Actions

Work Header

Episodes from Middle Earth

Chapter 32: Hurts that linger

Summary:

They have all survived the battle and Bilbo has stayed in Erebor. But Thorin's temper and Bilbo's recovery do not mix well.

Notes:

This was originally written for the Mizimel fanbook in early 2014. The theme was "jewels" and ... the story approaches that topic by crab-walking alongside it.

No warnings for this story, except for angst and an ending that is rather bittersweet than happy.

Chapter Text

The sun is low in the sky, painting it in shades of orange and gold. Bilbo stops for a moment to catch his breath and bask in those last rays of daylight – his ribs still ache, though the injuries he sustained in the battle are healing. Yet Oin remains worried, and so was Bard during today’s short meeting.

Bilbo knows he is paler and thinner than he should, but food is scarce and he is not all that hungry. The nightmares are probably to blame for his pallor. If there was one night he could sleep without waking to memories either of the battle or of Thorin dangling him from the parapets, it would help.

Perhaps today’s exertion of hiking to the camp outside the ruins of Laketown and back might have exhausted him enough for at least a few hours without dreams.

He closes his eyes for a moment. The sun is warm on his skin, and once winter is over he will return to the Shire and its green, rolling hills. He looks forward to spending tranquil days under a clear blue sky, gazing out over Hobbiton with a pipe – far, far away from Erebor’s dramatic grandeur and terrible memories. Maybe then the nightmares will finally fade.

A cold gust of wind rushes over the mountainside, pulling at his coat and hair, and Bilbo shivers. Winter here is only beginning and already ice is collecting at the shores of the Long Lake. The clouds collecting in the north are grey and heavy – Oin has predicted for the first snows to come soon. At least within the mountain it will be warm.

“Bilbo, there you are!” somebody calls and Bilbo turns to see Kili waving at him. The archer has his bow slung over his shoulder and is grinning – his arm must be improving then. Bilbo is happy to see it. There was a time when the young dwarf’s prospects were far from promising.

“Come on, let’s get inside before it is dark and people start wondering where we are,” Kili says, and then looks at the rolls of parchment Bilbo has under his arm.

“How was the meeting with Bard today?” he asks.

“Same as always,” Bilbo replies with a shrug, “Though with the Master gone, he breathes a little easier, I think. They want to send another ship south before the lake freezes completely – he is worried that we’ll all be cut off for months.”

“That might happen. Thorin told us winter in Erebor could be fierce – and especially now they do need a lot of supplies to rebuild Dale,” Kili says, and Bilbo nods along, thinking that Erebor, too, will face shortages.

“Though I do suppose they’ll need more gold for that,” Kili finishes, and Bilbo sighs. He’s not looking forward to approaching Thorin on that matter – the King has been in a foul mood recently, caused by overenthusiastic courtiers and returning nobles demanding to be reinstalled. The gold madness is gone, but Bilbo can’t help but be wary when he sees Thorin gazing darkly at the jewels they are buying supplies and peace with.

“Well, we’re going to profit from that, too, so it shouldn’t be a problem,” Kili returns, optimistic, “Uncle knows that as well, don’t worry. But why didn’t Balin go with you – he normally does, doesn’t he?”

“Apparently a group of particularly argumentative dwarves from the Iron Hills arrived today. Firebeards, I think? Anyway, Balin was needed to help Thorin fend them off.” Bilbo tugs the collar of his coat higher so that most of his throat is covered, hiding the shadows of healing bruises. The wind gets colder and sharper as they ascend. The giant statues guarding Erebor’s gates tower above them, statements of wealth and intimidation at the same time.

“Ugh, yes, that help was certainly needed, then,” Kili replies with a grimace, “I met one of them once, and that was already one too many. If the entire clan is here…” He shudders.

The guards salute them as they pass the gates. It's strange and new for both of them. Bilbo has been used to a degree of scrutiny from gossiping neighbors, but these gazes are different. To the returning dwarves they are not just Kili and Bilbo, but the prince and a traitor-turned-hero.

Bilbo knows that the returning dwarves are skeptical of his place in the kingdom – it is one of the reasons why he longs to return. The company may be the family of his choosing, but at the end of the day he is a hobbit among dwarves.

He's almost waiting for something to happen – for a dwarf to voice his malcontent at having a hobbit, especially the one that dared to steal the Arkenstone – treated this reverently in their kingdom. The fact that Thorin and the company understand the madness brought on by gold sickness and Bilbo’s motives does not mean that the recently returned dwarves do as well.

But now he must speak to Thorin on behalf of Bard.

***

Thorin has spent the majority of the afternoon discussing with and shouting at the Firebeard clan heads. Being just as hard-headed as Thorin, they have been shouting back for just as long and loudly. Needless to say, tempers are frayed. There had also been other, demanding petitioners during court session – the majority of them former nobles of Erebor, at least according to their own claims; Thorin recognizes few – and Thorin swears he will murder the next one to walk up to him and ask for their due reward.

He hasn’t won Erebor back so that those slimy nobles can march here and demand they be given their inheritance, plus interest, plus whatever else they desire based on claims nobody can verify. His grinds his teeth audibly – at least the Firebeards have retired for tonight.

Justice is easier imagined than spoken, a truth Thorin is familiar with. And though he has learned to beware of his own temper, he cannot help the fact that his blood boils when he marches back toward his own chambers, chattering courtiers on his heels.

“… a new tapestry,” one is saying, “Of course, this should be inlaid with gemstones as befitting. One of Lord Frar’s entourage possesses just that skill, and I hear he is …”

“I heard there were still jewels in Dale’s treasury – apparently a dwarf from the Iron Hills discovered them, and I wonder why they keep asking Erebor for gold, when they obviously – “

Thorin does his best to block out the voices – his head is spinning as it is. He wishes they would stop talking of gold and treasure, wishes a moment would pass without a demand being directed at him.

“Dale plans to send another boat south for supplies and food,” a voice cuts through Thorin’s unsettled mind, “They need gold from Erebor to afford these, but they are willing to -”

And it is all he can stand.

“No!” Thorin roars, whirls around in a fit of blinding fury, “I will not part with a single more coin, not if the end of all days was upon us! I have given and given and given and what have we seen in return?”

He can hear the blood pulsing in his ears, and he knows he must appear mad, but he cannot stand the voices any longer. “Every day the claims grow bolder, every day they come back and demand more and more, and one day we will have nothing left! I have not endured war and fire to see the fortune of my people stolen away by greedy men and treacherous elves! I will not – “

“Stop! Uncle!” Fili shouts, and Thorin hadn’t even noticed his nephew’s presence, “Uncle, stop it!”

Thorin stops, surprised, to see Fili look at him, pale and shocked, and Thorin blinks. He had not meant to fly into a rage, certainly, but the madness is past, and his temper is not new. Then he realizes that Fili is not looking at him, but at the person Thorin has been yelling it.

Dread floods his chest. It cannot be -

“Mahal, Bilbo – “ Thorin breathes, and lowers his hands slowly, unclenching his fingers, but there is no reaction. Bilbo stares at him with terrified, wide-open eyes set in a face as white as paper.

“Bilbo,” Thorin mutters, and his voice hitches. He didn’t mean to harm Bilbo. Not Bilbo who already sacrificed so much for him. The hobbit, however, remains frozen in place – doesn’t even appear to be breathing.

“Fetch Oin!” Fili orders, running up to them, “You there, fetch Oin! Everybody else– out! Out!”

The courtiers scatter, muttering amongst themselves, but Thorin doesn’t hear them. Does barely notice Fili stopping few paces behind Bilbo, uncertain all of a sudden. Horror holds him in place – what has he done? Has he not sworn to never again raise a hand against the hobbit? Has he not promised Bilbo would be safe?

And now the hobbit is as pale as he was that day out on the wall, staring at Thorin with the same terror in his eyes. Thorin remembers all too well how Bilbo’s grieved determination had turned into fear, when the mad king had threatened to throw him to his death.

“Uncle?” Fili asks, “Uncle, is –“

Back then he’d shouted at Bilbo, too.

He hasn’t meant to summon the memories. Hasn’t meant to reawaken a terror Bilbo has pretended to have forgiven and moved past – not when Thorin knows how these events haunt their victims. Not when Thorin has observed how pale Bilbo has become, how he avoids rowdy dinners and flinches at physical contact.

“Bilbo?” Thorin whispers, wishing for any type of response – anything to let him know that he hasn’t with one careless action completely destroyed the brave soul before him.

He doesn’t hear Fili suck in a sharp breath, before looking helplessly for Oin.

“Bilbo, I am sorry. So sorry. I promised no harm would come to you – and I meant it,” Thorin continues, forcing himself to steady his voice. Hoping against hope those calming words might draw Bilbo from the nightmare he must be seeing. “I still mean it. Had I known it was you, I would never have shouted. I promise I will not make the same mistake again – I never meant to harm you. Please, Bilbo, forgive me.”

Bilbo gives a soft gasp. His eyes refocus for a split second, before his knees buckled and he collapses like a puppet whose strings have been cut. Fili shouts in surprise, Thorin leaps forward to catch him, heart in his throat – but Bilbo doesn’t scream or fight; the hobbit is deeply unconscious. Thorin sinks to his knees, draws the slight body to his chest. There is a sense of fragility to Bilbo's unmoving form he does not like - and up close he can see the memory of those stressful last weeks written all over the hobbit's pallid face.

“Where is Oin?” he asks, as Fili leans closer, concern on his nephew’s face. His heir stares at Bilbo – “Will he… is he….” But Fili can’t voice what he fears; instead he jumps up, “I’ll look for Oin. I’ll … be back in a moment… just … just – I’ll be back.”

And Thorin barely manages to shout after him to bring Oin to Bilbo’s rooms.  

His chest clenches - he shouldn't have asked Bilbo to play ambassador to Dale, not matter how skilled the hobbit is and how well along he gets with Bard. The scar of Bilbo’s head injury is still visible, and there are finger-shaped shadows on his throat.

Thorin feels his heart break. He would give the Arkenstone to undo it, but he still remembers the soft flesh of Bilbo's throat under his fingers - one hand had been enough to wrap around it. And now, once again, he has to realize just how small that body truly is when he puts an arm under Bilbo's knees and lifts him up.

***

Laid out on the lavish bed, Bilbo looks small and fragile. With a pained frown Thorin gazes down on the still form, while Oin gravitates around them, lifting limbs and checking Bilbo’s eyes and pulse. His expression is unhappy, and his words give little confidence.

“Too skinny,” Oin mutters, and pulls back a sleeve to reveal an arm that is more bone than flesh, “Much too skinny. He hasn’t looked that bad since Mirkwood, and we were starving then.”

Thorin purses his lips. They have no abundance of food, but they are not starving. Why then would Bilbo –

“Probably nausea,” Oin adds with a frown, “Lack of sleep and I’d guess nightmares, too. Would explain both, the weight loss and his pallor.”

They have both seen warriors suffer this after battle. His own nephews, Thorin is certain, do not sleep without interruption. They try to uphold their cheer, and at least they have each other to lean on. Their uncle has failed them; Thorin has to acknowledge that, no matter how painful.

Bilbo has no such support. His supposed friends have already once stood by and watched as he was cast out and almost murdered in the process. It is unsurprising their hobbit is reluctant to trust them.

“What can we do?” Thorin asks with a heavy heart.

Oin rearranges the covers around Bilbo – the hobbit remains blissfully unconscious, testament to his exhaustion. Then he straightens with a sigh. “You know how it is in these cases,” Oin says, “Healing must come from within. There is little that can be done but offer comfort and companionship.”

What he does not say is that theirs is a companionship that may not be helpful.

Thorin wishes there was something he could do – he would offer Bilbo his head if it helped. He has told the hobbit he would gladly bear whatever punishment the hobbit deemed necessary, but Bilbo had shaken his head then, said he was glad they had come to understand his reasoning and never addressed the matter again. Too kind and too forgiving, Thorin thinks, and now he is paying for it.

“Might the elves have some medicine or technique?” Thorin asks. For Bilbo’s sake, he would swallow his dislike.

Oin shrugs. “While they have other techniques, in the end those amount to the same as ours. Those nightmares cannot be chased out by herb or enchantment.”

That would be too easy. Thorin is not so lucky that his troubles can be solved by a spell, but he wishes that for once, this fate would only affect him alone and not also those around him. Bilbo does not deserve to suffer for Thorin’s wrongdoings.

“A change of place, then?” he suggests.

Oin nods. “Aye, but I can only think of two places that might provide the peace for healing – and the roads will not open until spring.”

Rivendell and the Shire. Thorin sighs – he knows the company does not want to lose their burglar. He himself wishes Bilbo could stay at Erebor. But looking at the frail form resting on the bed, he knows that it cannot be.

***

He is warm and comfortable, but he does not know where he is. His head feels stuffy and his chest aches – his entire body feels as if he’d been through Mirkwood all over. Dimly he realizes somebody nearby is humming, though he cannot make out the words.

At first his eyelids stick together and won’t open, and maybe he makes a sound. When the world swims into focus, the humming stops, and Thorin is watching him with unveiled concern. Bilbo realizes he is back in his quarters, and there is a fire roaring in the fireplace, tinting everything in shades of flickering orange.

He tries to push himself up – his memories are blurry, but he probably fainted or did something equally embarrassing. Thorin reaches out to stop the movement and Bilbo can’t help flinching.

Then he can only watch as Thorin seems to shrink into himself. “I … I’m sorry,” the King mumbles, “I meant no harm.”

Bilbo’s heart aches, because he knows that. He knows, and yet his body betrays him, and –

And it was Thorin shouting at him, he remembers abruptly. Shouting and raising his hands, and he couldn’t help but recall another time when Thorin’s features had twisted with rage and madness. Suddenly, his throat feels impossibly dry, and with a trembling hand he reaches for the water.

Thorin makes no gesture to help him, though it breaks his heart. Bilbo would like nothing better than to tell him to go ahead – but he knows it won’t end well. There is a splinter of fear remaining deep in his heart, and now it is pulsing with remembered terror.

“I did not mean to harm you,” Thorin says eventually, “Had I known it was you, I would never have shouted. But, I suppose, it is futile – I should not have shouted in any case. In this I am my own worst enemy.”

And there is nothing to say, because Thorin is right.

“If there is anything you wish for – any way I can make up for this –“ the King continues, but Bilbo is already shaking his head.

“I have everything I need,” he replies, though that is only half the truth. What he needs is his smial – the blue sky and the lush green of the Shire. The unchanging light of the mountain leaves him unsettled and the dreary cold outside seeps into his soul.

“Still, I would see you not missing a thing,” Thorin returns, “Whatever you wish for, if I can provide it, I will do so. It is the least you deserve.”

“Your people need your care more than I do, Thorin,” Bilbo answers quietly.

Thorin sighs, and lets his head hang. For a moment, the silence between them is almost companionable; Thorin bowed by guilt and regret, and Bilbo by exhaustion and lingering trauma.

Then the King directs a sad smile at the erstwhile burglar. “I would see you laugh again,” he tells Bilbo, “I would take back my words at the gate. I would take back my treatment of you at the outset of our journey.”

He sighs. “There was a time when I dreamt of today. Then I thought we’d all be rejoicing – with the returnees happy to help rebuilding, with a stable peace with our neighbors. I imagined Kili and Fili happy and content. At times I even thought to ask you to stay…”

Thorin shakes his head, and it warms Bilbo’s heart that Thorin cares so much. He wishes he could recover, but he knows it cannot be.

“My dreams were the same,” Bilbo replies. And he thinks about those nights when he felt safe at Thorin’s side. Save and loved, and he wishes he could bring back that time.

“We can’t change what happened,” Bilbo continues, trying to bring at least some enthusiasm into his words, even if his heart is breaking, “But we can still dream of the future.”

***

It is a bright morning in early spring that sees all of the company assembled at the gate. A light dust of frost still covers the ground, but already the sun is warm. The once desolate ground shows first signs of recovery, with greens springing up in cracks and gaps.

It is a good day for travel.

A light breeze is playing with Bilbo’s curls as he stops before Thorin one last time with a small smile on his lips. With a heavy heart Thorin closes the distance and draws Bilbo into his arms, the way he did long ago on top of the Carrock. And like then, Bilbo stiffens before relaxing, and returning the embrace.

“May the Valar watch over you, dearest of all hobbits,” Thorin says, and his eyes are burning, “And if you ever need aid, do not hesitate to call on us. We will never forget what you did for us, and we will remain forever in your debt.”

Bilbo smiles, then, and even though there are tears in his eyes, some of his old light has returned to them, too. “Thank you. Thank you all so much. I … I wish I could stay, but there is a home I must return to.”

Then he draws a deep breath. “So farewell, my friends, farewell. Do not look so sad – I may be leaving now, but if I can, I will return.”

And with that they all forget propriety. Kili and Fili are the first to surge forward, throw themselves at Bilbo, sobbing and begging him to make this a promise. Ori follows hot on their heels, and eventually Dwalin has to step closer to steady them. They are shouting and crying and laughing at the same time, and from behind the group Gandalf watches with a smile.

This is, Thorin thinks later, as he watches the group grow smaller in the distance, a parting. And they do not know what the future holds. But for once the bright blue sky overhead looks like a good omen.

Fin