Chapter Text
At least Thorin had the decency to look a bit embarrassed when they saw Bilbo.
They did not apologize, but seemed less grumpy afterwards. Maybe that was their way of trying to make amends.
Whatever it was, Bilbo blamed it for their decision to foolishly come to Thorin’s aid when the stubborn dwarf attacked the pale orc later on.
That had been stupid. Stupid, stupid, stupid.
Being carried by an eagle, Bilbo had time to think about that. Endangering one’s own life to save someone as rude and stubborn as Thorin ... it was really stupid.
Thorin was very handsome, there was no denying that. They also had the most enchantingly beautiful voice Bilbo had ever heard, like dark velvet.
Still, it was no justification for losing one’s head over a rude dwarf. Bilbo had always thought themselves a very profound hobbit. Not superficial at all. Thorin, on the other hand, really was only desirable at the surface.
As soon as they opened their mouth, the impression was ruined. As soon, Bilbo corrected, as they opened their mouth for something other than eating or singing. Sing, Thorin could quite well, and their table manners were also superior to those of the other dwarves.
Under that polished surface, though, there was only ... cold, hard rock, Bilbo decided. Now, Thorin might be flattered by being compared to rock, what with dwarves and their mining, but Bilbo much preferred good earth for growing vegetables and flowers in.
After the eagles dropped a unconscious Thorin, Bilbo had to admit that they would have done the same all over again. There just was something about Thorin that made Bilbo feel dread at the thought of losing them.
Against Bilbo’s will and better judgement, he lo... they liked the dwarf. And they definitely had not rejoiced in being declared an in-betweener just because that was Thorin’s gender. No.
It was just like Thorin to start recounting all their insults towards Bilbo immediately after regaining consciousness.
What was not like Thorin was to admit they had been wrong, and to hug Bilbo.
Kíli giggled. Fíli whistled.
Thorin let go of Bilbo and growled “Stop it!”
Now, that was more like Thorin.
As they descended from the rock the eagles had dropped them on, the dwarves chatted excitedly in their native tongue, and occasional giggles and whistles were heard, always silenced with a glare by Thorin.
When they had made camp, Bilbo sat down next to Thorin, who was resting on their bedroll, and asked “What is so funny? We survived, which is a reason to be in a good mood, I guess, but not, you know, funny.”
“I should have warned you this would happen.” Thorin sighed. “It was a very unwise decision to ask them to help you figure out your gender, and even more unwise to agree that you’re inbetween.”
“Why?” The only one who had been rude to him was Thorin.
“No one wants to be inbetween. You may have noticed that Ori prefers the slingshot as weapon, but claims to prefer the hammer. People might question his masculinity if he used the slingshot too often. It’s also why he keeps his hair shorter than the others. Some say long hair can be masculine, too, but no one questions that short hair is. Ori does everything to avoid people thinking he might be inbetween genders.”
“But why? I feel alright. The others are not rude about it, either.” No one except Thorin, but Thorin wasn’t rude about Bilbo’s gender, just rude in general. Although remarkably less so at the moment.
“Thing is, most want to ... to find love.” Thorin’s voice was quieter now, and even more gruff than usual. “And if you’re inbetween, you can only be with other inbetweens. Who are even rarer than women.”
“Well. That is quite alright.” Bilbo pondered their words. “I mean”, they added hastily “Back in the Shire, they’ll consider me male, regardless. But what about you? You could have been male, couldn’t you?”
Bilbo was not entirely sure how this worked, but Thorin was a fierce warrior. Who fought with a sword. And had a beard. Would Thorin change genders if they forgot to cut the beard?
“I like to play the harp”, Thorin whispered, as if it was a shameful secret.
“Oh! I love harp music!” Bilbo exclaimed without thinking. “Um. Is that considered feminine?”
“It is. And I do not care for love and marriage, anyway. Being inbetween was a nice excuse for not wasting my time with those matters.”
“Was?” Wasting time. Was that how Thorin viewed love?
“Obviously”, Thorin mumbled. “They now think I’m courting you.”
“Oh!” Bilbo blushed. So that was what all the giggling was about!
“Which is rubbish, of course.”
Bilbo swallowed. That hurt. Even knowing that Thorin was not interested in anyone that way ... it still hurt to hear it said so bluntly.
“Inbetweens have no courting rituals”, Thorin continued. “We wouldn’t know who is to court whom, after all.”
“But it is allowed to be a couple?”
“Yes. Not that it would matter. You hate me, and ...”
Bilbo stood up. “Excuse me! I just saved your life! I do not do that for people I hate.”
“Oh.” Thorin blinked. “You did not just do that to prove your masculinity?”
“What? It was the stupidest thing I did in my life. If I had had a moment to think ... well, I would have done it regardless, but certainly not because I thought it would make me look good. Or manly. Or whatever. It was darn stupid of you to attack that orc, and it was foolish of me to join in your stupidity.”
“Then why ...?” Thorin’s eyes were shining with tears, blue like puddles reflecting the sky.
“Because you are the most handsome dwarf I have ever seen, and I am, apparently, a very superficial hobbit.”
“I am lucky I am so handsome, then”, Thorin murmured, bitterness in their voice.
“No! I mean, you are, but I am not ... I mean, I ...” Bilbo swallowed. That was all very hard to explain, but this new Thorin who was not rude was rather likable. Maybe lovable even.
“Just kiss them.”
Bilbo gave a start. “Kíli! What are you doing here?”
“Helping you. Kiss Thorin already.”
“No”, growled Thorin. “Kíli, leave. Immediately. No dinner for you!”
“I’m just trying to help”, Kíli complained, but scampered off.
“So you don’t want me to kiss you?” Bilbo asked quietly. It had been a rather helpful suggestion, taking into account it came from Kíli. At least the topic was on the table now.
Thorin stared. “What? Why would I not ... oh.”
Bilbo would not have thought that dwarves, especially Thorin, could blush, but that was what happened.
“You rebuked your niece for suggesting it.”
“She obviously has no business telling you what to do. Of course, if you wanted to ...” There was longing in their voice, desperate longing. Suddenly, it struck Bilbo: Thorin was lonely.
“I do. Want to, that is.” This new, vulnerable, almost shy Thorin needed a hug. And possibly a kiss.
“Come here, then. I do not feel like standing up just now.”
Bilbo knelt down next to Thorin and bowed down. “You have remarkable hair”, they murmured. “Just like ... fertile black earth ...”
“Yours is like gold”, Thorin replied. “I always admired it ... thought you’d never want me, you being male ... and then you decided to make it worse, give me false hope, after I had ruined everything by trying to hide my admiration ...
“You could just have apologized, you know?”
They kissed, chastely. There was no reason to hurry things Bilbo thought while petting Thorin’s hair. Thorin would go nowhere in the near future.
And there still was something ... “You said you didn’t want to waste time with ... love and ...”
“I do not want to waste time thinking and talking about it all the time”, Thorin murmured. “Besides, I was choosy. You are the only one I ever ...”
“Oh.”
