Actions

Work Header

Remember Me

Chapter 2: By Ancient Hills

Summary:

Present-Day Ireland, 104 BCE
3rd Life
The farmer and the warrior

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Use more force! Your blows are too weak!”

Trenaccatus stood in the middle of a large field, his arms crossed over his chest. In front of him, his nephews lunged at each with swords and shields, yelling and trying their best to knock the other off their feet.

“You can do better than that, Caliacas,” Trenaccatus called, slowly circling the two as they sparred. His youngest nephew glanced at him, his split-second distraction giving his older brother the chance to kick his feet out from under him and press the tip of his sword against his throat.

Caliacas glared at his brother. “That is not fair,” he argued, and Trenaccatus smirked.

“Do not get so easily distracted,” he said, leaning over his nephew. “Now come, on your feet. Try again.”

Caliacas groaned, pushing his brother’s sword out of the way so he could sit up. “Can we not take a break?” he asked. “We have been sparring since it was dark, and the sun has now risen.”

“But it is not yet high in the sky,” Trenaccatus pointed out. “You will spar for a while longer. If you do not practice, you will not learn.”

“Come, Caliacas,” his brother, Vendubaras, said. “The quicker you are on your feet the sooner our rest will be.”

Caliacas scowled, but still stood, readjusting his sword in his hand. “Then let’s do what we must,” he said with a slight sigh.

Vendubaras grinned, waiting for his brother to prepare himself before charging with his sword held high. Caliacas easily blocked his blow with his shield, and the two continued swinging and attacking each other while their uncle watched, attentive of their every move.

He had been training them since they had come to live with him two years ago, when Vendubaras was sixteen and Caliacas was only thirteen. They had received some training from their father, but Trenaccatus was much more stern and strict than he had been—he had his nephews practice nearly every day for several hours, carefully watching them himself to ensure that they made no mistakes. While they often complained about it, the relentless training had drastically improved their skills, and they only improved more with each day.

After another hour of sparring, Trenaccatus finally allowed them to stop, and they returned to the village, only a short walk from the field where they often trained. It was a large village, with nearly one hundred inhabitants living in many small, round huts. The entire area was surrounded by a large palisade, and the smoke from several fires could be seen rising into the sky from a great distance. The gate was open that morning, as people were out in the fields harvesting the fall crop and preparing it for storage and were often moving from the village to crop fields.

The streets were full of people as Trenaccatus lead his nephews through the village to their home. Many people sat outside their huts, socializing as they weaved or carved, despite the autumn cold. Several of them cried out in greeting to Trenaccatus as he passed, and he responded happily. He had lived in this village for his entire life, and knew the names of each one of its inhabitants, just as everyone knew him.

They quickly reached their hut, situated in the middle of the village. It was one of the larger homes, as Trenaccatus’s family was quite wealthy. It was the house that he had grown up in, and when his father had died it had passed to him; he now lived in it with his mother, brother, sister-in-law, and five nieces and nephews. While his brother and sister-in-law had three children, two girls and a boy, Vendubaras and Caliacas were the sons of his younger sister, who lived in another village  

Trenaccatus’s sister-in-law, Bruigga, was at her loom when they entered the hut, resting their weapons by the door. Her youngest child, a girl named Auitoriga, was sitting with Trenaccatus’s mother, Ulagna, watching as she wove a basket. The little girl looked up when they arrived and smiled, jumping to her feet and running to greet her cousins.

“You’re back!” she cried, letting herself be scooped up into Caliacas’s arms.

“We are,” Caliacas said, rustling her hair already-messy hair. “Where are your brother and sister?”

“They are outside, playing,” Auitoriga explained. “I was too but I came back because I hurt my knee.”

“Oh no! How’d you do that?”

“I fell,” the little girl said. “So I came inside to help Mama work.”

Bruigga looked over at them, smiling. “You should go back outside now,” she told her daughter. “Caliacas and Vendubaras are probably tired from training.”

Auitoriga scowled, but obediently wiggled her way out of her cousin’s arms, scurrying past Trenaccatus and Vendubaras as she ran out of the door.

“How was your training?’ Bruigga asked, once her daughter was gone, and Caliacas shrugged, frowning.

“He’s just angry that I beat him,” Vendubaras said, gently shoving his brother as he walked over to where a basket of bread sat, grabbing a piece.

“You do not fight fairly,” Caliacas argued, and Vendubaras scoffed.

“He fights fairly enough,” Trenaccatus said. “Others will not be so kind.”

Caliacas’s frown deepened, but he said nothing, instead going over to where his brother stood and taking a piece of bread for himself. Trenaccatus watched him with a scowl—while they had been living in peace for quite a while, violent disputes with other settlements and even other villages were still frequent. Their peaceful lives could be viciously disrupted at any moment.

◊◊◊

Branogenas woke before the sun, his eyes slowly opening to the dark world around him. He was on the ground near a forest, with nothing but a cloak and the smouldering embers of a fire to keep him warm. It had been several days since he had slept sheltered from the elements, and it was beginning to take its toll on him. He was exhausted, both physically and mentally, but he couldn’t shake the feeling of unease that followed him, no matter how far he ran., and so he kept going, without any idea as to where he would end up.

Stomping out the remains of his fire, he had a quick breakfast of stale bread and nuts and continued on his way, his hood pulled up over his head so that it hid his face, though the sun had still not yet risen. Autumn was quickly progressing, with each day becoming colder and colder, and Branogenas knew that he would have to find somewhere to live before winter set in, otherwise he would freeze to death in the middle of a forest. But for that day he continued his march, not even knowing in what direction he was walking.

He met few people as he travelled. The settlements that littered the area were few and far apart, and it was uncommon for someone to wander between them. Though he had seen several small villages, he had been careful to stay far away from them. Most people were not very welcoming towards strangers, and he would most likely be turned away.

So he slept outside, carefully rationing the small amount of food he had grabbed before he fled. Though it had been several days, he was still reeling from the shock of his escape and he spent much of his time thinking about the events that lead up to it.

Everything had started just over three weeks ago, when Branogenas woke up to find his wife dead. They had been married for nearly a year, and her death had come as a surprise—she had been healthy the night before, but had died suddenly sometime during the night. The entire village was saddened by her death, and she was given the proper funeral rites, with many people coming to visit her as she lay in their home in the days before her burial.  

Then, the day after she was buried, her brother began making claims that his sister’s death had not been natural and that someone had killed her. He named Branogenas as the perpetrator, and in a few days he had most of the village agreeing with him. A druid was summoned to decide whether he was innocent or guilty and what his punishment should be.

Branogenas’s brother-in-law insisted that he be killed, and while the druid agreed that Branogenas was guilty he felt that exile would be a sufficient punishment. So Branogenas had packed what could and had left as quickly as possible, and while days of travelling now rested between him and the village, he still did not feel safe.

Glancing over his shoulder, he peered into the shadowy forest and quickened his pace, tightly wrapping his cloak around himself.

◊◊◊

Trenaccatus stood with a sword in his hand, watching Vendubaras carefully and waiting for him to strike. Caliacas sat off to the side, with his younger cousin Lugaddu beside him. While Lugaddu was only six, he had begged to join his older cousins during their training sessions and Trenaccatus had allowed him to come along. Caliacas had given the young boy a small sword fashioned out of wood and he attempted to mimic the strikes and thrusts of his uncle and cousins.

Though he had tired after only an hour, he still sat with rapt attention as Vendubaras suddenly lunged forward, swinging at his uncle. Trenaccatus, however, easily blocked the attack and matched it with his own. Vendubaras just barely avoided the blow in time and nearly fell to the ground, though he managed to recover before Trenaccatus swung at him again.

They fought like this for several minutes, with Vendubaras struggling to maintain his footing and keep up, until he was finally knocked down, his uncle’s sword at his neck.

“You still have much to learn,” Trenaccatus said, pulling the sword away. “But you have improved greatly.”

Vendubaras sat up with a huff, rubbing his now bruised arm. Trenaccatus watched him for a moment, before motioning to where Caliacas sat. “Go spar with your brother,” he said, and Vendubaras grabbed his sword, standing and hurrying over to Caliacas.

Sheathing his own sword, Trenaccatus watched his nephews as Vendubaras goaded Caliacas to his feet and moved Lugaddu out of the way. The small boy protested a bit, but Caliacas handed him his wooden sword and sent him over to where Trenaccatus stood.

“Will you fight with me?” Lugaddu asked as he walked up to Trenaccatus, his toy sword held tightly in his hands.

Trenaccatus grinned. “You are not old enough yet,” he told the boy, kneeling down and tousling his hair. “But one day, I promise, I will fight you. And maybe you will even win.”

Lugaddu stared at him for a moment, awestruck. “But Vendubaras is really good at fighting, and he lost,” he said.

“Then you will have to become better than him,” Trenaccatus said, and Lugaddu smiled widely, sitting himself down in the grass beside his uncle.

They watched as Vendubaras and Caliacas sparred, Trenaccatus occasionally calling out, telling them not to hesitate and to strike quickly. After several minutes, however, Lugaddu looked up at him, a confused look on his face.

“Uncle,” he said, and when Trenaccatus didn’t say anything, too focused on what Caliacas and Vendubaras were doing, he stood, tugging on his uncle’s shirt. “Uncle,” he repeated, and Trenaccatus looked down at him, his eyebrows furrowed.

“What is it, Lugaddu?” he asked.

“What is that person doing?” the boy asked, pointing towards the nearby hills.

Trenaccatus frowned, following his nephew’s finger to a small, dark figure walking near the base of the hills. They were too far away to see properly, so it was impossible to know if it was someone from the village or not. However, it was uncommon for someone to leave the settlement alone, and they did not appear as if they had been hunting or gathering food, as they had no bow or even baskets.

“Caliacas, Vendubaras,” he said, turning back to his nephews. “That is enough.” The two boys stopped, staring at their uncle in confusion. “Remain here with Lugaddu.”

Caliacas frowned. “Why?”

“Simply do as I say,” Trenaccatus said, his hand going to the hilt of his sword as he looked back towards the figure.  

“What’s wrong?” Lugaddu asked, looking from his cousins to his uncle. “Is that person dangerous?”

Vendubaras blinked, confused. “What person?” he asked, looking to his uncle.

“They are over by the hills,” Trenaccatus explained. “I am going to go see who they are, and what business they have here.”

“Are they not from our village?” Vendubaras asked.

“It is hard to tell,” Trenaccatus admitted. “But it does not appear so, as they are alone and have no obvious weapons for hunting. It is more likely that they are a traveller.”

Caliacas furrowed his eyebrows. “Do you believe that they are dangerous?”

“I could not say,” Trenaccatus said. “Which is why I am going to speak with them.”

“I do not like that you are going alone,” Vendubaras told him.

“They are most likely harmless,” Trenaccatus assured his oldest nephew. “Just a simple traveller.”

“It is odd for someone to travel alone,” Caliacas observed, a slight frown on his face.

Trenaccatus nodded in agreement. “That is why I have some suspicions,” he said. “But I will not be long.”

Though they looked as if they wanted to argue further, neither Caliacas nor Vendubaras said anything more; they simply watched as Trenaccatus left them standing in the middle of the field and began making his way over to where the person wandered, a shadowy black figure against the tall, bright green hills.

◊◊◊

It was nearing dusk when Branogenas spotted a small group of people standing in a nearby field. Though the setting sun had basked everything in gold and turned the people into dark shadows, he could see that some of them were sparring with each other. He had never been much of a warrior, but he had received enough training to recognize that they were novices, and therefore relatively young.

Fortunately, they were rather far away and seemed to be preoccupied with their training. As such, Branogenas hoped to be able to avoid catching their attention and suspicion, so that he would be able to pass by peacefully. But, because of their presence, he knew that a village would be nearby, and scanned the horizon for any signs of smoke from fires, for if he knew where it was, he could easily avoid it and any other people that might be lingering nearby.

However, it didn’t seem as if he would be able to travel through the area unnoticed—when he looked back to the group, they had stopped their training and appeared to be looking in his direction. Tugging his hood further over his face, Branogenas quickened his pace, hoping to be out of their sight before they decided to confront him. People were typically very suspicious of those who travelled alone, as they were considered to be dangerous—to most, only criminals travelled alone.

Glancing back to the group, he saw that one of them had broken away and was heading in his direction. Quietly, he swore under his breath and gradually began increasing his speed. Though he wanted to break out into a sprint and run away as quickly as he could, he knew that that would only increase the person’s suspicions of him, and so he continued to walk, often casting a glance over his shoulder to see how close they were.

Slowly, they grew closer and closer until they were only a few metres away. Looking back, Branogenas saw that it was a man—he had a rather imposing stature, and seemed to be quite a bit taller than him. Though he only caught a glimpse of him, Branogenas was able to see that he had a sword strapped to his hip, and that further increased his anxiety about the situation. The man appeared to be a rather skilled warrior, and while Branogenas had of course received weapons training, he was simply a farmer. He didn’t have the skill that a seasoned warrior would have.

Pulling his cloak around himself, Branogenas tried to figure out what to do. If he ran, he would be caught quickly and most likely killed. If he kept walking, the man would eventually catch up to him and he would once again end up in a very unsatisfactory situation. No matter what he did, it was likely that he would end up dead.

“Stop!”

Branogenas stumbled, surprised at the man’s sudden cry. Catching himself, he continued on for a few more steps before slowing, turning to face the man. He had stopped walking, and now stood only a few feet away, one hand clenched tightly around the hilt of his sword. From what Branogenas could see, it was a very good sword, skillfully crafted and lovingly cared for. It was the type of sword he often saw in the hands of nobles, and that combined with the quality of his clothes meant that this man was most likely very wealthy.

Though it was quite cold that evening, he wore only a pair of trousers and a shirt with short sleeves. His clothes were very clean, and didn’t appear to have many holes or stains, though they were worn in some places. His hair was quite long, but well-kept, pulled back from his face, which was covered in a thick, dark beard.

“Who are you?” the man asked, his voice full of suspicion.

For a moment, Branogenas said nothing. He still had his hood pulled far over his face, covering his eyes, so he could not see most of the man’s face. Silently, he wondered what to say—whether he should tell the truth, or lie.

“What are you doing here?” the man continued, quickly becoming aggravated. “Speak quickly.”

“I am simply a traveller,” Branogenas told him, and stood straighter, pulling the hood back from his head and staring the man straight in the face.

They both stood silent for a moment, expressions of absolute shock on their faces.

“Bilbo,” the man—Thorin, Bilbo thought, Thorin—said, stumbling forward.

Bilbo stared at him, struggling to believe what he was seeing. He felt almost as if he was waking up from a dream, with all these memories of lives that were somehow his.

“I...” he mumbled, failing to find something meaningful to say. “I died... I truly died.”

“You did,” Thorin said, taking Bilbo’s hands in his own. “But I told you we would see each other again. I always knew we would.”

Bilbo blinked at him, the warmth of his hands in Thorin’s so strikingly familiar it made his heart stutter. “But... this means that you died as well,” he said, and Thorin frowned, nodding.

“I did,” he said. “Only a few months after you.”

“How?” Bilbo asked, his forehead creasing in worry. “What happened?”

“That is a story for another time and place,” Thorin said, rather quickly. “First, tell me what you are doing here, travelling alone with no weapons or protection.”

Bilbo scowled. He debated over lying for a moment, unsure of how Thorin would react.

“It is a very long story,” he explained,             quickly deciding on the truth. “I will need to tell you more details later, but... I have been exiled from my village.”

Thorin’s eyebrows shot up, his eyes widening in surprise. “What?” he asked, his voice suddenly growing quiet, as if there was someone nearby to hear their conversation. “What did you do?”

“I did nothing,” Bilbo replied. “But everyone was lead to believe that I did.”

Thorin was silent for a moment, watching Bilbo and thinking. After a moment, he asked, “What do they think you did?”

It took Bilbo several seconds to answer. “I... had a wife,” he said, his eyes falling closed, as if he was physically in pain. “Her name was Magliga. We were married this past year, but a fortnight ago... I woke up and she was dead. Her brother told everyone that I had killed her, and so I was exiled.”

“Why... Why did he believe you killed her?” Thorin asked, still obviously shocked.

“I am not sure,” Bilbo admitted. His expression was pained, and when he looked at Thorin there was great sorrow in his eyes.

“Have you been travelling since your exile?” Thorin questioned, and Bilbo nodded.

“It has been close to a week.”

Thorin watched him for a moment, lifting Bilbo’s hands to his lips. They were cold and dirty, covered in cuts that had scabbed over, hands that had seen years of hard work and were worn with calluses and scars. But they were undoubtedly still Bilbo’s hands, and Thorin held them tightly as he leaned in and kissed Bilbo—it was just a quick kiss, but Thorin still felt his heart jump in his chest as their lips brushed.

“You will come and stay with me, then,” he decided, his face only centimetres from Bilbo’s. “We have room enough for you.”

“What of your companions?” Bilbo asked, his voice merely a whisper. “What will they say of you deciding to harbour an unknown traveller?”

Thorin smiled. “They are my nephews,” he clarified. “We will tell them, and the rest of my family, that you are the kin of a friend.”

Bilbo stared at him. “You do not believe me to be a murderer?” he asked. “You would house an exile?”

“I know you,” Thorin said, cupping Bilbo’s face. “What reason would you have to kill someone?”

Bilbo said nothing for a moment, before whispering, “Thank you. You are the only one who has believed me.”

“I have every reason to believe you,” Thorin said, and kissed him again.

◊◊◊

Thorin’s nephews stood as he approached, regarding the stranger who followed behind him with apprehension.

“Who is this?” Fíli asked, stepping in front of his brother and cousin and glaring at Bilbo. “Do you know him?”

“There is no need to be so harsh, Vendubaras,” Thorin said, placing his hands on his oldest nephew’s shoulders. “This man is the kin of a friend who lives in a nearby village. He is travelling to visit him, and I have offered him shelter for tonight.”

Fíli furrowed his eyebrows. “Which friend?” he asked.

“His name is Dalagnas,” Thorin answered. “You do not know him.”

“What is your name?” Kíli asked, motioning to Bilbo.

“I am Branogenas,” he answered, trying his best to keep a straight face. It was odd to see Fíli and Kíli again, looking as they had in Middle-earth. Fíli appeared to be around eighteen, and while he no longer had a mustache or beard his golden hair was once again long, pulled back from his face and braided. Kíli seemed to be only a few years younger, and both had the mischievous air about them that Bilbo had missed. He had grown close to the brothers over the course of their quest, and their deaths had been hard.

“These are my nephews,” Thorin said, looking at Bilbo and smiling. “Vendubaras and Caliacas are the elder two, my sister’s sons, and Lugaddu is my brother’s son.”

“Hello,” Lugaddu greeted him, grinning widely. “Are you good at fighting?”

Bilbo blinked in surprise before chuckling, leaning down slightly to better speak to the boy. “I am afraid not, no,” he answered. “I am a farmer, and never learned to fight well.”

Lugaddu frowned. “Oh,” he said, disappointed. “My uncle is a very good warrior. He is the best in our village.”

“I do not doubt that,” Bilbo agreed, straightening. “I have heard many tales of your uncle from my cousin.”

“I will be a warrior like him one day,” Lugaddu announced proudly. “My cousins are very good at fighting as well.”

Bilbo nodded, glancing to Fíli and Kíli. Fíli was watching him suspiciously, his arms crossed over his chest, while Kíli looked as if he didn’t know what to think, his eyes darting from his brother to his uncle.

“Are they?” he asked, and Lugaddu nodded.

“Come now, my nephew,” Thorin said, stepping in and scooping Lugaddu up into his arms. “Do not pester him so much.”

Bilbo smiled. “It does not bother me,” he said.

“Grandmother will not be happy that you brought a visitor home without her knowing,” Fíli pointed out.

“That is none of your concern,” Thorin told his nephew. “There is no need to hold such suspicions, Vendubaras. Not everyone is looking to harm you.”

“But many people are,” Fíli argued.

“That is why you must be cautious, not hostile,” Thorin replied. “I have known Dalagnas for many years, and I trust his kin as much as I trust him. You must do the same.”

Fíli frowned, but said nothing and started walking away, back towards the village. Kíli hurried after him, and they were followed by Thorin, Bilbo, and Lugaddu, the small boy now walking beside his uncle. The village was not too far away, and as they walked Bilbo answered Lugaddu’s many questions. The child wanted to know everything he could about this mysterious stranger, and Bilbo happily answered, though he had to lie many times.

Thorin watched him as he talked, a small smile on his face. It was indescribably wonderful to see him again, and though the situation was much more complicated than it had been before, Thorin couldn’t help but feel happy. After Bilbo had died, Thorin hadn’t been sure if they would see each other again. He hadn’t known if they would once more find themselves in some other place and time after their deaths, or if they would go to heaven, or the halls of his ancestors, or someplace else entirely. Though he still did not understand why, Thorin was glad that they had ended up together once again.

◊◊◊

The gate to the village was still open when they arrive, though no one now remains in the fields. Only a few people were outside as they walked through the streets, and while many of them stared at Bilbo no one said anything—they simply watched as they passed by.

They reached the hut quickly, and Fíli pulled aside the cloth covering the doorway, holding it as everyone else walked through. Inside, Frerin was hacking up large chunks of deer meat, some of which was put in a pot to be boiled while the other part was salted by Bruigga to be preserved.

They both looked up when the group entered, and his mother stood from where she had been sitting at her loom, blinking in surprise at Bilbo’s presence. It was not often that strangers came to the village, and they were all immediately suspicious.

“Who is this?” Ulagna asked, her hands on her hips.

“This is Branogenas,” Thorin explained. “He is the kin of a friend that we found wandering near the field. He is travelling to a nearby village.”

Frerin furrowed his eyebrows, looking from Bilbo to Thorin. “Which friend is this?”

“You do not know him,” Thorin answered. “His name is Dalagnas—I met him many years ago during a conflict with another settlement.”

“You have never mentioned him before,” Frerin observed, and Thorin frowned.

“Must I name all of my acquaintances?” he asked, and his younger brother glowered at him.  

“It is simply odd that I have never heard you speak of this Dalagnas,” Frerin argued.

“I know many people that you do not, Ircittis.”

“There is no need to hold such suspicions,” Bruigga told her husband. “Trenaccatus says that he knows this man’s kin, and therefore we honour him as our guest.” Giving her husband a scolding look, she turned to Bilbo and smiled, asking, “Will you be staying the night here with us?”

Bilbo, not entirely sure of what to say, turned to Thorin, who nodded. “He will,” he answered.

Bruigga’s smile widened. “We have plenty of food and space for you,” she said. “You are welcome to stay for as long as you like.”

“Thank you,” Bilbo said, bowing his head and giving her a gracious smile.

Bruigga nodded in return and sat back down to continue her work, while Thorin introduced Bilbo to the rest of his family.

◊◊◊

Later that evening, after dinner, Bilbo and Thorin sat behind the hut, watching as the sky slowly darkened. The children were playing nearby, and they could hear their cheerful shouts and laughs as they ran around.

Heaving a sigh, Bilbo rested his head against the hut’s wattle-and-daub wall, staring up at the sky. It was a brightly-coloured mix of reds and oranges, the clouds dyed in warm hues cast by the setting sun. Letting his eyes fall shut, he breathed in the crisp evening air.

“Will you tell me the story of how you died now?” he asked, his eyes remaining shut.

Thorin said nothing for a moment. “...It was in April,” he finally replied, looking down at his hands, calloused and caked with dirt. “The sixteenth, I believe. We did not do very well, after... after you died. We were forced to retreat back to Scotland, and there was a battle near Inverness.” He paused, taking in a long, deep breath. “So many died—we were slaughtered. I was not killed until the end, as we were making to flee. The Redcoats charged us, and one stabbed me with a bayonet. I was dead in seconds.”

Bilbo was silent for a long while, unmoving. “What about everyone else?” he asked, after several minutes had passed, finally opening his eyes and looking at Thorin. “Drogo and... and Víli. Did they survive?”

“I do not know,” Thorin answered. “They were alive when I died, but I am not sure if they escaped.”

Bilbo sighed, pulling one knee up to his chest and resting his chin on it. “Drogo is named Ulcagnas here,” he said. “We are not very close—he is much younger than I am.”

“Are many of the people of your village your kin?” Thorin asked, and Bilbo nodded.

“Many are, yes,” he said, and to Thorin’s surprise he gave a short, curt laugh. “You know, most did not believe my brother-in-law’s story that I had killed Magliga... not at first. But the wife of my cousin believed what he said from the very beginning, and she convinced everyone else to believe him as well. Ercagriga, her name is.” He chuckled again, shaking his head. “Lobelia Sackville-Baggins.”

Thorin furrowed his brows, frowning. “What is so funny?” he asked, genuinely confused.

“Lobelia has never liked me,” Bilbo explained. “No matter the circumstances, it would appear. It is very unsurprising that she was the one who turned my kin against me.”

“How could they believe that you killed your own wife?” Thorin asked, and Bilbo shrugged.

“You know how everyone here thinks,” he said. “No one knew what had killed Magliga, and when my brother-in-law suggested murder it seemed, to them, like the most logical explanation. There were, of course, many who rejected the idea, but Lobelia and my brother-in-law managed to convince them otherwise. When the druid was called there were only a few who still believed me, but they seemed to decide otherwise after hearing the druid’s ruling.” He paused, taking in a deep breath and letting it out slowly.

“Why would your brother-in-law accuse you of such a crime?” Thorin questioned.

“I do not think he liked me,” Bilbo explained. “I feel as though he despised me, actually, though I do not know why. When the druid exiled me, he argued and said that I should be put to death—that I did not deserve to live anymore.”

Thorin frowned. “That is... extreme.”

Bilbo scoffed, nodding in agreement. “But I think, in the end, he had convinced himself that I did kill Magliga, if he did not believe it right from the beginning,” he said. “He absolutely adored her. She was his younger sister, and he would have done anything for her. I do not think he thought I was good enough, and when she died he wanted someone to blame—someone to get angry at.”

“And he chose you,” Thorin concluded, and Bilbo nodded once more.

“Yes, I think so.”

There was a moment of silence, when neither of them said anything, and Thorin simply watched Bilbo. The sun had almost completely sunk below the horizon, casting a dark shadow over the world, and Thorin could just barely make out Bilbo’s features in the twilight. He looked sad, and Thorin moved closer, brushing the strands of hair from Bilbo’s face.

“Did you love her?” he asked, his voice so quiet it was nearly inaudible.

Bilbo waited a moment before replying. “Yes,” he murmured, turning to look at Thorin. There were tears welling in his eyes, and he blinked rapidly, trying to hold them back. “Not in the way I love you—I don’t think I ever could have loved her like that. But in a way, yes. I loved her very much.” He paused, taking in a deep breath of air before continuing, “I have no idea what to do now. I... I have no home, I have nowhere to go.”

“Do not say that,” Thorin said, taking Bilbo’s face in his hands. “You have me. You have my home. We will figure something out, I promise you.”

Bilbo nodded, smiling. “I feel as though we will never have anything easy,” he said, and Thorin laughed. It was a laugh that Bilbo heard so rarely, and his smile deepened at the sound of it.

“I love you,” he whispered, taking Thorin’s hands in his own and holding them tightly. “I never want to leave you again.”

“You will not,” Thorin assured him, and leaned in to kiss him.

◊◊◊

Bilbo awoke with a startle early the next morning. The world was still dark, with the first beginnings of light just starting to creep their way into the hut. All around him, everyone else was still sleeping, their even breathing and the wind outside the only sounds penetrating the early morning air.

The sun would not rise for a while longer, but Bilbo knew that he would not be able to fall back asleep. He had been restless during the night, and sleep had evaded him for several hours. Though he was exhausted, and wished for nothing more than to sleep and never wake up, he knew that to try would be useless.

So, instead, he threw back the furs covering him and slipped on his shoes, grabbing his cloak and crossing the floor to the doorway. Outside, the air was cold and he shivered as he wrapped the cloak around his shoulders, wishing for a moment that he had thought to grab the fur from his bed.

Sighing, Bilbo leaned back against the hut, craning his neck to look up at the stars. They were slowly growing fainter as the sky turned from black to grey, and he watched as they dimmed, his breath curling up to form clouds above him. He suddenly felt the urge to hold a pipe in his hands, though he hadn’t smoked since Middle-earth. He didn’t even know what year it was or even where he was, but he was very sure that neither tobacco nor pipe-weed had been discovered yet—it would probably be some time before he would be able to smoke again.  

Closing his eyes, he let his thoughts wander. He couldn’t tell how long he stood like that, breathing in the crisp morning air, but when he reopened his eyes the sky was noticeably brighter. People were beginning to start their days—fires that had died during the night were being relit, their smoke curling from the tops of the huts, though only a few people were out in the streets, fetching water or food.

Bilbo stood still for a moment, watching as the world begun to awake, before turning to return back inside. He was shivering from the cold, and longed to crawl back under a pile of warm furs, at least for a short while before Thorin and his family awoke.

As he was about to pull back the cloth covering the doorway, however, someone suddenly grabbed him from behind, one hand going over his mouth and the other across his chest, dragging him away from the door.

◊◊◊

When Thorin woke up, Bilbo was gone.

The furs under which he had slept were thrown back, piled near the foot of his bed. His shoes and cloak were gone, but his bag still sat on the other side of the room. Sitting up, he brushed the hair away from his face and looked around. Frerin and Bruigga were already up, and had restarted the fire. Kíli sat in front of it, with Auitoriga in his lap, both of them half asleep and chewing lazily on pieces of bread.

“Where is Branogenas?” Thorin asked, throwing aside his furs and standing up, slipping his feet into his shoes.

Frerin looked up at him, and shrugged. “I do not know,” he answered. “I have not yet seen him.”

“Is he not outside?” Thorin asked, and Kíli shook his head, yawning.

“He was not there when I went out,” he said.

Thorin frowned, and hurried over to the doorway, grabbing his cloak from where it sat nearby. Outside, Bilbo was nowhere to be seen. Several people milled about, but they paid him no attention. Running around to the other side of the hut, Thorin spun around in circles, looking for any possible spot Bilbo could be.

It was not likely that he had left before they had awoken—his bag was still inside, with all the rest of his belongings and supplies. He would not have wandered off, either, as he did not know the village or the surrounding area. He knew it would have been dangerous for him to go too far from the hut.

Frerin appeared in front of him, his forehead creased in worry. “Where has he gone?” he asked, and Thorin said nothing for a moment, instead scanning the area for any signs of Bilbo.

There was nothing—absolutely nothing. Turning to Frerin, he frowned, his eyebrows furrowing together. “I have no idea,” he admitted.

◊◊◊

The pain in his chest was absolutely excruciating—it was so painful that, for a moment, Bilbo thought that he was back in Scotland, with a bullet in his lungs and rain pouring down on him.

But the sky was clear. The sun was shining against a cloudless sky, and not a drop of rain was falling. Then Bilbo remembered—he had been stabbed, by his brother-in-law.

He was dying.

He was dying for the third time, and it was so incredibly painful. The first time it had been a slow, but peaceful, death—there had been little pain, and he had not even known it was about to happen. The second time had been horrible; a quick death, filled with the worst pain he had ever felt. But Thorin had been there, and that had alleviated some of the suffering—it had made it more bearable.

But this time, Thorin was not there. There was no comfort for him as he lay on the cold ground, struggling to breathe through punctured lungs. There was only the unhappy knowledge that he was about to die, and the menacing form of his brother-in-law looming over him.

“I didn’t kill her,” Bilbo said, the words coming out as a choked sob.

His brother-in-law said nothing for a moment, scowling. He had been the one to suddenly grab Bilbo from behind, and he had dragged him from the village. Outside the palisade, a small group of men had been waiting. They had tied Bilbo’s hands together with a length of rough cut cloth and had lead him far from the settlement, daggers and swords clutched in their fists.

The rest of the men had disappeared now—Bilbo didn’t know where they had gone, but he didn’t care very much. His brother-in-law frowned.

“Do not lie to me,” he growled. “I know you are lying. I know you killed her.”

Bilbo shook his head and coughed, blood spluttering from his lips. He had known that his brother-in-law was dissatisfied with the druid’s ruling, and had wanted him killed, but he had not thought he would take matters into his own hands. His brother-in-law had chased him incessantly since he departed from the village, bent on finding him and exacting his own punishment.

“Why would I kill her?” Bilbo asked, struggling to force the words from his mouth. He could barely breathe, and each second he could feel himself slipping closer and closer to death.

His brother-in-law’s face screwed up into an expression of intense anger, and he adjusted his grip on the dagger in his hand, slick with blood. “Why would you not?” he questioned, and leaned down.

He hovered above Bilbo for a moment, staring into his dying eyes, before he plunged the dagger deep into his chest. Bilbo’s mouth flew open, as if he was about to gasp or scream, but the only sound that came out was a small choke. His brother-in-law stared at him, his expression of anger slowly melting away into emotionless.

Bilbo stared back, until he could stare no longer and the world faded away.

◊◊◊

They did not find him for two days.

His body was lying, discarded, near a creek. It was obvious that he had been dead for some time, and while Thorin had not expected to find Bilbo alive, the confirmation that he was dead had still hurt—there had always been a chance, however slim it might have been.

Kíli was with him when they found Bilbo. They had spent the last two days searching the village and the surrounding area for any signs of him, and it was beginning to look more and more likely that they would never find him when Kíli found a knife, discarded on the ground and covered in blood. A few minutes later, they found the body.

Kíli stood, watching, as Thorin crumpled to the ground beside Bilbo. He was covered in stab wounds, his chest caked in dried blood—whoever had owned the dagger Kíli had found was obviously the one that had killed Bilbo.

Thorin took in a deep breath, and turned to face his nephew. “Go tell the others we found him,” he said, and Kíli nodded, hurrying off without a word, his face sickly pale.

After he had gone, Thorin took Bilbo’s cold hand in his, holding it tightly. “I am sorry,” he apologized, trying to hold back tears. He didn’t know what exactly he was apologizing for, but he felt as if it was his fault that Bilbo was once again dead. “I am so sorry.”

Frerin and Fíli arrived soon after that, and helped Thorin carry Bilbo back to the village. There, his body was washed and wrapped in a death shirt, and a druid was summoned. He decided that the murderer had run off, and it would now be impossible to catch them.

“I do not know what reason this person had for murdering Branogenas,” he said. “But it is no matter. They are long gone, and cannot now be apprehended and punished. Instead, what we must now do is ensure that Branogenas receives the proper burial rites. Though it has been two days since his death, he can yet be guided to the Otherworld and onto his next incarnation.” He turned to Thorin. “You said he was travelling to visit his kin in a nearby village?”

Thorin nodded, his lips pressed tightly together and his hands clenched in his lap. He did not like lying, least of all to a druid—they were an order he had grown up being taught to respect and obey, and lying to one felt like a crime. But there was no way he could explain the truth.

“How far is this village?” the druid asked, studying Thorin, as if he could he was holding something back.

“One day’s walk,” Thorin answered, avoiding looking the man directly in the eyes.

“You will take him there,” the druid said. “And you will deliver him to his family. They will ensure the proper rites are performed, I am sure.”

Thorin nodded once more. “Of course.”

The druid sat, watching him for a moment, before standing. “You must leave as soon as you are able,” he told Thorin. “For Branogenas’s sake, and the sake of his kin.”

“I will leave tomorrow,” Thorin assured him, and the druid nodded, satisfied.

“When you arrive in the village, make sure a druid there is made aware of the situation,” he said. “In that way, the proper measures can be taken.”

“Yes, thank you,” Thorin said, and the druid bade them goodbye, turning and leaving without another word. He lingered by the doorway, however, and looked back to Thorin as if he wanted to say something to him. He didn’t.

◊◊◊

Thorin left early the next morning, before anyone else had awoken. He wished to leave without their notice, as both Fíli and Frerin had insisted on coming, though Thorin had refused. There was no village for him to travel to, and no kin to deliver Bilbo’s body to. He needed to leave alone, so he could bury Bilbo himself.

Therefore he brought many things with him, loaded onto the small cart alongside Bilbo’s body—candles, wine, a pouch of coins, a small amount of food, and even clothing. Though it would only be him, he would try and give Bilbo the best funeral he could, according to the customs he had been taught since he was a child.

Thankfully, as he prepared to leave, no one woke up and he was able to slip away quietly. The village was silent as he led the horse-drawn cart through the streets to the gate and outside the palisade, and no one bothered him. He walked for several hours alongside the cart, until the sun was high in the sky and it was past noon. He stopped then, near a tall waterfall that cascaded down the side of a hill. Several trees stood at the bottom, their leaves bright hues of gold and orange.

He took Bilbo’s body from the cart, laying him on the ground and surrounding it with the lit candles. As they burned, he gathered large branches and sticks, arranging them into a pyre; by the time he had enough, the candles had nearly gone out, burned to nearly nothing, and the sun was beginning to sink in the sky.

“The world appears to be against us, Bilbo Baggins,” he said, sitting down beside the body. “We shall never have our peace, shall we?” He smiled, though it was small and tears were beginning to well in his eyes. “But there shall be another chance. We will meet again in our next life, and I will make sure that no harm comes to you.” He paused and looked up at the sky, watching as it turned from blue to orange. “Do you think that here, we know the truth? About what happens after we die?” He looked back to Bilbo, almost as if he expected him to answer.

After a moment, Thorin continued, “In Middle-earth, I believed that, after I died, I would go to the Halls of Mahal, where I would be reunited with all who I had lost. In Scotland, I believed I would go to heaven and I would spend the rest of eternity in bliss. But here, I believed that when we died, we would go to the Otherworld, where we wait until it is time for us to be reincarnated. That is the belief that seems to hold the most truth—I have not yet been to the Halls of Mahal, and I have not seen heaven, but I have lived more than one life.”

He stood, blowing out the few candles that still remained lit and putting them back onto the cart. He then gathered up Bilbo’s body and set it atop the pyre, gathering a few more leaved branches and covering it with them.

“You must wait for me in the Otherworld,” he told Bilbo as he prepared a torch. “When I arrive we will go to our next lives together, and we will never be apart until we are ready to die. This I promise you.”

When the torch was lit, Thorin stood by the pyre for a moment. It was odd, performing a funeral in the middle of nowhere with no one else around—no family, no druid, no friends. Only Thorin and a meagre offering of grave goods.

“I am sorry I have not been able to do better by you,” Thorin apologized. “I would try and counsel you on how to reach the Otherworld, but I feel as if you already know. You are most likely there now, waiting for your next incarnation.”

Bending, he placed the torch atop the pyre and watched as it caught fire, the flames slowly spreading until they had engulfed the entire structure.

“Be sure not to wait for too long,” Thorin said, watching as the fire burned, its smoke rising high into the darkening sky. He did not move until night had fallen.

Notes:

Characters
Trenaccatus - Thorin
Branogenas - Bilbo
Caliacas - Kíli
Venubaras - Fíli
Ulagna - Thorin's Mother
Ircittis - Frerin
Ulcagnas - Drogo