Chapter Text
“I give up,” said Hamfast with finality, burying his head on his crossed arms.
“Come now, Gamgee.”
“It’s too much information to handle! I’ll never understand.”
“Don’t be so thick,” Paladin firmly said. “Eregion is just one kingdom.”
“But why do we have to know all of its history?” Hamfast moaned.
“A gross simplification of its history. It’s not that hard,” Paladin corrected, scowling. “Now get up.”
Hamfast groaned in protest, eventually getting up. The common room buzzed with liveliness as usual, gracefully accepting the arrival of autumn, of damper skies of gray and winds that chilled all the way through the bones, forcing the students to get out their coats and scarves wherever they would go.
“I’m fine Paladin,” Hamfast eventually said. “You’ll be late to Professor Oakenshield’s if you do not hurry up.”
“Right,” Paladin sighed. “Professor Oakenshield.”
As usual, Bilbo was nowhere to be found as class began. It had been four days since the boggart incident, and with time the situation had gone from bad to worst.
***
Paladin still remembered that day clearly.
An hour had passed after Bilbo’s lesson, then two, then three. One hour passed after another, making Paladin and Hamfast’s anxiety accumulate with time. They waited anxiously for Bilbo in the dormitory, where everyone else was sound asleep.
“That’s it!” Hamfast had blurted out. “I’m looking for him. Forget the bloody curfew.”
There was no need.
Paladin and Hamfast had not even swung open the portrait of the Fat Lady when they found Bilbo sitting in the common room, chin propped up on his knees as he curled on a sofa. He was staring glassily into the dying fireplace.
His face held no blood in it, his cheeks were tearstained and his eyes looked hollow. His robes were tattered and dirty, as if he had been sprinting around the grounds carelessly. When he spoke his voice was hoarse, and it was the most heartbreaking thing to hear. He kept repeating to himself in a rhythm of breaths, “What did I do? What did I do? What did I do?”
“Bilbo,” the name tasted dry on Hamfast’s tongue. “What’s wrong?”
Bilbo had whimpered in the smallest voice, as he told them everything. It made Paladin and Hamfast feel so helpless, but there was nothing that he or Hamfast could do because Bilbo was determined not to speak another word after that. When the two encouraged him to say how he felt, he shook his head and buried his head between his knees, unwilling to go with them to the dormitory.
“Why,” Hamfast had said to Paladin in the darkness of the dormitory, “does everything happen to Bilbo?”
Paladin was already half asleep and did not answer.
***
“Good morning,” Bilbo grinned at the two next morning, fumbling with his clothes. “You should have woken me up sooner! Professor Thranduil will skin me if I am late again…”
If he noticed Paladin and Hamfast staring at him as he looked for clean robes, he said nothing.
“Er,” said Hamfast. “How-How are you feeling Bilbo?”
Bilbo raised an eyebrow. “Never been better.” He left Paladin and Hamfast gaping as he walked down to get at least a piece of toast before rushing into Potions.
It was as if the last night had never happened. Every time Paladin and Hamfast tried to bring the subject up, he acted as if he didn’t hear them and would strike up a completely different conversation.
The closest Bilbo ever acknowledged the event was when he had declared that he’d never go back to Defense Against the Dark Arts.
“I’m not going,” Bilbo had simply said. “I’m done.”
“You are being ridiculous,” Paladin replied in outrage.
“I’m sorry, Paladin,” Bilbo said. “I’ve already talked to Professor Balin about it.”
“You can’t just go to the head of Gryffindor and get out of a class!”
“I know that now,” Bilbo smiled weakly. “But he said that if I was to not go anymore and fail the class, there was nothing he could do about it.”
Paladin and Hamfast thought he would grow out of this madness, but for four days, every afternoon, Paladin would walk alone to Thorin’s classroom as Bilbo would stay in his dormitory and read. Paladin was so furious with him on the second day, he would not talk to him. It was ridiculous! Bilbo could not fail a class because of a heartbreak! The ache would pass, but the grade would stay forever.
The third day he tried to be reasonable, forcing Hamfast to reluctantly make himself sit next to Bilbo in the library as he tried to speak with him. Hamfast rolled his eyes up to the heavens in pleading before Paladin sharply said at once, “Bilbo, look. I know…”
Paladin paused. For the first time he contemplated the delicacy of the situation. “I know that the last thing you want to do is see…him…again. But this is bigger than that, this is your education. You cannot fail! You are just going to have to redo it next year anyways. Bilbo, please! You are a Baggins. Be logical.”
Bilbo, who had been reading Fantastic Creatures and Where to Find Them for the thirteenth time, sighed and placed the book down. He looked at Paladin with pure honesty in his eyes. “Paladin, do you not think I know I am not being logical?”
Paladin said nothing.
“I know I’m being illogical. I have never done anything so stupid in my life. And I…I know…” His voice began to quiver. He cleared his throat and tried again. “I know this is something my parents would not be proud of…but I just don’t know what to do. I just…” The mirage of calmness Bilbo had held the last few days faded down momentarily, and his crestfallen expression made Paladin regret mentioning anything at all. “I just don’t know what else to do.”
So by the fourth day, Paladin dropped it. At least that’s what Bilbo thought. The dormitories were dimming with the descending sun. Bilbo had just started Stories of Rivendell when the hobbit slowly sat next to him. This time, Paladin’s voice was warmer.
“Thorin spoke to me.”
Bilbo’s heart skipped a beat, but he did not let it show. “And?” Bilbo said, trying to sound normal.
“He asked me how you were.”
Bilbo could not help but to snap his head up.
“I told him you were fine,” Paladin said hastily. “But Bilbo…” Paladin hesitated. “He told me that you should go to class.”
“Paladin— "
“Just hear me out, all right?” Paladin said. “He said you don’t have to make up your missing work until the next test and that I can help you pick up on the days you missed. He’ll even overlook the days you haven’t gone and—“ and the boggart incident. Paladin did not have to finish for Bilbo to know what he meant.
Bilbo was at a loss for words. All of the arguments he had repeated to himself for days suddenly didn’t make sense to him anymore. Typical, Bilbo thought sourly.
He looked down at his lap, then back at his friend. He thought of Thorin, telling Paladin in a concerned voice to convince Bilbo to go back to class.
Bilbo could not help but to give a grim smile. What a good teacher Thorin was, not permitting a student to fail on his watch. Paladin looked at him expectantly, waiting for Bilbo to respond.
“I’ll go,” he heard himself say, and was just as surprised as Paladin when he said it.
And so Bilbo joined Paladin as he walked all the way to that room full of Cithril runes and dwarf books, convinced that everything would be better for his friend now.
But Paladin was wrong.
Before, there was a wordless bond Thorin and Bilbo had always shared in class. There would be little things that no one would notice, except the two and Paladin. Thorin would glance at Bilbo in amusement when he would fail at a spell and Bilbo would roll his eyes. Bilbo would snicker when Thorin would trail off the lesson to a personal tale. In the rare times when Paladin did not understand a concept, Thorin would raise his eyebrows in mock astonishment and everyone would laugh, but no one’s laugh was richer than Bilbo’s. The bond held something stronger than words: it held mutual fondness. It had always annoyed Paladin to death.
Of course, Paladin did not expect the two to have this anymore, but he hadn’t thought of them being so viciously cold with each other either.
Bilbo and Professor Oakenshield had somehow mutually agreed to ignore each other the most they possibly could. When Professor Oakenshield would acknowledge Bilbo’s existence, which was very rare, it would be to ask him a question concerning the lesson, and Bilbo would always lie about how he understood even if it meant he’d have to ask Paladin later.
To anyone else it would have seemed Bilbo did not mind this little agreement between the two, but Paladin knew better. He could see the crushed expression when Thorin was not looking, heard his random melancholy sighs at dinners, noticed his longing glances at the grounds in the mornings, and Paladin hated it. He hated how his friend was suffering so much. He hated it with a passion.
The only people who hated the situation more than Paladin were Fili and Kili.
***
Fili and Kili were always good in twisting the truth out of people, Thorin had always known in amusement. He became much less amused when they used it on him.
***
Two fortnights came and passed by, and there were no noteworthy events but three.
The first was the second Gryffindor match, where Gryffindor was almost crushed by Hufflepuff if they had not caught the Snitch. The team did not let that one go for a week, and even Paladin was getting tired of mentioning it.
The second was that Professor Thranduil was being abnormally happy. Bilbo remembered distinctly to have been reading something about an orc raid in the Daily Prophet that day, but he had to hurry up to Potions if he didn't want to be late again.
The sight that had greeted him was bizarre. Professor Thranduil was humming a light tune, cauldrons around him fuming with all kinds of pleasant smells and colors, as he stirred a particularly small one made of silver that held a purplish liquid. Bilbo slowly raised an eyebrow, wondering for a second if he had accidentally ran into a wall earlier.
“Ah, come in Bilbo!” Professor said, smiling. “Turn in your essay before you sit.”
“Yeah, er, about that,” Bilbo bit the inside of his cheek. “I did not finish it, Professor. I am truly sorry.”
To be fair that essay of the Elixir of Life was insanely difficult, and Thranduil had barked at them to do it in four days. Even Paladin himself could not have done it without straining himself.
“I did not do it either Professor,” chirped in a freckled human girl.
“Neither did I.”
Unsurprisingly about half of the class had not completed it, but what scared the life out of everyone was when Professor Thranduil gave them another week to finish.
“Professor Thranduil,” Lobelia said slowly, lifting the lid of a lonely cauldron in the corner of the classroom. “What’s this potion?” From inside the cauldron, there was a visible pinkish fume swirling upwards.
“Careful, Lobelia,” Professor Thranduil said playfully. “That is Amortentia, the potion of love. Obviously, no one can truly force someone to fall in love with them. It is mere infatuation. Nonetheless it is very powerful and dangerous, so I bid you to leave it alone.” Lobelia scowled at Professor Thranduil, slowly lowering the lid.
The way Professor Thranduil walked, as if he was treading on clouds, made Bilbo think something was amiss about his Potions teacher. Whether it was good or bad, Bilbo still wasn’t sure. His own head was somewhere else too.
The third was the orange.
Orange was all around the castle, unusually so. It was on the back of trees and the tips of the branches. It was cluttered on the earth and caught between the wind. In previous years the grounds would be greeted by autumn with the greens of grass and leaves gradually turning to shades of yellow and red, with orange caught in the middle. But now all students woke up to be slammed by a sea of orange, and it was breathtaking.
Restless winds and booming thunderclaps tapped Bilbo’s dormitory, snapping him awake at once. Everyone else had awoken, leaving him alone. His window panes rattled with violence as he left for breakfast.
He caught Hamfast in Charms, sitting as quietly as possible so Professor Proudfoot would not notice him. Thankfully, Professor Proudfoot was too busy trying to make Bofur not inundate the classroom.
“Why did you not wake me up?” Bilbo hissed. By how the classroom was flowing with silence he knew they were practicing incantations without speaking again.
“I was already late myself,” Hamfast snapped back. “Now let me do this, Professor Proudfoot is already on my back…”
“Mr. Gamgee, can I see you try?” came the Professor’s voice, as if summoned with his name.
Hamfast jumped, turning pale. “Er, yeah.” With a slow swish of his wand, what seemed a savage, small-scale hurricane of water spurted out of his wand. It soaked the brunet elf boy next to Hamfast, who scowled at him with loathing.
“Try not to be so nervous, Gamgee,” Professor Proudfoot tutted. “Now let’s see you, Mister Baggins.”
“Yes, Professor,” Bilbo quickly said, promptly filling his cup with clear water wordlessly. Professor Proudfoot nodded in content, and gave five points to Gryffindor.
Hamfast looked at him with the clearest I-hate-you glare in existence. Bilbo chuckled.
At lunch, Paladin joined them. “Why do you look like you swallowed a lemon?” he said to Hamfast.
“I was given extra homework in Charms again. And perfect Bilbo did not.”
“Lighten up, will you? I’ll help you do it.”
“Anyways,” Paladin said loudly. “I was going to go visit Bard, but I rather not be blown by the wind to the Forbidden Forest.”
“Yes,” Bilbo sighed. The day stubbornly did not let go of its windy and rainy nature all day.
“I have Quidditch practice today, so I do not see the difference,” said Paladin. “Do help me pick up on History of Magic later, will you Hamfast?”
“Sure.”
By the way the sky darkened from gray to black, it was just after sunset when Bilbo and Hamfast walked back to the tower. Neither spoke.
It was quite obvious how much quieter Bilbo had turned nowadays, even to Hamfast. But Hamfast, unalike Paladin, was rubbish at talking about feelings. He has and always had been, and Bilbo knew that. So it was better for both if they did not speak.
A sudden burst of laughter came from the corridor next to them, and Fili and Kili walked in front of them. They froze.
“Oh,” Fili said awkwardly. “Hullo Hamfast. Hullo Bilbo.”
Bilbo did not answer, so Hamfast said, “Hullo.” He looked at them suspiciously. They were covered in mud, holding their wands steadily as if they had just managed a conspiracy. “What are you up to?”
Both smiled mischievously. “Nothing,” Kili said. “We just thought the Quidditch team would be bored. Thought we would make their day more interesting.”
“What exactly did you do?” Hamfast’s voice turned sharper.
“Just forget about it,” Fili said airily. “How have you two been? What has been going on in your lives?”
Bilbo smiled weakly. Kili and Hamfast stared daggers at Fili. Fili’s mouth mouthed “oops.”
“We really should be going, we probably have a mob following us,” Kili said in a rush. “Come on Fili—"
“OI!”
The four turned around and gasped, facing not a mob but something much, much worse; Tauriel was storming towards them, her fire-red hair dancing behind her and escaping the elaborate braid she had put in.
“Okay bye,” said Fili, him and Kili making a run for it.
“Move one more step and I will stun you both!” Tauriel yelled. Both dwarves immediately stopped.
Like Fili and Kili, Tauriel was also spattered in mud, except that only in her front, as if she had been caught in a mud explosion. Her eyes were full of fire.
“What,” she said in such a low voice, her chest rising and falling, “were you two thinking?”
The two did not answer.
“Professor Balin will hear about this—“ Tauriel began.
“Whoa, whoa, hey,” Fili said. “It was just a bit of fun.”
“Our practice had to be postponed! Everyone will be wiping mud from them for weeks!”
“Look—“
“Why would you do this?”
“Can’t you take a joke?”
That was the wrong thing to say. Tauriel had already opened her mouth in seething rage when Kili spoke for the first time.
“We did not mean to sabotage your practice. We’re very sorry.”
Fili scowled at him and Tauriel’s eyes widened. Her expression softened for a second, but it changed to irritation again. “Do not do it again.”
She stomped off, presumably to the showers. The four looked at her go. Fili waited until she was out of sight before he blurted out, “The nerve of that girl! Can’t she take a joke? Berk.”
Kili did not say anything, still staring at where the she-elf had disappeared to.
“We are leaving now,” Hamfast said loudly, taking Bilbo by the wrist and pulling him on towards the tower.
On their way there they ran into some very grumpy Quidditch players indeed, all covered in twigs and mud.
“I don’t want to talk about it,” Paladin snapped at them as he also passed by, but Bilbo and Hamfast did not hear him. They were too busy laughing.
***
“I can’t stay, I have to go to Bard’s,” Bilbo said over the pile of books.
The weekend came as a blessing for the hobbits, school work gradually creeping up on them until it was close to drowning them. They had agreed to spend the whole day diving in the pile, or so Paladin and Hamfast had thought.
“But what about Potions?”
“Professor Thranduil has been oddly generous lately. He barely even gives us homework.”
“You don’t have to lie to us, you know.”
“I’m serious!” said Bilbo. “He’s gone bonkers! But that’s a story for another day.”
“Well you know we can’t go,” said Paladin. “Quidditch practices have made me slow on work and Hamfast has that test on Monday.”
“I’m not asking you to come with me,” Bilbo said kindly.
It had been an unsaid agreement that Bilbo was to be escorted everywhere right after the…event, just in case they would stumble across Professor Oakenshield out of class and Bilbo could not handle it. That rule with the days and weeks had faded off. It was clear now that the unspoken rule was over.
“Fine,” Paladin said, turning back to his book. “As you wish.”
Bilbo nodded and walked away. The halls were more vacant than usual, for the weather was unusually pleasant. The sun hung brightly over them, covering the grounds with a warmth that had become unfamiliar to the students. Everyone took advantage of this and wandered outside.
But Bard was not in his hut. The home was firmly shut and Bilbo huffed in annoyance. All of his gardening tools were in the shack, which was locked. The key was inside. He was almost positive that trying to unlock it with magic would not work, but he tried anyways.
“Alohomora,” he said clearly, pointing his wand at the door. Nothing happened. Bilbo’s face darkened.
He thought he might as well go back to the library as he entered the school again when he ran into a familiar face. Tauriel was sitting in the corner of the hallway, hidden between the wall and a large knight statue.
“Tauriel?”
Tauriel looked up. “Hullo there. Bilbo, yes?”
“Yea, I’m Bilbo Baggins.”
Tauriel paused, looking at Bilbo up and down. She cautiously said, “Were you there when I yelled at the two dwarf boys last night?”
Bilbo considered lying to save her from the embarrassment. “I was there. They’re named Fili and Kili by the way.”
Tauriel stood up, making Bilbo turn his head up. “I’m so sorry you had to see that. I’m usually not so cynical.”
“You don’t have to apologize, Fili and Kili can be tossers sometimes.”
Tauriel laughed. “They can.”
“But they are good tossers,” Bilbo said quickly. “They’re usually not gits, promise.”
“I am sure they are not,” Tauriel grinned.
“You should be,” a voice that was neither Bilbo nor Tauriel’s answered sheepishly.
Bilbo and Tauriel turned to see a very wary Kili standing next to them. He was bouncing on the balls of his feet.
“I was looking for you to apologize about yesterday properly.”
“You already did,” Tauriel pointed out.
“Right,” Kili said, feeling stupid. “At least let me thank you for not reporting us to Professor Balin.”
Tauriel’s narrowed slightly. Kili continued, “If you need help cleaning what we did—”
“No need,” said Tauriel. “It just needed a couple of spells.”
“Ah,” Kili nodded. “Good.”
Kili and Tauriel gazed at each other, and Bilbo found himself feeling oddly uncomfortable. He reckoned that he could walk away without the two noticing.
“I better go,” Tauriel said. “I have to go speak to the Astronomy professor.”
“Astronomy, huh,” Kili grimaced. “Not quite my favorite subject. I always thought stars as a cold light, remote and far away.”
“Astronomy is more than just stars,” Tauriel said. “And it is memory, precious and pure.” Tauriel hesitated, before saying. “I will only talk to the professor briefly. Would you like to go with me?”
Kili brightened before clearing his throat and saying with a ridiculously deep tone, “Yea, yea, of course.” He smirked at her, a smirk that reminded Bilbo awfully of the smirk of another dwarf.
They started to walk away, Kili looking behind his shoulder and mouthing, “Sorry.”
Bilbo smiled, shaking his head. “It’s fine,” he mouthed back, waving him away.
He could hear the two talking merrily as they walked away.
“I have walked there sometimes,” Tauriel was saying. “Beyond the Forbidden Forest and up into the night” and in her voice her excitement of doing such a wild thing was apparent. “I have seen the world fall away and the white light forever fill the air…”
Not knowing exactly what had just happened, Bilbo decided he might as well check if Bard was home again before calling it a day.
***
“Have you seen Kili?”
Paladin snapped awake and Hamfast fell off his seat, dropping half a dozen books with him. Fili was looking at them expectantly.
“Can you repeat that question?” Paladin slurred.
“Kili,” Fili said. “I can’t find him anywhere. He’s not in the common room, not in the Forbidden Forest, not at Bard’s…”
“And what would make you think he would be in the library?”
“As you can see, I am desperate.”
Hamfast sat up and yawned before answering, “We have not. Sorry, mate.”
“Well, where on Middle Earth—“
“Oi! Fili!”
Fili turned around. Paladin and Hamfast glanced curiously as Bofur approached them.
“Found your brother,” Bofur said. “He’s sitting by the Great Lake.”
Fili sighed in relief. “I thought he had gone to the Forbidden Forest by himself again.”
“Don’t worry, he’s just with Tauriel.”
Fili froze. “What?”
“You know Tauriel! That brilliant Chaser.” Bofur’s eyebrow creased. “Anything wrong?”
“You said they were at the Great Lake.”
“Well not now anymore, it’s too dark. They’re probably at the common room now. What’s wrong with you?”
“I need to check on him,” Fili growled. “before he does something insane. Like pick a fight with the Giant Squid. Or fall in love.”
“What are you doing?” said Bofur. “Don’t be mental, Fili!” He groaned when Fili ignored him and swept off. “Fili, comeback here!” He ran after him.
Paladin and Hamfast stared. “That sounds like a whole lot of drama,” Hamfast muttered.
“We sure shouldn’t get into that mess.”
They both looked at each other, thinking exactly the same thing. In the blink of an eye, they stuffed their bags with their books and scrolls before sprinting to the common room.
***
They did not need to go that far, Fili and Kili having the biggest row right in front of the portrait of the Fat Lady. The two slowed their gait as they were within earshot.
“—dragging me from there like that!” Kili was shouting.
“You said you didn’t like elves! Too thin and too much high cheekbones, you said!”
“I can change my mind, you know? And why are we even discussing this? I don’t even know if I fancy her! And it is not your business anyways,” Kili added.
“You are my small brother. You are my business,” Fili snarled.
“This is getting out of hand,” Hamfast muttered.
“We should do something,” Paladin agreed. Both walked towards the three, who were now speaking in hurried whispers.
“Do you want to end up like uncle? Do you want to suffer like he is now?” Paladin heard Fili say, and Paladin let out a small gasp. Hamfast heard too, raising his eyebrows. The two made sure they stayed out of sight.
“Uncle’s situation is completely different,” Kili hissed. “He fell in love with a student. Tauriel’s an elf. She and Bilbo have nothing in common!”
“What?”
The four froze, including Paladin and Hamfast. Neither of them had spoken.
“What?” the voice repeated again, the figure of a hobbit with honey curls and blue eyes walking towards them. He had been walking behind where Paladin and Hamfast were hiding. His voice was steady, but his hands were noticeably shaking.
“Bilbo,” Paladin breathed, horrified. “What are you doing?”
Bilbo seemed to not have heard him. “What did you just say?” he said to Kili.
Neither Fili and Kili said anything, staring at the three with wide eyes, like if they stared hard enough they would disappear from sight.
“What did you just say?” Bilbo repeated forcefully, his voice threatening.
“Uncle is going to kill us,” Fili said under his breath.
“Bilbo,” Kili said gently. “You have to understand why we did not tell you—“
Before Kili could finish Bilbo sprinted off in the direction of Thorin’s classroom. “Bilbo, wait!” Fili yelled, but it was no use. Bilbo was long gone.
“What just happened?” Paladin said.
“Since when were you two standing there,” Fili said heatedly.
“Not important right now,” Hamfast said. “And don’t try to turn this on us.”
“Should we go after him?” Kili said anxiously. “Uncle is not even—“
Paladin shook his head. “No,” he said. “No, let him find it out himself. He needs to settle his thoughts.”
***
Bilbo did not know what to feel, what to think. He only knew that he had to reach Thorin and hear the words from him, to be completely sure. Then, and only then, would he let the dam of emotions he felt tapping at the back of his head overwhelm him.
In a rush, he found himself in front of the classroom, leaning on the door and catching his breath. Without knocking, he opened the door to the familiar room, his heart pounding with the possibilities: but the torches were unlit and no one was there.
“My dear Bilbo, what are you doing?”
Bilbo jumped. It was Professor Balin, standing behind him.
“Professor Balin,” said Bilbo. He tried his best not to sound breathy. “I was just looking for Professor Oakenshield. It’s...urgent.”
“Professor Oakenshield? Oh, you will have to wait, my dear boy. He left the school a while ago, said he was traveling North. He has a meeting with our kin but he’ll be back soon.”
“How soon?”
“Tomorrow! He will not want to miss tomorrow!” Balin chuckled dryly.
“What’s tomorrow?”
Professor Balin raised an eyebrow. “The Feast of Starlight, of course.”
