Actions

Work Header

The After Effects of Amortentia

Chapter 5

Notes:

For those who had read this fic before, this is where the big changes begin. No real plot-changers, just certain events.
Enjoy my wonderful darlings <3

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“And why me anyways?” Bilbo snapped at the common room. The four—Paladin, Fili, Kili, and Bofur—shushed him at the same time.

“Bilbo, please do relax,” Fili huffed, collapsing on the loon couch opposite of him and Paladin, next to the two other dwarves. “If anything, you got the better end of the stick.”

Bilbo tried to grin weakly, turning to a grimace. Paladin pursed his lips. If only those two knew how wrong they were.

When Professor Thranduil had escorted them to the tower and had left, Bilbo could barely force himself to go inside. Paladin and Fili had to help him crawl onto the sofa. The poor hobbit muttered his thanks and stared fixedly at the dying fireplace, eyes wide.

“What’s wrong with him?” Fili had muttered, but Paladin had only shaken his head. Fili and Kili, they were simply the least two people who should be aware of this, after Thorin. They had issues of their own.

And that reminded him now—“Fili, Kili.” Bilbo’s voice had taken such a sharp tone that the brothers looked at him in mild alarm. “Tell them,” he beckoned towards Paladin and Bofur.

Fili and Kili exchanged a look, but said nothing. Bofur glanced at them curiously. “Tell us what?”

As their silence grew, Bilbo repeated in a more forceful tone, “Tell them.” His quiet voice did nothing to hide the fury and exhhaustion vibrating through it. “I am taking none of these scams, yeah? Just get it over with.”

The two shamefully bowed their heads.

“Bofur,” Fili said quietly. “We’re sorry.”

“We are really, really, really sorry.”

“We-we might have charmed Paladin’s broom.”

Bofur stared. “I do not understand.”

“We got you to get in, Bofur.” Kili said this with his head still bowed, hands between knees. His voice sounded muffled. “We wanted you to get to be Keeper.”

Paladin’s mouth opened in shock. Bofur was staring at Fili and Kili with glassy eyes, fists clenching so tightly it looked painful.

“I’m sorry Bofur,” Bilbo said, putting a consoling hand on his shoulder. He knew he should say more than that, that his friend needed him, but he was awfully tired and he had problems of his own to worry about. It also did not help his case that his best friend was the reason of his pain. “I really am.”

After Bofur slowly nodded, he muttered, “Come” to Paladin and left the three dwarfs alone, walking towards the dormitories in strangled silence.

“Happy now?” Bilbo grunted to Paladin, settling himself on his bed for the second time that night.

“Surprisingly, no,” Paladin quietly said back.

***

The week went so fast Bilbo had woken up to stare at the dormitory’s calendar for about a quarter of an hour, realizing it was Saturday morning already. The event still felt surreal, as if there was no detention at all and it had all been a dream. Of course this thought was quickly busted anytime Paladin would moan about the weather being anything but appropriate—with the skies pouring both hailstones and rain—and Hamfast keeping on asking the smallest of the details of the event.

“Can’t believe I missed it,” Hamfast said grouchily to his breakfast, looking disappointed.

Paladin’s hand, which held a forkful of scramble egg, froze in midair. “Did you want to get in trouble?”

“Well, no,” Hamfast mumbled. “But I just hate missing this kind of stuff.”

“But why me?” Bilbo wondered aloud to particularly no one.

“Bilbo Baggins, if you repeat that question again I will personally murder you.”

“Yes but why me?” said Bilbo, dropping his fork. “Why not you? Or Fili or Kili? Or Bofur?” Bilbo’s panicked state did not move either Hamfast or Paladin. That question had been repeated at least a thousand times already.

“As I have said already,” Paladin said in a mechanical, exhausted voice. “It means nothing. It was sheer coincidence, so accept it.”

“But what if it wasn’t?” Bilbo said weakly. “What if Thorin chose me because he thought I couldn’t handle the Forbidden Forest?” The thought made his voice turn bitter. Bilbo Baggins was not weak, and should never be pitied. Thorin should know that.

“Then he did you a hell of a favor, if you ask me,” Paladin said sourly. “Now if you can stop your sulking, I have some Quidditch morning training to do.”

With that Paladin left, leaving Hamfast and Bilbo to finish their second breakfast, only that Bilbo again barely touched the food.

***

“Bilbo, stop looking so pale, Thorin does not bite,” Fili said, looking appalled at the threatening clouds outside roaring when passing a window. “I am probably going to catch a cold with this weather,” he declared.

The hobbit chuckled dryly, more out of nervousness than out of humor. Fili had been kind enough to escort him to Thorin’s classroom when he saw how much Bilbo dreaded today even if he had no idea why. He, however, had some sense on not to go on asking.

“So like I was saying,” Fili continued chirping on with his story. “Kili and I had been cornered. The headmaster was right on our tails. Nowhere to go, only the cursed corridor in front of us, and we both knew that behind that door, there…” Fili mimicked opening an imaginary door in front of him, his eyes dramatically wide. “There Professor Thranduil was waiting for us.”

Bilbo rolled his eyes and smiled. Fili must think him mad if he actually thinks Bilbo will buy that he and Kili almost outwitted three professors. Bilbo appreciated him trying to distract him though—it had partly worked.

But they were now approaching Thorin’s door and that bliss soon ended.

Bilbo gulped.

“It’s all right, Bilbo,” Fili said kindly. “I know that detention is not so common for you, but I assure you, getting Thorin to take care of it was the best thing that could have happened to you.”

Bilbo grinned unconvincingly.

“No really! I’ll take care that he’ll treat you right, eh?”

“And how do you suppose you’ll do that?” Bilbo said incredulously.

“I’m his favorite nephew,” Fili said proudly, knocking on the door.

Bilbo gaped. “What?”

“Good evening.” Thorin looked down at them.

“Hullo, Uncle!”

“Fili? Are you not supposed to be with the groundkeeper?”

“I just came to accompany Bilbo here. See that you treat him well.” Bilbo looked at Fili in horror and tried not to blush, avoiding Thorin’s eye.

“Really?” Bilbo could hear Thorin’s amusement.

“Yep, the poor boy has been agitated for da—oi!” Fili cried in pain, rubbing his shin that Bilbo had kicked, “Careful now.”

“Thank you for coming Fili,” Bilbo said firmly, the dismissal being clear in his voice.

Fili scowled at him, his face crying “Is this what I get for helping out?” But he nodded once, breaking into a smile. “I should go. I’ll probably get in trouble if I do not appear soon to my detention.”

Thorin nodded. Fili spun around and left.

And that left the two of them. Alone. Bilbo took a deep breath and closed his eyes, spinning to face Professor Oakenshield, who was smirking in amusement back at him. Bilbo wrinkled his nose in annoyance at his smugness.

“Why won’t you come in, Mister Bilbo?”

Bilbo sniffed and entered the room as haughtily as he could only to lean back on that in front of him.

The classroom had only two torches lit, the majority of the light seeping from the moonlight let in by window. The Cithril runes around the room seemed as if they glowed, and there was simply a more serene feeling to the room, and Bilbo could not put his finger on what it was.

It felt very…dwarf-like. Bilbo could not help but beam at the room. It felt very much like Thorin.

“Beautiful,” Bilbo muttered in awe despite himself. He heard Thorin give a dry chuckle behind.

“Is it? It makes me feel at home.”

Bilbo turned to look at one rune, brighter than all, and he remembered reading about it somewhere on his books.

“Erebor,” Bilbo said out loud.

Thorin frowned, impressed, “Where did you learn Khuzdul.”

Bilbo waved his flattery off, saying, “I truly do not know much. Just recognized that from a Cithril runes book.”

“And what was a hobbit doing with a Cithril runes book?”

“I…” Bilbo hesitated, “was just curious, that’s all.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow, but did not press him further. He went to his desk and beckoned Bilbo to do the same. “We’ll be grading third-year essays. I can be sure that you are still familiar with werewolves?”

Bilbo firmly nodded, taking a seat next to him and going ahead to grade the essays, glad to have something to distract him from the fact that he was sitting next to Thorin. Thorin did the same, the room falling quiet except for the occasional scratch of a pen or the dipping of ink.

Yet by the fifteenth essay Bilbo was getting bored. The reading became blurry and monotone as the moon remained to shine by. His eyes wandered from the papers and around the room, the brick walls with the runes, the bookshelves with books of the dark arts and dwarf literature, the torches remaining to flicker by lazily, the window displaying the sky outside.

There were so many mysteries around, of stories and wars won and lost, of love and tragedy, almost humming to him inside the room.

“I have read so much of dwarfs,” Bilbo started quietly. “Of their battles and history and politics, but never have I read…” Bilbo let out a breathy sigh, “Of their stories.”

Thorin, who had been attentively grading, turned to look at the hobbit in confusion, frowning. “What do you mean?”

“Everyone has stories,” Bilbo spoke softly, still looking around him. “Of their lives, their mistakes, their family and their homes,” Bilbo turned to catch Thorin’s eye, “and their people.”

Professor Oakenshield grinned approvingly at this, nodding. “We dwarves keep these stories to ourselves. We don’t share them through ink, but through spoken words.”

“Is that so?” Bilbo said excitedly, forgetting the essays altogether and leaning closer to Thorin. “Tell me one.”

This took Thorin aback. “What?”

“Tell me something. Any story that only a dwarf would have heard.”

Thorin scowled at this. “There is no logic to that if I do.”

“Come now, I won’t tell anyone! Anything would do. A joke. A tragedy. A love story.”

“Why don’t you tell one of hobbits first,” Thorin retorted, trying to throw the hobbit off balance. Which went in vain.

“Okay,” Bilbo said brightly, standing up straighter, screwing his face in concentration, “Hmm, which one? Ah, I know.”

Thorin wondered if Bilbo knew how when he was to tell stories, he changed. His eyes grew wider and his cheeks got a natural flush, and a smile would tug at his lips. Before he began he inhaled deeply, his voice turning richer.

“Around Bree, there is a forgotten tavern all travelers know and whose name does not matter. When you started talking about the tavern, everyone who had visited instantly knew which one it was, and those who did not would never know.

“And in this old tavern, there was an old man, the drunk of big smiles and endless rants. Whenever a man would enter the place the drunk would croak, speaking to no end and annoying every bloke. To this men frowned upon, walking away and to their business they’d go on. And the tavern keeper, hobbit he was, was so restless when none but one to the tavern would come in, started to see that he’d need to get rid of the loyal drunk.”

Thorin decided to put his quill down and hear with rapt attention, annoyed once again how Bilbo was still the only being he knew who could entice him so.

“His opportunity he took when the drunk had struck a conversation with a couple of men who actually did not mind him, grinning and speaking and laughing and crying.

“The poor drunk had said, ‘I never drink enough to forget my poor wife, no drink in this land can ever fulfill me!’

“To this the tavern keeper remembered intently, waiting all night for the men to leave before he said, ‘Do you really believe there is no drink that would fill you?’

“The drunk nodded wildly, ‘No drink has and no drink will.’

“The tavern keeper grinned wickedly, ‘I know of a drink that could fulfill to your desire. It is on a place known to me.’

“The drunk looked up at him happily, ‘Why then show me this place! Show me!’

“And so he and the tavern keeper walked for day and night, through the Old Forest until finally reaching the Brandywine River.

“The drunk frowned, ‘Where is this place with this drink that will fill me?’

“’We are almost there,’ the tavern keeper said soothingly. ‘We just need a boat and then we will find it.’

“What the poor drunk did not know was the wicked tavern keeper’s plan, to throw him off the boat and let him drown! ‘That drink should fill him up,’ the tavern keeper thought grimly.

“On the boat they got in, on the boat they went, through the treacherous water that would take a life that night.

“’If you lean close you will see it,’ the tavern keeper said quietly.

“’Where?’ said the drunk eagerly, leaning too much to the edge of the boat.

“But what neither had noticed in their anticipation was the high rock on the front, and when the boat struck it this sent the drunk to fall back on the boat when it sent the tavern keeper flying into the waters. And the poor drunk, who did not know how to swim, could do nothing about him drowning.

“Around Bree, there is a forgotten tavern all travelers know and whose name does not matter. There an old drunk will serve the travelers, telling everyone who will listen how he came to be the new tavern keeper.”

Bilbo ended the story with an air of importance, smiling absentmindedly at what were probably memories that came with the story, memories of grass and running and the green hills of the Shire.

He finally looked up expectantly at Thorin. “Well?”

“It was a strange story,” Thorin said slowly. “I believed hobbits were creatures incapable of malice.”

“It is extremely rare, but not unheard of,” Bilbo shrugged. “And I feel as if the story is more of a warning. We can’t swim and it is very frowned upon to go on boats—it is too dangerous. And it also is about not leaving Hobbiton. That is probably why the hobbit was depicted as malignant. Those who wander too far from the Shire are always criticized and judged, and those who leave are practically all ostracized.”

Thorin frowned. “Including you?”

Bilbo’s smile automatically wiped from his face. “Not exactly. I still live on Bag End and many still sympathize me because of my parents.” Bilbo remembered these last summers, how people talked ill of him when they thought he could not hear and how many old friends were not willing to speak to him anymore. Because he was different. “But yea,” he said quietly, “Including me.”

Both grew quiet, Bilbo out of miserableness and Thorin out of fury. How could anyone shun Bilbo? How could anyone have the heart to willingly not see him and talk to him every single day? The mere idea in his head sounded ridiculous. He wanted to travel all the way to Bag End just to yell at every single one who had the nerve to do this.

In the silence they somehow continued to grade papers, but it was not the same. Thorin could tell by Bilbo’s slouched back and the slowed nature of the pen scratches. And this Thorin would not take.

He knew that Bilbo did not know of the implications of a dwarf revealing a story. When the language of Khuzdul, the secret language of dwarfs, leaked into everyone, a part of the dwarf culture was revealed to everyone as well, making it less precious as it had been for ages before. Dwarfs learned to replace this hollow with stories and tales, since young them taught not to reveal them to no one.

Very dramatic, really.

Thorin took a deep breath, his voice seeming louder on the silent room as he spoke, “In the First Age by the Lone-Lands, the dwarfs of Ered Luin there would roam. And in the dwarfs of Ered Luin was the line of Dûrambhar, young brother and sister only remaining.”

Bilbo looked up, startled by Thorin’s voice, expecting Thorin to not tell a tale after at all. With attentiveness he listened.

“The sister’s name was Mim, and she lived on the Lone-Lands with grace and brightness. But she was alone. Her brother, no matter his youth, had the kingdom Gabilgathol to rule, known today as Belegost. Girl dwarfs were scarce and all would be intimated by her. Boy dwarfs sneered at her. Adult dwarfs ignored her. And so she had no one to care for her.

“In her loneliness she would venture the woods, treading under trees and listening to the sound of life, there feeling the closest to having a friend. One night when wandering out of the roads and into a brook where she had been warned to avoid, there she found a boy.

“The boy was curious, taller and fairer with white blonde hair. She figured out he was not a dwarf, for he was too slender and his ears were pointed. But she did not care; that day she had made a friend.

“Deep in her heart she knew him to be an elf, and likewise the elf knew her to be a dwarf. The Sindarin elves and the Ered Luin dwarfs had been on a war since memory, vowing eternal hatred towards each other. And yet both naïve elf and dwarf did not care, for in each other they accepted their flaws.

“But with the end of youth came the end of innocence and naiveté, the meetings between each other less and less frequent, and taking place more and more in the secrecy of the night. Mim had turned to a woman, dark and beautiful. The dwarf had grown as well. And in their young, reckless nature they fell in love under the stars.

“Yet the war called the elf and to Mim he wouldn’t return for some time. The elf battled with reluctance but with distinction, and after he was permitted to return home in his restlessness left the main path and traveled to the forest, in search Mim. Mim he did not find, instead running into a whole troop of dwarfs marching home.

“Mim heard of the execution of some elf the next day and she did not wish to see such atrocity, but curiosity of who it was won over her and she ventured to the gallows where it would take place. At seeing her beloved about to be shot, she screamed and ran through the thick crowd, throwing herself in front of him and warning the executioner he’d have to go through her first.

“The king was informed of what was happening, and the dwarf king, so far away he did not recognize the girl being her sister, ordered the executioner to kill her too. To put his dwarf girl as an example, of what happens when you defy the king.”

“But what the king did not think of was the persistence of those in love, and somehow, the arrow pierced through Mim without even leaving a scratch on the elf. When the king had realized what had happened and who he had killed it had been too late, and he had let out a bloodcurdling yell to the heavens. Through his grief he decided to let go of the elf boy, asking for his forgiveness, for the peace of the two realms in the name of her sister.

“The elf traveled to the Sindarin, his home, and told his story to the king. The elf king was awed, and in seeing the maturity and wisdom the dwarfs could be capable of he accepted the dwarf king’s peace.

“Both realms lived through peace and prosperity, and the elf boy lived a long life as an advisor to both elf and dwarf king before his grief overpowered centuries and he ceased to be, meeting Mim in whatever is destined to all of us after death.”

His voice carried throughout the room, dying at once. Bilbo stared at him, awed. He opened in close his mouth, but no sound came.

“You could have said we were telling those kinds of stories!” Bilbbo finally said, exasperated.

Thorin smiled. Bilbo did not know the reason why he had told this particular story. To be frank Thorin did not know himself. In his youth he had scoffed at the dwarf girl, thinking her love of the dwarf ridiculous, a flaw. But now, a bubbling sympathy grew inside of him for her.

The stack of essays was gone, a less than a dozen remaining. Professor Oakenshield took a piece of parchment Bilbo had graded and nodded in approval.

“Very good, Mr. Baggins. I can see you are at least good on doing essays.”

“What is that supposed to mean?” Bilbo replied sharply.

“Your skills concerning protection against the dark arts are dreadful, of course,” Thorin said this matter-of-factly.

Bilbo looked at him, heavily offended. “No I’m not.”

“Yes you are.”

“Well, it’s not a skill I find to be useful for me later in life.”

“If this is true, then why did you enroll yourself in the class?”

Bilbo opened his mouth only to close it again. He dramatically slammed another essay on the desk and started grading it furiously.

Bilbo did have a reason, but it was too silly to be said out loud. All over Middle-Earth, on the calm land of the Shire even, the orc raids were very known and feared. Rumors of a dark force did not make the fear fade away any sooner, but that was all that they had been: rumors. The darkness was not returning.

“You know, I could assist you in your lessons.”

Bilbo’s grim thoughts vanished in an instant. He turned to look at Thorin, eyes wide. “Assist?”

“Some personal tutorials would not harm you, Bilbo. I usually do not give this option, but then again your situation is quite…unique.”

“Yes!” Bilbo said too quickly. “I mean…yes, I believe that would be helpful.”

Thorin nodded, proceeding his grading.

Later on the night, Bilbo could not help but yawn and Thorin noticed.

“It is late,” Thorin said, noticing the time to be after midnight. “You should go now. Get some sleep.”

“But tomorrow is Sunday,” Bilbo protested before realizing a normal student usually does not protest to being dismissed from detention.

“Go,” Thorin sharply said.

Bilbo huffed in annoyance, walking next to Thorin as he escorted him, walking him out the door. Outside no students or teachers could be seen or heard wandering the halls anymore. Perhaps it was late.

Professor Oakenshield stood there, holding the door open. “And now that you are to leave, you can tell me why you have been angry at me.”

Bilbo was stunned; he had thought he had done well on hiding it. “It may be because you called my skills dreadf—“

“No,” Thorin said simply.

Bilbo deflated. He muttered in the smallest of voices, “Why did you choose me to have in detention? Why not another?”

Thorin grinned. “Selfish reasons.”

And with this he closed the door, leaving Bilbo even more confused than he was before.

Notes:

The dwarfs of Ered Luin and the elves of Sindarin are canon and did quarrel, but I made up everything else.