Chapter Text
Among Middle Earth’s kingdoms Erebor has always been the richest. It is built on foundations of gold and precious stones; even mithril is plentiful enough to be traded on common markets. Houses are decorated with rubies and sapphires, gold is spun into clothes and diamonds fashion hair ornaments – this glittering kingdom has long been the center of admiration and jealousy of all surrounding lands.
Thranduil of Mirkwood will pay his tribute, as will the King of Rohan and the Stewards of Gondor. Distant lords may grumble, but they all know that Erebor is unsurpassed in strength. Weapons forged from mithril will not rust. Soldiers paid an abundance of gold will fight for the kingdom’s cause.
Erebor grows in riches and in power. The surrounding lands, though, begin to drain. Food prices soar – the kingdom is voracious.
“And yet,” says Smaug, a stranger come from the far east in front of a congregation of farmers and workers with haggard faces and dirt-stained clothes on Dale’ central square, “Golden coin is not food. Whatever they pay you, they will pay more for that loaf of bread you wanted to buy.”
Voices cheer in agreement.
King Thror, however, does not know of this. He is deaf to the whispers, blind to the desolation spreading before Erebor. His eyes are fixed on the glow of his gold and riches, and above all of them, the Arkenstone. His son’s eyes yet stray away and sometimes halt the ambitious councilors. At other times Thrain’s word is not enough.
It is not enough to stop yet another rise in taxes.
It is not enough to stop an increase of the prices for gemstones.
“Our smithies have shut down,” Bard, a man of Dale proclaims, “Our craftsmen have to forsake their crafts – for they can no longer afford the materials they need to work with. Our borders lie defenseless, for we cannot forge weapons. And even if we could – Erebor will easily outbid whatever price we offer for iron and copper.”
The voices that join his outcries rise in volume. This cheer is fed by anger and malcontent.
“Henceforth,” the message the King of Erebor has distributed throughout Middle Earth, “the tenth shall be paid in corn or stock, in order to put no further strain on civic savings.”
The Thain of the Shire glances at the fellow clan heads assembled with him. They are far from Erebor and have until now only paid tribute to be left alone – their land is plentiful, and nobody ever demanded to control what they deemed to be their tenth.
Yet now “corn prices have risen again,” the Master of Buckland reports, “In Erebor, a loaf of bread may sell for a gold coin or more. Already the demands of Bree are higher than what we can deliver.”
Deliver without cutting into the Shire’s private stocks, that is. The hobbits of the Shire are helpful, but will look after their own first. Nobody else looks out for them, after all.
“Well, let them have their tenth, I say,” says the white-haired head of the Bracegirdle clan, “We don’t want trouble – let’s just send them enough so they will not grow suspicious.”
“It is risky,” Bungo Baggins weighs in. But he, as everybody else knows, they have few other options.
***
“They are calling him the Necromancer,” prince Frerin tells his siblings. Neither of the three likes Thror’s latest advisor, the man (though he seems no man either, but for all that he is neither dwarf nor elf, they do not know what else to call him), “He seems to think that ruling will work best once all subjects have been starved to death.”
With the steady increase in prices, now even Erebor’s poorest are experiencing a shortage in supplies. Though, much to Thror’s content, with the Necromancer’s advice, Erebor’s treasuries are filling up further.
***
And then, all of a sudden, the citizens of Dale rise up against Erebor. Cries for change ring through the air, citizens block the roads and for once raise their cries for equality and justice. They are no longer willing to continue – and change suddenly appears immediate.
But some hunger for more. Blood is spilled. The Master’s head put up on a spike. Barricades block the streets. And then a man with dead eyes puts a spear through Frerin’s chest.
Erebor’s vengeance is terrible.
Dale burns for three days. Most of Dale’s citizens perish, and those that flee know they can nevermore return. A refugee camp by the shore of the great lake springs up, but it is poor and ramshackle, and Erebor refuses all aid as long as Bard’s and Smaug’s heads are not delivered.
***
“Mad,” Dis whispers to her remaining brother, her eyes anxiously tracing the footsteps of her two children. Her husband died in Dale, though rumor has it that he died fighting for the wrong side.
“He’s gone insane,” she tells Thorin. Her brother frowns – she knows he shares her opinion. But what can they do, when even their father’s words fail to reach the King?
And looking at her children, while the world grows darker around them, Dis knows she cannot stay.
***
Erebor’s rulers may not know that the Shire is extraordinarily fertile and would perhaps never have realized that they never received the tribute demanded – but others know, and Azog has his own ambitions and grudges. Mostly he hates that patch of peaceful green land.
And informing Erebor of the betrayal grants him a permit for a punishment expedition.
What resistance the hobbits put up is laughable. The orcs enjoy themselves running some done, others they slaughter or torture. Some they use for their enjoyment. Enslavement is spoken of, too.
And then one tiny hobbit lass – one Belladonna Baggins shoves a rusty fishknife through Azog’s throat with fire in her eyes. It does not bring back her husband – Bungo, one of the first the orcs had publicly executed – but it saves her son, her gardener, her tenants and many other hobbits.
“We will not be slaves to anyone,” she proclaims, “We are hobbits of the Shire and we protect what is ours!”
That night the Shire burns all contracts with Erebor together with the corpses of orcs.
***
The night news of the battle in the Shire reach Erebor is the first time a tumult breaks out on the markets of Erebor’s lower levels. Thorin later learns that a boy – an orphan without relatives or income – had lost a hand for stealing a loaf of bread. The watching crowd had protested the unforgiving stance of the judges – and risen up in protest.
Quelling the protest of half-starved people is not difficult. But Thorin who can recall a time when he himself could stroll through this market without being glared at is uneasy.
His grandfather remains deaf.
***
News of the events in the Shire spread. Gondor and Rohan seceded quickly. They are too far and too strong to fear retribution from Erebor. And while the lack of access to Erebor’s markets may hurt, Gondor has open harbors and Rohan will instead trade with the Shire and look further to the South.
And Rivendell, backed by the White Council, demands an explanation. Did Erebor truly intend to enslave the hobbits? Were there truly orders given to slaughter even the youngest child?
Rivendell may not be a military stronghold, or even an economic power. But the White Council is made up from wizards and some of the oldest beings to walk on Middle Earth. Not to mention those that bear rings of power. Even Erebor, where one ring is held, will be careful not to anger those.
***
“I cannot watch while the weakest are starving and we abuse our power,” Thorin’s hands shake as he reads the letter, “I cannot be on a council that brings such evil into the world – I will not have part in this any longer.”
The handwriting of his old friend is unusually shaky and smudged. But then, those words were written after Balin had drunk the poison already.
Thorin sighs and gently brushes a hand over the lifeless figure’s head resting on the desk. The body is pale, the lips are blue – Thorin knew it to be too late the moment he entered.
“I hope you are happy wherever you now are,” he mutters.
***
“We did never intend to extend any tyranny,” Thrain, heir to Erebor, declares as he readies for departure, “Nor do we advocate greed. I will find out what happened. I will make things right.”
No council will sway him, and Thrain’s promise echoes the desire of what is fast becoming a majority. Erebor’s nobility still dwells in luxury, but its craftsmen and tinkers are becoming thinner at an alarming rate. Already, reports of dwarves starving amass.
Others leave Erebor for Laketown. That small settlement of those that dared to defy Erebor, the survivors of Dale. Already the Necromancer is warning Thror of them, telling him to strike ere they grow too strong.
Strategically, Thorin knows that he is right. Laketown may pose a danger to his kingdom.
But can he truly begrudge them whatever actions they may take?
All those contemplations disappear when Thrain fails to reach Rivendell. His entire escort just vanishes into thin air, and Thorin cannot deny that by now – with his brother dead, his father perhaps as well and his sister gone into the unknown – he is afraid.
***
Laws grow stricter.
The air grows tense.
Belladonna Baggins is assassinated.
***
And then Laketown rises. Trade with the south has provided the materials Erebor no longer delivers. Ideals and dreams give courage to a movement that lacks dearly in materials, but in their cries Thorin finds many long-forgotten words that once Erebor’s intellectuals proudly wielded.
He knows what will happen now before it does.
Now Erebor’s intellectuals have moved to Laketown, advocate equality, justice and freedom – and are echoed not only by those that survived the terror wrought upon Dale, but also by those that still live in Erebor; and not just those that struggle to make ends meet.
When the palace is overrun, Thorin recognizes many faces. There is young Ori, one of Balin’s former pupils, Bifur, who used to sell toys to the palace. Their faces, now, for the first time in what feels like forever, look hopeful. He cannot fault them.
And Thorin, when Dwalin tugs on his arm, urging him to flee, hesitates.
Before his eyes the palace is set on fire. The Arkenstone torn from its place. Nobles scatter, the kingdom crumbles. And then Smaug takes charge.
His first act is to behead the old king.
For weeks a new hope blooms in Erebor. People remain poor and food remains scarce, but now there is a silver lining to their suffering. The mad King is dead, their new leaders promise equality and justice and at least they’re all starving together.
The possessions of nobles are seized – and those that do not enthusiastically agree with the goals of the revolution are done away with. Bard is not happy with these proceedings, yet he does not dare speak up against Smaug.
Not as it was him who allowed the crown prince and his bodyguard to flee, for he knows they could have snuffed the revolution earlier, and still could have commanded the army to fire into the uprising. And all that the revolution will offer them is death, for naught but being the sons of their fathers.
Bard thinks this is not fair – and didn’t Smaug invoke equal rights for all? How come he is unwilling to grant them to those that may be situated among their enemies?
So he lets Thorin and Dwalin vanish into the night, and secretly wishes them all the best.
For them, the world is not a friendly place, either.
***
News of the successful revolt in Erebor spread across Middle Earth. Soon enough, others attempt to imitate the movement – but in Rohan nobility has never considered itself above its citizens and no real animosity has ever grown, and in Gondor it is another enemy that holds all attention.
Orcs do not care for revolutions. Neither do they care for noble ideals, enlightening ideas and dreams of fairness. They rather care for riches and food and bloodshed, and are willing to work for those that will provide.
Which includes the revolution.
When it becomes obvious that ideals enough are not enough to spread the fire through Middle Earth, Smaug uses Erebor’s riches to hire mercenaries and spies, to spread unrest and ideas and to support the opposition where it is too weak.
“We will change the order, even if we need the sword to do it,” Smaug proclaims, “It will take sacrifices, but in the end, we will live in the land we have always dreamed of.”
Bard does not think it likely. Almost daily, heads roll in Erebor and Laketown, and many more distant towns have changed their allegiance. The orcs scare them. The fever does, too.
***
Thorin and Dwalin wander. They keep their heads down, their treasures hidden. A skilled smith is always welcome, even where dwarves are eyed with distrust.
Though as around them the world continues to fall apart, the requests for manual labor dwindle. Strangers are not welcome, and the two are turned away from more than one town. Still, they continue on their way to the Ered Luin.
They would have made for the Iron Hills, but “the roads will be watched,” Dwalin had said, “They expect you to go there – they know Dain would come to your aid. Only death lies that way.”
So their path leads them west, past desolation and devastation, across rivers and ranges, and Thorin thinks that he will have ask Dain to interfere anyway, and pray that it will be enough.
***
“The revolution may have been quelled,” Smaug tells his army of orcs and mercenaries the evening before they set out for the Shire, “But it has not been quenched! We will aid the poor and oppressed in rising against their tormentors and bring justice to those that until now have been above it!”
Slaughter them, Bard thinks, and take their belongings – not so much their riches, but the Shire’s fertility has become known, and with winter on the horizon, even Smaug has to look for a way to feed his men and Laketown.
“He wants not to liberate the Shire,” Bard tells a few of his old compatriots late at night, “He wants to enslave it.”
Because many have by now grown disenchanted with Smaug who brought terror instead of freedom, many nod in agreement. And none are surprised when their meeting is busted, and a day later – with Smaug as their sole juror – they are condemned to death.
With Bard’s head on a pike, few dare to protest against Smaug. But once again, a slow exodus begins, with those that once came to Laketown to fight for their ideals now moving on elsewhere or returning home, disappointed and afraid of what their enthusiasm has wrought.
***
“Thorin!” Dis exclaims, rushes forward and throws her arms around her brother and his former bodyguard, “Dwalin! You’re here! I didn’t … I heard….”
She is unable to speak the words. News from Erebor have always left her disheartened, to the point that she sometimes wishes to just let go of these memories. Beautiful memories of warmth, love and laughter do not go well with news of desolation, destruction and slaughter. And she does not want to know how many more beloved people the kingdom cost her.
Yet now, by some miracle, her brother has been spared. Even though he looks haggard and worn, he is nonetheless alive.
And when he eventually smiles, she sees that his heart is still the same.
***
Bilbo is awoken in the middle of the night by his gardener.
“You need to hide,” he is told before he is truly awake, “There’re orcs in the Shire! They’re killing all the gentlefolks!”
And before Bilbo quite knows what has happened, he finds himself locked into one of the secret corn stores the hobbits have built under their hills after Azog’s first expedition. He’s dropped in with a bundle of blankets, a change of clothes and that old ancestral sword that used to hang over their fireplace.
He is afraid, and all he is told is to stay down and hide – because he’s too young to fight, because he’s popular with his tenants, because he is the son of Belladonna Baggins, the Shire’s own hero, and because the forage is led by Azog’s son, Bolg.
Then the sounds of fighting are joined by a familiar child’s voice crying.
And history, ironically enough, repeats itself as Bilbo stabs Bolg in defense of his gardener’s son, and the hired troops begin to falter. It’s not a clear victory, though, because there are other leaders and the second half of payment will only be delivered once their work is done.
Also, because Bolg’s mace catches Bilbo across the chest. He will die painfully without proper treatment, and eventually, Drogo Baggins braves the road to the Ered Luin with a cart his injured cousin, and a fierce Lobelia for company.
***
The dwarves of the Ered Luin are quick to come to the Shire’s defense.
“We trade with them for food,” Dis tells Thorin, “And they don’t overcharge, even though everybody knows they could sell their wares for twice the price a bit further east.”
It is also the place where the dwarves send their few children to play and trade and grow. Hobbits never do any worse than eye strangers with suspicion, and are willing to pay a fair price for metal wares. The inhabitants of the Ered Luin have grown protective of the Shire, to say the least.
Both, Dwalin and Thorin then, join the armed forces of the Ered Luin. It does not take much to chase away or slay the remaining orcs and mercenaries – most are too fond of their lives in the end to keep fighting when faced with a fresh, well-fed army.
Still, the Shire has sustained losses, and most faces Thorin sees look afraid.
***
A rare free day, few weeks after the battle, sees Thorin accompany his nephews to Hobbiton’s market. He is surprised to see that, a few charred ruins aside, most damage has already been cleaned up or is in the process of being done away with. The hobbits, now, seem cheerful, singing and humming and Thorin has his sword drawn when he hears shouting – only to, moments later, realize that all he heard was a lady yelling at her husband to “clean your feet before you come in, how many times do I have to tell you?!”
The sky is blue, the air clear and warm and the landscape green and gentle. Before Thorin’s eyes spreads a dream-like land, one that consists of blooming fields and quaint, peaceful settlements and he cannot understand how such a place can exist.
Hobbits chuckle at his confusion, and would rather discuss the weather or the harvest rather than political ideals. They have found a system that works for gentility – and Thorin is somewhat surprised that Bilbo Baggins, so beloved by all – is actually a landowner – and like everyone else cares for little but good food, merriment and a warm hearth to return to.
Thorin, raised to tales of glory and noble deeds, cannot understand how this can be enough, but he envies the hobbits for their content lives.
***
But hobbits, too, must talk politics. Gerontius Took, the latest Thain of the Shire, joins a strategy meeting in the Ered Luin, accompanied by the heads of the major clans – among them one Bilbo Baggins, who still is pale and leaning on a crutch.
It is the first time Thorin meets him that he is conscious.
“Dain Ironfist of the Iron Hills,” Thorin tells them, “Would offer us military support. However, they are short in supplies, especially food stores he cannot provide.”
“Many of the dwarves here would follow you, Prince Thorin,” Gloin, one of the dwarves that left Erebor when Thorin was still young, says.
There’s some whispering among the hobbits. “Prince Thorin of Erebor?” the Thain asks, and Thorin can see mistrust in his eyes. It is warranted, he thinks, for all the trouble has originated in Erebor.
“Yes, but he has no hand in what has been done,” a third party – Gandalf who is here on behalf of the White Council, says, “King Thror was led into madness by a dark wizard – the Necromancer, I believe he was called.”
“And Smaug is a calamity of his own,” a man mutters. He is one of the Dunedin, and apparently of some importance, though nobody is certain exactly how.
“Very well,” the Thain says, “We are rather interested in restoring our safety and peace – for that we could supply food for an army.”
Thorin wonders how he can say that without knowing just how large this army will be. From the intelligence provided through Nori – the spy of uncertain loyalties, once planted by Thrain –, the number of Smaug’s supporters is dwindling. They do have access to Erebor’s armory, but they have a hard time trading for food.
“We will wait out the winter,” it is eventually decided, “For cold and starvation will weaken them further. Once spring comes, we march.”
***
“I would not ask this of you if there was another choice, but we need to know what happens at Erebor,” the Thain tells Bilbo. His grandson remains pale and thin – and he already regrets what he must ask of him, for he knows it will not help him heal.
“You are the only one knowledgeable enough to understand what consequence any development at Erebor may spell for us. You know our stores and resources, as well as our customs and I think most hobbits here will trust you to make the right decisions on their behalf,” the Thain continues, “You know how to defend yourself – if it comes to that, which I hope it doesn’t. Ered Luin has promised their protection.”
There’s a second thought in there, one that is all too clear to Bilbo. He has no spouse and children waiting for him; barely any family at all. If something happens to him, not too many will grieve.
And yet, the pain in his grandfather’s eyes is honest.
“I will go,” Bilbo tells him, and musters a smile.
***
It is a long journey from the Shire to Erebor with much ill news to be found on the way there. Yet, at the same time, Thorin learns to smile again.
Against his wish, Dis and his nephews – young men now – are riding with them. They are no experienced warriors, they should not be here, but their antics bring a smile to Thorin’s face. They also take the hobbit under their wing.
And, to Thorin’s surprise, Dwalin joins them in this endeavor.
Bilbo, at first, is wary – a lone hobbit in this company of dwarves and men –, but as the days pass his face regains some color, and he has learned to dodge Kili’s hugs, and brace himself for the shoulder pats Fili gives.
In the evening, Dwalin instructs him how to use a sword, and at some point Fili and Kili will start to give their commentary. Which inevitably has Dis rise and challenge her sons to best her.
Gandalf will sit under a tree, watch and smoke his pipe, and Gloin next to him mutter over expenses.
It doesn’t feel as if they’re going to war, Thorin thinks. They might die – they don’t know what they will find –
And yet he hasn’t felt happier in a long time.
***
Their arrival causes an uproar. Smaug and his leaders flee Laketown and barricade themselves in Erebor, even before Dain and Thorin can put forward their demands.
“We will not give up what we fought for!” Smaug exclaims before the amassed citizens. All look pale and hungry; their clothes gem-studded cast-offs rather than fitted coats.
“I do not want to attack,” Dain confesses that evening.
Dwalin snorts. “It’d be slaughter.”
Thorin is silent. But if he wins back his kingdom by slaughter, he knows he will not have any grateful subjects to welcome him. Already, there are far fewer of them than there ought to be.
It was a brutal winter.
When they come to renew their terms, Smaug meets them with armed bodyguards. “You would have us abandon what we fought for,” he proclaims and there are many, dwarves and men, hanging fearfully onto his words, “Once again let us starve?!”
“And are you not starving already?” Bilbo urges his mount forward. He is aware that he does not look very impressive – a hobbit on a pony never is, no matter how many fur coats he wears – but he will hold his head high and argue his point.
And there is more than one point he intends to take up with Smaug.
“From what I see, Master Smaug, you have not improved, but rather exacerbated the situation of those you proclaim to protect,” Bilbo says, “And yet, only your coat appears to fit.”
“What would you know, creature?” Smaug hisses back.
Bilbo coolly replies. “A creature, am I? Are we hobbits not equal then? Is that why you sent Bolg to slaughter my kind?”
The whispers have died down. Now all attention has come to focus on Smaug and Bilbo. The leader of the revolution hisses in anger, but finds no words to say.
“Was not your revolution supposed to bring peace to all?” Bilbo accuses, “Then why is its pathway covered in blood? Why do your citizens fear your laws? Why is it that you need violence to support your cause and guarantee your rule? Where is your equality in that?”
“And what would you know of ruling?” Smaug asks, seething, “What would you know of those just waiting for a chance to reinstall themselves, of those hungering for power without a care about those slaughtered along their way?”
“Like you would have slaughtered my kind for not supporting your revolution?” Bilbo questions.
“That madness for power, Smaug,” Dain says, “has long since become your own. Look around – those who follow you now do because they fear you, not out of love or loyalty.”
He clears his throat and steps forward. “To each and every resident of Laketown and Erebor I would guarantee safe passage shall they desire for peace. I do not ask them to fight for me, I merely asks them not to take up arms against my men. Nor will my men hinder those that wish to leave.”
***
Smaug does not wish for anybody to leave. But he cannot keep the gates shut, not with many desiring to accept Dain’s offer, and his mercenaries nervous in face of the well-armed and well-fed army waiting just outside.
When Dain eventually decides to march, they meet no resistance. Rather, in Laketown some children shyly wave at them from the windows of depilated houses. And once the food is carried into the market square, a cheer rises up.
The mountain capitulates without even one drop of blood being spilled. It is pitiful, Dain thinks, that it is only this late that a peaceful resolution arises. How many more lives could have been saved had Smaug capitulated before winter came?
“His head is yours,” he tells Thorin.
His cousin remains grieved and solemn in manner. Instead of drawing his sword, he turns to the curious onlookers. “He shall have a fair trial.”
Later, when more dwarves and men are listening, Thorin continues, “I am aware that once this revolution was not without cause. I watched my grandfather succumb to madness and Erebor fall into ruin. I have known starvation and poverty, injustice and contempt – and I wish them onto no one."
***
Rebuilding Erebor is not easy, though Dale is worse of. Fractionalization and distrust run deep through these societies, and old crimes are quickly brought to surface. But how shall they deal with what was stolen legally under another reign? Shall they take the stolen materials that now provide for a family’s livelihood?
Thorin wants to despair.
And yet, when he sees his nephews wandering the markets, joking and laughing with the merchants, he knows he has to see this through. Erebor may not regain its former glory, but he intends to leave them a united, healthy kingdom.
It turns out that Bilbo is the key. The hobbit is good at gauging legal matters and settling arguments. But most of all, his continued presence ensures a generous supply of food from the Shire. Thorin hastens to pay, but on one occasion he has had two gold chests returned to him simply because they were “too heavy and cumbersome to carry”.
His people may not trust Thorin easily – he is considered fair, but too many recall his grandfather’s madness and fear he may fall prey to it, too – but they love Bilbo for his willingness to share coin and food for nothing more than good company and shared happiness.
***
In the end, Bilbo stays.
At first, it is out of necessity. The situation is tense, and constantly in danger of dissolving into violence. Filled stomachs do much good in diffusing the tension – and Bilbo now is generally considered the one responsible for the food supply.
Surprisingly, it is not difficult. The Shire is far, so initially he is afraid to have to seek out closer providers. Yet, all are open to negotiations and Erebor’s gold is welcome as payment. He does not consider his duties difficult – or impossible to be taken on by any other.
It is weird, Bilbo thinks, he could no return home – he has done his duty, has seen the contracts signed and sealed. Yet, all that awaits in the Shire is that empty smial filled with bittersweet memories and relatives that may mean well, but remain distant.
Here, in this far away kingdom that is so different from his home he has finally found his welcome. He is no longer considered odd, nor does he remain alone. But he is beloved by the people, and – more than anyone – by the king.
fin
