Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2015-05-16
Completed:
2015-05-31
Words:
76,700
Chapters:
12/12
Kudos:
2,029
Hits:
0

The Ghost And Mr Baggins

Chapter 10

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

My dear Bilbo,

 

isn't it curious, how time flies? It feels like yesterday since you first wrote to me, since you first sent me the beginnings of your book, or your excellent shortbread recipe. Years pass quicker the older we get, I believe. My sons, for example, don't understand yet, I don't think – they are angry with me still, on occasion, for not telling them about Thorin earlier. For abandoning him, and never worrying about him until it was too late. They are not wrong, but I have long since realized that one mustn't wallow in one's past mistakes for too long – only work hard at not repeating them in the future.

And with that, I admit I am worried about you – spending so much time alone at Oak Cottage only leads to dark thoughts, and I'm sure my brother would confirm that. Our children grow up faster than we can see, and letting them go is about the most difficult thing that life with them has to offer. I know Frodo loves you immensely, and will always be grateful for what you did for him, offering him a childhood free of any more tragedies – but like you said, he is not eleven anymore, and I speak from experience when I implore you not to be too surprised if he decides one day that he desires more out of life than staying put.

We were young once, too, and longing for adventure – you once told me yourself that the culmination of your adventures was finding Oak Cottage, after all. One certainty of life is that our children will always leave us – and we must let them – but it is by no means the end of it. You were my support when my Fili was leaving for his studies, and so now I am yours, telling you the same things you told me, years ago – do not isolate yourself. Spend time with your friends, your acquaintances – certainly hold that birthday party you mentioned, it would be a shame to break tradition after all this time. Oh, I only wish I could be there to celebrate with you. You've become my closest friend over these years – and to think it was such a coincidence that brought us together. I'm almost sure my brother would disapprove greatly, may he rest in peace.

Perhaps one day, I will collect the prospects – and the courage – to travel the distance and visit the cottage again, with or without my boys. Walk that beach once more, hear the cry of seagulls, touch the wood of my old harp, watch the sun set beyond the line of sea on the horizon. When that day comes, I shall finally be able to look you in the eye and thank you for everything that you've done for me, and absolutely dismiss any sort of gratitude of your own – it was you, after all, who put everything in motion, when you decided to write me all those years ago.

Whenever this may reach you (hopefully in time), let me wish you the happiest of birthdays, my friend, my confidante, my favorite author, and accept this small gift without a word of complaint, if at all possible – you deserve it, and so much more. Oddly enough, and I hope you won't find this too strange, it used to belong to my brother – it was the only thing I had of him all those years, and now it feels like I'm simply sending it back home, where it belongs. Sending it so that one day, hopefully, I may follow it.

Sincerely yours, always

 

Dis Durin

August 2nd, 1914, Paris

 

Bilbo folds the letter with utmost care, smoothing its surface, long and thorough, before sighing and gazing out of the window, listening for the noises outside, hoping to hear the sound of the porch door clacking open, but to no avail. The sun is still out, after all. But at least Frodo always remembers to come home for supper.

“Any idea which trinket of yours she might be sending me?” he asks out loud, tracing the edges of the small box, no writing on it, not even a pattern or a painting, just plain wood, though rich in color.

He receives no response, but can sense him far too well, all but breathing down his neck, figuratively speaking of course – though apparently, the common courtesy to make oneself presentable is too much to ask for.

He fiddles with the unfamiliar brass mechanism until he manages to get the box open, and on a cushion of somewhat faded blue fabric rests a compass – must be, for there is an engraving of a compass rose on its lid, so delicate and smoothed with time it's almost invisible – but it won't open, no matter what Bilbo tries.

“A little help here?” he grumbles, “it wouldn't do to destroy it, I only just got it.”

“The hoop,” the quiet voice behind him would have startled him years ago, barely so now, “click the little button in it.”

Bilbo tries, and the lid pops open with an unlikely ease – a crack spreads like a thin spiderweb over the glass and the needle is tilted unnaturally, but it's still beautiful, the curved letters signifying the directions painted in bright red, the petals surrounding the center a dusty pink, like a primrose. And on the bottom of the lid, another engraving – a large, looped letter D adorned with delicate spirals like vines growing all around it, and when Bilbo looks closer, the year 1825 etched in tiny numbers below it.

“It used to belong to my grandfather. I thought we'd lost it.”

Thorin gazes at the compass with a largely unreadable expression in his face, but then, he's rarely ever clear – but Bilbo hasn't been watching him for years to fail to recognize emotion when he sees it.

“It's beautiful,” he smiles, “I only wish we had that when we were writing the book, I imagine it would have looked perfect on the cover. Or the first page, anything. To think it's almost a hundred years old!”

Thorin says nothing at all, eyes scanning the letter, re-reading it even though Bilbo recited it to him out loud a mere moment ago – it's become a sort of odd tradition of theirs, and Bilbo only wishes Dis knew that her brother has been there all these years, hearing her words of regret, and of joy, hearing about his nephews growing up.

But then again, it's been years, and somehow, for the most part, Bilbo has also come to terms with the fact that Thorin is exclusively... his. In a way. They spend days without talking, sometimes, days when Bilbo is busy entertaining guests, or Thorin is in one of his moods, or there's simply no need for conversation, and it's difficult to believe, difficult to recall that time years ago, when they were still only getting to know each other, when they spent evening after evening bent over the work desk in the master bedroom, arguing over the details of the Captain's story...

These days, nothing is quite as... intense. Sometimes, Bilbo walks the span of the beach alone, stopping by the derelict pier and tracing the faded letters carved into it, and when he looks up at the house, he sees just that – plain white walls and a dark roof, and the sunlight catching in the lens of the telescope up in his bedroom, a brief brilliant glimmer through all that greenery.

Sometimes, he sits in the rocking chair in the drawing room and hears the gentle plucking of the harp standing close by, and almost manages to convince himself it's just the breeze.

Only he knows he's never alone, not really.

In another version of events, a story that he sometimes considers writing, Thorin would be there to greet him every day, in person, and he'd fumble with the dishes while Bilbo cooked supper, and fixed the faulty plumbing himself, or the wooden railing of the back porch after that one dreadful storm.

In another version of their story, they would have both gotten what they wanted, but maybe this is the only version that would have ever allowed them to meet. And for that, Bilbo is glad.

It is a small miracle, really, that he's managed to keep his cantankerous companion a secret all this time – who would believe him, anyway? He has to tread lightly, maintain a precise number of public appearances and social calls, if he doesn't want to be branded a recluse by the townsfolk, and Frodo worries about him enough as it is, no need to add questions about his sanity to the mix.

Oh, and speak of the devil.

“He's home,” Thorin exhales, and soon after, Bilbo can indeed hear the boy being all noisy downstairs – he places the compass back into its box, shutting it gently and leaving it on his desk, and hurries to the kitchen, only to find his nephew stuffing himself with biscuits he's procured from lord knows where.

“Let those be, they're for the guests,” Bilbo scolds him, and a receives a blinding grin in response.

“Hello, Uncle. Don't worry so much!”

“Eats for two, and remains thinner than seaweed,” Thorin comments from his favorite spot by the doorway, and Bilbo almost tut-tuts at him, before stopping himself and fussing around the stove to get things going.

“You're back early. Where are the boys?” he asks, slapping Frodo's hand away, just as he reaches to sneak a taste of the contents of the largest skillet, smelling of cilantro and butter.

“They'll be here soon! Sam will come with Missus Bell, and Merry and Pip are on their way.”

“Alright then,” Bilbo sighs, “I wouldn't want this to start late.”

Dis would certainly find it amusing, he thinks, to discover that her letter has arrived on exactly the birthday party she reminded Bilbo to hold – it's more than a month early this year, as per the boys' suggestion, and the official reason is that Sam and Merry will be leaving for their studies once the summer is over, but Bilbo watches Frodo sitting at the table, legs no longer dangling high up above the floor, his serene, soft features, and thinks that Sam and Merry might not be the only ones to go in the end.

“What have you got there, then?” he asks softly, “who's writing you?”

“Oh, it's... nothing,” Frodo fumbles to fold it, but Bilbo is too quick, intercepting, and eyes darting over the untidy handwriting.

“A poem?” he smiles, “did you write this?”

“No, I... I didn't,” Frodo waves his hand in a gesture that, Bilbo notes with some concern, is very similar to his own, “Sam did. It's for Rosie.”

“Rosie – Cotton?”

“Yes. Only it's... well, you know. Sam. He's better with plants than he is with words. He's asked me to look over it.”

“Well, he certainly likes to talk about plants in his poetry, doesn't he,” supplies Thorin, who's been peeking over the lad's shoulder.

“Hmm, I suppose that's what young girls like these days,” Bilbo shrugs, “flowers and... things. Oh, roses – very thoughtful, I'd say.”

“Rhyming rose with douse, though?” the Captain chuckles, and it is only after Bilbo snorts a quiet laugh, that he notices Frodo staring at him somewhat curiously.

“What, Uncle?” he demands to know, “remembering your days of writing love poems? Think you can help me with remaking this one into something presentable?”

“My days of... oh, don't be ridiculous,” Bilbo grumbles, removing himself from the table and returning to the stove, “I don't think I've written a love poem in my life.”

“What a shame,” Thorin remarks.

“Shame,” Frodo laughs, “you should! Branch out a little bit. Maybe your next work could be a collection of poems, you know! Wives writing to their sailors, or something.”

“Cheeky brat,” Thorin chuckles, while Bilbo grows red in the face.

“And what would make you think I know anything about sailors and their wives, you?” he sputters.

“Well, it's just... you spent so much time with that Captain of yours, I thought you might have learned a thing or two!”

“About what exactly?!” Bilbo huffs, his back still turned to Frodo, lest he sees his mildly horrified expression – as for the Captain in question, he simply seems to be having too much fun to get lost just yet.

“Oh, you know – lovers lost at sea, mourning widows, things like that...”

“Where do you get such ideas?!” Bilbo exclaims, and Thorin is laughing so much the sauce Bilbo is stirring begins bubbling again, the stove acting up.

“Sam says it's what girls like. It's romantic.”

“Cut it out, you,” Bilbo hisses at the Captain, and then continues, louder, “oh yes, I'm sure the boy who rhymes rose with douse knows all about romance. For crying out loud. Clear the table, would you?”

“Fine, alright,” Frodo is still giggling, “I tried explaining that you have no interest in that area, but he wouldn't listen...”

“What area are we talking about exactly?” Bilbo sighs, exasperated and not entirely sure he wants to know the answer, as he sets the plates on the table, only just stopping himself from laying down a third one, and Frodo gazes at him silently for a bit, before answering, a tad more seriously: “People are beginning to worry about you, you know.”

“What people?”

“Just... people. Unsociable, they're calling you. You've been on your own all these years.”

“On my own – I'm not on my own! I've got your hungry mouth to feed, don't I?” Bilbo dismisses him, and Frodo rolls his eyes.

“Yes, yes, I know that, but you... it doesn't do to live all on your lonesome here, so far away from the town, writing your books and never marrying – not my words!”

“And whose words are they, hm?” Bilbo demands sharply, “I bet it was that old wretch Amarantha Grubb, wasn't it. I expect she will never forgive me for refusing to marry her eldest, and I shall never forgive her for trying to set me up.”

“Uncle!” Frodo exclaims, but his eyes are gleaming with amusement – as are the Captain's, following Bilbo's every move.

“What? No, I will not stand for it. You were the only family I ever needed, and you know that,” Bilbo declares firmly, “I have no intention of letting someone else near my kitchen, or my garden.”

“Or your heart,” Frodo sings, already reaching hungrily for the pot full of buttered potatoes.

“Oh, hush you. There was simply never any time for all that nonsense. There was never any...” Bilbo's voice falters when he meets with the gaze of sky blue eyes, Thorin having grown quiet and standing calmly by the door, and he finishes on a somewhat quiet note, “...need.”

“I know,” Frodo smiles, and it is in moments like these that Bilbo still sees him as the little boy he'd brought here all that time ago, barely talking, simply watching thoughtfully, listening... It's only natural, he thinks, for him to have grown into such a vibrant young man – it's what Bilbo has wanted for him all this time, after all.

“You're still going to throw that party though, aren't you?” he asks, all excited, and Bilbo sighs raggedly, but not without a smile of his own.

“You sound just like Dis. I suppose I must.”

“Oh, is she coming?” Frodo perks up, “it's high time we met her, don't you think?”

“I do think,” Bilbo agrees, “but can you see here anywhere, you ninny? I'm afraid she couldn't make it just yet.”

“Hmm,” Frodo pouts, but it never lasts him long, “maybe next year, then! Maybe she'll decide to stay, and you won't be so alone anymore-”

“Oh would you cut it out, you troublesome little – go change, you look dreadful,” Bilbo scolds him, to no avail, since he only laughs more and more – Bilbo punishes him by attempting to straighten out his collar and make him squirm.

“You don't have to worry about me so much, you know,” he grumbles, and Frodo snorts in disbelief.

“Of course I do. If I don't, you'll end up sitting in your study for days without talking to a soul, or gardening until you drop.”

“Now, what's wrong with a little bit of gardening?” Bilbo defends himself, “keeps the herbs on the table, you know!”

“And whatever would we do without our herbs,” Frodo declares gravely, and Bilbo proceeds to swat him over the top of his head, albeit gently – but then his sight is stolen away by Thorin, who watches on with a strange fondness in his eyes still, half hidden in the shadows in the far corner of the kitchen, and Bilbo is suddenly overcome with the need to invite him closer, for him to sit down with them and share their meal, as if that'll ever be possible... At least until Frodo retaliates in kind, his jab in Bilbo's ribs much more noticeable, that's for sure.

“Oi – you! Watch your table manners!”

“See, this is what I'm talking about, Uncle,” Frodo scolds him, “you staring into space and looking all...”

“All...?” Bilbo beckons him to finish, albeit with a healthy dose of irony.

“Pensive. And sad, when you don't think I can't see you.”

For that, Bilbo doesn't really have a suitable answer ready quickly enough, and Frodo merely watches, like he's just won some argument they didn't even have.

“What exactly do I have to be sad about?” Bilbo counters at last, and his nephew sighs heavily, like Bilbo is the immature one in this conversation.

“I don't know, Uncle. But you would tell me, if you did, right?”

“Would I... Frodo,” Bilbo exhales, and the genuine concern in his boy's eyes concerns him – has he really managed to make Frodo worry this much?

“I'm alright,” he declares, with as much conviction as he can muster, and out of the corner of his eye, he can spot Thorin watching him still. “I'm anything but miserable, you know that, don't you?”

Frodo inclines his head, his smile a bit uncertain, and Bilbo pats his arm briefly, ruffling his hair like he used to when he was just a boy, which is always guaranteed to make him grin.

“It's very sweet of you to worry, but spend more time fussing over yourself than your Uncle, alright? I'm not lonely, or alone.”

Frodo stares some more, chewing his bottom lip in a thoughtful tick that is so similar to his mother's, even though he'll never know, and then he shrugs, beaming at Bilbo effortlessly.

“If you say so,” he laughs.

“I do say so,” Bilbo huffs, “now, is that barking I hear?”

Frodo perks up, all but jumping to his feet and hurrying outside, to greet his friends – Bilbo sighs fondly, and gazes out of the window – gunmetal grey clouds threaten to ruin the fun even before it starts, traveling across the sky lazily, dragging their heavy bellies filled with rain along, and later on, Bilbo will think that perhaps this is where it all started, the beginning of the end – that very last fated birthday party.

It's yet another habit he's established over the years, mostly thanks to his friends forcing their well wishes on him when first they found out about his birthday, until he relented and decided that there might as well be some food to go along with it.

Since then, he's been inviting a carefully selected group of people – who seem to grow in number each year despite his best efforts, though – and if the Captain objects to the garden of the cottage filling with guests every now and then, he keeps it to himself.

“Won't start until late at night,” Thorin assures him, still standing by his side, and it takes Bilbo a moment to realize he's talking about the weather. All the commotion sort of happens around him, as always – whenever he shows up for Bilbo with other people around, it's as if everyone subconsciously decides to avoid the space he's in, like an unlucky step you skip when walking down the stairs, or the spot just out of the field of your vision that your mind is telling you not to look at, out of some primal fear of what you might come to see.

“If you say so,” Bilbo sighs, “I'd hate for it to ruin the pastries.”

The commotion really begins then, and he barricades himself in the kitchen, getting everything ready, slapping Merry's hand away from the bowls overflowing with biscuits and poppy-seed cakes on the table, and reminding Pippin that if he dares step over the threshold of the pantry one more time, he'll end up banned from the house for good... The truth is, he's come to love all these boys almost as much as he loves Frodo over the years, and having them all around reminds him very much of when he himself was growing up, with his countless cousins and other relatives. Sometimes he misses that, and sometimes he even ponders sending a letter addressed to one Lobelia Sackville-Baggins, but then he's always reminded that the only two times she ever bothered him after he moved here were at the very beginning, doubting that very decision, and then shortly after his book came out, wondering about a loan and cleverly disguising it as this or that sum Bilbo had forgotten to pay where his father's property had been concerned.

No, he's found new family here, and he's better off for it.

Amidst his hundredth absentminded rearranging of this or that collection of pies in their bowls, his gaze rests on Thorin, standing as he always does, by the door, his own eyes, though aimed at the table, mostly unfocused, as if he's watching something only he can see.

“What is it?” Bilbo asks casually enough, moving on to the stove to stir the sauce getting ready in his best skillet, but still hoping to catch the Captain's attention before he disappears into thin air once again – that's what usually happens when he gets this look on his face.

“How long has it been?” Thorin asks quietly, almost as if he's just muttering to himself.

“Since...?”

“Since you came here.”

“Five... no, six. The august of 1907. Time flies, doesn't it?”

“Your tree hasn't grown.”

“...Excuse me?” Bilbo looks at him over his shoulder, to see him glaring out of the window now, with an intensity of someone simmering with anger.

“Your tree,” Thorin repeats sternly, not affording him a single glance, “the one you planted instead of mine. It never grew.”

“Well, of course it didn't!” Bilbo laughs, “I told you, the seed had long since dried up. That was years ago, though! Why are you remembering it now?”

“Was it?” Thorin exhales, like the quiet rustling of leaves outside, “years ago? I don't...”

“Yes, my first spring here, remember?” Bilbo reminds him gently, “we were right in the middle of writing the book.”

“The book,” Thorin repeats numbly, eyes still wide, still staring at a horizon that isn't there, “yes, of course. The book.”

“I told you when I was planting it,” Bilbo recalls with a smile, stirring the sauce in languid circles, “I had no hopes for it actually growing. But I had taken it from the oak that-”

“That grew over your childhood home,” Thorin finishes for him, quietly, almost desperately.

“Yes. My mother always used to say-”

“Plant a tree, after you've stopped running.”

A shudder dances up Bilbo's spine, for he could swear he almost heard her voice instead of Thorin's, softer, gentler, laughter like the tinkling of a hundred little bells.

“Yes,” he dismisses it and smiles at the Captain instead, “see, you remember just fine.”

Thorin's lips move wordlessly for a moment, his eyes large and almost frightened, before he swallows it all with a huff, straightening up and marching to stand by the table, hands clasped behind his back, shoulders ramrod straight, and Bilbo simply leaves him to it. He's seen this happen before, countless times, more often these days – he doesn't suppose ghosts can grow old, not in the traditional sense of the word anyway, since Thorin looks exactly the same as the first day Bilbo met him, not a single wrinkle more than how he's depicted on his painting, but sometimes he thinks...

Sometimes he's reading in his armchair in the bedroom, and a metal creak will interrupt his peace, and he sees the telescope moving, tilting, as if there lays some land yet undiscovered outside their windows, and has to actually speak up for Thorin to remember to show himself.

Sometimes, Bilbo hears him reciting passages from the book, from his own story, even though he's nowhere in sight, and sometimes he finds him on the beach, talking to someone who isn't there.

Every now and then, Thorin calls him or Frodo by another name, and sometimes, he simply doesn't respond at all, as if he indeed is nothing more than an echo of his former self – and it is in moments like those that Bilbo realizes he's been forgetting as well.

“Now, nevermind all that,” he declares now, through a mouthful of sauce, “this is delicious! Remember, just a couple of weeks ago, I didn't think I could get the cilantro to grow at all, and look at this! It's so strong! Here, you have to taste it-”

He swirls around with the wooden spoon at the ready, to bring it up to Thorin's mouth, and it takes him far too long to realize what he's just done – Thorin stares, perfectly attentive now, blinks once, twice.

“I can't,” he reminds Bilbo plainly, his voice soft and his eyes somber, the color of the sea at dusk now in the dim lighting of the kitchen.

“Oh,” Bilbo exhales, feeling incredibly nauseous all of a sudden, “oh, of course. Of course you can't. Silly me, oh my goodness. Here, let me, um...”

He turns away swiftly, busying himself around the stove, and a good thing too – he feels Thorin's scorching gaze on him, and knows he would not be able to withstand it very long, or continue talking much longer with that painful lump in his throat.

“Silly me,” he repeats feebly, and what he hears might be a roll of thunder from somewhere very far away, or just his heart beating heavily.

“Bilbo-” the Captain begins, but before he can say any more, a loud call comes from Merry or Pippin: “Master Bilbo! The Gamgees are here! And, uh... Someone else, too!”

Bilbo is jolted back into sensible action by that, fortunately, and hurries to switch off the stove, wiping his hands on the nearest dishcloth, thinking about everything, anything else than the presence of his Captain still close by.

“What do you mean, someone else?” he calls back, “hold on, I'm coming! Is Frodo welcoming them?”

Frodo is indeed, and Bilbo's heart flutters when he sees a rather fashionable motor car parking by the Gamgees' wagon – he's almost too busy keeping Merry and Pippin from ogling it up close, to notice those who clamber out of it. But if he had any doubt, Frodo's loud 'Gandalf!' explains everything rather quickly.

He's visited them countless times over the years, almost always turning up unannounced, almost never explaining why, but Bilbo has been glad for his company nevertheless – he always brings with him stories from lands so far away that Bilbo and Frodo can only imagine them in their wildest dreams, and simply seems very interested in the inhabitants of Oak Cottage in general.

Thorin doesn't like him one bit, though, never sticks around when the man is staying – even now, Bilbo shoots a worried look at the house back over his shoulder, but then the taste of their previous encounter not a moment ago still lingers bitter on his tongue, and so he leaves it be.

“Gandalf!” he exclaims, “what a surprise! What brings you here?”

“Aside from your birthday?” the man laughs, deciding whether he should shake Bilbo's hand or prevent the breeze from carrying his fashionable hat away.

“We did send him an invitation,” Frodo reminds Bilbo, grinning from ear to ear – he's grown very fond of Gandalf and his tales, no doubt strengthened by the fact that the man has never failed to bring him a little something from his travels.

“That's true, we did...” Bilbo muses, “though I wasn't sure at all that it would reach you, what with you having a different address every month.”

“Well, it did reach me, dear boy, and I couldn't be happier to be here,” Gandalf counters, finally shaking his hand, and Bilbo certainly won't be leading the conversation with that, but he notices how much older he looks – it's been a couple of months since they saw him last, and his eyes, though gleaming, are sunken, even more wrinkles fanning out around them, if that's even possible, and he's certainly leaning on his cane heavier than Bilbo ever remembers him to be.

“Don't you have tables to prepare?” he reminds Frodo, who'd much rather spend his time jumping around Gandalf like a very excited puppy, and after the boys scurry off, he escorts the man to the house himself, his curiosity taking over after all, making him ask a concerned: “Are you alright?”

“Fine, dear chap, just fine,” Gandalf rumbles, and when Bilbo scowls at him, he adds, “it's not exactly news to bring to a birthday party. I'll tell you later.” And Bilbo doesn't get another word of it out of him.

And besides, he has a birthday party to orchestrate. Lately, Frodo and the boys have taken it upon themselves to help a great deal, but even they are more excited about all the food – and in some cases, the company of certain families with beautiful daughters of age – than anything else, and Bilbo happily leaves them to it.

At least the weather behaves, just like Thorin has predicted – a pleasant breeze makes the leaves of the tall elms sing, and the garden quickly fills with people, quicker than Bilbo and Frodo and the boys can greet them in person, quicker than they can bring out all the food.

Among the last to arrive is Bard – Mister Bowman, that is, Bilbo's publisher, and, over the years, a friend as well. He has a sizable family of tree lovely children, and if he has any reservation about his eldest daughter shuffling off after Merry and Pippin, her brother and sister following her with no less enthusiasm, he doesn't voice them, simply seems to be relieved to have a place to sit and catch his breath.

“Professor Grey, fancy seeing you here,” he sighs (even through all these years, Bilbo has had trouble figuring out how exactly the two know each other), “I thought you'd be busy in Germany, preventing some international disaster.”

“International disaster?” Bilbo repeats, piece of mince pie stuck halfway to his mouth.

“That's long since been out of my hands, I'm afraid,” Gandalf smiles amicably, but his next words carry a sharper edge that's very easy to miss, if one isn't as curious as Bilbo, “and like I said to Bilbo, it's hardly birthday-time conversation.”

“Oh, no no, I'd love to hear about... whatever it is that you now do, apparently,” Bilbo waves his hand, crumbs flying, “it's my birthday, I think it's only fair I decide what we talk about!”

Gandalf and Bard share the same slightly amused look, but before the intriguing conversation can progress any further, some commotion catches Bilbo's attention – and lo and behold, not all aspects of his party are under his reign.

The cake is massive, and delicious, and Bell Gamgee preens as Bilbo praises it and scolds everyone for being too nice to him in the same breath, and there's laughter, and there's Beorn's mead and Missus Bolger's fruit punch to drink, and both get into everyone's heads equally quickly.

The sun travels lower and lower down the overcast sky, coloring it in rich hues of a late dusk, and conversation flows – Bilbo feels full, and contented, and like doing nothing else but flinging his feet up on the bench and accommodating everyone who sees it fit to talk to him, which is probably why he doesn't notice anything wrong at first, and almost topples off said bench when he does.

Thorin is there among the crowd, having appeared out of nowhere, tall and black and very much out of place, and Bilbo chokes on the punch he's drinking and looks this way and that, to confirm that he really is the only one seeing him.

He scrambles to his feet and marches over to him, but the Captain pays him no attention whatsoever – no, instead he seems to be very interested in whatever Gandalf and Mister Bowman are discussing, hovering nearby and glaring with such an intensity that it alone surely must give him away.

And if one were to simply not care very much, they wouldn't notice anything odd about those two particular guests, just two more men in a merry conversation, but the closer Bilbo gets, the clearer it becomes, the troubled frown creasing Gandalf's brow, the tight set of Bard's jaw.

“Are you gentlemen enjoying yourselves?” Bilbo butts in overly cheerfully, sending a warning look in Thorin's direction, who utterly ignores it, eyes wide and furious, piercing Gandalf.

“Quite,” the man attempts to dismiss Bilbo easily enough.

“They know about my ship,” the Captain utters under his breath, standing by Bilbo's side now, but never ceasing to stare at the two.

“They wh- well, um. Are you sure?” Bilbo asks both his visible and invisible companions.

“Yes, yes, perfectly fine,” Gandalf smiles, “a lovely party so far, Bilbo.”

“It really is,” Bard agrees, somewhat distracted, scanning the crowd, no doubt for his children.

“Ask them about it,” Thorin murmurs, his voice barely louder than the breeze and the chatter, “please.”

Bilbo senses more than sees him fading, and suddenly, the idea of him disappearing is about the least pleasing thing about today – they've spent years with his story, and they came to terms with the fact that some truths would simply never be revealed. Thorin himself has stated on several occasions that what's done is done, that even if he did find out what happened to his crew and ship after his death, it wouldn't really matter... But right now, Bilbo feels somewhat angry on his behalf, because surely, the same Bard and Gandalf, who have both been nudging him to write another novel, find out more about 'his mysterious Captain', would not hesitate to tell him if they discovered any new information... would they?

“You know,” he declares, sitting on a chair nearby, ignoring the concerned looks they very secretively exchange, “I've been thinking about writing some more after all.”

“Oh?” his publisher cocks an eyebrow.

“Indeed? That's wonderful,” Gandalf smiles, but there's no conviction behind it, and Bilbo glares from one to the other highly suspiciously.

“Yes. Perhaps a memoir, of sorts. Titled something along the lines of 'The Many Birthday Parties I Spent Wondering What People Were Whispering Behind My Back'. What is going on?”

Yet another concerned look exchanged, and Thorin now standing so close by Bilbo's side that he can almost sense him – if there were anything to sense, anyway.

“...Alright,” Gandalf sighs at long last, having reached some sort of decision, apparently, “but I did warn you, it's not a very birthday dinner sort of conversation.”

“Carry on,” Bilbo says firmly, simply raising his hand in an acknowledgment when he hears someone calling his name from across the garden.

“I told you once that the records which would allow me to find out what happened to your Captain's ship were sealed to my eyes,” Gandalf starts broadly, “and you said that what we knew so far was enough. That Captain Durin had decided to resign his career after the unsuccessful battle of Velacruz near the coast of Spain in...”

“1902,” Bilbo supplies mechanically.

“Yes. And you see, when the book came out, we didn't think anyone from the actual Navy would particularly care for it...”

“Which they didn't, until very recently,” Mister Bowman continues.

“I don't understand.”

“I received a very strange letter some weeks ago,” Bard explains, “stamped with the official seal of Her Majesty's Royal Navy and everything.”

“And in it...?” Bilbo asks tensely, very much aware of the wind rising just a tad, Thorin's hands clenched into fists.

“A complaint... of sorts,” Bard gazes at Gandalf again, as if seeking guidance – the old man simply nods, and takes over smoothly: “Apparently, since you mentioned very many real names and events in your book, the Navy took notice.”

“Are we – am I in trouble, then?” Bilbo gasps, but then it occurs to him, “took them long enough.”

“Indeed,” Gandalf chuckles, “and no, you're not. They simply saw it fit to point out some... inaccuracies.”

Bilbo can't help it, he glances at Thorin, who for his part appears somewhere halfway between flabbergasted and furious.

“Inaccuracies,” Bilbo repeats dryly.

“Yes,” Bard notes, “not through any fault of yours – you only told a story you deduced from whatever materials you discovered here, and a compelling story it was.”

“Then what did I get wrong?” Bilbo breathes out, all commotion, food and other company forgotten.

“You painted your Captain in such a positive light,” Gandalf tells him almost apologetically, “we wouldn't want you to-”

“Oh, just tell me, would you,” Bilbo retorts, perhaps a bit too harshly.

“How did you describe him leaving the Navy behind, along with his ship and crew?” Bard inclines his head.

“Uh... Just like Gandalf said, he'd resigned his post after the battle of Velacruz. I don't expect I'll ever be able to find out what really happened there-”

“What happened there,” Gandalf says softly, “was Captain Durin defying direct orders and leading not only his own ship and crew, but half the fleet with him, into peril. The records remain sealed, but one thing is certain – he was dishonorably discharged after that.”

“Dishonorably – what now?” Bilbo gapes.

“Bilbo-”

“It means that he had his rank stripped from him, and-”

“Yes, I know what dishonorably discharged means, I think,” Bilbo interrupts Gandalf, “what I don't know is how this has managed to slip my mind.”

“You couldn't have possibly known,” Gandalf frowns.

A gust of wind tears through the garden, tablecloths flapping, hands flying to secure hats from flying away.

“It's not all how it seems-”

“Oh, really?” Bilbo huffs, standing up, directing the next question at both Thorin and the other two, “tell me, what happened to the ship?”

“I have no way of knowing, that's why I wanted you to find out!”

“Long since destroyed.”

The sudden silence is suffocating. Not a single leaf or a blade of grass flutters, the wind ceasing, even the chatter subsiding – Captain Durin stares in the midst of it all, eyes the color of his beloved sea, large and blue and shocked beyond compare.

“What?” Bilbo breathes out, incapable of anything louder than that, “h-how?”

“A common practice,” Gandalf explains, “they would have offered her to another Captain, let her remain a part of the fleet, but she had long since been rendered obsolete by the newer metal ships. She would have been sunk, or alternatively anchored in some harbor somewhere as a spare, but before either of that could happen, she was sent on one last mission, apparently, a low risk, guarding a merchant fleet – the Captain who led her was someone fresh out of training, and was supposed to learn his ropes with her, but they never made port; the fleet or its guard. It might have been a storm, or pirates, no one can say, and I expect no one in the Navy much cares for her fate, since they were already planning on scrapping her anyway-”

“Traitors!”

This time, the wind is much more violent, and a loud crack and pop echoes through the garden, startling some into gasping – Bilbo sees that the window to the master bedroom has flown open.

“Sorry, sorry everyone,” he speaks up loudly and far too brightly, “I suppose the weather isn't as stable as we might have hoped, is it? Let me just... Frodo?”

He motions to his nephew, who simply nods and takes over the job of herding his friends and carrying whatever is redundant, back inside.

Thorin is nowhere in sight, and Bilbo pays no mind to Gandalf and Bard anymore, only hurries to the house, his heart tolling like a bell.

“Calm down, please...” he breathes out.

No!, the wind roars, they took away everything! Everything from me! Do you think I chose to be discharged?! You think it was my fault, don't you?!

“I don't know what to think, Thorin-”

Bilbo reaches for the latch of the porch door, but it remains stubbornly closed.

“Let me in, you stubborn ox!” he hisses.

You think I deserved it, don't you?!, the branches of the elms sway and croak.

“Don't be ridiculous, I don't think that-”

You do! You do, just like all the rest of them! Traitors!

“Thorin...” Bilbo pleads with him, tugging at the door handle, but a part of him already knows it'll be no use – the sky grows darker by the second, and the guests are getting distressed, some standing up, watching the horizon with concern and fright.

Traitors, all of you!

The first roll of thunder is a deep rumble, and Bilbo shudders, while everyone else yelps, and the true commotion begins – the door gives way at long last, with a strong waft of wind seemingly coming from inside the house, and Bilbo almost trips over his own feet.

“Stop this!” he calls, not really caring if anyone hears him, “settle down!”

But Thorin isn't listening anymore, because he isn't inside the house anymore – the roar of the wind carries his voice, the clouds swirling overhead and obscuring the sun unnaturally fast are all his rage and betrayal.

The guests swarm like confused ants, some of them having enough wherewithal to help Frodo and the boys carry some of the trays with food inside – Beorn grabs two long benches at once, one under each arm, and marches towards the house, aided by his barking dog.

The first heavy drops of rain splatter on the swiftly emptying tables, and before anyone can say a peep, the storm is upon them, a heavy drumming on the roof, and though Bilbo and Frodo beckon everyone to come inside, not many heed their call – Bilbo watches families hurrying to their coaches mindlessly, and wonders if he is the only one who can hear the voice in the wind, the cries of anger and resentment, wordless but no less chilling, pointless but no less powerful.

The sky is torn apart, rain pouring down on them, and Frodo shouts at Bilbo to stay inside, but he doesn't listen, of course he doesn't listen – he keeps dashing back and forth for more of his precious bowls and trays and plates, all the while hoping that he might see him, see Thorin and get near him, talk to him, calm him down... to no avail whatsoever.

It's as if the sea itself has decided to drown Oak Cottage whole, and they can hear the roof leaking, they can see the water streaming in on the veranda, and they can do nothing but mourn the handful of forgotten chairs and tablecloths the wind has caught and carried away.

There's the boys and Beorn, all dripping wet in Bilbo's kitchen after having bravely rescued all the tables, and there's Gandalf gazing out of the window with a quiet curiosity, and Bofur, who immediately begins assessing the damage to the roof he's been tending to all these years, and Bard and his children, and a handful others, and Bilbo keeps apologizing and apologizing to them – some of them leave the second the rain becomes less of a solid wall, and some of them, those closest to Bilbo, stay overnight, and it is the strangest birthday party he's ever had.

Sleep eludes him no matter how hard he tries, and every now and then bright lightning cleaves the sky, even though the rain has calmed down into a quiet pitter-patter, and he lays with his duvet all the way up under his chin, listening to the boys' quiet laughter and chatter coming from Frodo's room, and the beams creaking and whining, and tries to hear him, but fails.

“Thorin,” he whispers into the dark, time and time again, “Thorin, please.”

But the house is quiet, and it feels like it's always been only Bilbo and Frodo there, as if it's been deserted all these years, the stone of the walls cold, the painting staring at Bilbo from across the room just that, a painting.

The morning is far too quiet, the sky wild and the air much colder than they'd anticipated, and they few stand on the veranda, munching on yesterday's leftovers and watching the desolation quite desperately – branches broken off, grass flattened by hail here and there, the rose bushes ruined mercilessly. Bilbo bids farewell to those returning home, without continuing yesterday's conversation with Bard and Gandalf, and with the help of Beorn, Merry, Pippin and Bofur, Frodo and him begin cleaning up and repairing whatever they can, ever so slowly, and Bilbo tries his very best not to let the silence unnerve him too much.

“Are you alright?' Frodo asks him privately nevertheless, “you look pale. Have you caught a cold?”

“Oh, it's you fussing over me now, is it?” Bilbo teases, but when the lad's worried gaze doesn't subside, he sighs, reassuring him, “I'm fine. You?”

“Sam should have been back by now,” his nephew points out, “he promised he'd bring some new tablecloths from his Mam.”

“Oh, dear Missus Bell. That's very kind of her, but I don't think – oh, see, there he goes now.”

And indeed it is the Gamgees' wagon rattling to the gate, and Sam jumps off it and hurries up to them.

“Slept warm, did you?” Pippin teases him, referring to him escorting Rosie and her family home yesterday before the storm hit in full, but Sam ignores him completely – Bilbo and Frodo both notice he is paler than usual, his round, honest face all worried.

“What's wrong, lad?” Bilbo asks him.

“It's the talk of the whole town today!” Sam says breathlessly, as if he's run here, not driven a coach.

“What is?” Frodo gapes.

“Something happened in – in one of them lands in the east, some important person or other got killed, and everyone's started kicking up a fuss about it, and now...”

“And now?” Bilbo nudges him gently.

“We're at war, Da says!” Sam exclaims, “Britain's at war!”

 

Notes:

BA-DUN-DUNNN there we go! Thorin being a fading forgetful angered ghost was difficult but entertaining to write, so I hope you liked it, guys! Can't believe it's almost over D: