Actions

Work Header

Communication

Summary:

5 times Thorin talked to Bilbo when he thought he was asleep and 1 time Bilbo did the same.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Chapter 1: To Bree

Chapter Text

Bilbo had very few regrets in life. Being a Hobbit mostly ensured this for they were simple creatures who, as long as they had good food, a warm house, and a big family, easily led a fulfilled and happy life. There may be small regrets, such as not eating more of Jessamine’s plum pie before she wrongly assumed a change in the recipe would be a good idea or tumbling around as a child too much and earning a nasty scar that would lead to years of rude name-calling; but Hobbits were content people who lived mostly regretless lives.

Bilbo had followed this pattern quite well. He regretted ever letting Lobelia Sackville Baggins see his nice silverware, he regretted accidentally washing his nice red jacket with his even nicer white shirt, he regretted that the pie he baked for the one lass he wanted to court had berries she was allergic to in it. Very normal Hobbit regrets.

However, then a wizard came to the Shire and Bilbo completely gave up being a normal Hobbit.  

Bilbo found that now that he was an unusual Hobbit, he had an unusually large number of regrets and this whole adventuring business was all of them. The first thing he came to regret was that he forgot his handkerchief at home (leading him to be ridiculed by the Dwarves when he wanted to go back and get it). Then only hours after that, he found out he would only get 2 meals a day (2, not even 3 like he had feared, it was even worse than he could imagine). His butt was sore from riding all day long and they weren't even to Bree, the Dwarves were either terrifying, aloof, or annoying (and he didn't know which he preferred), Gandalf kept laughing at him for no reason, and he had been rained on. Twice.  

However, none of those (added all together) could possibly compare to how much he regretted ever making the acquaintance of Thorin Oakenshield. It wasn't even because he was the catalyst for this nasty adventuring business (no, Bilbo blamed Gandalf for that). It was because Thorin was the rudest, most arrogant person Bilbo had ever had the displeasure of meeting (and there were some nasty people in the Shire no matter what the big folk thought). Thorin had walked into his home as though he owned it, insulted him even though he had supplied his companions with food and shelter, and then had the nerve to treat him like nothing more than a nuisance after he decided to come on this quest. He would rarely speak to Bilbo but when he did, it always managed to be insulting and lead Thorin to angrily turn away in silence as though it was he who had been insulted. Why, Bilbo would even go as far as to say he was ruder than all the Sackville-Baggins put together. Just because he was a king and he had a handsome face and beautiful eyes didn't mean he could act like everyone else was below him. If Bilbo wasn't sure the bald Dwarf that always rode near Thorin (was it Dwalin or Balin, or maybe one of the Ris) wouldn't stick an ax through him quicker than a hot knife through butter if he did anything funny, he would have marched straight up to Thorin and given him a piece of his mind.

At that moment, he could see Thorin riding point at the head of the group, looking grandiose as ever (that prat). It was getting dark and they should be stopping soon but Thorin showed no sign of slowing down. He never did, he always forced them forward as though the mountain would somehow disappear. It was only when Balin (Dwalin? the one with the big white beard) had a quick conversation with Thorin did he finally let his pony slow down to a stop in a place that looked nice enough to stay the night. He dismounted with a (annoying) flourish before turning to the company with whatever orders he decided he needed to give. Thorin never gave Bilbo orders (which he didn’t know if he was grateful or angry about) so instead, he wandered over to Bomber to see if he needed any help in preparing dinner. Bilbo didn’t know much about life on the road but he did know food and he was happy to help in any way that he could.

Unfortunately, he never made it to Bomber’s side.

“Master Baggins,” Thorin called out in that infuriating superior way he did, as though Master was an insult rather than a title. “Go collect some firewood. It’s easy enough for a child so you must be able to do it. It will give you something to do other than complain as you like to do.”

(He did not just do that)

Some of the Dwarves snickered but Thorin turned away from Bilbo without another word and tended to his pony. Bilbo felt his face go red in equal parts anger and embarrassment.

(How dare that pig headed piece of)

Bilbo’s hands clenched at his sides and for a moment he entertained the (suicidal) idea of choosing this moment to stand up to Thorin. But instead he turned on his heel and marched his way into the forest. He didn’t stop until he couldn’t hear the laughter of the Dwarves anymore.

He muttered to himself as he picked up his sticks, cursing Thorin Oakenshield in every way he knew how to. The anger that was curling in his stomach burned and made his hands shake. He wanted to scream.

Yet, as he time passed and he cooled down he began to realize that no matter how rudely he had said it, Thorin wasn’t wrong. He did complain a lot and he wasn’t really all that more skilled than a child when it came to this traveling and adventuring business. His insides that were once twisted in anger relaxed and began to twist in a different way. In a sadder way. A more regretful way.

When he returned to the camp, he ignored Bomber’s sympathetic look, He ate his meal as fast as possible and went to bed a soon as he could without a word to anybody.

He laid with his eyes firmly shut and pretended to be asleep. He stayed as still as he could, back to the fire and Dwarves, and if he tried hard enough he could almost pretend he was back at Bag End.

 

The night passed and the Dwarves settled down for sleep, sleep that Bilbo was not getting. They established watch, put away their instruments, and snuggled into their bed rolls allowing for the day to officially be done. Bilbo had thought that now it was silent he would be able to drift off to sleep but instead of peace, the lack of noise only allowed for his thoughts to be louder. They crashed against his mind, reminding him of Thorin’s mocking orders, the snickers of the Dwarves, his own self-doubts. He wondered if he got up and left now, how long it would take him to get back to Bag End.    

“Hobbit,” Thorin’s voice harshly shatter the silence.

Bilbo almost popped straight up out of his bed roll (much like his heart had popped out of his chest) but his body froze where it laid the moment Thorin continued to speak.

“No, that’s not right. That will just be seen as threatening. Master Burglar. No. Bilbo Baggins. Master Baggins. Good enough,” he grumbled to himself before clearing his throat.

“Master Baggins, I would like to apologiz-. I would like to make clear the situation that-. I would like to apologize for the way I have treated you, today and the days before that. You have joined this quest when you have no reason to and I believe that to be an honorable thing. But that's the problem because you seem to be an honorless creature. Wait no, that’s wrong. You're not honorless,” Thorin let out an angry and frustrated huff.

Thorin, Bilbo realized, was talking to him. Or at least he was pretending to talk to him. He was practicing.

Bilbo wanted to laugh but he was too flabbergasted to remember how to do much of anything. The almighty leader of this quest was currently pacing back and forth in the dirt, worrying about how to talk to him. Bilbo almost reached over and pinched himself to see if this was really happening or if it was just some strange dream his subconscious had bestowed upon him.

“Master Hobbit,” Thorin began again. “I would like to say you are very honorable for coming on this quest even though you are clearly unsuitable for this and do not belong here. Damn, I insulted you again.”

It was actually almost sweet of him, Bilbo thought, if he ignored how ridiculous it was for Thorin to be stumbling over his words as he pretended to talk to him. He should probably pretend to wake up to save Thorin from further embarrassment (like hell he would) but the urge to hear what he was going to say was too much. So far it had been mostly insults and he did that often enough when Bilbo was awake, there was no reason for him to wait till he was sleeping. There had to be something else.

Suddenly, Thorin let out a long-suffering sigh and he sat down on the log next to Bilbo’s bed roll. Bilbo braced himself for what he would say, he expected more insults maybe another halfhearted apology, but he didn’t expect the soft, sincere, and absolutely bewildered words that came next.

“I do not understand you, Master Baggins. I do not understand why you came with us when even many of my kin and close friends would not. You have no reason for being here, nor do you seem to enjoy it. Do you think this is just some vacation from your little home? Are you here simply to see the world or some other naive reason? I would be thankful for you joining with us if I could understand why you joined in the first place. I do not trust easily. In my experience trust has only ever been something broken. I do not trust you Master Hobbit. Again I am insulting you,” Thorin let out a groan.

“I don’t mean for this to happen. Though you are weak and soft, no again. It seems I’m unable to speak to you for more than a few seconds without managing to belittle you in some way. I’ve never had a silver tongue a king should have.”

The last line was said quietly, almost conspiratorially. The idea of Thorin whispering secrets to him in the middle of the night was surprisingly nice, it made him feel almost as though they were friends. If only Bilbo didn’t have to pretend to be sleeping for this conversation to happen.

Bilbo heard Thorin stand up from his log.

“I do not wish to mistrust you, Master Baggins. I simply do not know how not to.”

With those final words, he walked away, off to check the perimeter or perhaps even have a one-sided conversation with someone else in the company. Bilbo opened his eyes the moment he was sure Thorin was far enough not to see. Without Thorin there, Bilbo was left with only his thoughts once again and boy were they company right now. Much better company than they had been before.

His mind whirled, trying to make sense of what had just been said. He ran through Thorin’s words over and over until he concluded three things:

1.  Thorin didn’t know how to not insult him

2. Thorin didn’t mean to insult him all the time and was slightly sorry for it

(This, of course, didn’t mean he no longer felt insulted, but oddly enough he was rather pacified by the idea that it was all an accident)   

3. Thorin didn’t know why he was here

Well, that made sense, seeing as Bilbo didn’t really know why he was here either. It was a split-second decision that he spent almost every waking moment regretting. Why was he here?

He had better figure that out before Thorin asked him about it tomorrow. He had his practice for the conversation but Bilbo still didn’t know how he would be able to add to it. Bilbo settled into his bedroll planning out his responses. He felt excitement flood through his veins at the idea of having this conversation again, only being able to respond this time.

   

The next day Bilbo woke up completely unrefreshed, he had spent too much time thinking about what to say to Thorin his mind wouldn’t let him sleep (but that wasn’t really a problem seeing as he probably wouldn’t have gotten much sleep last night with or without Thorin’s midnight talk). But it was worth it because he was completely prepared for Thorin to approach him. There would be no floundering or stuttering. Just a clear, civilized conversation between two adults over misconceptions and confusion.

When he woke, his eyes automatically found where Thorin was discussing something the whitebeardedalin, his face was scrunched and scowling like always and for a moment Bilbo wondered what Thorin's face had looked like last night when he was whispering softly. Surely he couldn't have been scowling even then. He wondered if he would make the same faces when they talked today. The thought made Bilbo's stomach do a small turn. Thorin looked up and their eyes met and anticipation bubbled in his stomach. Bilbo’s breath caught when Thorin parted his lips, he was going to call him over to talk. This was going to happen. But then he closed his mouth and turned away.

"We're moving now Master Baggins. Get up." He said.

That wasn't right. Bilbo frowned to himself as he began to collect his things. Maybe later. Maybe he was saving it for when they were on the road. Or maybe when they set up camp that night. Later was fine, Bilbo could wait.