Chapter Text
CHAPTER ONE
THORIN
Some time passed before the Green Lady came again to Thorin’s forge.
After many hours of delicate work, Thorin had finished his mithril circlet, its broad oak leaves entwined with lily-of-the-valley and subtle clusters of seed-pearls. He was proud of his creation -- even if a few of the smaller branches had been shaped a little clumsily -- but was quite at a loss as to what to do with it. He thought perhaps to make a gift of it to Freís or his grandmother, and so set it aside and gave it not much more thought.
A far more practical shirt of sturdy iron rings was his next project, but he had not been working on it long before the Lady Yavanna appeared again on his threshold, this time alone.
Thorin bowed his head, uncomfortably aware that his hair and beard were in sweaty disarray from his labours, but she seemed not to notice or care, for she drifted into the room before he could say a word of greeting.
“Has something happened, my lady?” he asked, for he could think of no other explanation for her presence.
“What a suspicious heart you have.” She made a leisurely turn about the forge, green vines curling around her toes, but her eyes never left him. There was a look about her that Thorin did not like -- cool and evaluating, with something akin to cunning. “You asked me of the fate of a hobbit. I bear you news of him.”
A nauseous certainty suffused his belly, pain swift on its heels. “He has died.”
“No,” she said. “But he ought to have. Bilbo Baggins has lived a long life, and his years are spent. I am trying to call him home to my Pastures, but something is holding him back, and he cannot be called.”
Thorin did not know how he should feel. There was relief that the hobbit still lived, but Yavanna’s solemn look filled him with trepidation. “I do not understand.”
“To live beyond one’s years is no blessing. It is a dark and unnatural thing.”
Thorin caught his breath. Dís had come to them bearing ill news of the magic ring that their burglar had found deep in the Misty Mountains. There had been tales too of the young Baggins who had borne that ring to Mordor at a great cost. The Company had gathered many nights in Durin’s Keep to hear sobering stories about darkening forests and hordes of Urûk-Hai and devastating, bloody battles among Men. Thorin had shuddered to think that something so vile had been in Bilbo’s pocket all along. “I was told that the great war was won."
“That is true. But wickedness leaves its own mark.”
Suspecting he would get nothing more than airy evasions, he did not press further. There was something more important at hand. “What will happen to the hobbit if he cannot be called?”
“It is a fate you would not wish upon your greatest enemy,” she replied, and Thorin’s heart splintered with ice.
“What can be done?” he cried, forgetting himself in his anguish. “What can be done to help him?”
Yavanna drifted away to settle herself onto one of the benches set against the wall, her robes curling around the stone like crawling stalks. “I will tell you a tale, Thorin Oakenshield. In the ancient times when hobbits wandered freely across Middle-earth, there lived a hobbit lass, Erda, and her mate Erágol. They lived happily together in a village of Men, blessed with a fruitful garden and many fauntlings to play at their feet. One fell winter, Erágol sickened. No healer could help him, though Erda made many offerings and wept many tears.
“Eru Ilúvatar, high above in his Timeless Halls and concerned with the many wars and griefs on Arda, took no notice of one ailing little hobbit. It seemed that all hope was lost. But Erda loved Erágol so dearly that she left her home and travelled across Varda’s starry path to Ilúvatar himself to beg for his favour, to ask him to heal her mate so that they might not be parted so soon.”
“Was her favour granted?” Thorin asked, when Yavanna seemed content to say no more.
“There are many endings to the tale. In some, Ilúvatar is touched by Erda's steadfast heart and restores Erágol’s health. In some, she becomes lost and dies in the stars before she reaches Ilúvatar’s Halls, and Erágol soon follows her to the Pastures out of sorrow. In some, she is turned away and returns home to find that Erágol has perished in her absence.”
Thorin stood silent for several moments. “Which is the true ending?”
“None of them,” Yavanna said, “and all of them. It is only a story.”
“If I were to ask -- if I were to go beyond these Halls ---”
“I cannot lead you from the Halls, for you are no child of mine. Only your Maker can say who is allowed in and out of his hold.”
“I have never heard of a dwarf leaving,” Thorin said. He could not understand what she wanted him to do and was growing frustrated. “Here we wait until we are called to rebuild Arda. I cannot ask.”
“Did your Maker not craft the Seven Fathers out of love, though he had not the permission of Eru Ilúvatar, Father of All?”
Her words were honeyed, but there was terrible strength beneath them; it took Thorin some effort not to flinch from her. Her braids seemed to move of their own power, flowering even as he watched, and her lovely face shimmered and shifted like pond-water -- so very unlike the people of stone, who were as reliable and slow to change as bedrock. She intimidated him in a way that Mahal could not.
She caught his gaze, and her eyes flickered. “Do I frighten you, son of Thráin?”
“Yes.”
His answer seemed to please her. “Then your honesty can be stronger than your pride. I leave you with this: remember that you seek to correct one last misdeed of Sauron.”
“My lady?”
“You do know, do you not, that Sauron was once a faithful Maia of my lord husband's house?”
Thorin bit back an oath. “I . . . I did not.”
“The march of time brings curious turns." Her voice was heavy with old regret. “Ply your tongue wisely.”
“I understand." Yavanna rose and made as if to leave. “A moment, my lady,” Thorin said, and he fetched his new circlet, offering it to her with a bow. “I would give this to you as a token of my gratitude.”
Yavanna did not smile, nor thank him, but she accepted the circlet with careful hands and set it atop her swaying coils of hair.
“I wish you well, Thorin Oakenshield,” she said, and she left as abruptly as she had come.
*************************
The Great Feasting Hall sat squarely in the center of the keeps. It was a cavernous room with silk banners and a dozen blazing hearths, crowded with banquet tables hewn of the most beautiful polished mahogany. There was always food and good drink, and the fires never burned low.
Thorin had not rested well, the Lady’s words spinning round and round in his mind, but hunger eventually drew him from his lonely bed to the Hall.
“Uncle!” Fíli waved his hand, flanked by his brother and Dáin. He reached out to tug the sleeve of Thorin’s tunic when he drew close enough. “Sit with us and hear about the battle for Dale.”
“Does it improve after a hundred retellings?” Thorin asked, and Dáin bellowed out a good-natured laugh.
“Jealous, Cousin? You'd have liked to have been there, I know. At least I can say I cut through more than a few of their ugly black hearts before they got me.”
“I would have taken my bow to them,” Kíli said, not for the first time.
And not for the first time, Dáin cuffed his ears fondly. “Ha! And I would’ve liked to see you try, laddie. The Urûk-Hai are nasty bastards, and it takes more than your wee little stick and twigs to slay their like!”
Fili snickered into his tankard. His brother turned back to his plate, scowling, before dealing him a brutish punch to the thigh. While Fíli and Kíli squabbled, Dáin turned his keen eyes to Thorin. “You’re scheming, Cousin."
“Have you been in the mead this morning already?” Thorin snapped.
“Aye, and now I know you’ve a secret. What are you plotting?”
Thorin made a noise of disgust low in his throat and moved on, choosing a seat at his grandfather’s side. Thrór was repairing one of Frerin’s beard-clasps and scolding him for being careless all the while. Frerin seemed to be listening with only half an ear, more interested in the cakes he was stuffing into his maw.
Between Fili, Kíli, and his brother, Thorin sometimes wondered whether his father ever despaired for the line of Durin.
“Good morning, Thorin,” his mother said, watching Frerin from the corner of her eye with something like resignation. Thrór grunted his own greeting, attention mostly fixed on his tools and the delicate hinge-work.
Thorin tapped his mother’s forehead and put together a plate, though he had no real appetite. The Hall grew loud and merry as dwarrows spilled in from the keeps; Thráin soon arrived and kissed his wife fondly before sitting down with a mug of dark ale and an old book. Thorin ate what he could bear and listened to the arguments and laughter around him until a small commotion caught his ear.
Mahal had arrived, talking at the table of the Broadbeams. Thorin felt his chest constrict with dread and then reprimanded himself for being surprised. The Lord of the Halls frequently visited the Feasting Hall, mingling freely among them. Why should this day be any different?
“Thorin,” Frerin whispered into his ear. “Brother, what it is? You look as though you’ve been run through.” His hand curled into Thorin's sweating palm, pressing worriedly.
Thorin could not answer. He watched intently as Mahal finished his conversation with a Broadbeam elder, laughing jovially, and made his way to the table of the Longbeards. He took a seat at its other end, shaking the whole length of the bench as he did so, and began to speak with Queen Dinrís. The Vala seemed to feel the weight of Thorin’s gaze then, for he lifted his head to look down the table. “You have something to say to me, son of Thráin,” he boomed, and all eyes turned to them.
This was not at all how Thorin had intended to make his request. His jaw clenched tight, words trapped behind his tongue.
“Say it now, child," Mahal called, brimming with good cheer. "I have no patience for faintheartedness.”
“Thorin,” his grandfather murmured. “Do not keep him waiting.”
“Brother?”
Thorin took a measured breath. He thought of Bilbo, white with shock, his small hands scrabbling against Thorin’s fist around his throat. He thought of the halfling’s joy in Beorn’s gardens, his smiling face lifted to the sunlight. He thought of his tears, the kindness of his farewell as he clasped Thorin’s hand and wept in the sickroom tent.
For Bilbo. “I ask your permission to leave the Halls."
Mahal roared and slapped his massive palm against the table -- it shuddered mightily under his hand, jostling dishes and upending goblets, and Thrór’s face drained of colour. All noise in the great banquet hall seemed to cease at once. “What is this madness? Leave?”
“I must make a journey to help a friend, if I am able.” He remembered the Green Lady’s words and steeled himself. “A friend who has fallen ill of the foul deeds of Sauron.”
A great and awful stillness seemed to take the room then. Not a sound was uttered, not a dwarf so much as shuffled his feet. Mahal sat stiff and silent, and in his blazing face was a wealth of ancient pain. “You dare,” he breathed.
“I beg your indulgence to go to my friend.” Thorin briefly met his mother’s wide eyes before turning back to his Maker. “For the sake of the love you bear your children, I beg you.”
For what seemed like an eternity, Mahal said not a word. Thorin met his glare as well as he could and tried not to tremble, though Frerin’s fingers shook around his.
“Never has a dwarf asked to leave my Halls,” Mahal said lowly. His face was as hard and bright as diamond. “Have your journey, Thorin Oakenshield, and travel where you like. But know this: if you linger seven days in any realm of Aman, there you will stay, and never return to your kin in my Halls.”
Thorin heard his father gasp, and Frerin’s hand tightened like a vise. Mahal rose to his feet as though the movement pained him and stormed from the Hall. The hearths spit up great, angry tongues of orange flame in his wake before easing back into their crackling calm, leaving the air thick with smoke.
In the tense silence, Dáin’s voice floated down the length of the table, sounding a little faint. “Well, then. Well. I suppose I was right, wasn’t I?”
******************************************
Word spread quickly through the keeps. It was not a great surprise that Balin came to Thorin’s chambers that evening with Fíli and Kíli, Ori, Bofur, Óin, and Bifur in tow, all of their old Company that dwelled in the Halls.
Bifur had been the first to follow Thorin and his sister-sons to their ancestors’ halls; a fever had taken him not six months after Dáin ascended the throne of Erebor. For quite some time afterwards, no one from the Company had come, until Bofur arrived after what had apparently been a chance cave-in deep in the diamond mines of the mountain. And what a blow it had been to see Balin and Óin and Ori appear, shaken and telling tales of horrific beasts in the depths of Khazad-Dûm.
“Well, laddie,” Balin said, when Thorin opened his door to find them there, “seems you’ve gotten yourself in a spot of trouble.”
Thorin grumbled a little but ushered them inside.
Never before had he weathered such an unpleasant day in Durin’s Keep. His mother had held him, tense and speechless, and then shut herself away in her workshop. Thrór’s furious reprimands had echoed off the stone walls for hours, and Thráin had been in tears as he’d pleaded with Thorin to go to Mahal and take back his words. Thorin had borne it all as stoically as he could and slunk away to his chambers when he could endure it no longer.
Bofur helped himself to a decanter of mead and began pouring out goblets and passing them around, and they settled at the table to hear Thorin’s tale. Thorin kept no details to himself, trusting that they might be able to suss out subtleties that had passed him by. Kíli and Fíli were as wide-eyed and entranced as dwarflings at his descriptions of the Green Lady, while Ori looked as though he were itching for a pen and ink to record the story of Erda and Erágol. They all of them cried out in alarm to hear of Bilbo’s plight and pestered Thorin with so many inquiries that he soon lost his temper.
“Durin’s bones, I do not know,” he shouted. “I don’t know why she came, nor where to go to help. She told me nothing but that hobbit tale and hinted that I should leave the Halls.”
Bofur whistled under his breath. “Not a terribly helpful lass, is she?” Bifur elbowed him in his side, looking deeply affronted on the Lady’s behalf.
“Did she mean you to go to Valinor, I wonder?” Balin mused aloud, carding idly through his beard. He had been still through the entire story, his brow creased in deep contemplation. Thorin hoped fervently that his old friend would be able to provide some wisdom when his pondering was done. “Perhaps she means you to seek information on your own. There must be a reason she has chosen not to tell you more herself. Perhaps the elves know something.”
Thorin decided, for his own sake, not to acknowledge the eager light that entered Kíli’s eyes then. “Yes! She might want you to find Bilbo in Valinor, Thorin.”
“Maybe it’s the elves that are doing it,” Óin said darkly. “So many of them in one place would be enough to make anyone ill.”
Kíli grinned. “Have you still got your beard in a tangle about Tauriel being a better healer than you?”
Óin scowled and pretended not to hear.
“What could I do for him in Valinor?” Thorin demanded. “If it is dark magic, I would be of no use to him.”
“There must be a reason she told you, laddie. What does she want from you, I wonder?”
Thorin sighed and rubbed at his temples.
Kíli made a rude noise. “Lady Yavanna wouldn't have told you that story unless you were meant to follow it. We’ll go to Ilúvatar and ask him to save Bilbo.”
Bofur scratched his chin. “That’s all well and good, but how exactly does a body go about finding the Father of All Things?”
There was a brief silence.
“If we went to the elves, we could ask them,” Kíli said.
“If they would be willing to help a dwarf.”
“It’s my understanding that only elves live in Valinor,” Ori ventured. “If they allowed Bilbo to stay there, they must hold him in high esteem. I think they would help us if it meant helping him.”
“You’re forgetting one thing,” Balin said patiently. “No one knows the way to Valinor. We none of us have ever been beyond these Halls. So far as I know, no dwarf ever has."
Thorin turned to look at the scribe. "Ori?"
Ori tugged his short braids nervously. “I’ve done a fair bit of reading, and I don’t think I’ve ever seen real descriptions of Valinor. There’s not a great deal of information out there about anything outside the Halls. Of course there are the old legends, but there's not much detail in them. If there ever were records, we don't have them now.”
Bofur shrugged. “Can’t be that hard to track him down, aye? We’ll just wander about and ask if anybody’s seen any old hobbits lately.”
“We,” Thorin said flatly.
“You didn’t think we would let you leave without us? It’ll be like old times, tramping about to pull our burglar’s arse out of the fire.” Bofur paused and stroked his mustache. “To be fair, it was usually him pulling our arses out of the flames. Canny little things, hobbits.”
“Absolutely not,” Thorin said.
There was an uproar. Fíli and Kíli were on their feet in an instant, and even meek Ori was red in the face with outrage. Thorin had been shouted at quite enough for one day and retreated to the hearth.
“Enough!” Balin said sharply to the others, and he went over to Thorin by the fire. “Surely you expected this. He’s one of ours, and it’s not the nature of dwarrowkind to forget kin.”
Thorin drew in an unsteady breath. “I did not let myself think of him. I could not.” he said roughly, and Balin’s hand came to rest on his elbow. “I must go, Balin. Let me do this for him.”
“No one’s stopping you, laddie. But we are coming with you.”
*******
Frerin ambushed Thorin in his rooms the next morning.
“I would go with you,” he said.
“No.”
“You won’t prevent me going. I spoke to Adad already, and he said it would be good for me.”
“Did he?”
“Not in those exact words . . . oh, don’t look at me like that, Thorin! You all had adventures, and I want my turn. There is no danger in it. I’m dead already -- it’s not as though I can die again.”
Thorin wanted to shake him until his teeth rattled. “Did you not hear Mahal when he said that we could be stranded, banished?”
Frerin gave him an exasperated look, which, under the circumstances, seemed unjust. “I heard. Dís is going to string you from the ceiling by your beard when she finds out, and you might appreciate some support then.”
“I’ll not risk you.”
Frerin’s eyes kindled with familiar temper, and for once there was no shade of mischief in his face. “I choose to go with my brother.”
Thorin wondered, not for the first time, what madness he had begun. “As you will.”
******************
Ori had unearthed a paper (which had, curiously enough, turned up suddenly among his books, though he was certain he had not seen it there before) that told an old fable of a dwarf queen travelling around Aman. There was a brief mention of following an Outer Sea to the shores of the elves. It seemed as good a start as any: they would go west until they reached the sea and hope that Valinor was not difficult to find.
“It’s not as though it’s any more foolhardy than thirteen dwarrows and a hobbit crossing Middle-earth to confront a dragon,” Balin said dryly.
Thorin had to concede that this was true, though he did not have to like it.
No one else seemed to share their trepidation, seeing it either as a necessary evil or a fine adventure. Fíli and Kíli were nearly as eager as Frerin, though their excitement was tempered by the greatest obstacle of all that yet lay ahead: their mother.
“No.” Dís’s face was like stone, and she did not even look up from her hammer. “No. I forbid it.”
Kíli bristled, but Fíli, always the more intuitive of the two, spoke with sympathy. “Bilbo is kin, Amad. For honour’s sake, you cannot ask us to do nothing.”
It was not easy to see the unguarded anguish that flickered in Dís’s blue eyes before they hardened. She dropped her hammer down to the anvil and swung around to confront Thorin, who stood quietly by the bellows. “I am coming as well.”
“Sister . . . “
“No.” She marched toward him until their noses nearly brushed, her expression fierce; Thorin saw a sudden flash of little Dís at the training ring, competing against dwarrows twice her size, fearless and grinning like a wolf. “You listen to me,” she said dangerously. “I will not stay behind again, do you hear me? Not. Again.”
He did the only thing he could and ceded to the will of one who had always been stronger than himself.
It took more time and many more arguments for them to find provisions for their company of ten. It might have been more, for when he learned that his wife and sons were to go, Víli wanted to come as well. “Víli will stay to look after Amad and Adad,” Dís had said simply when Thorin had asked whether their number would be eleven. Thorin had no doubt that a loud and passionate quarrel had preceded that decision, but Víli was a wiser dwarf than he. It gave Thorin some comfort too that their parents would not be left deserted by their children.
They made as many preparations as they could, though Thorin could see that it irked Balin, with his orderly mind, to be left floundering with no clear notion of what to prepare for. The lands beyond the gates of the Halls were more a mystery than the trek across Middle-earth had ever been, but they did their best. Foods that would not rot and could be carried easily were efficiently gathered and packed. It was not as though they could actually starve to death, but like sleep, eating was a comfort and none of them were eager to find out what would happen if they went entirely without.
It was impossible to know whether they faced any real danger beyond the Halls either, but any dwarf worth their beard was never unprepared for combat. Dís strapped her war-axes across her back and wore Víli’s favourite dagger at her waist. Kíli brought his bow and Fíli his knives, and Frerin had slung over his shoulder one of Thrór’s spears (which Thorin strongly suspected he had acquired without their grandfather’s knowledge.) Thorin longed for the steadying weight of Orcrist in his hand, but he had had time enough in the Halls to craft many weapons, and he chose a new blade, strong and well-balanced. The rest of the Company bore their share of weapons, and Bofur, with an insouciant wink, brought his fiddle.
At last they were packed and ready. It seemed that hundreds of dwarrows had gathered in doorways and balconies, muttering and staring, a few of them waving or softly calling out blessings as the Company filed down the long foyer to the front gates. Thorin thought he saw his grandfather in the crowd, but he could not be certain. At the end of the hall stood Mahal, and at his side was Yavanna.
As Thorin neared, nine dwarrows trailing behind him, Mahal’s face might have been amusing to behold if it had not also been so frightening. His cheeks were near to purple with rage, but his wife’s willowy hand on his arm stayed any angry words. He slammed his golden axe upon the floor and the gates were flung wide.
“Go,” he said harshly, “and remember my warnings.”
“A safe journey.” Yavanna caught Thorin’s eye and lifted her hand to the circlet on her brow. “Fair skies go with you, and hasten your steps.”
At his side, Frerin gripped his spear, seemingly torn between excitement and fear, and Thorin felt his own pulse pounding in his throat. Out they stepped, and the gates swung shut behind them.
FRODO
When Frodo arrived at the house of Elrond in Valmar, out of breath from his walk and determined not to be sent away, the elf-lord seemed unsurprised to find a hobbit on his doorstep. “Gandalf said you would not be far behind,” he observed fondly as he drew Frodo inside. “Come. Galadriel will arrive shortly.”
Frodo’s resolve to leave had been tested when he realized that he would have to journey all alone to Valmar, for the City of Bells was some distance inland from the Bay of Eldamar, where their little cottage sat. He had visited the gleaming golden city with its tall silver arches often enough, but the roads of Aman were strange and frightening, for all that they were perfectly safe. Just as time passed strangely in Valinor, distances too seemed unreal and unearthly -- Frodo could walk for what seemed like hours in the woods, only to realize that he had scarcely gone a stone’s throw from the cottage, and what ought to have been a few days’ travel from the bay to the city felt as though it took no more than a half-hour. It was deeply unsettling.
But Frodo, his mind resolved, would not be deterred. He saw that Bilbo was comfortable in his chair, packed a modest elevenses in his knapsack, and went off to Valmar.
The sandy gravel paths of the bay gradually gave way to wide, golden fields of wheat-grass and sunflowers, not a single tree in sight for miles. The day was mild, with a pleasant warm wind, but Frodo did not tarry. He had spent the whole of the night in deep contemplation and now found himself dwelling on a tale Legolas had told the Fellowship one frigid day in the mountains. The winds had been so bitter, and their bodies so frozen and exhausted, that Aragorn had acknowledged that they could go no further that day. They’d taken what meagre shelter they could, huddling together under a rock outcropping. Merry and Pippin had tucked Frodo snugly between them, and to distract them all from their misery, Legolas had told them the story of Ainulindalë.
“Long ago, when there was nothing, Eru Ilúvatar brought to being Eä, the great universe, and called forth his Ainur, for he wished to create a beautiful world for his Children.” Legolas’s voice had taken on a slight chanting quality as he told a tale he had no doubt told many times before. “And so the fourteen blessed Ainur sang the Ainulindalë, the song of creation, and Arda was brought to being. Manwë swept Arda’s lands with wind to breathe, and Ulmo filled the seas; Aulë carved the rock and crafted the sun for Manwë to hang high. Varda walked across the sky, her footprints glittering stars, and Vairë wove them into constellations. Yavanna covered the stones with trees and grass and good growing things, and Oromë guarded the animals of the forest with his watchful eye. Nienna wept to see such beauty and watered her sister’s green lands until they burst with fruit and flowers; Vána touched them so that they might bloom, ever-young, with the changing seasons. Lórien and Estë wandered these gardens, and gathered to them visions of what they had seen, so that Ilúvatar’s Children might dream of beautiful things. Mandos lowered the sun and lifted high the moon, that the Children would be able to mark the passing of their days. Nessa danced with joy on the new grass so that those days might always be filled with laughter and good things. Eru was well-pleased with their song, and brought forth his Children, the Elves and Men of old, to settle Arda.” A sly little smile had curled his mouth then, and his pale eyes had flickered over to Gimli, who sat in uncharacteristically respectful silence. “And so too came the Dwarf Fathers, crafted and brought forth by the impatience of Aulë and adopted as his own by gracious Eru Ilúvatar.”
Gimli had scoffed then, breaking the spell that the elf’s words had wrought over their company, but Frodo had thought it a lovely story.
Hobbits did not often tell tales of the Valar with the exception of Yavanna, whom they honoured at each harvest with a full week of song and dance and feasting. They cherished the Green Lady even though she was not their Maker, and Frodo had always liked hearing of her deeds, but hobbits did not seek the wisdom of the Valar like the elves, or pray to them as Men did. Perhaps hobbits had when Arda was young, but such knowledge had been lost long ago; if they worshipped anything at all, it was the green earth that was so generous to them. Indeed, before Frodo had sailed West, the Valar had been little more than figures of storybooks to him.
In Valinor, the proof of their presence was all around him. With Legolas’s words fresh in his mind, Frodo was eager to share the half-formed plan that had sprouted from them. “I had a thought,” he ventured, as he and Elrond went up to the roof-terrace. “I’ve heard many tales of the Ainur here in Valinor. Would they help us, if we brought Bilbo to them?”
Elrond seemed to hesitate. “It was our immediate thought as well,” he admitted. “The Valar have their own limitations, mighty as they are. Melkor was once the most powerful of all the Ainur before he betrayed Ilúvatar and took the name of Morgoth. It is his perfidy that strengthened Sauron’s Ring. We do not know whether even the chiefest among the Ainur could undo Morgoth’s work. In truth, I do not know that anyone short of The One himself could do it.”
Frodo felt as though something had settled in his chest. “Then I will go to him.”
Elrond halted right there on the staircase between one step and the next, and for perhaps the first time since Frodo had known him, he looked utterly astonished. “No,” he said sharply, and Frodo shied away. “No one may go to the Timeless Halls. They are beyond Varda’s domain.”
“But----” Frodo began, but he was interrupted by Gandalf’s appearance at the top of the stairs. “Ah, there you are! What took you so long, my lad?"
Were Elrond a lesser elf, Frodo thought he might have rolled his eyes. As it was, he shook his head and guided Frodo up the stairs. “Come and have something to eat while we wait for Mother. She will arrive in her own time.”
Frodo was not so unsettled that the thought of Elrond’s delightful table-spread did not restore some measure of cheer to him. He was a hobbit, after all. They ate a leisurely dinner on the terrace and talked of inconsequential things.
Lady Galadriel arrived as the stars began to rise. She seemed calm and unruffled as she slipped off her silver travelling cloak and joined them at the table, giving no hints as to the news she brought them. She accepted a goblet of mulled wine and kindly asked after Bilbo.
“As well as he can be,” Frodo told her. “When I left him he was determined to go outside and weed the tomato patch.”
Galadriel smiled. “Very like him.” She set down her glass and turned to Gandalf, who stood smoking at the edge of the terrace. “We are not the only ones seeking to save him.”
The wizard looked momentarily bewildered. They shared a long gaze, and then his eyes widened. “Oh, for . . . confounded dwarves!”
Frodo blinked.
“It seems that we are not alone in learning the fate of Bilbo Baggins,” Lady Galadriel said, and Frodo spared a moment to be grateful that someone felt the need to explain. “A number of dwarves have petitioned their Maker to leave the halls of their ancestors so that they might find help for Bilbo. They seek Valinor for aid. ”
“How did you learn of this?” Elrond asked.
Galadriel raised a brow at him in return -- Frodo had not thought her capable of looking so wry. “I dwell in the Gardens of Lord Lórien and Lady Estë. Even the Valar are not immune to the pleasures of gossip. There is no doubt: Thorin Oakenshield and his companions have left Aulë’s Halls.”
“Thorin?” Frodo thought of the mithril shirt glittering, light-as-air, in Bilbo’s hands. “You cannot mean the dwarf king whom Bilbo travelled with?”
“Eru forbid there should be another Thorin Oakenshield,” Gandalf said irritably. “Yes, the very same.”
Lady Galadriel put a staying hand on his arm and looked solemn. “As I walked in the Gardens of Lórien, I tread a path of dreams, thinking of their quest, and had a vision. The dwarves shall not succeed. They will linger too long in the Realm of the Firedrakes, and there they will be chained in flame until the world is remade.”
Gandalf made a sound of annoyance.
“Oh dear," Frodo cried. "What can be done? We can’t leave them there.”
“Of course not,” the wizard said crossly. “It is clear to me that Thorin will lead them in circles unless someone intervenes. When we reach them, Frodo, remind me to extract a promise from Thorin that he shall never again attempt to lead anyone on a journey farther than the hall to the dining table, and even then I would strongly suggest someone provide him with a map.”
Lady Galadriel turned away, but not before Frodo saw the edge of her smile. Elrond, however, was not amused.
“Mithrandir, you cannot mean . . . .”
“Yes, I can,” Gandalf said stoutly, “and I do.”
“Mother,” Elrond sounded almost plaintive, “surely you do not agree with this.”
“We are but Eldar and cannot see the true workings of Eä. If Aulë has let his children go, he knows of something that we do not, and cannot, understand. You must have faith.” She touched Frodo's cheek with her soft hand. “For now the matter of Bilbo's fate must be addressed, and soon. Frodo, will you go with me to the Gardens? I believe that if we ask, Lord Lórien and Lady Estë will allow you to walk a path of dreams, and we may find some answers there.”
Frodo looked from Gandalf’s expectant face to Elrond’s concerned one and managed a small smile for the Lady of Lórien. “I will go.”
******
It was with an anxious heart that Frodo returned to their cottage the next evening. He wandered for a while in the front garden, unable to settle his mind. He had never enjoyed deceiving Bilbo, but he knew that this time he could not burden him with the truth. His uncle would never let him go if he knew it.
Inside, Frodo found Bilbo at the table reading through his papers, and he spoke happily of his visit to Valmar while they took tea. “Galadriel has invited me to come to the Gardens of Lórien, Uncle,” he concluded, taking care to keep his tone light and cheerful. “I’ll go tomorrow, and Elrond has said he will stop by to see you while I’m gone and keep you company. I should like to see more of Valinor. I’ll tell you all about it when I return.”
Alas, Bilbo wasn’t fooled for an instant. “What nonsense has Gandalf dragged you into?”
“Nothing.”
“Frodo.” Bilbo grasped his arm, and his grip had not a fraction of its usual strength. “You must promise me that you won’t do anything foolish. I have lived my life, but you have not -- I couldn’t bear it if anything else were to happen to you. Do you hear me? Give me your promise.”
“I promise." It felt as though the lie would burn his tongue.
"Good lad," Bilbo said, and there they sat quietly until the candles sputtered low. After Frodo helped his uncle to bed, he stood at the bedroom window, remembering nights long past when he was tucked between toasty covers and told fantastical stories. He sighed and turned to leave, but at the threshold he could not help but look back once more at the frail figure huddled under the coverlet, already asleep.
They left at dawn the next morning. Frodo slipped from the cottage before the sun rose, and he and Gandalf retread the main road to meet Lady Galadriel on the outskirts of Valmar. Gandalf hummed as they walked, his earlier vexation seemingly forgotten. “Well, well . . . this shall be amusing indeed, Frodo. I had not thought I would see Thorin Oakenshield again.” He produced a pouch from one of his many pockets and tamped fresh leaves into the bowl of his pipe. “Though I suppose if any dwarf were to stir up trouble by leaving Aulë’s Halls, it would be him.”
Frodo, whose thoughts kept turning back guiltily to their cottage and its lonely occupant, latched eagerly onto the offered distraction. “What are Aulë’s Halls like? I suppose Gimli will go there one day. Do the dwarves never leave?”
“To my knowledge, they never have. Each of the Valar govern their lands differently. Aulë prefers to keep his children close to him. You know how dwarves are, my boy -- always suspicious of outsiders.” He paused. “Or perhaps you don’t. Gimli is a rather strange dwarf in that regard, and you haven’t met many others.”
“Have you been there?”
“Once or twice a very long time ago. The Istari go where they choose, for the most part. I have rambled about as much as the others beyond Valinor.”
“And what is beyond Valinor?”
“Many things.” He tapped the stem of his pipe against his lips. “Beyond Valinor is the rest of Aman, the resting grounds of the races of mortals and beasts, where they wait until the remaking of the world. There are many realms, known by many names, but we Maiar call them the Ever-Lands.” He smiled. “A rather fanciful name.”
A terrible notion came to Frodo then. “Gandalf, Galadriel said the dwarves would be stranded in the land of the Firedrakes -- do not tell me that there are actual dragons there.”
“Of course there are. They are mortal creatures. They must have a place to rest as well.” He puffed at his pipe. “There is a very real danger in traveling through the Ever-Lands, Frodo. I will not pretend that there is not, especially for a living soul. You have traveled far and braved more dangers than any one can reasonably be asked to bear. You need not feel as though you must take this journey too.”
“I’m not afraid of death.” How could he be, after spending so long in the shadow of it? “And I won’t go to the Pastures without Bilbo.”
“If only all creatures had the courage of hobbits,” Gandalf said affectionately. “I will do my best to keep you from the worst of the danger. You have my solemn word.”
“As long as we shan't have to pass through the resting grounds of orcs and goblins.”
“Those twisted creatures are of Melkor’s creation, not Ilúvatar’s. Wherever their resting ground is, it is not in Arda.”
They walked in companionable silence until another question occurred to Frodo. “If Aulë’s Halls are closed to outsiders, how did King Thorin learn about Bilbo?”
“I have my suspicions. Thorin’s request to leave must have caused a great deal of excitement.” His smile took on an edge of mischief, and he chortled happily. “What a commotion! Aulë’s temper is a marvelous thing to behold, Frodo, for it burns as high and hot as his Great Forge. I wish that I could have seen it.”
Frodo’s curiosity was now very much piqued. Bilbo had always spoken of his dwarf friends with the greatest warmth and of their leader with a fond sort of wistfulness that had seemed to discourage Frodo, even as a lad, from asking too much about him. “It was very brave of him. I wonder what made him think to go.”
The wizard blew out a lazy ring of blue smoke. “I haven’t the foggiest notion, and I am keen to find out. Though I suppose love must make fools of us all.”
Frodo stumbled a little. “What did you say?”
Gandalf looked as though he’d sucked some smoke down the wrong way, and he coughed extravagantly, waving a hand before his face. “Gracious. Where does your uncle get this dreadfully potent leaf?”
“I . . . Did you steal Bilbo’s pipeweed?”
“Never you mind,” the wizard said sternly, and he lifted his staff in welcome, his eyes fixed on the road ahead. “Ah, and there is Galadriel! Hurry, Frodo.” And off he went, his white cloak fluttering behind him.
Frodo stared after him and decided that perhaps some things were best left unasked.
With Galadriel at their side, they made excellent time. Before the sun reached its zenith they came upon the outskirts of a breathtakingly tall forest, the land studded with towering beech trees, ashy willows, and scarlet poppies as wide around as Frodo was tall. He peered, awestruck, into the woods as they followed a grassy road into its depths. He was astounded to glimpse windows and doors carved into the thick tree-trunks.
Galadriel saw his look of surprise and laughed lightly. They paused before a high gate of vines and willow branches, and she lifted her golden head and closed her eyes for a moment in bliss. “These are the gardens of Lórien, the Ainur of Dreams and Visions, for whom my home in Lothlórien was named. He steers and guides the paths of those who walk in dreams, and Lady Estë the Healer soothes night-terrors and brings sweet thoughts to grieving souls.” She raised a hand to stroke the trellised gates, and branches seemed to curl in on themselves, parting to reveal the entranceway. “Estë asked Lady Yavanna to plant these gardens as a gift to her husband so that she and Lórien might walk these paths together, tending the dreams of those who dwell in Arda.”
The gates were fully open now, and Frodo could see that the road continued deeper into the trees. They had not taken more than three steps inside, however, before two figures appeared before them, seemingly from the air itself. Galadriel and Gandalf knelt, and Frodo hastened to his knees, though he was unable to lower his eyes from the magnificent sight before him.
The Valar seemed more shadows than beings, their bodies composed of something almost like dust motes, if that dust were made of stars; their glittering faces were near to transparent, though none the less beautiful for it. They pulsed and glowed with warm amber light and seemed to ripple formlessly in the wind as they drew closer.
“Ringbearer,” said one of them -- Frodo did not know whether it was Lord Lórien or Lady Estë, for they looked perfectly alike with their colourless long hair and their swirling, wispy robes. “We welcome you to walk the paths.”
Gandalf’s staff nudged Frodo gently in the back. He startled, and realized that he had been gawping silently at them. “I . . . thank you.” He knew he was blushing, and in his mind he felt a warm flicker of amusement not his own.
“Come,” the other Vala said, extending an upturned palm. “May you dream of pleasant things.”
Frodo looked behind him; Gandalf smiled and Galadriel made a graceful shooing motion, her ageless eyes soft. Smoothing nervous hands over his waistcoat, Frodo breathed deep of the sweet air and followed Lórien and Estë into the trees.
************************
He walked with Sam down the lane, and with each step they took, Sam seemed to grow older, his steps slower, his hair whiter, until at last Frodo turned to look at him and there was no one there beside him.
He was in his uncle’s parlour in Bag End. The lamps were dimly lit, and Frodo followed the sound of muffled weeping to the kitchen.
On the table there lay the body of a dwarf, his chest unmoving. His black hair, streaked with veins of silver, dripped beads of blood onto the floor. Bilbo sat at the table and wept and wept, and his tears fell into a porcelain teacup, filling slowly until it shattered. Frodo cried out as the water swept Bilbo away.
He dove down, reaching out, only to find the faces of his mother and father before him, their eyes open and peaceful as they drifted with the current. He screamed, and the water filled his throat with salt.
And then he was flying, soaring high above the water atop an eagle, toward a towering silver mountain crowned by white clouds. The wind sang in his ears, and joy lifted him higher and higher, until he thought his heart should burst. Up he flew, over the mountain, over the clouds, until the sky was left behind and all that remained were stars.
Frodo?
“Frodo?”
Frodo blinked, his eyes watering. He was lying on the grass and Gandalf was patting his cheeks briskly. He took one shuddering breath, and then another, and was soon able to sit up gingerly. Galadriel gave him a skin filled with cool water, and greedily he drank it down.
“Can you speak of what you saw?”
He told them, and though Gandalf’s hands tightened on his shoulders when he spoke haltingly of his parents, neither one of them said a word until he had finished.
“I believe Lórien and Estë have granted you a special gift,” Galadriel mused, “for they have shown you your path. In your dream, the Eagles of Manwë bore you to the mountain wreathed in clouds: Mount Taniquetil. It is the highest peak in all of Arda, and home to Lord Manwë.”
Gandalf seemed disturbed, however. “Curious indeed. It seems we are to pay Manwë a visit once we have collected our dwarves.”
Frodo looked to Galadriel and, feeling a little silly, thought, And what of the stars?
Galadriel did not look at him, but her voice was clear and crisp in his mind. Mount Taniquetil is said to touch the realm of Manwë’s wife Varda, Elbereth Gilthoniel, Keeper of the Stars.
And what is beyond them? Frodo pressed. Elrond said Ilúvatar’s Timeless Halls were beyond Varda’s realm.
Galadriel merely smiled.
A resolution was growing in Frodo’s breast, and he knew then what he would do. He would go with the wizard to rescue Uncle’s friends, but when they came to Manwë’s mountain, he would find his own way to reach Ilúvatar, whether Gandalf liked it or not.
Task done, there was no reason to tarry in the Gardens. Galadriel took them to her home, carved into a gigantic birch tree, and plied them with all manner of travelling gifts: water-skins and lembas, blessing-stones and lamps and healing potions and oilcloth cloaks. To Frodo she gave a delicate, thin-bladed dagger in a handsome sheath.
“It is not Sting,” she said, “but it ought to serve you well, should the need arise.” She kissed Frodo’s brow and warmth spread from his head to his toes. “Safe journey, little one, and do what you believe is right.”
Frodo held her blessing close to his heart and thanked her.
He and Gandalf left soon after, Frodo’s knapsack a great deal heavier than it had been when they arrived. They passed rapidly through the woods but at the other side, the wizard came to a sudden halt. “It is not too late for you to turn back. There is no shame in it,” he said kindly.
Frodo shook his head, and on they went. They had not walked far, however, before they were halted again.
“Mithrandir,” called a low voice, and Frodo turned to see an elf moving swiftly up the road toward them. She was beautiful in the ethereal manner of all elves, but to Frodo’s mind she looked nothing like Arwen or Lady Galadriel. She even moved differently, her steps quick and fluid but somehow rougher, with a coiled power beneath every motion. She seemed dangerous in a way that the Fair Folk rarely did. The long knife at the belt of her tunic and the bow strapped to the pack-roll on her shoulder only added to that impression.
Gandalf peered at her for a moment. “Ah! Captain Tauriel, isn’t it?"
She dipped her head and shining red hair flowed over her shoulders. “I am a Captain no longer. Well met, Mithrandir.” Her eyes flitted over to Frodo, cool and evaluating.
“I did not expect to see you here,” Gandalf said mildly. “It was my understanding that the elves of Greenwood chose to remain in Middle-earth for now.”
“I could not return to Greenwood,” she replied in a tone that said quite plainly that she would not elaborate. “Lady Galadriel and Lord Celeborn kindly allowed me to dwell with their kin in Lothlórien, and when they sailed, I sailed as well. I hear that you are to leave Valinor for the Ever-Lands.”
“And who told you that?”
“Lady Galadriel.”
Gandalf mumbled something that sounded suspiciously like ‘of course.’
Tauriel shifted from one foot to another, betraying a smidgen of unease for the first time. “If you allow me, I would accompany you.”
Frodo could only be grateful that Gandalf's piercing gaze was not directed at him. “To what purpose?”
She met his stare unflinchingly. “One that will not interfere with yours.”
He appeared to consider this, combing one hand idly through his smooth white beard. “It would not hurt, I suppose. But it must be Frodo’s decision. This is his quest.”
Frodo shifted, a trifle flustered as two pairs of searching eyes fixed on him expectantly. “Bilbo says one can never have too many friends on the road.” Besides, if Galadriel had sent her, he wasn’t inclined to question her judgment.
The rigid set of Tauriel’s shoulders eased a little. She drew her short sword into her hands and bowed formally, as though to present him with it. “You have my bow and blade to command, Master Hobbit.”
Frodo glanced down at the wicked, curved steel and tried not to wince. “Just Frodo, please.”
Gandalf looked between the two of them for a moment longer before tamping the ground with his staff. “No use standing here and nattering like fools. Let’s be off!”
