Actions

Work Header

The After Effects of Amortentia

Chapter 7

Summary:

A Quidditch match, a drinking contest, and a boggart.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It just had rained, and the damp, red earth under Bilbo’s feet would stick and feel coarse as he kneeled, tending a yellowing camellia and thought. It was almost night, a chattering of flying birds clouding the golden sunset. The wind started to bite maliciously at his pinking skin. From afar the castle started to glow from inside. He knew it was time to leave, but the flowers needed caring, and he would not be able to come to Bard’s tomorrow. Bilbo’s fingers were numb from raking the pumpkin roots but he kept tending the camellias.

Hamfast struggled silently at his side, spade stubbornly on hand as he dug a hole deep enough to plant strawberry seeds. Bilbo grinned. If there was one student at Hogwarts who knew more about gardening than he, it was Hamfast. Hamfast huffed in contempt and drew out his wand, muttering something under his breath. Four holes identical to the ones he had just dug appeared side by side, and Hamfast happily dropped the remaining seeds inside each one and filled them by sliding mountains of soil individually.

Bilbo smirked. “Using magic, are we?”

“What about it?” Hamfast said, half defiantly and half sheepishly, turning to study the squash.

“What about all that ‘There’s nothing like planting your own trees’ rubbish?”

Hamfast’s round face darkened. “Shut up, Bilbo.”

Bilbo laughed, his mirth turning into chuckles. The sun was about to disappear. “I wonder when Bard will come back,” he sighed.

“Bard told us not to wait for him to come back,” Hamfast said gruffly to the earth. He snapped his head up. “It’s getting dark.”

“We should get going,” Bilbo agreed, already standing up. The wind was howling, and the now scarlet sky gave the Forbidden Forest from afar an eerie look. It struck Bilbo then how this was autumn at its finest. It made him smile. “Paladin will be worried.”

“It is not our fault that he did not want to come with us,” Hamfast’s eyebrows creased.

“He had Quidditch practice.”

“Oh practice, practice. Doesn’t he deserve a break?”

“Their match with the Ravenclaws is in three days.”

“Your point is?”

“I dunno—hey, is that Bard?”

Hamfast narrowed his eyes. “Yes, but who is that he is holding by the neck?” His eyes blew wide. “It’s Kili.”

“What?” The two figures stepped farther away from the evergreen trees and it became clear that it was no other but the young dwarf, robes askew and arms crossed in contempt. Bilbo leaned in and looked closer, curious.

“It is Kili” said Hamfast, awed. “It’s been awhile since we’ve seen that mad dwarf. Oi!” Hamfast bellowed, raising his hand and waving it wildly. “Bard! Kili!”

Bard’s head snapped towards their direction, and his face broke into a smile. “Ah, Hamfast. Is that Bilbo with you?”

“Yep!”

“Good!” Bard said back, walking towards them, Kili still in his grasp. “Just the two hobbits to help me.”

“What can we help you with?” Bilbo said politely, looking up at the human.

“Do me a favor and escort Mr. Kili to the Gryffindor tower,” Bard said bitingly. “And I would be furtherly grateful if you could inform his uncle of his and Fili’s misdoings. This is just getting ridiculous.”

“I’ll see what I can do,” Bilbo said placidly. He beckoned Kili to follow him as he and Hamfast continued walking back to school. “Goodbye, Bard!”

“Goodbye, boys.”

“You know, that human is very good at his job,” Kili announced. “He’s caught my brother and I more than Radagast ever did in three years.”

“Why do you sound so smug? Is that not supposed to be a problem?”

“Well yes, I guess,” Kili shrugged, a devious smile appearing on his lips. “Or maybe he’ll make our trips much more interesting.”

“Kili, what do you even do in there?” Hamfast asked, exasperated.

“It’s better you don’t know, little hobbit,” Kili said importantly.

“Probably just goes around passing his time swatting pixies,” Hamfast said under his breath. Bilbo laughed.

Kili scowled not unlike his uncle. “Better than gardening.”

Bilbo grinned. “I beg to differ.” The grounds disappeared, entering the castle illuminated by fire and full of stretched shadows. “But I must say, I am glad I’ll go back to Thorin’s lessons soon.”

At his comment Kili’s gait slowed, grimacing. “Yea, of course. Right. I better go off.” He turned around on his heels and walked in long strides on the opposite corridor, away from the tower.

Hamfast and Bilbo stared at the distancing figure. “O-kay,” Hamfast said slowly.

“That was odd.”

“Since you developed a crush on the new Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher odd is normal to me,” Hamfast yawned. “Let’s just go study for Transfiguration.”

Bilbo kept his gaze lingering where Kili departed. He nodded.

The common room was flooded with people. They shouted and laughed and chatted and would not let Hamfast and Bilbo concentrate. It got to a point that Hamfast burst, flicking out his wand and booming, “SILENCIO!” He was promptly expelled from the common room for the night. Paladin, who had been lost in a conversation with the Gryffindor Beaters, glowered at them both, unable to do otherwise until someone in the room figured finally out how to repel the charm silently.

Bilbo could not help but to laugh at the whole thing.

The moon that hung over the window now bid Bilbo’s eyes to droop sleepily. He yawned. Bilbo changed his clothes and settled over his bed, the blankets turning his sleepiness thicker until his eyes were too heavy to open and his mind turned blissfully silent as well.

It did not last.

***

Bilbo had noticed Thorin’s odd reaction that day with Bard, of course he had. Thorin’s face had darkened and his fists had noticeably clenched. Arguing and handling an angry Thorin was something Bilbo was used to, as he had proved when tutorials had gone wrong sometimes. So he had not thought much on that evening until Hamfast, Paladin, and Bilbo were walking towards the library and had happened to run into Fili and Kili. The two brothers reacted immediately, turning around, a step away from breaking into running.

The three hobbits were befuddled. Hamfast and Bilbo exchanged a glance with raised eyebrows and Paladin said, “Has it struck you guys that we have not seen much of them two lately?”

“Haven’t even seen them passing by since we ran into Kili yesterday,” Hamfast said softly.

The three looked at each other questioningly.

It had happened again on dinnertime. The two brothers were walking out of the Great Hall and caught a glance at them before rushing to get lost in a corridor. The three reacted quickly.

“Stop right there!” Paladin shouted dangerously. The two brothers froze. They turned around with a fake smile.

“Ah, Paladin,” said Fili. “Didn’t see you there.”

“Of course you didn’t. Why have you two been avoiding us?”

“We have not,” Kili said, affronted. “I just saw you yesterday.”

“Yea, before running away the second we got into the castle,” said Hamfast.

“I have no idea what you are talking about.”

Bilbo spoke, “Look Kili, if it is about me telling Thorin about you wandering the Forbidden Forest, don’t worry about it. He already knows anyways, no reason to remind him.”

Fili and Kili looked at Bilbo for the first time, and their faces held true guilt and miserableness. “Oh Bilbo, don’t be kind,” Fili groaned. “You’ll only make this harder for us.”

“Make what harder?” Bilbo said.

“Bilbo, can you wait? We are trying to make Uncle snap out of it.”

“What did Thorin say?” A dull, unpleasant feeling had started to flicker inside Bilbo’s chest.

“Give us a couple of days to change his mind,” Kili persisted.

Bilbo laughed hollowly. “We three know not even the Minister of Magic himself can make Thorin change his mind. Just tell me.”

“But—“

“Just tell me,” Bilbo repeated.

Fili fell silent. Kili sighed an bowed his head before stuttering, “Er, Uncle—I mean Professor Oakenshield—wanted us to inform you that, well, that you have improved immensely in his class and um, your private lessons are…over.”

Two second years passed the corridor, their voices deafeningly loud in their pass. A dull buzzing started to poke Bilbo’s ears. He felt numb, like when one gets burned and the pain has not kicked in yet. Paladin looked enraged out of words and Hamfast kept opening and closing his mouth.

“Oh” was all said, all Bilbo could say. “Okay.”

Everyone was looking at him, waiting.

“Bilbo,” Paladin said in the gentlest voice. “Are you okay?”

“What?” Bilbo said. “Oh yes, yes.” His voice had started to tremble, and Bilbo hated that. He cleared his throat. “I actually have to go.”

Bilbo knew that the three were looking at him sympathetically as he left. He wished they wouldn’t. His insides felt on fire. His head felt cold and unconnected to his body. All around him did not matter. It felt like a dream.

He thought of the lessons, of the wary question and endless demonstrations, of Thorin not minding to repeat himself because Bilbo was not listening, of the victory in understanding. He thought of the wary touches, the brief eye lingering, and the fluttering hope. And the stories.

In his numbness he bumped into someone and did not bother to apologize. If people were not around he would gladly sink on his knees right then and there in the middle of the corridor and lay there with his cheek on the cold stone.

No more hearing of Thorin’s stories. Of epic battles and love tragedies. Of taking care of his nephews when babies. Of the Blue Mountains and Erebor. Of unnecessarily detailed anecdotes on why his sister Dis cheated on Quidditch matches when he was young.

No more of Thorin’s stories. No more Thorin.

The worst part, the part that made Bilbo flinch without will, was that it was true. Bilbo had gotten significantly better. He was not on the edge of failing anymore—quite the contrary. There was absolutely no reason for Thorin to still teach him anymore. Not one.

In his mind he saw Thorin realizing this, changing his view of Bilbo’s tutorials, not a necessity anymore, but a disturbance. Plucking his time with Bilbo like Bilbo plucked the shriveling, yellowing leaves of his plants.

All around him did not matter.

The pitch-black skies made the castle turn darker and somehow, Bilbo found himself five footsteps from Thorin’s classroom. He knew the professor was probably not there, no reason to being so late in a Friday.

Why? The question at last dared to fade into his mind. Why did Thorin not like him? A thousand logical answers exploded in Bilbo’s mind. He’s a student, he’s a hobbit, he’s young, he’s weak against the Dark Arts, he sometimes laughs too hard at bad jokes, he has a passion for gardening, he’s unlovable.

Each and every reason evaporated at the image of Thorin’s smirking face in his mind.

The weight of his grief finally made Bilbo’s knees give away and buckle. He remained standing up only as he leaned into the door. His breath became shallow, sprawling his hands on the rough wood, trying to hold on as if his life depended on it. Him leaning made the door creak slightly and his hands turned into fists when there was nothing to grab, to feel fold between his fingers.

His throat felt heavy, his eyes watered, but he blinked the tears away.

A part of him wanted to yell, to punch the door until his hands turned raw and shout until his voice turned into a tired croak, demanding Thorin to open the door. He wanted to ask why to Thorin, to make him clarify, to make him tell Bilbo all of this in his face.

But Bilbo was a Baggins and a Baggins did not mourn over what was never his. A Baggins is honorable, respectable, reasonable. One of the only things he remembers his father telling him in that little hobbit hole surrounded by so many books and scrolls.

He knew the only thing to do now was the logical thing from the start. Forget and pray this incident of his heart is never discovered.

With a deep, shaky breath he stands up. He manages to align his posture and slowly walk, away from Thorin’s classroom and to the tower in the most strained gait he could manage, like had done a thousand times before. He did not go to class the next day.

***

It was time.

The stadium was roaring in a sea of blue, gray, scarlet and gold, stretching out to form waves and holding signs with things such as “GO RAVENCLAW” and “Fear Gryffindor!”, almost all enchanted to change their words every second or so. The excitement was palpable in the air.

Bilbo and Hamfast sat down, waiting for the match to start. Bilbo was on the edge of his seat, looking around eagerly at all the exhilaration around him. “Fili was not lying,” Bilbo cried. “That little first year dwarf is the new speaker!”

“Who?’ Hamfast leaned forward.

“Ori!”

“And so we are off!” Ori boomed at the microphone, making the whole stadium twitch. He quickly lowered his tone after the recognizable voice of Professor Proudfoot’s barked at him. “Oops, sorry there folks. Apparently the Ravenclaw players are barely getting in position.”

“How did a first year even get to be speaker?” Hamfast said incredulously.

At the sound of Ori’s voice all dwarves from every house shouted in happiness, deafening the whole stadium.

“That’s why,” Bilbo smiled.

“Gryffindor’s already positioned, and the game begins!” Ori says. “Chaser Legolas immediately takes the ball, dodges it from Rendil. He tries to pass it to Bratt but—ooh, she misses it! Ravenclaw tries to retrieve it but Legolas is too fast. Legolas gets closer. HE PASSES IT TO TAURIEL. TAURIEL SHOOTS AND-“ The rest of his sentence was lost to the cheers and hisses of the crowd. “TAURIEL SCORES! SHE SCORES!”

The Gryffindors are ecstatic. By Tauriel’s sixth score in a row all the signs had changed to say “GO TAURIEL!” The fifth year elf could be seen beaming at every cheer, fiery red hair whooshing with every move.

When the ball would be taken from them Paladin would immediately come to the rescue, refusing to let one Quaffle pass.

“Is that a hobbit?” said Ori. “I didn’t know hobbits were good Keepers. Chasers maybe, and even Beaters—” Bilbo could not have missed Professor Proudfoot’s growl. “—but Paladin Took has made me eat my words, obviously.”

The game was almost over. Ravenclaw knew they were on trouble, and the game turned more intense. It got to the point that when the Ravenclaw Chaser was getting dangerously close to scoring, one of the Gryffindor Beaters sent a Bludger to her only to miss and hit Paladin straight in the face instead. Like a limp doll, he fell off his broom and to the floor, unmoving.

“HOBBIT DOWN!” Ori screamed over the cries and gasps of the crowd. “HOBBIT DOWN!”

“Paladin!” Hamfast shouted. Bilbo was already moving out of his seat. In the midst of all the chaos no one noticed that the Snitch had been caught.

Even when the Ravenclaw Seeker caught the Snitch Ravenclaw had no chance; Gryffindor won with a whopping 190-170. The Gryffindor fans stood up to an uproar, crowding the team into suffocating in a rush of red and gold. Some Ravenclaw players could not even help but to grin, Gryffindor fans going on to congratulate them on the game and clapping them on the back appreciatively, cracking jokes to cheer them up.

But Bilbo and Hamfast noticed nothing of this, rushing to get by Paladin’s side. They moved through the thin circle of a crowd surrounding the hobbit, where Professor Galadriel was already inspecting him. Paladin was sitting up and was thankfully conscious, moaning in pain and clutching his leg. His uniform was matted in grass and torn right below his left kneecap, exposing a gruesome lesion.

“I’m fine, I’m fine,” Paladin smiled weakly, turning to a pained grimace as Professor Galadriel tapped her wand on his wound, making a bandage wrap itself over it.

"No, Paladin. It really looks bad," Hamfast said.

“I could cure your wound," said Professor Galadriel. "But I rather send you to Mister Oin, since I don’t know the severity of it. By the looks of it you could have broken a bone.”

Paladin face lost all of its color.

Mister Oin seemed pleased in seeing the three. “So this is the famous hobbit that won Bofur on getting in the team,” he said as he inspected his leg.

Paladin looked up at the dwarf. He did not seem resentful. “Yes. Do you know Bofur?”

“I do!” Oin said merrily. “I know him and his cousin from the Blue Mountains. Bifur did not get magical powers though, brave lad that he is.” He opened a white cupboard and took out a medicine bottle labeled Skele-Gro. “Not many of us do.”

He poured enough to fill half of the cup, handing it to Paladin. “Here, this’ll fix you. It tastes awful so I’d drink it in a gulp if I were you.”

Paladin took the cup and stared at it wearily, swallowing the whole thing before choking and wrinkling his nose in disgust.

“The wound I can fix but the broken bone will take more time,” Mister Oinexplained, gently tapping his wand on Paladin’s wound. The scratches and ugly red gash immediately seemed a week older than they were, then disappeared altogether. “If you’re lucky you’ll be free to go before dinner. Just rest.”

“You heard him, Paladin,” Hamfast snipped as Oin left. “We’ll stay here and you rest.”

“Yeah, mate,” said Bilbo, nudging Paladin playfully on the shoulder. Paladin winced. “We’re here for you. We’ll never leave your sight today.”

“Yeah, thanks,” said Paladin, not sounding thankful at all. “I really appreciate it guys, but I really do need to rest. Alone would be better. I feel exhausted.”

“Oh,” Hamfast blinked.

“Fine,” Bilbo said coolly. “But take in mind that the team will come to greet you. You did just win a match.”

“I will,” Paladin yawned, stretching his arms and wincing once more. “I just want to see if I can sleep off this pain.”

Bilbo and Hamfast nodded. “We’ll check on you later,” Bilbo said.

“I really hope that Paladin gets better today,” Hamfast muttered as they left. “I’d feel awfully guilty if we’d go to the Quidditch after-party without him.

“We don’t have to go, you know,” Bilbo said, amused. Hamfast seemed to not have heard him.

“So how have you been feeling Bilbo?” said Hamfast, frowning. “Everything all right?”

“I’m fine. Why would I not be?”

Hamfast looked at him.

“All right, all right. I may not have been after what Fili and Kili told us but now I am fine.”

“Really?”

“Yes. Actually I’m happy this happened. Now I saw how ridiculous I’ve been acting. Now it doesn’t even bother—Thorin’s walking this way."

“What?” said Hamfast. From the distance the professor could be seen walking towards them, scrolls on hand.

“Turn around,” Bilbo urged Hamfast, turning his back towards Thorin and gripping Hamfast’s shoulder.

“What? No--!”

“Just do it—“

“He saw us already--!”

“No he hasn’t—“

“Mister Baggins.”

They ceased blabbing immediately, unmoving and looking at each other in alarm. Bilbo took a deep breath, straightened his robes and turned to look at Thorin, whom was now walking towards him.

“Yes?”

Thorin looked down at him, but Bilbo simply could look at him in the eyes. He instead looked at his feet. “You did not go to my class yesterday.”

“Yes.”

“And you went to all other classes.”

Bilbo clenched his jaw. It was not a question. “Yes.”

“Why?”

Bilbo did not answer, feeling his cheeks tinting pink and his blood slowly boiling. It made his fingers tingle.

“I am afraid you missed a very important class. You will have to make up for the lesson after class.”

Bilbo snapped his head up, finally meeting Thorin’s eyes. He was wearing a cream coat of dwarfish fashion over his usual dark robe and his hair was disheveled from the outside wind. His lips were turned down unhappily and his eyes glowed.

“Yes, Professor Oakenshield. I’ll see you tomorrow.”

Thorin nodded, turning to Hamfast. He bowed his head in salute and the hobbit did the same. Until he was out of sight did Bilbo let himself panic.

“I need to get out of it.”

“Bilbo, calm down.”

“I can’t do it.”

“Blast it Bilbo, just calm down!”

The hobbit inhaled deeply, slowly evening his breath. “All right,” Bilbo said. “I’m fine. No worries. I-It’s just a lesson. Just one thing.”

“Yes?” said Hamfast.

“What is a boggart again?”

Hamfast grinned ruefully.

***

Paladin had healed before nightfall as Oin had predicted. Neither Hamfast or Bilbo showed up to meet him, so he walked happily towards the tower, thinking if maybe the team was going to pamper him in the after-party. Goodness knows he would be thankful for some fun. He had been so stressed lately with the N.E.W.T.s preparations and endless Quidditch practices. A relaxing day of celebration wouldn’t go amiss.

But the poor hobbit had just climbed into the merry common room when he felt a hand pull him towards the dormitories. No one noticed.

“Ow! What is it Hamfast?” Paladin hissed as he yanked his arm from the hobbit’s grasp.

Hamfast shook his head, leading him to the unlighted dormitories, where the chatter and music of the common room echoed mockingly.

Bilbo told him everything in a rushed whisper, and Paladin’s face twisted more and more in distaste. When he finished, Paladin shortly said, “Tell him you can’t.”

Bilbo looked taken aback and Hamfast raised his eyebrows. “What?”

“Tell him you can’t,” said Paladin. “I do not like this any more than you do, so just say you have a club or something. You don’t even have to tell him personally. Send him an owl or something.”

Hamfast let out a low whistle. “Paladin, your Took is showing.”

“Haha,” Paladin said bluntly. “Send him the letter in the morning. Now can we all just go relax and enjoy the party downstairs?”

Bilbo did look brighter as they joined the common room, where everyone roared as they saw their champion. Paladin was quickly lost in a tumult of the Quidditch players and admirers. Bilbo and Hamfast quietly submerged into a hobbit group.

The party gradually turned wilder and louder when a human seventh-year was shouting how he was convinced elves could handle a drink better than any dwarf. The dwarfs took this as personally as it gets and from the crowd of dwarfs Bofur emerged, challenging any elf brave enough to prove this. All the elves looked at the dwarfs good-naturedly and with amusement, some faces clearly saying oh-you-silly-things. When the dwarfs had started shooting them insults, Legolas stepped up from the crowd, always the peacemaker.

“We don’t even have drinks,” Legolas pointed out.

Bofur yelled something in Khuzdul and a stocky, red haired dwarf immediately handed him two cups of fine Firewhisky. “You were saying?”

“I’m putting my money on Bofur,” Hamfast whispered to Bilbo as Legolas had dramatically sighed and taken the Firewhiskey, led by a whooping cry of the supporting elves. Every eye in the common room was watching them now.

Bilbo looked at Bofur’s confident, smirking face. “No bet.” Hamfast snorted.

Surprisingly Legolas did know how to handle his drink well. Only by the fourth mug had he started to look pale and twitch as he was passed another. Bofur was going at it, draining the drinks down and waiting expectantly as Legolas finished his.

By the sixth Legolas’ finally swooned, and Bofur gulped his cup to the last drop before banging it on the table and raising his hands in triumph. All the dwarfs went ballistics, slapping Bofur on the back and shouting so loudly the other houses must have heard. Fili and Kili were jumping like mad.

“Why don’t they challenge the hobbits, huh?” Paladin finally appeared next to them, handing them two cups of punch.

“I think we all know the answer to that one,” Hamfast scoffed, and the three broke into laughter.

***

Everything had gone well the next morning. Bilbo woke up early to send the letter and he brightened up considerably. It started to rain cruelly outside so they chose to spend their Sunday on the library. The three tried their best to catch up on homework, but only ended up looking around the vast line of bookshelves for hobbit-related books. They were a little homesick lately.

But all calmness ended by lunch, when Bilbo was shocked when an owl carefully landed next to his plate and held a letter on its beak expectantly. Bilbo took the letter and the owl took off, but not before stealing some of his bacon. Bilbo did not even seem to notice.

“It’s probably from Professor Oakenshield,” Bilbo muttered. “I didn’t think he’d answer this quickly. Or at all.”

“Just open it, Bilbo,” Hamfast said, “Get it over with.”

Bilbo ripped it open at once, recognizing Thorin’s cursive handwriting at once. It wasn’t even formally addressed.

 

I am actually aware that you have, in fact, no outside activities, academic or extracurricular, today. That us why I chose this day so you can make up for your unfortunate absence. You can choose not to come, but this activity contributes significantly to your grade, as Mister Took can assure you. It will be very likely you will be failing the class yet again.

I will be expecting you at 6 o’clock sharp.

 

Bilbo unconsciously crumpled the paper in his hand as he passed it to the two to read.

“He cannot be serious!” Hamfast cried in outrage. Paladin hurriedly shushed him.

Bilbo tuned out on what they were saying after that—Paladin trying to reason the situation while Hamfast incoherently cursed Thorin—and stared at the distance of the Great Hall. He felt calm in a resigned manner, like when one knew when there was no way out but one.

Paladin and Hamfast tried their best to cheer Bilbo up as they walked him in the afternoon towards the classroom.

“Good luck,” Paladin said consolingly. “And just remember: In the end, there is nothing there to fear.”

Bilbo barked out a dry laugh at the cheesy advice, feeling some of his nervousness bleeding away. “Thank you, Paladin. I’ll be fine.”

Paladin looked at him searchingly, and then nodded. Hamfast awkwardly waved at him.

Bilbo sighed, turning to face the classroom door. He fought the impulsive to run away as far as he could and ignored the uneasy feeling that had started in his stomach. He gulped, opening the heavy wooden door. Time to get it over with.

***

The room seemed exactly the same it did every afternoon Bilbo came here. The sun would already be lowering down with the call of an approaching winter and the vast room would be vastly empty and organized except for the disarray of grading work Thorin would place in his desk. It all seemed so familiar he had the urge to crack a joke about Thorin’s sloppiness in grading and Thorin would smile.

But it was not so easy now. He stood by the door until Professor Oakenshield would recognize him there. Thorin looked up from the papers and mused, “Do get in, Mister Baggins.”

Bilbo nodded, opening the door wider and getting in. He noticed now there was something unusual inside. A cupboard was rattling impatiently on a corner, whatever in there determined to get out. The unpleasant feeling on Bilbo’s stomach deepened and his heart hammered wildly.

He had prepared himself for this, planned what to do. He had talked himself into going and getting this over with because he did not even know what his greatest fear was. He was a hobbit, what could he fear? But now that he was here, facing Thorin, it was definitely as clear as water, and it terrified him out of thought and reason. His prime instincts were dominating now, yelling for him to go, to run, to disappear.

Thorin had been too immersed on his speech of boggarts to notice any of this. “—essential that you have something specifically in mind when you say this spell, or it will not work. Understand?”

“Yes.”

“Good,” Thorin said, moving towards the cupboard, which in turn rattled on more wildly. “Think hard on that what you fear. When I open the—“

“What if I offer a proposal?” Bilbo blurted out.

Thorin tilted his head, frowning.

“What if,” Bilbo started, his voice awfully thick. “I just write a very thorough essay on boggarts…instead.” His vice grew quieter, but he was determined. “I’ll learn much more really. No need to actually face it.”

The dwarf looked at him with an expression that looked almost annoyed. “No.”

“But just think about it,” Bilbo said. “It’s much more productive for me. And I could see this in a whole point of view. It’s not even like I’ll face a boggart in real life—“

“No.”

“Could you just think about it?” said Bilbo, his pleading turning to frustration. “Could you not reject every idea I have?”

“To actually confront a boggart is vital to understanding them. I cannot let you—“

“Yes you can, you’re the bloody teacher!” Bilbo yelled. “If you just—“

“Enough!” Thorin roared. Bilbo felt silent at once. His anger was replaced with the fear he had previously had. “If you do not confront the boggart this instant, I will fail you!”

“Go ahead!” Bilbo tried to say clearly, but it came out all wrong. His brittle voice cracked at the last word. He was shaking so noticeably, unconsciously making himself smaller. All of the blood from his rosy cheeks left his face. He ceased to glare at Thorin, staring at the wardrobe now as if the Reaper was waiting for him there.

At the sight of Bilbo all of Thorin’s anger vanished. He shook his head, relaxing his shoulders. He is just afraid, Thorin thought.

“Bilbo,” Thorin said in a soft voice that startled Bilbo. ”It is just a ghoul. It will not hurt you, whatever is in there. It cannot. I will not let it.”

But Thorin did not understand. Bilbo’s worst fear was not dragons or monsters. It was not a villainous warrior. At the sight of Bilbo, so vulnerable and terrified, Thorin had a sudden impulse to take him in his arms and sweep him away from here. But Bilbo had to do this, face whatever shape the creature inside that wardrobe would take.

“I can’t,” Bilbo breathed.

“At least identify what it will turn to. What is your worst fear?”

“I cannot tell you. Not you,” Bilbo whispered.

The words stabbed Thorin in the chest like a knife on fire. He closed his hands into fists and his lips tightened. There was a long, painful silence.

Thorin at last growled, “What have I ever done to make you loathe me so, Mister Baggins?”

Bilbo stared at Thorin. “What?” Bilbo said, confused.

“Why else would you hold such attitude only with me?”

“No—“

“What is it, halfling? What have I done?”

“I—”

“I understand I might not be the best at teaching—“

“Will you just—“

“Then why do you hate me?”

“I DON’T. I LOVE YOU, YOU RIDICULOUS DWARF.”

The words slipped through Bilbo’s tongue before he could stop it. They filled the great room and the walls echoed them back cruelly until they ceased at once. There was no sound to be heard, not even the rattling of the wardrobe.

Bilbo was slightly panting, his outrage slowly being replaced by pure horror. He ran his fingers through his hair, scraping his scalp so he’d feel a tingle of pain, making sure this was not a dream. That this was happening.

That was it, he was done for now. Nothing else could possibly matter now. Nothing.

Thorin was completely silent, and Bilbo could not help but look up.

The dwarf was looking at him with a set of so many emotions, Bilbo could not pinpoint half of them. But two were clearly there, one being shock and the other sympathy. And Bilbo most certainly did not want sympathy.

This.

This was all he had feared.

“Well, there you have it,” Bilbo said, his voice too distant, too calm to be his own. “You wanted me to face my worst fear. Now you know.” He turned away and left without another word, not looking back.

“Bilbo,” Bilbo heard Thorin say, and at the sound of his name he slammed the door shut and broke into running as fast as he could.

Angry tears swelled his eyes as he ran blindly, and no matter how hard he blinked them away, they overwhelmed him, running down his cheeks traitorously.

Notes:

1. In my mind Ori has a rep in the dwarf community for being so smart and courageous despite him being so young.
2. That little part with Paladin falling and saying it was nothing was completely inspired by Romeo ad Juliet’s Mercutio. No Mercutio, that is not a scratch, you are dying.
3. How the dwarfs got to get the Firewhiskey will be explained later on. And both Bifur and Legolas are both overage so that’s good.
4. It will take me more to update more because a) for a reason the chapters are getting longer and b) I don’t have a beta reader so I have to re-read this a thousand times. Even like that I’m sure I have some errors.
5. Thank you all for being such patient dearies.