Chapter Text
The sea was endless.
For miles, in every direction, it was all that Franklin May could see. It seemed as if the blue expanse of the ocean stretched on forever, into infinite. Like he could just sail for the rest of his life, and never see any land.
May smiled, taking in a deep breath of salt-filled air. This is what he loved best about sailing—the days when the sky was clear and the ocean never ended.
Behind him, a group of men broke out into loud, raucous laughter. It was sweltering hot outside, even with the cooling ocean breeze, and May had been forced to abandon his usual jacket. Typically this weather made the men irritable and lethargic, but they were in high spirits that day. The prize they had been chasing for weeks was finally within their grasp, and growing closer every hour. The sooner they captured the prize, the sooner they could return to Nassau, and the sooner the men could spend their earnings on drink and women.
“What are you bastards doing?” a loud voice asked, and May turned to see Roberts, the quartermaster, looking down at the laughing group of men. He had a grin on his own face as well, though he was trying unsuccessfully to school into a more serious expression. “Get back to work, you lazy pieces of shit.”
The men grumbled quietly before standing and wandering off. Roberts watched them go, before turning to May, the smirk quickly returning to his face. “It’s impossible to find good, hard-working crew, isn’t it, Captain?” he asked, walking over and leaning against the railing beside May. “All they do is laze around, drinking and speaking of their various dalliances with Nassau’s finest whores.”
“There are some very fine whores in Nassau, though,” May pointed out, and Roberts let out a barking laugh.
“If you have the coin, there are,” he agreed. “Otherwise you can never know what you’ll end up with.”
“Had some bad experiences, have you, Roberts?”
The quartermaster gave another chuckle, shaking his head. “More than you’d care to know.”
“I don’t doubt that,” May admitted. Looking up, he watched a single cloud drift slowly across the sky as men climbed the rigging and adjusted the sails. He turned back towards Roberts, who was watching the sea with a distant look on his face. “Have you spoken to Quigley recently?” he asked.
“Aye, not too long ago,” Roberts answered, his gaze remaining focused on the dark waters below them. “Why?”
“Did he say where we are?” May asked. “I’d like to know.”
Roberts shrugged. “He might’ve, but I can’t remember. I never listen to most of what that man has to say.”
May scoffed, shaking his head. There was a pause, and his expression turned serious. “Do you suppose we’ll find this merchant ship?” he asked.
Roberts let out a loud sigh, shrugging. “She could be days ahead of us, or days behind,” he said. “But if she’s stayed true to the schedule we received, it’s likely we’ll be seeing her shortly. She was heading for Spanish Town, and this is the route most British merchants take to Jamaica.”
May said nothing for a moment, his gaze scanning the bare horizon that stretched on for miles in front of them. “We left Nassau nearly two weeks ago,” he said. “The information that we received about the Princess Martha was found on a ship captured over a week before. It could have been horribly inaccurate, or the Princess Martha could have changed courses since then. Unlikely, but entirely possible.”
“We’ll find her,” Roberts said with absolute conviction. “Don’t worry about that.”
“We had better find her,” May said. “She’s full of commodities from England that will sell for a large sum of money.”
“High-quality textiles from what I saw. Most likely for the wives of wealthy plantation owners.”
“Then let us hope we rob them of their fancy dresses.”
Roberts laughed, clapping a hand on May’s shoulder. “We shall,” he promised. “Or else we will have a crew of unhappy men on our hands, and no one wants that.”
May let out a loud sigh, facing the sea once more as Roberts turned to take his leave. His gaze remained focused on the horizon, which seemed to stretch on until the ends of the Earth and then into eternity itself.
◊◊◊
The hold was dark and full of supplies, and James Gibson cursed loudly as he tripped over a crate for the third time in a row. The lamp in his hands swung violently as he straightened and kicked the crate, calling it a whole slew of swears.
“You alright?” came a quiet voice from behind him, and he turned to see his apprentice, a young boy named Henry Browning, standing a few feet back. He had a bag of supplies slung over his shoulder, and another lamp clenched in his hand.
James grumbled an annoyed “yes”, and Henry shuffled forward, carefully stepping over the barrels and sacks littered around the hold.
“Do you know where the leak is?” the boy asked, and James scowled.
“I was told it’s on the starboard side,” he said, motioning towards the wall he was facing. “Near the stern.” He shrugged. “Matthew wasn’t very descriptive when he told me where he found it.”
“How will we find it then?”
“We’ll look for the spot where the water is coming in,” James explained. “It won’t be a huge gaping hole, but it shouldn’t be too hard. Matthew said it seemed to be coming from between two boards, and it was only a slow trickle of water. Oakum will fix it up just fine.”
Henry nodded, quickly following James as he climbed over the supplies and goods packed around them. It had been over fifty days since they had left England, bound for the colonies in the British West Indies. Just yesterday, the Bahamas were spotted for the first time on the horizon, and they had continued towards them until earlier today, when they had turned south to pass between Eleuthera and Cat Island. It would be another week before they reached Spanish Town, where the majority of their wares from England would be unloaded and sold.
James, as the ship’s carpenter, had only had to make a few repairs since leaving port in England. There had, of course, been problems, as there were on any cross-Atlantic voyage, but those that did arise were minor and easily fixed.
He turned to Henry. “Do you have all the tools?”
Henry glanced at his bag and nodded. “Yes, sir,” he said. “Which will we be needing?”
“We won’t know that until we find the leak,” James said, stepping over a half-empty sack and quickly steadying himself as the ship lurched, nearly sending him off balance. He quickly moved aside the crates and barrels lined up against the wall and bent over, holding the lamp in front of his face as he scanned the side of the hull. A rat squealed and scurried away, disappearing into the maze of supplies. Behind him, Henry made a quiet noise of disgust.
“This is your first voyage on a ship, Henry, is it not?” James asked.
“Um, yes, sir,” Henry said, fidgeting with his lamp.
“You had better get used to rats, then, if you plan on making more.”
“Oh, I’m used to rats,” Henry explained. “Our house is full of them. But I don’t like them. One bit me once when I was eight.”
James chuckled despite himself. “Just get over here and help me look for this leak.”
“Yes, sir.”
They found it in less than ten minutes. Like James had predicted, it was close to the floor and the water was slowly seeping out from between two boards. The area around it was damp, with a constant stream of seawater trickling into the ship.
“Here we are, nothing major,” James said, crouching down and setting his lamp beside him. “This will be fixed in no time. Hand me some oakum, will you, Henry?”
Henry nodded and, placing his lamp on a nearby crate, dug through his bag until he pulled out a long strand of the tarred fibre. He handed it to James, who unraveled it and placed it over the crack between the leaky boards.
“The wedges and hammer, please.”
Henry dug them out and handed them to James. Within a few minutes, the oakum fibres were jammed into the thin space between the boards and the water had stopped. James pulled out the knife hanging from his belt and cut off the extra fibre, giving it back to Henry, along with the wedges and hammer, which he returned to the bag.
“And that is how you seal a leak between two boards,” James said, standing with a huff and picking his lamp back up.
“Do we have to do anything else?”
James shook his head. “No, we’re done for now,” he said, clapping a hand on the boy’s shoulder as he walked past him. “Now let’s get back up to the main deck. It smells like shit down here.”
“Probably the rats,” Henry suggested.
◊◊◊
May was woken at just past dawn by a loud knocking on his door.
“Captain!” the voice on the other side said, and the door opened to reveal Moses Radley, the boatswain. “Sails have been spotted on the horizon!”
May sat up quickly, running a hand over his face. “Is it the Princess Martha?” he asked, his voice groggy from sleep.
“Yes, sir,” Moses replied, obviously excited himself. “Quigley says we’ll reach her before noon.”
May nodded, and Moses quickly turned and left, closing the door behind him. May got dressed in under five minutes, grabbing a telescope from where it sat on his desk before hurrying to the door. Though it was early in the morning and he was exhausted, he wasted no time as he leapt up the stairs to the main deck, where much of the crew was gathered.
Roberts was already there, and he greeted May with a giddy, excited smile. “There she is, Captain,” he said, motioning towards the north, where a set of sails could just barely be seen on the horizon, little more than white dots against the lightening sky.
May extended his telescope and held it up to his eye, quickly focusing on the ship. It was, almost undoubtedly, the Princess Martha—the prize they had been chasing for the past fortnight.
“We need to sail as quickly as possible,” May said, lowering the telescope and closing it with a snap. “I want her to be captured by noon.”
Roberts nodded. “Aye, Captain.”
May turned to face the crew. “I want as many sails unfurled as is possible,” he yelled. “Make sure the cannons and other weapons are prepared, and that we are ready to board if necessary.”
The men quickly got to work, some heading down to the gun deck and others climbing up the rigging and tugging at ropes. May stood by the railing, leaning over it as he watched the distant ship slowly grow closer and larger. Spanish Town lay several days ahead of them, and so if they did not speed up enough they had no hope of catching the Princess Martha.
“Peter,” May said, addressing the sailor standing the closest to him. “Check our speed. I want to see if it’s possible for us to go faster.”
“Yes, Captain,” Peter said with a nod, hurrying off to fetch the necessary equipment.
May and Roberts remained silent as Peter completed his task, both of their gazes focused on the distant merchant ship which, with any luck, would soon be within their grasp.
“Four knots!” Peter cried from the other side of the deck.
Roberts turned to May. “That ship is approximately fourteen miles away,” he said. “If we stay at this speed, we can reach her by mid-morning. Unfortunately, the wind doesn’t always like to cooperate, which means it’s more likely we’ll reach each other by noon.”
May nodded, his lips curled into a slight frown. “We shall hope for the best,” he said. “One way or another, we will reach her.”
Roberts gave a small grin, leaning forward with his arms resting against the ship’s railing. They both stood silent, their hopes for the events to come slowly unfolding in their minds.
◊◊◊
James sat on the main deck, whittling away at a small piece of wood. He had brought several along with him, knowing that there would be long stretches of time with nothing for him to do. Voyages such as these could be long and incredibly boring, which meant that he often had lots of time with little to do—he usually spent it sleeping, whittling, or explaining how to fix the various parts of a ship to Henry, though that was difficult to do when nothing was broken.
He sighed, dragging his knife along the piece of wood and shaving off thin slices of it. He had started it about two hours ago, and it was just beginning to take on the shape of a small, rather crude fox. He usually carved animals—they were simple, and didn’t require particularly large sticks. Once or twice he had attempted to make a flute, but it hadn’t turned out very well. They never made much noise, and the noise they did make sounded horrible. Still, his daughter had loved them, and often played them as if they were real musical instruments.
James smiled at the thought of his daughter. She was seven, and would be eight by the time he saw her again. He missed her terribly every day he was at sea, during which she stayed with his sister and her husband in their London home. She was the reason he went on these long, hellish trips across the Atlantic—they paid well, and there was always work on merchant ships for skilled carpenters. Though he was away for several months at a time, the pay was so good that he only needed to go on one or two voyages per year. The rest of the year, he was able to stay with his daughter. Those were always the months he looked forward to, and the ones he cherished the most.
“What are you doing?”
James was pulled from his thoughts by Henry, collapsing down beside him to peer at the partially completed fox in his hands.
“Whittling,” James replied.
“Whittling what?”
James scowled at him. “You’re worse than a child.”
Henry frowned, but still leaned in to take a closer look at the carving. “Is it a dog?” he asked. “Or a bear?”
“It’s a fox,” James said, carefully shaping the pointed ears.
Recognition dawned on Henry’s face. “Oh,” he said. “It does kind of look like a fox.”
“It isn’t finished yet,” James said. “So of course it doesn’t look entirely like it’s supposed to.”
Henry nodded, then stood and leaned over the nearby railing. The wind whipped at his scruffy hair, and he squinted as salt water splashed in his face. “What do you s’pose that ship is?” he asked.
James looked at him, his brows furrowed. A ship had been spotted on the horizon several hours ago, at dawn, and had been slowly gaining on them all day. As it drew closer, they’d been able to determine that it was a frigate flying the Union Jack—most likely another merchant ship.
“What do you mean?” he asked, and Henry shrugged.
“Is it a Navy ship, or a merchant ship,” he explained, glancing down at James. “Or even a pirate ship.”
“A pirate ship?”
Henry nodded fervently. “Old Jack was saying that it could be a pirate ship flying false colours.”
James scoffed. “They’re not pirates.”
“How do you know? Even the captain seems nervous.”
“The captain is always nervous,” James argued. “And you shouldn’t listen to Old Jack. Everything he says is absolute nonsense.”
“But what if it is a pirate ship?”
“It isn’t,” James insisted. “You’re worrying yourself for no reason. It is simply another merchant ship, most likely heading to Spanish Town. Just like we are.”
Henry didn’t seem convinced, but said nothing else on the matter. He stood, silent, for a moment, before pushing away from the rail with a sigh and walking off, his hands shoved in his pockets. James watched him go, before shaking his head and going back to his whittling.
However, he found that he couldn’t concentrate, and after less than half an hour he stood, putting the knife away and storing the carving in one of his pockets. He glanced up at the sky, quickly determining that it would soon be noon.
He took in a deep breath of air and leaned over the railing, watching the ship trailing behind them. It had become significantly closer than when he had last looked, and if its speed kept up it would soon be passing them. The thought made him suddenly nervous—what reason did they have for going so fast? He leaned out further, attempting to see the flag flying from the other ship’s stern. It was still the Union Jack.
Glancing behind him, James scanned the expressions of his crewmates. Some seemed worried, while others obviously were not bothered by the quickly nearing ship. The captain was nowhere to be found.
He frowned, and quickly moved away from the railing, searching for something else to occupy himself with.
◊◊◊
May lowered his spyglass, closing it with a snap and returning it to the inside pocket of his jacket. Turning, he sought out Moses in the large crowd of men gathered on the main deck and found him standing near the helm of the ship.
“Moses!” he called, slowly making his way across the deck.
The boatswain looked up at the sound of his name. “Captain?”
“We’re nearly within firing range,” May pointed out, and Moses nodded. “I want us to be prepared to sail up alongside the Princess Martha, and I want all guns ready to fire as soon as I give the command.”
“Shall we raise the black?”
May thought for a moment, before nodding. “Yes,” he said. “As soon as it is raised, fire three warning shots. Aim to have them land just in front of her bow.”
“Yes, Captain,” Moses said, giving another nod. He turned to face the crew and, pointing at two nearby men, cried, “Oi! You two! Raise the black!”
He was met by a round of energetic cheers, and the men lifted their hands in the air and waved their weapons around. Roberts walked up to where May stood, leaning against the short wall behind him.
“Let us hope this merchant captain does not put up much of a fight,” he said, crossing his arms over his chest.
“I will not be surprised if he does,” May admitted. “He is carrying valuable cargo, and is not likely to give it up too easily.”
“Then we will have to take it from him by force.”
◊◊◊
James watched, his face paling, as the Union Jack was removed from the back of the ship and replaced by a flag as black as pitch, in the middle of which sat a stark white skull and an hourglass. Seconds after the flag was raised, three shots sailed over the top of the Princess Martha in quick succession, splashing into the water in front of her.
Pirates.
Around him, the other men erupted into frantic yelling. The captain appeared suddenly on deck, his expression both angered and terrified.
“Pirates, Captain,” one the boatswains said, and the captain glared at him.
“Yes, I can see that,” he snapped, an edge of fear in his voice. He turned to face the crew, watching him with anxious faces. “Prepare for battle,” he announced, and the men cried out in protest. James stood silent, his fists curled at his sides. The captain continued yelling, “I will not lose this cargo without a fight.”
“But Captain, this will be suicide!” the boatswain argued. “They have more men than us, and more weapons, too. We cannot hope to defeat them.”
The captain glared at him. “This is my most valuable shipment of cargo ever,” he said. “I am not going to lose it to pirates.”
“You are dooming us all!” someone cried. His voice was followed by dozens of others yelling in agreement.
“Then so be it!” the captain replied. “I am the captain. I make the decisions.” He paused for a moment, before adding, “This is a risk for us all.”
“But we do not have a choice!” another man yelled.
The captain stood silent for a moment, scowling as he scanned the crowd in front of him. “Prepare for battle,” he repeated.
James swallowed thickly, glancing at the ship behind them, now so close that he could see the people gathered on her deck. A man stood near the bow, watching them as his dark red coat whipped around him in the wind. James quickly looked away, sucking in a deep breath of air that tasted like blood.
They were doomed.
◊◊◊
“Fire!”
Another round of cannon shots exploded through the air, striking the masts and deck of the Princess Martha. All around May, men stood with pistols and cutlasses in hand, waiting eagerly for the moment to board. Gunfire rang out and a man fell, a small trickle of blood leaking from his forehead. May clenched his jaw and looked away.
Captain Edmonds of the Princess Martha was stubborn. No matter how many cannon balls splintered the wood of his ship and no matter how many of his men died, he refused to give in. In a way, May admired him for that. But mostly it frustrated him.
Most of Edmonds’ crew had managed to shield themselves from incoming shots and the shrapnel caused by the cannon balls’ impacts. Some had fallen, but not many—not enough.
May frowned, quickly surveying the damage done to the Princess Martha. She was very obviously incapacitated. Many of her sails and rigging were damaged, and her mizzenmast was nearly in pieces. She would not sail far, nor quickly, in that condition. In just a few more minutes, they would be close enough to board her.
He turned to face Roberts, standing beside him and barking orders at the men. “Are the ropes ready?” he asked
Roberts looked at him and nodded. “Aye, Captain,” he said. “There are men prepared to throw them at any moment. They simply await your order.”
“Good,” May said, before turning to address the men. “I want you all ready to board as soon as the ropes are thrown and we are securely attached to the Princess Martha. Waste no time in getting across."
The men nodded and, slowly, they grew closer to their prize. May waited for the perfect moment to board, carefully watching the ship and her crew. He could see the fear on their faces, but still their captain ordered them to fight on. He must know that this was a fight he could not win.
As soon as they were close enough, May gave the order and half a dozen ropes shot out, the metal hooks on their ends latching onto the railings of the Princess Martha. A second later, planks were laid across the gap between the two ships, connecting them.
“Remember,” May yelled as some of the men began running across the boards. Others jumped across to the merchant ship, grasping for nets that hung from her side. “Take what prisoners you can, but ensure that the captain is killed.”
The fighting began mere seconds later, the air quickly filling with the sounds of gunshots and screams. May pulled his cutlass and pistol from his belt as he made his way across one of the planks. Jumping down onto the deck of the Princess Martha, he raised the pistol, and fired.
◊◊◊
The deck was littered with dead bodies. All around him was the sound of gunshots and the metal of cutlasses clanging together. James took in a shaky breath, tasting the iron tang of blood on his tongue.
The captain’s head lay just a few feet away from him, his eyes rolled up into his skull.
James pressed his lips together, trying desperately to stop himself from shaking. He forced his expression to harden and focused his gaze on the torn sails, refusing to look at the carnage spread out in front of him.
His hands were bound behind his back by a length of coarse rope, and he could feel his wrists being rubbed raw each time he moved. He had been forced to kneel in row with his other captured crewmates, and a pirate prowled around them, a pistol clenched in his fist. The battle was nearly over now—the captain was dead, and most of the crew had either been taken prisoner or killed. They had lost.
James watched the tattered sails fluttering in the breeze, and wondered what would happen to him now. He would most likely be offered the choice to join the pirates’ crew, or he would be killed. Either way, he would never see his daughter again—once he joined their crew, the pirates would most likely be unwilling to allow him to leave and return to England.
His family would think him dead. They would grieve, and carry on with their lives. And as a pirate, he would die, much sooner than he would otherwise. Piracy was a short-lived career. There was little hope in it of ever returning home, to his daughter. But there would be no hope at all if he was dead.
Around him, the world suddenly grew quiet. The gunshots and screams stopped, and James lowered his gaze to see the pirates standing around, wiping the blood from their swords and their faces. So, it was done then. The battle—the slaughter—was over.
One pirate lifted his cutlass into the air and cheered. He was joined immediately by his comrades, and James closed his eyes, biting down on his cheek until he tasted blood.
The minutes passed, and the pirates wandered through the ship, laughing and talking loudly. They collected everything of value they could find and stacked it on the main deck to be carried over to their own ship. Once that was mostly done, one of the pirates walked over and stood in front of them, his arms crossed. He watched them for a moment, not saying anything, before moving to the beginning of the line and asking each man what his role on their ship had been.
There were eleven of them in total, and James’ heart lurched when he realized, quite suddenly, that Henry wasn’t among them. He hadn’t been captured, which meant he was most likely dead. James fought the urge to lash out at the pirate as he stopped in front of him, looking at him expectantly.
“And you?” he asked, his arms still crossed over his chest.
“I’m the carpenter,” James answered, and the pirate nodded, as if in approval, before moving on to the next man.
James watched him, full of rage. Henry hadn’t deserved to die, certainly not at the hands of pirates. He was only seventeen. James should have looked for him after the pirates began attacking, he should have found him and protected him. Henry had been his apprentice and his responsibility, and now he was dead.
James squeezed his eyes shut and let his head fall forward, ignoring the pain of his cut wrists and his knees against the hard wood of the deck.
◊◊◊
May sat at the desk in Edmonds’ quarters, digging through his papers and books. He tossed what was useless on the floor, but stacked anything of value on the desk in front of him. Edmonds had quite a few novels with him, and May was flipping through one by a man named Woodes Rogers when a knock sounded at the door.
“Yes?” he called, looking up only briefly as Roberts stepped into the room.
“Captain,” he said, nodding in greeting. “The hold has been emptied of its goods, and the men have already begun bringing them over to the Journey.”
“Has everything been recorded?” May asked, and Roberts snorted.
“You know you do not have to ask me that,” he said. “Every last bolt of fabric has been recorded and accounted for, and I know precisely where it will be stored aboard our ship.”
May smiled, nodding. There was a reason Roberts was quartermaster.
“And what of the prisoners?” he asked.
“There are eleven in total, all sound, able-bodied men.”
May finally looked up from the book, frowning. “We cannot take on eleven more men,” he said. “We do not have the space, nor the resources, even with those that we gained today.”
Roberts nodded solemnly. “I know,” he said. “There is a cook among them, as well as a carpenter. The rest are ordinary sailors.”
May nodded, rubbing the pages of the book between his fingers as he thought. “No surgeon?”
Roberts shook his head.
“We shall take the carpenter and the cook, then,” May decided.
“Aye, Captain.”
Neither of them said what would be done with the remaining prisoners, though they were both thinking of it.
◊◊◊
James stared down at Henry’s bloodied face, the lump in his throat growing larger and larger with each passing minute. The young boy’s eyes were still opened, staring blindly at the hot mid-afternoon sun, and so James knelt down, closing them gently. He stood back up and wrapped his arms around himself, cold despite the blistering heat. There were two bright red rings on his wrists, like bloody bracelets, and he felt as if he was wearing shackles.
“You’ll get used to it,” someone behind him said, their hand on his shoulder, as if it was any comfort. James turned to see Moses, the boatswain, and nodded dumbly, unsure of what to say.
They stood, silent, for a moment, before Moses’ face brightened. “Ah, there’s Roberts, the quartermaster,” he said, pointing in the direction of a dark-haired man who was yelling orders at the men carrying the cargo across to the pirates’ ship. “He’ll want to meet you.”
James nodded again, and followed as Moses lead him across the deck to where the quartermaster stood.
“Roberts.”
The man straightened at the sound of his name, smiling when he saw James. He looked more like a friendly innkeeper than a pirate.
“This is James Gibson, the new carpenter,” Moses introduced.
James took Roberts’ offered hand, trying to push all thoughts of Henry and his other dead crewmates from his mind.
“Valentine Roberts,” the other man said. “Quartermaster of this fine crew.”
“Have you met the cook?” Moses asked, and Roberts nodded.
“Aye, he seems like a good man,” he said. “I believe we shall all be safe in his hands.” He turned to James, his smile surprisingly warm. “I know you’re probably very shocked right now, but you’ll get used to this life soon enough. I promise you that.”
James nodded, still unsure of what to say.
“Now, come,” Roberts said, either not noticing or ignoring James’ obvious discomfort and placing a strong hand on his shoulder. “I shall take you to meet our captain.”
James nodded, and followed Roberts as he was once again lead across the deck through the large crowd of men. He made a point not to look at the bodies carelessly stacked together, as if they were nothing.
Roberts’ voice pulled his attention away. “There he is,” he said, motioning to a man standing nearby, watching as the cargo was carried across the planks to the other ship. “Captain!”
The man looked over at the sound of Roberts’ cry, looking first at the quartermaster and then to James. His face fell as their eyes met, and Thorin felt his mouth go dry. He stumbled back a few steps, but quickly steadied himself, never once taking his eyes off Bilbo, who now stood frozen with a horrified expression on his face.
Thorin glanced at Roberts, and found Bofur looking back at him, oblivious to what was happening. He grabbed Thorin by the elbow and lead him towards Bilbo, who Thorin could tell was desperately trying to school his features into neutrality.
“Captain, this is our new carpenter, James Gibson,” Bofur introduced, motioning to Thorin. “And this”—he motioned to Bilbo—“is Captain Franklin May.”
Thorin bowed his head slightly, his teeth pressing together so hard that they hurt. “Captain.”
“Welcome aboard, Mr. Gibson,” Bilbo said, his voice revealing none of the emotion Thorin could see swimming just below the surface.
They stared at each other for a moment, neither saying a word, until Bilbo nodded and promptly turned on his heel and walked away. Thorin watched him until he disappeared below decks.
“He’s a bit odd,” Bofur said, and Thorin nodded, having nothing else to say.
◊◊◊
Bilbo felt like he was suffocating. Every breath of air he sucked in failed to fill his lungs, and he braced his hand against the wall to keep himself from collapsing to his knees. It was like he was drowning, and each breath was causing him to sink deeper and deeper down, until his feet touched the sandy bottom.
The lower decks were empty, having already been picked clean of anything valuable or useful. Bilbo stood there, one hand pressed against the wall and his head bent, sucking in big gulps of air until his breathing calmed. Even after, he didn’t move, his eyes squeezed shut as thoughts raced through his mind.
Thorin was here. He was alive, and with him he had brought all the memories of these lives that Bilbo could never have even imagined before—these lives where he seemed like an entirely different person, like someone he wasn’t, and couldn’t be, anymore.
He let out a loud sigh, running a hand over his face. Up above, he could hear Roberts—Bofur, a voice whispered in the back of his head—yelling orders to the men. Soon, all the cargo would be transferred over to the Journey and the Princess Martha would be sunk, along with the bodies of her dead crew.
Bilbo pushed himself from the wall. He wondered, briefly, what he would say to Thorin—what he could possibly ever say to him now. Bilbo had, no doubt, just destroyed his life. Few wished to become a pirate, and certainly not those who had a job on the ship of a wealthy merchant. For years Bilbo was able to remove himself from the things he had done and the things he would do. He never dwelt too long on them, because he knew if he allowed himself to feel even the smallest amount of guilt it would overwhelm and destroy him.
He took in a deep breath and turned towards the stairs that led back up to the main deck. He climbed them slowly, and when he surfaced he immediately sought out Thorin, his eyes scanning through the crowd for his familiar dark hair and tall figure.
“Are you alright, Captain?”
Bilbo jumped at Bofur’s voice, the quartermaster suddenly beside him. His heart lurched as he turned to face him and saw Bofur for the first time in decades. He looked different, lacking the hat, braids, and facial hair, yet at the same time he looked the same. He looked like Roberts, whom Bilbo had known for years, but also like Bofur. It was odd to look at him and see how the two mixed, a combination of lifetimes.
“I’m fine,” Bilbo answered, his response coming after several seconds of silence.
“Are you sure?” Bofur asked, and Bilbo nodded.
“Yes. Perfectly fine.”
It was obvious that Bofur didn’t believe him, but he said nothing else on the matter. “Alright,” he said, giving a curt nod. “If you’ll excuse me, then, I have to go ensure that those buffoons didn’t miss anything when they searched the ship.”
Bilbo nodded, and Bofur walked away with a short wave over his shoulder. He stood where he was for a moment, at a loss for what to do, until he finally spotted Thorin near the pile of cargo. He seemed to be waiting for the others to carry their loads across to the Journey. Bilbo waited until he had picked up the crate at his feet and was heading for one of the planks to move towards him.
Thorin noticed him immediately and paused, watching him approach with an intense expression. Bilbo, however, only stopped for the briefest of moments as he brushed past Thorin, just long enough to whisper, “Meet me in my quarters, when you are done here.”
He didn’t wait for Thorin to reply, instead continuing on to one of the empty planks. The deck of the Journey was a hive of activity, and he quickly wove his way through the crowd of men, disappearing into his office.
◊◊◊
It was nearing sundown when the long-awaited knock sounded at his door. Bilbo’s head shot up at the sound, and he quickly stood, straightening his ruffled jacket.
“Come in,” he said.
The door creaked open, and Thorin stepped into the room. He stood there for several moments, unmoving, and Bilbo could feel his heart speeding up with each passing second.
“Close the door,” he said, after what felt like eons. Stepping out in front of the desk, he motioned to a nearby chair. “Sit, if you’d like.”
Thorin nodded and stepped further into the room, sliding the door closed behind him. Bilbo watched him, trying to think of something—anything—he could say. He had told him to come here, but he hadn’t thought of what to say when he showed up. There was nothing, really, that he could say. He was a criminal—a thief and a murderer. He wasn’t the person Thorin knew him as, and he hadn’t been for a long while.
“Bilbo.” Thorin broke the silence, his voice quiet and full of pain. He took a few steps forward and then stopped, his gaze focused on Bilbo.
“I’m sorry,” Bilbo whispered, just loud enough for Thorin to hear. They stared at each other, Thorin’s eyes full of confusion and sadness. Bilbo hated that he was the cause of it.
“What will happen now?” Thorin asked. He had always been so sure of everything, but now there was uncertainty in his voice. He had no power here. There was nothing he could do, and Bilbo could tell that he hated it.
There were several seconds of silence. “We head for Nassau,” Bilbo said, taking in a deep breath. “Until then you’ll... you will act as a member of this crew. We will decide on what to do next when we reach New Providence.”
Thorin nodded, but didn’t say anything. An unasked question hung in the air—Bilbo could see it written all over Thorin’s face.
What happened to you?
Bilbo frowned. I don’t know.
He sighed, returning to the bench that sat behind his desk and lowering himself onto the springy, worn cushions. “Please,” he said, once again motioning to the chair in front of him. “Sit.”
Thorin complied, settling into the hard wooden chair without a word. The silence that hung in the air was nearly palpable.
“Why did you apologize?” he asked, after several seconds had passed.
Bilbo’s frown deepened. “I feel guilty,” he explained. “And I... I do not know what to do about it.”
Thorin was silent for a moment. “This does not seem like something you would do,” he said. “Piracy. You always were so adamant that you were not even a burglar, and now you are the captain of a band of criminals.”
“I am not Bilbo Baggins anymore,” Bilbo said, his expression hard. “I did not grow up in the peace and gentleness of the Shire. I can no longer be that Hobbit from Bag End, just as I can no longer be Benjamin MacDonell or Jakob Nielsen. And just as you are not Thorin Oakenshield or Toma Izbaşa or the son of some Danish lord.”
“But you are still Bilbo Baggins, in many ways,” Thorin said, picking up a nearby a book and flipping open its cover. “You may no longer be a Hobbit of the Shire, but Mr. Baggins is still a part of who you are.” He paused, closing the book and setting it back down on the desk. “You have always been a great lover of books.”
His words were full of affection, and Bilbo stared at him, his forehead creased slightly. “You will always be Bilbo Baggins to me,” Thorin said, his voice soft and quiet. There was another moment of silence before he spoke again, “How did you end up here, Bilbo? What happened for you to become a pirate?”
“I had few other choices,” Bilbo explained, his gaze still focused on Thorin. “I did not join this crew willingly—it was forced upon me, much like it has been forced upon you. And I stayed because I thought this life would offer me freedom and opportunity. There was nothing and no one for me to return to.”
“You have no family?”
“My father died when I was young,” Bilbo said. “And my mother had been dead for two years when I joined this crew. I have aunts and uncles and plenty of cousins, but no one close. Not in this life.” He noticed the sadness in his voice only after he had spoken, and awkwardly readjusted his hands in front of him. “What of your family?” he asked, hoping to draw the topic away from himself. “What has become of them in this life?”
Thorin looked as if he wanted to ask more, but held back. “My mother died several years ago,” he replied, leaning forward and pressing the tips of his fingers together. “My father, however, is still alive, as are Dís and Frerin.”
“And Fíli and Kíli?”
Thorin nodded, a small smile on his lips. “Alexander and John,” he said. “They’re ten and fourteen, and as troublesome as always.”
A pause. “And are you married?”
Thorin looked at Bilbo, who was staring intently at his dirt-covered hands, his teeth clenched together. “No,” Thorin said, shaking his head. “Lucy died the same year as my mother. There was a measles outbreak.” He paused, running his teeth over his dry lips.
“But I have a daughter,” he said, and Bilbo’s head shot up, his eyes going wide.
“A daughter?” His voice was quiet, barely audible. “How old?”
“She shall be eight soon,” Thorin answered. “Her name is Elinor.”
Bilbo stared at him for a moment, before leaning forward, his hands in his hair. “Fuck.”
Thorin’s eyebrows furrowed together. “What’s wrong? What—”
“Quite a lot is wrong, Thorin,” Bilbo interrupted, standing abruptly and causing the desk to shake violently. “Quite a fucking lot.”
“Because I have a daughter?”
“That... that’s not the only thing,” Bilbo said, walking over to a cupboard in the corner of the room and pulling out a bottle of dark liquid. Rum, most likely.
“But it’s part of the problem.”
“It’s not your daughter,” Bilbo said, his voice growing quiet again. “It’s... it’s me. I’m the problem.” He pulled the lid off the bottle, tossing it onto the table, before taking a long drink from it.
Thorin stood, leaning cross the desk to wrap his hands around Bilbo’s and pull the bottle away from his lips. “What do you mean?” he whispered, their faces inches apart. “Why are you the problem?”
Bilbo hesitated for a moment before answering. “I love you too much,” he replied, the words barely leaving his mouth. “I cannot bear to let you go, but I know I cannot keep you.”
“You will always have me,” Thorin said, gently taking the bottle from Bilbo and setting it down on the desk. “I will always be yours.”
Bilbo shook his head. “That isn’t true,” he insisted. “You have your daughter, and she needs you. Much more than I do. I know now that I cannot keep you here, no matter how much I want to.”
“Come with me,” Thorin said, his voice pleading. “Return with me to England.”
Bilbo scoffed, sitting back down on the bench. Thorin remained standing. “I cannot ever return to England,” Bilbo said. “The minute I set foot on any British colony I will be arrested, let alone if I were to return to England itself. That would be suicide.”
“There must be something,” Thorin argued. “We cannot simply accept our fate as it is.”
“Yet that is what we must do. There is never anything that can be done, in any lifetime, and there never will be. We can accept the goddamn reality of our lives and live with it, but that is it.” He paused, taking in a deep breath of air and exhaling it through his nose. “That’s all.”
There was a moment of long, drawn-out silence. Neither of them said a word, but Thorin’s gaze remained glued to Bilbo, his jaw clenched.
“What the hell has happened to you?” he asked after several minutes had passed. “You don’t even want to try. You’re too scared about what might happen to you.”
“Oh, don’t be such a fucking idiot, Thorin,” Bilbo snapped. “For God’s sake. I don’t give a shit what happens to me. I’m doing this so you survive. Do you not remember what’s happened in the past? Shortly after we meet again, one of us ends up dead. We didn’t even last two days the last time, so I’m trying to do everything in my power to ensure that you’re the one to survive. And to do that you need to go back to England as soon as possible, without me.”
Thorin was silent for a long while. When he didn’t respond, Bilbo continued, “I’ve spent the past three hours trying to come up with an idea on how to save you, and everything I’ve thought of includes you getting as far away from me as is possible.”
“I don’t want to leave you,” Thorin whispered, stepping around the desk and moving closer to Bilbo.
“You have to,” Bilbo insisted, grabbing Thorin’s hands and holding them in his own. He stared at them, as if trying to commit every last detail to memory—every callous and scar that wasn’t there before, that showed a lifetime of carpentry and work. “If you want to see your daughter again, you need to leave.” He paused for a moment. “When we reach Nassau, I’ll be able to get you safe passage to Port Royal. You’ll be able to leave within the week. You will have no trouble finding a ship there willing to take you to England. There are always crews in need of skilled carpenters.”
Thorin took in a deep breath, closing his eyes and wrapping his fingers around Bilbo’s. “When do we arrive in Nassau?”
“A fortnight,” Bilbo answered. “A week and a half, at most, if we are able to move quickly.”
There was more silence, followed by Thorin’s voice, desperate and pleading, “This cannot be the only way.”
“I can’t leave my crew. And if I did, I would only put you in even more danger. I’m a criminal, Thorin. The British do not take kindly to pirates—I am a dead man if they apprehend me, and so are you.”
“One of us is going to die, no matter what happens,” Thorin pointed out.
“And I would rather it be me than you.” Bilbo stood, his hands still tangled together with Thorin’s. “I have nothing waiting for me at the end of this life but a noose around my neck. No one would care if I died.”
“I would.”
Bilbo looked at him. “This is what needs to happen,” he said. “Your daughter... Elinor is waiting for you.”
“Why do you carry on with this life?” Thorin asked. “Why do you not give it up?”
Bilbo gave a sad, quiet laugh. “I’m in much too deep to give it up now,” he said. “The most I can do is repent when my time comes and hope that God forgives me.”
There was a pause. Thorin freed his hands from Bilbo’s grip and wrapped his arms around his shoulders, pulling him close. “I don’t want to lose you,” he whispered. “Not after I’ve just found you again.”
“I’m sorry,” Bilbo replied, struggling to get the words out of his mouth. “I don’t want to leave you, but I have to. I must let you go.” He took in a deep, shaky breath. “I’m so sorry.”
Thorin left soon after that. Bilbo remained in his quarters for the rest of the evening, even as the Princess Martha was sunk and they sailed from her burning wreckage.
◊◊◊
Two Weeks Later
Thorin had heard stories of Nassau. Most had been told to him by former crewmates on various merchant vessels. He wasn’t sure how they had heard them, or from whom, but from what he had seen of the city they seemed to be true, for the most part. He had been in Nassau for less than twelve hours, and already he had seen half a dozen brothels, several fist fights, and an innumerable number of men passed out, drunk, on the streets.
There seemed to be few rules, despite what Thorin had been told by the crew of the Journey. The majority of the men operated under the pirate code of their own captain. It was unlike any city he had ever been in before.
He sighed, turning a corner onto one of the busier streets. He had been trying to make his way back to the beach, where they had set up camp, for nearly half an hour, to no avail. Nassau was a maze of warehouses, taverns, and houses of ill repute, and he seemed to getting more lost by the minute. The chaos of the streets did not help, and he didn’t trust anyone enough to ask for aid.
He stopped on the side of the street, near the entrance to a bar. He stood there for several moments, trying to figure out where in the city he was, when a hand on his shoulder made him jump. He spun to see Bilbo behind him, a relieved expression on his face.
“Jesus Christ!” he swore, and Bilbo gave an apologetic half-smile.
“Sorry,” he muttered, slipping his hand off Thorin’s shoulder. He cocked his head in the direction he had just come from. “Follow me.”
Thorin furrowed his brows in confusion, but made no argument. He followed Bilbo as he silently led them through the streets of Nassau, with obvious knowledge of exactly where they were going. They came out near the beach, and walked across the sand to where the crew of the Journey had made their camp. Bilbo stopped in front of a large tent, beside which stood a pole flying his flag—the black, with a white skull and hourglass. Thorin still shuddered at the sight of it, though he had seen it every day for the past fortnight.
Bilbo pulled aside the tent’s flap, motioning for Thorin to duck inside and quickly following after him. The room was dimly lit, with a single candle illuminating only a corner of it. Bilbo grabbed it and used it to light the other candles lying around, brightening the room immensely, though there was not much to see. A mattress lay on the floor, covered in a few blankets and pillows, and a desk and chair sat on the other side of the room. There were papers and books spread all across the surface of the desk, as if Bilbo had been living here for weeks instead of hours. A chest shoved into the corner was the only other object of note.
“Would you like a drink?” Bilbo asked, wandering over to the desk, where a dark bottle sat.
Thorin nodded, and Bilbo smiled. He uncorked the bottle and poured its contents into two glasses, one of which he handed to Thorin. He took it gratefully, throwing back most of the liquid in one gulp. As he lowered the glass, he noticed Bilbo watching him, a now sad expression on his face.
“I have managed to secure you a position on a ship heading for Port Royal,” he said, after Thorin shot him a questioning look. “The captain wishes to meet you tomorrow, in the morning. You leave in four days.”
“Only four days?” Thorin asked, his expression incredulous.
Bilbo nodded, solemn. “It was the best I could do,” he explained. “There are few crews here who sail to Port Royal, and those that do are often of a... better repute than most. As such, they are unwilling to deal with pirates any more than is absolutely necessary. The only reason this captain agreed is because he knows and trusts me.”
“But I am no pirate,” Thorin said, frowning.
“Unfortunately, you are,” Bilbo said. “At the moment, you are working and sailing under my banner, which makes you a pirate in the eyes of nearly everyone on this Earth.” He paused, taking a long swig of his drink. “But not for much longer. The moment you sail away from this godforsaken island, you desert my crew and cease being a pirate.”
Thorin let out a loud sigh, staring at the dark liquid swirling in his glass. The notion of leaving this crew was both relieving and devastating. “How will you explain my... sudden disappearance to your men?” he asked.
“I will tell them you ran off,” Bilbo said with a shrug. “Desertion is not at all unheard of. They will, of course, be unhappy about it. Good carpenters are not easy to come by, but there is little they will be able to do.”
Thorin set his glass down. “I’m sorry,” he whispered, frowning.
“Do not be,” Bilbo argued, placing his own glass on the desk. He moved towards Thorin, taking his hands in his own. “There isn’t any reason for you to apologize. This life is hell—it isn’t one you want to have, and I’m glad you will not be joining it. You deserve better.”
There was a pause. “So do you.”
Bilbo laughed quietly, rubbing his thumb along Thorin’s knuckles. “No, I don’t,” he argued. “I... I really don’t.”
Thorin’s brows furrowed together. “You’re not a bad person, Bilbo,” he said, his voice quiet.
“I wish I could believe you.”
“You should.” Thorin lifted a hand, brushing strands of hair from Bilbo’s eyes. “No matter what you say or think, you are still that Hobbit from Bag End who insisted that he was not a burglar and whined about a forgotten handkerchief.”
“I’m much more than a burglar now, aren’t I?”
“But simply because you do bad things, you are not a bad person,” Thorin insisted.
“There are quite a few people who would disagree with you,” Bilbo pointed out, a small smile curling the corners of his lips. “Most notably the British government, as well as the entire Royal Navy.”
“Then fuck them,” Thorin muttered, leaning forward and pressing his lips to Bilbo’s.
Bilbo reacted immediately, his hands moving to Thorin’s neck and up into his hair. Thorin smiled into the kiss, pulling Bilbo closer until there was virtually no space between them.
“I love you,” Bilbo whispered, their lips only millimetres apart. Thorin’s smile grew, and he let out a quiet laugh.
“I love you, too,” he responded. “No matter these lifetimes throw at us.”
Bilbo laughed, and kissed him again, until it felt as if they were going to drown in each other.
◊◊◊
4 Days Later
The sun had not yet risen when Bilbo was shaken awake. He cracked his eyes open, bleary from sleep, to see Thorin hovering above him. He was already dressed, though dark circles hung under his hairs and his hair was tousled.
“Wake up,” he said, shaking Bilbo again.
“What time is it?” Bilbo asked with a moan, rubbing his eyes in an attempt to wake himself further.
“Before dawn,” Thorin answered with a glance towards the tent’s flap, which had been pushed aside to reveal the quiet world outside. “Most likely around 4 o’clock in the morning.”
Bilbo sighed, running a hand over his face. “You’re leaving in an hour.”
Thorin nodded. “I’m leaving for their camp now, before anyone else wakes up,” he explained, a frown appearing on his face.
“What about the men keeping guard?” Bilbo asked, sitting up with a groan.
“I don’t believe they noticed me,” Thorin said. “If they did, they said nothing about it.”
Bilbo nodded, and Thorin stepped out of the way as he stood. “I...” he started, but stopped himself. He let out a loud sigh, his forehead wrinkling as his eyebrows drew together. “I know I’ve apologized a lot, but I’m... I’m truly sorry for bringing you into this situation.”
“You’ve apologized too much,” Thorin said, grabbing Bilbo’s hand. There were scars littered across his knuckles, and he traced them gently with the pad of his thumb. “There is no need to. There has never been any need to.”
Bilbo took in a deep breath, nodding again. “I know... but that does not stop me from feeling guilt over what has happened.”
Thorin sighed. “The only bad thing to have come from this is that now we have to once again part ways,” he said.
“We’ll meet again,” Bilbo said, cupping Thorin’s cheek. “It may not be for a long while, but it will happen. This goodbye isn’t forever.”
Thorin smiled, nodding. “I know.” He leaned in, gently kissing him. It ended much too quickly for Bilbo, and he followed Thorin to the door, their hands still clasped together.
“Be safe,” he said, as Thorin pushed the tent flap aside.
“You as well.” He pulled their hands apart, and then he was gone, the flap falling back into place. Bilbo stood there for a long while, silent, before stepping out onto the beach. Thorin had already disappeared into the maze of tents.
Bilbo took in a deep breath of salty air, scanning the beach as if looking for some sign of Thorin, though he knew there would be none. He stopped when he caught sight of Bofur, watching him from where he sat by a dying fire. There was a confused look on his face, and Bilbo quickly hardened his expression into one that warned him not to ask questions.
Frowning, he turned on his heel and retreated back inside the tent, making sure the flap was closed all the way.
◊◊◊
6 Months Later
“Papa! Hurry up!”
“Elinor!” Thorin called, chasing after his daughter as she ran ahead of him. “Be careful!” He hurried towards her, scooping her up as she wandered onto the busy London street and placing her back on the sidewalk. “It’s too dangerous for you to run ahead like that.”
Elinor scowled. “But you’re so slow,” she whined.
“It doesn’t matter,” Thorin argued. “These streets are very busy, and you’re only a little girl.”
“I’d be safe,” Elinor said. “Promise!”
Thorin shook his head, reaching out his hand for her to take. “Sorry, love.”
Her scowl deepened, but she still took her father’s offered hand. “Now, come on,” he said, swinging their arms as they walked down the street. “Your aunt’s expecting us.”
They arrived at Dís’s house a few minutes later. She already had a large amount of food spread out on the table for lunch, and was brewing a pot of tea when Elinor raced into the kitchen to greet her.
“Auntie! Auntie!” she cried, throwing herself at Dís.
“Hello, little Elinor,” Dís said with a laugh, gathering her niece up into her arms. “How are you?”
“I’m good!” Elinor answered with a smile. “How are you?”
“I’m very lovely, thank you.”
“Where’s Georgie?” Elinor asked, looking around the room for her aunt’s cat, an animal that she absolutely adored.
“I don’t know,” Dís said, standing and letting Elinor slip out of her arms. “Why don’t you go find him? And look for your uncle at the same time, as well!”
Elinor nodded, giggling happily, and ran off, yelling for both the cat and her uncle. Dís watched her go with a smile, before turning to face Thorin.
“And how are you, James?” she asked, wandering over to the fireplace where the kettle had begun boiling. She carefully removed it from above the fire and poured its contents into her delicate white teapot.
“I’m alright,” he answered, taking the kettle from her when it was empty and returning it to its place.
His sister looked at him, a concerned expression on her face. “Are you sure?”
He frowned. “Yes, Cecily, I’m very sure. You do not need to ask me that every time we see each other.”
“I’m worried,” Dís replied, her look of concern turning into a glower. “I feel as though that’s reasonable, considering what happened.”
Thorin let out a loud sigh, running a hand over his face. It had been just over three months since he returned to England. In the first few weeks, his story had been something of a phenomenon—people had been eager to hear of his life amongst the pirates and how he had managed to escape them, never mind the fact that he was a member of their crew for a fortnight and the story of his escape was a bold-faced lie. Still, it had been published in several London newspapers, and while most of the intrigue had died down Frerin was still trying to convince him to write a book about it, insisting that it would sell well.
While public interest in the matter had greatly diminished, most of Thorin’s family still acted as if he might be on the verge of a breakdown at any moment. Though none of them asked him, they all seemed to be of the same agreement that he had suffered unspeakable horrors at the hands of the pirates. He did not bother trying to correct them, knowing it would only cause more trouble.
“I’m fine, Cecily,” he said, walking over to his sister and placing his hands on her shoulders. “I promise you that. If I wasn’t, I would tell you immediately.”
“You had better,” Dís said, giving him a warning glance. “I know you find all this tiring, but please, know that we—William, Nathaniel, Father, and I—do it because we care for you. You act strong and like none of what happened bothers you, but you’re still only human. There is no need to push your feelings away.”
Thorin nodded, leaning forward and placing a gentle kiss on Dís’s forehead. “Thank you, Cecily,” he whispered. “I’m sorry I have caused you so much worry.”
Dís smiled. “Do not—”
She was cut off by the door swinging open and Fíli and Kíli running into the room, their faces red and their breathing heavy.
“Hello, Uncle!” Fíli greeted, Kíli’s own hello only a few beats behind.
“What are you two doing, running in here like madmen?” Dís asked, reaching over and brushing the hair from Kíli’s face.
“We didn’t want to miss lunch!” the boy said, grinning widely at his mother.
“Especially since you’re here, Uncle!” Fíli added, and Thorin smiled.
“I’m glad you boys enjoy my company so much.”
Kíli nodded vehemently. “You’re my favourite uncle,” he said, quietly, as if he were divulging a secret.
Thorin laughed, pulling his youngest nephew into his arms and ruffling his hair. “You had better not tell your Uncle Nathaniel that,” he said. “It would break his heart.”
Kíli laughed, struggling to get out of Thorin’s grasp. “Uncle, let go!” he cried, though his voice was full of joy.
“Is James torturing you again, Alexander?” Dís’s husband, Víli, asked, suddenly appearing in the room. Elinor arrived a few seconds later, Georgie the cat held tightly in her arms.
“No, of course not,” Thorin said, letting Kíli slip from his grasp. The boy scrambled away, still laughing, and Thorin stood, smiling at his brother-in-law. “I would never.”
Víli chuckled, shaking his head. “It is good to see you again, James,” he said, placing a hand on Thorin’s shoulder. “I hope you are doing well?”
Thorin nodded. “I am, yes,” he responded.
“Uncle!” Thorin’s attention was one more drawn to Kíli, scurrying up to stand beside him. “Can you tell us the story of how you escaped the pirates again?”
Thorin opened his mouth to respond, but was cut off by Dís.
“Alexander, you’ve heard that story so many times already,” she said. “Is it necessary that you hear it again?”
Kíli nodded. “Please, Uncle?” he asked, looking from his mother to Thorin. “I love it!”
Thorin smiled again. “Of course I’ll tell you,” he said. “Though I’m sure you could tell it yourself by now.”
“You do it best, though.”
Dís sighed. “You will have to wait until after lunch,” she said, placing a hand on her son’s shoulder and gently pushing him towards a chair. “There shall be no pirate stories at the table.”
Kíli frowned, but complied, quietly taking his seat. Everyone else followed suit, with Elinor climbing into the chair beside her father. As Víli began reciting the prayer of Grace, Thorin’s mind wandered to Bilbo. He had thought of him every day since his departure, and constantly wondered about his well-being. He could very easily be dead, and Thorin would have no way of knowing.
He frowned, and pushed the thoughts away. It was no use to dwell on them—there was nothing he could do.
◊◊◊
Bilbo was drifting in and out of sleep when the jangling sound of keys jerked him awake. He had been awaiting that sound all day, and a surge of fear jumped through him. He watched as the pair of soldiers unlocked the door and entered the cell, the sound of his heartbeat roaring in his ears. His eyes slipped closed momentarily and he took in deep breaths in a futile attempt to calm himself. He lingered briefly on memories of the green, rolling hills of the Shire, where his life had been so much more peaceful than the one he knew now. Though it had been years since he had last seen it, he could still easily picture the calm fields early in the morning, and the tall tree that grew atop Bag End.
He was thrust back into reality by a rough hand on his upper arm, yanking him to his feet. Shackles were slapped onto his wrists as he was pushed towards the door. The soldiers surrounded him as he was lead from the cell and through the jail, past the other prisoners in their filthy, rat-infested cages.
Bilbo sucked in a deep breath of rancid air. He had known this day would come—nothing had ever awaited him at the end but a rope around his neck or a sword through his gut. It seemed as if fate had chosen the former.
In a way, he was glad it was soon to be over. It had been four months since his capture by a pirate hunter, several miles east of the Bahamas, and he’d spent that time rotting in the cells of decrepit prisons. But it was his own fault, he knew—he’d been reckless, and had given the British a reason to find him and see him hanged. It was never wise to attack the ship of a governor, and yet he had.
He frowned. He knew he had been the cause of his own undoing. Bofur had accused him of wanting to die and had told him that he was being rash, but Bilbo hadn’t listened. He was right, in the end.
Bilbo squinted as he was pushed out into the blinding sunlight. It was early afternoon, and the streets surrounding the prison were busy. People stopped to watch as Bilbo was loaded onto a waiting cart, alongside several other prisoners. He recognized none of them. Most of the members of his crew that had survived the battle had already been hanged, Bofur included.
Bilbo chewed on the inside of his cheek, willing his face to show no emotion. As the cart slowly made its way through the streets of Port Royal, he focused his gaze on the grainy wood beneath his feet, and imagined himself to be elsewhere.
He did not look up until the cart rolled to a stop and he was once again pulled to his feet. The gallows stood in front of him, tall and ominous, and he kept his head bowed as he and the other prisoners were lead towards them. A large crowd was gathered to watch the execution, and they cheered as the pirates were lined up and the nooses were placed around their necks.
A Navy officer began to read out their names and crimes, his voice loud so that all gathered could hear. Samuel Milford. Walter Newby. Roger Till. Franklin May.
Bilbo winced as his named was read. He had faced death so many times, and knew what lay beyond, but it still scared him. Dying was never something he could become accustomed to.
The officer paused and the chaplain spoke up, offering the men a final chance to repent for their sins. Bilbo considered it for a moment, before decided not to. He would not be going to heaven, no matter what he said at the end of his life.
He felt his heart rate speed up as the chaplain finished and the officer ended his speech. The rope was like an anchor around his neck, and he squeezed his eyes shut as the cheers of the crowd grew louder. He willed himself to think of the Shire, and of Scotland and Denmark, and of Thorin. They would meet again, he knew. That much was inevitable.
He took in a deep breath, and the floor fell out from under his feet.
