Chapter Text
They don’t actually mean to lose the hobbit.
After the encounter with the trolls Fili has sworn to be careful, though for once the forest next to their camp seems truly harmless. They have learned to watch their ponies – and they are calmly grazing on the open plain tonight. Gandalf has left them for a reason or another – wizarding business, and they shouldn’t expect him back very soon – especially not to save them from trolls again.
At least they have it easy finding food; the woods in these parts are dense and rich in game and fruit. It will just take some time gathering the ingredients for a hearty dinner – and they all desire one after a hard day of riding.
Tonight, Kili, Fili and Bilbo have been sent out to forage. They set out in a fairly good mood.
“Let’s split up here,” Fili suggests after they have left their camp ground a good way behind, “It’ll be easier to sneak up on prey alone.”
Bilbo does not look happy with the idea, but he agrees. “If you don’t mind, though; I’ll look for berries and mushrooms.”
“’course not,” Kili easily replies, “But let’s make a wager – who do you think will bring back more game – me or Fili?”
“Err,” Bilbo looks between them, “I don’t know?”
“Just take a guess. If you win, you get first dibs on the meat of whatever it is,” Kili urges on.
Bilbo looks between them. Kili has a bow and arrows – perhaps the more obvious choice – and yet Fili looks rather confident on his own.
“Well, let’s meet back here before it’s completely dark, then,” Fili says – Bilbo seems uncomfortable, and Kili is likely to badger him until he answers. While the hobbit appears to have forgiven them for the troll incident, Fili thinks it would be rather unkind to try his patience again.
And Thorin’s mood is bound to sour further should dinner be late.
***
The forest floor is covered in leaves and small bushes, darkening the uneven ground considerably. It takes Bilbo a moment to spot the first mushroom patch, but after that, he knows what to look for and it’s easy work. He hums an old tune under his breath – if he doesn’t think, he can pretend he’s back in the Shire, looking for mushrooms as he has done on many an afternoon.
That there will be a warm home waiting for him, and not a company of dwarves that – well, he can’t call them unfriendly, because everybody knows that dwarves are gruff, but their treatment of him feels quite cold at times. Not all of them – Bofur, Fili and Kili certainly try to make him feel welcome, Ori is curious and Balin is willing to educate him in cultural matters – and yet…
It remains that he is no dwarf and therefore nobody is certain if he is truly a member of their company, or just some odd afterthought.
When he looks up, it is almost completely dark. The sun is behind the horizon, and the sky overhead is a smoky blue with the first stars growing visible. His heart skips a beat, and with a silent wish not to prove himself further incompetent by losing track of the time, he hurries back to their meeting point.
It’s empty – and at first Bilbo is relieved. He isn’t late.
But the forest around him grows darker with each passing moment. What if he is indeed late? So late that the others moved on without him?
***
Hunting takes patience, but tonight both brothers are in luck. They do meet up on chance, both earlier and at a different place – and, looking at what they got – decided that it’s more than enough to feed the entire company.
Contend and hungry, they make their way back to camp.
***
Bilbo tells himself to calm down. The brothers will show up any moment – they are not particular punctual, so he should not worry. They will not abandon him – they …
Something rustles in the trees, but no dwarf emerges, and abruptly Bilbo’s heart is in his throat. The peaceful atmosphere suddenly seems menacing, and if the dwarves were close, he ought to at least hear them.
But he is alone, and it’s almost completely dark now.
A shudder runs down his spine. Maybe more time passed than he thought? Perhaps the brothers have waited for him quite a while, and only then left because he failed to show. Bilbo wouldn’t blame them, he dislikes unpunctuality, too.
So he ought to head back and apologize.
Bilbo takes a deep breath to calm himself. It isn’t completely dark yet – at least the sky overhead is blue, not inky black. The darkness between the trees, though, is foreboding. He swallows, turns – and realizes he has no idea where to go.
Don’t panic, he tells himself, just be rational and keep your head – as his mother taught him. He could certainly figure it out. He knows they didn’t walk too long into the woods, and he remembers in what direction each of them left. So roughly – if he turns right, he should at least be vaguely headed in the direction of their camp.
The problem with hiking through unfamiliar woods at night, however, is that time passes differently. What was a beautiful area at day grows strange and threatening. Each rustle causes him to flinch, the trees look unfamiliar, and with every step Bilbo is less and less certain he made the correct decision.
And how long has he been walking? Shouldn’t he be hearing his companions by now? Or at least be out of the wood? The trees do look rather unfamiliar. Did they pass this spot on their way in? Has the ground always been this uneven?
Hobbit feet don’t mind uneven ground or sharp stones, but in the darkness he barely sees the roots sticking up or the holes in the ground. Going is slow and unsteady, and Bilbo’s heart is in his throat.
Then wolves howl.
***
The howling picks up while the company is eagerly awaiting dinner. A hearty smell fills the air, and Kili’s stomach is grumbling in anticipation. Nearby, Bofur is whittling away, while the rest of the company has taken the chance to sit down and relax.
Wolves don’t pose a serious danger for a group of dwarves. When the noise first sounds, they all do stop for a moment and listen – wolves are no danger; wargs are another category entirely – but the high howls in the air are definitely wolfish.
A sigh of relief escapes from Fili’s lips and he leans back against a rock. Dwalin loosens his grip on his axes a bit.
“I think we’ll be alright tonight,” Balin comments, “This part of the mountains is fairly safe.”
It’s too far from Moria and too close to Rivendell to be hounded by orcs or goblins. They are already high up in the mountains, and the access to the area is limited to a few, steep paths – wargs will avoid these, as will most other travelers.
And their campfire ought to keep the wolves away.
“Stew’s done,” Bombur announces.
Kili jumps to his feet, while Bofur turns to glance back the woods. “Where’s Bilbo?”
***
Bilbo presses himself flat against the tree and dares not to breathe. The wolves are close, close enough he can hear them pad through the bushes. Their howls are too close to comfort, and Bilbo is too terrified to jump – and that saves him.
He knows he must get away, he knows he ought get out of here as fast as possible – or climb a tree, but his head’s in an uproar, his body barely moving and he feels as if he was suffocating. It’s as if his heart wants to tear itself out of his chest, while at the same time everything feels odd, surreal.
And he can’t stop his mind.
He ought to search a tree to climb – instead he thinks about how cold the night air feels, how much like then, when the world was black and white, snow and the darkness of the trees and the encroaching night.
It had been cold then, so bitterly, bitterly cold, and he’d felt so alone, even though his mother had held his hand. But there had been nobody but them on the snow-covered path, that beautiful path downhill from Bag End that cut through the fields, a patch of forest and was Bilbo’s favorite in spring.
But winter brought early nights and they were out too late, much too late, and Belladonna hurried them and yet they were barely out of the woods when the howling started behind them.
Bilbo remembers telling himself that it’d be alright, they are out of the woods, the wolves will not follow them – but they do.
A branch cracks just next to him. Bilbo flinches, blood draining from his head.
There is a pair golden eyes staring at him, no more than an arm’s length away.
***
“Didn’t he go with you?” Bofur asks.
Fili pales and he turns to stare at the forest. Only blackness can be found between the massive tree trunks – darkness and no sign of their hobbit.
“I thought he’d gone back already…” Kili mutters.
Bofur curses under his breath. Balin sets aside his bowl and stands. “You thought he went back?”
“Yes,” Kili says, and he looks afraid, “He didn’t show up at the meeting point, so we thought he might have…”
“He hasn’t been here,” Ori tells them. Needlessly, Fili thinks, but Ori appears as terrified as Fili feels.
“You haven’t seen him since you left?” Balin asks, tensely.
Dwalin is already buckling up his weapons. Fili feels terrible – and responsible. Have they really abandoned Bilbo in that unwelcoming forest? Hadn’t he vowed not act so thoughtlessly anymore after that debacle with the ponies?
What if something happened to Bilbo?
“We split up so we could be faster,” Kili tells the company, “He went looking for mushrooms…”
Thorin climbs to his feet. “We’ll have to look for him. Bombur, Gloin, you watch the camp.”
Then he turns to the rest of the company. “Take your weapons and torches – who knows what awaits us.”
He is as decisive as always, yet Fili can’t help but feel that his uncle is exasperated. Whether at their blunder, he can’t tell. But he hopes it is not at the necessity of them now having to look for their hobbit – whatever befell him, it is not Bilbo’s fault.
(And he prays it is something simple. Maybe he fell asleep from exhaustion. Maybe he overate and then decided to take a nap. Everything but what would make Bilbo feel their abandonment. They did not mean to – Fili is aware how isolated Bilbo must feel in the company, how unwelcoming some are – and hasn’t he sworn to not be one of those? Will he now be the one who abandoned Bilbo alone in a dangerous place?)
Fili has never felt so wretched. This could have been a wonderful evening – for once they are safe out here, and the food smells good – but now his heart is pounding, and he’s panicking on the inside. Kili keeps staring at the forest – “He’ll be alright, won’t he?”
But Fili can’t reply, because he does not know. He hopes so – because if Bilbo is harmed, it will be Kili’s and his fault.
He wishes they’d waited. Frantically wishes he could change his behavior then, could go back and remember. He’s not usually so scatter-brained, it’s just sometimes…
They had not meant to leave the hobbit behind. They’d just had a good run, and were eager to share their spoils. He’d just … forgotten.
Which is pathetic – you don’t forget a comrade, much less a friend. He only hopes Bilbo is willing to forgive them.
“We should split up,” Dwalin calls out.
“Only in pairs,” Dori cautions.
It’s only wolves, Fili wants to say, and they’ll be quicker to find Bilbo if they cover as much ground as possible. But a small risk remains, and as harmless as this forest may seem, splitting into single individuals is always a bad idea.
“Alright,” is the short response, and then they’re off.
Kili clings to Fili’s side, and he has to force himself to slow down, because they just might miss something.
***
For a moment, both Bilbo and the wolf are utterly still.
Then the wolf growls and lunges, teeth snapping shut a hair’s breadth from Bilbo’s face as he squeaks and stumbles backward. His foot catches on something and his heart stops and he thinks that this is the end, this is it, he will die torn apart by wolves, even as he falls.
He hits the ground hard, but the wolf misses him, its second lunge too far, and lands somewhere behind Bilbo. A howl goes up nearby, this time accompanied by snarling and Bilbo can’t breathe, can’t think, doesn’t even know what is real and what not. All he can see are gleaming white teeth, and he can smell the foul breath of the beasts and he doesn’t even know how many there are, but they are too close and he needs to get away.
Bilbo doesn’t even think about calling for help.
He rolls to his left, and a clawed paw scrapes across his back, tearing through cloth and skin. Bilbo doesn’t even feel it, he needs to get to his feet, up, up, up, and move, even though his back stings and there’s a trickle of something wet and warm running down.
Bilbo makes it to his knees, blindly reaching for the sword that has somehow become tangled in his coat and won’t budge, and then a heavy weight slams into his side. He’s thrown off his knees instantly, and something sharp and cold brushes past his jugular – and then he is flying and the other thing is not.
The ground rushes up and he tumbles and rolls more than he lands, and behind him the wolves howl with frustration. He’s gained moments, but his head is spinning and his shoulder burns. With his stomach rolling, he struggles upright, clutching onto the branches of nearby bush and his stomach threatens to empty itself while a cacophony of growls and snarls rushes his way. He sees glowing eyes in the dark, wicked teeth glinting in the moonlight, and his heart is in his throat.
With strength he doesn’t even know he possesses he jumps, because otherwise he’ll die, and in sheer desperation manages to grab hold of a higher branch. His arms tremble and the skin of his hands rips open on the rough bark, but Bilbo only hears the wolves snapping at his heels, their furious growls and feels their breath on his skin.
Gasping for breath he leverages himself up, his arms aching from the strain. He manages wrap his right leg around the thick branch, and is almost up, when suddenly jaws snap close around his left foot.
He doesn’t hear himself scream.
***
“I think Bilbo went this way after we –“ Kili breaks off the moment the howling begins again. But this time the sounds are ferocious.
He turns to Fili, who mirrors his frightened expression. Please not, they both think, and then Fili, chalk white and wide-eyed, he draws his sword.
“This way!” he shouts and runs off.
Kili follows, and the howls turn into snarls and barking and growling, and it sounds terrible. He has never feared wolves, but the snapping of sharp teeth now fills him with terror. The ground under his feet is unstable, the darkness so penetrating he barely sees a thing, and yet he runs faster than he ever has in his life.
Please not, he prays, once more, please, please, please.
And then Bilbo screams.
***
The beast digs his teeth in, holds on, while Bilbo clutches the branch in desperation. The weight on his foot is pulling apart his muscles, and he feels his tendons stretching further and further and he has never felt a pain like this before. It hurts so much it barely even registers, except for the whiteness overcoming Bilbo’s vision, and the feeling of hot liquid running over his feet, while the beast’s tongue pushes against his toes as the teeth slowly scrape down through flesh and bone.
He clings to the tree trunk with a strength born from desperation, uncaring of the wood biting into his skin, scratching up his cheeks. There might be tears burning in his eyes, and his eyes are wide-open, but he sees nothing.
Then the weight is gone and his lower leg throbs – throbs because there is so much pain it does not even register, and Bilbo is afraid to look down. He scrabbles to hold on, his sweat-soaked hands bleeding from the rough bark.
A loud snarl – and teeth cut into the soft flesh of his leg again, but this time the jaw closes around his leg, and Bilbo can’t even scream –
And he loses his hold, and he’s falling, and then he hits the ground and his head is spinning, and he can’t move, but he can smell the wolves, and hears them and they are so close, and -
And he must die.
What the wolves of the Shire did not accomplish all those years ago, these beasts will. Bilbo does not even know what to feel – pain, despair, loneliness – but it is all swallowed by sheer terror.
He wants this to be over – but he can’t just lie still in agony. He rolls over, and teeth find his arm instead of his neck. Claws scrape over his thighs, and he whimpers, as the wolves growl.
Then abruptly something loud crashes into the space, the wolves snarl and turn, and some of that noise sounds like yelling, and footsteps, and the side of his collar is warm and sticky, and the world fades into black.
***
Kili’s arrow kills the wolf hovering over the unmoving shape of their burglar, and Fili launches himself at the next one with an unintelligible cry. Dwalin beheads another, and Thorin takes care of the snarling beast that tried to sneak up on Ori.
The wolf pack does not stand a chance. Not if they counted twice as many; not against a group of furious dwarves.
Fili does not care for clean kills – from the corner of his eye he sees the crumpled form of their hobbit, and he can’t tell if he’s alive or dead, but those screams, those screams –
He cuts and cuts and cuts, and does not even hear when the growls turn into whimpers, and the wolves turn to run. Kili shoots the stagglers, and Oin is already across the cleaning, followed by Bofur and Thorin.
Fili’s blood is singing, his heart crying for revenge when he joins them. Kili, next to him, gasps for air, but whether from exhaustion or fear, none can tell. Oin curses, and Thorin looks appalled and Fili is terrified.
Up close he can smell blood. Much of the ground is covered in it – and even if Bilbo’s burgundy jacket hides some, there is no covering the four, deep, parallel scratches running across his back. His right shoulder has been bitten – and Kili abruptly gags and turns.
Fili glances down.
Bilbo’s lower left leg is a mess. It looks chewed on – most of the skin is gone; tendons and muscles exposed, with chunks missing from in between. Bone is peeking out from the mess here and there, and Fili can’t even tell if all toes are still attached.
His stomach twists, and he has to turn away, just when Oin asks Dwalin to come over and get rope or a belt, because they have to stem the bleeding if Bilbo is supposed to even have a chance. Under Dwalin’s hands Bilbo looks even smaller, and there is already so much blood on the ground.
Somebody retches, but Fili’s can’t tear his eyes away. Not when he is responsible for this disaster, not when Oin carefully rolls Bilbo on his back.
The hobbit whimpers, his brow creased in a pained frown. His face is pale, scratched up and bloodied, and Fili wishes he could undo this all.
Oin carefully works his way down Bilbo’s torso, muttering under his breath. His face is drawn, posture tense – his expression does not darken (but neither does it lighten). With a lurch of his stomach Fili realizes that Bilbo’s leg looks even worse like this. Even now a bit of blood trickles from the open wound (is that mess of flesh and bone even a wound?), and around him, the company looks grave.
“Oin?” Dwalin asks.
Their designated healer leans back. He does not look happy when he turns to face them. “He may have a chance…”
They all hear the unspoken ‘but’ in there. And truly, it is not a difficult conclusion to come by, given the amount of blood covering the ground and the gory mess that is Bilbo’s left leg.
“Let’s get him back to camp,” Thorin orders. His voice does not betray any emotion, and Fili wonders how he does it. His own hands are trembling, and he doesn’t dare to speak – his voice would break.
Instead he falls in step next to Kili, who is still as white as chalk; his eyes wide in disbelief and terror. Fili manages to grip his brother’s upper arm – and from there on it is difficult to tell, just who is supporting whom.
Bofur is the one who carries Bilbo – tenderly and carefully. The hobbit, thankfully, remains unconscious, though his expression twists in pain at each small movement.
By the time they have reached camp, Bilbo is shivering. His pallor is worse, and Oin frowns worriedly.
“He’s in shock,” he announces, “Not a surprise, but…”
“Will he make it?” Ori bursts out, “Is there something we can do?”
Oin wipes a hand across his face. He looks at Bilbo again, visibly making a call. Then he sighs. “There is nothing we can do. With the materials at hand I can’t save him.”
Fili’s gaze is drawn to the mangled leg. Of course, Oin can’t help him, here, out in the wilderness. Even in a settlement this kind of injury would be difficult to treat.
Dwalin clears his throat. “If we cut off the leg,” he says, “It’s harsh, sure, but if we cut it off and then cauterize it at once, it’d stop the bleeding.”
Thorin glances over to the merrily flickering campfire. Fili swallows – this is brutal, but if it saves Bilbo’s life… And the hobbit is unconscious, so he might not even feel it.
Oin shakes his head. “He’s lost too much blood already. He wouldn’t survive.”
They turn their gazes back to the figure shivering pitifully on the ground. Bilbo has been wrapped in several blankets, with only his maimed leg sticking out. Oin has barely dared to touch it – he could clean it with alcohol, but with the state of the leg he doubts it would help.
“What do we do then?” Kili bursts out, and stumbles forward “We can’t just… can’t just stand there and watch him die?!”
“Kili!” Thorin hisses.
“You can’t do this!” Kili shouts accusingly, and sinks to his knees next to Bilbo’s prone form, “You can’t just let him die! We’re … we’re not…”
Fili hears the tears in his brother’s eyes, and so does everyone else.
Balin draws a loud breath. “Rivendell,” he says, “It’s about a day’s ride if you hurry.”
Thorin glares at him, but Oin seems thoughtful. “The elves might be able to help,” he offers, “It’s no guarantee, but I have heard that Lord Elrond is a gifted healer.”
“Then I will take him there!” Fili announces. His knees feel weak, and he might be trembling on the inside, but this is the least he can do. Their foolishness has landed Bilbo in this situation – it is their responsibility to get him out of it again.
“And I’ll come with you,” Kili says, before Thorin can protest.
Their uncle does not look happy, but the remainder of the company has already accepted their decision. “You’ll have to ride hard,” Balin says, and Dori adds, “Take Minty and Daisy – they are the fastest.”
“Try to keep the burglar stable,” Oin says, “I’ll wrap his leg, and see if I can get some liquid into him. Check his breathing – and his heart. He might get a fever, so try and keep him out of the sun.”
Already Bofur is leading the ponies to them, and Kili is preparing their bags.
Fili watches it all with a pounding heart. He swallows, looks at Bilbo and prays to whatever deity might be listening to please, please not let the hobbit die.
***
Later Fili will not remember much of their desperate ride through the night, even though it seemed to last forever. They are lucky in that they do not encounter any hostile being. Instead, Middle Earth seems lonely as the eastern horizon begins to grow lighter.
The mountains glow once the sun crests over the horizon, but all they focus on is the road ahead and the hobbit in Fili’s arms. His breathing is uneasy, shallow, but there is no more comfort to be found atop a horse.
It is just before noon that they reach Rivendell. Neither of them has eyes for its beauty; instead Fili bows to the first elf he sees and says, “Please, our friend needs help.”
And draws back his cloak to reveal Bilbo’s slumped form.
***
Fili and Kili do not leave Bilbo's side, even as Elrond and his aides cut away the blood-soaked clothes. The skin underneath - where it has not been torn open or hideously bruised, is sickly pale, and Fili has to swallow down bile when he realizes that on top of everything, the hobbit has also lost a significant deal of weight.
Just three weeks ago he was a prosperous, round little thing - now little of that remains.
In daylight, the injuries look worse. Bilbo's skin is littered with cuts and scrapes, but they all pale compared to the deep scratches running across his shoulder. They are bright red, and oozing puss - Fili knows the claw marks on Bilbo’s back are even deeper, and he does not dare think about the foot. Dread fills Fili’s entire chest.
Even Elrond sucks in a deep breath when he unwraps that mess.
"In all honesty, master dwarf," Elrond says after a heartbeat, "I do not know if I can save him."
And the fragile hope in Fili’s heart falters. Something burns in his eyes and he has to avert his gaze. Bilbo rests quietly on that cot prepared for a much larger being, looking pale and fragile. Any other being - even a dwarf - would have died from the blood loss alone. That Bilbo has managed to linger is nothing short of a miracle – Fili knows that.
And yet…
"Please just try," Kili chokes out, not even trying to hide his desperation, "Please."
Elrond looks taken aback for a short moment. Then he turns his attention back to Bilbo's mangled leg, inclines his head and says, "Of course."
Fili's watches in petrified horror as the tourniquet is opened and replaced - the skin underneath is blue and black, and with growing queasiness Fili realizes that Bilbo may lose the entire leg.
An elf suggests this, but is shut down, since "He wouldn't survive it."
Fili's notices that his hands tremble.
A painful moan draws all attention to Bilbo. The hobbit's eyelashes are fluttering, his face is sweat-soaked and a shudder runs through his entire body.
"He's coming to," a blond elf calls out, and Fili is frozen to the spot. Bilbo can't wake - not to this, not to even more pain, not when they can't give him anything because they are all too afraid he might not wake up again.
Nonsensical sounds leave Bilbo's chapped lips. It may be a name or a plea for help - the hobbit's eyes are glazed, and whatever he sees, Fili desperately hopes it is a friendly face.
"His heart is speeding up - he's going to lose more blood like this," says another elf, with a pointed glance to where, in spite of the new tourniquet, the sheet underneath Bilbo's leg is turning bright red at an alarming rate.
"Talk to him," Elrond tells Fili and Kili, "He knows your voices, there is a chance they may calm him."
Or scare him further, Fili thinks. After all, they are the ones that left him on his own, have consigned him to this.
Kili abruptly unfreezes. He falls more than steps next to the bed, and gently reaches out to smooth the hair out of Bilbo's pale face, muttering under his breath, pleading with Bilbo to calm down, to rest and to relax. Fili, with his heart in his throat, follows his brother.
Carefully he settles down on the mattress, and reaches for Bilbo's hand. The palm is clammy and cool, frighteningly limp and fragile. It disappears entirely between Fili's hands, as he sets out to rub some warmth back into it. (Or so, that if the worst comes to pass, Bilbo will not be alone).
He finds that there are tears burning in his eyes, and he closes them before the elves see.
Bilbo flinches violently as one of the healers begins cleaning out his maimed leg. Elrond is muttering a spell or something under his breath, eyes closed in concentration. The hobbit's brow furrows, and a pained sound escapes from his throat, but the healer does not falter.
The rag turns red and brown, and so do sheets and water. A strong septic smell fills the air, and Fili makes the mistake to look down. Red flesh glistens in the air, but chunks of it are missing. In between the white of bone glares through, and there is one patch in Bilbo's foot, where Fili can actually look through the space between the small bones.
His stomach turns violently and he has to look away. The bile rises, and if he clutches Bilbo's hand like a safety line, nobody notices.
The hobbit's struggles lessen, and when Fili looks to his face, it has grown impossibly paler. Kili is half frantic, telling Bilbo to hang on, to wait for them, because they will save him this time, but all it garners is a weak shake of the head.
In the end, it takes even Rivendell's skilled healers a long time until the wounds have been taken care of. By the time they are done, Bilbo's life hangs by a thread, and Elrond himself needs to be helped by another elf to remain upright.
"I cannot do anymore," he tells Fili and Kili who both bow deeply to show their gracefulness, "But your hobbit friend is strong to have lasted so long."
And that is truly all that can be said.
Fili and Kili stay with the hobbit all through the night and the next day. Elvish healers come in and out, change bandages, apply ointments and check on Bilbo's breathing. The hobbit remains unconscious, and Fili is almost glad once he develops a fever - it is better than the pale stillness that so much resembled death already.
Though when Bilbo, delirious with fever, twists and turns, yells for his mother and cries, Fili can't help but detest his own relief at what so obviously causes Bilbo further pain. Kili is quick to wipe the tears away, to caress Bilbo's hair in a way a mother might have done.
But they are a paltry replacement.
By the second morning, Bilbo still stubbornly clings to life. Kili has finally nodded off in the chair - the princes have refused to leave the hobbit, even when Elrond himself told them to rest - and Fili, too, feels utterly exhausted. An elf tells him that the rest of the company arrived, but Fili does not truly make sense of the words until the door is opened and Thorin marches in, followed by Bofur, Oin and Balin.
"Elrond says he may live," Thorin announces, "Oin?"
The healer moves and begins to peel back bandages, muttering under his breath. "They have something nice for those cuts," is something Fili catches, "Probably won't even scar..."
But Fili is distracted by the twisting expression on Bilbo's face. And when Oin touches the leg, Bilbo's eyes abruptly snap open, and he tries to sit up. Fili checks the movement, and a pained gasp leaves Bilbo's lips as he falls back against the pillow, eyes wide with panic.
"Bilbo, calm down," Kili calls out, "Calm down, you're safe. It's alright! Bilbo!"
"Make sure he doesn't hurt himself further," Oin orders, and Fili presses Bilbo back against the pillows, as gently as possible. But the hobbit is fighting him with all his strength - not much, but Fili can already tell his grip will leave bruises, and Kili keeps pleading.
It takes far too long, but eventually Bilbo's eyes clear.
"Fili, Kili," he mutters, in wonderment, "What...?"
And then the exertion takes its toll and Bilbo faints again before he can even complete that sentence.
Fili feels like crying. But with so many people in the room, he keeps his head bowed and his mouth shut, until Oin steps back and releases a deep breath.
"I'd say he'll make it," he pronounces, "Unless his heart gives out. Mind you, any other creature's heart would've already done so, but apparently hobbits are a fair bit hardier than expected."
***
Kili initially only pretended to be asleep, so that Oin and Thorin could not badger him into abandoning his post. Balin had already frowned at Fili's pallor, and Kili knows that once Oin recommends rest, Thorin will make sure, they follow.
But he has promised not to leave Bilbo's side again, not when the hobbit might wake up alone and in pain.
Though, perhaps, he had underestimated his own exhaustion. When he wakes up, it is far later - the light has grown dim again - and it is due to something touching his own hand. Blearily, he raises his head - and Bilbo's eyes meet his.
The hobbit is awake and aware and Kili's heart skips a beat. Certainly, exhaustion is prominent on Bilbo's face, and he is still far too pale, but the panic is gone. Instead, Bilbo's brow is furrowed.
"Kili," he whispers, "Where are we? What happened?"
Kili blinks, dumbfounded as dread wells up in his chest. "Don't you remember?" he asks before he can stop himself.
Bilbo bites his lips, "Only that we ... We went looking for dinner, I think. You, your brother and me, didn't we? I'm afraid it's all a bit blurry..."
And Kili wants to scream for help. He does not know how to deal with this, how to reply to the innocently trusting gaze Bilbo is directing at him.
He draws in an unsteady breath and nods. "We did. And ... We're at Rivendell."
"Were we attacked?" Bilbo asks, "Is everybody alright?"
Kili's heart breaks. He wants to draw Bilbo into his arms, shield him from harm - and yet, he barely can look at the hobbit when he finally finds his voice (choked as it is).
"It... We ... We are alright. Just you ... I'm so sorry," he bursts out, even as Bilbo frowns in confusion, "We went to look for food, and there were wolves, and Fili and I thought you'd already gone back - and I'm sorry, we're sorry, we never meant to leave you alone, please. We didn't mean to, we just, just ... Failed completely."
He hangs his head.
For a moment Bilbo is silent. Then Kili feels a hand coming to rest on top of his own. A hand swathed in white bandages.
"Err, it's alright, I think?" Bilbo mutters, aiming for a light tone, "I mean, I'm no fighter and I can be fairly clumsy. And I've never been good with wolves...."
A shudder goes through Bilbo's body, and Kili feels as if he must cry. "I'm sorry," he mutters, feeling useless.
"How bad is it?" Bilbo asks, "I, I don't remember anything, just that we went into the forest. And now... Well, nothing hurts, but my head feels a bit bloated, so I know better than to trust my senses."
He laughs uneasily as Kili's eyes widen in disbelief. "I, ah, well, if it isn't much I'm certain I won't be holding you up much longer. I'm afraid I'm a bit out of practice with this falling down and getting up again - from a certain age on we hobbits try to avoid the falling down but entirely so..."
"You almost died," Kili blurts out, and Bilbo grows pale. "Oh," he mutters, "I... I didn't know..."
Kili shakes his head, and it takes all not to grab Bilbo by the shoulders and shake some sense into him. The hobbit has no business looking at him like this when he lingered at death's door for the last two nights. When Kili has seen more of his leg from the inside than from the out.
"You almost died because we left you there," Kili yells, and this time he can't stop the tears from falling, "We thought you'd gone ahead and left, and didn't even think to check on you until dinner. And then, and then..."
He is gasping for air, but the words keep tumbling out of his mouth. He needs Bilbo to understand how badly they screwed up, how ill this went - the hobbit cannot just laugh this away, that... That would offend his honor just as much as Bilbo's.
"We went to look for you, but the wolves found you first... We killed them, but... I'm sorry," the last words are barely louder than a whisper.
"You couldn't have known there were wolves," Bilbo says, but the silence has already stretched too long, "Or that they prey on hobbits."
He sounds tired, and Kili realizes this discussion is perhaps detrimental to his health. So he forces himself to calm down, clench his fists and contain his inner tumult. However, before he can answer, a new voice joins their discussion.
"But we were supposed to wait for you," Fili says from where he stands in the doorway, clad in an unfamiliar tunic - perhaps borrowed from the elves, "And that was for a good reason. We might not have known about the wolves, but the wild is a dangerous place, and there are worse things than wolves out there - which is why uncle insists that nobody ever leaves the company on their own."
Kili wipes angrily at his eyes, while his brother crosses through the room. "And in that duty to you, both us failed. For that, we will accept whatever punishment you deem fit."
Fili inclines his head gracefully, and Bilbo flushes. "Er, I, uh,..... I don't think that will be... Unm..."
"Take your time and think about it," Fili tells him, "We and the entire company are aware of our culpability. And it would ease my own conscience."
Kili nods.
"Anyhow, I am glad you are awake," Fili continues, "And before my brother and I tire you out, I believe Lord Elrond wanted to speak with you."
Though Bilbo is fatigued, he agrees.
***
Bilbo is only left alone for a very short time. After Fili has pulled Kili from the room, they are soon replaced by Elrond, and Bilbo wants to rub his eyes. A part of him can hardly believe this is real - he is at Rivendell, being treated by such an illustrious historical figure - and Elrond is everything he imagined and more.
And yet the elf asks unsettling questions. If the dwarves purposefully endangered Bilbo's life - which he, strained as his relation to the group may be, firmly denies. Thorin and some of the more old-fashioned dwarves may disapprove of him (and they are not wrong, Bilbo is certainly no burglar), but Fili and Kili are honest in their regret, and Bilbo likes them, and Ori and Balin and Bofur and Bombur (and the others, too).
"So what is a lone hobbit doing amid a group of dwarves?" Elrond inquires.
"Well, one day Gandalf..." Bilbo begins, and Lord Elrond - rather unbecomingly of such an ageless being - sighs deeply, "Gandalf," he repeats, exasperated, "I should have known."
Bilbo can't help but chuckle. "Well, he is known as a disturber of peace back in the Shire."
Elrond raises an eyebrow. "Your people thus are wiser than many others. So why did you leave?"
It is both too difficult and too personal to explain his reasons - from loneliness to his mother's adventurous streak to the enchanting singing and to simple boredom - even if the other party is a famed elf lord. So Bilbo shrugs. "I thought it was the right decision."
Elrond waves it away, "I merely wanted to ascertain you joined the company on your own wishes, and were not coerced."
Whether by wizard or by dwarves remains unspoken, yet in this Elrond is surprisingly easy to read. Bilbo gives a wry smile - he certainly wasn't coerced, but he won't say he wasn't convinced. And he also knows that his decision will not appear rational or sane to any outsider.
"Well, be at peace while you are here, and take your time to recover," Elrond tells him. Somebody will be by later to change the bandages. If you feel so inclined, I could have somebody bring you something to read, also."
Bilbo perks up. "I would love to. Actually, might it be permissible if I visited the library myself?"
Elrond frowns. "Certainly permissible, but I am afraid it will be sometime until you are able to walk. And, I'm afraid to say, the library is quite some distance away."
Bilbo blinks. "I ... Well, I think I might manage with a crutch, then?"
Elrond steps closer and peers at Bilbo's face. "Master hobbit, a crutch will not nearly suffice. Do you not remember what happened to your leg?"
Bilbo swallows. "I'm afraid I don't," he admits, suddenly fearful. He'd thought it was a break - he'd seen it happen to other hobbits. One wrong step, a loud crack, tears, and quite a while spent wearing thick and stiff bandages until the bone had mended.
The bandages wrapped around his left leg certainly seem thick enough.
"Though they did tell me that apparently I was rather... injured," Bilbo adds, uncertain whether or not Fili and Kili might have overplayed the seriousness of his injuries.
"That was apt," Elrond comments gravely, "For two days we did not know whether you would live or not. And for your information - your leg was maimed. Had we not been certain it would kill you, it would have been amputated."
"Oh," Bilbo has grown pale and weakly slumps back against the fluffy pillows, "I ... I wasn't aware."
"And that is no bad thing," Elrond replies gently, "Because it means that the medicine we give you against the pain is working. It doesn't always, and I'm afraid to say it loses some of its potency after a while. So you may experience some discomfort yet."
"But nobody is going to cut off my leg?" Bilbo asks. He'd be stranded without his left leg, and the idea leaves him terrified.
Elrond smiles. "No. The injuries are healing surprisingly well. Baring complications, you may actually make a complete recovery in time."
At that point Bilbo is too relieved to think further on it.
But once night has fallen and Bilbo finds himself unable to sleep, he grows uneasy. He is either too hot or too cold, and he can't lie down anymore, but he has barely enough strength to push himself to a sitting position.
His thoughts begin to wander as well.
How much time has passed since their arrival? How far had they been from Rivendell when it happened - his mind still comes up with nothing when he tries to recall what occurred after he left for the forest.
He will need to talk to Kili and Fili again. Make certain they don't blame themselves - though it would be easier and more convincing if Bilbo actually knew what happened. But he thinks they are truly sorry, so he is willing to forgive and go on.
If he can go on, that is.
They - that is Thorin - is operating in a limited timeframe. Bilbo is not quite clear on the details, but Thorin wants to reach Erebor quickly. Though even Elrond told Bilbo that healing will take time. And if his leg is truly that badly injured, it will need a lot of time.
He swallows against the knot building up in his throat.
Bilbo doubts Thorin will be inclined to wait. Not that he can fault him - a break may very well take an entire season to heal, and if his leg is injured worse ... If Thorin decides to move on and leave Bilbo behind, the hobbit can understand his reasons (and to Thorin he has been but a deadweight all along).
It just...
He doesn't want this adventure to end already. He doesn't want to go home. Doesn't want to return to his calm, in exciting life. Not when he has just started to get to know the dwarves, is constantly learning new and fascinating things of their history and culture. He hasn't given it much thought, but the campfire conversations have made him feel more alive than feuding with Lobelia ever had.
(And even his prized tomatoes don't taste as good as a hearty meal after a long day of riding).
Something burns in his eyes, and Bilbo clenches them shut. He doesn't want the adventure to end, but he knows that it is only sensible.
When sleep comes, it is uneasy and filled with odd nightmares.
***
The nightmares are frequent, and most of the time Bilbo doesn't remember anything - at least he says so.
Until one night, when the moon is too bright to let Fili sleep, so he has taken up his bedside vigil at the hobbit’s bed, and stays silent long after Bilbo has woken abruptly and struggled to get his breathing under control.
Instead of lying back down, that night Bilbo turns to look at him. "It was a pack of wild wolves, wasn't it?"
Something cold runs down Fili's spine. "Do you remember?"
Bilbo makes to shake his head, but then shrugs. "I don't think so. But, in those dreams... I think I tried to climb a tree..."
He is silent, gathering his thoughts, and Fili waits.
"In the Shire, we sometimes get wild wolves. They teach you to climb as high as possible in that case and wait them out," he laughs, "We aren't fighters."
"It's actually a fairly decent strategy," Fili comments, "Better than entering a fight you may not win."
Bilbo nods. "And it's very rare that wolves come to the Shire - not enough easy prey. But sometimes, when the winters are too cold and last too long you can hear them howl in the woods. And in the twilight you see them hovering along the tree lines on the other side of the rivers."
Fili shudders at the description. He has never feared wolves, but there are other enemies. Though dwarves tend to go out and fight them - how horrid must this game of wait and see be.
"One year," Bilbo continues, "When I was still fairly young, the Brandywine froze. It was the worst winter in recent memory - and with the river frozen dozens of wolves crossed into the Shire. It got so bad we couldn't leave our homes - old Mr. Cottonfoot was torn to pieces right on his own porch."
Bilbo shivers, his gaze fixed on an invisible object in the distance. "But then the food started to run out, too. Though we were lucky - my parents had a pretty well-stocked pantry."
A habit Bilbo has kept; Fili recalls. A habit with a far more practical background than any of them expected - they had taken the filled pantry as an expression of wealth more than anything.
"Though then we started running out of firewood. And my father had become ill, so we couldn't really let the rooms grow any colder," Bilbo chuckles unhappily, rubbing at his wounded shoulder, "It was in the middle of the day, it shouldn't really have been a problem. Mam and I went out, just down the hill, to get some more wood. Before we're even halfway done that howling starts up, and the beasts are practically everywhere."
Fili bites his lip. He has seen hobbit children in the Shire - he wouldn't pit any against a grown solve, much less a starving one.
"Mother told me to climb a tree and stay there," Bilbo shudders, "She could handle herself, always could, and I was so frightened...."
Fili holds his breath, and prays this story has no gory conclusion. Abruptly, Bilbo returns to the present and catches Fili's horrified gaze.
"She killed three of them with an axe," he tells Fili with a wry smile, "Got pretty scratched up, but the wolves fled and left us alone long enough to get some wood. But it was fairly horrible, altogether."
"Mahal, Bilbo, I'm sorry," Fili says, dumbfounded, "If we had known, we'd never sent you out there on your own."
Bilbo shrugs. "You couldn't have known. And anyway, wolves are afraid of dwarves, rather than the other way around, I believe."
It is true, but it doesn't calm Fili's mind.
"Anyway," Bilbo ends his little narration, "That is why I'm not certain if I remember, or if it's merely old memories all over again. It's not so bad."
Fili blinks. “It’s horrible,” he protests, “It should never have happened!”
Bilbo smiles sadly. “Many things should never have happened,” he agrees, “And yet they do. But for what it’s worth, I’m still alive, so it all could have ended much worse.”
No words come to Fili’s mind on how to respond. So he acts on instinct and draws Bilbo into his arms and keeps him there until he has fallen asleep again, and the sun begins to rise.
***
The next day brings Gandalf to Rivendell. The wizard is most upset when learns what has happened to Bilbo, and after a short and harsh exchange of accusations, Thorin ends up even less willing to let Elrond view his map.
Fili and Kili steal away. They had wanted to make their own apology to the wizard, but with tempers foul as they are, a strategic retreat may be the better - if more unsettling - solution. (They would have preferred not to upset the wizard. The worst they have seen Gandalf do is storm off in a fit of pique, but rumor tells of unwary beings turned into toads and worse).
Their footsteps lead them back to Bilbo's room.
The hobbit is still asleep, so they take care to enter as silently as possible. In silent agreement they both draw up chairs so they can sit as close to the bed as possible. It is Kili's voice that draws Fili from his uneasy thoughts.
"Fili," he calls in as quietly as possible, and nods to Bilbo.
The hobbit's expression is twisted as if afraid or in pain, he twists under the blankets and is muttering under his breath. Nightmares, Fili realizes.
Not a surprise, after what Bilbo went through, but they had all hoped the hobbit would be spared this evil since his memories seem gone. But perhaps they aren't truly gone - Fili knows that this happens to seasoned warriors, knows it from listening behind closed doors when he ought to have been asleep.
He also knows that waking somebody caught in a violent nightmare is not without risk. But Bilbo is hardly strong enough to do damage, and Fili finds he can't watch this fearful expression on the hobbit's face a moment longer.
"Let's wake him," he tells Kili.
Kili blinks - and then nods with a small smile. And Fili breathes a little easier, as he steps forward and calls Bilbo's name.
When the hobbit fails to react, he reaches out to gently shake his shoulder. And the effect is instant - Bilbo jumps up, eyes wide and out of breath.
"No, don't -" he shouts, before he realizes that he is no longer caught in the nightmare. For a moment he just stares at Fili and Kili, before he falls back with an exhausted exhale. Warily, he wipes the sweat from his forehead, and Fili wants to apologize - but this is not the time for it.
Instead he clears his throat before the silence grows too long. "How are you?"
Bilbo seems grateful for the distraction, and manages the shadow of a smile. "Exhausted. Drained. Somewhat sore - but apparently I am still lucky. Master Elrond was in earlier this morning and indicated that I am extraordinarily lucky that I am not crippled by pain."
"He has said as much to us," Fili agrees.
"And some more," Kili mutters glumly. When Bilbo inclines his head in question, he continues, "Looked at us really grimly and more or less asked us if we actually wanted you to die."
Bilbo actually grins, "He more or less asked me the same."
"What?" exclaims Kili, "But you know we didn't! You know, don't you? We didn't know about the wolves and we would have never left you out there! You know that?!"
Bilbo flinches at the noise, but eventually raises a hand and signals Kili to calm down. "I know, I know," he says, "And I'm not angry or anything. Really, you don't need to worry. I'm rather afraid, though, that your uncle will now like me even less than before."
"Thorin?" Fili echoes, surprised, "Why should he?"
Bilbo twists the blanket between his hands. "Well, I haven't been much of a help, and now he had to go to Rivendell. I don't think he wanted to go here... And certainly not for such a long time."
Fili, who is too familiar with his uncle's mindset, grasps for words to say that aren't a lie, but Kili is quicker. "Well, he's hard to win over - half of the time I think he disapproves of me, but that's just his normal temper. Don't take it to heart - everybody else likes you far too much to leave you behind."
Bilbo straightens, and blinks. "Wait, what, wait for me? But everybody has been saying that it will take ages until I can even walk again."
Fili shrugs. "I doubt we will be leaving before the map has been deciphered, though. Uncle may be stubborn, but Gandalf has the right of it. If Elrond can read it, we should ask him."
"Yes, and I would think that Thorin would be off the moment after," Bilbo adds, "And I doubt I will be up to running by then."
"We dwarves can be quite stubborn," Kili chimes in, "If he puts his mind to it, uncle can easily last years."
Bilbo smiles, but his heart isn't in it. There is another matter weighting on the hobbit's mind, Fili realizes, and wonders how to address it.
"In any case," Bilbo says, "You needn't wait for me. I believe this may take a while."
"But we don't want to leave you behind," Kili whines, "And what would you do? Wouldn't you be bored to death within days, surrounded only by elves? Wouldn't you rather come with us?"
Bilbo chuckles, "I'm afraid it's not so much a matter of what I want, and rather a matter of what I can do."
Fili tilts his head. "But if that wasn't an issue," he says, and while his words are light, he can't help but tense as he speaks them - much rides on the answer, "Would you come with us? Even though we got you into this mess? And please don't say anything to make us feel better - nobody is going to think less of you if you decide to stay or go home after that. Actually, I think, my brother and I would make certain you got home safely - it's the least we could do."
Bilbo looks at Fili with wide eyes, and in that precious moment he looks nothing like the stuffy, fussy hobbit that first opened that green, round door. There is a certain spark to his eyes, and he looks young.
"In that case," Bilbo says with a wistful smile, "I'd like to continue with you."
And Fili had never known how much he himself had invested in Bilbo's answer, until he feels happiness blossoming in his chest and he gives the hobbit a bright smile in return. Kili is a little faster. "Well, then that's cleared up," he announces, "I'll tell the others."
He is practically bouncing when he leaves the room.
Bilbo looks at Fili, confusion on his face.
Fili shrugs. "You can always change your mind. But unless you do, prepare yourself to be carried."
"What?" Bilbo exclaims, "You can't mean - no, that is preposterous, that is..."
Fili keeps smiling and Bilbo trails off.
"Really?" he asks, and then shakes his head, "You are mad, you can't carry me all the way across the Misty Mountains. You..."
Fili's expression doesn't change and Bilbo blinks. "You're serious?"
"My mother taught me to take responsibility for my actions," Fili ascertains, "And my brother and I are most certainly at fault, so it is also our duty to see that our failure does not impede on you any further. So if you want to continue, we'll carry you."
Bilbo stares at him, dumbfounded.
"Though I think the others will probably want to carry you to at least for a bit. We all feel a bit guilty, to be honest," Fili admits, "So I think we'll all be rather happy if you remain our burglar for a while longer."
The smile they receive is nothing short of brilliant.
Fin
