Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2015-05-16
Completed:
2015-05-31
Words:
76,700
Chapters:
12/12
Kudos:
2,029
Hits:
0

The Ghost And Mr Baggins

Chapter 9

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Dear Mr Baggins,

 

thank you for such a swift response – I did not expect it to arrive at all, I must admit. My heart rebels at the idea of my brother dying by such a pointless accident, but I thank you for not immediately assuming the worst of him. In the eyes of the people from Dale, he did indeed have more than enough reason to take his own life, and if they do not believe the contrary, then I suppose I must be content with your faith in the matter, at least.

I have not yet mustered the courage to tell my sons. I cannot say whether it is utter folly, or simply a mother's instinct to protect her children from more harm. My eldest, Fili, will be leaving me for Sorbonne, the university, after this summer, and his younger brother has rather adventurous plans of his own, despite the fact that he is barely fourteen years old. Perhaps it is unreasonable of me to keep this from them, I don't know. Do you understand? You mentioned a nephew of your own – surely the need to let them be children for as long as possible isn't entirely unknown to you, as unreasonable as it may be at times.

As for all the questions of your own, I don't mind you asking in the slightest, but I'm afraid I won't be much help in that matter at all. My brother certainly never shared very much of his work with me, and the disappearance of his ship is as much of a mystery to me as it is to you.

With that said, no matter how curious I might find it that you decided to write a book detailing his life, it is not in my heart to stop you – I am as much at fault as anyone for not paying attention to him when he most needed it. We were his family, and we abandoned him. His story deserves to be told, to be known, to be read by young men not unlike my sons – I think that perhaps it is fate working in your favor, and his as well, albeit too late, by sending you to Oak Cottage. He might never have admitted it, but he would have wanted his story to be told. You are doing a great service to a great man. Thank you, and please, don't hesitate to keep me up to date with your progress.

Sincerely yours,

 

Dis Durin

3rd of May, Paris

 

Bilbo's throat is uncomfortably dry by the time he finishes reading the letter, and he almost daren't look at Thorin – before he can fold the papers in half once more and hide them in his desk drawer, one pale hand reaches down, fingertips hovering over the neat slanted handwriting, the two curved D's of the signature, as if Thorin hopes he might get closer to his sister like that, as if it is the only connection with her he has left.

“I told you,” Bilbo murmurs gently, “she has forgiven you a long time ago.”

The Captain says nothing, moving away, the breeze in the grass and the elm leaves the only sound now, a quiet, calming whisper.

Bilbo watches, watches Thorin as he moves silently from the veranda to stand in the garden, walking towards the hedgerow that severs the premises of the cottage from Beorn's fields, walking until he begins fading, until he is nothing more than translucent dust for the wind to pick up and carry off to the sea. Bilbo doesn't think he will be getting used to the sight any time soon – not the disappearing part, that's Thorin's favorite thing to do on any odd afternoon, after all, but mostly the grief. Somehow, Bilbo has become a part of this family's story, and he is no longer an innocent onlooker – he hesitated telling Madame Durin about the book, or about his personal little inquiries about the long lost HMS Erebor, but every time he doubts, he imagines her sitting alone in some lofty French apartment, a proud but lonely widow, and he feels a sort of obligation, both to keep informing her about his progress, and keep her company.

For his part, Thorin doesn't seem to mind, but Bilbo gets the distinct feeling that he's torturing himself too much over it all – indeed, when he himself thinks too long and hard about the fact that the siblings have missed their chance to make things right between them, and that two boys have missed the chance to see their Uncle ever again, it's enough to make him feel such compassion for both Madame Dis and the Captain that it threatens to completely consume his thoughts.

And it seems that all that he can do to help them, is tell this story, even though he's been advised against it.

His unexpected meeting with Gandalf still lingers heavy on his mind, and he wonders if he will ever be able to discover this part of Thorin's past entirely on his lonesome – it is not part of the actual story per se, since the Captain wishes the book to be only about the time he was actually alive and thriving in the Navy, but that doesn't mean Bilbo doesn't wish ardently to know the truth.

 

But in the meantime, others have somehow learned about his plans, and while Bilbo wasn't paying attention, his book has somehow swiftly become the talk of the entire township.

“I say, writing sounds like a terribly difficult way to make a living, that's all.”

“And carpentry isn't?” Bilbo chuckles, his friend Bofur scowling good-naturedly.

“Well, at least I know when money is coming my way, for each and every thing I do,” he declares, clearly jesting, and it is Bilbo's turn to huff in pretend indignation.

“Oh, and I don't? May I remind you that it is my advance that has provided for about half this feast's baked goods?”

One broad gesture is enough to cover all the tables straining under the weight of countless plates overflowing with food of all kinds, from the aforementioned pastries of Bilbo's making to Bell Gamgee's fruit salads, from sorbets to an entire leg of ham – apparently the people of Dale find any and all cause to celebrate, and though Bilbo can't even pretend to understand whose birthday it is this time (someone long dead, a founding father of the town/type/person?), he shares his neighbors' love for feasting and enjoying themselves whenever the opportunity arises. When Bell Gamgee and her consortium of housewives approached him about holding the grand celebration at his house, it is about time you put that large garden of yours to use, isn't it, Bilbo had promptly choked on the tea he was drinking at the time, and almost said he would have to ask Thorin first, but fortunately stopped before he could make a fool of himself, and, even more fortunately, Thorin ended up agreeing, though under strict orders not to let anyone anywhere near the second floor.

“Fair enough, fair enough,” Bofur pats Bilbo's shoulder, “I think it'll be a thrilling book, don't get me wrong. I just wonder what the Captain himself might think about it if he were alive. I can't imagine he would be very happy.”

“Then I suppose it is for the best that we will never know,” Bilbo huffs a laugh, having already started scanning the crowd for a familiar tall figure – the Captain has kept to himself so far, fortunately, but frankly, Bilbo expects to hear someone's startled shrieking any second now.

But so far, the only louder sounds are the cackling of seagulls, who have begun flocking above the house, tempted with all that food, and the laughter of all the children dashing through the garden – Bilbo allows himself to relax somewhat, even beginning to enjoy his role of the host. He doesn't think he will be doing this often, he likes his solitude far too much, but it is a refreshing experience, every now and then.

“Perhaps you could read a bit of it to us!” someone suggests at one point or another, and though he attempts to protest, he ends up fetching his notes eventually, his mind racing as he tries to come up with the best portion of the book to share – he would very much like for Thorin to offer some insights, but the house remains utterly quiet despite Bilbo's uttered inquiries when no one is looking. It was only yesterday after all that the letter from Dis arrived, and though Thorin did make a brief appearance in the evening to bicker with Bilbo about this or that absolutely necessary naval detail in the story, it's understandable that he wishes to keep his distance, and Bilbo has had too much on his mind to be anything but momentarily grateful for that.

But right now, he's about to share what the two of them have been spending almost every evening hunched over ever since Bilbo came here, and he would very much like to know how the Captain feels about that.

In the end, he decides to read what he once let his publisher read, sitting in the richly upholstered armchair in his office some weeks ago, wringing his hands in his lap out of sheer nerves, only to receive a much better reaction than he could have ever hoped for. The words feel foreign in his mouth, probably because they simply aren't his own, but the afternoon is warm, the elm trees offering a pleasant, cool shade, and Frodo sits in the grass at the foot of Bilbo's chair, gazing up at him reverently alongside the dozen other faces, and it feels... right.

He doesn't dare turn around to confirm, but he feels as if Thorin is watching as well – or at least Bilbo hopes he is. He receives an applause even after reading only a handful of paragraphs, and he wants to tell Thorin, you were right. It is a good story, and people are going to love it. See?

 

Fortunately for the more reclusive parts of Bilbo's personality, the cottage is too small to house anyone but him and Frodo overnight – that might not be completely true, but Bilbo has very little desire to make breakfast for anyone but himself and the boy. He feels drained, but it is a pleasant kind of exhaustion, and one by one, he sees his neighbors and friends off, coach after coach, family after family disappearing off up the hill and beyond, like a line of ants. Bilbo and Frodo stand on the veranda, waving everyone off – only Bofur, the Gamgees and Beorn the shepherd remain in the end, helping them clean up the garden, taking the tables and chairs inside, Missus Bell persisting until Bilbo relents and lets her help with the dishes.

But even they find their way home eventually, the barking of the large black dog the very last sound until the cove sinks back into its solitary silence, the sun having almost finished its journey across the sky and below the line of the horizon. The air is cooler now, the breeze refreshing, and Bilbo is in no rush to usher the boy inside – instead, they sit side by side up on the wooden steps leading up to the veranda, Bilbo calm and Frodo fidgeting, tugging at the tall grass and tying it into knots, and it is the most peaceful they've been in all their time here, Bilbo concedes.

“Seems like we've finally managed to convince everyone we don't live in a haunted house,” he announces, ruffling Frodo's hair, and as the boy giggles, Bilbo finally sees him, the figure he's been missing all this time – he suddenly stands down there by the wooden gate, darker than any shadow, his back turned to them, and Bilbo knows he's watching the sea again, though what he really sees, he couldn't venture a guess.

Bilbo cautiously looks from him to Frodo, but the boy really doesn't see him, preoccupied with trying to weave blades of grass into some sort of braid, his face a picture of serene concentration – and in that moment, Bilbo feels such an overwhelming love, for him, for this house, for the sea and the beach, for the echo of a man only he can see.

 

“That was... eventful.”

Frodo has been put to bed, falling asleep easily and soundly, but Bilbo hardly feels like resting himself – no, the night is too nice, too warm, and so he's made himself some tea and returned to the veranda, to gaze at the stars and breathe the fresh air, knowing that he wouldn't end up alone.

“Indeed,” the Captain mumbles, standing close by, and if Bilbo concentrates, he thinks he can see the fireflies flickering in the grass around him, making the garden appear a night sky of its own, Thorin somewhere halfway between disappearing again and staying. At least now, Bilbo knows which one he would prefer.

“Did you ever have company here, aside from...?” Bilbo swallows the ending of that sentence, not entirely sure yet how much of Thorin's past with his family he can bring up around him.

“After she and the boys left, not really,” he replies calmly though, “before that, on occasion.”

“No one from the town, though,” Bilbo observes.

“No.”

“Your crew, then?”

Thorin inhales deeply, shoulders straightening, and turns to look at Bilbo – who expects to meet some distance in his eyes, even some sorrow perhaps, but meets with the softest smile.

“You didn't think I built this house entirely with my own two hands, did you?” the Captain notes, and Bilbo grins.

“No. What were they like?”

“Brave,” Thorin declares somberly, “loyal. Great fans of rum.”

Bilbo giggles into his tea, and catches a bright flash of teeth as the Captain's smile broadens. The night is very warm indeed.

“Where are they now?” he dares ask, and Thorin's face is veiled in darkness yet again.

“Most of them? Same as me.”

“Annoying the tenants in their places of residence by banging on the shelves too early in the morning, you mean?”

That grants him a huffed laugh that tries and fails at not sounding at all amused .

“I don't think so, no. Just... gone.”

“I see,” Bilbo sighs, leaning against the wooden railing, “why do I get the idea that you don't actually know? Would you like me to look into it?”

“That won't be necessary. Don't waste too much time on a dead man's affairs.”

“Excuse me, that's all I've been doing lately,” Bilbo reminds him playfully, but this time, his smile is only a flicker, before his jaw is set with brooding tension again.

“You shouldn't.”

“Why not?” Bilbo inclines his head, fighting the urge to scowl at Thorin teasingly.

“You know what I mean,” the Captain declares, taking to pacing in front of the veranda, entirely silent, not one blade of grass stirring as he moves by, “entertaining guests obviously... agrees with you.”

“...Thank you?” Bilbo squints.

“You should be out there,” Thorin continues, jerking his hand briefly and sharply to point towards... the entirety of the world, in one way or another, before quickly retreating, turning away, his striding becoming more restless. “You are young yet, and well-read, and educated. It should be your goal to share that, to be among people, start – start a family, someplace that's not the very peak of the world...”

“Now you're starting to sound a bit like all my Aunts,” Bilbo snorts, but when he sees that it doesn't move the stone of Thorin's features one bit, he adds more seriously, “when did you decide I needed to get a proper life? Are you telling me to leave you here on your own, and go back to the city, is that it?”

“No, I just-”

“Because as far as I'm concerned, Frodo is all the family I will ever need, you know,” Bilbo counters effortlessly, and when Thorin continues frowning, he adds, “and as for being among people, can you honestly imagine me doing this every night? Goodness gracious, I've had enough of company for a month, at least!”

The Captain laughs almost uneasily, like he's not entirely certain he wants to.

“I just mean-”

“I know what you mean,” Bilbo interrupts him gently, but firmly, “and it's kind of you to worry, it really is. But I'm fine here. I came here for a reason, you know.”

“Frodo.”

“Yes, him, of course. But also...”

Bilbo sighs, clutching the mug in both hands and taking a long gulp before continuing: “Him and I share the grief of losing our parents, though of course to lose them as a child is much worse, I'll admit that. But the point of the matter is... I've found peace here. Ironic, isn't it? Once, I thought I would be able to be happy in London, surrounded by people, like you said, students, fellow scholars, even my numerous meddling family members. But...”

Only then does he truly realize the intensity of Thorin's gaze, and whatever words he'd wanted to say, never make it past his lips. He blushes, looking away, and for a moment, both of them are silent, the crickets taking over with their discordant love songs.

“I wish I had met you while I was still alive.”

Bilbo's heart skips a beat in a shocked gasp, and he looks at Thorin, only to see him staring back, softer around the edges, regret and kindness in equal measures. It steals Bilbo's breath away, utterly and thoroughly, but he still laughs, because he doesn't know what else there is to do, really.

“Right. Because we would have liked each other so much, I'm sure.”

“Not more or less than we like each other now,” Thorin smiles, but there's very little joy in it.

“Well, at least I could slap your hand away every time you tried interfering with my baking,” Bilbo offers lightly, because he really doesn't want to steer this conversation anywhere that isn't their usual teasing.

“And you'd continue doing next to no real damage,” Thorin retorts swiftly enough, but his grin is only a passing thing.

“You could chop firewood for me, instead of just calling me some sailor equivalent of a pansy when I try to do it myself.”

“Oh, I don't think I'd stop doing that anyway.”

“Fair enough. Well, I certainly think you'd never let us stay here if you were able to write that blasted book on your own, now would you.”

Thorin opens his mouth to reply in kind, but it's as if Bilbo has hit some invisible sore spot – his usually stern features twist in some unvoiced pain ever so briefly, but then he decides to overpower that the same way he usually does, by offering a half-hearted smile.

“I wouldn't say never,” he says quietly, and for that, Bilbo doesn't have a sharp response at the ready at all, which is unsettling, to say the least.

Befuddled and slightly concerned, he can do nothing but hold Thorin's gaze, piercing sky blue eyes hiding words that neither of them have ever said out loud; never will.

“I'm sorry,” Bilbo breathes out, and he truly is, for whatever happened to Thorin, for his sister and his nephews, for his crew and his long-lost ship... For himself, for being his only connection to the outside world anymore, for not being enough, never enough.

“No,” Thorin breathes out, more than he says it out loud, and steps closer, not a sound, not his breath, not his footsteps on the pebbles of the path.

“No,” he repeats with such earnest conviction, as if proving Bilbo wrong is the only thing left for him to do, and reaches forth, his hand at Bilbo's cheek – Bilbo's breath catches in his throat, a shudder dancing up his spine, and it's as like the gentle spray of sea foam when one stands by the sea when it's windy; the feather-light caress of breeze after opening a window wide first thing in the morning.

But it will never be any more than that.

“Thank you,” Thorin tells him quietly, and before Bilbo can ask him what for, assure him that he's glad he could help, anything that requires the actual effort of wringing out a couple of words, Thorin performs his vanishing act once more, and only the crickets and fireflies are left to keep Bilbo company.

 

-

 

Dearest Mrs Durin,

 

enclosed you will find the first draft of the first two chapters of the book. My publisher was gracious enough to employ a person willing to print these out for me on some very special thin paper, as you can no doubt see – and yet, I couldn't simply send those in a plain envelope, hence the package. I hope you don't mind, but my nephew implored until I relented, and packed some of my freshest batch of shortbread to go with it. It is very durable, and provided they don't toss the package around too much on the way there, it should arrive in more or less edible condition.

But to address what you talked about in your letter to me – I understand perfectly what you mean about the desire to keep our children safe from the terrors of the world for as long as possible. My nephew lost his parents mere two years ago, and though he is a healthy, happy child, I know that that experience has left a mark on him, one that I will never be able to completely erase, despite my best efforts.

At first, I worried about him immensely, and wouldn't bring up his parents at all, in fear of upsetting him further. But then one day, as I was reading a bedtime story to him, he asked about them himself, shared a fragment of a memory he had of them, and while it touched me deeply, it also made me realize that perhaps it was for the best, talking about it. He's never seen a reason not to – he misses them still, immensely so, but he will not simply stop, if I refuse to mention the issue. I do not mean to pressure you into telling your sons about their Uncle's demise, nor do I presume to know enough about your relationship with them to cast myself in the role of adviser, but I thought I'd share this experience with you nevertheless, just in case it might help. Whatever you decide, I'm sure you will be doing it with your sons' best interest at heart.

In other news, the title of the book eludes me still. The publisher has had some suggestions, of course, but 'A Corsair's Life At Sea' sounds a bit vague, while 'The Adventures Of A Sea Captain' is downright boring. If you have any suggestions at all, don't hesitate to share them. As I find myself nearing the end of this strange undertaking, it is becoming clearer and clearer to me that your brother indeed was a great man – and don't ask me how I can possibly know this (perhaps I am only imagining things yet again), but I do believe that he loved all of you until his dying day, and never stopped hoping that he might one day get the opportunity to tell you that there never had been anything to forgive. The mistake might have been, in your own words, on both sides, but please, do not torture yourself over never granting him your forgiveness, or your apologies, in person. I'm certain he knew.

Don't hesitate to offer your sharpest critique on the excerpt from the book – it is you, after all, who knew him best, and I am attempting but a retelling of his incredible tale. And I do so hope you like the shortbread.

Sincerely yours,

 

Bilbo Baggins

27th of May, Oak Cottage, Dale

 

-

 

It has been almost a year now, a year since they first laid eyes on Oak Cottage, nestled in its little cove, and every day, it shines ever brighter. Bilbo has since learned how to chop firewood, and safeguard a roof against the elements, and tell when a storm is coming simply by the color of the sky and the sea alike... And, somehow, among it all, how to write a book.

It is a strange sort of excitement, unlike anything Bilbo has ever experienced, and Frodo and him make a day of it – get on the train in the morning and ride it to Norwich, only to see it the first batch of volumes bound in deep, royal blue stacked in the window of a bookstore that Mister Bowman the publisher shows them to.

'A Seaman's True Colors', they decided to call it in the end, and Bilbo thinks it's nice – very nice indeed. After arduous arguing, Thorin had agreed upon it one sunny afternoon on the beach, and Bilbo can only wish he were here now, to see this. There is a very meticulous drawing of a ship struggling on a stormy sea on the cover, and Bilbo traces it with his fingertips thoughtfully, the delicate lines, the waves crashing high, and thinks he can almost hear the roar of them, the wood protesting, a man at the deck standing tall and shouting at his crew to keep their ship afloat...

“Hmm, yes, excuse me?”

He's managed to lose track of the conversation quite successfully, and across the table, Mister Bowman is smiling at him somewhat inquisitively, while next to him, Frodo is leafing through his own copy of the book with a reverent caution.

“I asked if you were planning on continuing the story,” the publisher notes, “you yourself said that there were some fact you've yet to discover.”

“Oh... oh. Yes, that's right, I did say that,” Bilbo stammers, “well, um... you see, I don't quite know if I'll ever be able to find out everything. My sources are, after all, limited.”

“Are they?” Mister Bowman smiles mysteriously, and when Bilbo frowns at him, he waves his hand: “Oh, nothing, I meant nothing by it. It's just that... if I didn't know better, I'd think you must have consulted the esteemed Captain himself, at one point or another. It's all so vivid.”

Bilbo's throat dries up very quickly, and he has to take a sip of his tea to remedy it, but he manages to reply effortlessly enough: “No no, just a very active imagination, that's all there is to it, I'm afraid.”

“Well, I'm sure the Captain would enjoy your take on his life story,” the publisher declares, “as will the readers, I assure you.”

“If you say so,” Bilbo takes care to smile a tad shyly.

“Oh, I do say so. I'll send you a telegraph immediately when we have the results of the first sales. This will be a success, I can sense it!”

 

The train carries them back to Dale with the setting of the sun, a whole bag of books richer (as Bilbo has already promised some to his acquaintances in town, as well as one to send all the way to France to Madame Dis), but oddly enough, Bilbo doesn't feel any particular sense of accomplishment, not really. Frodo spends the ride either with his hands pressed against the window, staring out at the countryside passing them in a dash, or reading out passages from the book, and Bilbo is seized by a sudden fear – what if they arrive at the cottage... at home, and Thorin isn't there anymore? What if getting this book published, getting his story out there, will have been what it takes to... to finally put his spirit at rest?

The evening is warm, summer in full power, the sky bleached a periwinkle blue, seagulls keeping them company as they walk the length of the road leading all the way from Dale to their cove, and yet, Bilbo feels a strange, unsettling cold creeping up the back of his neck – Frodo should, for all intents and purposes, be tired from their travels, and yet he skips ahead of Bilbo without a care in the world, fingertips tracing the long grass at the side of the road, and he'd probably run all the way around the cliffs to the cottage if Bilbo let him.

Fishing boats cross the calm sea here and there for an evening hunt, and by the time they've walked all the way around the cliffs and down the beach below Oak Cottage, Frodo even calls his attention to a massive steamboat on the horizon, but close enough for them to recognize the tiny dots of dozens of windows, and the crease it rows in the water like a lace ribbon.

“Did the Captain have a ship like that, Uncle?” Frodo asks, settling down for a moment as they stand side by side by the wooden railing lining the road, slipping his hand into Bilbo's.

“No no, his ship was a frigate,” Bilbo replies quicker than he can really think about it.

“What's a frigate?” his nephew wants to know, following him dutifully forth to the house, though he keeps looking back over his shoulder to check if the steamboat is still there.

“It's a warship,” Bilbo explains, stopping only for a second to consider how easily this knowledge is coming to him, especially since it's something he never would have bothered with a year ago. “They are built for fighting in battles, and are very quick and easy to steer.”

“They have guns?”

Bilbo opens his mouth to respond, but almost swallows his tongue, that's how startled he is by Thorin appearing out of nowhere just a couple of steps away, by the old ruined pier with the initials of his nephews carved into it – no matter how somber he might look, such a wave of relief washes over Bilbo at the sight of him that he barely stops himself from running ahead to say hello.

The Captain turns to him, arms behind his back, the gentlest smile on his face, and up and behind him, the last of the sun's rays set the white walls of Oak Cottage ablaze, the brightest orange, and a grin spreads over Bilbo's face, and he raises his hand in a greeting that his nephew doesn't notice – unlike the lack of his answer.

“Uncle? Did the Captain have guns?”

Thorin's smile softens even more as he gazes at the boy, and Bilbo chuckles.

“Yes, lots of them,” he says at last, Thorin turning to look at him, his eyebrow arching up curiously. “You see, our Captain's ship was very old, and built entirely from wood. She was the fastest one around, and won many, many battles.”

“Wo-ow,” Frodo's mouth forms an awed 'o' – Thorin laughs softly, and it disappears in the cackling of the seagulls overhead.

“But then they started building ships from metal,” Bilbo continues carefully, but Thorin doesn't seem to protest, simply taking to pacing by their side, a little ways off, “and our Captain's frigate was no longer the strongest one.”

“But it was still damn fast,” Thorin grumbles.

“But it was still very fast, yes,” Bilbo chuckles, “and they offered that they would either rebuild it for him, or assign him another ship, and Erebor would be decommissioned.”

“Decommish-” Frodo attempts to repeat the word.

“Decommissioned,” Bilbo says once more, “it means... put out of active use. Not allowed to serve in the Navy anymore, because it would no longer be as quick or as powerful as the rest. But our Captain-” the smile on Thorin's face is right there, always there, even though Bilbo only catches it out of the corner of his eye, “-would have none of it, of course. He said that if they decommissioned his ship, they'd be decommissioning him with it.”

“And... did they?” Frodo breathes out, almost endearingly worried.

“No, no, of course not,” Bilbo smiles, “in fact, no one quite knows what happened to the ship.”

“Not even the Captain?” Frodo asks perfectly innocently, and as he bends down to pick up a particularly interestingly shaped piece of driftwood, Bilbo and Thorin exchange a curious look.

“I haven't,” Thorin answers a question Bilbo never asked.

“Well, if he does, he's not telling me any time soon,” Bilbo answers his nephew cheerily, which seems to appease him for the moment – by his side, Thorin rolls his eyes, but it's all in unnaturally good spirits, at least for him.

They manage to get home eventually, even though Frodo once again attempts to bring half the beach in with him, and Thorin lingers around as Bilbo prepares a late dinner, leaving one book at the kitchen table for him to inspect – the quiet hiss of leaf after leaf turning is somewhat peaceful to his ears, and Thorin doesn't comment beyond the occasional huff that might be indignation or amusement, it's difficult to tell.

“What do you think?” Bilbo asks him when he finds him in the same spot still after having put Frodo to bed and gotten ready for sleep himself, only having come down here to get a glass of water, and instead discovering a ghost reading his own memoir.

“True colors,” Thorin smirks, “I like it.”

“Well, you approved it,” Bilbo chuckles.

Silence reigns for a moment, pierced only by the distant call of a bird Bilbo can't recognize, until the book on the table shuffles shut, and Thorin gazes at him calmly.

“Thank you,” he says simply, and Bilbo inclines his head.

“You're... welcome. For?”

“This,” he gestures to the book, “telling my story.”

“Well,” Bilbo smiles at him just the slightest bit wryly, moving to sit at the table, “someone ought to. It is a good story. And you were the one who told it, really.”

“You know what I mean.”

“I do. And you're welcome. It was my pleasure.”

Those words aren't said exactly lightly, though Bilbo can barely discern why – outside, the crescent moon reflects in the surface of the sea, a thousand brilliant speckles of pure silver, and Bilbo can't look away. He exhales raggedly, and it's as if it rattles his whole body – that ill feeling from that evening hasn't quite left him yet, and there's no telling where it even came from.

“What is it?”

Thorin stands by his side, gazing in the same direction as he is, silent, breathless, cold, translucent like the moonlight. Bilbo remembers the other night, the fireflies and the touch he never felt, and he hangs his head.

“I thought you were going to – that you wouldn't be here anymore.”

He doesn't look, but knows that Thorin is frowning.

“Why wouldn't I be here?”

“Because... because perhaps finally finishing this book, getting your story out there, was what you wanted, and that it would... put your soul to rest. That sounds awful. I'm sorry.”

The silence continues to be near unbearable for a moment, but then, to Bilbo's surprise, Thorin laughs, quietly but earnestly, genuinely amused.

“Is mine the first sailor story you've ever been told?” he notes, and when Bilbo does look up at him, frowning slightly instead of an answer, his smile only broadens.

“A seaman's soul is never at rest,” he declares quite plainly, “that's why we're buried at sea, because we never want to part from it.”

“Were you?” Bilbo peeps.

“No. But that's not why I linger here.”

“No?”

“No,” the Captain shakes his head, still looking dead ahead, “I sat down in my armchair one night, and the next time I got up from it, I didn't have a body. That's all I remember.”

“So you... don't know where you're buried?” Bilbo asks, his eyes glued to the painting of the ship on the cover of the book – the glow of the moon is making the waves appear almost alive.

“I don't.”

“But – why didn't you tell me?!”

“Why would I? I wanted the story to be about my life, didn't I,” Thorin shrugs, and that smile is too soft, too resigned – it tugs at Bilbo's heartstrings.

“What about this story?” he murmurs quietly.

“What about it?” Thorin smirks, and Bilbo thinks, I am a man in his nightshirt at the edge of the world, sitting at a kitchen table with a ghost. Who's going to write about this, one day?

“I don't want to be the only one who... knows about you,” he replies unsteadily, “you don't deserve that, now do you.”

“Bilbo-” Thorin starts, and he can hear the nonexistent breath catching in his throat.

“You deserve to see your sister again,” he says firmly, “and your nephews. And you deserve people to know that it was you telling your story, and that you're still – still here, still watching, still listening, still feeling-”

“And what good would that do anyone?!” Thorin interrupts him rather sharply, and when Bilbo looks up at him with wide eyes, his glare softens somewhat, as does his voice, “I'm long gone, Bilbo. I'm not the man you wrote a book about. I'm not here-”

“We had this conversation before,” Bilbo is now strangely determined to jump in, “remember? I can see you, so you're real. I can talk to you, so you're real. I can feel for you, so you're real.”

His voice wavers here and there, but the words come out of him in one uncontrollable stream anyway, and Thorin stares at him, such a likeness of his painting, eyes blazing, angry and stern, and Bilbo thinks he's magnificent.

“I do wish we'd met years ago,” he says at last, and it's as if he's accusing Bilbo of somehow not making that happen.

“You said that before, too,” Bilbo fights right back.

“Well, it is true!”

“Well, you would have hated me! And I you.”

“Stubborn man.”

“Obstinate sprite.”

“...I'm sure you would have gotten seasick within the blink of an eye if I took you on my ship.”

“Who said I would ever set foot on your blasted ship? I'd bet good money I'd never teach you how to bake without burning things.”

“Oh, what a valuable skill to possess at sea, yes. I'd just let you plant your herbs while I was away, that would be for the best.”

“Yes, it would, because I'd finally get a moment of peace, without your constant hovering!”

And so on, and so forth. Outside, the moon climbs higher up the dark sky, flooding the entire cove in a pale, cold light, and maybe, if one listens closely, it's there in the murmur of the waves and the swaying of the tall dried grass, written in the patterns of seaweed and pebbles in the sand – the words neither of them will ever say, the words they will only ever get close to, but resort to arguing before they can truly mean anything they let out of their mouths. The story of a man who wrote a book, and the man who told him how to do it. The story of a man who moved closer to the sea, even though he'd never been there before in his life, and the man who'd spent his entire life sailing it, but could never return there again. The story of a man alive, and a man long gone, who'd missed each other only by a handful of years – the story of the ghost, and Mister Baggins. The story that, for all intents and purposes, might only be at its very beginning.

 

Notes:

Oh man okay here we go! Only three chapters to go, and this one ends on such a... well, final note, mostly because of where the next one will find Thorin and Bilbo. You'll see :D Hope you all enjoyed it, your feedback has been absolutely amazing and encouraging! :')