Chapter Text
Bofur informed the rest of the company, and they all were eager to help Bilbo figure out what his gender was.
Everyone except Thorin, that was.
Ori brought him corncockle and bachelor’s button and asked him which he liked best. Bilbo really couldn’t say, and settled for admitting that violets had always been his favourite. He had always preferred flowers that were edible and smelled nice.
Dori asked him whether he wanted to grow his hair longer or cut it shorter. Bilbo found it quite alright the way it was, thank you very much.
Nori presented him with a brooch he had bought in Bree, to help him try out a more feminine look.
Fíli took him on a hunting trip, which was very generous as Bilbo thoroughly ruined it because he didn’t have the heart to kill a rabbit. .
Kíli took him to braid her hair, which went a lot better, even though Bilbo didn’t know the traditional dwarf braid patterns for women – apparently they were different from those for men.
Bombur reassured him that only a woman could cook such wonderful meals as Bilbo did.
Bifur didn’t say anything, but nodded approvingly when Bombur asked him to utter an opinion.
Dwalin tested his weapon skills and found that he was most skilled with feminine distance weapons. (Throwing chestnuts, that was)
Òin first didn’t understand what all the fuss was about, but when he had fetched his hearing aid, he nodded, took a look at Bilbo, prodded his belly, and declared that he was a sire.
“That was not the question!”, Glóin said in an exasperated voice, but could not get Óin to say something else. “Personally”, he declared. “I would just wait and see which gender you are attracted to to know for sure. When I saw my wife for the first time ...”
Bilbo fled before he could be regaled with the whole story.
The verdict was that he must be a woman, but Balin said they didn’t yet know enough to make a decision, and should get Thorin to make a statement before they changed Bilbo’s pronouns.
Thorin just muttered that they had more important things to do.
And then the trolls happened.
After they had survived that, the dwarves (except Thorin) came together to discuss Bilbo’s gender anew.
“Parasites”, Kíli said in a disgusted voice. “No woman would think we have parasites, I am sure.”
“Only a man could keep such a cool head while fighting trolls” Dwalin agreed.
“Bilbo did not faint this time” Bofur admitted.
“I am sorry”, Balin looked at Bilbo with pity in his eyes. “It looks like you are an in-betweener.”
“You say!” Bilbo tried very hard to suppress his smile.
“I suspected that when he said he likes violets best”, Ori piped up. “Sorry. When they said they like violets best.”
“Thorin!” Kíli shouted. “Bilbo is the same gender as you!”
Thorin shot her a deadly glare. “I fail to see how that would be of any relevance to our quest.”
While Gandalf switched the pronouns he used for Bilbo, Thorin refused to acknowledge their newly discovered gender identity and kept saying “the burglar” whenever he talked about Bilbo, with no pronouns whatsoever.
When they came to Rivendell, though, Thorin insisted that the elves use proper pronouns for the company’s burglar.
Bilbo would have enjoyed this protectiveness had they not suspected it was more due to Thorin’s hate for elves.
The haughtiness in Thorin’s voice whenever one of the elves misgendered Bilbo and they could correct them, was a clear hint as to the origins of their newfound protective feelings.
After they left Rivendell, Thorin went back to ignoring not only Bilbo’s gender, but Bilbo in general. Except when they felt the need to chastise “the burglar” about something.
Bilbo was thoroughly fed up with it all, and had just made up their mind to return to Rivendell, to lead a life of peace and boredom and being misgendered, when the elven sword started to glow blue.
And then Gollum happened. Bilbo felt, for the first time in their life, the full pain of being misgendered. “He” and “His” was alright. What Bilbo really could not stand was being called “It”.
Not even Thorin was that rude!
Bilbo really felt they deserved the magic ring as compensation.
They had just found the company again, when they heard Thorin rant about how “the burglar” would have long left them.
Using male pronounes, no less!
Bilbo had never felt so hurt in his – their – life!
But. The longing with which Thorin spoke of the home Bilbo had, that they could return to ... no, Bilbo could not just leave.
Besides, that would be proving Thorin right.
