Chapter Text
The Eagles might have saved them once, but when Azog catches up with the dwarves on the edge of Mirkwood – three days after they left Beorn’s house – luck is not with them. Gloin goes down first, when an orc blade collides with his head.
For a split second Thorin freezes (and Oin screams, but he’s not hearing it over the roar of the battle), his eyes fixed on Gloin’s downed form – remembers other battles, the loss of friends and kin, and already despair is forming in his chest. Then he sees that there’s no blood on the ground, and no blade protruding from Gloin’s body.
Unconscious, but alive.
Thorin realizes this just in time to duck another blade. He twists away, and neatly slices off the orc’s arm. Blood splatters the ground, Thorin hears a warg howl. It cuts of abruptly as Dwalin smashes its head in, but three others take its place.
Too many, Thorin thinks, and sinks his blade into a warg chest. The beast collapses, but behind him there’s orcs, and orcs and orcs. And on a hill, only a little distance away, Azog oversees the scene, calmly.
“Bombur!” Both Bofur and Nori yell, as an orc sends him tumbling.
Bombur, too, stays down.
Thorin presses his lips together. His next swing decapitates two orcs, but there are too many. Too many.
They need a miracle. Yet Gandalf has left them for good, this time. What miracle can they hope for? Or strategy? Thorin realizes they can’t win like this, they need to regroup, they need a plan… and suddenly there’s a scream.
A spear is protruding from Kili’s shoulder – Thorin sees the shocked expression on Kili’s face, and his heart skips a beat. No pain yet, but Fili roars and dispatches the orc. Behind him, Kili collapses and the brothers are driven apart.
Azog shouts something in that ugly language. Thorin wants to shout, but he is too far away. Helplessly he watches as Kili – unconscious and helpless – is surrounded by at least eight orcs. One coolly levels a sword to his throat.
“Draw together!” Balin shouts, next to him, and Thorin absentmindedly realizes the remaining company is forming a circle. Bifur stumbles next to him, covered in blood, and to his left Dwalin is smashing in orc skulls.
“Bilbo!” Bofur yells.
There’s a choked-off scream, and Thorin catches sight of the hobbit going down, an orc behind his back. Bilbo’s sword flies out of his grip, landing too far away. And when Bilbo attempts to stumble up, the orc points a sword at his throat.
The Halfling stills.
Azog’s laughter echoes in time with the pounding of Thorin’s heart. The sweat on his back is icy, and the sword in his hand feels clumsy and useless. Fili screams – curses and threatens to not effect. Only Dwalin’s arms wrapped around his torso keep him from an insane charge.
Thorin knows this ought to be his task – but how can he, when Azog has a blade pressed to his other nephew’s throat? Kili remains unconscious – a small mercy – but that does not stop the small trickle of blood from running down his neck.
“Tonight,” Azog boasts, “victory would be easy for me. But, Thorin Oakenshield, instead I will offer you a choice.”
Thorin growls low in his throat. The company draws closer to him – Bifur even drags his unconscious brother with him. At least Bofur seems alive – another small mercy. Around them the orcs guwaff and snort; shrill, mocking sounds.
“A choice most befitting of a King,” Azog continues, “It should not be too hard for you, oh King under the Mountain.”
At a nod of his head, one of the other orcs comes forward, dragging the smallest member of their company along. Thorin’s heart drops.
Bilbo is alive and kicking quite ferociously against the orc’s shin and scratching at the arm wrapped around his upper torso. But for all his struggles, they hardly even bother the creature.
Even Fili’s screams have stopped.
“Your choice, King under the Mountain,” Azog announces, “Is which of your two companions here will rejoin you.”
“What of the other?” Thorin asks. His voice does not betray the uproar in his heart. Could they take the orcs by surprise? Could a desperate fight be won?
He looks at the tableau – one orc holds a blade to Kili’s throat, while the other could easily snap Bilbo’s neck with its bare hands.
He cannot risk it.
Azog contemplates the question. “We kill them,” he tells Thorin.
Bilbo has ceased struggling, and by chance Thorin’s eyes find his. There’s fear in those wide eyes, fear and pain and Thorin wishes he could undo those emotions. Bilbo does not beg for his life – but he can’t hide the desperation from his eyes, the heart-wrenching plea to be saved.
Yet, Thorin also sees resignation – Bilbo knows better than to hope for salvation, is trying to accept that he will be condemned to death by those that should rescue him.
Thorin swallows. “Kill me,” he tells Azog, “It is me your quarrel is with. Neither of them need be involved.”
Azog throws his head back and laughs. The noise echoes sharply through the darkening world – a world where nobody is near enough to help them. No wizard is here. No eagle will come.
“No, Thorin Oakenshield,” Azog states with a twisted grin, “There are only those two options. Choose. And be quick about it – lest they both die.”
Thorin’s heart speeds up. He can’t make this decision – he can’t decide who gets to life here and now, can’t decide between his nephew and his friend – but he must.
Once more, he looks to Bilbo. The hobbit is breathing heavily, and it is difficult to see in the fading light, but there might be tear tracks on his face. When he sees Thorin turn to him, Bilbo closes his eyes. And gives a minuscule nod.
Because this decision, no matter how much Thorin wishes otherwise, is not that difficult at all. Kili is his sister’s son, his own heir and far too young and cheerful to perish here.
“Then I’ll have the dwarf back,” he tells Azog, and bows his head.
He feels the shocked gazes of his companion bore into his back. There’s an aborted shout of protest, another gasps for air – and isn’t it lucky, that Bofur is unconscious? Bofur is a far better friend to Bilbo than Thorin will ever be; Bofur would not condemn the hobbit to die.
Thorin might as well be the one to kill Bilbo himself.
There’s movement, and Thorin glances up. The orc that holds onto Bilbo is joined by another – and the two of them start wrapping the hobbit with long, coarse rope. Bilbo struggles, protests, and Thorin is spared seeing betrayal on his face.
Confusion rears its head, and unbinds Thorin’s tongue. “You said you would kill him,” he tells Azog. Because somewhere he had prayed for a quick, painless death for Bilbo. If he cannot save his life -
The orc smirks. “Certainly, at some point.”
Black guilt envelopes Thorin’s heart. What fate has he abandoned Bilbo to? What has he done? Perhaps if he gets hold of Kili’s bow, he can still shoot Bilbo with an arrow – such a death is preferable to whatever Azog has in mind.
Instead of finding the bow, Thorin once more finds Bilbo’s eyes. They’re wide with tears and desperation, pleading – and Thorin knows this moment will haunt him until he dies.
And he will deserve it.
Then the second orc hits Bilbo over the head with a rock and the hobbit slumps forward, unconscious. The orcs finish tying him up, and then throw his form across a warg’s back. Azog returns to his own white warg, and barks out an order to the others.
“Until our next meeting, Thorin Oakenshield,” he promises. And with loud howls the group disappears, leaving behind a reduced and disconsolate company.
Fili is the first to unfreeze. He frees himself from Dwalin’s hold and stumbles forward. Drops to his knees once he reaches Kili’s motionless form in the grass, and then just sits there, dumbfounded. Behind him, the others awaken – weapons are put away, and Oin first kneels down next to Gloin.
Thorin’s mind is reeling. What has he done, what monstrous deed has he committed against one that has never so much as wished him ill.
***
Time passes, the shadows lengthen, and Oin declares even those unconscious well enough for transport. They need shelter – even if it is unlikely that the orcs will haunt them this night. Shelter, and food, and Thorin feels hollow as he addresses the company.
Nobody protests.
And yet the world has shifted. The unwavering loyalty has been shaken. His dwarves will continue to follow him, but to them Thorin has shown a willingness to sacrifice one of their own without a blink.
Not one blames him for the choice he made.
No one tells him it was right, either.
***
Bilbo wakes to the rough sensation of being dragged. His head scrapes over stones, and his vision blurs – he can’t twist into a more comfortable position; the moment he tries, white hot spikes of pain races down his arms.
Then his memory returns, and he wishes he had stayed unconscious.
All around him, orcs chatter in their grating language, and even the earth smells foul. There’s a fire crackling nearby, and with a bout of hysteria Bilbo wonders if they will eat him – if they will accomplish what three trolls failed to do.
Instead, he is lifted by the coarse ropes wrapped around his torso, biting into his skin even through his clothes. Weakly he tries to struggle, but his feet are in the air, and all it does is set his body swinging.
The orcs laugh.
“He’s awake,” one yells, and Bilbo shuts his eyes and wishes fiercely he had never moved.
Heavy footsteps draw him from his contemplations. A grow nearby forces him to open his eyes, and he sees Azog’s white warg stare up at him. Next to the beast is a pair of legs that –
A hand grabs Bilbo by the hair and forces his head up. His neck aches in protest, and he can’t help the pained gasp that falls from his lips. Azog’s face is close, too close, and Bilbo’s heart pounds so fast he thinks he must faint.
Azog grins. “You are right to be afraid,” he growls, and when Bilbo attempts to glare in response, he chuckles, “But not afraid enough yet. What an odd creature…”
He turns Bilbo’s head, and the cold metal claw that is Azog’s other arm prods at his ears.
“Elvish ears,” some other orc snorts, “I’ve never seen such a short elf. Must be bastard.”
Laughter echoes through the group, and Bilbo hopes that whatever must come to pass will do so quickly. And without much pain. Already, his eyes are burning.
“Are you an elvish bastard?” Azog inquires, looking actually honestly curious. When Bilbo remains silent, he gives him a painful shake.
“No,” Bilbo gasps out, “I’m a hobbit. A hobbit.”
“Never heard of those,” another orc growls.
“From the Shire,” Bilbo hastens to add, though from the reactions it seems that the name is not known to this group.
“I say we cut them off,” one orc jeers, “Cut off those elvish ears.”
“Nonono,” Bilbo protests, and his throat begins to ache from the strain, “That, really, no, I’m not an elf. Hobbits and elves aren’t even…”
Azog smirks. “I like that idea. Bring me a knife. And you, make sure he doesn’t move.”
“NO!” Bilbo screams, but it only makes the orcs laugh harder.
He kicks and struggles, but the ropes are tight and thick and fixed to a point high above him.
It takes two orcs to hold him down, and Bilbo bites at all fingers that come too close. Yet he is powerless when rough hands grab him by the hair and pull his head back so far he can’t move or risk his neck snapping.
Perhaps he should, he thinks as he is left gasping for air, his vision askew, but not blurred enough to not see the glint of metal in Azog’s hand. He wishes he could – though in this position he cannot move a muscle.
“Don’t,” Bilbo mutters, not caring about the tears exposed for all to see, “Please.”
The cold metal touches his ear, just underneath the tip. Azog chuckles. “Oh, don’t worry. We’ll start slow.”
Then the blade cuts in and the pain makes the world fade away.
***
Thorin’s feet have carried him to his nephews. Oin is bowed over Kili; skilled hands wrapping the injury to his shoulder and Fili hovers anxiously. The cut on his throat is an angry red line – it will heal on its own, Thorin knows.
He can’t stand to think how close to losing his nephew he had come.
“He’ll be alright,” Oin announces, “Just has to take it easy for a couple of days – not strain that shoulder, and such. He was lucky, that spear did not go in very deep.”
As if on cue, Kili’s eyelids start fluttering. The next moment they snap open, and only Fili’s and Oin’s quick reactions keep him from jumping to his feet.
“Kili!” Fili exclaims.
“Brother?” Kili asks. Then a frown settles over his features. “What happened? Did we win?”
Guilt clenches in a cold fist around Thorin’s chest. He can’t breathe, nor form words to explain what occurred. Instead, Fili pats his brother’s head in a soothing gesture.
“Not quite,” he says, “But the orcs are gone.”
“What do you mean? Is everybody alright? Uncle?” Kili asks.
“I’m alright, Kili,” Thorin tells him. His voice his raw, obstructed. It’s probably the first time he has spoken since he made that ill-fated decision.
“I … the Azog took Bilbo,” he says.
It’s not the entire truth. But how can he tell Kili that Bilbo was traded for his life? How can burden his nephew with that knowledge, when the decision was Thorin’s?
“What?!” Kili exclaims, and this time he sits up. Fili is there to steady him, but Kili does not sway, nor does he appear dizzy. “And you let them go?!”
Thorin bows his head.
“There was no other choice, laddie,” Balin offers, “We could not have won.”
It’s not an absolution. But at least Balin understands his decision.
“We should’ve fought,” Kili protests, “We shouldn’t have….”
“If we’d all gotten ourselves killed, they’d still have taken the Halfling,” Dwalin interrupts, “As long as we’re alive, we can take him back.”
And they must.
Thorin has been too wrapped in his guilt to realize that there is a need to take action. Dwalin’s words are like a blow – he is the leader, he should have figured this. But now that he has been awoken, the pieces are falling into place.
With a deep breathe, he straightens his back.
“Fili,” he tells his nephew, “I need you to step up as the leader of the company. Keep to the river until the path to Mirkwood opens – you cannot miss it, and Balin will recognize it. Stick to the path – we will catch up with you when we can.”
“But I…” Fili makes to protest, and Thorin shakes his head.
“I allowed Azog to take our burglar, and I will see that he is rescued. That is my responsibility.”
“But we all could have done something,” Ori protests, “I want to go and rescue him, too!”
“We still have a quest,” Thorin tells them, “And I would ask you not to abandon it – think of those that miss their homeland – for them we need to continue forward.”
“You can’t go on your own,” Dwalin interrupts him, “That’d be stupid. I’ll join.”
Bifur mutters an affirmative, and within moments the entire company is offering to go with him – but for Bofur and Gloin who remain unconscious. Thorin swallows – he hopes they will be in time for Bilbo. They all have grown fond of their hobbit.
He will not be able to persuade Dwalin to stay – not as he knows that Dwalin has a soft spot for their burglar. Thorin does not know about Bifur – Bofur is the one who first befriended Bilbo – but Bifur is a capable fighter and quick on his feet.
“Dwalin and Bifur are with me,” he tells them, “The rest of you continue.”
***
Bilbo awakes to a dull pain pounding through his skull. His arms are numb and his body aches – and his neck is sticky. He winces and the movement makes him swing. Nausea rises.
It takes far too long to fight it down, and when Bilbo’s mind clears, the orcs have noticed he is awake. Azog, though, is barking about in that harsh speech, uncaring of the hobbit trussed up like a pig for slaughter next to his throne.
It is not really a throne, though. Just a large stone seat overseeing the ruined watchtower and the lands surrounding it. Azog perches upon it like a King, and the white warg lies to his feet. Bilbo dangles from a column next to him – he will not escape from this on his own.
“He’s awake,” one of the orcs exclaims, and a fierce pain explodes in Bilbo’s head. His ear – or what remains of it – pounds, and he feels like vomiting – and somehow the world is askew.
When he comes back to himself, Azog is watching him closely. There’s unholy light in his eyes and Bilbo can’t help the shiver that runs down his spine. Already his body feels wrong – the pain may be dull, but he knows that he is not alright, that this is worse than a scraped knee – and he fears what will come.
Bilbo drops his head and closes his eyes. A sharp slap wrenches his head to the side, causes his entire body to swing, but the movement is aborted as a hand buries itself in his hair and forces his head upward.
“You don’t look away when I look at you,” Azog growls.
Bilbo tries to nod, though his neck feels strained to the point he thinks it must break.
“It does not surprise me that dwarf scum was so quick to abandon you,” Azog tells Bilbo, “Or did you expect him to choose you over one of his own kind?”
This time Bilbo holds the orc’s gaze – no matter if his heart pounds faster than it ever has. But if the orc thinks he can taunt him –
“Especially with how weak you are. I wonder why they took you along, but then, that particular line has never been very bright. Too obsessed with treasure, all of them,” Azog continues, “They’d rather kill than pay – not that I disagree with that, but you look naïve enough to believe whatever they promised you.”
If this is supposed to unsettle him, at least it is not working? Though Bilbo wonders if he can feel more afraid than he does now – the orc could snap his neck with one movement, and maybe…
Maybe that would be for the best? Bilbo’s heart contracts painfully – suddenly, he realizes, he does not want to die. He does not want to be in pain, does not want to be here – but he does not want to die here either.
Yet a rescue seems unlikely.
“They are probably glad to be rid of you,” Azog says, and the words cut.
That one instant in which Bilbo saved Thorin’s life does not outweigh all the other moments when Bilbo slowed the group down. Or demonstrated his unsuitability to adventure – doubtlessly, the company will move faster without him.
And have fewer persons to worry about when it battle.
It’s painful to breathe, and Bilbo feels a familiar burn in his eyes. This is not the right moment, and the fault is not with Azog’s words, though the orc may think so. It’s the slowly-settling realization that there will be no escape from this. No wizard, no magic ring, nothing will save him here.
Death remains the only option.
“My scouts have told me they’ve already traveled onward. They’re moving about a lot of faster, too, without you,” Azog says, with a toothy grin.
Bilbo does not want to provoke him. But he will do what he must. “Then you should start pursuing, shouldn’t you? In the time you needed to catch up last time, we had almost a fortnight of a holiday – so if that’s your normal speed, they’ll be on the other side of middle earth before you’ll even reach their next campsite.”
Only then Bilbo notices that Azog is not looking at, but past him – and before he can turn, there’s a sizzling noise and pain explodes from the soles of his feet. He can’t stop the scream, can’t even try not to struggle – because it’s hot, blinding, burning – and around him the orcs laugh and laugh, and he tries to kick, to squirm away, but a strong hand grasps his ankles.
When it’s over, the air smells of burned flesh and Bilbo’s throat is raw. He hangs numbly in his bindings, while around him the orcs frolic and gurgle and he just wants this to be over. His ear is numb, is feet pound – both, the soles and the left ankle – and he feels so wrong.
He feels as if this is the kind of injury one does not recover from.
Azog grunts, and says something to the other orcs that evokes a spirited reaction. Much chatter arises, and Azog rises to walk away, the white warg at his heels. The pale orc turns once again.
“Leave the face alone,” Azog growls, “I want to see the dwarves reactions when I return the body.
***
Tracking the orcs is not difficult. They have left a wide trail of trampled bushes and upturned earth. Thorin, Dwalin and Bifur can practically follow the trail running – though they have to be cautious, lest they stumble upon scouts.
Or worse, run into another trap.
Thorin does not dare think of what other cruelties Azog might come up with.
He lets Bifur take the lead, because he knows he is not at his best. His mind is too clouded, too wrapped up in contemplating the choice he made. Trying to find alternative solutions – but the only ideas that come are dangerous or suicidal, and none would have guaranteed Kili’s and Bilbo’s survival.
The Orcs do not even attempt to hide. Their quarter is an abandoned watchtower, that sits on a hill surveying the surrounding woodlands. The shine of a fire brightens the nightsky and their voices carry.
Thorin gestures for Dwalin and Bifur to come closer. They are yet far away, and it is unlikely that they will be seen or overheard, but he cannot allow any further mistakes.
"We meet under that outcropping," he points at a rock formation halfway between them and the watchtower, "At the latest, in an hour, earlier if one of us discovers Bilbo. If you do, hoot three times."
The other two nod, grim determination on their faces. Then they split.
***
Bilbo only registers pain. Something is fundamentally wrong with his body, and the remains of his ear pound. His feet are another affair entirely - they feel hot and sore and he does not even want to see how they look. Not even the hardened soles of hobbit feet are good against hot iron.
His ribs ache - there are some blurry memories of the orcs directing their iron rods - now cooled - towards his middle, but at least he was so far gone that he did not feel any pain. Now the pain is all too present; as is the sticky, wet warmth that coats his neck and his feet.
He cannot see the extent of his injuries. Yet he fears some may be beyond recovery.
He does not want to die here, but if he must, he hopes it will not be long, now. The horrified expression on Thorin's face is naught but a distant memory. And that not long ago he rested, at ease, with the dwarves, must have been a recollection from another lifetime.
Thoughts of another lifetime summon memories of home. The pain is too much, and Bilbo has to bite down on his lip to stifle a sob lodged in his throat. It may prevent the tears from escaping, but it does draw Azog’s attention as well.
The pale orc rises, and prods Bilbo’s side with his metal arm. “Awake, are you now? Doesn’t take much to make you faint – well, those dwarves may yet thank me for ridding them of you.”
White hot sparks of pain race through Bilbo’s arm – numb until now – and he barely even hears what Azog says.
“Though I wonder what that dwarf will say when I return your body,” he continues, “Maybe he won’t care. In which case it really doesn’t matter how many pieces we cut you into. But the others – they did have the look of being stupidly attached. So I wonder, what would horrify them most?”
Azog prods Bilbo’s side again, setting him swinging. He hates it, hates how the movement first propels him away, then right against Azog’s chest. The orc stinks of death and sweat, and Bilbo would vomit if there was anything left in his stomach.
“Shall I gouge out your eyeballs? Cut up that pretty face? Do you think that would scare them?” Azog asks, “Or maybe take an arm or a leg – though that would be a quite quick death for you. And I want them to know that it was long and painful.”
***
Not too far away, the remaining company rests only because they must. The mood is low, and Gloin and Bofur have yet to awaken. It is unlikely any of them will find rest during the last hours of this night, but they need their strength tomorrow.
And Fili does not want to march too far tonight, in case – should luck be with them – their away party return early.
The place they found is better protected than their former campsite – still, Fili joins Dori and Balin during their shift. Kili wants to stay awake, too – he is unsettled and upset, however, Oin is quick to put the notion from his head.
No matter how bleak their situation, exhaustion is quick to put most dwarves to sleep.
“How long until we reach Mirkwood?” Fili asks Balin. The new responsibility rests heavily upon his shoulders.
“Tomorrow afternoon if we keep our speed,” Balin replies, “The morning after at the latest.”
“Should we wait there for the others?” Because he cannot seriously contemplate that they will not come back. He can only accept this horrifying responsibility if it is temporary.
Balin sighs. “Not for too long, though. It will not be easy to guess which path we intend to take, and there are other, hostile beings that live along the borders of the forest.”
“But we have to…”
“Laddie, there is only three of them – they can travel far quicker than we will be able to. And Thorin expects you to continue onward. They will catch up with us when the time is right,” Balin says, gently.
Fili can’t help but shudder.
“Now, however, perhaps we ought to think about our stores? I think some was lost in the attack, and Mirkwood is…”
A low groan cuts off Balin’s words, and they are both up and over before Bofur has even managed to open his eyes. The dwarf blinks in confusion, and in lieu of Oin, Balin checks the bump on his head.
“Oh,” Bofur comments, “I do remember hearing that orc behind me – just couldn’t turn around in time.”
“Well, the wound will be fine if it does not get infected,” Balin pronounces, but before Fili can even feel relieved, Bofur sits up and asks: “So, what happened?”
The silence says it all.
Bofur draws in a tense breath. “Oh. What ….”
“The orcs took Bilbo,” Fili says, tonelessly, and Bofur pales, “Thorin, Dwalin and Bifur went after them. We … are expected to continue on.”
Bofur blinks, and Fili watches different emotions run over his face, before he settles for a grim determination. “I suppose it is too late to join them, now,” Bofur comments, “Though… morbid as it is, why did they not kill us? I thought Azog was among them.”
Fili can’t help the instinct to look away, and Balin, noticing his discomfort, leans forward. With a heavy sigh. “They could have. We did not win that fight – could not have won it, truly. Though rather than kill Thorin, Azog came up with a better form of torture.”
Fili closes his eyes against the memories. His uncle’s face is burned onto the backside of his eyelids, as is the expression on Bilbo’s. Especially the quiet, terrified resignation when Thorin had decided for Kili.
“He made Thorin choose,” Balin says, evenly, “Between Bilbo and Kili.”
Bofur sucks in a sharp breath. Then he curses.
“Please, I understand if you are angry, but … there really was no other way,” Fili pleads before he even knows what he is pleading for, “Uncle… uncle did not mean to abandon Bilbo. He, he just had no choice, and Kili….”
And Kili is Fili’s little brother, Thorin’s nephew and the youngest in their group. Whereas Bilbo is practically a stranger, unskilled with weapons and not even a dwarf. Even though Fili knows that there could have been no right decision, it still tastes like betrayal.
He hopes Bofur understands it is not meant to be.
Yet Bofur looks at him for a long moment, his eyes dark and unreadable. Then he frowns. “I see,” he says and his voice sounds oddly hollow, “And I know what you want to say, but … once this is over and should worst come to worst I – that is all of my clan – will claim Bilbo as kin. Just to make sure he’s done by rightly for once. Not necessary for --- compensation, or anything.”
Fili’s heart is painfully twisted, even though he nods in agreement. He would have liked to claim Bilbo as kin himself – with all the rights and duties it entailed. To look out for the hobbit, to help him and to care for him, to demand for compensation on his account – the right to treat him as family.
But he – his kin – has lost that right.
And for a slight like Thorin committed, Bofur can demand his head by the ancient dwarvish laws.
***
Thorin hears the hoot moments after he discovered Bilbo himself. They regroup within a short time, though the mood is tense.
"You all saw the hobbit?" he asks, and Dwalin and Bifur nod.
Bilbo's form is hard to miss, dangling from a beam in the middle of the ruined watchtower, right next to Azog's decripict throne. And the pale orc and his servants right next to him. Sneaking in would only be possible if any of them could be invisible.
"We need a distraction," Bifur says in Khuzdul, "and a bow."
***
“What do you say?” Azog asks again, “Answer. If you don’t use your tongue, we may as well cut it off.”
Bilbo swallows, and Azog’s metal hook digs into his side. Something shifts in the pocket of his poorly mended waistcoat, and with a dull thud, a small golden ring falls out.
“What is….”
On the other side of the camp, a scream goes up.
***
They procure a bow and arrows from one of the warg riders. It’s ridiculously easy, and Dwalin and Thorin can only watch how Bifur uses the orc’s dead body, one arrow and a whole lot of sounds to create an uproar.
“Murderer!” one of the orc yells, “You murdering scum!”
The other orc turns. “You murdered him! You did it!”
“I saw him do it!” And within minutes, the orcs are stabbing each other. It is amazing, how in the fire mess three dwarfs can sneak unseen right up to the campfire. Bifur hands the bow to Thorin, while Dwalin sets the arrowheads on fire.
“Four patches. Then the rope,” Thorin hisses.
***
Azog has barely taken three steps as a glint of red lightens the air, and abruptly a fire goes up on the other side of the camp. Orcs shriek in confusion, panic breaks out, and even Azog’s roars are barely audible over the dim.
Bilbo watches with wide eyes as more fires go up all over the camp – an attack? Infighting? How is this…
A last arrow, this one dark and invisible in the night, pierces through the rope holding him up. It’s a lucky shot, Bilbo thinks, and then the rope rips. He is tied and cannot catch his fall – he hits the ground hard, the impact knocking all air from his lungs and for long moments the world swims.
Then Azog roars a familiar word in a bout of previously unseen fury. “Dwarfs!”
Bilbo’s heart jumps. A sudden spark of hope springs up in his chest – he doesn’t care who it is, but he is on the ground, he can try and get away, because everything is better than dying like this –
Azog turns, his hate-filled eyes find Bilbo.
Whatever the orcs have done to Bilbo until now will be a child’s play in comparison to what Azog desires now.
But Bilbo won’t let that happen. He can feel the familiar cold metal of his ring press against his hipbones – some uncomfortable shifting and stretching, and he no longer feels just how chafed and raw his wrists are – and his right hand closes around it.
Azog unsheathes his blade, sprints forward while the world behind him grows red –
And Bilbo slips the ring on his finger and rolls away.
The pale orc halts, confused.
Bilbo’s heart is pounding like mad – he tries to get his feet under him, even though the pain makes him want to scream. But this is his chance, he must run, run, run, before his luck runs out.
And he manages, half stumbling, half crawling, to get away, to get down the stairs from the plateau of the ruined watchtower. Farther and farther away from Azog who yells in fury, yet with the camp on fire the orcs do not listen.
Then he sees three familiar shapes pushing their way through.
***
They’re half-way to Azog’s throne, when out of thin air, Bilbo Baggins materializes in front of them. Thorin can barely suppress a surprised exclamation – the orcs have not recognized them for dwarves yet, and they have kept to the shadows.
But now….
“Bilbo,” Thorin mutters and sinks to his knees in front of the hobbit. There’s dried blood on Bilbo’s face and he looks a mess, but he is alive and his eyes are clear.
“We need to get away,” Bifur hisses urgently.
Before Thorin can say anything, Dwalin has scooped up their burglar in a gentle hold. At least Thorin hopes it is – they have no time to treat injuries now. They don’t even have time to undo the ropes.
“Let’s disappear,” Dwalin agrees. He and Bifur turn, and hurry away. Thorin casts one last look at Azog – the pale orc remains on his plateau, shouting orders – he could perhaps kill him in this chaos, but he will not risk Bilbo’s life for this.
***
All of a sudden, Dori gestures at them to be silent. Balin has already drawn his blade before Fili even hears the odd sounds over the rustling leaves. He reaches for his own blade, and with the other hand, firmly presses Bofur back down.
He may have been awake for hours, but when he had first attempted to stand, Bofur had needed support.
Fili holds his breath and listens. Footsteps, he realizes, approaching. They sound heavy, cautious – and not quite like orcs. Yet they are definitely headed here, not merely passing by.
Balin is on the other side of the clearing in the blink of an eye. He makes no sound when he aligns his sword – and it is met by another, familiar blade.
“Thorin,” Fili breathes in sudden relief.
Balin heaves a loud sigh and puts his blade away. “Where are the…”
But before he can complete the sentence, Thorin is joined by Bifur and Dwalin. Both are silent, and Bifur’s spear is glistening with blood. There’s a small bundle wrapped in Dwalin’s arms, and Fili’s heart jumps, but before he can rise, Thorin moves forward.
“Oin,” he calls out, not caring that he also wakes all the other dwarves, “Wake up. You are needed.”
The old dwarf grumbles, but Thorin insists. His uncle does not look at Fili or Kili, and his face is white and tense. It is not a familiar expression, and deep down it scares Fili. With baited breath, he turns to look to Dwalin, who had found a soft patch of moss to settle his cargo down upon.
“Dwalin?” Fili asks, and his own voice sounds high and choked, “Is …”
He peeks over Dwalin’s shoulder as he unwraps the layers. But seeing Bilbo’s face – pale and still – only brings fear.
Were they not in time? Have they…
But Thorin is waking Oin. He would not be waking their healer if there was no hope. He would not… not wake Oin if it was futile. Though to Fili, all three look grim, and as Dwalin pulls away the layers around Bilbo’s body, the smell of burnt flesh and blood reaches Fili’s nose.
Horror-struck he steps closer. His knees feel weak, unsteady, and next to him he can hear Ori whimper, while Bombur curses softly. Fili catches a peek of blood-matted hair framing a too-pale face. Then Oin pushes through and is on his knees next to Bilbo.
“Make space,” Oin thunders, “Leave some room to breathe.”
***
Some dwarves shuffle back a little, but none dares to take their eyes of their hobbit. Bilbo remains deeply unconscious and his face is pale, except for one darkening bruise on his cheek and a trickle of dried blood in the corner of his mouth. And that is the part that worries Thorin the most – for the blood might indicate an inner injury, one that can yet be fatal.
“You and you, help me,” Oin orders, pointing at Bifur and Thorin, “the rest of you – stay back!”
The circle widens a little, then, and Bombur goes off to procure hot water. For the time being, Oin removes a flask of sharp-smelling alcohol from his belt, as well as a relatively clean piece of cloth. His first action is to check Bilbo’s back and neck for hidden injuries – Thorin is familiar with the procedure, has seen it countless times after Erebor’s fall – but that does not mean his heart does not tremble at the sight.
Though Oin finds no hidden injuries, and tilts Bilbo’s head on its right side. The left is a mess – it’s where Bilbo was first struck by Azog’s henchmen to be rendered unconscious. Dried blood has crusted skin and hair together, shaded the curls a dark rusty shade of red. And when Thorin catches sight of the maimed remains of Bilbo’s ear, his stomach twists violently.
Behind him, Gloin gasps and Nori curses. Somebody stumbles backwards, and there is the unmistakable sound of retching. Thorin feels nausea himself, yet forces himself to look. The upper part of Bilbo’s ear is gone – cut off, but not in one smooth move, but with a blunt blade, going by the serrated edges of the injury.
With a sign, Oin reaches for a cloth and water, and begins to clear the dried blood away.
Without the gore, at least the head wound does not look too grave. “Shallow,” Oin concludes, “It should heal just fine on its own.”
Which is a good prospect, but does not dispel the discomfort in Thorin’s stomach. Bilbo’s face twists as Oin washes out the wounds with alcohol – even unconscious he is in pain, and Thorin has to swallow hard against the clot stuck in his throat.
When he looks at the maimed ear, Oin frowns. “I don’t think he’ll lose his hearing in this ear,” he says, “But his sense of balance might be affected. It’s difficult to tell right now.”
“Will it grow back?” Kili asks, his voice choked – and for a moment Thorin envisions how this could have been his nephew’s fate, and the horror freezes him.
It is terrible, Thorin thinks while Oin shakes his head in response to Kili’s question, that there is a part inside him that is glad that Kili did not have to suffer this fate. That it was Bilbo who now lies here pale and still – and Thorin knows how unfair this is to their hobbit, and vows that he will not let any harm befall him in the future.
Oin has unbuttoned Bilbo’s waistcoat and shirt. Thorin sucks in a sharp breath through his teeth, because the hobbit’s body is littered with dark bruises and contusions, barely a patch of skin left that is not discolored. A quick look at Oin’s face does not make Thorin’s heart feel any lighter – the absence of blood is no indication of the severity of those injuries.
“Three cracked ribs,” Oin announces, as his fingers ghost over Bilbo’s torso. Thorin thinks he can see the cracks – like all of them, the hobbit has lost weight. Enough, that now his ribs are showing and injuries to them become visible.
“The stomach’s hard,” Oin continues, “I don’t like that, but it’s too early to say whether or not it’s serious.”
There’s little to be done for the bruising. Oin has some salve to ease the pain, but they lack the bandages necessary to stabilize Bilbo’s chest. The ribs will have to heal on their own – especially, since bandages are far more necessary for other injuries. Bilbo’s wrists are a stomach-turning mess. The skin has been scraped off, and the pale white color of bone peeks through.
Oin wraps them tightly, then looks to Bilbo’s hands. They are white, slightly swollen, and if Oin’s expression is anything to go by, he does not like their state. Thorin purses his lips, recalling what he knows of this type of injury. Cut-off circulation is usually not bad for dwarves – it is uncomfortable, but needs a long time to become true damage. Men are frailer, he knows – and nobody knows how sensitive hobbit bodies react.
True horror, however, are Bilbo’s feet. The soles have been burnt, and Bifur curses loudly. Fili gasps, and Thorin feels dizzy. Only looking at the charred flesh makes him realize that it will take a long time until their hobbit can walk without pain. And this is what his decision wrought.
When Oin is done, the rags he used are blood-soaked and Thorin can’t help the shudder that runs down his spine.
“Will he be alright?” Dwalin asks, gruffly. The cease between his eyebrows betrays his concern for the smallest member of their group.
Oin sighs. “Should be, I think. With a bit of luck, he sustained no internal injuries – it will take a while for him to heal, though.”
“He lost quite a bit of blood,” Dwalin comments, and Thorin has to concur. Bilbo’s face is white, almost bloodless, and Thorin knows that a lot of the hobbit’s blood currently coats the ground, as well as his and Dwalin’s clothing. On top of it, the hobbit is small – it seems unlikely he has much blood to spare.
“Certainly,” Oin agrees, “But his pulse is steady. Blood-loss does not seem to be a problem.”
“There is a settlement not too far to the South,” Balin weighs in, “Perhaps we should go there, and rest for a few days?”
Thorin frowns. Their funds are running low, and time is running out. Yet looking at Bilbo’s still form buried underneath a pile of fur-lined coats, that still are insufficient to heal him –
“That would help, I think,” Oin comments, “My stocks are almost depleted, and we all could do with proper beds to rest in.”
Not to mention that they are in no condition to fight. There’s still traces of dried blood on Gloin’s forehead, and Kili has sat back down again, testament to lingering dizziness. Should the orcs come back –
Thorin swallows.
“We make for the town,” he agrees, and pretends not to hear the relieved sighs Fili and Balin share.
***
They are not exactly welcome at the settlement, but nobody attempts to overcharge them, and Bilbo’s condition garners concerned inquiries, and a fresh batch of bandages courtesy of the inn owner’s wife. Dori, Dwalin and Bifur have alternated in carrying the hobbit for most of the way, though many others had also volunteered.
Bilbo had woken around lunch time – long enough for Oin to pour a hot broth down the hobbit’s throat, but far from coherent or hale. His eyes remained glazed, and whatever he muttered under his breath made no sense. None of them understood the words, though Thorin thought it might have been names.
For the last hours, however, Bilbo has been unconscious.
***
When Bilbo wakes, he feels warm, almost uncomfortably so. His body is filled by a dull throb – pain, then, and he is careful not to move. Instead, he slowly opens his eyes, and tries to puzzle his fragmented memories together.
Battle, orcs, then… hearing Thorin decide for Kili, and even though Bilbo understand the decision from the depth of his heart, if he knows he wouldn’t have wished for another decision – the memory hurts, Not because of what happened after – but because it made clear that Bilbo is not one of them.
And when push comes to shove, they will not save him.
It’s a depressing line of thought, and Bilbo presses his lips together to shove it away. They came back for him, after all. Azog’s taunts cannot have been true – Thorin would not have returned for a burden.
A shudder runs down Bilbo’s spine. He recalls the mad glint in the pale Orc’s eyes clearer than he wishes to, and the high-pitched giggles of the orcs still echo in his ears. Still can feel those hands on his skin…
He flinches, and what was a dull pain until now explodes, and it is excruciating. His entire body locks up, he can’t even breathe, and all he knows is white, hot, furious pain, radiating from the tip of his ears to the soles of his feet. Nausea rises when he recalls the smell of burnt flesh, and for some unfathomable reason he attempts to curl his toes.
The pain is terrible, and his vision vanishes for moments.
When he comes to again, somebody is in a room with him and he is gasping for air. There is a fierce ache emanating from his ribcage, that strikes whenever he tries to take a deep breath.
“Calm down, you’re safe,” somebody – Fili, Bilbo thinks – whispers, and there is a hand stroking his hair.
Bilbo tries to, but it is difficult when he can’t quite catch his breath, his body feels wrong and his vision is blurry. Though Fili keeps muttering sweet nothings, and somehow these work their magic. The blurry shapes around him turn out to be a room, sparsely furnished but comfortable.
“Where---?” Bilbo wants to ask, but only manages a pathetic rasp.
“A settlement,” Fili replies with a gentle smile, “We’ll be staying for a few days.”
Bilbo has some memories – frozen and blurred by terror – of the battle. Of Bofur going down, and Gloin as well. And some orc holding a blade to Kili’s neck…
“Is everybody…?” he asks, fearing the worst for a moment.
“A little scratched and bruised, but most of us are fine,” Fili replies, “If you don’t mind, I’ll go and fetch them now – Oin said to do the moment you woke, and I think they’re all quite anxious to see you.”
Why would they be, Bilbo wonders while Fili gets up, walks to the door and shouts for the company. Azog’s taunts echo, though he told himself not to listen then. But now he does not know what to believe – that everybody cares seems too good to be true.
And it still feels like a dream when one after another the entire company files into the room.
Bilbo’s hands tremble, while he is carefully hugged, petted and exclaimed over. No gesture is dishonest, and the dwarves’ eyes show grave concern, and Bilbo has never felt so … coddled.
He wants to sit up, but Fili only allows him to once Oin has given his alright. Which is not given easily, but comes with many warnings and a cup of a particularly foul-smelling brew, that however, does soothe the ache in his head. There is a chance that it contains something stronger as well, since Bilbo finds his own tongue loosened after.
Eventually Oin clears his throat. “I apologize if this is uncomfortable, and I’d send away that bunch if they wouldn’t come back in through the window, but, well, as a healer I must ask if the orcs did … anything else.”
Bilbo’s smile vanishes instantly, and the experienced warriors suck in a sharp breath. Dwalin clenches his fists so hard his knuckles turn white, and Dori pales.
“Anything… else?” Bilbo echoes, hesitant.
Oin swallows. “Anything that cannot be deduced from your injuries… did they make you ingest anything, for example?”
Bilbo shakes his head. “No,” he says, “That they did not.”
“Anything else?” Oin inquires. Bilbo can’t quite look at the faces of his companions – their concern is heart-wrenching, though he does not quite know what to reply.
“No, I mean, Azog… he said some nasty things. Nothing too bad, but… just some mean words,” Bilbo stutters.
“What did he say?” Kili asks, and faced with his well-meaning curiosity, Bilbo can’t turn the question away. He does not want to remember – would rather forget the soul-crushing feeling of abandonment during those dark hours – yet he cannot stay silent.
“He just taunted me,” Bilbo tells them, “Said you’d … you’re better off rid of me. That… that nobody would come…”
His throat constricts, and he can’t continue. He’d wanted to retell it light-hearted, because he ought to know better than to believe those words, ought to know better than to let them get to him. But even among the oversized, fluffy pillows and blankets he suddenly feels cold and lonely.
Because…
Because they will leave him here.
The revelation is as sudden as it is mind-numbing. But it makes sense – the dwarves’ concern for his well-being, the apologetic expressions – with his feet this injured, he won’t be able to continue on. Waiting for those burns to heal will take long, and even if he forced himself to walk, he would slow them all down.
So, in the end, do Azog’s words come true? Is he a burden, will he be left behind in this strange town so far from all he has ever known?
“Master Baggins! Bilbo!” and that is Bofur shouting, and very carefully a hand settles on Bilbo’s shoulder. He flinches, violently, but it rips apart the dark maelstrom in his mind.
“What?” he blinks up at Bofur, wide-eyed.
“Are we exhausting you?” Bofur asks, gently, “Shall we leave you to rest?”
“No, I’ll… I’m alright,” Bilbo says, even though he can feel himself trembling.
“Then what is on your mind?”
Bilbo swallows. And then forces himself to seek the truth. “When are you leaving?”
“Leaving?” Bofur echoes. Behind him, Fili chimes in: “Not for some time.”
“At least not until you’ve recovered a bit,” Oin states.
It warms Bilbo’s heart, truly, but: “You don’t need to wait for me. I know time is running out – so just go on.”
“You know, time is not that short. And the rest of us does appreciate this opportunity to rest as well,” Nori says.
“You don’t honestly think we’ll be leaving you here?” Dwalin asks.
Bilbo ducks his head, and a din falls over the room. “Really?” Kili echoes, shocked, “You can’t …”
He should have kept his mouth shut, Bilbo thinks. This is an awkward situation, one he would rather have avoided. And he does not want the dwarves to feel guilty for leaving him behind, not when there is no other choice.
Thorin clears his throat. “We will not be leaving you behind, Master Baggins,” he states, and immediately raises a hand to forestall any protests, “I am aware your feet need time to recover – therefore, we will carry you as long as necessary.”
Bilbo can only gape. Carry him? “But…”
“Don’t worry,” Dori adds, “To us you’re no real weight.”
And Bilbo, tentatively, smiles
***
It is later – once darkness has fallen outside – that Thorin approaches Bilbo alone. The leader of their company looks weary and burdened, and initially he observes Bilbo’s every reaction closely. The close scrutiny makes Bilbo uncomfortable, especially since the encounter with Azog has left him unusually jumpy.
After Bilbo flinches at another shifting shadow, Thorin sighs deeply. “I do owe you more than an apology, and I don’t quite know how or what to say.”
Bilbo blinks at him, surprised.
“I… my decision … I… there was no real choice,” Thorin stutters, face flushed.
Perhaps it is still due to Oin’s brew, that Bilbo remains calm. “I know,” he says.
“I never meant to leave you to Azog!” Thorin exclaims, “I didn’t … I didn’t….”
But his good intentions amount to little, when both of them recall that Azog originally traded in lives. And that Thorin chose death for Bilbo.
“You had to make a choice,” Bilbo tells him, “I understand.”
He does, even though the words taste like ash on his tongue.
“I about killed you!” Thorin yells, “Don’t tell me you understand! After everything you….!”
Bilbo twitches at the noise, and has to unclench his hands. Next to the bad, Thorin is shaking, and his eyes are red-rimmed.
“But you would make the same decision again, would you not?” Bilbo asks. Thorin pales, looking momentarily like a fish out of water, and that is all the answer Bilbo needs.
“You would,” he tells Thorin, “And I understand. Kili is family – most of you are, I think, and then all of you are dwarves. I know those patterns.”
There is no need to add that he knows them all from the outside-looking-in position. Ever since his parents died, he has never been first in the circle of affections of anybody, really. It’s bitter, but Bilbo has taught himself to accept it.
A hand wraps around his shoulder, and when Bilbo glances up, Thorin has settled on the bed next to him.
“I would,” he confesses, “But that does not make it right. You know, they all yelled at me that I should have found another way… But I failed, and even if you refuse to blame me, I know I did. And you… don’t deserve that. After everything you have done for me and my kin, you don’t deserve to be the one standing alone.”
And very, very gently he draws Bilbo into his arms. The embrace is warm, smothering, and even with his mind reeling, Bilbo allows himself to fall into it. It’s so much more welcoming than the feeling of cold orc fingers on his skin.
He shudders, and Thorin’s arms tighten. “I have greatly wronged you, and whatever you desire in compensation shall be yours if I have the power to make it so,” Thorin whispers into Bilbo’s hair, “My life is yours, for I would have so easily traded yours away.”
It’s more than Bilbo would have ever asked for, and he wants to tell Thorin, but rather than speak, he stays in the embrace. Perhaps that gesture will tell Thorin that he still has Bilbo’s trust, that a little kindness is all Bilbo requires.
Eventually, a knock on the door has them separate.
“You alright?“ Bofur asks, glancing inside. Behind him, Bilbo can hear the rest of the company whispering.
“Yes, fine,” the hobbit replies. His voice might be a little hoarse, but that is to be expected. Exhaustion is heavy, though the feeling of marrow-deep loneliness has vanished, replaced by comfortable warmth.
“That’s good,” Bofur sounds relieved and steps into the room. He does, however, not march up to Bilbo’s bed, but heads for Thorin who sits on the other side.
Before either can ask, there’s the sound of a fist hitting flesh, and in the blink of an eye Thorin and the chair have toppled to the ground. “Oi!” Dwalin shouts from outside, and there’s gasping and tittering, and Thorin slowly sits up, a hand pressed to his cheek and his eyes wide.
“Wh- what—why did you?” Bilbo sputters, leaning over to check if Thorin is alright, then turns large, confused eyes on Bofur.
There is no smile on Bofur’s face, and his expression is unusually dark. His fist is still clenched threateningly. Bilbo falls silent.
“That,” Bofur announces coldly to the exiled king, “Is for abandoning out burglar.”
And that stops even Dwalin in his charge. The darkness on Bofur’s face is foreboding and full of anger. But then, just as unexpectedly as Bofur’s punch was, the dwarf relaxes his expression – doesn’t smile, though – and holds out a hand.
“Though you did get him back,” Bofur tells Thorin, who rather hesitatingly takes the offered hand and lets himself be pulled to his feet. Bofur claps his shoulder. “I’m not forgiving you,” he warns Thorin, “But since we’re all alive – Bilbo willing – we can put it behind us.”
Bilbo nods. Discussing this has already tired him out, and he does not want to drag the memories of feeling so terribly lonely to the forefront of his mind again. “Let’s,” he breathes, and sees the dwarves still lingering in the doorway smile in agreement.
For a moment, Thorin looks overwhelmed. Then he lets go of a deep breath, and it looks as if a huge burden has been taken from his shoulders.
“Well, if that is acceptable,” he says, and turns to Bilbo. Ever so gently, he takes one of Bilbo’s heavily bandaged hands into his, “My promise to you will stay valid, though. I …”
Bilbo shakes his head. “Let’s put this behind us. And just … just move on.”
He knows that it won’t ward off the nightmares. Nor will words heal his feet any quicker. But rather than move on with a cloud of self-recrimination and guilt hanging over Thorin’s head, he would have his friends be cheerful. And if, in turn, they will stay by his side – it is all he ever hoped for.
Fin
