Chapter Text
Deep within Bag End, in one of the seldom used back bedrooms, the one who calls himself Bo Took is pacing the floor. He knows Thorin is outside. Half the Shire has heard him pounding at the door, and the other half will know by tomorrow. The question is what to do about him. The obvious temptation is to let him in, of course. Let him in, and then never let him back out. Oh, eventually he might get tired of the Dwarf, but Bo expects he could be entertained for a long while. He doesn't have enough control yet to open the door, though. That's the problem. Somewhere, shouting into the void, Bilbo is fighting back. Bo can feel it in the thump of his heartbeat and the trembling of his fingers when he gets too close to the front door. Frustrated, blocked at every turn of the halls, Bo kicks over a small table in the sitting room, swipes rows of books off their shelves. He's stronger than Bilbo—stronger than any Hobbit has the right to be—and when he means to destroy, he does it well. Throws the cast-iron pot from the kitchen hearth, kicks the charred wood across the floor, knocks over chairs, empties out cabinets. Systematically, with the same precision as Thorin sharpening his axe, Bo tears Bag End apart.
From the doorstep Thorin can hear the noise of things breaking, crashing furniture and shattering glass and the creaking and bending of the smial's wooden braces and joists as the rooms themselves take a beating. More unsettling is the lack of any other noise. Bo has yet to make a sound. He must be furious, to do such damage, but he is silent. And he has taken care not to break any of the windows or doors that would allow Thorin access. It's fully dark now, clouds covering the stars and half a moon. Thorin runs the stone across the cutting edge of his axe one last time, and tests for sharpness on a stray branch from one of the shrubberies in the garden. The axe cuts cleanly through. Thorin pockets his whetstone and stands, takes a few steps back to adjust his swing. And then he sets to work chopping down the same door he'd raised only days before.
The firm “thunk” of his axe carries through Hobbiton, down silent lanes and across the Water. Thorin is only three swings in when he hears someone shout, “Stop!” and turns to see Prim running towards him, her skirts lifted up so she can take the garden steps two at a time. “Stop, Thorin, stop, what are you doing?”
“Breaking down the door,” Thorin says, his voice terse because it's obvious. He hefts his axe over his shoulder and adjusts his grip for another swing.
“But you just put up that door. And besides, can't you just knock?”
“Bilbo's not in there.”
“So you're breaking in to his house?”
“Someone else is in there. I have to get them out.” Thorin chops at the door once more. Prim grabs at his arm and tries to tug it down; he doesn't move. “Your cousin is in danger, Prim. Let go.”
“How do I know that you're not the danger? And how is Bilbo in danger if he's not in there?”
“He is there, but . . .” Thorin clenches his teeth. There's no time to explain. Bo's gone silent—probably he heard Prim's shout—but that's no guarantee that he's stopped tearing the place to pieces. And what of Bilbo? Thorin has this awful dread that the longer Bo stays, the harder it will be for Bilbo to return.
“I need you to tell me what you know,” Prim says. “Because you know something, something more than the rest of us do, and I don't know how or why but apparently Bilbo trusted you enough to let you in.” She looks Thorin in the eye, small and round and not anything like a warrior, except for her eyes. Thorin lets out a sigh and lowers his axe.
“Your family,” he tells her, “is full of secrets.”
“Every family has its secrets.”
“Do you know what's wrong with Bilbo?”
“He's been ill,” Prim says. “Fainting, forgetting to eat. Getting lost. He's . . . confused.”
“He's not himself.”
“That's one way of saying it, sure.”
“No, I mean he's not Bilbo. Not entirely, not anymore. He wouldn't tell me the details but there's something in his history, his family, which is changing him. He's become . . . different.”
Prim frowns, and looks at Bag End's door, at the long gash splitting the center. “Different as in, more reckless?”
“Yes.”
“More unpredictable?”
“Yes.” Thorin frowns at her. “What do you know?”
“No one really talks about it. But we all— It's something to do with the mixing of bloodlines, different qualities from different lineages, and sometimes they don't blend well. Bilbo is one of those times, one of the outliers, or at least, that's the superstition. So we've always kept an eye on him. Those of us who care. Though, there aren't really many of us left now, what with his parents . . . What do you keep looking at in there?” Prim asks as Thorin puts his head against the broken door.
“I'm not looking. I'm listening. Earlier, he was— I met him as Bo. Bo Took, he called himself. He's the one who takes over, those other parts of Bilbo. He was angry earlier. Tearing Bag End apart. But he's stopped now.” Thorin presses his ear to the door and worries.
“Oh,” Prim says.
They wait, listening, tense. Nothing comes.
“That's, um, that's not good, is it?” Prim asks.
“No.”
“That's actually really troubling.”
“Yes.” Thorin takes another swing at the door and splinters his way through.
“All right, you go in the front, and I'll stand by the back. If he tries to get out, I'll stop him.” She looks determined enough that Thorin believes she would, too, as she pushes through the garden past overgrown plants and marches around to the back door. He widens the hole enough to shove his arm in and feels around for the latch. Bo has to know that Thorin is coming. Chopping the door open certainly made enough noise. Still, once Thorin's unlocked the door, he swings it open and steps in quietly. After pausing a moment to think, Thorin shuts the door behind him and re-fastens the latch. Prim might be able to stop Bilbo if he leaves by the back door, but Bo isn't going to leave.
Thorin isn't going to let Bo leave.
He sets his axe on an overturned chair beside the door. The halls are a mess of papers and furniture, wax spilled from candles and seeping into the floorboards. It's a wonder nothing has caught on fire. Thorin rights a table as he passes it, runs his fingers over long grooves in the wood, four parallel lines scratched deep through the varnish. When he sets his hand over the lines they are smaller than the pattern of his bones but the shape is the same. Turning the corner Thorin passes the kitchen, a sitting room, one of the pantries, all empty, all in disarray. Knowing that Bo must be somewhere inside, he presses on, searching through every room until at last his hand comes to a door that it cannot open.
“I know you're there,” Thorin says. “Talk.”
“Why should I talk to you? You like the other one better.”
“I like both of you.”
“Not true.”
“It is true.” Thorin feels around the edges of the doorframe, seeking out a weak point. If need be, he could probably kick it down near the lock. “Bo . . . open the door.”
“What will you do, if I open it?”
“All I want is to talk to you.”
“Liar. You're no good at talking.”
“But from what I gather, I'm the only one talking to you.” Thorin leans his forehead against the door. “You've torn Bilbo's home apart.”
“It's my home, too. I can treat it how I like.”
“What makes it your home?”
“Bilbo is mine now.” Bo's voice is low and soft through the door; Thorin tenses. “He's not coming back, he won't., not if I wreck the things he loved. His books, his arm-chair, if they're gone what does he have to come back for?”
“He has family.”
“Family. Hah. They don't care much for him anymore. His cousin might come by but she'll leave soon enough. She has family of her own.”
Thorin breathes in, out. Puts his weight against the door. “Me, then,” he says. “He has me.”
“You?” Bo laughs. “He's never had you yet. I'm the only one who can claim that.”
Not rising to the bait, Thorin repeats, “He has me. I'm not going to leave him, wherever it is you've sent him.”
“Would you even know the difference?”
“Yes.”
“Shall we make a bet on it?”
“Open the door and find out.”
Bo laughs. There is a thump against the door, a shudder through the wood, as if he has collapsed against it. Thorin presses his hands against the door, lays his palms flat and pushes as if he could get through. “Trust me,” he breathes. “Please.”
Who can say how long they stay there, each waiting for the other to make the first move? The light changes in the hall, from bright morning to soft golden afternoon, shadows creeping in around the corners. There is a cool draft from the broken door; a shiver finds its way up Thorin's back. He closes his eyes. If he concentrates hard enough, he can hear Bo breathing, or Bilbo fighting to breathe.
Quiet footsteps from the front hall make Thorin tense. He turns, slowly, and sees Prim silhouetted against the fading light. Her cheeks are red with cold; she looks like she may have been crying. “Is he . . . in there?” she asks quietly, gesturing towards the door. Thorin nods, and raises a finger to his lips. “Can I talk to him?” Prim whispers.
“Bilbo's not talking,” Thorin tells her, his voice in a hush. “How did you get in here?”
“Same way you did, reached inside and lifted the latch.”
“Go home. Let me handle this.”
“He's my cousin, Thorin.”
“And he's my . . .” Thorin frowns, lets out a sigh. “Just go. It's better if I do this alone.”
“Do what, exactly?” Prim asks. “What are you planning?”
“Go home, Prim. Now, before he hears you. Come back in the morning.” When Prim still doesn't move, Thorin turns his frown on her, a look he full well knows is capable of sending people running for the hills. To her credit, Prim merely looks taken aback, and after a tense moment she backs away carefully.
“If you do anything to hurt him,” she warns, the shake in her voice betraying her nerves. Thorin nods once, and turns back to the door in dismissal. Prim, probably against her better judgement, leaves the way she came. Thorin can hear the click of the latch behind her as she goes. Once more, he is alone with Bilbo, alone with Bo—the three of them are alone, together. There's nothing to do but wait.
Sometime before dawn there is movement from the other side of the door, enough to wake Thorin out of the doze he's fallen into. A soft groan shakes him to his feet. “Bilbo?” Thorin asks, apprehensive, not wanting to trust to his instincts. “Is that you?”
“Thorin? What's going on? Where . . . what happened?”
“Bilbo, are you hurt? Can you open the door?”
“Why am I locked into my study?” Bilbo's voice is rough and uneven.
“The lock's on your side,” Thorin says. “Bilbo, open the door.”
“What aren't you telling me, Thorin?”
“Please open the door.”
“There's . . . blood on my hands. What time is it? The last thing I remember, I was going . . . How did I get here?”
“Bilbo, please, open the door, I'll explain.”
“Not until I know I won't put you in danger. I don't, um, trust myself right now.” Bilbo laughs a little and Thorin tries, so hard, to picture the hobbit on the other side of the door. The only thing he can't make himself see clearly is the look that must be in Bilbo's eyes, still too-dark and shaky—all he wants to see is calm, warm, sea-blue.
“I trust you,” Thorin says. “You won't hurt me.”
“It's a moot point anyway,” Bilbo says, and Thorin hears him sniff, hears clothing rustling. “My hands won't seem to do what I tell them to. Can't even wipe all this off.”
“You have to fight it, Bilbo, come on. You're stronger than him,” Thorin says, and prays that it's the truth. Prays that the blood is superficial, that Bilbo isn't too badly hurt.
“Who?” Bilbo asks.
Thorin knocks his forehead against the door and swears. Even now, even after everything, Bilbo still doesn't understand?
“Thorin, who?”
“The one who takes over when you . . . when you let your guard down. That other voice in your head.”
There is silence. Then, “I don't know what you're talking about.”
“You do know,” Thorin insists. “You must.”
On the other side of the door, there is no reaction. For minutes and minutes Thorin waits, frets, thinks he's lost the stand-off again. And then, slowly, Thorin finds himself falling forward as Bilbo opens the door into the study. Catching his balance with hands against the doorframe, Thorin looks up to see Bilbo standing there in the shadows, half-hidden behind the door, his gaze cast down at the floor and the broken glass beneath his feet. There is a streak of blood across his cheeks, as if he tried to rub his eyes; there is blood on his hands and the cuffs of his shirt. He looks ten years older, at least. Thorin wants to gather Bilbo into his arms but is afraid to touch him. Bo had asked him if he would be able to tell the difference between the two and he had said yes but now he's not so sure.
“Bilbo?” he asks, pitching his voice low, taking a soft step closer.
“I'm frightened, Thorin.” The hobbit takes a step back, into the shaft of pale pre-dawn light coming in from the hallway, and Thorin can see now that it is Bilbo, not Bo, standing before him. He breathes a sigh of relief.
“You came back,” Thorin says, and reaches out. “Can I . . . ?” Bilbo closes the gap between them, sinking against Thorin's chest. “Thought I'd lost you,” Thorin murmurs, his words half-hidden in Bilbo's hair, speaking into the top of his head. “Don't do that again.”
“If I could help it, I wouldn't,” Bilbo says, and puts his arms around Thorin, leaning into the solidity. “But I don't know how. And I don't think I can just go through life never sleeping again. Besides, I'm not sure shutting it—him—out is the best idea.”
“Of course it is.”
“I'm not sure,” Bilbo repeats. “The switch is part of me.”
“So you did know,” Thorin says. “You knew someone else was taking over, you even have a name for it. You lied to me.”
“I didn't lie. I'm not lying to you now.” Bilbo pushes away from Thorin and frowns up at him. “I call it the switch because it's as though I lose myself and something else comes in and swaps out, takes over. I never remember, not really, and I certainly never thought there was someone else running around with my face, my body, doing . . . who knows what. Tearing my home apart, apparently.” Bilbo looks down at his hands, scraped and bruised. “I've really made a mess of things, haven't it?”
“It's not your fault,” Thorin tries to tell him, but Bilbo shakes his head.
“No, no, it is my fault. Whoever else comes in and takes over my mind, he's my fault too. My body, my fault, right?”
Thorin does not tell Bilbo what he knows of his body, how it laid under his hands. He feels colour rising to his face and turns away. “It's not your fault,” he repeats, and suddenly hates himself quite a bit more for taking advantage, for not seeing things clearly enough. Some king he is.
“Thorin?”
“I'll . . . help you clean up. Your hands need bandaging. Come on.”
Thorin leads Bilbo through Bag End, around wrecked furniture and torn papers until they come to the kitchen. The sun hasn't even risen yet. Thorin rights a candlestick and lights it with the flint and knife from his boot. Bilbo picks up a bench and sits before the table, tracing his fingers over the gouges in the wood. “I did this,” he says, so quiet Thorin almost doesn't hear him. “This is my home and I . . . ruined it.”
“It's not ruined. We can fix it.”
“Why bother, if I can't figure out how to live with myself?” Bilbo asks, and it's a question that rings true in more ways than one.
They don't speak as Thorin draws water from the pump beside the sink and fills a basin, sits beside Bilbo and washes his hands and feet, dabbing away blood and shards of glass and wood. Bilbo won't meet his eyes as Thorin wraps bandages around his fingers, lets hands linger on the bones of Bilbo's wrists, trying to press forgiveness in through the skin.
“You'll figure it out,” Thorin says, as the sun is rising and they're picking up the kitchen, putting the front hall back together. Bilbo stares at the gash in his new front door, at the axe casually left in his entryway, and shakes his head.
“There are so many questions, I don't even know where to begin.”
“I'll answer anything I can,” Thorin offers, and Bilbo shakes his head again.
“I think I just need some time.”
There is time, and time, and still nothing makes sense. They're straightening up the parlour when Prim comes back, the sun pale-gold over Hobbiton and catching in her bright hair. She takes one look at them, gives Bilbo in a quick hug, and grabs a broom. Between the three of them they get Bag End back into somewhat respectable shape, the things broken beyond repair piled in the back garden for a bonfire.
“Someone needs to tell the Old Took what's happened,” Prim says as they step back and survey the mess, and when neither Bilbo nor Thorin moves she sighs. “May as well be me. Wish me luck, all right?”
“Luck,” Thorin tells her, and Bilbo only nods. His face is drawn; his shoulder shake as though he is cold, despite the warmth of the day. After Prim leaves they sit on the back step and look out over the garden. Thorin cannot keep from glancing over at Bilbo, as if to reassure himself that it still is Bilbo hunched there beside him. And it is, but it's also Bo; he's Baggins and Took in one.
“Were you the only one?” Bilbo asks, vaguely, but Thorin knows what he means.
“Yes.”
“So I don't have to . . . explain things to anyone else.”
“Not if Prim's already gone to tell your family elder, no.”
“She felt it was her duty, I suppose.”
“You'd rather she didn't?”
“I'd rather none of this happened. Except, I suppose, you. Meeting you was the one good point in all of this.” And finally, finally, Bilbo turns and meets Thorin's eyes and his gaze is blue as the afternoon sky, hazy with autumn. And Thorin feels his heart rise, and clenches it down, and thinks he's going to be sick. Because he's leaving, of course—he has to leave. He's already stayed too long.
“Bilbo,” he starts, and then swallows his words. Brings a hand up to sweep his hair back—he's going grey already, and when did that happen?—and tries to start again. “Bilbo, I'm glad I met you. It's selfish of me, very selfish, but . . . I can't deny that.”
“Why selfish?”
“Because I'm leaving. I have to leave. I was never meant to stay here in the Shire so long.”
“But you can't leave! We've only just . . . Thorin, I need you here.”
“I'm sorry,” Thorin says, and now it is he who has to look away. “Bilbo, believe me, if it was anything else—”
“What is it, that you have to leave for?” Bilbo asks, tugging at Thorin's arm. “How long will you be gone? When can you come back?”
“In all likelihood, I won't be coming back. I'm sorry I can't tell you more—there are more lives than my own at stake. I cannot share our secrets, not even with you.”
“Haven't I shared mine? Thorin, there's—” Bilbo lets out a laugh, bitter and dry. “There's really very little about me that you don't know, at this point.”
“I'm sorry. There's something I must do, and the time is running so short. If I could tell you more, I would, but . . .”
There's never enough time, not really. They sit until the air turns chill, and then Thorin lights the bonfire and they sit and watch it burn. Time passes, just as quickly as it always has. There is so much unspoken between them, unspeakable—it will take years for them to find the words to fill the void that has opened up, twinned, in mind and heart, each of them straining and knowing what they want but not what they can have, what they might be able to achieve if only they had time.
Thorin does not think they have years. Realistically, he himself has only months, however long it takes to trek east, across the Misty Mountains, and die a fiery death at the dragon's mouth. If that is to be his fate, he will take it and leave all else behind. Especially Bilbo—he cannot lead Bilbo into such peril.
Bilbo, for his part—his own part, as Bo has fallen silent now—can only think in terms of minutes, hours, brief glimpses of time before he loses himself again. And yet he knows, with alarming surety, that he cannot just let Thorin walk away from him. And if Thorin will not stay, then Bilbo has no choice but to follow him.
And so, when dawn comes and Thorin, axe over his shoulder, steps out the front door of Bag End, Bilbo picks up his walking stick. He takes one last, long look around his home and sighs, taking in the patched furniture and salvaged crockery, the portraits of his parents over the mantel, all his memories there beyond the newly boarded-up front door. What he carries with him now is all that will fit in his rucksack, and whatever, whoever, may come into his head. Thorin turns at the garden gate and looks back at him.
“What are you doing?” Thorin asks, hesitant, confused, hardly daring to hope.
And Bilbo forces out a smile that grows easier the further away from his door he steps. Family history, family curses, Shire and memory—he's leaving all of that behind now and feels, somehow, lighter for it. Even in the back of his mind there is a sense of oncoming quiet, as if Bo, too, is pleased to be leaving, or going, or not returning. Bilbo cannot tell which and it worries him, it worries him that he is leaving so much to chance. But he looks at Thorin, standing there despite it all; he squares his shoulders, and keeps his smile on, and says, “I'm going on an adventure.”
