Actions

Work Header

Episodes from Middle Earth

Chapter 33: Through the Ice

Summary:

Bilbo bursts into the final confrontation between Azog and Thorin - and falls through the ice after Azog. While the pale orc dies, Thorin - badly hurt - manages to pull Bilbo from the water.

Kili is the one to discover the aftermath.

Notes:

Syxx gave me the prompt "Bilbo falls through the ice" quite a long time ago. I believe even before the BotFA trailer had been released. Since it clicked with the confrontation between Thorin and Azog...

Warnings: Character Death!
Violence. Rather short?

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Azog’s primitive weapon misses Thorin by inches. The ice under Thorin’s feet cracks and splinters, he fights to keep his balance and breath. The rising sun casts long shadows, the ice groans. Below Ravenhill the sounds of battle grow dim, but Thorin does not know if it heralds victory or defeat. His blood now longer roars in his ears, only the exhausted drum of his heart continues. Hot blood coats his side from when he wasn’t quick enough to escape Azog’s blade, the throb distracting and his knees strangely weak.

Azog feints to the left, but Thorin does not have the strength to block his attack, instead sidestepping it, throwing half-hearted slice towards Azog’s shoulder. He almost slips on the ice, and Azog easily twists out of reach.

His breath comes in short, hard gasp and his mind is nearly blank. Azog, and he does not dare to think beyond. Not of what he has caused, not of the many that lie dead. Not of Fili who paid so dearly for Thorin’s own blindness.

He almost misses Azog’s next attack, only remembering to roll out of the way in the very last moment. A part of him wonders if he shouldn’t just give up. Close his eyes, let Azog take his head and have some other become the one to slay the pale orc.

It is tempting. But then Azog grunts and smirks and Thorin cannot allow him victory. Not for the sake of his own life tainted by the wrongs he committed. But for the harm Azog brought his kin and friends, for the life of his grandfather, the disappearance of his father. For Fili.

“Why do you struggle?” Azog taunts, “I smell your exhaustion. You smell of sweat and fear. Like your grandfather did. Like the whelp did.”

Thorin clenches his aching fingers tighter around Orcrist’s hilt, ignoring the throbbing in his raw knuckles. Coated in a stiffening mix of blood and grim, his hand has grown numb, as have his legs. But when Azog next swings, Thorin dives underneath the chain and aims for his gut.

The stroke opens a small cut in Azog’s unprotected side and Azog roars. Thorin has to stumble back clumsily, his feet sliding out under him, as Azog forces the chain to whip sideways and the stone swings so fast toward Thorin, he has no choice but to jump.

His feet slip the moment he lands, he falls backwards and all air escapes his lungs when his back hits the ice. Fire races up from his side and something shifts, and it feels so fundamentally wrong that he cannot breathe. For a moment he stares dizzily into the brightening morning sky, hears Azog grunt, the ominous crunch of the ice and thinks his fate is sealed.

Then a small shape tackles Azog with an angry shout, and Azog grunts in surprise, and then they’re both thrown off their feet.

For a split second Thorin wonders if he hallucinates. Another time, with smoke in the air veiling the stars and –

Azog roars in anger, he hears a gasp from a familiar voice and manages to push himself up to his knees to see Azog fling Bilbo away. The hobbit slides across the ice, blood in his hair, but struggling to find purchase. Azog is still down and Thorin throws himself forward.

At the very last moment Azog blocks the strike aimed for his head and from the corner of his eye Thorin spies Bilbo getting to his feet. Azog uses his distraction, forces him back and away and rises, ignoring the cracking ice. Underneath their feet, the ice is marred by crack lines and Thorin knows it will not hold them much longer.

And Bilbo is running back toward them. “Stay back!” Thorin yells, and only barely manages to escape decapitation by Azog. In reply Bilbo casts a glare at Thorin and dives for Azog’s thigh. The pale orc dances out of reach, and abruptly the ice gives.

Thorin freezes and Azog roars in fury as the ice under his feet crumbles away. He flings out his arms, wavers pathetically, seeking out stable ground. Thousands of small cracks run through the ice – and when Azog finds himself stable, his eyes meet Thorin’s and they both know what will happen.

A strange sense of calm suffuses Thorin’s body as sets down Orcrist and reaches for the stone still embedded in the ice near his feet. Azog yet holds the other end of the chain, daring not even to move to toss it away, the ice still cracking under his feet and black water lapping hungrily at the edges of already existing holes.

Thorin throws the stone at Azog, ignoring the fierce, protesting ache in his side and takes a calm step backward. The pale orc’s eyes burn with fury, he scrambles, but his weight is too much. With a thunderous series of cracks and pops the ice shatters and Thorin watches as black water swallows Azog’s struggling form in seconds.

Revealing Bilbo, just a few inches beyond where Azog had been standing, the ice under his feet a white, splintered mess. Thorin’s heart stops.

“No!” Thorin shouts and starts forward. Guilt surges in his chest, his eyes meet Bilbo’s for a split second and he knows throwing the stone only guaranteed Azog’s end at the price of Bilbo. But he hadn’t known, had forgotten about him for a moment and he would never have –

The ice breaks apart and Bilbo screams. Thorin throws himself flat on the ice, sliding forward on his stomach, just as Bilbo’s scream cuts off, swallowed by black water. His heart races and he plunges his arm down, not caring about the icy bite of the water or the sharp pressure of ice against his biceps.

Blindly, he grasps for anything, fingers numb, his thoughts racing. Hobbits don’t swim, he recalls Bilbo telling him, and even if the river isn’t deep here, it’s still deep enough for a hobbit to drown, and Thorin frantically stretches out his arm, praying for a miracle, already trying to shrug off his coat with one arm.

His fingers brush past something and he grips it, pulling desperately. It jerks against his hold, and small fingers wrap sluggishly around his arm. Thorin’s heart skips a beat and he pulls, ignoring the sharp throb running through his side.

Bilbo’s skin is cold under his fingers, but the hobbit struggles weakly as he pulls him up. Thorin’s side burns, and he pants, but the soaked, shuddering form of the burglar rests on the fragile ice next to him, gasping and coughing.

A cold gust of wind passes them, and Thorin ignores the blackness rising behind his eyelids, instead pushing himself up on his elbows, when the ice creaks in protest. They need to get onto firmer ground, his mind tells him. He needs to get Bilbo out of the wet clothes. They need to get somewhere warm.

But he cannot feel his legs anymore, and there’s a trail of blood on the ice where he was lying, and Thorin understands. He grips Bilbo’s wrist, and drags both of them away from the hole, over to the middle of the river where the ice is still stable and where the first rays of sunlight are touching.

They will not be warm enough.

Under his hands, the pulse in that thin wrist is weak, and Thorin knows his grip must be bruising. He could shatter those bones, how often had he thought this, back when the madness had eaten his mind, when he had forced Bilbo to stay next to him, ignored the hobbit’s obvious discomfort. It is all clear to him now –

“Bilbo!” Thorin calls, interrupting his spinning thoughts and rolls the hobbit over, “Bilbo, wake up!”

Warmth, if there was any warmth nearby he could still save him. Bilbo’s life could still be saved – but the ice isn’t warm enough, and it’s winter, not even the sun light carries warmth. Bilbo shivers violently, but his eyelids flutter, and Thorin forcefully strips away the blue coat and shrugs off his own.

There is no warm place nearby. There is nobody he can call. Bilbo’s life is forfeit, no matter how many of his own layers he sheds and wraps Bilbo in.

He barely feels the cold anymore.

“Bilbo, wake up!” he calls again, desperately, because time is slipping away for both of them. The burn in his side lessens, and Bilbo’s pallor is growing waxy.

“Thorin?” Bilbo mumbles when Thorin wraps his leather coat around the hobbit’s shoulder, hoping it may at least provide some warmth, even though he can feel the cold emanating from Bilbo’s body through it.

Something burning rises in his chest and Thorin clutches the hobbit against his own body. Their eyes meet, and Thorin can only see understanding in Bilbo’s.

“I’m sorry,” he grunts out and tightens his grip, his voice choked and shaky “I’m sorry I brought you into this, I’m sorry I was blind, I – I would take back everything, my words at the gate, every unkind word I spoke to you, I – “

A hand weakly tugs on his arm, interrupting Thorin’s ramblings. Bilbo manages a shaky smile, but his lips are turning blue, and his voice is barely working. “I… forgiven, Thorin. … I un- understand. And … I … I’m glad … I met … you…”

A shudder wrecks him and Thorin rubs his back, as if the gesture could return any warmth. He casts a desperate glance around, but they are alone but for the bodies of dead orcs, and he does not know what has happened on the battlefield. The sounds have faded, and the sun has risen, but the frozen river already feels removed from the world of the living.

“I, it may not be my place to say it, but,” Thorin’s voice hitches, “I’m glad I met you, too. You broke me out of the gold sickness, you know. If you hadn’t given them the Arkenstone, I would have never had to confront my feelings. Never would have woken from my stupor.”

Bilbo’s eyelids have started sinking, and he no longer shivers. There is yet light in them, and Thorin hopes he can still hear his words. “I owe you so much and in the end I have only led you to death. I pray the Valar will right my wrongs and bestow upon you what you deserve, and I … if I … had…”

Darkness rises behind Thorin’s eyelids. He doesn’t remember lying down next to Bilbo, and still the ground feels unsteady. Somehow Bilbo’s hand has come to rest against his wrist and twitches weakly and without a thought Thorin takes it.

The ice-cold skin is a shock against his blood-crusted fingers, and Thorin can only hope Bilbo feels his grip. There is a weak pulse in it still, but the hobbit’s body is huddled against him and quite still.

Thorin’s own body feels numb. He can barely raise his other arm and wrap it around Bilbo. His mind drifts, free from pain and even the guilt seems to dissolve. He thinks of holding the hobbit, the embrace they shared back on the Carrock. Of bright smiles and how he would have thrown his arms around Bilbo the moment their troubles were over.

How he would have offered the hobbit a home under the mountain and the laughter they would have shared. How they would have watched Fili rise to greatness and Kili to fame and would have lived out their days happily.

And happily gone to sleep.

***

It is Kili who finds them. He’s limping, one ankle badly sprained and his throat bruised black and purple while Tauriel follows, her left arm hanging limply. He’s seen the eagles descended, and Tauriel had said the tides had turned, but his heart still trembles from what he wants to have been a nightmare.

Ravenhill is silent and nothing moves on the snow, and Kili can see his brother’s still form lying where he fell. It’s not a nightmare and even Tauriel’s fingers on his shoulder cannot mend the rip he feels running through his chest.

With a dull thud, he falls to his knees, his mind blank. Not even tears will come.

Tauriel kneels next to him and murmurs a small blessing in Sindarin, before reaching out a gentle hand to close Fili’s eyes. Kili feels another part of his heart break away, as his mind reminds him that this was the last time he’s seen his brother’s eyes, and there will be no undoing this.

This is final.

“Tauriel,” another voice calls and Kili joins her in looking over her shoulder. Legolas stands a bit further from them, and Kili immediately sees the bloodstain on the ice before him. Red, not black.

And his eyes spring to the dark shape behind.

“No!” he shouts, “No, no, no!”

Because he knows whose coat it is, recognizes those bare feet even before he’s up and running. Tauriel shouts something, but he doesn’t hear her, not her, not Legolas, not even the rushing of blood in his own ears.

He cannot –

But it’s Thorin, lying in a pool of blood and clutching the unmoving form of their burglar to his chest. Ice covers Bilbo’s hair, and his feet are blue, and Kili wants to scream at the sky.

Not Bilbo. Not Thorin. They cannot leave him, not when he just realized he never wants to see battle again, not when he needs them, now more than ever. Thorin had always been there to help, and he cannot, he cannot do this alone.

He reaches out, helplessly, fingers first brushing past Bilbo – and he can feel the ice, and how did he become so cold – then landing on Thorin’s shoulder. The fabric is stiff, and Thorin does not even twitch and Kili can’t breathe.

“I’m sorry,” Tauriel says, but Kili barely even hears her.

He’s lost everything, he thinks, and it’s as if the ground has been pulled from underneath his feet. His brother, his uncle – with a shaky glance he raises his head and looks toward the mountain. Not worth it, he wants to shout, the dead kingdom is not worth these precious lives.

“Oh,” a new voice utters and the sound barely carries over the ice. “Oh no.” Kili barely recognizes it, for the uncharacteristic waver, but it’s unmistakably Dwalin’s blood-splattered form making his way towards them from the other side of Ravenhill.

“Are they -?” he asks, and it’s Tauriel who nods her head.

“How,” Dwalin mutters and sinks to his knees opposite of Kili, “They both were… Just a moment ago, Bilbo, he was with me. Got knocked out, but I thought he’d be safe…”

Kili swallows, and suddenly finds Dwalin’s eyes glued to him. “I’m sorry, lad. I’m sorry I couldn’t protect them.”

No, Kili wants to reassure him, not in this battle. Not when he knows from the scrapes and cuts littering Dwalin’s arms and face just how close a fight it has been. But the words won’t come, his throat choked by a noose and he is struggling to breathe.

“I’ll inform your kin,” Legolas tells them diplomatically before vanishing from the scene. Kili does not hear him go – he wants nothing more than to turn back time, protest when Fili said he’d inspect the upper levels. They’d both heard the sounds, why hadn’t he insisted they stay together at least?

Why had he –

“Lad,” Dwalin eventually interrupts his self-recriminations, “I’m sorry.”

He realizes he has no idea how much time has passed. But he can now see the others approaching, Balin and Bifur and Nori and Ori. Dori is limping, supported by Gloin and Oin’s head has been bandaged, and behind them walks Gandalf, and they’re joined by Dain and his generals and Kili’s heart sinks.

Dwalin rises to his feet. To the newcomers, he inclines his head.

“The King is dead,” he announces, “Long live the King.”

And when a mournful, subdued chant of “Long live the King” echoes over the ice on Ravenhill, Kili realizes that his fate has been set.

***

In spite of its bleak beginning, the rule of King Kili is later deemed as prosperous. The King’s close friendship with a particular elf may have helped and while a marriage was never possible – and indeed, the chroniclers have only ever used the term “friendship” – no other marriage proposal ever met with consideration. To regulate the line of inheritance, the King chose to foster two sons of a dear companion – and so the line of Ur rose to nobility.

But in a darkening age Erebor’s prosperity also caused misgivings and jealous. Perhaps, however, these were a blessing, for the all-seeing eye of the enemy never thought to look to the navel of economic uproar for its lost treasure.

For they all had not known what had slipped from Bilbo’s pocket that day when he had fallen through the ice.

Fin

Notes:

Also, I'm trying to find my way around on tumblr (paranoidfridge, if you're up for fangirling, technical mishaps and whatever else may occur) and while I won't promise anything, if you have prompts... ^_~