Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

Remember Me

Summary:

Bilbo Baggins and Thorin Oakenshield are destined to suffer. In every life they live, in every age, in every era, they meet, and this meeting brings back all the memories of the lives that have come before. But every meeting serves also as a death sentence, for once they have met, one of them is doomed to die soon after, usually tragically and prematurely. They remember nothing of their past lives until they meet, and once they have there is nothing that can be done to stop their fate.

Chapter 1: Through the Heather

Summary:

Scotland, 1745
2nd Life
The Jacobites

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Ben MacDonell ran through the forest, weaving between trees and jumping deftly over fallen logs. His feet slipped on dead leaves slick from the recent rain, and he grabbed onto an overhanging branch to keep from falling. Behind him, he could hear the sound of multiple pairs of feet pounding against the earth, running to catch up to him. A grin spread across his face, and he slowed down slightly. The feet grew closer, and he turned to see the small hoard of children mere metres away from him.

“Ben! You’re too fast!” one of the children whined, one hand on her head to keep her bonnet from slipping off.

“Then run faster!” Ben called back, and the girl scowled angrily at him, trying as best as she could to speed up. “You’ll never catch me!”

“Yes we will!” another one of the children called.

“You can try, but you’ll never succeed,” Ben teased, though even as he said this he slowed down even more until he was just out of reach of the children.

One of the older boys reached out his hands and ran faster, pulling away from the rest of the group. Jumping forward, he pounced for Ben, who turned just in time to be tackled and thrown on his back to the ground. The group of children piled on top of him, giggling and squealing in delight.

“We got you!” another boy yelled, smiling widely.

“That’s what you think!” Ben answered, wrapping his arms around the small group of children and heaving them off of him until he could stand up, his back damp and covered in leaves. They all immediately lunged for his legs, wrapping their small frames around them so he couldn’t escape. Still, Ben slowly started trudging forward, dragging his feet along the ground as he was unable to lift them. Thankfully, they were near the edge of the forest so he was able to plow his way out of the woods and into a small field that bordered the village.

Once there, he let himself fall to the ground where he was once more overtaken. He struggled with his attackers, pushing them off here and there, complaining about how strong and heavy they were.

“I do not think I can take you all!” he told them, huffing as they came at him with renewed vigour.

“Having some trouble, cousin?”

Ben tilted his head back to see his cousin, Douglas, standing above him, smirking. “Ah, hello, Douglas,” he greeted. “I actually have the situation under control, thank you.”

Douglas raised an eyebrow at him. “I am sure that you do,” he said, before looking at the children. “Come on now, my strong lads and lasses. Leave poor Benny alone.”

The children let out several pouty whines, but obediently rolled off of Ben and stood up.

“We’ll be back for you!” one of them warned as they turned to return to the village, though her childish voice made it significantly non-threatening.

“I’ll get you next time!” Ben replied, standing up and dusting himself off as best as he could.

“Should you not be working?” Douglas asked as the children disappeared down the hill.

Ben scowled. “Should you not be spending time with your bonnie new wife?” he retorted. “Your party is tomorrow, and I would think you still have much to do to prepare.” His scowl turned to a smirk, and Douglas gave him a rather unimpressed look.

“Fergus was looking for you,” he explained. “I was sent to find you, and I’ve just spent the last hour wandering around asking if anyone knew where you were. The blacksmith finally told me that you’d run off to the forest with a herd of children at your heels.”

“They thought they were faster than me,” Ben replied. “I had to prove them wrong.”

“Is that why you were on the ground?” Douglas asked, one eyebrow raised.

Ben shrugged. “I let them win,” he said. “Next time it will not be so easy.”

Douglas let out a snort of laughter, crossing his arms over his chest. “I’m sure that is the truth,” he told him. “But we’ve no more time for chatting—Fergus has called for a meeting.”

Ben furrowed his brows together, scowling. Fergus was the chieftain of Clan MacDonell of Glengarry, which itself was a branch of the larger Clan Donald, one of the largest clans in the Highlands. This made Fergus a rather powerful and influential man, at least in the north-east of Scotland, where the clan resided. He was also Ben’s great-uncle, and Douglas’s grandfather.

Fergus had been the chieftain of Clan MacDonell of Glengarry all of Ben’s life. As a young child, he would see his great-uncle only once a year when his family travelled from their estate near the coast to Invergarry Castle, where Ben’s grandfather had grown up, the youngest of five children. Then, when he was only six years old, a wave of smallpox had swept through their village, and both his mother and father had died. Ben was sent to live at Invergarry Castle, where he was cared for chiefly by his father’s cousin, Iain, and his wife, Edna. Douglas had been overjoyed to have a cousin his own age to play with, and the two had spent their days running through the castle halls creating as much mischief as they could.

Even then, Fergus had been a very fierce, serious man. Douglas, Ben, and Douglas’s younger brother, Gregor, had all been terrified of him as children, though he was never unkind or harsh with them. He was simply a very serious, imposing man. Still, they had avoided him as much as possible, and acts of bravery had consisted of sneaking into his office and stealing a quill or a roll of paper.

Heaving a sigh, Ben stood once more. “Do you know what it is about?” he asked his cousin, and Douglas smiled, throwing an arm across his shoulders.

“Prince Charles has come to Scotland,” he announced.

 ◊◊◊

Alasdair MacElheran swung one leg over the saddle of his horse, dismounting in one quick jump. He had been riding all day, and was sore and stiff, but he had finally reached his destination, which was some consolation for his aching muscles. It had taken him over a week to travel from his home in Clan Donald territory further south to the large village near Invergarry Castle, where his sister and her husband lived.

Tying his horse to the post outside his sister’s home, he grabbed the largest packs from off the saddle, slinging them over his shoulder. He would grab the rest later when he moved the horse to the stables, but for now he was anxious to be inside with his family. It had been nearly half a year since he had last seen them, and a visit was long overdue.

Adjusting the packs on his shoulder, he hurried to the door, rapping it twice in quick succession. He could hear someone scuffling inside, and a moment later the door was opened by a maid who quickly stepped to the side to reveal his sister, swollen from pregnancy but with a wide smile on her face.

“Alasdair!” she cried, lifting her skirts so she could run forward and throw her arms around her brother.

“Hello, Elspeth,” he greeted, grinning and returning her hug. After several seconds he pulled back, his hands on her shoulders. “My Lord, look at you! You’re about ready to burst!”

Elspeth scoffed and stepped aside to shuffle him indoors, closing the door behind them. Her husband, Rory, appeared in the entryway from down the corridor and walked over to them, clasping his hand tightly around Alasdair’s.

“It’s good to see you again,” Rory said, and Alasdair nodded, giving him a happy smile in return.

“Mary will show you to your room, where you can leave your things,” Elspeth told him, nodding to the young maid who had opened the door. “You can wash up a bit and then come back down. I’ll have Mrs. Burns fix you up something—you must be starving.”

Alasdair turned to Mary, who bowed her head and ushered him up the nearby stairs to his room, one he often stayed in when he visited his sister. As he entered, Mary curtsied and left the room, closing the door behind her. Leaving his bags at the foot of the bed, Alasdair cleaned his face and hands in the washbasin in the corner of the room, and then changed out of the clothes that he had been wearing for most of his travelling. Then he returned downstairs and made his way to the dining room, where his sister’s cook, Mrs. Burns, had laid out a bowl of stew and several pieces of bread for him.

Elspeth and Rory arrived behind him from the sitting room and sat with him while he ate, asking of his travels. Alasdair in turn asked them of their lives, and how they had fared since he saw them last.

“I am quite ready to have this little bairn out,” Elspeth said with a laugh, resting her hands on her swollen stomach. “The midwife said that he is due in just a few more weeks.”

“You are confident that it is a boy?” Alasdair asked, and Elspeth nodded.

“Though I wish for a girl,” she added. “But I believe that we shall have another wee lad.”

“Speaking of wee lads, where is the first?” Alasdair questioned. He had not seen any sign of his nephew since his arrival, which was odd. The young boy had turned three during the months since Alasdair had last visited, and he was rather loud and mischievous. 

“Napping,” Elspeth answered. “Though I suspect that he’ll be awake soon, so you haven’t long to wait.” She stood, and Alasdair and Rory rose after her. “Come,” she said. “Let’s go continue our conversations in the sitting room, where it’s more comfortable.”

Alasdair followed his sister down the corridor to the sitting room, where he sat in a soft, plush chair near the fireplace. Once they were all settled, Elspeth turned to her brother.

“Have you heard much from Ronald?” she asked. “I wish he had joined you, as it’s been far longer since I last saw him.”

 “He told me he will be visiting after the baby is born,” Alasdair explained, though he frowned slightly. Their younger brother, Ronald, had never been a very responsible person. To Alasdair, it seemed as if he had never matured past eighteen, though he was now in his early twenties. He spent his time roaming the Highlands, and sometimes Alasdair would go months without hearing anything from him. It worried their parents something dreadful, and he knew that they feared Ronald had become a criminal or was even rotting in jail. And if Alasdair was being honest with himself, he wouldn’t have been horribly surprised to find out that their fears were actually reality.

Elspeth sighed, and Alasdair knew she didn’t believe that Ronald would keep his promise. He hadn’t met her first child until the boy was almost one year old, and he didn’t believe that this time would be different.

“I will see him eventually,” she decided after a moment, and that was something Alasdair had no trouble believing. She would hunt their brother down herself if she had to.

“But enough about Ronald and his many shortcomings,” Elspeth continued, settling her hands in her lap. “How are Mother and Father?”

They spoke at length about their parents, as well as many other people from their village. This evolved into the telling of childhood stories, and Rory sat there listening with a smile on his face, occasionally asking questions. He had no doubt heard most of the stories already, but many that included some of Elspeth’s more embarrassing moments had been kept from him, and so Alasdair gladly told them while his sister sat glaring at him.

Eventually, a cry was heard upstairs and Elspeth stood, leaving the room. She returned a few moments later, holding her son’s small hand in her own.

The little boy’s face brightened as he entered the room with his mother and caught sight of his uncle sitting near the fireplace. “Uncle!” he cried, wiggling his arm until Elspeth let him go. Then he ran as fast as his small legs could take him to where Alasdair sat, and leaned against his uncle’s knees. “Uncle!” he repeated, smiling widely.

“Hello, Frankie,” Alasdair greeted, picking his nephew up and sitting him on his lap. “You’ve grown so much since I saw you last!”

“I’m three!” Frankie announced proudly, grinning at his uncle.

“My goodness, you are, aren’t you?” Alasdair asked. “You’re getting very big, lad. You’ll be very strong one day, won’t you?”

Frankie nodded, giggling. “Like Da,” he said, looking over at Rory, who smiled.

“Aye, just like him,” Alasdair agreed with a nod, bouncing the small boy on his knee.

“And you,” Frankie added, looking back to Thorin. “You’re the strongest, Uncle.”

Thorin grinned and kissed the top of his nephew’s head. “I’ve missed you, lad. Did you know that?”

“I missed you, too, Uncle!” Frankie said with a wide smile.

 ◊◊◊

Fergus MacDonell’s office was on the top floor of Invergarry Castle. It was not often that Ben visited the room, and the last time had been many months before. That day, there was a bustle of activity around the office, with people wandering in and out and milling around the corridors. Most of them appeared to be lairds from the surrounding area and the more important people from the nearby village. Gregor was there, as well, and when he spotted Ben and Douglas coming down the hallway he hurried towards them.

“Come on, now,” he said, pushing them both towards Fergus’s office. “Dad’s in there already, and Granda’s getting impatient.”

“Then we best not keep him waiting anymore,” Douglas said, and lead them through the small crowd into the office.

Fergus was standing behind his desk, with Iain beside him. A laird that Ben vaguely recognized was speaking with the chieftain, but when Ben and Douglas entered he quickly ended the conversation and motioned for them to come closer.

“What took you so long?” he asked as they approached the desk.

“I wasn’t in the village,” Ben said, bowing his head slightly. “I was in the forest with some local children, and Douglas couldn’t find me. I’m sorry to keep you waiting.”

Fergus frowned, sighing. “Well, I don’t suppose there’s much that can be done about it now,” he decided. “Gregor, go and get everyone else. It’s time we got this meeting underway.”

Gregor nodded and left, returning a few moments later with the rest of the assembled men. As they all entered the office, Fergus moved to the front of his desk, his hands clasped behind his back. He didn’t say anything for a moment, before giving them all a small smile and starting, “As you have all heard, Prince Charles has arrived in Scotland.”

The room erupted into cheers, and Douglas slung his arm over Ben’s shoulder, shaking him happily. Fergus waited a moment for them all to calm before continuing.

“As I have heard, he landed on Eriskay two days ago and is now residing near Loch nan Uamh with Clan Ranald,” he informed them. “I do not know how long he will stay there, but it’ll probably not be long. But what I do know is that Prince Charles is here to raise an army, and the MacDonells of Glengarry will support him and his claim to the throne!”

There was a second round of approving cheers, and Ben smiled as he clapped. He knew that, if Prince Charles succeeded in mustering an army, he would be among the ranks to fight against the British. The coming year would most likely not be an easy one, but the idea of their Jacobite rebellion having the chance to succeed was enough to make him grin and cheer, any thoughts of hardship far away.

◊◊◊

That evening, Alasdair sat with Elspeth and Rory in their parlour after dinner. Frankie had been put to bed long ago, and as the sun set Mary went around and lit the candles and lamps, stoking the fires to make sure they stayed lit.

“There is to be a party at the castle tomorrow,” Elspeth said after she had gone. “It is to celebrate the marriage of the chieftain’s grandson, Douglas. He is a good friend of Rory’s, and we have all been invited, if you would like to go.” She looked at Alasdair, eyebrows raised in question.  

“I would not like to intrude on a marriage celebration,” Alasdair argued, and Elspeth sighed, as if she had been expecting his answer. He continued, “I know neither the bride nor the groom, and I don’t want to appear rude.”

“I told Douglas a few days ago that you would be here for the party,” Rory told him. “He said he would very much like to meet you, and insisted that you come. We have both known him for a very long time.”

Alasdair said nothing for a moment. “Then I suppose I must accept,” he said eventually. “Though I doubt my dear sister would have given me much choice.”

“You are very correct there,” Elspeth said, smirking. “Many of our other friends will be there, and I would like for you to meet them. They are all very nice, and it’ll be a very fun time. So you should look forward to it.”

“Yes, madam,” Alasdair said, his expression one of mock seriousness.

Elspeth scowled at him for a moment before grinning, shaking her head. “Now come,” she said, adjusting herself in her seat. “Tell me all the news from home. How are the neighbours and tenants?”

◊◊◊

Ben stood in the great hall, watching as the large room slowly filled up with guests. They had begun arriving only a few moments ago, and most were still chatting with either Fergus or Iain; both Douglas and his new wife, Margaret, were still upstairs, and would not be making an appearance until most of the guests had arrived.

Sighing, he clasped his hands behind his back, looking from guest to guest. He spotted his two cousins, Gregor and Fenella, standing off to the side talking, and wandered over to them, unsure of what else to do. He had never much enjoyed these social events hosted by his great-uncle, and he rarely knew any of the guests very well. Still, he felt anxious and uncomfortable standing in the corner alone, and he had not seen either of his cousins for more than a few minutes all day.

He stood with them, chatting, as the hall quickly filled up with people until it was full of the sounds of music and laughter. Eventually, as the music died down, Fergus stood at the front of the room, Iain by his side. Opening his arms, he welcomed them all to his home to help celebrate this wonderful occasion.

“It has been long since a wedding was last celebrated at Invergarry,” he said, beaming widely at the crowd. “And it is with great pride that I announce to you my eldest grandson, Douglas, and his bonnie bride, Margaret.”

The room exploded into a loud round of applause, people cheering and clapping as they all turned to the set of stairs on the other side of the room, where Douglas stood arm-in-arm with Margaret. They were both smiling widely as they descended, Margaret’s long skirt trailing behind her.

“I do wonder how Douglas convinced her to marry him,” Gregor said quietly to Ben. “She’s the loveliest thing I ever did see; too lovely for the likes of him.”

“And the likes of you,” Ben retorted, smirking.

Fenella scoffed, rolling her eyes. “Don’t be so crude, Gregor,” she scolded. “Be happy for Douglas. He’s loved her for years.”

“I’m happy,” Gregor argued, scowling at his older sister.

Ben grinned at the two, shaking his head, before turning his attention back to Douglas and Margaret, who were now in the crowd greeting their guests. They both looked immensely happy, Margaret with her hand looped around Douglas’s elbow as they travelled through the hall to where Fergus and Iain stood. Ben couldn’t help but wonder, for a moment, if he would ever be happy like that, or if he would ever even marry. He had never much enjoyed the thought of marriage and could not, in all honesty, ever see himself in Douglas’s place, with a beautiful bride on his arm. All his life he had felt that way, and he was now beginning to feel as if there was something wrong with that—he and Douglas were the same age, and soon people would no doubt start expecting Ben to find a wife as well. The idea both frightened him and made him feel incredibly uneasy.

He was pulled from his thoughts by Gregor yanking on his arm. “Come on, Ben,” his younger cousin said. “Let’s go find something to drink!”

Forcing a smile, Ben nodded and complied, and they went off in search of drinks while Fenella wandered off to socialize. But as they made their way through the mass of people filling the hall, they were stopped suddenly by Douglas, who called them over to where he was standing with a good friend of his, Rory Blair, the younger brother of a local laird. Rory had grown up in the village near Invergarry Castle, and had known both Douglas and Ben since they were children. He was a year older than them, but was a good friend and always had been.

“Rory!” Ben greeted, pushing all his earlier thoughts from his mind as he approached the two, Gregor in tow.

“Hello, Ben,” Rory replied, reaching out to shake his hand and nodding at Gregor in greeting.

“How is Elspeth? And Frankie?” Ben asked.

“They’re quite well,” Rory answered. “Elspeth’s brother has come for a visit, which I told Douglas the other day. He is here with Elspeth somewhere; once I find them...” he paused, scanning the crowd. “...I shall introduce him to you all.”

Douglas nodded. “His name is Alasdair, is it not?”

“Aye,” Rory said. “Alasdair MacElheran. You would have met him earlier, most likely, but it has been a year since his last visit, and then it was only for a short while.” He stopped, stretching to see above the heads of the people around him, and his face brightened suddenly. “Ah, there they are! Elspeth! Elspeth!”

A few moments later, Elspeth appeared in front of them, smiling her bright, cheerful smile. “Hello, hello!” she greeted. “It’s madness in here! Absolutely impossible to find anyone.”

“Hello, Elspeth,” Douglas said. “This must be your brother.”

It is then that Ben noticed the tall, dark-haired man standing behind Elspeth, and for a second he wondered how he hadn’t seen him earlier before the man looked at him with strikingly blue eyes and Ben felt all the breath leave his body.

The last time he had seen those eyes had been very long ago, and then there had been no life in them—they had been staring, blind, at a cloudy sky full of eagles, and Bilbo had cried until he felt he could cry no more.

But now he was once again looking into those light blue eyes, and there was life in them. Bilbo could do nothing but stand there, dumbstruck, unsure of what was happening. The man in front of him was dead—he had been dead for many decades. Wild-eyed, he glanced at the others gathered around him, hoping to find answers in them. Instead, he found only more questions, for when he looked at Douglas memories flooded him of his cousin Drogo who had drowned while boating on the Brandywine River many years ago, but was now standing in front of him, whole and well.

Sucking in a deep breath, he looked back to the man—to Thorin. He looked just as confused and shocked as Bilbo did, but he said nothing.

“Ben.” Bilbo was suddenly aware that someone was calling his name, and he turned towards Drogo, or Douglas, now unsure of what to call him.

“Are you alright?” his cousin asked, a look of concern on his face.

“I, uh,” Bilbo stopped, worrying his bottom lip between his teeth. Purposefully avoiding Thorin’s gaze, he took in a deep breath, straightening himself. “Yes, I’m perfectly alright. Sorry.”

Drogo didn’t look as if he entirely believed him, but he said nothing, looking back towards Elspeth and Thorin. “As I was saying, this is my cousin, Ben,” he said, motioning first at Bilbo and then towards Thorin. “Ben, this is Alasdair, Elspeth’s older brother.”

Bilbo reached out his hand and Thorin took it, shaking it. “It’s very nice to meet you,” he said, giving a small smile.

Thorin nodded. “You as well.”

◊◊◊

Bilbo left the hall as soon as he could, quickly excusing himself from the conversation and slipping quietly through the doors. Once in the hallway he leaned against the wall, taking deep, measured breaths in an attempt to calm himself. Though he had remained collected on the outside, inside he had been slowly growing more and more confused and anxious. He didn’t know what to do with the memories that had suddenly flooded his mind, and he didn’t understand why Thorin Oakenshield, of all people, had triggered their return.

He stood there for several minutes, attempting to work it all out in his mind and wondering whether or not he should return to the great hall. His thoughts were interrupted, however, by the door swinging open and Thorin walking out into the corridor, an almost panicked look on his face.

The panic seemed to ease though when he spotted Bilbo standing only a few feet from the door. “Master Baggins!” he cried, hurrying over to where he stood.

“Thorin,” Bilbo breathed, and the assurance that Thorin also remembered both relieved and confused him. “I... Do... Please tell me you know what’s going on.”

“I have no idea,” Thorin admitted, his brow furrowing. “And it seems neither do you.”

Bilbo shook his head. “It doesn’t make any sense,” he said. “You... died. And I believe I must’ve died as well.”

Thorin paled suddenly. “In the battle?” he asked, taking a step closer. “Were you hurt?”

“What?” Bilbo gave him a confused look, before realization dawned on him. “Oh, no, no, not in the battle. I lived to be quite old, actually. Nearly made it to 135.”

Thorin relaxed considerably, smiling slightly. “Almost as old as I was,” he pointed out.

Bilbo chuckled. “I didn’t look half as young at 135 as you did at 195,” he said.

“That is still quite the feat for a Hobbit, is it not?” Thorin asked, and Bilbo nodded.

“I was the oldest Hobbit to ever live,” he said, before pausing. “That’s odd to think about. I was so old... and now I’m young again, but I still have all those memories. My mind does not feel old, though. I simply remember being old.”

“We are both young now,” Thorin observed. “How old are you?”

“Only twenty-three,” Bilbo answered, and he sounded as if he didn’t quite believe himself.

Thorin nodded. “I am twenty-five,” he said. “It is... strange.”

Bilbo laughed. “This entire situation is strange,” he said. “I really don’t know what to make of it.”

“It seems almost like a second chance,” Thorin said. “At what, I don’t know. But it’s like we have been allowed to have another try.”

Bilbo tilted his head to the side, considering this. “Do you suppose that’s really it?” he asked, and Thorin shrugged.

“It is as good an explanation as any,” he offered. “But to me it makes sense.”

◊◊◊

Bilbo sat at his desk, a blank piece of parchment rolled out in front of him. His quill hovered above the paper, poised to write out the words that were flying around his mind. He had only slept for a few hours that night, and the sun was just beginning to creep above the horizon. The entire castle was quiet, and outside only a few people were stirring, just starting to commence their daily tasks.

A drop of ink rolled from his quill and splattered onto the parchment, and Bilbo heaved a small sigh as he put the quill back into the well. All night he had tossed and turned, trying and failing to find sleep. The events of the previous evening replayed themselves in his mind constantly, and all he could think about was what it all meant. He had thought that writing it out would help, remembering how, as Bilbo Baggins, he would write stories and memoirs and poetry. But it appeared that as Ben MacDonell, all his former eloquence and skill at writing didn’t exist, or had left him for the time being. He had been staring at the same blank sheet for a quarter of an hour now and still had no idea how or where to begin.

So instead he took the ink-stained paper and crumbled it up, tossing it onto the embers still burning in his fireplace. He watched as it caught fire and burned quickly until all that was left were charred flakes of paper and then stood. He was already dressed for the day, and grabbed his jacket as he left, not entirely sure where he was going but feeling a need to leave the castle.

The morning air was cool as Bilbo stepped outside, but he knew that the day would be hot. He found his feet unconsciously carrying him towards the village, and he wandered through the quiet streets that he had known all his life and ended up quite suddenly in front of the home of Rory Blair. Thorin had told him the night before that that was where he was staying, and though Bilbo hadn’t planned on going there he couldn’t think of anywhere else to go.

He stood in front of the house for a few minutes, unsure of what to do. It was too early to go up and knock on the door, but he didn’t think he would be able to simply walk away.

“Master Baggins?”

He turned at the sound of his name to see Thorin standing behind him. He suddenly felt very stupid, figuring that he must have looked ridiculous standing in front of someone’s house before the sun had even fully risen.

“Thorin...” he said, his voice faltering as his mind drew a blank on what to say.

“What are you doing here?” Thorin asked, and Bilbo flushed, trying to come up with a viable excuse.

“I... I’m not entirely sure,” he admitted, wincing at his own words. “I couldn’t sleep last night and I decided to go for a walk to try and... clear my head, I suppose. I didn’t mean to come here, it sort of just... happened.”

Thorin watched him for a moment before nodding. “I could not sleep either,” he said. “I went out to the stables a short while ago to try and take my mind off of things, though it didn’t really work.”

Bilbo nodded. “I kept thinking that when I woke it would all turn out to be a dream,” he said. “And though it is still very confusing, I... I wanted it all to be real.”

“I’m glad it is real, then,” Thorin said, smiling. “It’s very nice to see you again.”

Bilbo smiled, looking towards the nearby woods, where birds were chirping in the trees, and neither of them said anything for a moment.

“Would you...” he started after several seconds but paused, crossing his arms over his chest and turning back to face Thorin. “Would you like to take a walk?”

Thorin raised an eyebrow at him. “A walk?”

Bilbo nodded. “I have always found them calming, in a way,” he explained. “Especially in the mornings. I know this place we can go to; it is not very far away, and it’s very beautiful.” When Thorin didn’t say anything right away, he quickly added, “But you don’t have to go, if you do not want to. It was simply a... suggestion.”

“No, no,” Thorin said, a smile spreading across his face. “I would love to go for a walk with you.”

Bilbo grinned widely, almost in spite of himself. “Great,” he said with a nod. “Excellent.”

“I’ll just run inside and grab some food to take with us,” Thorin said, motioning towards the house. “I haven’t had breakfast yet—I’ll only be a moment.”

Bilbo nodded again, and Thorin turned and hurried into the house. He reappeared a few minutes later with a small covered basket and they set out. Bilbo led the way, taking them away from the village and the castle. He often walked as a way to clear his head and to escape the sometimes hectic life at Invergarry Castle. Normally he was alone, but sometimes his cousins and friends would come along. Occasionally, he would spend an entire day walking—he would pack some food and a book and leave at dawn, not returning until the sun was almost set. There were some parts in the area surrounding the castle that were absolutely breathtaking, some of which were only a short walk from the village.

As he led them through the small forest outside the village, neither of them spoke. A thin early-morning mist clung to the ground, obscuring the trees and giving them an almost eerie look in the dim light. Eventually leaving the forest behind, they entered a wide open area covered in long green grass and scattered rocks. Here, the ground climbed gradually upwards, and hills and mountains could be seen through the haze.

“It’s beautiful,” Thorin said, pausing. A large lake glimmered faintly in the distance, nestled between the mountains.

“I have always loved it here,” Bilbo agreed, and pointed to the lake. “That’s Loch Ness there,” he explained, before turning and pointing to another, smaller lake. “And that’s Loch Oich. You can see Invergarry Castle there on the shore.”

“It’s really amazing,” Thorin said. “Loch Ness looks as if it stretches on forever.”

“It’s over thirty kilometres long—nearly all the way to Inverness,” Bilbo said. “I will have to take you there one day.”

Thorin smiled. “That would be wonderful.”

They continued walking, climbing slowly as the sun rose higher in the sky and the mist dissipated. The ground, which had been damp when they started, dried, and heat began to fill the air. Gradually the climb steepened, and as they walked they talked of their lives.

“I don’t have any siblings,” Bilbo said, stepping over a rock covered over in moss and lichen. “My parents died when I was only six from smallpox.”

“Oh,” Thorin said, slightly shocked. “I’m sorry.”

Bilbo shrugged. “I barely remember them now,” he admitted. “Though I suppose they must have been quite like they were before. In Middle-earth, I mean.”

“What were their names?”

“Before they were Belladonna and Bungo Baggins,” he said, smiling a bit. “But here they were Isobel and Gordon MacDonell.” He paused for a moment before turning to Thorin. “What about your family?”

“Most are still alive,” Thorin answered. “By the time we had met, in Middle-earth, most of them were dead. My parents, my brother, my brother-in-law. My brother was named Frerin then, and had died in battle when he was only forty-eight. I suppose that seems rather old now, but that was very young for a dwarf. Fíli and Kíli were eighty-two and seventy-seven when they died, and they were still considered teenagers.”

Bilbo stared at him for a moment. “I never knew,” he said. “That’s horrible. But he is alive now?”

Thorin nodded. “His name is Ronald,” he told him. “He’s your age. But he’s... not very responsible. He spends his time travelling with questionable people, and my mother fears he’s going to get himself in trouble with the Redcoats one of these days.”

“It’s likely that we’ll all soon be in trouble with the Redcoats,” Bilbo said, and though it was said lightheartedly there was a serious tone to his voice.

“Aye,” Thorin agreed with a nod. “That is true.”

They walked on for a few more minutes in silence, before Bilbo continued, “You mentioned Fíli and Kíli earlier. Do you think Frankie is Fíli?”

Thorin seemed to think for a moment. “I’m confident that he is, aye,” he answered. “He looks much like Fíli did as a young child, and has the beginnings of his personality.”

“Do you suppose this next baby will be Kíli then?”

Thorin smiled. “I hope so,” he said. “Elspeth thinks that it will be a boy.”

“I never met your sister, in Middle-earth,” Bilbo said. “Her name was Dís, correct?” Thorin nodded, and Bilbo grinned. “I’m happy I met her here.”

Neither of them said anything for a few moments. The climb was now quite steep, but Bilbo assured Thorin that they were almost at their destination.

“In a month, these hills will be purple with heather,” he said, motioning to the area around them. “You can see a few flowers on the bushes already. I normally come here around then—that’s when it’s most beautiful.”

“I would love to see it,” Thorin said. “I do not know how long I’m staying, but I hope it will be long enough to see that.”

Bilbo smiled. “I do as well,” he said.

Thorin watched him for a moment before turning away and continuing to walk. They went on for a short while longer before finally stopping atop a large hill covered in long grass and bushes of heather. Loch Ness could now be seen much more clearly, as well as the surrounding mountains. Walking to the very top, Bilbo sat down and stretched out, smiling contentedly.

“It’s gorgeous up here,” Thorin said, sitting down beside Bilbo.

“It’s one of my favourite spots,” Bilbo said. “You can spend your entire day here and never see a soul.”

“It’s very peaceful.”

Bilbo looked at him, and it was almost as if he wanted to say something. Thorin thought he was going to, but then he looked away, picking at the leaves of a nearby heather bush. So instead they sat in silence, simply enjoying the view.

Finally, after several minutes had passed, Bilbo looked up from where he had been staring at the ground. He didn’t look at Thorin, instead focusing his gaze on the far-off horizon, and took in a deep breath.

“All last night, I was thinking,” he said. “About everything that happened in Middle-earth. The quest and the Company and my life after... And I remember thinking of you all the time and one day realizing that... I loved you. Quite a bit, I think.”

Thorin looked at him, his mouth slightly open. Bilbo had turned away, and was sitting completely frozen.

“I know it’s not an... acceptable thing to say,” he continued, still refusing to look at Thorin. “But I spent an entire lifetime regretting not saying it when I had the chance. I don’t want to miss that opportunity again. I’m... sorry, I guess.” He trailed off, not knowing what else to say.

“Bilbo,” Thorin said, reaching out and putting his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “Bilbo, please look at me.”

Reluctantly, Bilbo turned to face him, though he refused to meet his eyes. Thorin’s hand stayed on his shoulder.

“Do you still love me?” he asked.

Bilbo did nothing for a moment, before slowly nodding his head. “Yes,” he whispered, his voice barely audible.

Thorin smiled and moved his hand to Bilbo’s chin. His heart was pounding in his chest and it felt as if his entire body was shaking—he had loved Bilbo for a long time, though it had taken him a while to realize it and he had not been brave enough to tell him before he died. But he was telling him now, and that was all that mattered.

Tilting Bilbo’s head up, Thorin leaned in and kissed him. It was just a slight brush of their lips and they were only together for a few seconds, but Thorin felt all the breath leave his body. As he pulled away, Bilbo gave him an absolutely shocked look and he smiled, reaching down to grab Bilbo’s hands.

“I love you, too,” he confessed, and Bilbo’s shock turned to joy and he pulled Thorin close to kiss him once more.

◊◊◊

3 Weeks Later

Bilbo stood atop a tall hill overlooking Loch Oich, a musket in his hand and a sword at his waist. He was surrounded by several dozen of his clansmen, and Fergus stood in front of him, staring out across the lake. Just a few hours ago they had received news that a company of Royal Scots were travelling to the nearby Fort Augustus and had been waylaid by a small group of MacDonalds of Keppoch. Fergus had quickly gathered them all to prepare to fight and help the MacDonalds, their kinsman, and they had marched from Invergarry Castle only two hours ago. Now they stood waiting for the Redcoats to appear, knowing that they would try to seek refuge at the castle.

They did not have to wait long. Soon a group of about eighty men could be seen moving swiftly in their direction. Fergus gave the order for them to advance and they marched down the hill, preparing to confront the Redcoats. As they marched, Bilbo could see two other groups of Jacobites approaching the British soldiers and realized that the Royal Scots would soon be surrounded, being now far outnumbered.

In only a few minutes time, the Redcoats were completely surrounded by the Jacobites. Fergus ordered them to halt, and Bilbo stood with the others, watching as a group of MacDonalds of Keppoch approached the British soldiers and forced them to surrender. A short while later, Fergus turned them around and marched them back to Invergarry Castle.

No blood had been shed by the Jacobites and while no one said it aloud, they all knew that the Rising had unofficially begun.

◊◊◊

It was nearing the late afternoon, and the sun was just beginning to descend into the west. Thorin was strolling through the gardens of the castle with Dís and Fíli, watching as the young boy ran ahead to explore. In Dís’s arms was a small bundle, wrapped tightly in a blanket—Thorin’s younger nephew, just over a week old. He had come two weeks before the midwife thought he would, but he was perfectly healthy and just the right size. Dís and Víli had named him Christopher, but the moment Thorin had first held him he had known that he was Kíli. He had struggled to keep from crying, and had apologized to him as quietly as he could over and over again.

Now, one week later, Thorin could still barely contain his disbelief whenever he looked at his youngest nephew. It almost felt like he had been transported back in time, back to Middle-earth and the drafty halls of Ered Luin. Dís had teased him for acting so sentimental, and Thorin had just laughed it off.

Beside him, Kíli started crying, rousing Thorin from his thoughts. Dís quickly started comforting the baby, hushing him and rocking him gently. She looked stressed, and Thorin couldn’t blame her. It had now been several hours since Fergus had left the castle with dozens of clansmen to go help in a fight against a battalion of Redcoats, and both Víli and Bilbo had been among them. Thorin had wished to join them, but had been in the forest with Fíli when Douglas had arrived to collect Víli, and by the time he had returned they had all left. So instead he had decided to take his sister and young nephews for a walk, hoping to distract both himself and Dís, who was driving herself mad with worry.

“Don’t fret so much, Elspeth,” he told her as they walked, reminding himself not to call her Dís. Though she hadn’t said anything, he knew that she was thinking about her husband.

“You should take your own advice, dear brother,” she said, scoffing. “You look just as worried as I feel.”

“I just wish I was there with them,” Thorin said. “I feel useless here.”

“It’s not some grand battle they’re marching off to,” Dís said. “Simply some... skirmish with the Redcoats. There is no reason for either of us to be worried.”

“Yet here we are,” Thorin said with a laugh.

“Aye,” Dís said, looking down at her baby with a sad look. “Here we are, spending your last day with us anxious and worried.”

Thorin frowned. He did not want to go, but he had responsibilities to tend to. He would be leaving Dís and his nephews in the morning, though he would not immediately return home. First he would accompany the MacDonells to Glenfinnan, where a meeting between the Jacobites and Prince Charles had been planned, and afterwards would return to his home with a small group of MacDonalds.

Thankfully, however, he knew he would soon return. Dís had invited him to come for Christmas and he had accepted, knowing it would give him more time with both his nephews and Bilbo.  

His thoughts were interrupted by a sudden commotion at the front of the castle. They both paused for a moment, and then Dís was rushing towards the front of the building, where many loud voices could be heard. Thorin wanted to follow after her immediately, but he had to find Fíli first. The little boy was still wandering along the path further ahead, oblivious to anything else that was happening.

“Frankie!” Thorin called, hurrying towards him. “Come on—Da’s back!”

Fíli brightened immediately, letting Thorin take his hand and lead him to the front of the castle. A large group of men were gathered there, all with muskets and swords. Though they looked tired, none were injured—Thorin didn’t see a single man with a bandage or cut anywhere. Hoisting Fíli up into his arms, Thorin moved slowly through the large crowd, searching for his sister. He found her after a few minutes, standing off to the side with Víli. He only stayed for a moment, handing Fíli off to his father, before leaving the small family alone.

He wandered around for a short while before finally spotting Bilbo. He had to keep himself from running to him, but he still quickened his pace, clasping both hands on Bilbo’s shoulders when he reached him.

“Are you alright?” he asked, searching him for any sign of an injury, and Bilbo smiled, nodding.

“I’m perfectly fine,” he answered. “Just a bit tired.”

Thorin let out a relieved sigh. “I’m so glad,” he said. “I was so worried.”

“We didn’t even use our weapons,” Bilbo told him. “We simply surrounded them, and they surrendered. Hardly even a fight—we didn’t lose a single man.”

Thorin smiled. “That’s excellent news,” he said.

Bilbo nodded, before looking to the castle step where his family stood. “I have to go now,” he said. “I’m sorry. My aunt will be looking for me. But meet me later, on the path to your sister’s home. We’ll talk more then.”

“Aye,” Thorin said, with a nod, and Bilbo was gone, disappearing into the crowd. That was how things had been between them for the past three weeks—in public, they would say a few quick words to each other and then go their separate ways. Then, later, they would meet secretly and wander away to somewhere far from the village where no one could stumble upon them. They spent as much time as they could together without arousing suspicion, but that meant only a few hours each day. And soon Thorin would be leaving, and it would be months before he saw him again.

“Alasdair, there you are!” Thorin turned to see Dís walking towards him, Víli trailing behind her with Fíli in his arms. “Come on,” she said, grabbing his arm. “Let’s go home.”

◊◊◊

Bilbo stood leaning against a tree, a book open in his hands. He was at the end of the long path that lead to Rory’s house, lined by a thin forest. From where he stood, he could just barely see the edge of the house, and he was constantly looking up from his book and down the path, hoping to see Thorin.

He finally appeared just as the sun was beginning to set. Bilbo met him halfway down the path and they ducked into the forest, where a narrow trail cut its way through the trees and out of the village. As soon as they were out of sight, Bilbo grabbed Thorin’s hand and pulled him close, relishing in the fact that they were free to be together.

“I’m glad that you made it out alright,” Thorin said, lifting Bilbo’s hand and kissing the back of it. “I would have gone with you, but I was in the forest with Fíli when your cousin arrived to collect Rory. I did not know that you had gone until I returned.”

“It was not much fun anyways,” Bilbo said with a smile. “We just walked to the other end of Loch Oich and back.”

“Still, I heard that two Redcoats were killed,” Thorin said. “And tomorrow we leave for Glenfinnan. Prince Charles is really here, in Scotland. Do you suppose this all means there’s truly going to be a rebellion?”

Bilbo was quiet for a moment, worrying his bottom lip between his teeth. “I suppose it does,” he agreed after a moment. Though he seemed anxious, he smiled. “Perhaps at the end, we shall have a Stuart on the throne.”

“It is not so easy to reclaim a throne,” Thorin said. “I speak from personal experience—it does not always end as you hoped.”

Bilbo frowned. “I’m sorry,” he said. “I—”

“Do not be,” Thorin cut in quickly, before Bilbo could say anything else. “I never thought I would live to retake my throne. But I had always hoped that at least one of nephews would become king.”

“Dáin was a good king,” Bilbo said, leaning against Thorin’s shoulder. “At least that’s what Balin told me.”

“I’m sure he was a great king,” Thorin said with a smile.

“You would have made an excellent king, as well,” Bilbo said. They were both silent for a moment before he continued, “Do you really have to leave, once the meeting’s over?”

Thorin sighed, slowing his walk and resting his head on top of Bilbo’s. “Aye, unfortunately,” he replied. “My parents expect me home, and now that my father’s so old he cannot run the estate alone. I cannot stay here forever, though I would love to.”

“I could go with you,” Bilbo suggested. “I’ll make up some lie for my family—I don’t even care if they believe me. I just got you back, Thorin. I’d rather you not leave me again.”

Thorin paused and took a step back, taking Bilbo’s face in his hands. “I’m not leaving you,” he said. “I promise you that. I will never leave you again. Dís has invited me to come for Christmas, so we will be together again before long.”

Bilbo frowned. “You had better write to me,” he said. “Every week, until you come back.”

“I’ll write to you every day if I can,” Thorin promised, and leaned in to kiss him.

◊◊◊

They left for Glenfinnan the next morning. Thorin said goodbye to Dís and his nephews as he and Víli left to join the others at the castle, hugging them tightly and promising that he’d be back in a few months. As they rode off down the path, Fíli waved and called to them, crying out his goodbyes until they were out of sight.

There were a few dozen men already gathered at the castle when they arrived. Many would be riding to Glenfinnan, but others would be walking—Glenfinnan was not too far, but it would take them about ten hours to reach it, as they were all travelling as a group. They would be joined along the way by other members of Clan MacDonell, and would most likely reach Glenfinnan shortly after nightfall.

As they approached the castle, Thorin quickly spotted Bilbo standing with Douglas, holding the reins of a horse in one hand. He looked annoyed about something, though his cousin was laughing. Dismounting, he and Víli walked over to the two, their horses in tow.

“Have you been forced to ride a horse, Ben?” Víli asked, grinning.

Bilbo’s scowl grew deeper. “I have, aye,” he said, huffing and glaring at the horse beside him. “I do not see why I can’t just walk.”

“You’re much too slow, Benny,” Douglas told him with a smirk. “Whenever you walk it is as if you’re simply out for a stroll, no matter the actual situation. You’d just slow us down.”

“Do you not like horses?” Thorin asked.

Bilbo shook his head. “I’ve never liked horses,” he answered. “And they don’t seem to like me either. I cannot tell you how many times I’ve been kicked in the chest—”

“That’s because you don’t care for them properly,” Douglas interrupted. “You’re too careless. It’s your own fault you get kicked in the chest.”

“No, I think the bastards just have it out for me,” Bilbo argued. “But even if they didn’t I still would not want to spend ten hours on one.”

“Well I suppose you’ll just have to put up with it,” Douglas said. “Now finish getting ready, for Christ’s sake. We’ll be leaving soon.”

They left about half an hour later. Most of those with horses rode in the front, followed by those on foot with the rest of the riders at the back. Thorin ended up at the back with Víli, while Bilbo and Douglas rode at the front. As the hours passed, however, the groups mixed together, until men from the front were riding near the back beside those on foot. In this way, Thorin ended up near Bilbo and the two slowly moved closer together until they were side-by-side. They stayed like that for the rest of the ride, talking about average, everyday things.

When they finally reached Glenfinnan, the sun had sunken below the horizons and the stars were slowly becoming visible. They set up camp just outside of town and had a quick supper; some stayed up later, talking around the fires, but most retired to their tents, tired from the long trek. As Thorin was about to enter the tent he was sharing with Víli, he caught sight of Bilbo standing a few tents down. He stood, watching him for a moment, until Bilbo noticed him and gave him a tired, but happy, smile and disappeared into his own tent.

◊◊◊

It was raining the next morning when Bilbo woke up. The air was chilly, and he wrapped himself up tighter in his blanket, wanting nothing more than to stay there and sleep some more, though the ground was hard and not at all comfortable. Unfortunately, Drogo was there a few minutes later to rouse him up onto his feet.

“Come on, Benny,” he said, bursting through the tent flap. “You’ve slept enough—there’s no sense in sleeping all morning.”

“You’re letting in the rain,” Bilbo whined, waving an arm at his cousin to try and get him to leave. “Go away, Drogo, I can wake up on my own.”

Drogo chuckled. “Are you sure?” he asked. “Because you just called me by someone else’s name. I think you’re more asleep than you realize.”

Bilbo said nothing for a moment, before sitting up with a sigh. “There, I’m awake,” he announced, glaring at Drogo. “Are you satisfied?”

“Don’t be so cranky,” Drogo said, making a face back at his cousin. “Just get dressed and come have something to eat.” With that, he left the tent, letting the flap swing back into place.

A few minutes later Bilbo stepped out into the rain, pulling a jacket over his shoulders. It wasn’t a heavy rain, but it was enough to make everyone damp and cold. Drogo was sitting by a small fire, and as he approached him a bowl of food was passed to him.

“Sorry it’s not warm,” he apologized as Bilbo sat down beside him. “It’s almost impossible to keep a big fire going in this weather.”

Bilbo nodded in understanding and ate the food quickly while Drogo talked.

“Fergus has gone to meet with the chief of Clan MacDonald of Clanranald,” he explained. “I think they’re going to meet Prince Charles, as well.”

“When is the main meeting to take place?” Bilbo asked, setting the spoon down in the bowl.

“Tomorrow, I believe,” Drogo answered. “There are going to be hundreds of people there, from all over the Highlands, all here to show their support for Prince Charles. We could actually win this, Ben.”

“Let us hope that we do,” Bilbo replied.

◊◊◊

The Jacobite Rising began officially the next day. The assembled highlanders gathered near a hill just outside Glenfinnan, where Prince Charles raised his father’s standard and announced his claim to the thrones of Scotland and England. As the pipers played and cries for victory rang out, Bilbo caught sight of Thorin across the crowd and smiled. Beside him, Drogo yelled out in joy and slung his arm across his cousin’s shoulders, and Thorin returned his smile with a wide grin.

◊◊◊

It was early the following morning before Bilbo was able to see Thorin. They had both been too busy the day before to find any time together, and Thorin had quietly woken Bilbo up before the sun had even risen to say goodbye. They stood in the forest now, not too far from the camp but far enough away that no one would be able to see them.

“I’ll be back soon,” Thorin promised, taking Bilbo’s hands into his own and pressing them to his lips. “I will write to you whenever I can until then.”

“Then we’ll figure out a way for us to be together,” Bilbo said. “I will not let you leave without me again after this.”

Thorin nodded. “I would not want to leave without you again,” he said, and pulled him close, one hand tangling itself into Bilbo’s hair.

“Be safe on your way home,” Bilbo told him, burying his face into Thorin’s shoulder. “Don’t die on me again.”

“I shall try my best not to,” Thorin said with a chuckle. Bilbo pulled back and reached up to kiss him, cupping his face in his hands.

“We should probably go back now,” he said after a moment. “They’ll be looking for you.”

Thorin sighed, nodding, and took Bilbo’s hand in his. They didn’t say much during the short walk back to the camp, and were quick to go their separate ways once they left the forest, departing with nothing more than a glance at each other.

Bilbo did not go with Rory to see Thorin off; instead, he stayed with Drogo and helped him pack up their camp. If they wanted to make it back to Invergarry that day, they would have to leave within the hour. Many other clans were staying in Glenfinnan for a few more days, but Fergus wished to return home, saying that there was much planning that needed to be done as quickly as possible. They left soon after Rory returned, travelling throughout the day and reaching Invergarry shortly after nightfall.

◊◊◊

4 Months Later

There was thin layer of snow on the ground when Thorin once again stopped his horse in front of his sister’s home. Looking back, he watched his brother bring his own horse to a halt. Frerin had appeared quite suddenly at his house only a few days before and Thorin had made him promise that he would go with him to visit their sister, and to his surprise Frerin had kept that promise.

Jumping down from his horse, he walked over to his brother, clasping a hand on his shoulder. “We’ll put the horses in the stable later,” he said. “For now, let’s go inside and see Elspeth and the boys.”

Dís opened the door when they knocked, and nearly fell flat on her face when she saw Frerin standing behind Thorin. “Ronald MacElheran!” she cried. “I thought you’d dropped off the face of the Earth! How... What... What are you doing here?”

“I’ve come to see you and your new bairn,” Frerin said, smiling widely. “It’s been much too long since I last visited.”

“That it has!” Dís agreed, laughing. “Now come inside, you fools, before you let out all the warmth.”

“Now don’t believe that he came here simply because he wanted to,” Thorin said as they stepped inside, stomping the snow off their boots. “He showed up with no warning on my doorstep less than a week ago and I made him promise that he’d come with me to visit you.”

“I’m still glad that he’s here,” Dís said, hugging her younger brother tightly. “Though I’ve half a mind to beat him for disappearing like that all the time.”

“Do not worry, I’ve already done it for you,” Thorin said with a smirk.

“I’m sure you have,” Dís said, pulling back and leading them down a hallway into the parlour, where her maid Mary stood waiting. “Make some tea, please, Mary, and get Effie to bring the boys down,” she told her, and Mary nodded, leaving the room with a quick curtsy.

“Where’s Rory?” Thorin asked sitting down in one of the chairs near the fire; Dís took the other, and Frerin sat down on the couch.

“He has gone to the castle,” Dís explained. “Half of the clan is away in England, and Rory heard that a messenger had arrived with news of them, so he went to see what it was. The chieftain and his grandson, Douglas, are there fighting, as is his nephew, Ben, and you know that Rory is good friends with them both. He’s been worried ever since they left.”

Thorin frowned. He had known that Bilbo was in England; he had told him in his last letter, dated early November. He had not wanted to go, knowing that if he did he wouldn’t be back when Thorin returned, but his cousin had persuaded him. He had apologized profusely before ending his letter, promising that he would come back as soon as possible.

“Do you know how long he’ll be?” Thorin asked, anxious to hear the news himself.  

Dís shrugged. “He only left a short while ago,” she said. “But he knows you’re arriving today, so he’ll be quick. I expect he’ll be home in less than an hour.”

Thorin nodded, tightly clasping his hands together. Dís then turned to Frerin, asking him about what he’d been doing since she last saw him. Thorin had heard most of the story already so he barely listened as Frerin told their sister. Mary arrived soon after with their tea, and a few moments after the nanny, Effie, arrived with Fíli and Kíli.

“Hello there, Frankie,” Thorin greeted his oldest nephew. The boy giggled happily and hurried to his uncle, crawling up onto his lap.

“Hello, Uncle,” he said, smiling widely. “I missed you!”

“I missed you too, laddie,” Thorin said with a grin. “Have you been enjoying being an older brother?”

Fíli nodded proudly, looking over to where Kíli was now cradled in his mother’s arm. “He’s really tiny,” he said.

“You named him Christopher, aye?” Frerin asked, and Dís nodded, taking the baby from Effie.

“Would you like to hold him?” she asked him, and Frerin seemed to hesitate for a moment before nodding. Dís stood, walking over to where he sat and gently laid Kíli in his arms, positioning them correctly.

“Don’t look so terrified,” Thorin joked, and Frerin scowled at him before looking back to the baby.

“His hair is so dark,” he observed. “He looks like you, Elspeth.”

Dís smiled. “Rory thinks he looks like Alasdair,” she said, and Frerin let out a loud laugh, grabbing the baby’s small hand and shaking it gently.

“He kind of does,” he agreed. “And Dad, too; they all have the same nose.”

“He’s going to quite handsome one day,” Thorin said.

Dís laughed. “Of course he is,” she said. “His mother is very beautiful.”

Frerin shrugged. “She’s alright,” he teased, smirking, and Dís glared at him.

Watching the two, Thorin smiled. It had been a long time since he had last been together with his siblings, and it had been even longer since he had known them as Dís and Frerin. By the time Fíli was born, Frerin had been dead for sixty years, and when Erebor was finally reclaimed it had been nearly a century and a half since Thorin had seen his brother. Thorin often thought that Fíli and Kíli were much like the uncle they never knew, though they grew to be much older than he ever was. Hopefully in this life, things would be different.

◊◊◊

Víli returned home as Thorin and Frerin were putting their horses in the stable. He greeted them as he walked his own horse into its stall, his face red from the cold. Though he seemed surprised to see Frerin, he didn’t say much on the matter, instead asking how their trip was and if they had been inside yet.

“Aye, we arrived about an hour ago,” Thorin said, nodding.

“I’m sorry I wasn’t there,” Víli apologized. “I was at the castle. A messenger arrived earlier with news of the men in England, and I went to hear what it was.”

“Elspeth told us,” Thorin said. “It was good news, I hope?”

Víli frowned, shaking his head. “They are in retreat, heading north back towards Scotland,” he replied. “There are three British armies waiting for them further south, and they simply do not have the men to fight them.”

“Have any MacDonells been killed?” Thorin asked, anxious to hear confirmation that Bilbo was alright.

“No, not yet,” Víli said, and Thorin fought the urge to sigh in relief. “There have been a few small injuries, as there have been several minor confrontations, but nothing big. Hopefully that doesn’t change.”

“Would the British not try to stop their retreat?” Frerin asked, leaning against a post with his arms crossed over his chest.

“They probably will,” Víli answered, scowling. “Let us just hope that nothing major comes of it.”

From where he stood brushing his horse, Thorin frowned. If Bilbo did not make it back safely, he didn’t know what he would do.

◊◊◊

1 Week Later

It was Christmas Eve when, coming over a hill, Bilbo at last saw Invergarry Castle. He and the rest of the men from MacDonell of Glengarry that had gone to England had spent the last several days marching, hoping to reach home as quickly as possible. A few had already left them, and while for some the march would end at Invergarry most still had a day or two left, though they would stay the night in the village before continuing in the morning.

From there it only took them a couple of hours to reach the castle. As they arrived, they were greeted by many people from the town, most of whom were the wives and other family members of the men.

As Bilbo was greeted by his own family, he anxiously searched the crowd, hoping to at least catch a glimpse of Thorin. Though he didn’t see him, he did find Rory, who quickly came to greet both him and Drogo.

“I am glad you two made it back alright,” he said, putting a hand on each of their shoulders. “I wish I could have joined you.”

“It wasn’t much fun,” Drogo said with a grin. “I would have preferred to be here with you.”

“It is good that you were there with your new baby, though,” Bilbo said. “I will have to visit soon and see how he has grown.”

“It seems as if he grows every day,” Rory said. “It is hard to believe he is already four months old.”

“Has Elspeth’s brother returned yet?” Bilbo asked. “I heard that he would be coming back for Christmas.”

“Aye, he returned about a week ago,” Rory answered. “Her other brother, Ronald, was him as well, which was quite the surprise. She hasn’t seen him in over a year.”

“That is a nice surprise,” Drogo agreed. “Will we be seeing you all at the dinner tomorrow? My mother has only just told me that it’s been planned, though I’m sure you’ve already heard.”

Rory laughed, nodding. “Yes, I have already told Edna that we will be there,” he said. “She was ecstatic when I said that Elspeth’s brothers would be with us, as well.”

“Oh, I’m sure she was,” Drogo said with a chuckle. “If my mother has planned it, then most of the town will be there.”

“Your mother’s dinners are always the best,” Rory agreed.

He left soon after that, and Bilbo and Drogo retreated inside, glad to be home, though it would only be for a short while.

◊◊◊

Invergarry’s great hall was already full of people when Thorin arrived with his siblings and Víli. There was a large fire burning in the hearth, and outside snow was falling against the backdrop of a setting sun, creating a very picturesque Christmas scene. In addition to the head table at the front of the room, there were two longer tables in the middle, where the guests would be seated, already laden with plates.

Though he didn’t see Bilbo at first, shortly after their arrival Fergus asked them all to be seated and Bilbo appeared, sitting down across from Frerin. He gave Thorin a wide smile as he sat down, greeting them all happily.

“Ronald, this is my good friend, Ben,” Víli introduced, motioning to Bilbo. “Ben, this is Elspeth and Alasdair’s younger brother, Ronald.”

“Very nice to meet you,” Bilbo said, reaching across the table to shake Frerin’s hand.

“You as well,” Frerin said, smiling.

Before the meal was served, Fergus stood and spoke a few words, mainly about how lucky they had been to return from England with all their men in time to celebrate Christmas. He also spoke about how, while it seemed that they had failed in England, they would soon return and come out victorious, with a Stuart on the throne. His speech was greeted with loud cheers and applause, and as he sat back down the food was brought out and served.

Everyone was cheerful throughout dinner; though many had been unhappy about the defeat in England, Fergus’s speech had renewed hope in them, and they talked excitedly about what the future may bring.

“The new year shall be wonderful,” Dís said with a smile. “Though it will not be easy, I know that we will win.”

“That we shall,” Víli said, nodding in agreement.

“If we had more men, it would become much easier,” Bilbo said. “We retreated from England because we were outnumbered; if we had continued south, we would have been slaughtered. The more men we have, the better chance we have of winning.”

“Then we will find more men, whatever it takes,” Víli said, a determined look on his face.

Thorin frowned. “If only it were so easy,” he said, though no one seemed to hear him.

◊◊◊

After dinner, the tables were moved the side to make space for dancing, and cheerful music played as couples spun and reeled across the floor. As Thorin stood watching Dís and Víli dance, Bilbo walked up beside him, his hands clasped behind his back.

“Can you meet me in the gardens in a few minutes?” he asked, just loud enough for Thorin to hear over the laughter and music.

Slowly, he nodded, and Bilbo smiled, reaching out to just barely brush his arm as he walked away. Thorin’s eyes followed him as he left, quickly disappearing out one of the side doors. Thorin waited until the current song was finished, and as a new one started up he made his way across the room to the main doors, slipping out as quietly as possible.

Bilbo was standing in the middle of the gardens beside what, in the summer, had been a large flowerbed but was now bare, covered in snow. Thorin nearly ran to him as he walked outside, wrapping his arms around his neck and pulling him close.

“I was so worried for you,” Thorin whispered, reaching one hand up to stroke Bilbo’s snow-covered hair. “I’m so glad you’re alright.”

“There was hardly any fighting,” Bilbo assured him, resting his forehead on Thorin’s shoulder. “I didn’t even get scratched. But I’ve missed you. Every day since you left I’ve missed you.”

“I missed you, too,” Thorin said, and pulling back he kissed Bilbo, cupping his cold cheeks in his hands.

Bilbo smiled, laughing as they pulled apart. “You’ve become careless,” he commented, though he didn’t seem to mind.

“We’re in a garden in the middle of December,” Thorin said. “It’s snowing and absolutely freezing. Only fools would be out here.”

“I have always known you were a fool,” Bilbo said, reaching up to run his fingers through Thorin’s hair. “I wish I could stay here with you forever, but we’re leaving again in a couple of weeks. The Lord only knows when I will see you again after that.”

“Hopefully not too long,” Thorin said. “I will be returning home in a week, and soon after that I will be joining the army as a member of Clan MacDonald. We may very well run into each other out there.”

“That would be nice,” Bilbo said with a somewhat sad smile. “Though now I will spend all my time worrying about you.”

“And I’ll spend all mine worrying about you,” Thorin said, smirking. “Though I think I can handle myself in a fight.”

Bilbo furrowed his eyebrows. “You died in a battle, if you’ve forgotten,” he said.

“But I took Azog with me,” Thorin pointed out.

“Please try not to die this time,” Bilbo said, bringing his hand down to rest on Thorin’s cheek.

“I will not die,” Thorin assured him. “I promise you that.”

◊◊◊

3 Weeks Later

The rain was pouring down in buckets. From where he was crouching, obscured behind a small hill, Bilbo could see very little of what was happening in front of him. The strong wind was whipping the stinging rain into his face, and all he could hear above the roar of the storm were the sounds of hooves and gunshots. He had a dirk clutched tightly in his hand as he waited for the perfect moment to strike, listening as carefully as he could to what was happening atop the hill.

As he sat there, the cold rain soaking through his clothes, he remembered making his way through the chaos of battle a long time ago, though then the enemy was an army of Orcs. Now it was an army of British soldiers, and Bilbo found that he had a harder time justifying their deaths than those of the Orcs.

Still, he only hesitated for a moment when the sound of hooves grew close. Within seconds he was on his feet at the top of the hill, his dirk slicing through the neck of a horse. The animal veered sharply to the side, and Bilbo slashed at its rider, who fell to the ground with a thud. He didn’t stay to see if the man had died, instead hurrying away as quickly as he could.

All around him was chaos—Jacobites ran in every direction, most wearing the MacDonald tartan, though he saw a few Camerons and MacPhersons. Very few Redcoats remained; most had already fled, and those who were still within sight were being relentlessly pursued. He could hear gunshots going off nearby, though he could not see where. The torrential rain obscured everything, and it was impossible to see further than a few metres in front of him.

“Ben!”

Suddenly Drogo was at his side, his breaths coming heavy as rainwater dripped down his face. “Are you alright?” he asked, and Bilbo nodded. “Come on, then. Let’s get the rest of these Redcoat bastards.” Grinning, Drogo nudged Bilbo along and they ran forward, chasing after the quickly vanishing British soldiers. In the chaos, however, he quickly lost sight of his cousin, but he kept running forward.

Out of the corner of his eye, he saw someone rushing towards him and turned to see Thorin, every inch of him soaking wet with mud up to his knees.

“Bilbo!’ he cried, slowing to a stop right beside him. “You’re alright? You haven’t been hurt?”

Bilbo shook his head, smiling despite the circumstances. Thorin had arrived only a few days ago with a contingent of MacDonald men, and while they had seen very little of each other since, just knowing that Thorin was nearby had made Bilbo feel more calm, though they were both now in the midst of danger.

“I’m perfectly alright,” Bilbo said, one hand on Thorin’s shoulder. “And you’re alright, as well?”

Thorin nodded, smirking. “Of course I am,” he answered. “I’m a seasoned warrior. It’ll take more than a few fleeing Redcoats on horses to hurt me.”

Bilbo laughed. Behind Thorin, another MacDonald appeared and hurried towards them. Bilbo quickly took his hand off of Thorin’s shoulder as he approached.

“Alasdair,” the man said, and as he drew closer Bilbo realized that he looked strikingly familiar. “There you are; come on. There are a few Redcoats up ahead, towards the northeast, and if we hurry we can get them before they run off.”

Thorin nodded. “Aye, I’m coming,” he said, before looking back to Bilbo. “Will you come, as well?”

Bilbo didn’t respond at first, too busy trying to figure out why that man looked so familiar. “Oh, ah, no, I can’t,” he replied, finally turning his attention back to Thorin. “I have to find Drogo, and I think he went a different way. But afterwards I’ll try to find you.”

“Alright,” Thorin said with a nod, and turned to leave with the man, who had already started walking away. As he was about to leave, however, Bilbo finally remembered who the man reminded him of, and reached out to stop Thorin.

“Wait, was that—”

“Dwalin, aye,” Thorin responded with a grin. “Just the same as always, though he looks quite different without all his tattoos. But we’ll talk about that later—go find your cousin.”

Bilbo nodded, watching as the two quickly disappeared into the rain before turning and running off in the direction Drogo had gone. There were now very few people around; he didn’t see anyone as he ran, climbing over the many hills that covered the landscape, and he could no longer hear any gunshots in the distance.

He had been running for around ten minutes when he suddenly heard the sound of hooves on the ground behind him. Bilbo turned, hoping to have time to duck behind the crest of a nearby hill, but saw instead a British soldier on horseback only a few metres away. The soldier had a pistol in his hand and he quickly raised it when he saw Bilbo, standing exposed with only a dagger.

Before Bilbo even had time to react the soldier fired and there was a loud bang. A sudden pain bloomed in the right side of Bilbo’s chest and within seconds he was on his knees. The soldier watched him for a moment before galloping off, and through the haze that was clouding his mind Bilbo could see someone running up the hill towards him. As the person approached Bilbo realized that is was Thorin, though his vision was starting to blur.

“John!” Thorin yelled, and for a moment Bilbo wondered who John was before he saw Dwalin climbing the hill after Thorin. “John, go get help! Quickly!”

As Dwalin ran off, Thorin fell to the ground beside Bilbo, taking him in his arms and pressing on his wound.

“You’re going to be alright,” he was saying, and Bilbo smiled, reaching up to touch his face. “Bilbo, do you hear me? You’re going to be alright.” Thorin grasped Bilbo’s hand in his own, and his fingers were stained red, leaving streaks of blood on his cheek.

“What... are you doing here?” Bilbo asked, every word a struggle.

“I’ve been chasing that Redcoat bastard for the past five minutes,” Thorin answered.

“Oh...” Bilbo said, taking in deep, laboured breaths. “I never knew... how much it hurts to get shot. I just... I just want it end.”

Thorin shook his head, tightening his grip on Bilbo’s hand. “You’re going to be okay,” he said. “Dwalin’s going to get help and you’re going to be alright.”

Bilbo smiled, blinking as the rain fell in his eyes. “This is all very... familiar,” he observed. “Except last time... I held you as you died.”

“Don’t say that,” Thorin said, holding back the tears that were welling in his eyes. “You’re not going to die. I promise you that—you’re not going to die.”

“Do you think we’ll see each other again?” Bilbo asked. “In some other place... and time?”

“You won’t die,” Thorin said, the tears now flowing freely. “Not here and not today.”

“I’m sorry, Thorin,” Bilbo whispered, lowering his hand from where it was still pressed against Thorin’s cheek. “I’m so sorry... for leaving you. I know how it feels... to be left behind.” His breathing had become shallow, and his words were now slurring together. “I love you... more than anything.”

“No, no, don’t you dare,” Thorin sobbed, struggling to speak through his tears. “Don’t you dare die. Don’t leave me, Bilbo. Please...” He trailed off as Bilbo’s breathing slowly stopped and he stilled, his eyes staring blindly at the stormy sky above.

◊◊◊

Dwalin returned a few minutes later, with Víli and several other MacDonald men in tow. Thorin was still kneeling on the cold ground, Bilbo’s body cradled in his arms. Though the torrential rain had washed most of the blood from his hands, the front of his shirt was still stained with red and a bloody streak ran from his cheek down to his chest.

He looked up as they approached, and Víli ran towards him, his face paling as he grew closer.  He skidded to a stop in front of him, frantically looking between Thorin and Bilbo. “Alasdair? Alasdair, what’s happened?” he asked, putting a hand on each of Thorin’s shoulders.

“He... he was shot,” Thorin said, fumbling over his words. “I tried to save him,” he continued, swallowing back the tears that were threatening to spill over again. “But I couldn’t... I couldn’t do it, Ví—Rory... I’m sorry.”

Víli said nothing for a moment, simply falling to the ground beside Thorin. “We need... we need to get him back to camp,” he said, moving Thorin’s hands, which were still resting on Bilbo’s chest. “This storm’s getting worse. We have to hurry.”

Numb, Thorin nodded and stood. They had brought a stretcher to carry Bilbo back, and he watched as they lifted his lifeless body onto it, following after as they carried it away. Víli walked beside him, one hand on his brother-in-law’s shoulder, and Dwalin walked further ahead, his expression stony. No one spoke as they made their way off the battlefield, and Thorin tried not to break down crying.

◊◊◊

The next morning the sky was clear, and Thorin awoke in a warm room buried under a pile of blankets. The clear weather revealed a battlefield littered with the bodies of British soldiers—over three hundred of their seven thousand men had been killed, and another three hundred had been captured. Just over fifty out of the eight thousand Jacobites had been killed, and their bodies had all been collected for burial.

Thorin tried not to show how much Bilbo’s death affected him. To the knowledge of everyone else they had simply been acquaintances—nothing more. Still, it was difficult to pretend to even be somewhat happy over their enormous success. All he felt was overwhelming guilt and sadness.

A few days later, the dead were buried. Afterwards, Douglas spoke about how everything felt empty without Bilbo. They had been like brothers since they were six-years-old, and now that he was gone—truly gone—nothing felt right. Thorin had felt like that at the death of his own brother when he was fifty-three, and he felt it again now, though in a slightly different way.

Later that night, after everyone had gone to bed, Thorin slipped outside and walked to the graveyard. Wooden crosses marked where the dead were buried, and he quickly found Bilbo’s. Benjamin MacDonell was etched into the wood, along with the dates September 12, 1722 and January 17, 1746.

Kneeling on the cold, soggy ground, Thorin put one hand on the cross. “If I could take this death from you, I would,” he said, his voice barely above a whisper. “And I would give it to myself, for you do not deserve this. Death does not suit you.” He paused for a moment, giving a small, sad smile to the ground. “We’ll meet again. I don’t know when or where it will be, but I’ll make sure it happens. I... I love you, more than I ever realized I could. So farewell, Master Burglar, until we meet again.”

He stood, his hand lingering on the cross, before he turned and walked away. He didn’t look back as he left, instead turning his gaze up to the moon, which shone brightly in the cloudless sky.

Notes:

Characters
Ben - Bilbo
Alasdair - Thorin
Douglas - Drogo
Margaret - Primula
Elspeth - Dís
Rory - Víli
Frankie - Fíli
Christopher - Kíli
Fergus - Largo
I'm sorry this chapter is so long, I really didn't mean for it to get over 10k words. The next one will definitely be shorter because this one had a lot of establishing stuff, and the next one will take a lot less time to write. A big part of the reason I'm writing this fic is to get myself into the habit of writing every day because right now it takes me like a month to write one chapter and I really want to change that. So I'm hoping the next chapter will be out before November and that's what I'll be aiming for, but it might not happen. Updates will probably be pretty irregular, especially for the first several chapters. There's probably going to be somewhere around 15-18 chapters, so hopefully by the end it'll take around two weeks for me to write one chapter.