Chapter Text
“Your sister doesn't know you're dead?!”
“It's not as simple as all that...”
“Oh, I've got time! Explain!” Bilbo springs from the bed, taking to pacing the room, the envelope forgotten on the mattress.
“It's none of your-”
“Oh, we are long past 'none of your business', don't you think?!” Bilbo exclaims – Thorin glares all defensive, but at least he hasn't yet disappeared to sulk somewhere in the rafters. “What happened?” Bilbo asks firmly, “with your nephews? Is that why she left and never came back? A falling out?”
“That's putting it mildly,” the Captain scoffs, and when met with nothing but Bilbo's inquisitively arched eyebrow and crossed arms, he groans, turning away and standing by the window, his favorite spot for being all broody.
“She moved to France,” he mumbles, almost unintelligibly, and Bilbo is actually surprised he's going to get to hear the story, at long last. Dear god.
“After... the incident,” Thorin continues reluctantly at best, “she had every right to be angry with me, and I... I went on to my deployment overseas, like I told you, and we simply... never got back in touch, before I... well.”
“Well,” Bilbo repeats dryly, “care to explain what exactly the incident was, that it made your sister refuse to ever see you again?”
“I don't,” Thorin retorts curtly, “care to explain, that is. It's in the past, all of it.”
“And yet,” Bilbo grabs the envelope, hurrying to stand by the Captain's side, “it's coming back around to bite. You know what...?”
Bilbo tears the envelope open without any regard for decorum, and Thorin actually flinches, but merely stands stock still, not a word.
“Dear Thorin,” Bilbo reads the very lovely, neat handwriting, “oh my goodness, I can't believe you... Dear Thorin. You and I both know it has been quite a while – but if either of us is capable of swallowing our pride, I know now it's going to have to be me. Years, it's taken us. But it is going to be Christmas soon, and the boys will not stop talking about you. It was actually Fili who convinced me to write to you, and I feel there's some irony in that. In their eyes at least, there never existed anything that needed forgiving, you know that – Alright, will you just tell me what happened, or do I have to write to your sister myself to find out?”
“No one's writing to anybody,” the Captain growls.
“With the obvious exception of your sister. And she... yes, would very much like to hear from you again... Oh, Thorin, this is awful. Just horrible. How can she not know that you... died?”
Thorin inhales, long and deep, as if preparing himself for some sort of terrible ordeal, then deigns to look at Bilbo at long last, an indescribable sadness in his eyes, so raw that it manages to stop Bilbo in his tracks, for a moment at least.
“It's not uncommon,” Thorin explains quietly, “so many sailors have been lost to the sea without anyone retrieving them.”
“But surely there's... you know? Some rules? About contacting the family in such an event?” Bilbo peeps, feeling a chill creeping up, the draft from the window and the news alike the culprits of that.
“There are rules, yes,” The Captain sighs, “many of them. They might have tried contacting her after I expired, I do not know. You see, I never quite submitted the address to her new home anywhere. I didn't think it important at the time. I didn't think I'd...”
Silence reigns, heavy and interrupted only by the wind howling outside, and Bilbo feels inexplicably out of his depth, really.
“Tell me what horrible thing happened between you, that you severed all ties with your own family,” he suggests, pleads with Thorin, who stands there immovable and stern, as if he's doing his best to imagine he's anywhere else but there.
“Read the letter to me,” he says at last, nothing much more than a hoarse whisper.
“I – this is really something you should finish on your own...”
“Read the rest of the letter to me,” Thorin repeats, “please.”
“...As you wish,” Bilbo shrugs, unfolding the paper once more, stepping closer to the lamp to see better. “Where did I – oh, that's right. ...In their eyes at least, there never existed anything that needed forgiving, you know that. They would very much like to see you again some day, and I find myself taunted by the idea as well. I do miss the house. I've since bought a better harp, as you might imagine, but that doesn't mean that leaving that one behind doesn't sting sometimes. I don't know when this letter will reach you, if at all, but know that we have not forgotten you.
Perhaps I should have written you earlier, years earlier, though the fault is on both sides, after all. But no matter. If ever you find yourself on dry land for more than a shore leave, do write back. The address is on the envelope, that's apparently required when one lives abroad. Paris is lovely this time of year, but then it is always lovely. Kili wonders if your travels might eventually take you to the shores of France, I always reply that I haven't the faintest idea. They are both older now, you might have trouble recognizing them – but no less curious. Fili has Sorbonne in his sights, while Kili cannot be persuaded to stay still for long – I might be discouraging him from a navy career soon, if I'm not careful, and I feel like you might be able to help with that.
How are you? Did you ever find out what happened to Erebor? I think I would very much like to hear from you, but come to think of it, I shall count myself lucky if this letter reaches you at all. But then again, I don't think you would leave the cottage behind, would you.
Either way, in time or not, merry Christmas, your sister Dis.”
This time around, the silence is aching, ringing in their ears – though they are the words of someone Bilbo doesn't know, never will, they still hurt, still strike close to his heart, and he feels immensely sorry for this woman attempting to reconnect with her brother, not knowing that her efforts are in vain. For the most part, anyway.
“Thorin-”
But he is alone in the room once more.
And continues being alone. He doesn't really have a surefire way of making Thorin do anything, least of all appear whenever Bilbo would like him to – and so for the following couple of days, Oak Cottage is unpleasantly silent. Bilbo has gotten used to the routine of listening to the Captain's melodic voice and transcribing his words every day before going to sleep, he's gotten used to his complaining and his appearing out of nowhere even – without him, without his presence clearly announced, the house feels too big, too cold, too hostile.
Some of it is probably the weather's fault as well – snow does indeed come, slowly and gently at first, soft white specks like feathers peppering the ground and the treetops one morning, but much like everything else by the sea, it gains in ferocity eventually. Christmas dinner is had at the Gamgees' house, at their more than gracious invitation, and Bilbo and Frodo end up having to spend one more day there, it's snowing so relentlessly.
They come back to a near frozen house, the stone walls swift to cool and slow to warm back up again, and Bilbo struggles to light the stove and get the gas heaters going without the help of a sulking someone – he can't even remember why he felt bad about leaving the cottage for Christmas in the first place.
“Merry Christmas,” he wishes to the dark empty corners of his bedroom, and pointedly stares at the notes laying abandoned on the desk – no response, still, not a creak.
“If you're going to be this way, I might as well start researching on my own,” he announces the next day, baking exactly the shortbread that the Captain has always helped out with by making the oven burn at exactly the right temperature – this time around, though, he doesn't lift a finger, figuratively speaking, and the biscuits come out far too burned for Bilbo's tastes, though Frodo seems happy to just chomp down on them, not a care in the world.
“I'm writing a Professor friend of mine in London,” Bilbo mumbles, keeping one eye on the boy in the garden, far too excited about all this snow to care about his sodden shoes and trousers, while Bilbo himself sits at the large table in the living room, mug of steaming tea ready, wearing at least one sweater more than necessary.
“He'd spent some time in Her Majesty's Navy before he joined my University in London. Teaches geography now, I believe. He might know something about your lost ship.”
His name?
“Oh, it speaks,” Bilbo chuckles, though the truth is hearing the voice again, quiet but seemingly everywhere, has managed to give him quite the scare – but it wouldn't be Thorin otherwise, now, would it.
“I'm not telling you, sulking like that,” Bilbo accuses him, and a sudden gust of wind out of nowhere makes the wood of the house whine and complain.
“Don't be a child,” Bilbo tut-tuts absentmindedly, but receives no response.
This might go on for quite a while, if it weren't for that fateful week – in hindsight, Bilbo should have anticipated that letting a child quite unused to any weather harsher than the occasional London rainy day play outside for prolonged periods of time, especially when that playing included snowball fights with his friends, would only spell trouble.
Frodo complains about a stuffy nose and a 'scratchy' throat one morning, and coughs like his lungs have been set on fire by the most vile of infections the next, and, certainly not for the first time but perhaps with the most intensity, Bilbo feels uncomfortably far away from anything resembling civilization – an apothecary just around the block that he could just stop by for some throat lozenges and a cough remedy, a doctor that he might simply call upon whenever he pleased...
Well, there is one doctor he knows of, isn't there, but he can't exactly make the trek to Dale and leave Frodo, pale as a sheet and sweating through nightshirt after nightshirt, alone, now can he. A grocery run is in order as well, unless they fancy surviving off jams and pickled vegetables and biscuits for the foreseeable future, but with his boy burning up and sleeping through most of the day, Bilbo is very much helpless, and very much stranded here. All he can do is make him tea after tea, force him gently to drink it, and change the cold cloths on his forehead in unnervingly short intervals.
He could use the company, during his sleepless nights and his restless wandering, nothing much to do in the house beyond cleaning up for the hundredth time and checking the contents of their pantry, but Captain Durin remains silent, unhelpfully and infuriatingly silent.
On the fourth or fifth day (it's become difficult to keep track, he must admit), just when he's all but had enough, all but decided to risk it and leave Frodo on his own, just to get to the town as fast as possible and carry the old Doctor Brown here on his back if necessary, a miracle occurs. During his daily reading pause, h e hears the faint barking of a dog, the first proper sound to have pierced the unsettling white silence of the winter's grasp on the cottage, and he springs out of his armchair with a speed quite unlike him, only pausing to grab the nearest sweater to hastily throw on, before he's dashing out the front door, hoping that the dog is indeed who he hopes it is.
And yes, there they are, the unmistakable tall and broad figure of Beorn the shepherd and his dog trotting by his side, nothing but two black dots against the endless pristine brightness of the snow-covered hillock heaving up behind the house. Bilbo has never been happier to see anyone in his life, and he calls out to them, his own voice sounding unnaturally loud to his own ears, since he hasn't exactly been overusing it lately, and he waves his arms like a madman, trying his very best to capture Beorn's attention.
But it seems like the man has been heading towards the house all along – he takes his time, but fares much better in the dire conditions, a thick wool-lined leather coat and sensible, heavy boots protecting him against the w eather , his cheeks even redder than usual, a frown on his face, no doubt on account of this freezing weather they've been having. Despite all that, he seems as elated to see Bilbo as Bilbo is to see him, and pats his shoulder powerfully, almost making him stagger.
“Master Baggins!” he booms, his breath immediately freezing into little clouds, “it's good to see you're alright! Folk in town were beginning to worry. Missus Gamgee has been saving her best batch of honey for you, or so she tells me...”
“Yes, yes, that's very kind of her, but it's my boy,” Bilbo explains breathlessly, only glad the man doesn't seem to protest following him back inside the house.
“What about your boy?” Beorn asks, stomping the snow off his boots and ordering Ursa the dog to stay outside, despite Bilbo's protests.
“He's very sick. High fever and a cough, and I am too worried about him to just leave his side, but I am afraid there's not much more I can do for him – he needs a doctor.”
“Poor kit,” Beorn shakes his head, “I'll go fetch the doctor for you.”
“You'd – you would do that?” Bilbo stammers, forgetting his hospitality in all his rush, leaving the man to hover in the foyer, not even inviting him in for a cuppa.
“Of course. Give me some time, I'll be right back with him-”
“Oh, I – don't you... I mean, stay. Have a cup of tea, I'm sorry-”
“It's alright,” Beorn smiles at him, “your boy's health comes first.”
And before Bilbo can say two words, he's off again, marching towards Dale at an impressive speed – it might take an hour or a whole afternoon, it's difficult to tell. It gets dark so fast, and Bilbo has already come to terms with Beorn doing his best, but the doctor refusing to come, or deciding to come tomorrow, if at all, but just as the sun has started sinking below the line of the horizon, like a bucket of brillian t purples and orange spilled into the sea, he hears the crunching of snow once more, and... is that a horse whinnying?
Bilbo dusts off his flour-covered hands and hurries to go see, and indeed, it is Beorn once more, this time steering the Gamgees' pony and wagon, the old Doctor Brown a right bundle of blankets on the coach-box next to him.
But the second they get some tea into him and let him warm up by the fire, he is more than eager to take a look at Frodo – the visit barely rouses the boy, a sickly sheen of sweat covering his face, his eyes darting this way and that behind closed lids, and Doctor Brown takes his delicate wrist in his soft aged hands, and frowns, frowns ceaselessly.
“He is, of course, vaccinated,” he grumbles, sitting at the edge of the boy's bed, rummaging through his large bag.
“He is,” Bilbo sighs – frankly, he's a bit surprised the doctor even believes in all this medical advancement, the image of his house filled with all sorts of peculiar herbs and jars still very clear in his memory.
“Very well, very well... Now, where was it, where did I put it – oh, but of course! I already gave it to you!”
“Gave it to me – you've given me nothing yet, Doctor,” Bilbo squints, and Beorn by the door shakes his head, crossing his arms.
“Yes, yes, I have! The drops, remember, the remedy for your boy!”
“I don't...” Bilbo mumbles, but then he remembers all of a sudden. “Oh, the, uh, the little vial you gave me for free? When I first came to visit you?”
“Yes, yes!” the doctor exclaims, his eyes gleaming happily, “do you still have it?”
I t is swiftly procured from the desk drawer Bilbo had stashed it into without a second thought when he first got it, and the doctor uncorks it with a distinctly pleased grimace, smelling its contents with a happy sigh.
“Of course, of course,” he mutters happily to himself, “just add a bit of cinnamon, yes, that was a good idea...”
“...Doctor?” Bilbo tries getting through to him, “will it work? What do I do with it?”
“Of course it'll work!” the old man declares so loudly Frodo stirs in his distressed sleep, writhing around on the bed and whimpering lightly.
“Obviously it'll work,” the doctor repeats, quieter now, “fifteen drops on a spoon, swallowed three times a day, for as long as it takes. I have some cough drops, too, see, here, take them, take them all.”
“You are most gracious,” Bilbo exhales in relief, “how much do I owe you?”
“Owe me?” the old man laughs in pure delight, “you owe me nothing at all! Perhaps one more cup of tea.”
“Oh, but I must pay you!” Bilbo protests, “you've come all this way!”
“Or perhaps,” Beorn chimes in, lingering by the door and pointing intently towards the window now, snow beginning to fall thickly once again, “you might let the good Doctor stay overnight.”
“Of course, yes, you're right,” Bilbo gasps, standing up to scrutinize the rapidly worsening weather outside, “I do have two spare beds, after all. I just don't think I'll find anywhere to hide the poor pony, though...”
“No need,” Beorn raises his hand, “I promised Master Gamgee I'd return Myrtle to him today, she is very much needed. And I have to go back to me sheep myself.”
“Not in this weather, surely...”
“Better now, before the blizzard really comes,” the shepherd shrugs, “best be warned, I think Missus Gamgee has been planning to send her husband here with a battalion's worth of food ever since she first heard your boy was sick, so you might get a delivery of that first thing tomorrow. And a good thing, too, the doctor will have a ride home, isn't that right, doctor?”
“Hmm? Yes, yes, of course, lovely weather we're having this time of year...”
And with that, Bilbo has an overnight visitor for the first time since they came here. After Beorn manages to convince him that he he won't dissolve under a bit of snow, Bilbo lets him leave, albeit reluctantly, and goes about tending to the old doctor and Frodo alike. He manages to rouse the boy long enough to make him drink a bit of tea and swallow the prescribed remedy, which, fortunately, turns out to be rather sweet, and then feeds the doctor and himself a very late dinner indeed.
The man spends most of his time mumbling nonsense Bilbo can't hope to decipher, but he is pleasant company nonetheless – mostly because he provides some company at least. Very often, Bilbo looks over his shoulder and checks every corner for a third party eavesdropping, but Captain Durin is maintaining his distance still.
Up to a point, anyway.
The strong winds usher the snow to assault the house with unceasing ferocity, and every now and then, the lights flicker feebly, threatening to die out on them – but Doctor Brown accepts the bed in the tiny guest room happily enough. Before Bilbo leaves him to it, he switches off the gas heater, the small chamber more than warm enough now, thankfully, and remembers with some fondness Thorin doing that for him once upon a time, and reminding him to do it ever since.
He almost wishes he knew how to call on him, apologize for prying too much, indulge his stubborn ways, because it is precisely those stubborn ways that have been keeping him pleasantly occupied for these past months... And as if the Captain can read his mind (or, perhaps, because he longs for the company as well, he likes to think), Bilbo finds him standing by Frodo's bedside when he goes to check on the boy the last thing before catching some sleep himself.
The sight startles him, because Thorin is... well, barely there. Like the shadows one sees after staring into the sun for too long, fading around the edges, shimmering like pale mist over a meadow first thing in the morning. But his face, that is clear enough to see, and he is... Bilbo is astonished, lingering in the door, glad he hasn't been noticed (or acknowledged) yet – Thorin gazes down at the boy with such tenderness, such quiet adoration, and worry at the same time, that Bilbo wonders if there's a part of him he's been missing all this time.
It's not difficult to connect the dots and realize that Frodo must surely remind him of his own nephews, and Bilbo has been thinking about them a lot lately – two boys he has never known, and never will, who once used to spend their time here, playing with their Uncle, perhaps performing the same antics in the wild garden that Frodo and his new friends now do... Up to the point that... whatever happened, happened, and they disappeared along with their mother, never to come back, leaving behind nothing but a bunch of old toys.
Bilbo didn't dare ask the doctor about them again, partially because he wasn't sure he'd get any sort of coherent answer out of him, but still, he wonders. The picture of them and their mother rests in one of the drawers of his desk in his bedroom, along with the letter, and every time Bilbo so much as glances at either, the air in the room gets a bit colder.
“He will be alright.”
Hearing Thorin's voice again after the interlude of days upon days of stilted silence is... not exactly unpleasant.
“I hope so,” Bilbo murmurs, stepping closer, to stand by the Captain's side, glad he seems to have decided to... solidify, for the lack of a better term, no longer looking like nothing more than a fleeting reflection of himself.
The boy stirs in his sleep, small fists clenching, and Bilbo hears a shuddering sigh, full of concern, escape Thorin – he decides not to comment, simply exhales wearily, brushing sweat-drenched strands of hair from Frodo's forehead, and sits down on the edge of the bed.
“He had pneumonia when he was very little, almost a toddler still,” he confesses, without any particular goal, simply to talk now that Thorin is here, “lay in high fevers for weeks, Prim... my cousin couldn't get him to eat anything, nothing worked to bring the temperature down. They thought he was going to die. By some miracle, he didn't.” Bilbo swallows thickly. “But he's never been the healthiest child. Never grew up properly... strong, you know? After his parents... after they died, he stopped talking altogether, and wouldn't eat, wouldn't smile, and I thought – I thought the sea air would be healthy for him. I didn't... I should have been smarter.”
“He's going to be alright,” Thorin repeats, with more conviction now, and Bilbo hopes with all his might he were able to... sense him, know that he is really there, standing so close beside him, and not just another comfort he is only imagining.
“He is happy here,” Thorin claims, and Bilbo does look at him properly then, the determination in his voice surprising to say the least.
“...I hope so,” he repeats, once again.
“I know it,” the Captain nods, and when Bilbo frowns at him inquisitively, he says no more, simply takes one step back from the bed, as if giving them some space.
Bilbo opens his mouth to say something, inexplicably touched by the meaning behind Thorin's words, but finds that he isn't quite able to. He swallows his unfounded gratitude and brushes his thumb across Frodo's cheek gently, dabbing at his forehead and his neck with a soaked cloth for the last time, before blowing out the lamp on the bedside table and tucking the boy in.
Come to think of it, he doesn't even expect Thorin to linger, but that doesn't mean he isn't glad to find him there still, and even let him follow him to the bedroom.
“Fili was about his age when it happened. Maybe a bit older.”
Bilbo freezes halfway to his wardrobe, turning around only very slowly, half afraid that Thorin will have changed his mind by the time he looks at him.
“Frodo is eleven,” he offers a bit pointlessly.
“Older then,” Thorin nods, turning to gaze out of the window, clasping his hands behind his back, “twelve or thirteen, I don't...”
“It doesn't matter,” Bilbo hurries to assure him, coming to stand by his side, and the Captain glances at him with something akin to gratitude in his eyes.
“One day, I took them to the beach,” he begins, each word an ordeal, “and I... fell asleep, and by the time I woke up, they were nowhere in sight. Turns out they'd decided to explore the cliffs. Fili decided to climb up there, and I suppose my only luck was that Kili was too little to follow him. By the time I heard him calling for me, Fili had already climbed up to the highest rock, and couldn't get back down by himself. He'd injured his foot, and I told him to stay still, and I tried getting to him, but everything was far too slippery...”
“What happened?” Bilbo peeps, and Thorin's jaw clenches, as if he is reliving that day far too vividly.
“He slipped, fell. Hit his – his head on a rock, before almost drowning in the sea. I jumped after him, of course, but...”
“Thorin,” Bilbo exhales shakily, reaching out to touch his hand in a gesture of comfort, realizing far too late how pointless that would be, jerking back awkwardly.
“I carried him home – had to carry both of them. Kili was only six, and he couldn't stop crying. My sister... We didn't know if he was going to wake up at all.”
How could you?! How could you have let them out of your sight?! You promised you wouldn't drink around them! You swore you wouldn't let them anywhere near the cliffs!
Bilbo shudders – it's almost as if he can see her for just a second, rage and tears both in her eyes, shouting at her brother while her eldest lay pale and motionless in the bed nearby, a nasty bruise on his forehead...
“We called on the doctor,” Thorin continues, his voice quiet, subdued, as if the shame has never really gone away, “he gave us... Gave us a salve or two, said to keep watch by his bed, said... it was a matter of time, and luck, nothing else. Even gave us some sort of tea for Kili – he just presumed he'd have trouble sleeping. He wasn't the only one, of course.”
“Your sister,” Bilbo guesses, and Thorin nods.
“She was livid, and grief-stricken. She'd lost her husband only a couple years prior, and she was... terrified. And I was hardly the best of company. We quarreled ceaselessly, instead of... supporting one another.”
“Oh my,” Bilbo murmurs, staring out of the window, blinking away the sudden daze.
“After Fili woke up, she packed the three of them up and left, never to come back,” the Captain says calmly, almost as if anticipating Bilbo's reaction.
“But you – it wasn't all your fault, surely?” he tries, and Thorin shakes his head with a flicker of a somber smile.
“She had every right to be angry with me. I had been... I'd lost my ship, and I wasn't... exactly myself. She would try to talk some sense into me, and always meant for the best, but I wouldn't listen.”
Bilbo blinks once, twice, unsure what he should say. It isn't difficult, imagining the Captain disagreeing with his sister, and hurting her with his inconsideration enough so that she decided to leave, but still...
“I'm sorry,” he murmurs at last, “that must have been very difficult.”
Thorin gazes at him pensively, as if trying to determine whether he really means those words, but then he shrugs, inhaling deeply, letting out a long sigh that might very well be relief, for finally having told this story that, Bilbo suspects, few other people know.
“Now you understand why they all think I took my own life,” Thorin says then, casually, “I certainly had all the reason to.”
“Oh, but-” Bilbo gasps, but faced with Thorin's quirked eyebrow, he deflates.
They stand in silence for a moment, save for the arguing of the elements outside, and Bilbo can't help but mull over the tragedy of it all. Can't help but think that he's arrived here a couple of years too late. Yes, because Thorin would adore him so if they knew each other back then. Please.
“She's all but forgiven you now,” he points out softly, thinking of the letter folded in a drawer nearby, and Thorin chuckles wryly.
“And what good is that anymore?” he replies, “I can hardly spend a lovely afternoon chatting with her about it in my current state, now can I?”
“Why not?” Bilbo shrugs, “I'm sure she'd get used to you eventually. I did.”
“Don't be ridiculous,” Thorin chortles, “she would have no reservations about smacking me over the head, and you can imagine how well that would go.”
“You could use a good smack over the head, though,” Bilbo notes innocently, and only grins when the Captain groans, equal parts exasperation and a warning.
“I still think I should write to her,” he says more seriously, “if only to tell her about your... demise. She deserves to know, don't you think?”
Thorin doesn't respond, merely continues glaring out of the window, eyes distant and, Bilbo thinks, sad without him realizing it, lost in thought.
“Thorin?”
“Yes, yes, alright, do as you please,” the Captain grumbles, waving his hand fussily, “let us just... not mention this in the book.”
“As you wish,” Bilbo smiles, and then, after a moment of silence, warmer now, a smirk lingering on Thorin's lips, one that might as well have been forgotten there without noticing, he adds, “if your sister is anything like I imagine her, I think she'd find this... you, rather exciting.”
“I hardly think so,” Thorin grumbles, moving to stare at the mess of Bilbo's notes on the desk, fingertips hovering, as if he'd like to sift through the papers, but can't.
“Oh, come now. Perhaps she'd be glad to find out that she had the chance to talk to you still? Perhaps that's why you... lingered here in the first place? To make amends?”
“Make amends,” Thorin snorts sardonically, “that's not possible.”
“Why not?”
“Because-!” Thorin exclaims, then inhales sharply, as if defending himself against some onslaught of emotion, “because... I can't. How could I. I don't know why I'm here. I don't know why I stayed, and I don't know why you of all people are the only one who can see me. But she – how could I cause her such grief, all over again? How could I?”
“Thorin...”
“I am not real, Bilbo. I am not supposed to be here, not like this. I am just an echo, incapable of touching, of feeling, of leaving this blasted house. I'm not real.”
“Oh, but Thorin,” Bilbo says intently, stepping closer, his hands once again flying forth, reaching to touch before he can realize it's in vain, and the Captain watches with eyes wide, almost frightened.
Bilbo beckons him, turning his hand palm up, fingers fluttering lightly, an almost playful come hither gesture, and Thorin frowns darkly, but seems to be strangely captivated by the sight.
He raises his own hand tentatively, nearing Bilbo's ever so slowly, and Bilbo fights the instinct that tells him to close his eyes – no, he watches, and feels... nothing, when their hands are supposedly touching, nothing except a strange, gentle tingle and a cold, like dunking your hand underwater, or running it over soft blades of grass, and it doesn't last long enough for either of them to make up their mind about it. Did Bilbo feel anything at all, or was he just hoping he might?
“You are real enough to me,” he says resolutely nevertheless, curling his fingers inward – Thorin's hand jerks away, his gaze a disarming mixture of awe and uncertainty, and perhaps for the first time during the time of their unusual... acquaintance, Bilbo thinks him rather endearing.
“As long as you're capable of meddling with my shortbread, you're tangible enough, believe me,” he adds somewhat teasingly, and after the Captain chuckles, uneasily, as if he himself didn't quite anticipate his own reaction, Bilbo wishes him a good night and lets him mull over his words, and this time, sleeps soundly for the first time since Frodo got sick, for the first time since winter started, perhaps, and dreams of spring.
-
Dear Mrs Durin,
my name is Bilbo Baggins, and I write to you from Oak Cottage in Dale. I've been renting this house since this summer, August of 1908, that is. Your letter took me by surprise, and I do so dislike being the bearer of tragic news, but the thought of you not knowing the truth is unbearable. Your brother, Captain Thorin Durin, is deceased. I do not know the exact circumstances of his death, but I have been informed that it happened several years ago – five, to be exact.
Though I am not in the business of prying into private affairs, from the nature of your letter I understood that there was some unfinished business between you two, and I deeply regret that your brother is not here by my side to read your words.
As a complete stranger, I don't feel entitled to saying any more, so please simply accept my deepest condolences for your loss, and feel free to write me back, should you desire to. I do not know if I will be of any help, but the option is there.
Sincerely yours
Bilbo Baggins
January 23rd, 1908, Oak Cottage, Dale
