Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2015-05-16
Completed:
2015-05-31
Words:
76,700
Chapters:
12/12
Kudos:
2,029
Hits:
0

The Ghost And Mr Baggins

Chapter 8

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Winter passes them gently, as if it has long since decided to offer spring its place – the skies remain clear for longer than the blink of an eye in the morning, and the ground thaws, allowing the very first of the resilient seaside growth to sprout once more. The humid air smells of things breathing anew, of fresh dirt, and of course, of the sea – but it never ceases to amaze Bilbo how what once seemed like just one persistent scent to him, can change with the shifting weather.

When they'd first arrived here, at the apex of summer, it was sun-bleached driftwood, seaweed caught on rocks, almost pungent at times, the air dry and the breeze bringing little relief.

The colder it got, the less he could recognize the water, and instead felt the winter approaching, a freezing spike stinging in his lungs, promises of storms and mud and, eventually, snow.

But now, all he smells is life – it reminds him of where he grew up, watching the plants slowly wake up, blooms uncurl and grass grow greener, the heady and yet fresh tingle of rejuvenation, the joy of new life everywhere you look. Before he knows it, the cliffs are covered with resilient little flowers, their yellows and purples and whites scattered like colorful beads everywhere he looks. The grass in the garden is threatening to become unmanageable if he doesn't do something about it, growing tall and thirsty, and warmth begins worming its way into every nook and cranny of the house, its old stone and weathered wood. Soon, winter alongside all its unpleasantness, the days they had to spend locked inside because the blizzards wouldn't let them out, Frodo's illness, firewood running short, all of it becomes nothing but a fading memory.

Frodo and him are both thrilled that school resumes regularly, the lad for the excitement of seeing his friends, Bilbo for the routine, and the glee he observes in his nephew's eyes – he is quiet still, always will be, and bruises like a peach, and spends more time silently watching and reading than talking, but Bilbo also sees that he smiles more, eats more and sleeps soundly on most nights, and there is an achievement in that.

As for Bilbo himself, he doesn't know exactly what he's been looking for here, but he seems to have found it nevertheless. Sometimes, it's in spending an entire afternoon gardening, sweat breaking on his brow and dirt catching behind his fingernails, and sometimes it's in watching the sun set through the window in his bedroom, the soft squeaking of his rocking chair seemingly the only noise in the whole wide world.

And sometimes, it's in crushing the sand under his shoes, walking the length of the beach with no particular goal in mind, leaving one neat set of tracks, even though he's never alone.

“You never married.”

Sometimes, Thorin doesn't say a word the whole time, nothing but one more fleeting cloud in the corner of Bilbo's eye, but sometimes, it's... this.

“Shrewdly observed,” Bilbo chuckles, sizing his companion up and down – always in black, his hands clasped behind his back, always just like he's stepped off the deck of his ship only a moment ago – the sun never bothers him, and he never casts a shadow.

“Why not?” Thorin asks, though his gaze is firmly affixed to the horizon, as it always is, as if he's waiting for something, his ship to emerge from the mist and take him away.

“Well, um,” Bilbo clears his throat, unsure whether this is a question he really wants to answer, “I suppose I never felt... the need? I spent my youth studying, and when I decided it was something I wanted to, you know, pass on, become a professor myself, I had long since passed any sensible age for marriage.”

“And your family,” the Captain notes, still not affording him a single glance, “were they not disappointed?”

“My mother probably would be, now, if she were here to witness me leading a bachelor's life at this point,” Bilbo chuckles, “but as I said, I never... desired it. My father only married my mother because she decided for the both of them that they would be perfect together – or at least that's how he always told the story. The truth is they loved each other very much, very much indeed. Perhaps I simply didn't think I'd find someone as kind to me as she had been to him. And I'd sooner become a monk than force some unfortunate soul into an arranged affair of any sort.”

A smirk dances across Thorin's lips, like a streak of sunlight, and he doesn't comment further.

“What about you, then?” Bilbo asks, hands in the pockets of his sensible overcoat, kicking a pebble in his way rather than daring to look Thorin the eye, “why did you never marry?”

“How do you know I didn't?” comes an almost playful response, and laughter bubbles up in Bilbo's throat.

“Because I know. Writing a book about you and all that, remember?”

“Who's to say I've revealed all my dalliances to you?”

“Well, that's the thing,” Bilbo decides to indulge him in his teasing, “you didn't. All these conquests, all these adventures, and not one mention of a – a bonny lass waiting for you in each port, or a picture in your locket...”

To his surprise, that makes the Captain laugh, though his pensive mood remains.

“There were some... conquests,” he admits a bit hesitantly, ignoring Bilbo's snort at the term, “but none ever warranted anything... permanent, be it a picture in a locket, or god forbid, a wedding ring.”

“God forbid,” Bilbo repeats, amused, and Thorin huffs, stopping, turning away to gaze off to the horizon.

“I only ever loved the sea,” he concedes, so quietly and somberly, “those first couple of hours after the ship left port. The smell of brine, and the wind in my face, and the sway of the waves lulling us to sleep. There's no freedom quite like that. Certainly not in a marriage.”

The corner of Bilbo's mouth quirks upright at that last sentence, but he couldn't laugh if he wanted to – there he is, a man without his ship, a seaman stranded, never to sail again, and Bilbo had meant every word that he'd said to him once. He is real, to him at least, even though Bilbo spends most of his time wondering if he really is the only one who can see him. His story is real, and as reluctantly as they've been cooperating, it's almost done now, and Bilbo finds himself wishing... hoping, that other people will read it, and see.

He thinks he can understand now, Thorin's desire to tell it – to leave something behind.

 

Spring takes over, and the ground has warmed and thawed, and perhaps in that very same desire, Bilbo is found kneeling in the damp grass one late afternoon, digging a narrow, deep hole with his best trowel, sweat beading on his forehead, and if it weren't for the fact that he's being watched by a ghost, it would be a perfectly usual afternoon. Or, well, at this point, that's probably why it is a perfectly usual afternoon.

“I thought you said nothing would grow in the garden if you didn't let more light in,” Thorin comments casually, and Bilbo sits back on his heels, wiping at his forehead with the back of his hand, chuckling a bit breathlessly.

“Oh, I have no hopes for this one actually growing,” he reaches into his pocket, and Thorin comes closer to see. “It's far too old for that.”

“An acorn?”

“Indeed,” Bilbo smiles at the perfectly shaped seed in his dirty palms, brushing at its smooth surface with his thumb.

“Then why put it in the ground at all?” the Captain asks – it's hilarious to see him so genuinely interested.

“It's from the oak that grew over our house back home,” Bilbo explains, “it was the only thing I took with me to the city after my mother died. When I was little, she would tell me stories about that tree, you see, and I thought... well, it's that one tiny bit of home that I've always carried with me, you know? She would always say, plant a tree, Bilbo, after you've stopped running.”

“What are you running away from?”

Bilbo opens his mouth, surprised at the sudden shudder, a slightly unpleasant tingle dancing up his spine, but then he shakes it off, quicker than it came, and smiles brightly at his companion.

“I don't quite know. I think it might have been her way of reminding me to just settle down already. Either way, I'm done running, or even walking, anywhere. I'm staying put, if that's alright with you, and this acorn might never grow into an oak, but at least it'll have a nicer place to rest than the bottom of my satchel someplace. ...Oh, I've rambled a hole into your head again, haven't I.”

Thorin glances down at him as if he's only ever noticing him now, and then resumes gazing off towards the sea, like he always does – Bilbo thinks that if they ever do manage to finish this book, and someone were to illustrate it, he'd very much like them to draw the house like that, cliffs heaving like the waves of the sea itself, the sun only just beginning to set, and its owner standing in front of it, hands clasped behind his back, his ship waiting for him on the horizon.

“You did no such thing,” Thorin mumbles, and the spell is broken, though not unpleasantly – it's simply a soft pang that Bilbo feels somewhere close to his heart, like a longing he can't quite explain, or perhaps doesn't wish to.

As he gently lowers the old acorn into the hole he's dug, he doesn't quite know what his mother would have to say about that, but he does know it makes him feel grounded, quite literally like sprouting roots and finding his bedrock – he remembers when he first came here, how he feared every strange sound, how the house offered nothing but endless struggles with this or that, how he felt like he surely must have never left the city and was only dreaming when he met Thorin...

Now, he knows every inch of it intimately, every noise a reassurance he can read like a book, and as for Thorin himself... Sometimes, Bilbo forgets. Forgets that he's been spending his time with someone who doesn't rest, or eat, or – or cast a shadow when the sun is up. Who doesn't breathe, and can only offer a sardonic comment or two when Bilbo struggles with chopping wood, or moving the table, or repairing a broken chair, instead of actually picking up the tools and lending a helping hand.

Someone who, for all intents and purposes, shouldn't be there, but is. Sometimes, and he doesn't know if it's because Thorin lets him, or simply forgets he's even there, Bilbo catches himself watching, staring at the stern lines of Thorin's face, his posture, shoulders broad and chest proud, still every bit the commanding officer he used to be, and pondering... Is this luck, really? Living like this, lingering on? Should anyone wish to be seen like this, stuck in between life and death, incapable of claiming the life they'd lost, doomed to merely observe?

Especially compared with the overabundance of life he sees elsewhere. If there is one undoubtedly good thing that Oak Cottage has done for them, it's making Frodo whole again, rejuvenating him. He is much like the spring that now reigns in full force, teeming with energy and shining bright, and though Bilbo still catches him stirring restlessly in his sleep occasionally, or staring into space absentmindedly, sky blue eyes unfocused, he also hears his laughter infinitely more often now, and there are afternoons when he can barely make him stay still to eat one meal, until he is dashing off to the beach or the hills, one or more of his friends in tow, often guarded by Ursa the dog barking excitedly and racing them as if they're just more of the innocent lost lambs he must lead back to their herd...

If this is what Bilbo's entire life has been aspiring to, ensuring one boy's happiness and seeing to it that he grows up happy and healthy, then he will take it, bear it without a single complaint.

 

“Uncle Bilbo! I'm back! A letter came for you, Mister Gamgee gave it to me!”

“Oh, did it now? Hold on, where are you going?! Oh, hello, Samwise...” Bilbo calls after the boys, dashing through the kitchen and stomping up the stairs before he can so much as blink, “oh, one of these days I'll start having trouble keeping up with you...”

But polite as ever, Frodo and Sam are back in the kitchen just when he's set a fresh batch of biscuits and jam on the table, dutifully washing their hands and faces while Bilbo sits down with the letter, turning it over in his hands, and indeed, there it is, the return address: Mme Dis Durin, Bellevue Avenue, Paris, and so on, and so forth, and Bilbo's heart jumps in his chest, beating faster. It's been so long since he's written to her, and he's all but ceased to expect a response, after all.

“What is it, Uncle?” Frodo asks curiously, licking jam off his fingers.

“Oh, nothing, nothing, don't speak with your mouth full, you,” Bilbo scolds him only as an afterthought, standing up to get the letter opener from one of the cupboards, slicing the envelope open with utmost care.

“Master Bilbo, my Da says he might be able to build us a swing from one of the trees in your garden,” Samwise declares through a mouthful of biscuits as well, “that one tree by the hedge is good, Da says...”

“Yes, yes, of course, that would be wonderful,” Bilbo exhales, unfolding the paper covered in neat slanted handwriting.

“Can we go play in the garden, Uncle?”

“You know the rules,” Bilbo barely glances at them, already immersing himself in the text, “no climbing the trees, stay away from the well, don't... wander off... I'll be right back.”

“Don't wander off, Uncle!” Frodo calls after him, followed by a burst of giggling from both boys, but Bilbo only grunts something unintelligible in response, already steering out of the kitchen, the letter outstretched in his hands.

 

Dear Mr Baggins,

 

thank you for taking the time to write to me, even though it was hardly your responsibility. The news of my brother's death came entirely unexpected, to say the least. As my letter to him might have hinted, we have not kept in touch for some time now, and in the grand scope of things, I suppose I can hardly be surprised that the information never got to me.

I do not desire to bore you with unnecessary details of our falling out, but you are correct in assuming that there remained a lot unsaid between my brother and I. It is difficult to imagine that I will now never get the chance to remedy that.

But no matter – my grief is hardly something to burden strangers with. Once again, my sincerest gratitude for your decision to write to me, that was very kind of you. Perhaps I shouldn't ask, and you are welcome to simply ignore these queries, but I cannot help but wonder – you will have lived at Oak Cottage for some months by the time this reaches you, and surely you must have learned something. Was my brother the one who offered it up for an agency to rent, while he was away? Did he perish at sea?

I know that these questions might seem odd to you, especially coming from an estranged sister who never took the time to actually get in contact while there was still time, but perhaps it is because of that fact that I now find myself longing for some sort of closure. It would be fortunate if you were able to assist me, but like I said, I shall not hold you at fault if you decide to simply leave this letter be. You've already done more than enough for me.

Sincerely yours,

 

Dis Durin

23rd March, 1908, Paris

 

Bilbo isn't entirely certain what he'd expected – perhaps an emotional confession of a widow who has now lost one more person close to her heart, ink smudged by the tears she shed while writing the letter? But come to think of, if Madame Durin is in the least like her brother, Bilbo should expect a woman grieving, but strong against all odds, heartbroken, but proud. And certainly, much like the Captain himself, she's already spiked Bilbo's curiosity.

He doesn't get the time to write a response until that evening, though, because the boys demand his attention of course, and by the time he makes it back to his study, Thorin is already there, standing over the letter – Bilbo has left it unfolded on the desk on purpose, of course, and he is very curious to find out what Thorin thinks of it, very curious indeed.

“Should I tell her about what really happened to you, do you think?” he asks casually, taking a seat, Thorin moving to the window and his telescope as per usual. “I thought I'd certainly write to her about the harp. And the house is in very good shape, after all. I might even ask about her sons, you know, obviously I'd conceal the fact that I'd be asking for you, but I thought perhaps you would like to know...”

“Whatever you deem necessary,” Thorin responds, his back turned to Bilbo, and his voice is dull and, as ironic as that sounds, lifeless.

“Oh, no, I didn't mean to upset you, I just figured, you know, it would be good to... know more about them, don't you think? It's been so long...”

Thorin snaps to look at him, jaw set tight and eyes blazing with some unvoiced urgency, almost desperate, but then it disappears all at once, the sky clearing after a storm, and he shakes his head and turns away again, sadness sitting heavy on his shoulders.

“It doesn't matter,” he declares evenly, as if he actually believes that, “let us return to the story. Where did we stop last night...?”

Bilbo glares at his back for a silent moment, trying to decide whether he should push the issue or not, but he relents eventually, sighing and shrugging to himself.

“Fine, have it your way,” he grumbles, “and... yes, here we go. You were just telling me about that merchant ship your fleet was guarding, the one off the shores of Spain...”

 

And just like that, Bilbo finds himself making arrangements with an editor in the nearest larger city, which would be Norwich, where they first arrived to set up renting the cottage via Laketown Realtors – it is only then, setting up an initial meeting, that he realizes he has not gone further than Dale in so long now, and truth be told, he is rather excited about the trip. Almost as excited as Frodo is about the opportunity to stay with the Gamgees for the night again – Bilbo has been worrying about the trip back, since they don't own a motor car, or have sufficient finances to rent one, and so the travels will have to rely on the train, which is bound to, with its very unreliable schedules, fail to deliver him back home before the end of the day. And on a school night, too.

But with Bell and Hamfast agreeing swiftly to accommodate Frodo, and pick up Bilbo at the train station the following day, he is miraculously unburdened, and it proves a very odd feeling to say the least.

The whole predicament of presenting the first couple of chapters to the publisher makes him incredibly nervous, but not in the least as antsy as the actual author of the book.

“And don't forget to mention the Battle of Abtao, will you?” Thorin marches the span of the master bedroom while Bilbo performs last-minute checks of his luggage, as well as everything he will be leaving behind, “it doesn't occur until later in the story, but needless to say, that's what will draw people's attention...”

“Yes, yes, stop fussing over it already,” Bilbo sighs, “it will be alright. It is a good story, and I'm fairly confident I can convince them of that, you know. Have a little faith. And don't forget to keep the windows latched!”

“Yes dear,” the Captain grumbles, and Bilbo gasps in indignation, his cheeks heating up.

“Impertinent sprite,” he scolds Thorin, “don't you mess up my sheets while I'm gone, do you hear me? Or I'm not bringing back any treats.”

“Oh, I wonder what I might possibly want,” Thorin declares theatrically, “perhaps a bottle of something that I can actually drink.”

“I'll see what I can do,” Bilbo snorts, “I must get going now. Be good.”

The memory of the sound of the Captain's laughter keeps him company all the way to the train station.

 

Norwich is a bustling city, a little bit too industrial for Bilbo's tastes, the noise of its many mills working overtime a ubiquitous hum in the background, but he navigates it easily enough, catching the first coach he comes across and simply asking the driver to deliver him to the Bowman Publishing House. It is an inconspicuously grandiose building, and Bilbo climbs the stairs to the second floor all but shivering with anticipation, wishing almost foolishly that a certain someone were there with him.

“I have a three o'clock appointment with Mister Bowman,” he introduces himself to the receptionist, who sizes him up and down somewhat suspiciously, and demands his name.

“Yes, yes, Mister Baggins. Mister Bowman himself?”

“I... think so?”

“That doesn't seem very likely,” the spindly man dismisses him, still measuring him over the rim of his neat glasses like he's the strangest specimen to have ever walked into this house.

“Well, it's – it's what we agreed,” Bilbo shrugs, “we exchanged a number of letters, you see...”

“Yes, yes, I imagine you have. Take a seat please, I'll see what I can do. Mister Bowman is a busy man, you see.”

“Yes, well, obviously, that's why we set up a meeting so long beforehand,” Bilbo doesn't save on thinly veiled bitterness, but takes a seat by the far wall more or less obediently, withstanding the man's glare quite well, in his own opinion.

“There's a gentleman in there with Mister Bowman right now, you see,” he is informed coldly, “you wouldn't have me interrupt their meeting, now would you.”

Bilbo takes care to shrug with overt cheeriness, but apparently, all irony is lost on the busy Mister Bowman's assistant, and so he merely sighs and takes to idly rapping his fingers on the armrest of his chair, and inspecting the paintings on the wall, none of them quite as impressive as the ones back home, he swiftly decides.

It might be an hour or ten minutes, but finally, the door flies open, and Bilbo is immediately summoned by Mister Judgmental Stare, as he's come to privately refer to him, so he doesn't get to see outright who it is that has just walked out of the publisher's office – and he doesn't think he has any reason to care, until a hauntingly familiar 'Bilbo Baggins! Is that really you?!' makes him spin on his heel and look up, up, until he's certain that the impressive man standing in front of him really is who he thinks he is.

“Professor Grey?” he exclaims, “what are you doing here?”

“Always with the Professor. We have known each other for years, I assure you Gandalf will suffice, my lad.”

“I'm, uh... well, that is...” Bilbo stammers, blushing a bit, “of course. I'm just surprised to see you! I wrote to you a while back...”

“Yes, I know!” Gandalf beams, “that's why I'm here!”

“That's why you're – huh?” Bilbo inclines his head a bit helplessly, “but... how did you know I was going to be here in the first place?”

“Master Baggins, you did set up an appointment,” the assistant jumps in just as Gandalf is about to answer, and Bilbo finds he is a bit dazed by this sudden turn of events.

“Yes, yes, of course, I just...”

“What do you say I wait for you to finish in there, and then we have a cup of tea?” Gandalf is very quick to jump in, “I know a lovely place just around the corner, and I would absolutely adore it if we were able to catch up. What do you say?”

Bilbo gapes at him mutely, a face from his past he didn't think he'd be seeing again any time soon, and from him to the open door waiting for him, the weight of his – Thorin's – manuscript tugging at his satchel...

“Yes, yes, of course, that would be... lovely,” he concedes, “I don't quite know how long I will take in there...”

“Doesn't matter to me in the slightest,” Gandalf waves his hand graciously, “I'm sure I'll have a grand time with Mister Peabottom here, hammering out the finer details of my arrangement, while you figure out yours.”

And with that, and a powerful glare from the surly assistant, Bilbo can do nothing but hurry inside the publisher's office at long last, casting a glance or two back over his shoulder, just to make sure that he hasn't dreamt the entirety of this encounter. But no, Gandalf is really there, folding his impressive frame into the chair Bilbo had sat in, putting his top hat on with a signature flair that makes Bilbo smile, hooking his umbrella on his forearm, almost as if neither of them have ever left the university...

“Everything quite alright?”

He actually starts, remembering only now that he's in fact not alone in the room he's just entered, and he swivels around quickly.

“Oh, my apologies. So sorry. I just – um. Good afternoon. My name is Bilbo Baggins.”

“Good afternoon, Mister Baggins,” the man behind the spacious table smiles, standing up to shake his hand, “are you sure you're alright? You look like you've seen a ghost.”

Bilbo barks a laugh before he can stop himself, and then abruptly clears his throat as the man quirks an eyebrow – he is surprisingly young, perhaps younger than Bilbo even, and has a very trustworthy, if stern, face, dark hair and a brooding brow, but Bilbo is, after all, used to seeing all that in much more stupefying quantities elsewhere. And besides, something about this person immediately puts him at ease, which certainly couldn't be said for the Captain at first.

“I'm perfectly fine,” he says with an apologetic smile, “it's a pleasure to meet you, Mister... Bowman, I assume.”

“Yes, that would be me,” the publisher grins, “I gather you know the gentleman who was here before you?”

“Oddly enough, I do, yes,” Bilbo admits with some confusion still, “we used to be fellow... professors, in London, a long time ago. What did he want with your Publishing House, if you don't mind me asking?”

“What everyone usually wants from a Publishing House, I suppose,” Mister Bowman smiles, “to publish a book. Isn't that why you're here as well?”

“Is that... yes, yes, of course!” Bilbo titters.
“Well then,” Mister Bowman leans forward, “I understand you're writing about a sea captain?”

 

When he stumbles out of the publisher's office, slightly stupefied and not a small bit exhilarated, it has started raining heavily, his stomach protesting the lack of anything of any real sustenance in it since lunch – he barely expects Gandalf to have actually stuck around (in fact, he's not entirely sure they even met in the first place, but come to think of it, it isn't even the strangest thing that has happened to him lately), but the man is still there where he left him, sitting in the chair by the wall, somehow having succeeded at roping the bitter assistant into a lively debate. He springs to his feet the second he lays eyes on Bilbo, though, and steers him out of the Publishing House and into a coach he has miraculously summoned seemingly out of nowhere, leaving Bilbo a bit flabbergasted.

“How did it go, then?” he asks him, the rain drumming on the roof of the coach as it rattles off to god knows where, “are you going to be a published writer after all?”

“It... seems like it?” Bilbo offers unsteadily, “this was supposed to be only an initial meeting, for him to look over the draft of the first chapter or so, but he ended up reading all the way through to the unfinished parts, and even offered me an advance!”

“Oh, but that's wonderful! Congratulations!” Gandalf leans forth to pat Bilbo's arm, “who would have thought.”

“Not me, that's for sure,” Bilbo mutters, and then squints at Gandalf, “will you tell me how come we've met here, of all places? You never replied to my letter, so I figured you were either busy or uninterested, or maybe I'd gotten the wrong address...”

“Nothing of the sort, my dear fellow,” Gandalf still looks so enthused, like he's in on some secret outcome of their meeting he hasn't quite shared with Bilbo yet, “but you're right, I was too busy to respond immediately. So I figured I'd best meet you in person.”

“You could have given me a warning, you know.”

“No time,” Gandalf waves his hand, “never enough time. But tell me more about this sea captain you're writing about! How terribly exciting!”

 

They end up sitting down for afternoon tea in a lovely little cafe somewhere in the city, and Bilbo couldn't hope to find his way from here to his lodgings for the night in his wildest dreams, but that doesn't matter now – without having any say in it whatsoever, he is swept off his feet by Gandalf deciding to tell him probably every single exciting thing that has occurred to him, or someone they used to know, at once, and really, it has been years, and Bilbo finds he is... Not completely without interest, but... invested elsewhere. Yes, that's one way to put it.

Which certainly shows when Gandalf inquires more and more about the Captain. Thorin and him have long since worked out what Bilbo is to say in these instances, and so he speaks about the hoards of letters he found at the house, and the people of Dale telling him about Thorin's life, and stitching the story together from all that, and as far as he can see, Gandalf believes it. It would be stranger if he didn't, after all – the alternative is far too ludicrous for anyone to comprehend.

“...But yes, there are some facts I can't quite access, and don't feel very confident making up,” Bilbo explains further.

“The fate of his ship,” Gandalf says, “yes, I remember from your letter. What was its name again...?”

“HMS Erebor,” Bilbo recites, “according to him – his writings, it was... lost, somehow, or taken from him alongside his title, I don't know the full story, obviously. And I have nowhere to look it up, that's why I wrote to you.”

“And that's why I came to see you,” Gandalf nods, and Bilbo's heart leaps in anticipation.

“You know of it?”

“I haven't heard that name in a very long time,” Gandalf sighs, slouching in his seat in the upholstered booth, some concern of a darker kind briefly flashing in his eyes.

“And the last time you did hear it?” Bilbo asks bluntly, trying to figure out if taking out his notebook and pencil to jot down some notes would be terribly inappropriate.

“Erebor was among the oldest ships in the navy even back when I served,” Gandalf explains broadly, “built back when the idea of a metal ship would make any proper sailor laugh. It had served in Her Majesty's Royal Navy all that time, but always belonged to one family, from what I understand.”

“Durin,” Bilbo breathes out, and Gandalf's eyes narrow.

“Yes. I don't know the full story, and I don't really think anyone does, these days, but the name of Admiral Thror Durin meant something, back in our day – back when I was barely more than a green landlubber myself. He must have been your Captain's grandfather, it's so long ago.”

“Grandfather,” Bilbo repeats, trying to file it away in his head to further question Thorin when he gets home.

“Indeed. Something happened, and he was all but stripped of his title, ending up with one ship instead of an entire fleet, Captain instead of Admiral.”

“And then his grandson ended up losing the ship altogether,” Bilbo hums thoughtfully, “one may only wonder... I know from him – his sister, that is, err, the correspondence with her, that something happened to him as well. Something that he... refused to talk about, fearing for the safety of his old crew.”

Gandalf frowns strongly now, gazing away from Bilbo and out of the window of their cafe, rivulets of rain streaking down it, but Bilbo himself watches his hands, wringing together on the table in what could very well be perceived as an intense worry. When Gandalf looks at him again, there is a sadness, but also an urgency, in his eyes, and coupled with his next words, it does very little to sate Bilbo's curiosity.

“I took the courtesy of contacting some old acquaintances of mine when I read you were interested in the HMS Erebor, and they all told me the same thing,” his old friend admits heavily, “let that story rest along with the Captain.”

 

Notes:

Well then, here we are! Bard was a lot of fun to include, but don't ask me how it works with Dale and Laketown Realtors and everything :D Hope you enjoyed!