Actions

Work Header

Pirates!

Chapter 8: The Mermaids

Notes:

So this is technically really chapter 4 in that in the chronological order of the story it is the chapter just after chapter 3 in this work. Sorry if that confuses anybody! but as a writer i am really enjoying the process of writing the different chapters of the story as they come and take form in my head :)

so anyway - introducing the mermaids (and some potentially familiar faces!)! hope you enjoy!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

For days afterward, Fili’s head was reeling after Bofur’s story. They were on a quest! They had a task, a purpose, an adventure ahead of them. However, Fili’s enthusiasm was short lived and in the weeks that followed it started to ebb. Sure, they were on a quest – but where to begin? How did one find a treasure hoard guarded by a sea serpent, undoubtedly at the very bottom of the sea leagues and leagues under them, in hundreds and thousands of square miles of ocean? The words ‘needle’ and ‘haystack’ seemed to have a distinct significance here.

Any hope he had that the others had any more of a clue than he did faded fast – the pirates had no more insight than he did, and judging by the fact that they spent most of their days on the ship aimlessly wave-wandering, he was starting to wonder hesitantly if the story Bofur told had been no more than a myth.

But things changed when they met the mermaids.

Fili had heard tell of the fish-legged nymphs of the ocean depths – who hadn’t? He had always thought of them as little more than stories, despite fervent assurances from the rest crew that they were real, until one lazy sunny day, when winds were low and they were little more than drifting on the high seas, and Dwalin suddenly roared, “Mermaids ahead, Captain!”

The atmosphere of the ship changed palpably, all the pirates jumping to their feet, scanning the waves ahead warily.

Thorin’s eyebrows furrowed. “Make sure Kili stays inside,” he murmured to Dis, voice suddenly like ice. Dis nodded, lips pressed together and eyes narrowed with uncharacteristic stoniness.

Fili hesitated. “Should I –“

“You can stay. After all, you’ll end up meeting them eventually.”

The water ahead was roiling, jumping and twisting as if a huge shoal of fish were swarming beneath. Fili caught glimpses of pale arms, expanses of back, swirling hair, moving too quickly for him to see them properly.

A figure rose from the water – his skin was pale to the point of being almost translucent, long silvery hair cascading over a bare chest underneath a crown of white coral. Around him more of them rose, all with long, straight hair, tails in various shades of grey and blue flashing in the sunlight. One had hair almost the exact same hue and a similar, smaller version of the crown set atop the head of the central figure, whose gaze was now fixed on Thorin, a mocking, arrogant smirk twisting his lips.

“Well if it isn’t the long lost son of Durin,” the merman drawled. “I wondered who was loitering. Many moons since we last met.”

“These aren’t your waters, Thranduil,” Thorin snapped.

“Ah but there you are wrong. This whole domain is mine.”

“How much territory could a paltry band of fishfolk such as yourselves need?” Thorin muttered testily.

“I have half a mind to turn this ship over,” Thranduil told him with a sly chuckle, dragging a hand lazily over his trident. “But I won’t. After all, we are united in common cause.”

“That we are,” Thorin bit out in reply, sounding as if the words took him immense effort to utter.

Thranduil chuckled again, his eyes roving over the crew and finally alighting on Fili. “And who is this? A newcomer I see?”

None of the pirates answered but almost as soon as he had asked his question the merman king’s eyes widened, as if in recognition. “Oh. You must be the Ironfoot boy. Another long-lost son of the sea.” His eyes narrowed, a nasty smile still playing about his lips. “I know someone who’s been looking everywhere for you...”

“W-what?” Fili stammered before he could stop himself.

“Oh yes, just everywhere. Haven’t you heard? Your uncle Dain has sent quite the search party. But I don’t suppose this lot tell you anything,” Thrainduil said mockingly, gesturing elegantly with slightly webbed fingers to the crowd on deck. The pirates bristled.

Bofur grabbed Fili’s arm. “Don’t listen to him!” he hissed. “He’s a sneak-thief and a liar!”

Fili was conflicted.

“Your uncle’s offered a pretty price for your whereabouts,” Thranduil said silkily, enjoying the tension that had suddenly sprung among the pirates, twisting around them like fish in a net. It was this that made up Fili’s mind.

“I belong here,” Fili told Thranduil coolly, trying to ignore the way his heart was racing under the merman’s crystal blue boring stare.

Thranduil raised an eyebrow. “Among a raggle-taggle band of the finest the gutters can offer?”

The scowl on Dwalin’s face deepened. Thorin, who seemed to have composed himself somewhat, stepped forward and slightly in front of Fili, as if to conceal him.

“If you send the marines Fili’s whereabouts, we will both be finished,” Thorin told Thranduil calmly. “Especially given that we are united in common cause as you so put it. And given your track record – do you think the men on the land will look kindly on you once you show them your face?”

Thranduil’s expression soured. He nodded, reluctantly. “Regrettably. It is so.”

“I think that would be best for us both,” Thorin conceded. “And if that is all, we will be on our way.”

“You blundering bipeds don’t belong here,” Thranduil said suddenly. His tone was sharp. “You are doomed to fail. Once something is lost to the dragons in the sea, it is not up to you nor anyone else to retrieve it. It is impossible.”

“I fear we shall have to agree to disagree,” Thorin replied icily.

“As always, Thorin.” Thranduil and Thorin stared at eachother for another minute, blue eyes battling for dominance in mutual distaste. Eventually Thranduil lifted his chin and swung his trident, as if trying to shake off the palpable hostility in the air.

“Until next time, Thorin. Safe travels. I hope next time we meet it will not be down in my own watery kingdom.”

“You can count on it,” Thorin muttered through gritted teeth.

Thranduil’s fingers twitched in the most miniscule of gestures – and in an instant the mermaids were gone as soon as they had come, diving down in a flurry of scaly limbs and flying hair. The waves they left in their wake were strong enough to rock the ship, swaying for a minute before eventually calming. The sun was out – it was as if they had never been there.

“So that’s the mermaids,” Thorin said. “Full of support. As always.”

Dis head poked out from the doorway of the cabins. “Have they gone?” she asked.

“Yep.” Dwalin heaved a sigh, glancing sideways at Thorin, staring broodingly out to the horizon. “Well, there you are boy, the mermaids. What did you think?”

Fili realized after a second that Dwalin was talking to him. He shook his head slowly.

“Theyre – not quite what I expected.”

“Aye? And what was that? Pretty little nymphs with sweet smiles and hearts of gold? Pff.” He sent a glare at the rippling water where moments ago the mermaids had disappeared.

“How often do you see them?” Fili asked.

“Might be months. Might be years. You never know.”

“When was the last time you saw them?”

“At least a year. Didn’t you hear him?” Dwalin snorted. “’Many moons’. Not enough as far as I’m concerned!”

“What was this ‘common cause’ he kept talking about?”

“Only that they claim to hate the snake as much as we do,” Thorin replied, tone sour. “Though he takes a different approach. He believes the safest way to retrieve the Arkenstone would be to wait until the snake is dead and rotting and then take back safely what he stole. But that’s easy to say when you’re immortal!” Thorin snorted. “Waiting a few centuries for a dragon to die of old age is nothing to him. Sadly some of us don’t have the luxury of eternity. But he’s perfectly happy to let others fight his battles for him and swoop in to cash in on the winnings when its’ all over. And about the men on the shore, well, he’s not exactly averse to tipping boats over when it takes his fancy or when they stray too close to his coral kingdom. Most landlubbers don’t believe in their existence anyway, think it’s freak storms but we know better.”

Fili wasn’t entirely sure he followed Thorin’s rant – his head was swimming a little. Dis peered into his face.

“Are you alright dear? You’re white as a sheet.”

“Yeah. I’m – fine.”

Dis smiled. “Not uncommon symptoms the first time you see a mermaid. You should have seen some of the others on their first sighting. Most of them fainted.”

Fili gave a hollow chuckle. “At least I didn’t pass out.”

“You still look very pale. Go and have a lie-down.”

“Aye - I think I will. Thanks.”

Fili felt light headed as he crossed the deck towards the hold. He tried to concentrate on putting one foot in front of the other – when he finally reached his cabin, he sank onto his bunk and closed his eyes. He could distantly hear vague thuds and shouted orders coming from above, mixed with the lulling slap of waves against the ship’s hull as they began to move.

It wasn’t the mermaids on his mind (although they had been surreal enough); it was his uncle. Had he really sent out a search party for him? And could they possibly have missed all message of it, out on the sea though they were? They did have dealings with other vessels occasionally, and they had been back to shore at least once – is it possible they had simply missed the memo? Or maybe there never had even been one – Bofur had called him a liar and a “sneak-thief”, whatever that was meant to mean. Or had Thorin and the others been actively concealing it from him? The thought made his head spin even more.

Thinking of his uncle made Fili think of his family. His heart constricted and he rubbed his neck, as if to dislodge the lump that had suddenly formed in his throat.

The door creaked open and Kili bounded into the room.

“It’s always so boring when the mermaids come,” he said, pulling a face as he sat down heavily next to Fili. “Mama makes me wait downstairs til they’re gone and everyone’s grumpy after they leave.”

Fili smiled thinly. “I can imagine why.”

“I’ve only ever heard bad things about them. Mama told me to come down and see if you’re okay. She said they asked you about your family and then you got sad.”

“Yes. They mentioned my uncle. I’m not sad – exactly.”

“Oh. Do you miss him?”

“Not really.”

“You must miss your mum.”

“I do.”

“Where is she? Does she live in the Carribbean too?”

“She’s dead,” Fili told him. “So is my father.”

“That’s sad. I’m sorry.” Kili watched his bare feet swinging slightly, his eyebrows pulled down in genuine concern. “Do you have any other family?”

“Only a sister.”

“Where is she?”

“In England, I suppose. I haven’t seen her for years. Shortly after my parents died I was shipped out to the Carribbean to go and live with Dain, so he could train me up to run his business one day. My sister was sent to live with an aunt in Salisbury.”

“Where’s that?”

“Somewhere in England.”

“How old would she be now?”

“A few years younger than you.”

“How did your parents die?”

“They got sick.” It had been hard – Fili’s mother had died first, of some kind of consumption, and his father had been so heartbroken he hadn’t lasted much longer. Rumour had it that Fili’s mother had been expecting a third child but Fili didn’t like to think about that.

“I’m sure she’s happy, your sister,” Kili told Fili earnestly. “Girls don’t tend to like the Carribbean. Too hot.”

Fili still missed his sister desperately, but Kili’s attempts to cheer him warmed his heart somewhat. He chuckled and Kili, thinking his joke had been met with mirth, grinned broadly.

“Maybe we can persuade Thorin to go to England so you can visit her. How far is it to England?”

“Many many miles,” Fili said, laughing genuinely this time. “I don’t know that there’s much hope of persuading Thorin to venture that far, but maybe one day. I’m hoping somehow to get back, eventually.”

“But you’ll come back right?”

Fili smiled, taking hold of Kili’s chin gently and resting their foreheads together.

“Probably. I’m a beach boy, me.”

“Me too.”

“How do you know if you’ve never been anywhere else?” Fili asked, amusedly, as Kili bounced off the bed and stood in front of him, pretending to do a wave dance.

“Don’t know, don't have to know. Was born on this ship, I belong on the sea.”

“Don’t you ever think about – the future?” Fili asked. “Like – getting an education or getting married, or…” Fili gestured uselessly, realizing what a stupid questions he was asking. Kili was barely twelve – he was probably more interested in what he was having for dinner than any vague prospect like the future.

“Eurgh, don’t talk about education. Mum’s already been talking to your old tutor Balin about it and giving me lessons.” Kili stuck out his tongue and cartwheeled effortlessly, showing off. “And as for marriage – if we ever get to England maybe I’ll marry your sister.”

“Don’t you dare,” Fili growled with mock aggression.

“I’ll do it if she’s even half as pretty as you are.” Kili fluttered his eyelashes and blew him a kiss.

“You cheeky nit!”

“Always!” Kili pirouetted and smiled angelically. “We’d probably best get back on deck before Dwalin accuses us of plotting something decidedly unhelpful and a most definitely a nuisance.”

“We never do that,” Fili said with mock sincerity. Kili nodded solemnly, following suit.

“Absolutely not. Race you to the deck!”

“Not fair, you got a head start!” Fili yelled after him as Kili bolted for the door. He jumped to his feet in hot pursuit, sadness at faraway sisters and past homes forgotten for the moment as he raced up the stairs to the sunshine of the deck he had learned to call home.

Notes:

soo i wasn't sure how to end this chapter so i just let the characters speak for a while - and out of it a sister emerged! In my head I call her Caroline

 

hope you enjoyed, as always kudos/comments/feedback are always muchly appreciated :)