Chapter Text
Bilbo tosses beneath the blankets, his limbs feeling unnaturally heavy. Though he is asleep, or mostly asleep, and should not be seeing anything, still there is a shadow behind his eyes. If he tries, he can just barely make out shapes, silhouettes, someone sitting in a chair by his bedside. More than that, there are murmurs in the air, all voices he does not recognise, except for one. Thorin, sitting bent forward in the chair, elbows resting on his knees, is whittling something with slow strokes of a knife and humming. Bilbo wants to say something to him. He tries to sit up, and is astonished when he does.
“Bilbo?” Thorin asks. He sets aside his carving and leans in. “Are you awake?”
“Yes,” Bilbo says, when he means to say no. “Just need a drink of water.” His legs swing out of bed, and his feet hit the floor.
“Stay there,” Thorin says. “I’ll get it.”
“No, I’ll go.” One step, then two; Bilbo is almost at the door.
“Bilbo.” Thorin stands to block his way. “Are you really awake?”
“Of course.” He feels his lips move, the light stir of his own voice, but it’s all pretense. Someone else has taken over. His lips pull into a tight smile. “Don’t be silly, Thorin. I’ll just be a moment.”
“Get back in bed.” Thorin advances on Bilbo with worry in his eyes and though Bilbo’s face doesn’t lose its false smile he is—privately, immensely—relieved as Thorin steers him back to bed, tucks the blankets up around him, and stands there glaring with his arms crossed. Defeated, Bilbo finds himself falling quiet, and lets out a sigh as his vision clears. There is just enough candlelight for him to make out what Thorin is carving: a spoon, wide and flat, with delicate markings on its handle.
After Bilbo falls asleep, or continues to sleep but calmer now, Thorin catches himself staring at the Hobbit rather than watching his fingers and the knife. It’s hardly a problem; he’s been carving since he could hold a blade and has yet to cut himself. But he’s not usually so careless. If it weren’t for the quiet whisper of breath and occasional rustle of sheets, Thorin could almost pretend Bilbo wasn’t there. As it is, though, he cannot take his gaze away. The gentle turn of Bilbo’s nose, the way his hair falls across his forehead, one exposed ear with a soft point at its tip, dark shadows beneath his closed eyes. Though the Hobbit looks young, and almost certainly is young compared to Thorin, there are lines on his face that belong to someone with many more years. Someone who has seen many worse things than could possibly be common to the Shire.
“What is wrong with you?” Thorin asks, turning away from Bilbo to survey the room. Nothing seems amiss. He goes back to his carving, making a neat pile of woodshavings between his boots. As far as guard duties go, this is one of the easiest watches he’s ever taken. No orc raids, not even a pack of wargs. Just one Hobbit, looking exhausted and somewhat ill, and a growing list of unanswered questions. What kind of family matter is this, that keeps Bilbo worried for his own safety? Had something happened to him, the night before? But Thorin hadn’t heard anything, and he’d been just next door. He shifts in the chair, uncomfortable at the memory of his behaviour, how shameful it now seems, inviting in a relative stranger for those kinds of relations in the house of his host, without the host’s knowledge. Not that it would have been better if the host had known.
The fact that Bilbo looks so alike to Bo now strikes Thorin every time he glances at the Hobbit. How did he not notice it earlier? Being in the Shire has dulled his senses after. So much so that he jumps out of his chair and brandishes his carving knife, rather than his sword, out in front of him when there is a tapping at the windowpane. Silhouetted against the starry sky is a raven, black as the night, regarding him with what looks an awful lot like disdain. Thorin slips his knife into its sheath and goes to let it in. The raven alights on the mantel and preens for a moment, adjusting its wings before rotating its head slowly around the room.
“Well?” Thorin asks it, crossing his arms over his chest to keep from fidgeting. Unless he’s mistaken, this is his sister’s raven, which means news. But what kind of news?
“I bring greetings from Lady Dís of the Blue Mountains,” the raven croaks. “She bids you read this message.” And it holds out a leg, onto which a tiny scroll of paper has been tied. “And send word in reply.”
“Very well,” Thorin tells it, untying the scroll. “You may tell her I’ve received the message.” When the raven does not leave, but ruffles its feathers as if settling in for the night, Thorin groans. “If you must stay, there are plenty of trees outside.” It still doesn’t leave. “Useless bird.”
The raven tucks its head to its breast and closes its eyes. Thorin has been summarily dismissed by his sister’s envoy. With nothing else to be done, he latches the window again, draws the shades, and settles back down in the chair to read. The raven dozes. Bilbo flinches beneath the blankets, abruptly, and then lies still again. The scroll is written in Dís’s neat handwriting, the Khuzdul runes sharply inked.
Thorin,
You’ve been gone long enough. There’s work to be done back here, just as well as there is out there. Come home. The boys have been asking after you, and with summer coming on we could use your help with the harvest. Don’t frown so, as I’m certain you are right now. We have had more than enough years to adjust to this way of life. Finish up whatever work you have taken on, make sure they pay you, and then return.
Until then,
Dís
Thorin crumples the scroll in his fist and frowns. Dís is right to suspect it. He despises harvesting, bringing in the crops and sowing seeds as if he were a farmer rather than a warrior. Rather than a king. It’s beneath him, gathering up summer squash in his shirtsleeves, working beside peasant Men, scraping a living out of soft green earth rather than hard rock. He has to take a moment to control his breathing before he can smooth out the scroll and turn it over to write a reply on the back. Feeling slightly guilty, Thorin rummages through Bilbo’s desk drawers for a quill and ink. The Hobbit has an awful lot of papers—letters, ledgers, books, journals filled with fine, round writing. Thorin is tempted to read them, but he’s already intruded enough on his host’s privacy. With as much discretion as can be had, when one is sitting in another’s quarters as they sleep, Thorin takes a seat at the desk and writes his reply.
Dís,
You know as well as I do that those mountains will never be “home.” I wish you would stop calling them that. As for my work, I am in fact nearly finished. I would have started for home today, if . . .
There is someone here whoTell the boys that I’ll be there soon. There are some things I must take care of before I can let myself leave this place, but I am not far from the mountains so the journey will be short.I remain, as ever,
Your brother
What Thorin doesn’t say is that even if his work is done, even if there were to be no more jobs in all the Shire, he does not think that he could simply pack up his things and leave come morning. He ties the scroll up neatly and wakes the raven, who grumbles at him before sticking out a leg to take the message. Once the bird has been dispatched, Thorin checks on Bilbo. Asleep, but not looking very happy about it. So that makes two of them, unhappy, in one room. Thorin was sorely tempted to write to Dís about what’s truly keeping him here, but when he started to pen the name his quill stopped after forming the first rune. What would follow the “B”?
It shouldn’t even be a dilemma. He’s not meant to desire two partners equally, to be torn between the two. Dwarves find one single partner to form a bond with, and there is very little deliberation involved. It’s simply part of their nature. Or at least, that’s what he’s always been told. And as the king, it would be very poor form for him to be the first to break that tradition. Besides, why should he be putting Bilbo and Bo in the same position, when he’s slept with one and merely imposed upon the other as an unplanned guest? They’re not equal at all. There should be no question in his mind.
And yet . . . and yet . . .
Thorin paces the bedroom, his hands going to tangle in his hair, fretting. He needs to leave, before this gets any worse. He’s going to make a fool of himself if he stays.
He already has made a fool of himself. Standing here, in his shirtsleeves and trousers, barefoot in another man’s bedroom while said man sleeps, it’s appalling behaviour. He wasn’t raised to act this way. Not only is it unlike a king, it’s unlike a gentleman. Deposed though he may be, living in exile, Thorin should know better. Bilbo had even told him—pleaded with him—not to make any untoward advances. Looking over at the Hobbit, it’s impossible not to notice how much smaller he is, how much frailer. For all that he’s as well rounded as his kin, there is something thin about Bilbo, in the lines of his face and the angles of his elbows and the paleness of his skin.
This is none of his concern. Thorin has lived all his life without having anything to do with Hobbits beyond the briefest business, and he can live the rest of it just the same. He’ll wake Bilbo in the morning, make his excuses as civilly as possible, and be on his way.
Of course, things don’t turn out to be that simple.
----
Bilbo wakes up at the first light of dawn. Restless, uneasy, he sits up and sees that Thorin has fallen asleep, slumped in the chair with his head tipped back against the wall. It’s no surprise, considering how hard the Dwarf had worked the day before, and Bilbo certainly doesn’t blame him. It seems that he did what he was asked to do, at least. Bilbo is waking up in his own bed, with no dirt under his fingernails or scrapes on his feet. With vague, but present, memories: movements and words that were not his own, last night, and the impossibility of fighting them. He knows enough, now, to know that he cannot stay here. Whatever it is that’s been plaguing him will return, and he can hardly live under watch all hours of the day and night. He’s proved his theory, that something comes over him which he cannot control, and the ease with which the switch happened, and his own powerlessness in the face of it, and the unpleasantness of the mood inside his mind . . . No, he cannot stay.
Hobbits can be incredibly quiet creatures, when they want to be. Bilbo packs his rucksack and slips out of the bedroom soundlessly. Thorin has one hand curled loosely around the handle of an axe, and is presumably a light sleeper, but he does not stir. Moving quickly, so that he has no time to feel guilty, Bilbo wraps some bread and cheese for himself, a couple of apples, and writes a quick note. It is the height of poor hosting, to leave before your guest is even awake. So it doesn’t matter much that Bilbo sticks the note to Bag End’s front door with one of his kitchen knives before he goes. He may as well break all the rules. Horrify all his neighbours enough so that their whispers of “Mad Baggins” overtake any good reputation he may once have had, so that they all stay away from Bag End, so that no one comes prying into his affairs.
The mists are still clinging to the hills as he sets off, making for Bree and lands beyond, where no one will know him. Where it won’t matter who he is, or becomes, or might be. Bilbo takes a deep breath and rubs his hand over his eyes. “Right,” he tells himself. “Come on. This is for the best.”
It’s not as though he’s never left the Shire before. He used to travel all over the area, long walking holidays and overnight stays, journeying far more afield than was considered proper for a Hobbit of his position. So this should be as simple as putting one foot in front of the other. Bilbo tries to trick himself into believing that he’s not really leaving with the intent never to return, but Bag End tugs at him from the back of his mind. What’s more—and more perplexing—Thorin’s face keeps coming up in his memories, the hard lines of his profile against the early light of Bilbo’s bedroom wall, the inexplicable fondness not quite masked by the gruff tone of his voice as they made their deal in the Green Dragon, the tumble of dark hair shot through with grey. Bilbo has never noticed so many things about one person before. It’s exhausting, keeping them all in his head. It’s exhausting and he doesn’t like it, doesn’t want it, doesn’t even know when it started. The switch was more than enough to deal with. Now he has this . . . interest, this infatuation, this desire as well, and if he’s being honest he’s running away from more than one thing right now.
The road to Bree is long but well traveled. He shouldn’t run into any problems. Once arrived, he’ll take a room for the night, and plan out where to go the next morning. Even if he has to keep moving, become some sort of nomad, it’s better than standing still and watching all the things he thought he knew become unfamiliar to him. If he is to become a different person, let him be in a different place as well. Let him entirely reinvent his life.
Yes, it’s for the best, Bilbo thinks, as he hitches his pack up on his back and lengthens his stride.
----
It’s the silence in the room that wakes Thorin. He’d fallen asleep just before dawn to the soft sound of Bilbo’s breathing, unable to keep his own eyes open. Most of the night had passed, and without incident, so he let himself fall into a light doze, his senses on half-alert. And now he wakes, hand on his axe, heart pounding, to an empty bed and an empty smial. No sign of Bilbo. The fire in the kitchen is cold, the bath is empty, the front door is shut. Shut, but not bolted. Thorin opens it and steps outside, glaring at the neighbouring Hobbits in their gardens. Did one of them take Bilbo away? He’s about to go interrogate the nearest one when a glint catches his eye: a kitchen knife stuck into the door, nearly to its hilt, pinning a note to the wood. Thorin wrenches the knife free and scans the note. It’s Bilbo’s writing, the same as was in his ledgers. He’s gone away, he says; called away unexpectedly by some ill relatives, and won’t be returning for quite some time. Thorin is to let himself out and give the keys of Bag End to a man called Gamgee—likely the neighbour Thorin has been staring down as the man crouches in front of his tomatoes, looking concerned. Thorin scowls and strides back inside, slams the door shut behind him.
He’d decided last night to leave. Now Bilbo has told him to leave. And now leaving is the last thing he wants to do. This is ridiculous. He’d already made up his mind; the note should be encouraging, not conflicting. And it would be, if not for the sound of fear in Bilbo’s voice last night, as he told Thorin not to let him leave. Some guard Thorin has turned out to be. Dwalin would have his head, if he pulled a stunt like that while on the King’s Guard. Never mind that he’s the King. It’s unacceptable. He cannot leave, unless it is to go and find Bilbo, and bring him back here, and figure out whatever it is that’s going on with him and with Bo and why everyone in the Shire apparently expects it of Bilbo, to do something like this. Because that’s what he’d said, in his note: “Don’t worry about me. My neighbours have been counting down the days till I would go running off, so you can just let them think that until I return from my relatives. I don’t know how long I’ll be. Please don’t trouble yourself, as I know you have family of your own to look after.” That would all be fine, if Bilbo hadn’t already told him that he has no close family. Certainly none close enough to running after before morning’s properly broken, coming off of a night of drunken confusion. None of this makes any sense, not in words that Thorin can put into order, but the feeling in his gut that tells him things have gone wrong is as sensible as it’s ever been. He dresses quickly in his traveling coat and leather traveling armour, laces up his boots, and locks up Bag End.
“Look after these,” he tells the Hobbit by the tomatoes as he throws him the keys. “Don’t give them to anyone but Bilbo, or myself.”
“Uhh, yes, sir,” the Hobbit says, but Thorin’s already walking away. Bilbo has at least an hour’s headstart on him, which isn’t much, but the Hobbit knows the terrain and, more importantly, which direction he’s headed. Thorin will have to guess.
He stops in at the Green Dragon first, asks around if anyone’s seen Bilbo. No one has. Thorin is about to leave when he changes tactics and asks after Bo Took. That gets him a few shifty glances, and a casual hand running over the hilt of his sword brings one Hobbit forward who tells him that Bo had left a note for Thorin at the inn, after the Dwarf had already left. It’s an invitation to join Bo for supper, now two days old. Bo must have left it after leaving Bag End, the night that they . . . Thorin takes the note before the Hobbits can stare at him any longer, and leaves the darkened room to have some light to read by. Leaning against the wall outside, he scans the note. What it says is trivial, more words of flirtation and a jest at how quickly Thorin had fallen asleep afterwards. No, it’s not the content that has Thorin on full alert, but the fact that the handwriting is exactly the same as the other note he carries with him. The note Bilbo left him, stuck to Bag End’s door. A quick comparison of the two proves it. Side by side, they are identical, the curves of the B’s in the signatures matching up precisely.
The Dwarves have no word for this, as there is no record of it ever affecting any of their kind, but Thorin has heard tales from the traders who come from foreign lands, stories of men who lose half of themselves and begin to lead two lives. It is something akin to madness, but more dangerous, for at least when one is going mad one’s companions usually take notice. For those who lose only part of themselves, only at certain times, they keep up the illusion and all are fooled, until one part overtakes the other and they are entirely changed. How this sort of curse got to be in Bilbo’s family, Thorin has no guesses, but he’s certain now, with a cold finality as he searches the length of the Shire, that the Bilbo who left him this morning was not entirely himself. Part of him—and the crucial question is how large a part—has to have been Bo. Feeling like a fool for not seeing it sooner, never mind that he’s only known them each a handful of days, Thorin shoves aside cornstalks and searches the fields, tramps through streams calling out each name in turn, not knowing who might answer.
Why did none of Bilbo’s relatives or neighbours notice? But of course, they all thought him a bit mad already. Probably, to them, it just seemed that things were taking their natural course. It strikes Thorin suddenly, as he’s hacking his way through Bindbole Wood, that perhaps he’s thinking about it the wrong way; perhaps it’s Bilbo who takes over, and Bo who is being lost? But no, surely not, for Prim would have known her own cousin, and people would have recognised the name. In fact, today is the first time Thorin has met someone other than himself who even knew the name Bo Took. No, Bilbo must be the one, the one slowly losing hold of himself. That must have been what he meant, last night, pleading with Thorin not to let him go. Furious with himself for not living up to expectations, for not following through on his promise, Thorin makes his way through the Wood to that hollowed out tree where he found Bilbo once before. But though the clearing is the same, and the ground still slopes gently downwards into a mossy hollow, there is no hole now in the massive tree. There is no sign that there ever was a hole.
Thorin takes his axe to the trunk, chopping away at the smooth expanse of bark and wood, but it is as solid as any tree. No hidden hollows. Just chipped wood, and uneven roots underfoot, and the uncomfortable feeling of being watched. Thorin is loathe to put the tree to his back, for some reason, but does so anyway as he turns to survey the forest. No glittering eyes, nor animal sounds. But the Wood is restless, just as it was before, leaves rustling and branches creaking, and Thorin wields his axe before him and runs, making as straight a path as he can. The path he had cut on his way in has vanished, or closed up, or moved. It’s impossible to say. He feels heat at the back of his neck, and the moss is spongy underfoot, making his steps awkward and unsteady. Bilbo cannot be in a wood like this. Could Bo?
Breaking out into open fields and clean air, Thorin finds his momentum carrying him onwards, even as his lungs are burning. He slips on the grass and falls against a farmer’s fence, finally coming to a stop. Behind him, or beside him, for he’s fallen in a tangle of limbs, the forest looks quiet. Ridiculous, to be so frightened of trees, Thorin thinks, but there is a cut across the bridge of his nose and a ringing in his ears and all his senses are alight with the feeling of danger. He has been in enough battles to know that they do not all look the same. This is one he cannot fight, not even if he were to take a torch to the Wood. There is something there beyond what can be seen by the eye.
Defeated by his search, Thorin heads for Bag End again. He can clean up, eat something to replenish his energy, and set off for the borders of the Shire and beyond. Bilbo’s neighbour, Gamgee, is seated on his porch when Thorin returns, smoking a pipe with his eyes closed. He jumps to his feet, startled, when Thorin clears his throat.
“Oh, Master Dwarf,” Gamgee says, “you’ve returned.”
“I’ll take those keys back,” Thorin says, holding out a hand.
“Why, I’ve already given them back. To Bilbo, of course. He was in an awful mood when he came back here and couldn’t get into his own house. Couldn’t even persuade him to stop for a smoke. Hey, where are you going?” Gamgee calls after him, as Thorin turns and runs up the hill.
He shoves the garden gate open and takes the steps two at a time. There are no lights coming from Bag End’s windows, though the sun has nearly set. “Bilbo!” Thorin calls, and pounds on the front door with a fist when it won’t open. “Bilbo! Open up!” It must be bolted from the inside, and Thorin knows the strength of these timbers, the security of the latch. He cannot open it unless he chops it down. “Bilbo!” he calls, and still there is no answer. “Bo?”
Silence.
Thorin lets out a curse, exasperated, and takes his axe in hand. He swings at the door and the blow thuds against the wood with a dull, dead sound. Thorin feels the rebound jar his arms in shock. He knows his own strength. That swing should have buried the axe head in the wood, ruining his recent handiwork. But the cutting edge, he sees, has been worn to almost nothing, flat rather than sharp. Made useless by all his strikes at that tree in Bindbole Wood. Thorin throws his shoulder against the door. It does not even shake. “I know you’re inside. Open the damn door, you . . . whoever you are. Open up!”
Still there is no answer. Other Hobbits have started to gather, staring at this wild-eyed Dwarf trying to batter down the front door of one of their most respected smials. Thorin growls at them and they scatter, taking refuge behind garden sheds and hedgerows. He makes a circuit of Bag End and can find no open door, nor any window large enough for him to fit through. Defeated by his own craftsmanship, Thorin slumps against the front door, breathing heavily. He closes his eyes, takes a long moment to calm the feeling of danger still surging through him, and draws his whetstone from a pouch on his belt. As night falls and the Hobbits go home, each to their own smials with soft golden light flickering from rounded windows, Thorin sits on Bag End’s doorstep and sharpens his axe.
