Actions

Work Header

Communication

Chapter 2: In Rivendell

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Rivendell, Bilbo had decided, was where he was going to spend the rest of his life.

As much as he loved his Bag End and missed it all the more every step he took away from it, if he survived this quest he would turn right around and make his way back to Rivendell and never take another step. He would spend every moment of his life eating, writing, singing, and thinking with the Elves of Elrond’s House and never have to deal with another problem (or Dwarves) ever again. It was an absurd idea (especially the whole surviving bit) but as Bilbo sat in the exceptional library found in Rivendell, calmly flipping through a tome filled with breathtaking poetry, he was willing to believe it would become a reality.

It was peaceful in the library, the only sounds were from the soft rustle of old parchment as pages were turned and the soothing scraping of Ori’s pen as he wrote with fervor in his journal. Ori was, as Bilbo had found, one of the more reasonable and proper Dwarves in the company (which mostly meant he didn’t scowl and grunt at him whenever he was close enough to make eye contact) and they had struck up a peculiar but comfortable friendship over a shared love of stories and literature. And so when Bilbo had decided to sneak away to the library it only seemed right to invite Ori with him. Together they had gushed and marveled at the sheer size of it, had a lovely chat with the Elf in charge who had given them some wonderful suggestions, and each settled down with a large book and spent what felt like hours reading in peace, only breaking it to grab a new book or share a particularly interesting find.  

Yes, Rivendell was wonderful.

His only regret was that he had to come there with Dwarves.

 

“Here they are,” Kili’s loud voice seemed to echo in the quiet of the room.

Bilbo startled out of his reverie and looked up to see Kili leaning up against their table coolly. He was staring at them with a look of amusement which meant nothing good was about to happen. And if Kili was here that meant-.

“All this worrying and we find them squirreled away with some dusty books.”

And there was Fili, annoyingly popping up right behind him, causing him to jump. Bilbo scowled at them as Fili sauntered up to join his brother at the head of the table.

“Is there a problem?” Bilbo asked.

“Yeah, you better get back with the others. Thorin’s really angry-”

(When is he not?)

“About you guys going missing. Thinking the Elves are stealing our precious Hobbit away from us,” Fili said.

“And,” Kili said as they turned their grins to Ori. “One of our very own Dwarves it looks like.”

“That’s preposterous. Steal us away? What kind of things go on in your heads?” Bilbo said before they could start leaning into Ori more.

Fili and Kili actually started pouting as though they were nothing more than fauntlings.

 

Dwarves were ridiculous in every single way, a fact Bilbo was becoming all too familiar with. He could have ignored all their strange ways and annoying ticks if not for the fact they were interfering with Bilbo's enjoyment of Rivendell.

First of all, they had this unbearable suspicion of everyone.

If an Elf even looked at them funny (which happened quite often seeing as they were Dwarves in Rivendell) they went into a defensive formation with a harsh cry and Bilbo found himself thrown in the middle of a clump of weapons and angry Dwarves (of course the first time it had happened Bilbo was actually terrified out of his mind by the galloping horses and giant Elves and was actually thankful to be pulled into the safe Dwarf shield but by the third time of being grabbed when he just wanted to get something to get eat, he was ready to bash some heads in (or at least wag his finger at them)). Their horrible suspicion made them refuse to let Bilbo go anywhere they considered unsafe. And because they were Dwarves, that meant anywhere with Elves. Every time he wanted to explore he had to sneak away only to be tracked by the hoard of Dwarves who acted like he was going to disappear into the Elves' secret dungeons and be tortured to the end of his days (which in honesty would be less painful than watching these Dwarves try to sneak around him).    

Second, they were horrifically rude to the Elves.

The dinner (and every meal after that) was a perfect example. The way they insulted their music and complained about the food set Bilbo’s respectable Baggins blood boiling. It was barbaric and it reminded him too much of the horrid night they had invaded his own home. He didn’t wish that on anyone. And sure the Elves could be rather rude to them what with the lack of meat and the speaking to them in languages they didn’t know and sneering at them when they passed each other in the halls. However, a little bit (okay a lot of) rudeness didn’t excuse rudeness in return. If Bilbo had been rude to every Hobbit that whispered things about him or tried to use him for his money, he would be known as the rudest Hobbit in the Shire. Someday he would have to sit these Dwarves down and teach them proper etiquette when dealing with someone you hate. Perhaps Elf-Dwarf relations would improve if one of them could simply get ahold of their childish mannerisms.        

Third, they were just plain difficult.

Lord Elrond had graciously offered them each a nice room with an absolutely heavenly bed to sleep on (Bilbo almost cried when he heard that after a month of bed rolls and dirt) and the ridiculous Dwarves had the gall to refuse him. Instead, they gathered in a random room (that they promptly destroyed) and huddled on the ground as though they were still on the road. Bilbo was offended on Elrond’s behalf and refused to join their odd display of Dwarvish pride. He was going to enjoy the nice bed and clean sheets as long as he could (and enjoy them he did).

And finally, they had apparently had a secret meeting where they had decided that the Elves were trying their hardest to steal Bilbo away from them.

That meant that when he tried to sneak away they tried even harder to keep him with them. If he was having a nice conversation with Lindir, one of them would pop up and whisk him away. If one of the Elves offered to show him the gardens, Bifur would swoop in to show him them himself (it had been surprisingly nice to walk with Bifur and he believed they could become good friends if they could ever find a way to communicate). And if Elrond had extended an invitation to stay and the Elves were making it very hard to leave then that was no business of the Dwarves. Bilbo was a Hobbit of his word and he had signed a contract, he wasn’t going to back out now (even though he really wished he could).

All Bilbo wanted to do was have a relaxing time and it seemed like the Dwarves were doing their best to make that impossible.

 

“Don’t trust the Elves Bilbo. They’ll charm you with their weird music and pretty faces and you’ll never leave again,” Kili said.

(Would that be such a bad thing?)

“You best be getting back, Thorin is already angry about you sneaking away, if you don't turn up soon he’ll just get even angrier and start yelling. And Nori and Dori have been looking all over for you freaking out,” Fili said.

Ori shrunk in shame as Bilbo huffed.

“I will stay right where I am because I am enjoying this book. And you can tell your uncle that he can take his unreasonable suspicion and-”

(Shove it up his ass)

“Get over it.”

Fili and Kili’s eyes almost bulged out of their sockets and they shared a look, probably silently arguing over who got to tell Thorin Bilbo’s response.

Ori smiled at him softly as he stood up and gathered his things.

“I’m sorry Bilbo, but I better get back to Dori and Nori,” he said reluctantly.

Bilbo sighed, he had been enjoying Ori’s company.

“If you must, I won’t stop you but I do regret you leaving.”

Ori beamed at the admission but still hastily packed up his things, taking with him the books the librarian had given him. He nodded at Bilbo and then at Fili and Kili before scuttling away.  

Bilbo turned back to his own book and tried to immerse himself as he had before the two brothers had shown up. The only problem was that said brothers were still there, staring at him with wide eyes. Bilbo honestly tried to ignore them but they had a special (irritating) way to be loud when saying absolutely nothing.

“What are you two still doing here? Do you wish to look at a book?” Bilbo asked finally, resisting the temptation to throw the book at their heads.

“Thorin doesn't like that you won’t stay with the rest of the company,” Fili said.

“Thorin doesn’t like anything that I do for some reason. And I’m quite aware, as are you I’m sure, that Thorin doesn’t consider me anything but a burden, let alone part of this company. I don’t see any reason for him to be worrying. I think he’d be glad for me to stay here. One less thing to worry about,” Bilbo huffed out, not even caring when Fili and Kili winced and shared a look.

“Mr. Boggins,” Kili started. The use of his mistaken name (that had as of late become an endearment from Kili) made Bilbo’s heart soften and him feel guilty at the way he had blown up at them. It wasn’t their fault Thorin treated him like he did.

“Thorin, he takes a long time to warm up to somebody, but he doesn’t hate you. Thorin may treat you like you’re not, but you’re every bit as part of the company as each one of us,” Fili finished for him.

“Yeah, I mean you saved us from the trolls and you tell us great stories and even if you can’t do much we all enjoy having you with us,” Kili said passionately.

Bilbo’s heart warmed at their awkward but sincere comfort. It was nice to know even if Thorin hated him he still had friends in the company. He gave them both a warm smile that had them grinning back at him.

“Thank you both, but I will have plenty of time to be with all of you on the road. Who knows when I’ll be able to see Rivendell again?”

(If ever again)

“I’m sorry but I’m going to make the most of the small time I have here. You can tell Thorin that if he wants to talk to me he can find me here himself.”

And with that, he turned back to his book and he heard the two brothers scuffle away muttering to each other. Bilbo’s smile didn’t fade for another few minutes as he once again lost himself in his book.

 

The next time he looked up he realized someone had lit the lanterns that were scattered around the library. He looked to the windows and startled when he saw no sunlight peeking through. How long had he been in here? The time on the road had quickly diminished the need for him to eat his normal meals but he could still feel a small ache that told him he had missed dinner. Bilbo grumbled to himself as he began to tidy up the small desk he had claimed as his own. Surely there was something in the kitchen he could sneak before he went off to bed.

(He spared a small second of regret that Thorin had apparently never come to talk with him himself, but only a second before he was sneering at how outlandish the idea was and promptly putting it out of his mind.)

Bilbo left the library and walked towards where he believed the kitchens might be. Hobbits were always very good at finding food, wherever it may be. As he wandered, he began to marvel at the sight that was Rivendell in the dark.

Rivendell lost none of its beauty during the night, if possible, it only became more enchanting. Though the sun had set, Bilbo wouldn't say that it was dark, instead, Rivendell seemed to have an inner light that washed over the stones and allowed the shadows to deepen but never overwhelm. While it was quiet during the day, with elves silently moving through their routines and lack of conflict (save those inflicted by the Dwarves), the night was even stiller, almost free of inhabitants at all. Bilbo moved about as though he was the only one in the city, padding carefully, hoping that he wouldn’t accidentally stumble somewhere he shouldn’t be on his way to find the kitchen.

A pair of voices made him freeze. After a moment he recognized them as Lord Elrond and Gandalf, who seemed to be having a (heated) conversation. Bilbo knew that he probably should keep moving and not eavesdrop but he had always been a curious Hobbit (he wouldn’t be on this adventure if he wasn’t).  

“That dragon has slept for 60 years. What should happen if your plan should fail? If you wake the beast?” Elrond said briskly.

“But what if we succeed? If the Dwarves take back the mountain our defenses in the east will be strengthened,” Gandalf said.

“It is a dangerous move Gandalf.”  

Bilbo had a feeling deep in his bones that someone was near him but it was still a shock to turn and see Thorin looming right behind him, dark and imposing, the moonlight catching in his silver beads and his bright eyes. Bilbo felt his stomach drop and mouth go dry. He quickly turned back to the conversation happening below them.

“Have you forgotten?” Elrond almost spat out. “A strain of madness runs deep in that family. His grandfather lost his mind, his father succumbed to the same sickness. Can you swear Thorin Oakenshield will not also fall?”

The rest of the conversation faded out of Bilbo’s mind as the last lines repeated in his head. Madness? Sure Thorin was pig-headed and rude but he could never imagine him as… mad. The idea sat heavy in Bilbo’s stomach like a particularly rotten meal.

When he looked back Thorin was no longer the imposing force that he had seen before. Now he drooped, his shoulder hunched with the weight Bilbo suddenly realized he was carrying. His eyes were narrowed and pained and Bilbo had never seen someone look so lost. He wanted to reach out but he kept his hands carefully clenched by his sides. Slowly, Thorin looked up and met Bilbo’s eyes and his heart almost stopped.

Neither of them should have heard what they did but now that they had, there was no way they could ignore it, could they? Bilbo’s entire body tensed as Thorin opened his mouth slowly, as though was going to speak, but then he simply snapped it closed again, scowled, and turned away as he always did.

Bilbo’s lungs deflated and with it so did the rest of his body. Would Thorin ever talk to him? Did Thorin simply think he was not worth talking to? The idea made Bilbo grumble to himself as he turned and made his way to his room. He found that he was no longer hungry.

 

The lodgings that the Dwarves had claimed as their own was actually a small room that connected the many bedrooms that had been laid out for all thirteen of them. However, only one of the rooms was being used and that was by Bilbo. Because the Dwarves were ridiculous, they continued to have lookouts throughout the night, even though they were perfectly safe. The one keeping watch would sit outside Bilbo’s door not only because it allowed them to see everything, but also because they had the senseless worry Bilbo would sneak out and run away with the Elves in the middle of the night. It was only because the bed was so nice he didn’t make a bigger fuss, he simply sighed and allowed it to happen as long as it didn’t disturb him.

When he made it back to the room the company had settled down to sleep (thankfully) so he crept around them and made his way to his room. He briefly raised his hand to wave at Bifur who was on watch before scuttling into his room and letting out a sigh. He wanted to sleep and forget everything he knew and didn’t know about Thorin Oakenshield.

 

Bilbo startled awake at the sound of something hitting his door, not hard enough that it should have woken him but Bilbo had always been a light sleeper with very good hearing (and the trolls and wolves may have made him a bit paranoid).

“Master Baggins.”

It was Thorin. Bilbo sat up and threw the covers off him, rushing to get to the door. But just as he reached out to open it, Thorin spoke again.

“I would like to talk to you about-. I would like to talk with you.”

Oh, he was doing it again. That weird (sweet) thing where he talked to him as though he wasn’t supposed to be completely unconscious. Bilbo felt his lips twitch up into what must be a fond smile. He wondered what he would be hearing this time.

“First of all, you should stop making nice with the Elves.”

(Well, that was a horrible start)

“There is no reason for you to be so close to them. They are not trustworthy and they only wish to keep us from reaching the mountain. I know that you value your comfort above everything and they would steal you away with promises of food and shelter.”

(And he spent every moment regretting not taking up that offer, thank you for reminding him)

“You don’t understand these Elves.”

The way he spat that word was nothing new but it still sent a shiver running up Bilbo’s spine. So much loathing packed into a single word. He didn’t understand.

“They’re worth nothing more than dirt.”

There was a pause of silence but when he spoke again his voice was lowered and Bilbo had to lean forward to ensure he would hear every word.

“They came marching to us when the dragon came. We were still fighting, even though it was obvious the moment it came we couldn’t win, we still fought. It was worse than any battle I had been in or will ever be in. We attacked but what we confronted were no bodies nor anything we could kill. They were flames, hot and raging, from every angle they poured over us. Try as we might but swords pass through flames and do no harm. But for the flames it was different. All it took was a single spark and the mightiest of Dwarves would be engulfed by fire and burn until they were nothing more than a charred shell, blackened and smoldering. We had to leave our comrades scattered across the walkways for you couldn’t bury bones and ash. But that was not the worse part. No, the worse part was how the buildings crumbled, how we tried to evacuate, how entire parts of the city toppled over families, how mangled parts of children could still be seen through the cracks, how no matter how hard you tried you were always too late.”

Bilbo put a hand over his mouth and resisted the urge to choke. He could picture the flames, smell the smoke, envision the way the blood ran down the broken roads. He imagined Thorin standing there in the middle of it. Soot stained and watching his kingdom crumble. He imagined it happening to the Shire and had to push bile back down his throat.

“And then the Elves came marching. Our allies had pulled through. We looked up and saw them and the hate we held for them no longer mattered because for the first time we had a breath of hope. Thranduil, we knew, had battled dragons before and there was a small chance we were going to win this battle in the end.”

Thorin suddenly paused. The silence was loaded. Bilbo longed to break it, urge him on or offer comfort, but there was no way that he could. Thorin didn’t even know that he was listening and he would never actually have this conversation with him, no matter how much he wished he would. He needed for Thorin to continue, he needed to understand.

“They turned around.”

The words were so quiet. Bilbo wished Thorin had spit them out in anger. Had roared them like he did when he was faced with orcs. Even scoffed them as though they meant nothing to him. Anything was better than the soft whisper of someone who had suffered more than anyone should have to.   

“It was only a month later when we had given up fighting and were making our way through Middle Earth, homeless and mourning, did I realize he hadn’t even been wearing his armor when we saw him. He hadn’t marched to fight with us. He had marched to watch us die.”

Bilbo reached out and pressed his hands against the door. He imagined that Thorin was leaning against the other side and maybe, just maybe he would feel the comfort through the thin wood. It was all Bilbo could do and it was not enough.

“A dragon was the one that stole my home but it was Elves that kept me from getting it back. I will not have that happen again.”

Thorin stopped speaking and Bilbo thought that this time their conversation (if it could be called that) was done but Bilbo didn’t move. He kept his hands firmly pressed against the door as though it would do anything.

Then Thorin began to speak again.

“Erebor was amazing. More beautiful than anything I’ve ever seen or anything I will ever see. But more than that, it was my home. Where I was raised, where my father was raised. Ered Luin is nice, I was able to make a safe and comfortable place for my family and people to live. But it isn’t home. It will never be home.

“It was always meant to be mine, Erebor. I was trained to be King and I spent so much of my time planning how I could make it better. How I could improve the lives of my people, how I could make Erebor even more grand and plentiful than it already was. And my life, my home was ripped away by gold sickness and dragons.

“I will not be like my grandfather. They doubt me and think I am weak and that I will fall as he did. But I know better. I care not for gold. We had plenty of it in Ered Luin. I care not for all the treasures in the vaults of Erebor, only for the kingdom itself. That is my home. I need to get it back.   

Then Thorin cleared his throat, the sound shattering the atmosphere.  

“Master Hobbit, stop being alone with the Elves they are untrustworthy. It would make the company more at ease,” he spoke in the harsh way he always did, all sense of vulnerability and softness that had been there moments ago locked back up and hidden.  

It was then Bilbo knew that the conversation was over. He slowly removed his hands from the door and shuffled over to the bed. He sat down, stood back up, paced, and sat down once again and allowed his mind to digest all that he had heard.

 

He had wanted to understand Thorin and now he believed that in some ways he did. Thorin, at the end of the day, was just like him. He missed his home.

The thought that they had something in common made Bilbo smile and his stomach do a little flip as he buried himself in his pillow. Home. All this time Bilbo spent wondering about Thorin and what made him the way he did and it all boiled down to a single thing, a thing even Bilbo himself could relate too. It wasn’t bravery, or stupidity, or delusions of grandeur that drove him (though they did seem to play a role), it was homesickness. The simple longing for a place to belong that Bilbo himself felt stirring in his heart every time he thought of Bag End.   

For the first time, Thorin was something more than a rude aggressor or a (grudgingly) respected leader. He was someone Bilbo had a connection to, someone he understood. As Bilbo drifted off to sleep felt an overwhelming need he had never had before: to get Thorin’s home back to him. He knew that he would do anything he was asked to accomplish this, as improbable and impossible as it all seemed.   

Anything, except perhaps, stop being friends with Elves.

 

Notes:

This is one became rather long on accident but the next two will be short interludes before Thorin starts being embarrassing again.