Chapter Text
Bilbo rushed out of the classroom even faster than usual, clinging to his bag. He was more furious than anything, even if he did not know with what. Was he mad at Paladin for not being there for him? Or that Thorin was torturing him? But both had not intended it so. Then was he mad at himself? It did not help that as he passed by Lobelia and some friends of hers were shamelessly talking of Thorin.
“He is so attractive.”
“But did you see him in the lake the other day?”
“I’d like him to teach me a thing or two outside of class.”
Something inside Bilbo did not even know he possessed boiled up so quickly that he felt himself on fire. No one should ever talk like that of Thorin. His Thorin. Bilbo shook his head, walking blindly. No, not his Thorin at all. It was all in his mind only.
Neither Paladin nor Hamfast were in the Gryffindor tower, and Bilbo was in no mood to search for them right now. He took the best seat by the fireplace, sprawling himself on the couch meant for three and started his Potions essay.
It took three hours for Bilbo to remember that today was Gryffindor tryouts after all. He snapped his book shut and shoved his essay ruthlessly inside his bag; Seeing Paladin tryout would distract him more than the detesting essay Professor Thranduil had assigned. And he really needed the distraction.
Every year, Bilbo would get homesick at one time or another—it just did not occur this early on the school year.
He missed the smell of his garden, the sun on his back as he took care of his plants, the comfort of his dear hobbit hole. He missed the complete solitude, the food he would cook that was simply made his mouth water to think about. Or maybe he just missed not knowing of Thorin’s existence, like the summer before.
His thoughts of home faded away as he found himself passing a stricken Hamfast on a corridor. His eyes were wide, breathless.
“Hamfast”, Bilbo said, alarmed. “What happened?”
“Bilbo…” Hamfast wheezed. “Paladin…Bofur…a fight.”
“Wait, what?” It took a second for Hamfast’s words to sink in.”Paladin and Bofur are fighting?”
Bofur was Bilbo’s friend, a dwarf of the same year as he and Paladin. Bilbo never saw Bofur as violent, much less Paladin. Then again, he knew that both were trying out for Keeper, and things in Quidditch could get ugly.
“Where?” Bilbo said clearly, eyebrows furrowed.
Hamfast led Bilbo towards the Quidditch field, Bilbo wondering all the way as he sprinted what on earth could have led such pacifist creatures to turn like this.
There was a crowd visible from the distance, shouting incoherently at something they were surrounding. Moving through the thick crowd hastily, Bilbo found himself in the middle of Bofur and Paladin, who both held their wands in their hands threateningly.
“ENOUGH!” Bilbo roared, raising his hands to push them away from each other, stunning the two at his appearance. “This has been enough, both of you now.”
The two were in dirty clothes, scratches on elbows. Their chests were heaving, standing their ground firmly in the ruckus. Even Paladin looked intimidating next to Bofur when he was shorter than both Bilbo and Bofur, by far. The two barely glanced at Bilbo’s cry, Paladin barely flinching.
“Move away, Bilbo,” both Bofur and Paladin snapped.
Bilbo did not move, his hands remaining to block them. “I will not. At least until someone explains to me what happened.” Bilbo ignored the crowd, who were staring at him in annoyance. Clearly they were waiting for a fight, and Bilbo was ruining it.
"This rat insulted me.”
“Only after you took the liberty to insult me.”
“Why don’t you go back to the hole you came from, you hobbit.” The last word was said in such an ugly manner that even Bilbo felt offended. He turned to glare up at Bofur directly, not shying away from his intimidating stare.
“Enough,” Bilbo repeated, though more weakly this time. “Look at you. Shame on both of you. Where is Captain Legolas? He would never let this happen.”
“He left five minutes ago,” peeped a little human boy from the crowd. That reminded Bilbo…
“All of you, mind your own business” snapped Bilbo, shooing the crowd away. “Huddle off, now!”
A grumbling passed across the crowd before they dispersed. Bilbo turned around towards Paladin and Bofur, looking dangerously cross.
“Look both of you, I do not care what happened,” Bilbo said in such a harsh voice that Hamfast, who was standing behind him, took a step back. “You two know better. And one of you might become the Gryffindor Keeper, so do act like it!”
“Bofur became Keeper,” Paladin said bluntly.
Bilbo opened his mouth furiously before he heard Paladin’s words. “Oh.” Without another word he took Paladin by the wrist and led him inside, Hamfast following them two right behind him. Bilbo did not free Paladin until they were in a lonely corridor.
Paladin was agitated. “Oi! What—“
“Shut it, Took! What happened?”
“That worthless Bofur, that’s what happened!” Paladin’s nostrils flared.
“What did he do?”
“He cheated and I know it.”
“And what makes you say that?
“I just know it.”
“That’s it? That’s what the fight was about? Intuition? Well I am glad you did not get in the team because you would not have supported the Slytherin matches. Would have called them off every time.”
“Oh that is funny. HILARIOUS, I would say.” There was nothing amused in Paladin’s face. Bilbo turned to Hamfast, but he only shrugged. “They were already fighting when I showed up.”
“All right,” Bilbo sighed. “Fine. Listen.” He turned to Paladin again. “Just drop it. You did not get in because he was better, not because he cheated. Maybe next year you’ll get it. Understood?” He said it like that; short, heartless and simple. He waited for Paladin for respond, but he did not. Instead he pushed past Bilbo and swept away.
“I’ll take that as a yes,” Bilbo mumbled, watching Paladin’s figure strut to the Gryffindor tower.
***
“Bilbo? Bilbo. Bilbo!”
Bilbo groaned, covering his face with his pillow only for it to be snatched away and be given a sharp punch on his should.
Bilbo cried in pain. “What the—?”
“Shh,” Fili hissed. “You’ll wake him up.” He pointed to the top bunk, where Hamfast promptly snored.
It was Fili and Kili, the brothers Bilbo knew to be every teacher’s nightmare, the masters of mischief. They wore their pajamas and stricken expressions.
“What are you two doing?” sharply Bilbo whispered. “This is not your dormitory and I do not appreciate—“
“Shhhh” Fili repeated lividly. “Do you know where Paladin is?” Kili glared vigorously.
Bilbo was about to say to them to not be ridiculous, that Paladin was sleeping on the bed right next to them, but as he turned to the bed, it was empty.
He gaped, lost for words.
Fili and Kili both whispered “Damn” and hurried off the dormitory without any other word of explanation. Bilbo immediately took his robe and ran after them.
He found them climbing outside the portrait of the Fat Lady (who was not pleased at being woken up), muttering in worried whispers. He caught up to them in the corridor, where there was no one in sight, so he took the liberty to yell, “What is going on?”
”SHHHH,” both Fili and Kili said furiously. “What are you doing here, hobbit?” Kili sourly said, looking around to see if there was indeed no one around.
“What am I doing? Well I was perfectly sleeping before you two woke me! And where in the world is Paladin?”
Fili and Kili exchanged significant looks. Fili was the one who spoke. “Bofur’s gone too.”
Oh no.
“We do not know when he left, but it must have been not so long ago.”
“We have an idea of where they are.”
“Well, then what are we doing here. Let’s hurry!” Bilbo said loudly. The brothers led Bilbo downstairs.
What Bilbo still did not understand was what all of this chaos was about. Paladin was not the fighting type and he never accepted defeat so sourly, even if it was the Keeper position. He voiced this out this to the dwarfs.
Fili and Kili stopped in their tracks, stunning Bilbo in their suddenness. They looked at each other guiltily, balancing in the balls of their feet.
“What?” Bilbo said.
They stayed silent a second before Kili quietly said. “The tryouts might not have been fully just.”
Bilbo did not understand. “How do you mean?”
“Er, Fili and I might have…interfered.”
“You…”
“You should have seen Bofur, Bilbo. He so dearly wanted to get in…”
“Oh for the Shire’s sake, you two did not—“s
“We didn’t know Bofur and Paladin would go all ballistics about it!”
“Well guess what, he did,” Bilbo said in what almost sounded like a hiss, teeth bared. “And now were are looking for them like madmen all around the school for them past curfew and are risking getting caught!” He had not even noticed his voice had turned louder until that last word echoed all around the corridors, turning to watch in horror all around him instantly.
Fili’s eyes widened and Kili’s thin lips were pressed into a tight line. Along the far, so faint that it might have been lost if they had kept talking, there was the sound of hurried footsteps.
Bilbo had not even noticed that the two dwarf brothers had fled, leaving him alone in the unsettling darkness.
“Right,” he breathed, trying to sustain his panic. “Okay.”
To return to the tower was his first reaction, but Paladin’s face came into his mind, and with a pang of guilt knew that he wouldn’t have given in and would have looked for Bilbo in his place. Bilbo sighed in frustration and, closing and opening his fists anxiously, turned around and wandered around the corridors once more, hoping silently that the caretaker would not hear him.
***
Thorin woke with a start.
The night was one of biting cold, making him turn restless as he was a light sleeper already, but that was not what woke him up. Outside his room, restless voices could be heard passing by.
“—not an appropriate punishment for the five—“
“—should not be so hard on them—“
“—then what should we do—?”
“Lumos,” Thorin whispered, throwing his coat on and slipping on his boots. He opened the door to see the figures of Headmaster Gandalf, Professor Thranduil, Professor Galadriel, and the Gamekeeper Bard walking away. Thranduil and Bard were seemingly arguing quietly.
He cleared his throat. The four turned around.
“Ah, Professor Oakenshield”, Gandalf smiled. Thranduil did not seem so happy. “Cared to join us, I see.”
“What is the problem?” said Thorin.
“We found these five wandering around the school after curfew,” Professor Thranduil said curtly. “But if I may wonder, I do not see why the Gamekeeper cares to interfere or even be here.” He glared at Bard.
“The headmaster thought it would be appropriate to summon me in order to ask for my assistance” Bard said smoothly.
“Your assistance is not required.”
“And your opinion was not asked for, Professor Thranduil.” Gandalf said not rudely. Thranduil blushed noticeably even through the dim lighting of the torches and bowed his head.
“What students are we talking about?” Thorin asked.
“Mister Bofur, Fili, Kili, Took and Baggins.”
Something inside Thorin twitched, but his face remained passive.
“What is to be their punishments?”
“Their crime was small, so I suggest something reasonable” Professor Galadriel said.
“Agreed,” Bard said roughly.
“A small crime? Who knows what the the five were up to! I do not agree.”
“Then what do you suggest Professor Thranduil?” Gandalf toned.
Professor Thranduil hesitated, then said, “A week of detention with me.”
“Absolutely not”, said Professor Galadriel crossly, “You would have them as slaves cleaning your cauldrons all day.”
“What if instead of a week, I just bring them to the Forbidden Forest for a walk?”
Everyone stared at Bard.
Bard explained himself. “It would only be one detention, and it would be enough to encourage them not to try shenanigans again. Of course, I would take care of them. A simple shake is all I would give them to persuade them, if you will.”
Thranduil looked at him as if he was insane, but Professor Gandalf said, “Very well, Professor Bard.”
“You cannot be serious headmaster—“
“I am,” Gandalf said shortly. “But just to keep the security of the students intact, I suggest you take only four of them. Five would be too much to have an eye on. One of the five will be subjected to another punishment.”
Bilbo, Paladin, Bofur, Fili and Kili were all waiting anxiously on the next room where they were locked in. The teachers were deciding their fate. Fili and Kili had their ears pressed on the door.
Never in his six years in Hogwarts had Bilbo been in trouble, except when he had accidentally set the Potions class on fire in his first year. He was trembling head to toe.
Bofur looked concerned. “Bilbo, it’ll be fine.”
“Yeah, it was not your fault,” Paladin mumbled.
Bofur and Paladin exchanged remorseful looks. All of their personal problems had gotten their dear friend in trouble.
The two had been found on an empty classroom, yet they had not been found in any kind of fight whatsoever. Thranduil had been sulking nearby and had noticed the intruders, not wasting time in summoning the headmaster and head of Gryffindor.
Professor Thranduil opened the door, sending Fili and Kili falling back.
“Follow me,” he said sharply, hands behind his back.
The corridor where the teachers had been discussing their fate was now empty. “Where are we going?” Bofur asked.
“To the Gryffindor tower, obviously.”
“So we are not in trouble?” Kili said hopefully.
“Don’t be so dim, Mr. Kili,” Thranduil spat. “You have all been assigned a punishment. You four will be summoned on Saturday night to accompany the Gamekeeper to the Forbidden Forest.”
“The Forbidden Forest?” Paladin echoed, petrified. Even Fili and Kili looked uncomfortable.
“Indeed.”
“Wait. You said the four of us. What do you mean by that?”
“Mister Baggins has been chosen to not accompany you four to the Forbidden Forest; it was believed to have been too much for him to bear. Instead he will be taken care of by Professor Oakenshield on the same Saturday night.”
None of the faces that the four had previously done at hearing their punishment could ever compare to the expression of pure terror Bilbo wore upon hearing Thranduil’s words.
