Chapter Text
Hamfast Gamgee does not like dwarves. It’s not an especially new conclusion, nor a recent development – Hamfast, like most his fellow hobbits, is weary of strangers. Not because he believes them to mean ill or be dangerous, but for the far more practical reason that unknown habits easily produce grief and misunderstandings.
And in the Shire, misunderstandings and really, any sort of disturbance to the tranquil landscape, are unwelcome. So hobbits avoid dealing with strangers, even if they may enjoy tales of faraway countries and past heroics to accompany a hearty meal on a warm summer’s night. In the end, the peace of the Shire is what is home, and tales are just tales. And that is fine.
Hamfast is no different in this. He thinks he might like to meet an elf, at least they sound nice in those tales. Men are slightly more familiar – some of his relatives regularly deal with them in Bree, and Hamfast likes them well enough. Like with hobbits, he likes some more than others, but some of their customs in general leave him bemused. Perhaps it comes with being tall, he thinks to himself.
He hasn’t heard much about dwarves, but that their crafts must be fantastic and their kingdoms splendid. Hamfast thinks the wares on Hobbiton’s market are splendid enough for his likening, and he has some difficulty imagining how the dark interior of a mountain could be a sparkling kingdom.
Then comes the day when Bilbo Baggins vanishes after a rag-tag group of dwarves and the Shire is in an uproar. Hamfast himself hears the tale of Bilbo shouting “I’m going on an adventure”, and if he didn’t know the hobbit telling it so well, he’d be inclined to think him a liar.
After all, one of the Bracegirdles who saw some of the dwarves commented how they looked worn, grim and not at all trustworthy. So perhaps they kidnapped poor Bilbo – it’s not a secret that the hobbit has inherited a considerable fortune. Lobelia instantly offers to check upon Bilbo things and Hamfast, familiar with the odd relationship of Bilbo and Lobelia, steps in, saying he will care for the smial in the meantime.
As he cleans the smial his thoughts start turning. There is not much in disarray – it certainly doesn’t look as if a fight occurred here, but then again, he doubts Bilbo would have tried to fight an armed opponent. There are, however, a number of small clues suggesting Bilbo left in a hurry.
If he is really off to an adventure…
Hamfast can’t help the soft smile spreading over his face.
He had already been a teen when Bilbo was worn, and much as his own younger siblings, Bilbo had wormed his way into his heart. It hadn’t hurt that Bilbo, unlike some of his cousins, had never particularly cared much for the social hierarchies of the Shire. He’d certainly learned to act his part as he grew up, yet Hamfast remained probably his closest confidant after his parents’ death.
And that had been a bitter blow. Hamfast remembers wondering how Bilbo felt – just past his majority, without any close relations and yet so many responsibilities and expectations. When, at least to Hamfast, Bilbo was still that small, well-spoken and incredibly kind young hobbit.
That now had run after a group of dwarves.
Well, Hamfast also remembers a young hobbit telling him how he’d like to go and see the folks and countries his books (already then not all of them written in a script Hamfast could read). Hopefully then, this adventure will brighten that smile that dimmed with Belladonna’s death again.
***
Bilbo returns one year later, just at the moment when Lobelia finally had him declared dead and his possessions put up for auction. Hamfast protested it fiercely, but in the end he holds none of the sway Lobelia does, and by now it’s not only her interested in a repartitioning of the Baggins’ fortune.
Hamfast stays back during the initial uproar. He does not hear what is said, instead takes the time to observe this very changed Bilbo Baggins.
The most striking are the foreign clothes. Most is hidden under an inconspicuous travel cloak – one that still is well made, trimmed with fur and held together by clasp that may be bronze, but may also be gold and is inlaid with a fine gemstone.
Underneath Hamfast spies rich blue fabric, golden trims and a hint of white silk. It screams of foreign finery, but what becomes more obvious then, is how thick and padded those clothes are. And that Bilbo’s cheeks are not gaunt, but his cheekbones are far more pronounced than Hamfast remembers them being.
He is thin, Hamfast realizes, unbecomingly so.
His manner, at least from afar, in negotiating with a furious Lobelia, an uncomfortable Otho and an exasperated Fortinbras Took remains genial, although he appears changed. It might be the weight loss impacting on Hamfast’s perception, yet this Bilbo Baggins appears harsher than the one that left the Shire.
It’s good for it ensures Lobelia won’t walk all over him, nor will any of the others abuse his kindness.
But for Hamfast, who had hoped for Bilbo to return with a wide smile and sparkling eyes, this is almost a disappointment. Yet it is also a hint that this adventure may have not gone easily. There’s a bandage peeking out from underneath a long sleeve when Bilbo raises his hand to gesticulate.
And Hamfast thinks he doesn’t like dwarves, because the adventure they brought Bilbo on did not go well. (Because he perhaps had hoped that they could achieve what he never managed).
***
Once the shadows lengthen, Hamfast announces to his family that he will set off to Bag End and visit Master Baggins. Technically, Bilbo is still his employer, and for that at least – if not for their former friendship – Hamfast wants to go.
Bell calls for him to wait a moment; she’ll provide him with some cake and sweets – because “you saw how thin he got. That’s really unacceptable,” - and his children ask him just from where Master Baggins returned, and did he meet elves? Hamfast can only shrug and then has to promise he will find out.
Upon his knock (not the first, but he knows Bilbo sometimes ignores knocking when he doesn’t want visitors. The trick is to remain persistent. Bilbo has never been patient in this, and a number of hobbits know).
“Master Baggins,” he calls out, hoping his voice will still be familiar.
He doesn’t like it, but he is nervous. What if Bilbo changed so much he doesn’t really remember his gardener? What if somewhere on the quest he decided he would be well rid of this improper company?
The door opens, and Bilbo smiles at him from under too-long curls. “Hamfast!” he exclaimed, and the smile makes his face, thin as it is, glow, “It’s good to see you. I thought I saw you earlier, but you disappeared before I could greet you. But what’s with this Master Baggins nonsense?”
Hamfast smiles in return and shrugs, slightly embarrassed. He really oughtn’t have doubted Bilbo like that.
“Anyhow, do come in. I was just preparing a bite, and you’re welcome to join me. I hope you don’t mind the mess, though, I didn’t really manage to get settle yet,” Bilbo continues and waves Hamfast along to the kitchen.
In passing, he spies several bundles scattered along the entrance, most of them still tied close. There’s one in the kitchen, sitting next to a lonely plate that has been unwrapped and some its contents spewed on the table.
Upon Bilbo’s invitation, Hamfast takes a plate and a very small amount of food. The entire meal is tiny, far too tiny to even start filling his stomach. Bilbo, however, seems undisturbed. When Hamfast procures the pies, he chuckles and apologizes for the state of his pantry – there hadn’t yet been an opportunity to go shopping, and Hamfast feels relieved.
Now that the traveling cloak is gone, the weight loss is far more obvious. And even though the skin on Bilbo’s hands still looks soft, they now bear faint scars. There is a sword leaning against the wall, and while its presence perturbs Hamfast, Bilbo doesn’t even think about its presence.
It tells Hamfast a lot. Somehow this adventure must have familiarized Bilbo with weapons to the point that he doesn’t think anything of dropping one in his own kitchen. He tries and fails to imagine Bilbo using it – the image of a hobbit wielding a sword still seems bizarre.
The rest of the clutter is just as odd. Foreign currencies in gold, silver and bronze, a notebook, maps, three valuable-looking beads, letters, a wooden toy horse and a number of objects Hamfast doesn’t readily recognize.
“It’s good to have you back,” he tells Bilbo after a while.
The hobbit smiles up from his food. In the candle light, the shadows underneath his eyes look darker, still.
“It’s good to be back,” he answers, “Thank you for taking care of Bag End while I was gone.”
“’twas nothing,” Hamfast says.
“How are your children?” Bilbo asks, and pushes his plate away. A part of Hamfast worries – hobbits ought to eat more, but he knows better than to push this subject.
“Shooting up like weeds,” he laughs, “With stomachs like bottomless pits. My oldest asked where you went, actually.”
Bilbo laughs, but a shadow crosses his face. “Quite a good distance away,” he replies in good humor, as if he didn’t even notice the shadow himself, “The kingdom of Erebor, to be precise.”
The name is unfamiliar, and Bilbo’s smile widens. “If he wants to, he’s welcome to visit. I could show him on a map --- as a matter of fact, why don’t you bring your entire family over for tea tomorrow? I’ll make certain my pantry is re-stocked, then.”
Hamfast hesitates to agree. Bilbo looks exhausted and more in need of rest than of company, but his cheer at the prospect is genuine.
***
Indeed, Hamfast’s children are the ones to first draw details of Bilbo’s adventure from the hobbit’s lips. To Bell and Hamfast he’s been polite, but rather vague – mentioning that he had been involved in battle, yes, and suffered injuries, too – thankfully none grave or permanent.
But it’s his sons who first hear the tale of the trolls. The children listen with rapt fascination, and break into giggles when Bilbo tells them how he suggested for the trolls to “skin them first”. There’s more incredulous laughter when Bilbo imitates a shout of “mine are the biggest parasites” and how the trolls, upon seeing the wizard asked “can we eat him, too?”
Bell and Hamfast listen with polite smiles, but Hamfast thinks that as light-hearted as the tale is, it can’t have been a humorous experience. To have been threatened by a troll… he shudders.
It doesn’t really get better.
His younger son absolutely adores tales of Radagast and his bunny-drawn sled. It goes to the point that Hamfast catches him trying to construct rabbit-sizes harnesses, and asks, again and again, for Bilbo to tell how Radagast tricked the wargs and orcs.
Hamfast wonders how Bilbo and his dwarf companions got out of the situation. It is one of the details Bilbo does not include in his tales.
“Erebor’s a dwarf kingdom, isn’ it?” Hamfast eldest asks one afternoon, “I foun’ somethin’ ‘bout it in a book. Said ‘twas taken by a dragon, though.”
Bilbo’s smile remains soft, as always when it’s directed at the children. His eyes, Hamfast observes, glaze over.
“Yes, it was a splendid kingdom, and I suppose by now it is so again,” there’s something achingly wistful in his eyes, and Hamfast wonders what happened.
“So wha’ happen’d to the dragon?” Hamfast’s son asks, “Did you kill it?”
Bilbo’s lips twitch. “Not quite – I don’t believe it would have been possible. You see, the dragon had teeth as long as my arm, and could breathe fire.”
“So wha’ did you do? How come the dragon’s gone now – did he leave? Was there a fight?” The boy’s eyes sparkle with excitement fueled by too many tales of noble deeds and famous heroes.
And Bilbo sees no need to disillusion the child entirely. “Well, you know, there were only fourteen of us, so we really couldn’t have fought the dragon. Instead, I snuck in.”
Hamfast’s breath catches. Sneak up on a dragon? He may not be learned on all the creatures of Middle Earth, but that does not sound like a feat to make light of.
“Why didn’t one of the dwarves go?” Bell asks, her voice congenial and curious. Hamfast wonders the same – why did thirteen dwarves, all experiences warriors one way or another, send forward one hobbit to confront their enemy.
“The dragon had a fine nose,” Bilbo replies, “And it was well accustomed to the scent of dwarves. Not hobbits, though.” With a small shrug he turns back to the children.
“The first time, the dragon never noticed me, and I stole a golden cup directly from its horde,” Bilbo continues, his voice light as if retelling an incident of stealing apples from one of the Bolger’s apple trees, “But dragons are very aware, and Smaug more than others. He noticed at ones that something had gone missing. So the second time, he merely pretended to be asleep.”
The children lean forward eagerly, while Hamfast feels cold sweat forming on his back.
“He was furious, but also curious. And dragons love mysteries and compliments – they are very vain creatures. So I talked to Smaug and talked and he did show me his weakness – a spot on his belly that had neither armor nor was it hidden under scales or jewels, soft as a newborn’s skin.”
“I did, however, laugh at Smaug eventually. And if there is one thing that is a bad idea in this world, than it is to laugh at a dragon,” Bilbo concludes with a self-depreciating smile, “I barely escaped and even then my hair ends were scorched.”
Hamfast is reeling with horror. His sons still want to know what happened to the dragon.
“It was slain by Bard of Laketown,” Bilbo says, “Smaug left the mountain in search for us, and when he did not find us, he left for the town. Bard saw his weak spot and through his skill with the bow managed to slay it.”
Bilbo’s eyes say there’s a grim tale behind this. One he won’t tell the children. Nor one that he tells any other hobbit that asks.
***
While Bilbo’s adventure is a scandal among the Shire’s gentry, it’s an absolute favorite with the children. And once the adults note that Bilbo takes care not to scare his young audience, he becomes a popular guest at celebrations.
In this way, Hamfast learns the details.
For example, that one of the dwarves – named Bofur – did not lose his hat through all the trials they encountered.
That in east of the Misty Mountains lives a large skin changer by the name Beorn, one who is powerful ally, but not easy to win over.
That there are gigantic spiders living in Mirkwood, which in itself is a bewitched place. Its rivers cause a deep sleep and fantastic dreams; while its foliage is so thick no wind penetrates it.
He almost envies Bilbo for having seen Rivendell and met Lord Elrond. Thranduil of Greenwood sounds less likeable, considering Bilbo and the dwarves had to escape from his dungeons in wine barrels. This particular story is one of the absolute favorites, and come summer, Hamfast more than once catches sight of hobbits of all ages trying to navigate their way through the shallow rivers in barrels.
After a while, some of the dwarves sound sympathetic, too. Hamfast likes Balin – the figure of an old, wise advisor, and strangely Dwalin, too. If only for Bilbo’s throw away comment of having caught Dwalin with his hand in Bilbo’s cookie jar. Though apparently, the appendage had been too large to actually fit.
The tales are full of incredible creatures – Stone Giants, Goblins, giant Eagles and odd mountain dwellers that have to be defeated in a contest of riddles – amazing deeds and distant places. But they are also riddled with holes, and the more Hamfast listens, the more he notices them.
Bilbo does not gain back the roundness he had when he left, and sometimes Hamfast catches him staring longingly toward the east. He appears sad then, heartbroken, and Hamfast wonders just what the dwarves did to him.
Fili and Kili sound nice, though, if only for being young and enthusiastic. Bilbo does not talk much of them, nor does he say much of their leader – the King – and it’s only a question of time until one of the older hobbits asks.
“They fell,” Bilbo replies evenly, though under the table he clenches his fingers around the fabric of his trousers, “They fell in the battle of the five armies, just outside of Erebor.”
The battle is never part of Bilbo’s tales. It only ones is mentioned when one of the children asks if Bilbo got hurt – or has some impressive scar like some of the men in Bree, and Bilbo replies that he did get knocked around a bit, but that’s about it.
Hamfast wonders if Bilbo is not merely editing, but also lying. He can tell by now that there is one large scar all across Bilbo’s heart.
***
Bilbo does never fill the gaps, and Hamfast does not ask. He has an idea that some memories may be too painful to relive, and would still rather see Bilbo happy than grieved by bygones.
He still learns a number of little things. A year after Bilbo’s return he is sent a wagon load full of treasure chests, each filled with gold, gemstones and jewelry. The accompanying letters remain private, but Hamfast overhears the leader of the company guarding the treasure mentioning “reparations for past wrongs committed against you” and “I can’t take them back, my life would be forfeit with my King”.
Hamfast wonders what wrongs exactly the dwarves committed against Bilbo. But he’s happy enough that they realized it and are trying to apologize in their own way. He still thinks they should not have taken Bilbo along, or at least ensured, he walked from it with fewer grievances to bear.
The beads Hamfast spied that first evening are crafted from mithril, the most precious of all metals in medal earth. One of the books one of his now three sons brings home explains how beads are sacred to dwarves, and those with family seals only exchanged between family and lovers.
The blade is of ancient elvish make, though it’s engraving far more recent. It’s strange to think that Bilbo bears a named blade, like only the heroes of old legends do. It is kept in pristine condition, and Bilbo sometimes wears it when he travels – his movements, when he shows it to curious visitors, display that he knows how to use it, that he is familiar with that blade.
Curiosities and riches ensure Bilbo’s popularity in the Shire and among some a small degree of envy. Hamfast thinks those hobbits have to be blind, because no matter what Bilbo gained, what he lost on that adventure obviously had been far more precious.
***
One day in spring Bilbo asks Hamfast accompany him on a trip to Bree.
“You see, I promised to meet a dwarf – not one I have known directly, and I would be glad for company,” he explains and offers a handsome reward, since “I know Bell is with child, and it would be really impractical, but I am somewhat at a loss as for whom to ask.”
Hamfast is not interested in the reward. He would rather look after Bilbo – who is not all that good at it himself – because he knows his wife is more than capable of caring for herself. And indeed, she tells him to go along, and promises to ask one of her sisters to stay over in the meantime.
On the way to Bree Bilbo tells him he promised to meet Thorin’s sister, the only one with a stronger claim to Erebor’s throne than even its current King. Hamfast’s first reaction is to fret, because he’s dressed for travel, not for meeting fine people – though in honesty, he doesn’t think he owns any clothes nice enough to meet Kings and Queens.
They check in at the Prancing Pony, yet Bilbo explains they won’t be meeting Dis, sister to the late Thorin, King under the Mountain, there.
It’s the first time after his return that Bilbo wears foreign clothes. Not the ones he wore on his arrival, but a much more splendid set that almost seems to imitate hobbit style. Noting Hamfast’s curious eyes, Bilbo shrugs.
“They arrived with the treasure chests. The accompanying letter suggested they were for better occasions during travel – preferable to borrowing the clothes of human children, certainly,” he explains while he leads Hamfast into the direction of one impressive town house with brightly lit windows.
The light catches the highlights in Bilbo’s hair, and the ornate decorations on his clothes. Some of them look to be real gemstones, and Hamfast falls a step behind Bilbo as they approach the two armed dwarves guarding the door.
“What is your purpose?” one inquires harshly.
Bilbo remains calm. “My name is Bilbo Baggins and I have been invited to meet Dis, daughter of Thrain, son of Thror, here tonight.”
Instantly, the dwarf’s features transform. Cold mistrust is replaced by marvel, and he bows his head.
“Apologies, Master Baggins. You are being expected upstairs.”
Hamfast is distracted by the splendid interior, but he doesn’t miss the way Bilbo clenches and unclenches his fists, worries his lip and takes several deep breaths. A pair of wide-open double-winged doors let into a room that occupies the entirety of the second floor.
The smell of rich food is in the air, and Hamfast startles at the number of guards motionless in the shadows. On the other side, large windows lead out onto a spacious balcony.
A lone dwarf – dressed much more finely than all the others – raises from the table.
“Bilbo Baggins,” she greets and inclines her head. Hamfast sees a small crown sparkle, then. Next to him, Bilbo bows. “Lady Dis.”
If he is nervous, there is no tell.
Lady Dis, who, Hamfast repeats to himself, is probably among the richest and most powerful beings on Middle Earth, smiles at Bilbo.
“Long have I waited for this moment,” she says, “Your friends have told me much of you, and I will not deny they woke my curiosity. I hope you are willing to indulge me tonight, though I’m afraid I can’t vouch for dinner – my cooks did inquire locally, but it seems little is known about hobbit cuisine.”
“I wouldn’t be surprised if the only known fact was that we eat seven times a day,” Bilbo replies with a smile, “And the food smells rather lovely already. So I would thank you for your invitation and apologize for my unannounced companion. May I introduce my friend Hamfast Gamgee?”
Belatedly Hamfast realizes he is spoken about, and hurries to bow as deeply as his back permits. He accidentally pulls his shirt from his trousers, and feels his face turning red from embarrassment.
Lady Dis smiles at him – while he can’t still look her in the eye, afraid he will stare. Only upon closer observation her features reveal themselves to be female.
“Any friend of yours is a friend of mine, Bilbo Baggins,” she says, “And most welcome.”
Dinner proceeds quite well and Hamfast is glad not to have to contribute too much. He will gladly answer the lady’s questions on hobbit customs, but is careful to follow Bilbo’s lead. Even when Bilbo claims his return to the Shire was not much trouble – really, Hamfast thinks, only your relatives had declared you dead.
Most of the time Lady Dis and Bilbo exchange news of old friends, much of it interspersed with laughter. Bard, it turns out, has little understanding of architecture and is utterly lost on that aspect of rebuilding Dale. There is an amusing rumor of how, after another of Thranduil’s feasts, a number of elves attempted to re-enact the barrel escape. Accounts on whether or not Thranduil was along that number differ, but the tale still makes Bilbo and Dis laugh, and Hamfast chuckles along.
Radagast is back in his wood, eating mushrooms, while Gandalf keeps traveling the world, consuming pipe weed and setting off fireworks. Saruman keeps to his tower, mostly exasperated. It’s peaceful on Middle Earth, even though orcs remain in Moria.
“Balin means to set out to retake it,” Dis says over desert.
“Is it feasible?” asks Bilbo. Neither of them looks particularly happy at the idea.
“There is strength enough to our numbers,” Dis replies, “Though risks remain. And Dain already said he really can’t feasibly rule over a third mountain as well – he is already going grey faster than they can ship that special dye up from Gondor.”
Hamfast is somewhat surprised to learn that dwarves dye their hair. As he later finds out, this is indeed unusual. And the particular dye seems quite popular among Gondor’s female members of nobility. From Dis’ smile that is something they make sure not to let Dain forget about.
After dinner Hamfast remains seated at the table while Bilbo and Dis wander outside. Their voices grow softer, and from Bilbo’s face Hamfast can tell the subject has become more intimate. He is content to remain behind, then.
Still, from time to time, the warm wind carries over fragments of their conversation.
“… thank you for being there…”
“… regret this loss. They …”
“… wonder if I should have forbidden…”
“… many things…”
There is a short lull, and then Dis’ voice is audible again. “… he loved you, I think.”
***
Years pass and Bilbo regains his equilibrium. He never returns entirely to the hobbit he had been – still stares into the distance, and once even travels to Rivendell, again. Then a delegation of dwarves visits – not just any dwarves, rumors claim, but some of the highest importance. Some hobbits remember then that Bilbo traveled in the company of a king, so he must be of some importance among the dwarves, now, too.
Nobody is too certain, though, and the rumors eventually are nothing more than a way to pass the time. Until elves visit and the tongues start wagging again. Bilbo’s reputation suffers, naturally, yet as he is considered rich beyond measure by Shire standards he remains welcome at all social functions.
And the children still love his tales.
Bilbo himself is not as concerned as he was in his younger years to uphold his respectability. He remains polite and utterly kind, but now is well willing to draw lines, as Lobelia soon finds out.
The situation turns once more when Drogo and Primula drown, and, after a while, Bilbo decides to adopt his young nephew. Hamfast is glad for him, not only because Frodo and his Samwise become fast friends, but also because with Frodo at his side Bilbo appears a lot of more content than he has looked in a long time.
From then on, there’re seven meals a day appearing on the table in Bag End again.
Fin
