain pass when Fili collapses with a fever. He’s sweating and delirious, and while the old injury may be healing, Oin eventually concludes that the blade must have been poisoned.

Kili is completely besides himself – how could he have missed his brother’s worsening condition? Has he allowed himself to grow so distracted that now his brother has to pay the price?

“Everything but this,” Kili mutters in a silent prayer to whatever deity is willing to listen. But none does, and Fili dies in the night, with Thorin openly crying over the cooling body.

Kili walks away from the group, glances across the silent landscape under the unclouded night sky. Middle Earth seems tranquil, beautiful, and he can’t even cry – his heart is unwilling to believe this happened, unwilling to accept he missed this.

He doesn’t allow himself to think further. He knows he can’t continue like this.

So he intentionally steps too far and lets himself fall off the mountain side.

***

Falling is not a bad way to die, Kili realizes the next time around. Sitting and watching others die is worse – even now when he looks at Fili he can see his face pale in death. This time around he tries to the best of his abilities not to let anything happen differently.

It is unexpectedly difficult, because he is not reliving these moments for the first time, and the memories begin to overlap each other. Still, they make it past the trolls, escape the orc pack and get to Rivendell without any obvious alterations.

Kili can’t help the tension he feels – he knows Fili worries, but he doesn’t know how to share his secret.

And then, when they’re escaping from the goblin tunnels, Dwalin takes a blow meant for Kili and the young dwarf can only watch in frozen horror as Dwalin and the goblin fall from the bridge and disappear in the darkness.

Fili grabs his sleeve and drags him away before Kili can bring himself to follow Dwalin. He barely registers what is happening around him.

Everything went so well – and then…

He must have missed it because he was so nervous, Kili thinks while his feet go through the motions. They’re falling and running, and fighting, and nobody seems to notice that Kili isn’t all there.

And somehow, the dynamics completely shift.

The orc pack is upon them much earlier, and the eagles arrive too late. Dori and Ori fall to their death, only Nori’s echoing shout their companion. Bilbo jumps into the fray to save Thorin, but no dwarf arrives in time to save him – the Pale Orc smashes his weapon against the hobbit’s head, and the small thing stays down, the ground underneath slowly turning red.

Ten dwarves and one wizard are saved by the eagles. And even if Thorin lives, no joy is to be found. Balin waves away any comforting overtures made in his direction and proceeds to sit away from the group; Nori is furious and can’t help that his anger brings forward tears.

Kili stays silent, his heart still icy cold with terror.

They continue, though Kili doesn’t know why or how. Fili tries to encourage him, but even he looks pale, and with true fear Kili wonders if he has to watch his brother die again. They do not visit Beorn, but head directly into Mirkwood.

And to the spiders.

Kili fights as long as he can, but then there’s a sting in his thigh, and the world goes dark.

***

He wakes, once again, on the armchair in Bag End.

The spiders must have eaten them, Kili thinks, and shudders. It’s luck he never woke up, but the image leaves him disturbed.

It’s early, too – none of the other dwarves are awake yet, and the sun is only beginning to rise. Kili pushes himself up, stretching his arms and wondering just how he is supposed to get out of this nightmarish cycle.

This time he resolves to be proactive.

Prior to setting up camp, Kili points out the clues the trolls have left. The company successfully overwhelms them, and helps themselves to the weapons and gold. They don’t encounter Radagast, but make it to Rivendell. The stone giants and goblins can be avoided by leaving Rivendell a day earlier, and the fateful encounter with the Pale Orc does not occur, either.

Kili’s mood brightens then. They have suffered no injuries, are making good time and the mood is pleasant. The spiders do not trouble them either.

And then, in a vicious turn-about, their good health becomes their downfall. One moment they are wandering through Mirkwood, rations low but not depleted, and Kili knows the exit is not far any more.

They happen onto an elf patrol.

The ensuing fight is vicious.

Kili doesn’t quite remember who first drew their weapons, but he recalls the elves accusing them of trespassing their territory, and weapons being drawn. Bilbo throws himself forward, shouting for everybody to calm down.

And by accident of intention, receives a knife in his back for the effort. Blood tints the ground red. The dwarves have the greater numbers, but the elves know the territory and have not had to ration their food. Neither are they exhausted.

And when an elvish blade slices through Oin’s neck like paper, Kili’s stomach twists. He blocks a strike aimed at his own head, and ducks away, but his heart is pounding and his mind spins.

A gurgle to his left and he sees an arrow piercing Bofur’s chest. There’s blood dripping from the dwarf’s lips as he tries to say something before he collapses. Kili watches in frozen desperation. Several steps ahead, Bifur flies into a rage, and takes four elves down before one blade cuts his throat.

“Thorin!” Balin yells and Kili turns to see his uncle on his knees.

For a moment he wonders what is wrong with that picture. Then Thorin pitches forward and Kili sees at least three arrows buried in his back.

Dread settles in his stomach.

This is lost, he realizes, this is all lost.

Swallowing against his tightening throat, he turns the blade against himself. He hasn’t yet dared to end it quite like this. Not yet – but he won’t let himself be cut down by the elves either. His hands are trembling, yet he forces himself to breathe deeply.

And then pushes the sword through his stomach.

It burns viciously, and makes his vision darken. When it clears again, he’s on the ground and Fili hovering over him.

If there is one thing he knows, he never wants to see this particular expression on Fili’s face again.

***

The next attempt ends prematurely at the hands of the trolls. Kili deviates from the pattern, attempting to change things for the better. It ends with Bilbo unconscious and Kili having to watch as the trolls boil his companions.

He is grateful when they crush his chest accidentally.

***

Kili now has too many reasons to have nightmares to sleep. He awakens at Bag End, and resolves only to do what he must and no more. While this strategy does not save them from the close encounters, it gets them far – over the Misty Mountains, through Mirkwood and into Laketown.

Then the boats sink.

***

One of the most horrible moments occurs when they have reached Erebor and instead of letting Bilbo go with Gandalf, Thorin drives Orcrist through the hobbit’s chest. It’s not an instant death, and the heart-breaking expression on Bilbo’s face in those last moments burns itself on the back of Kili’s eyelids.

Fili and him die in the battle – dwarves against men and elves – long before the orcs arrive. He doesn’t particularly care to wake up again.

***

Then there is the incident where Smaug incinerates them all. They did not manage to close the door in time – or rather, Smaug is upon them too early, and Bilbo not conscious to warn them.

Thankfully, it is quicker than even Bofur’s words suggested. There is no pain.

***

Kili becomes notably silent and withdrawn. When he looks upon the faces of his friends, he invariably cannot help but recall the many horrible ways he has seen them die in. Twisted limbs, charred faces and blood-soaked garments.

Fili and Thorin worry, especially when the nightmares set in.

And when they’ve very barely made it to Rivendell, Kili can’t bear it anymore. He chooses Elrond of all people, to confess his secret to, but the elf lord is as mystified as Kili feels.

“There is a task you must fulfill, then,” he concludes, “And until you have fulfilled it, you will continue to relive this.”

Kili wonders if this task is supposed to be winning back Erebor with everybody alive. Which is, to be honest, in his very own interest, so he nods, takes a deep breath and steels his resolve.

It surprises many when Kili abruptly takes an interest in planning their routes. And it takes much convincing for Thorin to accept the suggested alterations – but eventually Kili is happy that they skirt the giants, goblins and spiders as far as possible.

The detour is lengthy, but they are making good time. And the land yields rich foods and little trouble, so Kili’s heart begins to feel lighter.

Until one evening they stumble over the fortress of Dol Guldur.

It does not feel abandoned.

That night, temperatures drop farther than they ought to this time of the year. Kili can see his own breath misting in the air. Bombur has first watch, but sleep does not come. It is eerily quiet around them, almost ominously so.

Kili wakes moments later; his body stiff with cold, to the sound of Balin’s rasping breath. Blood covers the dwarf’s chest, but what transfixes his eyes is the ghostly creature standing over him. It is not a ghost, but neither is it mortal.

And Dwalin’s axe passes right through it.

The thing – it has two arms, two legs and its skull looks almost human – swats Dwalin aside like a fly, not even bothering to look whether he stays down (and he does.  Kili can’t see whether his chest rises and falls).

With a yell, the rest of the company is upon their otherworldly opponent. And it is useless. Bifur is thrown against a pillar and Nori collapses, blood blossoming from a chest wound. Kili hangs back, frozen – Orcrist and Sting glow, even though there are no orcs around.

The strange being’s blade also cuts easily through armor. Fili looks just as surprised as the rest of the company, before his eyes roll back and he falls. Kili’s arrow passes right through the being’s ghostly frame – only Orcrist’s stike is blocked.

There’s an odd echo to the ring when those two blades clash. It’s nothing Kili has heard before, and the air is still so dreadfully cold. Something isn’t right, he thinks, something about this is wrong, beyond the evil of goblins and orcs.

Before him, the other members of the company continue to crumble.

Kili contemplates taking Sting from Bilbo – the hobbit clutches the blade in desperation – but then decides to let things be. When the being turns upon him, he doesn’t defend himself.

***

And yet, the sense of marrow-deep cold follows him to Bag End. Something evil clung to that creature, something not-human – and Kili knows he will risk no other detour again. Not if these are the dangers lurking outside of the road.

Instead he will take his chances with whatever powers are making him relive this.

He forces the company to wait – Thorin is not happy, and Gandalf surprised, but Kili’s sudden serious demeanor stays their protests – and once Bilbo has prepared breakfast he shares his memories. Even surrounded by incredulous faces, Kili feels a lot of better. Bearing this burden in silence is nothing he can do any longer, not when he only sees his friends and family die.

Dori is the first one to inquire if Kili’s certain this is not a very vivid nightmare – which is nothing shameful, he hurries to assure, most warriors suffer from them. Gandalf coughs and clears his throat.

“I have never heard of something like this,” the wizard admits, “Yet I do think it might be wise to follow Master Kili’s lead in this.”

They depart with a far greater deal of caution, and no small sense of perturbation. Kili is perhaps the only one happy, and only too willing to answer Balin’s and Gandalf’s questions when they confer with him for details.

Yet Fili is the one to draw him into his arms that night, and for the first time in a very long while Kili sleeps a good night’s sleep. He awakes the next morning in far better spirits, though his companions do not share them.

The trolls are hardly a worry this time. Trickery to lead them into the daylight, and the treasure is theirs. Still, they make certain to set up camp elsewhere.

Thorin and most are still hesitant to travel to Rivendell, especially when there is no orc pack chasing them – and as Kili already knows the location of the hidden door.  Yet Gandalf, Balin and even Thorin agree that there are apparently certain events in Kili’s tale that must come to pass. Bilbo comments he would have liked to meet Radagast and Gandalf frowns, recalling the parcel Kili mentioned.

Things are changing, again, and Kili can only hope this won’t end in a disaster.

Knowing what they do, they avoid the Thunder Battle, but not the goblins. It is uncomfortable, and Kili is scratched by a blade, yet the fight in itself seems a bit easier for him from one time to the next. At least, as long as his opponents stay in the same positions.

He is glad when Bilbo rejoins them on the outside. All of them are – Kili has only once heard the tale of what happened to the hobbit beneath the mountain, yet without his magical ring the quest is bound to fail. They all know this, which is why there are no harsh words this time. Only Bilbo who keeps looking unconvinced at the part he must play.

Much as it is an indication of them being on time, Kili is not happy to hear the wargs bowl.

This time, though, Gandalf is quicker to call the eagles. And with Kili, Fili and Balin clinging to his coat, Thorin does not leave the tree to confront Azog. They win no victory there, but at least they all escape unharmed.

They can’t avoid the spiders of Mirkwood, but they stay on the path and meet no elves. Rationing their food early on helps to make it last much longer, though the company has difficulties retaining their good cheer. Kili can’t look at his brother during those last days – the gaunt, pale features remind too much of how Fili had looked in death.

But then they are out, and well-received in Laketown. Kili informs Bard of Smaug’s weakness right away – perhaps then the devastation won’t be as dire.

Events, however, have been altered too far for this to come to pass. It is not Bard who slays Smaug, it is Kili himself. Instead of hiding inside the tunnel, he has hidden himself in one of the old guard houses, Thorin and Fili not too far, both with bow and arrow. Bilbo is wearing his ring and shouting at the dragon, drawing it closer and yet keeping it from striking.

Kili’s heart is racing as he quietly notches the arrow.

“So what good will your dwarves do, then? Do they not see my armor, oh barrel-rider?” Smaug inquires.

Bilbo replies: “Your armor glitters most bewitchingly in the sun, dragon-under-the-mountain.”

“Perhaps it has blinded them,” Smaug replies.

Bilbo continues with compliments and small riddles, while Kili takes aim. Thorin mirrors his movements, but it is Kili who sees the dragon’s weakness.

He breathes in.

And fires the arrow.

Smaug screeches, and a ball of fire erupts from his jaw. The mountainside is tumbling, and Kili’s world dissolves into a mix of fiery red and black.

When he comes to, he is many meters further down, half buried by rubble. Nearby, Thorin and Fili have started digging themselves out, groaning, but clearly uninjured.

“Is he…” Kili asks, rooted to the spot. There’s smoke rising from down below.

“Dead,” Fili replies, “Brilliant shot, little brother.”

And the expression on Thorin’s face is beyond words, really. It makes it worth having lived through so many deaths and disasters to see Thorin smile at him with so much pride and happiness that Kili feels his heart must burst.

There is one last hiccup at the battle of the five armies. Thranduil and Dain are much slower to arrive as no war appears imminent – until the elves show up Kili is not even certain Thranduil will come – yet offering Bard and the Laketown citizens refuge in Erebor is a wise move.

The battle is still hard and many die. Kili spends the entirety of it fearing for Fili’s life, but they both make certain not to wander far from the main host. And by combining their efforts with Dwalin’s, they can keep Thorin from chasing after Azog as well.

Heavy wounds are suffered, but Kili has never felt happier than once the battle is done.

And when the sun rises on the reclaimed kingdom, Kili smiles.

“Breakfast’s ready,” Fili calls out from behind him.

Kili casts on last glance at the sunrise – the clear sky seems full of promise this morning – before he turns and limps after his brother.

Fin