Chapter Text
There are some things in the world that are beyond imagination. Some things that the mind cannot perceive. Some things that the heart cannot bear.
Smaug, last of the great dragons, towers at a size no tale has correctly told. Nor will words ever accurately express the terror he instilled in those that saw him. In the dwarves and men that watched him descend in a whirl of fire and smoke, death and destruction. As he ravaged their homes, tore apart their lives and crushed all life in the mountain.
Nor will words ever tell what one small hobbit felt as he watched the great beast sail across the nightly sky. Overhead, stars twinkled and in the moonlight those vast wings shone gold. Down below, the lights of Laketown flickered peacefully on the water.
There is a moment when Bilbo asks what they have done. But his heart cannot grasp it yet. His mind does not understand what he is watching.
Then the town goes up in flames.
The night, up on the mountain, is quiet and peaceful. Down on the water, hundreds die in the firestorm.
Because he told the beast where he came from, a malicious voice hisses in the back of Bilbo’s mind. Because he set the dragon onto the town.
The blood is…
“Bilbo,” somebody calls and Bilbo flinches. Balin steps up next to him, his face lined with grief. But the fire is too far away to cast their faces in an orange glow up here. There is only a cool wind that ruffles Bilbo’s hair and freezes his fingers to match the feeling in his chest.
“Thorin wants us inside,” Balin announces, “We need to prepare for the dragon’s return.”
***
The dragon does not return.
Instead Bard arrives, backed by ragged group of survivors from Laketown and an elvish army in shining armor. Bilbo watches the negotiation escalate, and his stomach turns and twists.
“We have nothing left!” Bard shouts, his eyes fixed on Thorin. “Our town is burned! Whatever we possessed is gone! All our stores are destroyed, and it will be winter soon!”
Bile rises in Bilbo’s throat. He has not seen Laketown. But half the men behind Bard wear signed clothes. Some sport burns on their faces. If these are the ones who survived in good shape –
You sent the dragon down, the voice repeats. Bilbo clenches his fists in his pockets and is glad nobody is watching him, because surely his face must be as twisted as his heart is.
“You brought this upon us!” Bard adds, “I warned you not to disturb the dragon!”
His words pierce Bilbo like daggers. Thorin may have sent Bilbo inside. But he was the one taunting Smaug. He was the one who grew overconfident, who betrayed Laketown to its demise. Those deaths – and the lives winter will inevitably claim – Bilbo has caused.
He should have never left home.
“I will not treat with you as long as there are two armies camped on my doorstep!” Thorin shouts back, voice cold and hard. Bilbo does not recognize it, it frightens him. His hand touches the ring in his pocket – it is cool, unchanged. It can hide Bilbo from those accusing stares men cast upward, but it cannot hide him from the truth he knows.
Cannot protect him from the guilt he must carry.
***
Bilbo is no longer hungry. This is, perhaps, a small blessing – they have run out of food, and the majority of dwarves hardly care. They spend their days counting through the treasure, proclaiming their findings and seeking out the Arkenstone.
They do not care for those that wait at Erebor’s gates.
They do not care for the men that still die from wounds the dragon inflicted. That grow thinner as their slim stores are running out. For the new blood that stains Bilbo’s hands with each life the destruction Smaug wrought claims.
Bilbo sits listlessly, staring at the wall. Sometimes he wanders into the treasury. Sometimes he gets lost. Sometimes he uses his ring just to avoid everybody.
And, he thinks, maybe he should get lost forever. Wander into the gaping darkness of Erebor’s halls and tunnels. Fall down into an abyss – he has forgotten what it feels like to breathe freely. Cannot remember the feeling of sunlight on his skin. Warmth in his bones. What is was like to sit outside, on a warm summer evening and watch the stars come out while having a pipe.
That now seems like another life. One Bilbo does not think he can go back to. Not with so much red on his fingers…
In a trance, he pushes himself to his feet. The company will take some time until they notice he is missing. Perhaps he should leave a note – just so they know not to look for him? He wouldn’t want anybody else to waste time on his behalf, after all.
His eyes fall onto his backpack, and he recalls that there is another item hidden within.
For a moment, his lips twitch. Isn’t he just a walking disaster? Not only does he manage to pit a fire-breathing dragon on a town built from wood, he is also hiding the one item that is driving Thorin mad. Not many people have accomplished two feats so terrible – perhaps this is how history will remember him. Bilbo the Terrible.
It almost makes him smile and the trance fades. Bilbo purses his lips. Falling down a mineshaft is a rather cowardly way to go. His actions may be irredeemable, but that doesn’t mean he gets to run from it. Not when there is still something he can do.
His parents taught him that, at least.
Not that they would have been proud, Bilbo thinks, and then straightens his back. It’s unlikely Thorin will be receptive to suggestion. But he has to try.
Bilbo directs his feet toward the treasury. His head feels stuffy, numbed, and gathering a clear thought is difficult. Everything reminds him of what he caused and the guilt is suffocating. If there was a way to undo the damage …
He shakes his head with sad smile and pushes on. Soon, the corridor leads him to the vast treasure hall. He hears clinking, steps, and subdued voices. Mutterings in the dim, golden light. The sparkling diamonds and golden coins do little for Bilbo, and he turns his head to look for Thorin.
The dwarf is on top of a small mountain of treasure, digging carefully through it. Atop his head, the sturdy crown of Erebor sparkles ominously.
Bilbo gulps. “Thorin,” he calls out as he approaches, but the dwarf does not look up. Long hair hides his face from view, and his back is tense.
“Thorin,” Bilbo repeats, “I need to talk to you.”
He is an arm’s length away when Thorin finally tears his gaze from the ruby encrusted chalice in his hand. “What do you want, burglar? Have you found the Arkenstone?”
Bilbo reflexively shows his empty hands. “No, I came to – “
“Then you should continue searching,” Thorin orders and turns back to the treasure before him.
Bilbo’s heart drops. Perhaps he underestimated the degree to which the treasure has claimed Thorin’s mind. Perhaps – he shakes his head.
“I need to talk to you,” Bilbo insists, “It’s about Bard.”
Thorin’s finger clench around the chalice. When he looks up, his eyes are cold and furious. “We have no business with that man as long as he consorts with elves.”
“They need help,” Bilbo protests, and Thorin’s expression blackens, “Really, Thorin, just – you don’t need to help them, but I was thinking…”
He takes a step back as Thorin sets down the chalice, deceptively gentle. Then he rises.
“I was thinking,” Bilbo forces himself to continue even if he now has to tilt his head back to look Thorin in the eyes, “The dragon came onto Laketown because of me. And the contract accords me a fourteenth of the treasure – and really, I could never get so much gold home – how about giving my share to Bard instead?”
Thorin’s face twists abruptly. Bilbo barely registers the change, before Thorin grabs him by his upper arms in an unforgiving, iron hold. It hurts, but he’s spell-bound by the hatred filling Thorin’s eyes – all warmth gone from his expression without a hint that it had ever existed.
“You dare to suggest such a transgression? You would have me give my kin’s heritage away to a second-rate traitor?” he hisses and his voice is colder than ice. Bilbo’s heart freezes. “You would have me abandon all I fought for? Would have me bow my head to one who has never honored his word?”
Bilbo shakes his head frantically. His arms are numb, and he desperately searches for words to appease the King – he did not mean to offend him, he never wanted to unsettle him, all he ever wanted to do was make things right –
“You, Master Baggins, would have me sell out my kingdom before my kin has rightfully reclaimed it? You would have me summon another dragon?” Thorin continues, “For it makes no difference whether an elf or a dragon hoards my kingdom’s treasures.”
“No,” Bilbo stutters, “No, I – “
That’s not what he meant. Not at all – but Thorin doesn’t listen. He shoves Bilbo away suddenly, and the hobbit’s ankle gives. Bilbo hits the treasure with a dull thud, golden chalices and coins clink and roll. His head rings, but he sees Thorin tower above him.
The dwarf has a hand on his sword’s hilt.
“Next time before you make such a suggestion, Master Baggins,” Thorin says coldly, “Think. One day you may have to take responsibility for your actions.”
***
The words stay with Bilbo for a long time. He knows what he has brought about, understands it clearly even though the mountain is black during the night when only the snores of his companions provide company. Thorin no longer sleeps, the search for the Arkenstone having consumed his mind.
Bilbo wonders if this, too, lasts on his shoulders. Thorin will not find his gem, not as long as Bilbo knows exactly where it rests. But he cannot hand it over – it would not dispel Thorin’s mad obsession.
Instead he sits up, stares into the darkness and purses his lips. For a moment, the image of a distant town burning rises – it has seared itself onto the back of his eyelids.
Your fault, a voice inside his head hisses.
And Bilbo sighs. He will not deny his responsibility. But he will not see the men of the lake come to further grief either. He will not allow a pointless war to happen – not when he thinks he knows how to stop it.
Warily, Bilbo pushes himself to his feet. Casts a glance over his companions – or those that are present. Dwalin, Gloin and Fili are with Thorin. Bombur is outside, keeping watch.
They will not like him anymore come morning.
All that he gained in the months he traveled with these dwarves, the friendships, the easy companionship, the profound respect – it will all be lost. And nothing, nothing will be able to restore the trust he is destroying.
But they will live. And Laketown won’t starve. The elves won’t have to go to war.
In the end, does he have a choice?
***
What must come to pass, passes. Worse than Bilbo expected – he’d thought himself prepared, but hadn’t counted on the fierce pain ripping through his heart as Thorin raged and screamed. Suffocating – not from the hand around his throat – but from the disappointed stares cast his way.
Balin, Ori – even Kili – they all look at him, not with fury, but grief. And grief, too, perhaps drives Thorin to distraction. Once Bilbo’s legs dangle in the air and the wind howls around his ears – once he thinks it all will end, only moments left to this tragedy – once Thorin seems ready to kill him, his eyes turn blank.
Not from Gandalf’s shouts or Bard’s pleas. But from something that echoes in Bilbo’s own heart, something now ripped into pieces. Instead of letting him go to meet his fate, Thorin sets him back down. Turns around, unable to look at the traitor any longer. “Get out of my sight.”
And he does, and fate laughs into his face.
***
Orcs come, and goblins. Bats turn the day into night and only after much blood is shed the sun peeks through again, now casting light onto desolate, scorched earth. Broken bodies and smoking ruins remain, the survivors having dragged themselves to the ramshackle city of tents, their colors muted and stained. Even the elvish banners no longer resist the dirt.
Bilbo’s head aches fiercely. His vision is blurred and he stumbles forward, wondering where to go. Thorin’s words ring in his ears – he is banished from Erebor, but Laketown burnt down and Dale is a ruin.
His heart longs for the Shire. Or Rivendell. For blue skies and warm air.
An icy gust of wind makes him shudder. He clutches his torn jacket closer, and frowns at the dark sky. Already the shadows lengthen. Night will fall and temperatures drop even further. The wind carries the cold smell of snow.
“Bilbo!” somebody shouts, “Bilbo, there you are!”
He looks up to see Gloin running toward him. The red-haired dwarf sports a bandage wrapped around his upper arm, but his eyes are clear and no disappointment mars his features.
For a moment Bilbo contemplates reaching for his sword. But his body has reached its limit, and Gloin he could not have bested at his full strength. The ring then – Bilbo takes a deep breath. He doesn’t want to run, but he was banished. If the dwarves find him – if Gloin drags him back, it’ll be death.
Even though Gloin doesn’t look particularly angry.
And, Bilbo thinks, with the temperatures dropping, it is unlikely he would survive the night anyway.
“Bilbo,” Gloin gasps, and reaches for the hobbit, but hesitates, “Are you alright? Were you hurt? You look terrible.”
Bilbo blinks. “No, I … I … I was about to leave. I’ll not bo – “
“What? Leave where? Did Gandalf ask you? Is the wizard completely mad now? You can’t leave like this!” Gloin shouts, and grasps Bilbo’s arm.
“But I …” Bilbo stutters, “I mean … Thorin…”
Gloin shakes his head, “Owes you a serious apology. And not only he, and not just one. But I’ll get you to Oin first.”
Bilbo pushes his feet into the ground. Gloin doesn’t make sense; there is no point in bothering Oin when Bilbo will lose his head after anyway. Better to just go to sleep and let the cold do the rest. Declare him fallen in battle – that way it’ll be the least trouble for everybody involved.
Gloin notices the protest. And instead of merely dragging Bilbo along, he stops and turns. “Bilbo? What is it?”
Worry clouds his eyes as he leans down to study the hobbit closely. Bilbo’s heart clenches painfully at the reminder of the friendship they once shared.
“Just,” he stammers, “Just leave me here. It’ll … it’ll be easier.”
Gloin frowns and puts his hand against Bilbo’s forehead, not minding the blood and grime. Bilbo can’t help but sag against it.
“I apologize, but you don’t seem to be all here,” Gloin mutters quietly, “Yell at me all you want later, but I’m taking you to Oin first.”
And with that he scoops up a weakly protesting hobbit.
***
Thorin watches the sleeping hobbit with a deep frown. Bilbo has grown pale and haggard and he lies almost deathly still. The only dash of color provides a set of blue and purple bruises around his throat – and Thorin’s chest tightens.
Oin proclaimed the hobbit on the mend. Or rather said he’d done what he could.
Bilbo’s injuries are not terribly grave, Thorin knows this. But he suffered a head injury, and Thorin fears the outcome. Especially since Gloin remarked that Bilbo had appeared dizzy, not quite present. And had passed out before Gloin had gotten him into camp.
No matter, Thorin thinks to himself, he’ll make up for his transgressions. Regardless of whether or not Bilbo even remembers them.
A small noise from the bed attracts his attention. Thorin straightens, looks to the hobbit, and his breath catches. Bilbo's forehead is ceased, his fingers twitch.
For a moment Thorin contemplates sneaking out. He doesn't think Bilbo will be glad to see the king that almost murdered him, and Oin was deeply worried about that head injury. The few who'd seen Bilbo awake since Gloin carried him in - Bofur and Kili - described him as delirious.
Thorin stays and waits and hopes. His chest clenches, and he is afraid. Perhaps his presence will scare the hobbit, perhaps cause further damage. But he cannot go on with the guilt and uncertainty on his shoulders. If he is to take up the crown of Erebor, he will not do it if it cost him his burglar.
Should, Thorin vows to himself as Bilbo's eyelids begin to flutter, Bilbo not recover he will leave the throne to Fili and spend the rest of his own life doing what he can for this hobbit.
A soft noise comes from the bed and Thorin takes a deep breath. Bilbo’s eyes open, and stare at the ceiling without focus, and Thorin forces himself to speak before he can run out of air.
"Master Baggins," he calls, taking care to make his voice soft and gentle.
For a moment he receives no reaction and Thorin's heart grows heavy with dread. But then Bilbo frowns and tilts his head.
Thorin reaches for the waterskin Oin left behind, avoiding Bilbo's eyes a little longer. The hobbit grasps it with shaky, pale fingers that are bruised and cut up. They should never have been, Thorin thinks. He should have never gotten such a gentle creature into such a violent battle.
Only when Bilbo has drunken his fill he finally focuses on Thorin. A thin sheen of swear covers his forehead, and Thorin realizes he is still feverish.
"Master Baggins," he says gently, slowly, "How are you feeling? Shall I call for Oin?"
Bilbo blinks slowly. His lips move, but no sound comes out. Until "... for? Why if you'll ... kill me anyway?"
Thorin can't help flinching. "No," he protests, "You will not..."
Bilbo doesn't react to his emotional response. Instead the hobbit looks at him curiously, with fever-bright eyes free of accusation. Without any fear for his life.
Thorin swallows. Guilt is strangling his heart, and his chest feels heavy. "No," he repeats, calmer and slower this time, "We... I have since understood your reasoning. You have nothing to fear from us or any dwarf in this camp. All know you were the only one to resist the gold."
"Maybe," Bilbo quietly responds, his eyes still out of focus and staring at something Thorin cannot see, "But the dragon burnt it all..."
"You could not have stopped him," Thorin replies, though he isn't sure if Bilbo is listening, "Smaug would have come for the Lakemen sooner or later. We know that now. There is nothing you could have done."
At least the town did not get caught between a dragon and an Orc army. None could have survived - now, the town has suffered grievously, but Thorin knows that men are resilient. They will recover. Laketown will be rebuilt and so will Dale, and perhaps in two or three decades the terror of these days all but forgotten.
But the desolate expression does not vanish from Bilbo's face.
"Please rest some more," Thorin gently advises, "As much and as long as you need. No harm will come to you here. You are safe."
Somehow his words get through. Bilbo's left hand twitches before he turns to look at Thorin. "Safe?" He echoes, "But I..."
Thorin spreads his hands. "The ill-intentioned words I spoke on the wall I have long since revoked. And I cannot do but apologize again and again for not guarding against my ancestor's sickness. For not realizing the gold was cursed. For being blinded by greed and lashing out against a friend who had never given me cause to doubt him. I'm sorry to have driven you to such desperation, and I wish I could take it all back. I..."
"Thorin!" Oin calls, drawing back the tent flap, "Here you are! Balin is looking for you, he said - oh, Bilbo, you are awake?"
Thorin sighs, but when he turns back the hobbit is no longer looking at him. He can only hope his words were heard - he should not hope to ever receive any kind of absolution. But perhaps one day he can make Bilbo understand that he deeply regrets his actions.
Oin shuffles past him. "And, how are you feeling today, Master Hobbit? Up to some stew? We need to get some meat back onto those bones before winter comes."
Thorin rises to his feet. Casts a last glance at the hobbit who is now tracking Oin's movements without a visible reaction. Hopefully he will recover.
At least Oin appears tentatively optimistic.
***
Several days pass before the fever vanishes and Bilbo's mind finally clears. He's shaky on his legs, and sometimes still stares into space, but now he holds his own end in conversations.
At least that is what Fili reports. Thorin, completely swamped with work, has no time to visit and he gains the impression his company believes it would be better if he kept his distance. It hurts, but it's a fair judgment.
Eventually, Oin grudgingly allows Bilbo to leave his tent. The hobbit’s pallor won’t improve, and neither does his appetite truly return, but he’s awake and able to walk. As Bilbo buttons up his shirt and reaches for his coat he realizes he is almost excited.
Looking back, everything that happened since he set foot into Erebor appears like a dream. He doesn’t think he’s quite felt like himself since they left Laketown. Or longer even – the hobbit who left the Shire is gone, certainly.
But now it seems as if something was clouding his mind, and over the last days he has slowly been regaining clarity.
Icy air hits him the moment he steps out of his tent. Before him, off-white fabric flutters in the cold wind and the sky is light gray. A thin layer of snow covers the ground and Bilbo shivers. Draws his coat a little tighter around his shoulders and takes a deep breath.
Soft chatter echoes through the camp, intermingling with the noises of everyday life; clanging pots, snow crunching under heavy footsteps, the ringing of armor and subdued laughter. Bilbo swallows – he hadn’t quite realized just how far his tent had removed him.
When he casts a glance over his shoulder he notices that the fabric of his tent is one of the few that is colored. Dark blue – Durin’s blue, bearing the dwarven sigils as well. The fabric seems thicker as well.
Something within him flinches. He hadn’t wanted to be given privileges. Not when he…
Unconsciously Bilbo fists his hands and happens to touch the ring in the pocket of his coat. He’d completely forgotten about it during his recovery. But now he remembers – and wonders, if at some point it won’t become useful again.
With a shake of his head, he discards the dark thoughts and starts walking.
For now the dwarves appeared desperate to mend ties. And Bilbo enjoys their company, enjoys Kili’s and Fili’s bad jokes, Ori’s rants and Bofur’s roaring laughter. Not that Oin thinks too much excitement does him any good. He rather sends Bombur with stew or Bifur with a toy – Bilbo later learned that Bifur had been terribly worried for him about the head injury.
Bilbo knows he’s been lucky.
Unlike some. Dwalin misses two toes – Kili had jested nobody understood how since dwarven boots are sturdy, so perhaps the toes were lost in an accident after battle – and Nori broke his leg in two places. Balin and Thorin are doing their best to handle the administrative side of things, and Bilbo is left feeling useless.
Especially as he, walking around camp, realizes that everybody seems to have a duty. The dwarves and men may be talking and laughing, but they also fulfill their tasks; carrying water, food and messages. Others are clearing paths through the snow, caring for the wounded or feeding the ponies and rams.
“Bilbo,” somebody calls, and Bilbo turns to find Bard waving.
The man looks like death warmed over, but smiles brightly. For a moment Bilbo can’t find any words, wonders if he dares to ask after Bard’s family –
“I heard you were injured,” Bard says and looks Bilbo up and down, “Though I’m glad to see you’re feeling better.”
“It was just a small injury,” Bilbo replies awkwardly, “Nothing … I mean, how are you?”
There are deep shadows underneath Bard’s eyes. He shrugs. “Alive. Everything’s quite messy – the Master and Alfrid ran with all they could carry and we’re trying hard to reestablish some kind of order. But there’s no leader in Laketown right now, at least not officially.”
“I’m sorry,” Bilbo replies. Of course the master would have run – he remembers the oily character that so hard tried to win their favor. Remembers the rotten smell clinging to each room in his house, too. They should never have accepted his hospitality.
“Can’t be helped,” Bard shrugs, “It wouldn’t be a loss, really, but Laketown’s burned down and finding a new leader and rebuilding at the same time is quite difficult. But I shouldn’t complain – after all, I’m still alive.”
And he grins, but Bilbo cannot help paling. His hand brushes against the ring and when he blinks he sees the red flames that devoured the town.
“I’m …” he swallows, and Bard’s expression grows serious when he catches sight of the grief written across Bilbo’s face, “I … You were right. We should’ve never gone to the mountain. You warned us…”
“Bilbo?” Bard frowns, “What… No. What’s done is done. It’s been a terrible couple of days, but it could have been much worse. And if I’m honest – Thorin was right, too. He had every right to go and try to take back his mountain. I just wish… well, that doesn’t matter.”
He shrugs and reaches out to grasp Bilbo’s shoulder. “Now, Master Hobbit, don’t look so glum. I know it’s all very bleak, but at least now the threats are all gone and we have an actual chance at peace. That’s not worth nothing.”
Perhaps, Bilbo thinks, but at what price? He shivers, and the gold of the ring feels as frozen as his cheeks. They could have had peace without burning Laketown, if only he’d been cleverer with Smaug. If only he’d found a way to keep the dragon within the mountain.
But he nods to Bard’s words and forces a pale smile onto his lips to display some sort of agreement. In his heart, darkness surges upwards, and the grey sky begins to look threatening.
Your fault, the voice in the back of his mind hisses, it’s all your fault.
“Well, I have to go – the girls are waiting and Sigrid doesn’t like it if I’m late,” Bard announces, “How about you come and visit one of these days? They’ve all been asking – I think they liked having an adult smaller than them in the house.”
Bilbo manages a shaky laugh in response. “Certainly,” he responds, though he wonders who would like him for company. Probably Bard is only saying this to make him feel better – though Bilbo is certainly glad to hear his children are all right.
Bard is about to leave when he turns. “You should go back, too,” he says, “You’re looking a bit unwell, still – better take it easy for a while.”
And while Bilbo nods, Bard waves and disappears between the tents. The hobbit stares after him for a long moment, marveling at Bard’s good mood. It doesn’t make sense, he thinks and his hand closes around the cold ring in his pocket.
He’s humoring you, the voice suggests. He’s not honest. He knows it’s your fault. They all know.
Perhaps. Bilbo swallows, and decides he no longer feels like being outside. Not when he feels as if everybody is staring at him, judging him for what he did. For bringing the dragon down onto Laketown. For stealing the Arkenstone.
Hurriedly, he makes his way back to his own tent. Now he is glad for the thick fabric that keeps out the noises. His own pulse and the voices screeching in his head are loud enough.
That night his fever returns with a vengeance.
***
Winter comes early, and Oin’s frowns whenever he sees Bilbo.
“You are in no condition to travel,” he announces when Bilbo raises the issue. Not that he believes his guilt will lessen in the Shire - but once out if Erebor he will no longer burden the already small stores of men and dwarves.
The company will not hear of it. They will not let Bilbo leave the mountain until winter is past and he has regained his color. They don’t know that the voices in his head grow louder.
And with each passing day the dwarves grow ever busier. Some days Bilbo does not see a familiar face at all. Perhaps, if he had acted wiser, there would be no shortage of helping hands. If he had avoided the bloodshed, Thorin wouldn’t be sporting a new scar. Nori wouldn’t still be limping. Ori wouldn’t be so harried trying to establish a suitable narrative to record the events.
Bilbo does not like to talk about it. He enjoys being in the library, but that is Ori’s terrain, and the young scribe likes to question Bilbo on his opinions. Also on his motivations.
“When you took the Arkenstone to the men, what were you thinking?” Ori asks one evening, and Bilbo flinches. Pushes the book before him away. Swallows and hides away his sweaty hands.
But before he can try to even phrase an answer, Ori bites down on his lip and raises his hands. “Oh, I’m terribly sorry, Bilbo. Truly, I am sorry – that was an utterly unfortunate question and I should have known better than to ask. Really, sorry. Please believe me I didn’t mean anything by it. I just didn’t think – I’m sorry.”
“It’s alright,” Bilbo replies quietly. He understands Ori didn’t mean any harm – the young dwarf would never intentionally harm a fly. But he knows that this is an important question: one that Bilbo won’t answer.
What was he thinking – he was desperate, terrified and trying to make something right. He’d been clinging on to some odd hope of being able to accomplish something that he should have realized was wrong. How could one small hobbit secure peace?
And it didn’t even bring peace after all. Only caused unnecessary grief – the orcs and goblins achieved what Bilbo failed to do. Their enemies were the ones to unite the three races, not Bilbo’s foolish endeavor.
He’d rather not share his foolish hopes from back then. Not when to all observes the futility of his actions must have been blindingly obvious.
Ori apologies once again before he slips back into silence. But Bilbo has lost his concentration, and the voices in the back of his mind are growing louder. Isn’t he proving himself a waste of space again? Ori’s just trying to chronicle events, and Bilbo can’t even answer the simplest question. Why do the dwarves keep him around?
So, after more minutes pass, Bilbo leaves the library. He doesn’t care if he appears harried – he needs to get back to his room. The looks cast his way make his skin crawl. It’s not as if he doesn’t know that he’s a stranger. An alien object in a dwarven kingdom. There’s no place for him here, and he shouldn’t even be here.
He doesn’t understand why Thorin won’t let him leave.
***
“I don’t think he’s doing too well,” Balin overhears Kili saying during dinner one evening, and turns to the youngest prince. “Who are you talking about?”
Fili is the one who replies, casting a glance through the vast room. For now all dwarves – Dain’s remaining soldiers, the first arriving returnees, and the King – take their dinner together, this makes dealing with the rationed food the easiest.
“Bilbo. He isn’t here again.”
Balin frowns. “Perhaps he feels uncomfortable. I mean, it’s just him among quite a number of dwarves. I suppose he just comes by later and takes his portion to his room?”
He glances over at Bombur. Even though he’s head of the kitchens, Bombur always makes certain to eat with the company. “Yes, he does,” he replies between bites, “Though not always. I don’t think he’s fully recovered yet.”
“Or maybe a cold?” Ori suggests, “He didn’t have much of an appetite in Laketown either, and I think this winter is rather colder than winters in the Shire.”
Oin grumbles. “He’d better not. There’s still enough dwarves down with all sorts of ills. But I’ll look in on him later.”
Balin nods contently. It’s been a while since he last saw Bilbo, but then he’s been terribly busy. And Bilbo had looked pale and rather in need of further quiet and rest, so Balin had decided not to drag the poor fellow any deeper into Erebor’s messes.
Not when Bilbo had already done more than his due.
***
Days pass and winter drags on. The first caravans make their way through the snow - dwarves are hardy creatures after all, and Thorin opens Erebor to the men and women of Laketown as well. Their wooden houses on the water have never truly kept out the cold, but now they have been damaged by fire and battle as well.
"Enough have died already," Thorin declares before the unhappy councilors from the Iron Hills, "I will not allow another to die if I have the means to help it. We have a large, empty mountain. It will take time to restore the Kingdom, but these walls can save lives now. And that is more important!"
The councilors must accept his decision. But Thorin knows they will struggle for their own power every step of the way. They take up time, until he barely has time to sleep and only sees his nephews and Balin on a regular basis. Everybody else disappears into their own corner.
Until one day Thorin by chance catches sight of Bilbo
“Bilbo,” Thorin calls out instinctively, ignoring the envoys at his side. He hasn't seen the hobbit in ages, and it's been too long since anybody said something of him. If he comfortable now? Does he eat regularly? Has he recovered, is he feeling alright?
His heart clenches - he should have sought out Bilbo much sooner, should have set aside time -
Bilbo doesn’t seem to hear him and continues along the corridor. Thorin frowns, he should conclude his conversation with the envoys and still needs to look over the restoration plans for the lower levels. But this feels more important.
“Excuse me for a moment,” he tells them and turns away.
The hobbit has already disappeared around a corner, but Thorin's long strides take him there easily. A cold gust of air greets him, as he turns the corner, and he squints. The light is brighter, the air smells of snow -
And suddenly he realizes just where Bilbo is going. Thorin's heart freezes. True, there are not many functional exits to the mountain, and perhaps all the hobbit wants is some air.
But the last time he was out there with Bilbo he threatened to kill him.
"Bilbo!" he shouts. But the small figure in the distance doesn't stop, but continues to step outside. Thorin's heart jumps. Nothing to worry about? His palms sweat and he picks up speed.
The roar of the wind comes closer, and the light is painfully bright, he doesn't see the hobbit, and maybe he is being paranoid, but dread coils in his stomach and he knows he should have paid more attention to Bilbo.
Then he steps outside himself.
They are high on the parapets, and the Long Lake reflects the overcast sky down below. Much of the ground is blackened, and Laketown a ruin, though the fires have long died out. To his right, Bilbo stands and gazes out across the scorched fields without any type of expression.
Bilbo gives no indication he has noticed Thorin’s presence, or that he even notices the icy wind tearing at his clothes. He isn't wearing a coat, either. Only a dark, dwarven tunic over his odd, calf-length trousers.
Thorin shudders – the wind had been strong then, too. Back when he had dangled Bilbo over those parapets with every intention to throw the hobbit to his death. This is exactly the same spot, and he wonders why Bilbo came here.
“Bil-“ he starts again, but then Bilbo moves.
Thorin’s heart stops as Bilbo climbs onto the wall, not caring for the howling wind, the bitter air or the abyss before his feet. One wrong step and he –
Bilbo leans forward. Thorin is terrified.
“Bilbo!” Thorin yells, and the hobbit flinches. Shudders, and then glances over his shoulder.
“Stop!” Bilbo shouts back. Thorin freezes mid-step, an arm stretched out. His blood runs cold – there are dark shadows underneath Bilbo’s eyes, and his entire body trembles. The wind tears at his clothes, blowing dulled locks into his face.
Behind Bilbo the sky is a dark grey and the clouds announce a storm.
“Bilbo,” Thorin calls again, “Bilbo, what – “
“Don’t come any closer, Thorin,” Bilbo pleads, and his voice is thin, “Please, don’t. I –“
Thorin freezes immediately. His heart thunders in his chest and he forces himself to slowly raise his hands.
"I won't," he says and knows he may not keep that promise, "What are you doing?"
A shiver runs through Bilbo's body and the desperation on his face is clear. His hands tremble as the wind continues to howl across the mountainside.
"I ...", Bilbo stammers, "I ... I just..."
Thorin contemplates running. He can reach Bilbo in seven long steps - but Bilbo stands a finger's breadth away from a fatal fall. And the wind is growing stronger as night falls. A surprise may unbalance the hobbit easily enough.
"Whatever it is," Thorin calls back, "You can tell me. Please. But please, please, come down."
Confusion twists Bilbo's expression. "No, I should... I need to..."
"Bilbo," Thorin interrupts sharply, "No. Come down. Come back inside. Whatever it is, tell me about it."
Pain flashes across Bilbo’s face. Something glitters in his eyes and Thorin’s heart clenches. The hobbit hovers indecisively on the edge – Thorin is frozen into the spot by Bilbo’s words. Barely dares to breathe for the fear of startling Bilbo.
In a small movement he spots Bilbo gripping something in the pocket of his coat. The hobbit closes his eyes.
“I’m sorry,” Bilbo whispers. And leans backwards into the empty air.
Thorin has never moved so fast in his life. He’s shouting Bilbo’s name when his fingers find fabric and grip at it with desperation, he doesn’t even feel the weight, doesn’t hear Bilbo’s surprised cry, doesn’t notice his own body slamming against the stone with a thud. His heart’s frantic pounding echoes in his own ears, and for a moment there is no air in his lungs.
A choked sob escapes Bilbo’s throat and Thorin unfreezes enough to wrestle him over the wall, before his own knees give out. He slumps to the ground, the hobbit’s trembling body clutched in his arms. His fingers cramp and he cannot loosen his hold. Terror grips his heart, the moment Bilbo starts falling forever scorched onto the back of his eyelids.
Something pulls painfully at his hair and he finally notices Bilbo’s equivocally desperate grip on his coat. The hobbit’s face is buried in the fur collar and Thorin hesitantly unlatches his hand and rests it atop Bilbo’s head.
The curls are soft under his fingers. Even in the fading daylight they retain a golden hue. He just wishes Bilbo’s face would regain its color. For the hobbit to smile again –
But he may have brought this about himself.
“Master Baggins…” Thorin murmurs, “Bilbo.”
He has no right to use that name. No right to invoke their earlier friendship, not when he cast it aside so carelessly. But with the wind howling around them and the sky growing steadily darker as night falls, he will cling onto all straws offered. Desperation, to Thorin, is an old familiar.
“Bilbo,” he repeats and caresses those golden strands, “Why … why would you do this?”
His voice hitches on the last word, and he forces himself to press on. “I, I understand that… is it my fault? I know I wronged you greatly, but I will do anything – and I mean it, anything – to make it up to you. I can only beseech you to make use of it – or whatever needs to be done.”
A shudder runs through the body in his arms, and Thorin’s hold tightens involuntarily.
“Bilbo?” he asks quietly, “Please – if you can – and I know I have no right to ask you that, tell me why. I would have – will do anything to make you happy. Everybody will. Please, let me know how I can help you.”
With great effort Bilbo lifts his face. And Thorin’s heart breaks when he sees desperation and exhaustion marring those formerly smooth features. Red rims Bilbo’s eyes, and his voice is shaky. “Make it stop,” he whispers, “Just make it stop. Please.”
He curls into himself before Thorin can make sense of the plea. The king catches the hobbit by his upper arms.
“What?” Thorin demands, “What do I have to stop? Bilbo, please, let me know!”
The hobbit sags in his grip, and Bilbo wearily manages to gather himself enough to whisper one answer.
“The voices.”
And with that he passes out.
***
When Bilbo comes to, his head aches and he feels terribly drained. Crossing Mirkwood has not been this exhausting, he thinks as the familiar ceiling of his rooms swims into view. Indeed, everything that came before has not broken him down to this level.
For a moment he recalls the icy, howling wind. The darkening, grey sky, and the rocks below almost invisible in the growing darkness. In that world of death and desolation the Shire appears a distant vision. Even now that the voices have grown dim, he cannot remember what sunlight felt like on his skin. What it was like to be well-rested and content.
Your own fault, the voices whisper in their dissonant hisses, you brought this about yourself. And isn’t it a fair punishment? Remember how many lives you destroyed by your ill thought-out plans.
Bilbo closes his eyes against the pain in his heart even though it’s meaningless defense.
“Bilbo?” a familiar voice asks, and the gentle baritone feels like balm against Bilbo’s sore heart, “Are you awake?”
It takes Bilbo a moment to gather enough energy to nod. Open his eyes and attempt to sit up.
Face what you caused, the voices suggest with a cackle. See how much pain you brought about. Can’t even do one thing right.
“Thorin,” Bilbo greets. His voice sounds hoarse. He hasn’t spoken much recently – for a good reason.
A pained smile crosses the king’s face. Crown and fur coat are gone, and he looks more like the Thorin Bilbo has come to know through their journey. Though there are new lines on his face and new scars on his body.
And how many of those did you cause, the voices ask.
“How are you feeling?” Thorin asks and comes over to sit on a chair next to the bed. On the small table he sets two steaming mugs. “Tea,” he comments, “I think we both could do with some.”
Perhaps, Bilbo thinks. His fingers still feel so cold, though the voices are screaming at him that he doesn’t deserve this luxury. Shouldn’t indulge himself when others may need it more. When the greatest favor he could do anybody is to disappear.
Bilbo reaches for the cup, and the hot beverage manages to quieten the voices for a moment. Heat rushes down his throat, curls into his belly. And Bilbo can finally lift his head and look at Thorin.
“I’m sorry,” he mutters brokenly when he sees the unveiled worry in Thorin’s eyes, “I… lately. I don’t know… I’m not feeling like myself. It’s as if … somebody, something is … in my head.”
You’re going crazy, the voices mock. Poor, poor Bilbo Baggins. Can’t deal with just one battle. Will go insane at the drop of a hat. Really, what has he ever been but a burden and a drain?
He blinks and forces the voices back, because regardless of whether they are right or not, Thorin deserves better. Thorin deserves an explanation and not further heartbreak after having already endured so much grief.
“Your head injury,” Thorin offers, “Maybe it has not quite healed. I will ask Oin to check up on it. Visit him tomorrow, I will make sure he has time.”
Look at them, so concerned for you, the voices titter. If only they realized what a waste of space you truly are. But they will, in time. And then he’ll regret not having cast you to the rocks.
Bilbo manages a tiny, shaky nod. He sets the cup back and hides his hands under the blanket – they are beginning to tremble.
“Bilbo?” Thorin asks, leaning forward with concern shining in his eyes. “Are you -?”
“I’m sorry,” the hobbit mumbles and bows his head. Locks tumble forward and hide his face from view, “I’m sorry. I don’t know why I’m like this. I know it’s … it’s just causing trouble for you. And really, just, just, just don’t be so concerned. I’ll manage. Somehow. It’s just voices. I know that. I’ll handle that. Really. You’re all busy, you shouldn’t have to look after me as well. I can do that just fine. Please.”
A large dwarven hand sneaks into view. Settles atop the blanket, just above Bilbo’s own hand. And when Bilbo glances at Thorin in confusion he sees a watery glint in the king’s eyes. His heart gives a pained squeeze, but the voices laugh.
Your fault, they chide maliciously, everything is your fault.
“Bilbo,” says Thorin and his voice is louder and clearer and Bilbo clings onto it like a drowning man to a log, “Whatever you need, you will have it. I promised that, and I will not break that promise. And I will not leave you alone – whatever is haunting you, I have brought you here. You are only in Erebor because you decided to support me, all the terrors and desperation you experienced are my responsibility. I will not abandon you to face them on your own.”
Thorin hesitates, and Bilbo cannot tear his gaze away. His own heart trembles.
“I know I have not given you much proof to trust my word,” Thorin adds quietly, “But I beg you to do in this.”
And perhaps –
The world twists abruptly. A violent shudder runs through Bilbo’s body, and suddenly all strength vanishes from his muscles. His head hits the pillow with a thud, and for a moment he is left staring at the ceiling. And only after a deep breath he manages to tilt his head far enough to find Thorin’s frightened gaze again.
“Alright,” he whispers, because he can feel his body shutting down. The corners of his vision grow darker as exhaustion takes over. Not that he does not know what is to come –
“I will inform Oin,” Thorin says, “Tomorrow, he will be expecting you. Until then – “
And the smile that crosses his face lets warmth blossom in Bilbo’s chest.
“Sleep,” Thorin says and Bilbo sees the hope in his eyes. Hope that once morning comes the problems will have vanished. But as the darkness in Bilbo’s heart remains heavy, he only closes his eyes in defeat.
When he opens them, morning has come. But he does not feel rested, nor energetic. His body is heavy, his eyes dull. And his mind haunted by the horrors his mind taunted him with. Dreams full of death and desolation. Gory endings to dreams so dear to him and those his heart still reaches out to. Desperation and failure – a kingdom torn apart again, a mountain devoured by fire and a world overcome by blackness. Ruled by one worse than a dragon.
The voices laugh and frolic. This is what will come to pass, they cheer, this is what you are bringing about. Are you not proud, harbinger of evil? Whom will you murder first with one of your ill-devised plans?
Bilbo closes his eyes.
But, the voices continue cheerfully, you do know how to stop it. Don’t you?
***
“Dwalin,” Oin calls over his shoulder, “Are you on duty now?”
The tall dwarf stops with a hand on the doorknob. “Not until tonight, no.”
Oin hums, looking through his record of patients. “Could you perhaps tell Bilbo to come by? He was supposed to be here earlier already…”
Dwalin grunts in agreement. The hobbit wasn’t at breakfast and has looked rather terrible recently. “Anything serious?” Dwalin inquires.
And Oin hesitates.
Dwalin stops dead, dread abruptly coiling in his stomach. Their healer is known to be blunt and direct. Frilly speech is for politicians, Oin had always claimed. Healers – and warriors, Dwalin adds to himself – need to be understood in a few words only. Lives depend on it.
“Is he – “ Dwalin begins at the same as Oin mutters, “You haven’t heard?”
Dwalin shakes his head and presses his lips together unhappily.
“I, well,” Oin frowns and shakes his head, “I only have one side of the tale, and I think it’s not mine to share. Ask Bilbo or Thorin. He came in late last night and told me to do a check up on the burglar today.”
“Urgent?” Dwalin asks and relaxes a little. If Thorin did not inform him, it may not concern any affairs of state. But still, if their burglar’s health has taken a turn for the worse once more…
“Rather, though Thorin suggested to let our burglar have a full night’s sleep before,” Oin replies and Dwalin wonders what occurred. If it’s so pressing, why didn’t Thorin drag the hobbit here directly? And why is Oin so secretive all of a sudden?
“I’ll go and get him,” Dwalin announces shortly. It’s almost midday – even a hobbit ought to be awake by now.
He tries to convince himself that it’s probably something terribly mundane that has gotten Thorin concerned all the way up the stairs to the company’s private quarters. Thorin has a tendency to be overly worried at times – several memorable instances of Fili’s and Kili’s childhood come to mind where a bleeding knee had caused a frantic dash to the next healer. So perhaps it’s truly just something simple. A sprained ankle, a cold – hobbits are not as hardy as dwarves, this winter is fearsome and Bilbo has been looking under the weather.
But a grain of doubt remains in his heart.
Whatever Thorin has told Oin has unsettled their healer. And no simple cold, scraped knee or sprained appendage can do that.
Still. Perhaps there is a simple answer to the worry encroaching on his mind. Dwalin takes a deep breath before knocking on the closed door. The sound echoes down the corridor, clear and loud. However, no sound of movement comes from the other side of the heavy door.
With a frown Dwalin turns to look at the lock. Fairly simple – there hasn’t yet been time to bring the door up into proper shape. This one he can open within moments.
“Bilbo,” he calls and knocks again, louder this time, “Oi, Bilbo! Open the door!”
The hobbit might – against all likelihood – still be asleep. Or in the bath. Dwalin can imagine a myriad of reasons for Bilbo not to respond immediately. Though the silence continues and Dwalin’s calls remain unanswered.
Bilbo likes his privacy. And Dwalin would not dare to force his entry under any other circumstances. But today unease gnaws on his mind, and with a huff he reaches for the lock pick he keeps on him.
The lock opens almost instantly.
Dwalin grasps the handle. "Bilbo," he calls, "I'm coming in!"
The room remains silent when Dwalin pushes the door open. Dim light greets him - the fire in the fireplace has burned down, the chairs around it are empty as is the desk in the corner and the air feels oppressive.
"Bilbo?" Dwalin calls again. Nothing moves; and for a moment he wonders if perhaps the hobbit isn't even here.
But where would he go, especially if he isn't feeling well. Dwalin chases the thought away with a shake of his head. Then looks at the two remaining doors. One leads to the attached baths, the other to the sleeping room. No noise emerges from either.
Pressing his lips together, Dwalin marches toward the bedroom. Knocks, though this time the answering silence is no longer unexpected. Then he presses down the handle and steps inside.
The metallic tang to the air is the first thing he notices, the lump on the bed next. The hair on the back of his neck rises before his eyes have caught up.
Bilbo rests on the bed, atop the covers, curled toward the door. Unnaturally still.
"Bilbo?!" Dwalin shouts. Crosses the room in three long strides as his heart hitches. The form on the bed remains utterly still.
Abruptly terror floods his veins. Before he realizes what he's doing, he has taken the hobbit by the shoulders and is shaking the body. He feels bone under his hands, and much too little flesh around it.
"Oi, Bilbo! What's wrong!" he yells. Bilbo heads lolls to the side, his eyes remain close. And he is entirely too pale. Deathly pale.
Dwalin finally notices the stains discoloring the blankets. In the dim light they're almost invisible. On the night stand, he catches the metallic glint of a knife. An abandoned quill and a folded letter next to it.
And suddenly Dwalin understands. Terrified he glances down, sees the red trailing along Bilbo's arm, staining the sleeve of his tunic. The thin, but deep cut on the inside of his wrist. That still sluggishly bleeds.
Dwalin puts a practiced, but trembling hand against Bilbo's throat. Leans forward. Listens with baited breath - and catches a faint exhalation.
Alive. But time's running out.
With his heart pounding in his ears Dwalin straightens, rips off a long strip of the blanket. Ties it as tightly as he can around Bilbo's upper arm, silently praying for the hobbit to hang on. To spare them this tragedy.
Why, Dwalin wonders, terrified as he bandages the injury and wraps the hobbit in the blanket. Why would he do this? Where did they fail? What kind of friends are they to not have noticed until it's become too late?
Please don't die now, Dwalin thinks as he lifts the still body in his arms. Hang on just a little longer.
And then he runs.
***
The entire company has gathered in the antechamber by the time Oin finishes his ministrations. Tension suffuses the air, and Thorin especially appears pale. Balin has a hand on his brother's shoulder - and Dwalin stares at his hands, though the blood has since been washed off. The sight of Bilbo laid out on his bed, lifeless and bleeding, has been burnt onto the back of his eyelids.
Only Ori and Fili are talking quietly when the door finally opens. Oin steps out, looking harried, but not grieved. When he sees the expectant gazes cast his way, he takes a deep breath.
"He will live," he announces promptly. The fatigued lines on his face say it's been a close call, and Dwalin forces himself to take a deep, shuddering breath. He's been fast enough. Hasn't lost a precious moment too many, wondering if he should or should not open a locked door.
Oin clears his throat. "Physically, there is little reason not to anticipate a full recovery."
"But?" Dori asks immediately. And Oin frowns unhappily and shakes his head. "Whatever drove him to do this - I can treat the wounds, but I cannot heal what's haunting our burglar."
Dwalin swallows. Stares at his hands and only catches Thorin slump forward from the corner of his vision.
"Could it be something hidden?" Balin inquires, "He's unfamiliar with the mountain - perhaps the air or the food are causing him distress?"
"There is nothing physically wrong with him" Oin reaffirms.
"Perhaps the head injury?" Bombur mutters with a glance at Bifur, "They do strange things. Sometimes even years later."
Oin sighs and his shoulders slump. "I don't believe the head injury caused this. It has healed rather completely..."
"But can't it be?" Kili interrupts, almost hopeful, twisting the hem of his coat between his fingers, "Head injuries are not simple and can cause all sorts of troubles."
It would be a beautiful explanation, Dwalin thinks. One capable of absolving them of every responsibility for Bilbo's fate.
"They can, yes," Oin agrees without missing a beat, "But I think - and the other healers agree - that this seems unlikely. Injuries like this, I regret to say, come from a disturbance within... It was self-inflicted, wasn't it, Dwalin?"
Dwalin recalls the locked door. The undisturbed rooms and wearily raises his head to look at Gloin. "It was."
He has seen murders masked as suicides. He knows what to look for. And Oin obviously did not expect any other answer either. They have seen these things happen before. They know better than to hope for an absolving explanation.
"Why would he do that?" Ori mumbles unhappily.
"Well," Oin announces unhappily, "I'm afraid we need to find out what our burglar was thinking. Also, we found this in his coat pocket."
And Oin procures a small, golden ring.
"What's that?" Bofur asks, leaning forward. Oin places the innocuous golden item down on a table. It sounds heavy. Pure gold then, but still nothing special.
"Bilbo said it made him invisible," Fili provides hesitantly, "He used it a lot when we were captured. And to avoid Smaug as well, I think."
"Though he said it didn't work on the dragon, didn't he?" Ori asks, a frown on his face. A cold shiver runs down Dwalin's spine. Something feels wrong. Bofur frowns as well, and Balin appears deep in thought.
Dori wrings his hands. "He didn't look very good in the dungeons..."
"It's just a ring," Gloin protests, "What does it have to do with anything? He's welcome to any kind of souvenir he wants to keep."
Thorin looks at his hands. Dwalin purses his lips. Just a ring. Just some gold. The line of thought is too familiar for comfort, though Bilbo is unlikely to be affected by the gold. But something doesn't feel right - something is off.
Otherwise Bilbo wouldn't be lying next door, asleep with bandages wrapped around his wrists.
Nori clears his throat. "There are cursed rings," he supplies.
Of course they know that cursed items exist. Middle Earth is home to more than a few curious and magical artifacts.
"I was thinking it was a bit curious that the ring merely made its bearer invisible," Nori continues quietly, "It doesn't seem too surprising that in return for providing its bearer with a special skill, the ring would take something in return. Few magical items, after all can be used without ramifications."
The ensuing silence is heavy and only broken when Kili mutters, "But it looks completely harmless."
And that makes Dwalin wonder as well. He has seen magical items, and many can be identified at a glance. That this ring hides its true character -
It may be completely innocent. It may be pure chance.
But he has a bad feeling about it.
"Balin," Thorin says, "See to it that the ring is kept somewhere out of sight. Have nobody touch it until we know what exactly it is."
***
Three days pass before Oin decides to cut down on the sleeping potions and allows Bilbo to wake up. And no matter how much the company wishes to be there, Oin will not allow for any but medical personnel to be in the room.
It makes sense. But at the same time Thorin is terrified.
What if Bilbo cannot remember? What if he remembers and now hates the dwarves for having brought him into this position? What if he still wants to die?
Sun has already set when a messenger brings word from Oin. The message is short, but makes Thorin's heart best faster.
"Awake and responsive. Cause still unknown. Visit at your leisure."
Thorin immediately abandons all documents waiting for lecture or signature and barely manages to stop himself from running down the corridors. He ignores the councilors calling him on the way. Only inclines his head, but neither slows nor stops.
When he closes his eyes he still can see Bilbo standing on the wall, the howling wind tearing at his dark tunic and desperation twisting his features.
He never wants to see him like that again.
The healers jump out of his way when he storms into the sickrooms. Oin catches sight of them, but he's cleaning out some pointy utensils and only inclines his head. "Second door on the right. Should be awake and eating."
Thorin realizes he must look frightening, and forces himself to display some restraint. Thank Oin. Don't run. Don't show the other healers just how terrified you still are.
But once the door shuts behind him, the world narrows down to him and the pale figure sitting up among the pillows. In the beige tunic Bilbo looks thinner and whiter than Thorin has ever seen him, but there is a light flush in his cheeks and glittering green eyes greet Thorin.
"Tho -" Bilbo starts, though Thorin has already crossed the room and only at the very last moment stops himself from drawing Bilbo in an embrace.
"Bilbo," he exclaims, "You are alright?!"
Bilbo frowns and looks away. "Getting better," he mumbles and Thorin sees the white bandages wrapped around the hobbit's thin wrist. Relief floods him, and for the first time he has a notion that things may turn out right in the end.
His knees abruptly go weak and he has to sit down. When his head clears he sees Bilbo watching him with confusion.
"Are you quite alright?" The hobbit asks. His voice sounds different from that time on the wall as well. No longer do grief and desperation color it. Instead he for once sounds a bit closer to the hobbit they first met again.
"Very much so," Thorin mumbles and then gathers himself. "And better now. You truly scared me, Master Baggins."
"Bilbo," the hobbit corrects immediately, "I rather think we've seen each other in terrible enough situations to forgo the formalities at this point." He smiles wryly and Thorin cannot stop his lips from twitching in response.
"Of course," he agrees and his heart feels lighter. Even if Bilbo ought to resent him - he cannot help being glad the hobbit does not.
"But I'm being rude," Thorin says, "How are you feeling? Am I disturbing you?"
"No, no," Bilbo is quick to reply, "Truly, I don't think Oin is willing to leave me alone for too long."
"You scared us all," Thorin says quietly.
Bilbo purses his lips. "I know. And I'm sorry. I didn't mean to."
"Then forgive me. I know the question is terrible. But: why?" Thorin finally asks and his heart is in his throat again, racing away and suffocating him at the same time.
Bilbo turns his gaze at his hands resting atop the off-white blanket. His shoulders sink a little and Thorin wants to retract his question. But he remembers Bilbo's terrified words atop the wall too clearly.
Perhaps now Bilbo can tell them how to help him. Perhaps now he can answer.
"I ... I don't remember it all too clearly, but when you pulled me back on the wall," Bilbo says, "I mentioned voices, didn't I?"
"You did," Thorin confirms. His voice sounds choked, but Bilbo does not look up.
"Though so," he mutters and then continues a little louder, "I don't know when it started. But I kept hearing voices, and they were getting louder. Telling me that it was all my fault and that I was only being a burden."
"But that's wrong," Thorin immediately protests, "We wouldn't have reclaimed Erebor without you, Bilbo!"
The hobbit's lips twitch unhappily. "I know. Though it almost went wrong, didn't it?"
"I was mad from the gold," Thorin exclaims horrified at the implications, "Not a word of what I said them had even a grain of truth in it! I wish I could take them back - but never, never for a moment believe you bear any responsibility for what happened. I didn't give you a choice. It's my fault and mine alone."
Bilbo glances up with a small frown. "I disagree and I'm aware a number of dwarves does at well. But -" he holds up a hand to starve off Thorin's protests, "at first I was aware the voices were twisting my feelings and words. Logically I knew the orcs and Smaug had been the ones to kill so many. But the voices persisted."
Bilbo's eyes close. "They kept insisting and steadily grew louder. At some point I found I was unable to block them out any longer. I tried to sleep, but they intruded there as well."
Nightmares, Thorin thinks and his heart goes out to the slight creature before him. Dark shadows linger under Bilbo's eyes and have for a long time.
"They kept growing louder," Bilbo repeats quietly, "And while I knew I shouldn't, I think at some point I started believing them. Or maybe I just didn't know what to do anymore. It's all a blur in my head, and the only thing I remember clearly is wanting it to end."
Thorin can only wonder how they missed this. How they could have left Bilbo alone for so long that some voices could have driven him to desperation.
"And now?" Thorin asks gently.
Bilbo sighs. "They ... Aren't gone. But they're quieter. As if distanced. And they don't react any longer."
"React?" Thorin inquires.
Bilbo grimaces. "They used to react directly whenever somebody talked to me. Twisting their words. Or mine. Laughing at me... It was very distracting. Now, they're more or less an echo of things they've said before. Nothing new, and sometimes what they say doesn't even match the situation. It's much easier to ignore them like this."
Thorin swallows. The hair on his arm stands, and he cannot imagine the horror of having a voice in his head talk back to him. He's all too familiar with surges of guilt and crippling fear - but to have these take shape and speak to him directly.
"When did they start?" he asks quietly. Perhaps, he thinks, the head injury caused this. He's seen similar cases before - though he does not want to recall these for he knows how they ended.
Bilbo purses his lips. "I don't really know," he replies, "They just kept growing louder."
"After you received the blow to your head?" Thorin suggests.
An immediate shake of the head is his answer. "No," Bilbo returns with conviction, "Much earlier. I think perhaps even before we entered Erebor, but that's around the first time I remember consciously taking note of them."
Which means they had been torturing Bilbo when Thorin went and threw new accusations at his head. He cringes.
"But I do think they were there before. Even in the dungeons of Mirkwood," Bilbo adds.
Thorin recalls the trinket. Something cold runs down his spine. "There," he clears his throat, "Oin found your magic ring in your pocket. Nori thought it may be cursed..."
"What? Where is it?! Why did you take it?!" Bilbo shouts abruptly. Thorin flinches back. Blinks in surprise, as the color abruptly drains from the hobbit's face. His eyes widen.
Thorin finds his fear mirrored in Bilbo's eyes.
The hobbit bites down on his lower lip. "I'm afraid," he says quietly, "It may be."
***
Erebor's library does not answer the riddle of the ring. But now the ring makes them uncomfortable and Bilbo - while obviously torn - agrees to have it stowed deep in a sealed stone chamber until Gandalf can come and inspect it.
It's mid-winter when the wizard makes his way to the mountain. Bilbo has been healing, slowly. This time, they make sure he is at every meal and not alone for too long. Thorin finds he cannot sleep unless he sees the hobbit at least once a day.
Which results in one or two awkward late night visits with Bilbo in his nightclothes and once Thorin's crown is lost under the bed. But Thorin's heart grows lighter and Bilbo regains his color. The ring is almost forgotten.
When shown, Gandalf does not dare to touch it, and his face settles into a grim frown. In the small chamber, Thorin takes a deep breath and feels Bilbo next to him shudder. Being in the room alone has etched deep lines into his face, and Thorin wonders if the voices have returned.
"I am not certain, and I hope I am wrong," he mutters before he turns back to Bilbo and Thorin, "Are you sure?"
Thorin finds himself losing patience. Bilbo has answered this question at least three times already. Why is Gandalf so hesitant? Normally the wizard draws his conclusions quicker.
"Yes," Bilbo replies evenly, "The voices started whispering a while after I picked it up and grew stronger when I wore it for a long time. And, I think, it made use of my own weaknesses. Said terrible things and gave me nightmares."
"Nightmares? What did you see?" Gandalf inquires, his bushy eyebrows furrowed. The dim light is casting eerie shadows on his face.
Bilbo swallows, and Thorin wants to tell him he needn't answer. Gandalf is a guest in their kingdom - they can send him packing.
"The battle," Bilbo says quietly, "That everybody died. That the world turned dark all of a sudden. It was unlike nighttime - there was a constant reddish glow to everything."
Thorin wants to tell him to stop. But he sees that Gandalf has grown pale. Paler than he ever saw the wizard. And dread, once more, coils in his stomach.
"Anything else?" Gandalf asks, "Did you see anything else?"
Bilbo frowns. "I... It was very strange. Certainly dreamlike, though it did not feel like it. I think at one point I saw a giant, burning eye."
A century has passed since Thorin read the histories under the watchful eyes of his tutors. He cannot suppress a flinch. And neither can Gandalf keep the dread from showing on his face.
Bilbo looks between them. "What is it?" he asks, "Gandalf? Thorin? What is wrong with my ring?"
His voice breaks Thorin's heart. It is as if Bilbo already knows that there is something fundamentally wrong. Wrong, when things should finally turn right for him.
"It's not certain yet," Gandalf announces firmly, "I need to find answers first. I may be wrong."
"But what do you think?" Bilbo asks and takes a step forward, "Gandalf? Tell me. If it's something bad, I need to know. I brought the ring here, after all."
Gandalf looks at Bilbo and Thorin thinks he can see the grief on his face. He takes a step forward and puts a hand on Bilbo's shoulders.
"I have a duty to this kingdom," he says, "I need to know what I guard."
Gandalf gives a small nod. And then takes a deep breath. "Very well. The clues all point to one answer, that I did not believe possible until a moment ago. This may very well be the one ring."
Thorin draws a sharp breath - his guess was right, but hearing it confirmed by a wizard turns the threat immediate. He feels Bilbo flinch at his side.
"Sauron's ring?" The hobbit asks quietly, "This is the one ring?"
Gandalf clears his throat. "As I said, I am not yet certain. If it is, there are a lot of question that need to be answered. But ..."
He does not need to complete the sentence. If Bilbo has seen a red, flaming eye in his dreams, then it is proof enough. Thorin swallows.
"It probably is," Bilbo concludes drily. Wrings his hands and looks to Thorin, "I am so sorry for bringing this here. If I had known, I would have never brought something so evil into your kingdom. If you want to, I will take it and go..."
Thorin tightens his grip on Bilbo's shoulder and shakes his head. "No," he interrupts firmly, "You didn't know, and I will not let you carry it anywhere. The roads are dangerous enough, but with such an item in your possession..."
It would spell immediate death. Indeed, it is a miracle Bilbo carried the ring all the way to Erebor. Had the servants of the enemy known -
"Smaug," Thorin exclaims abruptly, and ice floods his veins, "He knew you had it."
Bilbo nods in confusion and Thorin turns to Gandalf. "Then the enemy," he utters, feeling himself pale, "The enemy may know. That Bilbo has the ring."
Gandalf presses his lips together. Bows his head. "I'm afraid that is possible."
Bilbo, white as a sheet, stutters: "But th- that means they'll... He'll be looking for me?" His voice hitches on the last word.
"You must not leave the mountain," Gandalf declares, "Go no further than Dale, and never alone. Thorin, promise me you will watch out for your burglar. I need to find answers - I cannot stay. But Thorin, you must keep Bilbo and the ring safe until I return."
Thorin inclines his head. His heart breaks for Bilbo - unknowingly having been preyed on by the greatest evil of their age, and now denied his home after everything he already suffered.
"I will," he vows.
Outside, a storm is rising.
Fin
