Actions

Work Header

And in the Darkness Bind Them

Chapter 3: The Songs of Ulmo

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 


CHAPTER TWO


 


 THORIN


 

“SHOULDN'T WE MAKE CAMP now, Brother?”

Thorin summoned to himself all the patience he possessed (which was, admittedly, not much), and said with deliberate composure, “My answer is what it was ten minutes ago. We might yet make the ridge before the sun sets.”

Frerin huffed and fell back to walk with Kíli and Fíli. Thorin could hear their hushed voices and the occasional poorly-concealed chuckle as they pushed on, but he ignored their twittering and kept his attention fixed on the path ahead of them.

None of them had had the faintest notion of what to expect when the Halls unsealed, but it certainly had not been this. Before the keep stretched a perfectly ordinary stone road, carved into the flats of a perfectly ordinary valley and extending beyond the reach of their sight. It had reminded Thorin of nothing so much as the lazy, rolling pass that stretched between the lush borders of the Shire and the Blue Mountains.

Their party had lingered uncertainly on the marble steps of the Halls, the doors locked tight as a tomb behind them, until Balin had taken up his pack and said with his usual aplomb, “Shall we be off then?”

So began their journey. They followed the road west at a clipping pace, taking only a few short breaks for meals and rest, and camping at night in the shelter of what thin trees stood in the valley. The weather was neither mild nor unpleasant, and while the valley had green grass and vegetation enough, there was not the smallest sign of any bird or beast. Indeed, everything along the road was strangely lifeless.

Frerin and the lads seemed disappointed by the lack of flaming rivers of fire or dwarf-devouring monsters or forests of enchanted trees. Thorin, who had been grimly prepared to fight every step to Valinor, was disconcerted as well. Thus far their journey did not so much resemble a quest as it did one of Bilbo’s absurd little walking holidays.

Thorin had never had a taste for aimless travelling like this. As a dwarfling he had been very fond of tales of daring, and the clamour of battle and the first rush of discovery were still pleasing to him, but he disliked the daily drudgery of life on the road. What lay beyond the horizon did not interest him. One tree or hillside, after all, was much the same as another. He was not made to wander, though he had wandered enough out of sheer need. He preferred the comforts of home, of having one place to belong to, and his Maker's doors closing behind him with such finality had sent a shiver of real horror through his bones.

It was only the thought of the hobbit, weakened and ailing with only elves for company, that bolstered his steps and drove him onward.

The others seemed to feel a similar urgency -- it was their burglar, after all, who was in peril -- and never complained about the pace. Frerin, however, found everything on the road worthy of a second look. He lagged behind constantly and could not seem to understand why Thorin would wish to move quickly.

When the next hill brought them to a thicket of woods, Fíli and Kíli went ahead to scout. From the rear of their little caravan, Dis called out for them to stay close, but Thorin thought privately that it was a futile wish. They had always gone where they chose.

With his preferred walking companions vanished into the underbrush, Frerin returned to Thorin’s side. He paused every other moment to examine a bit of shrubbery or a particularly interesting cloud; after the third time he nearly tripped himself while walking backwards to talk to Balin and Ori, who were following sedately behind them, Thorin finally caught his shoulder.

“Watch your step, you’re clumsy as a newborn mountain goat. And come here, your braid is undone.” Thorin pushed at him until he could reach his brother's five-stranded plait, which was fraying pitifully. “Do you never brush your hair?”

“My comb is back in my chambers, I think. Or in the tanners' shop. Or the library. It’s somewhere.”

“Perhaps that explains Kíli.”

“You can't blame me for that one. I died before he was born.”

Thorin grunted and pulled the smooth, dark locks tight before refastening the heavy silver clasp. The motions were familiar and required no thought at all. How many times, after all, had he been called upon to make his disheveled siblings more presentable before an important court appearance or a banquet? More than he could count, he was certain.

Frerin hummed and reached back to feel the finished braid. “I could devote more time to grooming if we stopped to rest more than once a day. I saw a stream not too far back."

“A waste of time.”

“A half-hour won’t hurt anything."

“Enough.”

Frerin laughed at him. "So serious! Do you hear him, Balin? He sounded a little like Fundin just then, I think."

Thorin felt his hackles rise. "I told you this was no frolic in the woods. You shouldn't have come if that was all you wanted."

"For pity's sake, nothing says I can't help and want a bath. If you were this merry on your last journey, Brother, it's a wonder anyone went with you! I wouldn't have."

“Aye, and I wouldn't have wanted you! I know you’re foolish, but I hadn’t thought you so selfish as well.”

Frerin drew back as though he’d been roundly slapped. He stared at Thorin, his mouth working wordlessly, before he yanked his braid from Thorin’s hands and stomped away up the road.

Ori and Balin’s amiable chattering had ceased. Thorin felt the weight of several eyes on his back, but he steeled himself and pushed wearily on ahead.

Their camp that night was an uneasy one. Thorin found he wasn’t in a mood fit for conversation and kept to himself at the edge of the fire. When he finally managed to fall asleep, his rest was consumed by unpleasant, half-remembered dreams. After a hasty breakfast of watery porridge, they walked on. There were no songs this morning, no poems from Ori nor bawdy ditties from Bofur, and an edge of tension had enveloped their company. Thorin was certain that Mahal’s warning was weighing heavily on them all, for they had been following the path three days and nights already, and still there was no sign of the coast. With each hill they crested to find nothing but more lonely road ahead, their spirits sank lower.

By midday, Fíli, Kíli, Frerin, and Bifur had gone on ahead, hoping to find some definite signs of the shore. Dís, after a time, fell back from where she was walking with Óin and kept pace at Thorin’s side. For some distance they walked in silence, the only sound the soft tinkling of Dís’s earrings.

“You are too harsh on him,” she said abruptly.

“I told him this wasn’t a journey for his own amusement.”

“You know he doesn’t mean anything by it.”

"He is foolish."

"He is young."

“You were scarcely eighty when we came to Ered Luin. You organized the camps and the guard and handled the finances and raised the boys nearly on your own," Thorin said. No amount of hard feelings between them now could erase the deep respect he had for his sister, who had kept the tattered remains of their family together while he had struggled to rebuild a kingdom. “Age means nothing.”

Dís tugged at her marriage braid to unravel a little snarl from the wind. “He hardly set foot out of Erebor before Smaug came. Azanulbizar was his first battle. He didn't have the luxury of the years we had and the things we learned from them.”

“The luxury of never staying more than a year in one place? The luxury of begging at the villages of Men for enough work to feed ourselves?”

“Mahal save me from your ceaseless dramatics! The luxury of living, you insufferable marble-headed, scraggly-mustached . . . .” She stopped and took a deep breath, and in more measured tones said, “Don't punish him because you are afraid.”

“Perhaps you should take your own advice,” he snapped.

It would have been kinder if Dís had leapt at him to tear his beard from his chin. Instead she gave him a look of such cold disappointment that he felt his innards would shrivel from the shame of it.

“I spoke poorly,” he said, when he could bear the silence no longer. He resisted the urge to shuffle his feet. “I will try to be more patient with Frerin, though he must learn to accept how it is on the road. You always coddled him.”

“And you never did.” She dipped her head in reluctant acknowledgement, and for an instant, it almost seemed as though she might smile at him -- but then Fíli and Kíli tumbled from the bushes, shouting excitedly. The warmth ebbed from her eyes, leaving only flint behind, and Thorin told himself that it did not sting.

The company drew together to see what the commotion was all about: Frerin and the boys had found a seashell in a nearby stream, and Kíli proudly held the muddy conch aloft like it was the fabled Fire-Opal of Nelínori.

“The sea can’t be far,” Fíli said eagerly. “We found it close by -- a mile west at most.”

“Well done, my lads,” Dís said, taking the shell in hand to polish with the hem of her overskirt before peering at it like she expected to find fortune-runes written on it.

“Only a mile or so, you say?” Balin asked. When the lads began to bicker over how far exactly it had been, he turned to Thorin. “We should keep on before we lose the light. It’s not a definite sign, but it is better than nothing.”

With the hope that their journey’s end might already be upon them, their steps were lighter. They travelled with purpose, the distance eaten up under determined strides.

Thorin focused on the rhythm of his steps in an attempt to dissipate the sick feeling that had begun spread in the pit of his belly. He had no great fondness for the notion of being among elves yet again, but what he might find in their lands worried him. Yavanna had not told him how Bilbo fared, nor whether a cure could be found. Had he come only to discover that he was helpless? Would Bilbo welcome him? The terms of their parting had been far kinder than he had deserved, but nearly a hundred years had passed since that afternoon on Raven Hill. Perhaps his arrival would only bring the hobbit more distress. Perhaps he had been selfish to think that Bilbo would desire his help, let alone his presence.

These gloomy thoughts were banished, however, as they climbed the next low rise, for beyond it was the sea. Thorin’s stomach lurched.

There on the horizon stretched a flat expanse of yellow-grain sand and jutting cliffs of granite, with no sign of any great glittering elvish city. Indeed, there seemed to be no sign of any life at all, though the road clearly ended here -- no ruins, no docks, not even so much as a speck of a boat far offshore.

Silently the company crossed down to the sandy shore, as if moving closer might, by some spark of magic, reveal a bustling port-city to their eyes, but there was nothing there but water and rock and endless, pale sky.

Thorin stared at the calm water lapping against his boots, and if not for the sake of his pride, he might have kicked at it with a few choice curses. As it was, he steadied himself and turned to face the disappointed faces of his company.

“We’ll make camp here tonight and go on in the morning.”

“Go where?” Óin asked.

“Wherever we need to go,” Balin said reprovingly. “Let’s have a fire now and rest for a bit.”

With only a little grousing, camp was constructed on the highest swell of the sands. Crooked logs of driftwood made for serviceable seats, and the smaller, drier branches burned well. When the sun lowered, the sea-breezes cooled, and they all huddled together gladly by the warmth of their fire.

“‘Tis too still out here,” Bofur mused as they finished up a cold supper of rye bread and cheese. “We’re the only living things ‘round here for miles -- I’d swear by it.”

“Let’s have a story then, so it isn't so quiet,” said Fíli, pausing to muffle a yawn into his brother’s shoulder.

“I have one,” Frerin said, and he stepped away from the pile of driftwood he had been picking through idly for chips suitable for carving. “How would you like a story from the tender years of your Uncle Thorin, hmm? I’m certain it’s one you’ve never heard before.”

Thorin stiffened, pierced with a suspicious dart of dread --  a reaction which apparently escaped no one, if the frankly sly smiles of his sister-sons and Bofur were any great indication.

“Is that so? Do tell, o beloved Uncle,” Kíli said.

Frerin cleared his throat and perched himself with exaggerated dignity next to Óin. “This, beloved sister-sons, is a tale concerning your venerable Uncle Thorin and a Blacklock queen,” he began, and at that moment Thorin deeply regretted his sharp words of the day before.

“On the auspicious occasion of Grandfather’s one-hundredth year of rule, emissaries from all the great dwarfish kingdoms were invited to a summer market to be held in Erebor -- Stiffbeards and Ironfists, Broadbeams and Firebeards and Stonefoots alike. Ah, it was a sight, lads!

“Now, several of the cannier lords brought with them their unmarried sons and daughters, thinking to catch the interest of young Prince Thorin, who had lately turned fifty and would soon be reaching the age for engagement. And so with the diplomats came the marriage-hunters, decked in finery and instructed to woo the eldest prince, for the younger was but a charming, handsome lad of thirty-eight -- though even then he had already broken his fair share of hearts ---” Here, Dís snorted loudly. “Well, unfortunately for them, the Crown Prince was repulsed by their maneuverings. He was scowling and growling and offending all the guests, and Adad was in absolute despair of his manners. But, a week before the market-games were to begin, the delegation of the Blacklocks arrived.

“They were led by their good queen, Oûni, a spirited old dwarrowdam with a beautiful white beard that nearly reached her waist and a right hook worthy of a hundred verses. She and Amad had been great friends in their youth, and for some time they had harboured hopes of a further connection between their two families. With her to Erebor came her granddaughter Princess Nûr, a well-spoken lass with a face even elves would admire. Thorin, with his usual grace, rejected the princess and managed to mortally offend the queen all within a day.

“Now, here is an important bit, lads, so listen closely. Your uncle, at this impressionable age, was extraordinarily fond of poetry.” At this, Balin’s distinctive chuckle drifted over from the other side of the fire, and Thorin felt a cold sweat begin to bead on his upper lip. “Thorin, enamoured of the noble verse and possessed of a fine deep voice and no little talent on his harp, fancied himself something of a troubadour. Indeed, a passionately romantic heart beat in Thorin’s gruff breast, just waiting for a lad or lass to unburden all these instincts of the serenading lover.” The breathless silence was broken by Dís, who honked out a raucous laugh and then hastily wedged her fist into her mouth.

“Thorin had lately been working on love-poems and could think of little else. Every spare moment was spent on composition. I am sorry to say, dear sister-sons, that it reached the point that the sight of Thorin holding his harp was enough to send the rest of us scurrying away on urgent business. Only dear Amad, with the long-suffering heart of a mother, indulgently listened to each of his songs.

“Now, when Thorin realized that he had offended Amad's dear friend (and had received a good thrashing from Amad herself), he was filled with remorse and resolved to make amends to Oûni for his insult. Amad suggested that he memorize a traditional poem of contrition and sing it for her as a gesture of goodwill, but he decided that such a gesture was not enough: indeed, he would present to her a poem of his own invention, to show the depth of his respect.”

Thorin had resolved not to look up from his boots but unfortunately could not also block from his ears the sound of Kíli squeaking in sheer, unbridled glee.

“On the eve of the opening of the market-games, Thorin tuned his harp and sought an audience with Queen Oûni. But alas, under the gimlet eye of the queen, Thorin was struck by a sudden attack of nerves, and quite forgot all the words to the poem about the honour of the Blacklock clan that he had penned for her. In a blind panic, he began to sing the first thing he could think of -- a rather sweeping epic of a passionate and forbidden love. Thankfully, he had not gotten beyond the third verse before Oûni flew up from her chair in a rage.

“‘Impertinent, saucy lad!’ she hollered. ‘Why, I’ll grind your big presumptuous nose into the dirt, if for no other reason than for those dreadful rhymes!’

“In vain did Amad try to convince her friend that he had meant no insult, but the queen was sure that her good name had been besmirched by the young prince's amorous advances. And so to avenge her honour, she challenged Thorin before the entire court to compete against her in the wrestling games, and there, in front of the royal entourage and a goodly portion of the visiting dwarrows, Oûni soundly thrashed the Crown Prince of Erebor.”

There was a dull thud as Bofur toppled from his log. Ori had both mittened hands clasped tightly over his mouth. Dís was not even attempting to hide her laughter, and her sons were nearly bent-double, sobbing on her shoulders. Even Bifur was chortling.

Thorin looked to Balin and was betrayed to find his friend using his beard to dab away merry tears. Surely a king should not be expected to endure this! Drawing what was left of his dignity about him, he rose and walked calmly, if swiftly, away from the camp, howls of laughter chasing him all the way down the shore.

 

***

 

Thorin had not been sulking long before Balin came to find him, still chuckling under his breath. “You do have to admit it makes for a fine story,” he said.  

“Fíli and Kíli will never respect me, if he and Dís have their way,” he grunted.

“Oh, come now, no need for hard feelings,” Balin soothed. “We’ve all had our share of youthful foolishness, the lads especially. They’ll hardly think the worse of you for it.” The smile that appeared then was ripe with mischief. “Besides, we’ll be in need of good stories to keep our spirits up on the road, and I do believe the lads might be equally interested in hearing about wee Frerin’s first visit to Dale, eh?”

Thorin’s lips twitched despite himself, and he covered Balin’s hand with his own, giving it a firm, grateful squeeze.

“There’s a good lad. Now come along and join us. Bofur’s determined to have some music, and we’ve a mind to indulge him. There’s nothing better for easing the sting of disappointment.”

Balin returned to the fire where Bofur was readying his fiddle, and soon the sea-air was filled with stomping, clapping, and the swoops of a lively jig. Thorin lingered for a while longer at the water’s edge, feeling foolish. Do you never laugh at yourself?  Bilbo had asked him once, when Thorin had refused to respond to the wizard's insufferable teasing. You ought to try it sometime -- you may surprise yourself with how amusing you can be.

The jig flowed seamlessly into a miner’s calling-chant, and the chorus of his kin’s laughing voices seemed far away, a melody half-remembered. Drawing his coat closer against the sudden chill, Thorin turned to join them, but a tremor beneath his boots had him quickly twisting around again.

The waves were beginning to churn near the shoreline -- from the dark depths something was rising, great channels of foam sluicing off and spilling into the surf. Before Thorin could call to the others, the water swelled and surged forward; the sound of the fiddle stopped with a loud, discordant screech as a spray of salty white water erupted high into the air.

“Fall back!” Thorin barked, groping for the blade at his belt, but he never reached it. Before he quite knew what was happening, he had been swept off his feet and the sand was falling away, the cries of his kin ringing in his ears.

Up, up, and up he rose, and Thorin’s stomach plummeted. Disoriented, he struggled to turn onto his back and found himself looking up into the hideous face of a giant Man.

“Uncle!” Fíli screamed.

“Run!” The shelter of the nearest thicket was some distance back, but if Thorin could distract the monster for even a few moments, they would be able to reach it in time. “To the trees, all of you!”

But Dís, war-axes flashing, was already charging to his defense with a piercing "Baruk Khazâd! Khazâd ai-mênu!", the others fast at her heels.

Just as Thorin was attempting to decide whether or not it would be sufficiently kingly to bite the massive finger nearest him, the giant brought his palm close to his face.

“I did not intend to frighten you, little dwarf,” the creature said in a low, ponderous voice, like the tide on soft silt. “It has been a very long time since I have seen your kind here. I had forgotten that you do not like to be picked up.”

Very, very gently, he lowered his hand to the ground, allowing Thorin to dismount with as much grace as he could. Frerin, white-faced, grabbed his arm as soon as he reached their company, who stood all in a somewhat confused cluster with their weapons upraised. Thorin clasped his arm briefly in reassurance before turning round to confront his captor.

The sea-creature was broad and powerful and very unpleasant to look upon. Limp strands of seaweed hair hung from his proud, helmeted head, and from the gaps in his mossy bronze armour, tough flesh glimmered with scales of silver and pearl. His lamplike eyes were lidless and round, like a fish’s, giving him a look of perpetual surprise that might have been amusing on a less imposing face.

“I am Ulmo, Watchman of Sea and Storm,” the giant said, bending to peer at them curiously. “But what are you doing so far from Brother Aulë’s Halls? It is not safe out here for you.”

Thorin let his fist fall from the pommel of his sword, and he gestured at Ori to lower his war-hammer. “We left to help a friend in peril, Lord Ulmo.”

“Laddie,” Balin murmured behind him, but Thorin shook his head warningly. He would not lie to kin of Mahal, nor had he any desire to offend one of the Valar -- in particular a Vala who was capable of summoning fearsome tidal waves and gales, if Thorin remembered the tales correctly. “We are travelling to Valinor, to find the elves on the sea-coast.”

“Then you have come to the wrong shore, little dwarves!” Ulmo said. “Valinor is vast, but if you seek the coastal city of elves, it is to the east, not the west.”

Óin muttered such a foul curse that the tip of Ori’s nose flushed pink.

“I see I have brought you ill news. But come, it is not so far to travel, if you follow Sister Nienna’s river. You need only follow the water’s song, as I followed yours.” His bulging eyes flitted over each of them and stopped at Bofur. “What is that thing you have there? It makes such a sweet sound.”

Bofur, to his credit, did not look too shaken to be personally addressed by the Master of the Seas. “My wee fiddle, you mean? It’s awfully old now, and a bit battered besides, but it does make for a nice tune, doesn’t it, m’lord?”

“It does.” Ulmo knelt on the water’s edge, the sea hissing and roiling wherever his body touched it. “It has been so long since I’ve heard such music that I could not help but see who was making it. Elvish songs are not so merry as this.”

Bofur tugged indecisively at his mustache, glanced over at Thorin, and then grinned. “Shall I play something for you, m’lord? I’d be happy to. I always like to have a keen audience.” He made a neat bow and swept off his hat. “Bofur at your service, by the by.”

It was difficult to read the Vala’s expressions, but Thorin thought he looked rather taken aback. “I should be honoured.”

And so they settled back around their fire, if a little warily, and Bofur played The Jeweller’s Lament, a haunting, sorrowful piece that had been a favourite of his mother’s court when Thorin was young -- many nights he had been put to bed to the sound of her singing it low and sweet.

Ulmo listened with rapt, reverent attention, keeping time with the gentle swish of the waves on the sand, and when Bofur followed it with another rowdy alehouse reel, he laughed in open delight.

“Very good!” he cried, when the last note faded. “Very, very good indeed! I play my songs for Arda every day and night with the singing and sighing of the waves and the whistling winds on the surf. It has been an Age since I received music in return.” He was quiet for a moment, and there was the smallest flicker of something ageless and lonely in his bearing. “Would you be so good as to play another?”

Through a goodly portion of the night Thorin’s company made music for the Vala of the Seas. Bofur fiddled until his fingers ached and then passed his instrument on to Kíli and Fíli, who each attempted to outdo the other with stomps and reels and impromptu dances. Thorin sang a half-dozen ballads, Dís harmonizing with him in her silvery, clear voice, and even Ori was able to muster up the courage for a poem or two. Frerin accompanied them all with the small wooden flute he always kept tucked in his coat. Ulmo seemed to like the sound of the flute most of all, for he said it reminded him of the sweet southern winds in spring.

When at last they had no more breath to spare for singing, and Bofur had to pause mid-jig to yawn, Ulmo thanked them profusely for their company and showed them where the sea trickled into the beginnings of a river.

“Sister’s river crosses the whole of Aman,” he said, “and you need only keep to its banks and follow it east. Do not stray from the path, and you will find your elves soon enough.”

“Our gratitude for your help.” Thorin bowed to him, the others following suit, and the water began to ripple under Ulmo's feet as he stepped from the shore.

“One moment, pray!” Frerin called out, striding past Thorin. He held out his flute. “I would humbly ask that you accept this, my lord, that you might always remember our music.”

Ulmo was silent for a long moment before he reached out to take the tiny instrument into his mighty hands. He smiled then, and Thorin thought that perhaps his face was not so very hideous to look upon after all.

“You are kind, Master Dwarf,” he rumbled. “I will accept it, if you will accept this.” He dipped into the foam around his feet, and when he straightened, there in his palm was a delicate, pearly-pink conch shell. He offered it to Frerin. “Carry it carefully, for it holds inside it the winds from a summer tide, to use if you find yourselves in danger.”

Frerin thanked him graciously. Ulmo strode out into the sea, the water rising and bubbling around him until the tip of his forked helmet vanished below the surf.

Exhausted, the company returned to their campsite to rest until dawn, still astounded but heartened by the new purpose they had been given. They bedded down together around the embers of their fire, and soon the air was filled not with music, but with a cacophony of tired snores. Thorin took first watch, but Frerin was awake as well, lingering by the fringes of their camp and studying Ulmo’s gift. He looked perplexed, and perhaps a little lost, and Thorin felt a surge of pity rise in his breast.

“Frerin,” he murmured, and he lifted the furs at his side in a silent command.

Without a word, Frerin brought his own fur over and curled against Thorin’s side, the shell carefully tucked away into his pack. Whatever troubled him seemed to ease; after a few moments he was soundly asleep, the fingers of one hand tangled in Thorin’s coat. Thorin counted his brother’s slow breaths and listened to the gentle hiss of Dís’s snores and turned his thoughts eastward.

 

 


 


 

FRODO

 


 

 

IF NOT FOR THE nature of their quest, Frodo might have genuinely enjoyed his time on the road. He liked travelling with Gandalf, who was full of lively stories and accustomed to taking journeys with hobbits, for he always obligingly stopped for tea and second breakfast. The lands past the Gardens of Lórien were of course new and fascinating, and it seemed that Gandalf had a tale for every valley and stream and oddly-shaped rock they came across. They passed the hours with stories and walking-songs and riddles, and despite his many worries, Frodo found it pleasant to be out in the world once more.

His other companion, however, was more reserved. If Tauriel never seemed irritated by their unceasing conversation, she also rarely joined in. She kept largely to herself, scouting ahead or bringing up the rear of their party, and when they broke camp at night, she laid her blankets away from the fire, wherever the view of the road was best. Bow firmly in hand and keen eyes continuously scanning the fields and thickets around them, she walked without ever seeming to tire. Truthfully, Frodo was intimidated by her, though he could not deny that he also felt a good deal safer with her keeping watch.

They travelled quickly. Frodo could not begin to judge how far they went each day, but Gandalf assured them that they would have plenty of time to rescue the dwarves (though how exactly they would do this, he neglected to say), climb to Mount Taniquetil to seek Manwë’s help, and return to the Bay before Bilbo’s condition became dangerous.

“I know it is unpleasant to think of him being under the sway of the Ring any longer,” he had said, when Frodo had asked whether it would be faster if he sought Manwë on his own, “but I promise you that he is in no immediate danger. The trouble, after all, is the prolonging of his life, not the shortening of it.”

That was perhaps not as reassuring as the wizard intended it to be, but Frodo accepted the promise -- for all his secrecy and manipulations, Frodo trusted Gandalf as much as he loved him -- and resolved to let their journey continue as it would.

On their third day of travel, they had just finished breakfast when a beautiful white mockingbird appeared in the sky above them and fluttered down to settle on top of Gandalf’s staff.

“Ah!” the wizard exclaimed. “It is one of Elrond’s messengers. Has he news for us?” he asked it.

“I come bearing a gift from Bilbo Baggins to Frodo Baggins,” it announced in flawless Westron, ruffling its plumage self-importantly.

“I’m Frodo Baggins.” Frodo held out his hands, and the mockingbird fluttered over them and extended one of its slim legs, to which a dainty cloth package was bound with twine. Frodo gently untied it and parted the fabric, and a painful lump formed in his throat -- his uncle had sent him a handful of Belladonna’s biscuits.

“Bilbo Baggins sends a message as well.” The mockingbird cleared its throat noisily, and in a near-perfect imitation of Bilbo’s voice, it said, “‘Frodo, we shall have words about the manner of your departure when you come back, but for now, be safe and be brave.’”

Frodo bowed his head and clutched his bundle close. “Will you tell him that I’m sorry, and that I’ll return soon? Oh, and thank him for the biscuits.”

The mockingbird cheaped agreeably and then turned to Gandalf, who paused with his pipe halfway to his lips.

“And to Gandalf the White, Istari,” it said to him, “Bilbo Baggins says: ‘If Frodo returns with so much as a scratch upon his big toe, Eru himself will not be able to preserve you.’” The bird paused and swivelled its head back toward Frodo. “And you are not to share your biscuits with him.”

Gandalf frowned.

With his uncle’s blessing, Frodo’s burden felt at least somewhat lightened, and on they went. Two more days and nights passed before the landscape at last began to change from the gentle inclines and open valleys of the lowlands. The golden fields faded, eaten up by thick, gnarled tangles of old trees and cumbersome vegetation. The farther they went west, the darker and cooler and quieter it became, coming upon them so gradually that it wasn’t until they were halfway into its depths that Frodo realized they were in a forest at all.

It wasn’t like the beautiful thatch of meticulously-kept woods around the Gardens. This forest seemed utterly untouched and uncultivated, a wild mass of old plants and murmuring streams that dampened the air with musk and moss. It was lovely, in its own curious way. Gandalf seemed not the least bit concerned as the sunlight was overtaken by the leafy canopy, but Tauriel, walking behind Frodo, was as tense as a bowstring.

“What is this place?” Her voice echoed as though they stood in the grand marble hall of the White Citadel. “It feels . . . I do not know how it feels.” She stopped. “We should take another path.”

Gandalf turned to look at her impatiently. “You are not in any danger here.”

Whatever else he had intended to say was swallowed up by a ferocious growl from the road ahead of them. Creeping out of the shadows came a half-dozen sleek, monstrous masses of grey and white fur -- Frodo saw only a glimpse of a luminous yellow eye before the beasts began to run.

“Wolves!” Tauriel cried, and in an instant her bow was at her shoulder. She fired an arrow quick as lightning, but the wolves somehow evaded it, powerful hind legs pushing them out of its path.

“Behind me, Frodo,” Gandalf said, but strong hands snatched Frodo up, and his vision was obscured by a sheet of long red hair; he could do nothing but hold fast to Tauriel’s waist as she leapt up into the trees.

In a flash Gandalf was perched beside them on the thickest branch, and the wolves sprang at its trunk. Snarling and growling, their jaws snapped at the air as they clawed at the bark, leaping up so that Frodo could see their teeth, sharp as needles and dripping with glistening ropes of spittle.

“Hold on,” Tauriel commanded, and she let go of Frodo to take up her bow again. She aimed at the largest wolf, its hackles raised as it released a ghoulish howl. The arrow flew straight between the beast’s eyes and burrowed into the dirt.

The wolves vanished.

“Well,” Gandalf huffed. “How very rude!” He slid effortlessly to the ground, patting down his white robes to flick away the bits of dust and bark. “I suppose I should not be surprised. Oromë always has preferred the company of animals to Men and elves . . . .” He glanced up at Frodo, who was still clinging to the elf’s waist. “And hobbits too. It is best not to take it personally.”

Tauriel stared at Gandalf as though she suspected he had struck his head on a branch, and Frodo surprised himself with a laugh.

Gandalf smiled at him and reached up to help them down. “As I meant to say before we were so ungraciously interrupted, this is the Great Rider’s Forest, home to Oromë. He is the Huntsman, and he watches over the birds and beasts here. As you have seen, he does not always take kindly to travellers. I was not expecting him to be so direct, however. We must have caught him in a poor humour.”

Once he was safely on the grass again, Frodo took a moment to steady himself and adjust the cloak that had been torn from his shoulders during their hasty climb. Tauriel immediately went over to her arrow and prised it from the dirt.

“I do not understand,” she said.

“Those were no wolves. Or rather, they were wolves, once.”

Frodo froze with his clasp half-undone. “They’re . . . dead?”

“Did I not tell you that all mortal creatures must have a resting place?” Gandalf reminded him. “Their souls are not like our own, but they must have somewhere to go when their lives are spent. They are shades. They cannot hurt us, but we should take care not to disturb them in return.”

Tauriel looked ill, and Frodo closed his eyes briefly and then resumed fixing his cloak with deliberate calmness.

Deep into the heart of Oromë’s forest they went, and what had been silent and still was now rife with movement and sound: the chirps of a thousand bird-calls, rumblings and roars, scuttering feet and soft, padding paws. Yet no animals appeared. There were only flutters at the corner of Frodo’s eyes, the occasional rustle of the underbrush beside them, the spectral shadow of something scurrying along the grass. It was unnerving, but Frodo could not find it in him to be afraid. There was no menace, no ill will, no sense of danger here -- merely a long-unbroken peace, a stagnant place in which half-shadow lives were acted out eternally under the shelter of the trees.

They stopped in the early afternoon to eat and rest. Gandalf led them to a place where the canopy receded enough to allow for a small patch of sunny clearing, and he left them there with a vague assurance that he had something to do but would return at sundown. Neither Frodo nor his companion were pleased to be left behind, but Gandalf possessed a considerable talent for disappearing when an argument was imminent.

With nothing else to do, Frodo occupied himself in repacking his knapsack. The dagger Galadriel had given him was tucked into his bedroll, but with the memory of the wolves so fresh in his mind, he drew it out, deciding that it might be wiser to keep it at his belt instead. He unsheathed it curiously. The blade was slender and highly polished, with a slight curve at its end. It looked quite wicked, and even the thought of using it was enough to disturb him.

Tauriel sat beside him, and he felt something being pressed into his palm; he looked down to find that she had given him a flat grey stone. She gestured at her own long knife. “You may use it. I have already sharpened mine.”

He thanked her, and feeling the pressure to use the whetstone now that she had given it to him, he clumsily brought his blade to it. The resulting shriek of metal and rock was enough to raise the hair on his toes.

Tauriel watched him fumble, and though she smiled, it didn’t seem unkindly meant. After a few moments she leaned over to help him position it. “Have you no training?” she asked.

“Very little,” he admitted. “I have fought some with a sword, but nothing more. We don’t have much use for weapons in the Shire unless it’s for hunting.” He looked down at the knife, and thought of Sam -- Sam, with his gentle hands that were meant for rakes and shovels, not swords --  brandishing Sting to save him. Everyone always protected him.  Everyone always fought for his sake.

If he could wield this dagger, he might not feel so weak.

“Would you teach me?” he said, all in a rush, and then reddened at his own presumption.

“I could teach you,” she said simply.

The afternoon ebbed away in laborious cycles of standing and striking, blocking and falling. Tauriel proved a merciless instructor, driving her student hard, though it was obvious that she was restraining the force of her blows. Frodo ducked and wove in and out of her path. He excelled at evading her strikes but was hopeless at returning them. His arms were too short to reach her chest and neck, and she easily parried his thrusts at her long, nimble legs.

“You must not be afraid to push,” Tauriel told him, not breathless in the least. “I know you have strength. You have seen you walk swiftly and far.”

“A stroll in the Shire is not the same as a sword-fight,” Frodo said, dodging a soft tap to his side. Still, practice seemed to produce no improvement, and eventually he was obliged to call a halt. “No more,” he gasped, clutching at his side. “Please, no more for today.”

She stopped at once, planting her knife in the ground before crouching next to him where he lay sprawled on his back. “Perhaps I have been too demanding.”

He waved away the apology. “No, no, it’s good for me to learn. I’m afraid I’m just not very good at it.”

“Or perhaps I have been teaching you the wrong thing. Tell me, Master Frodo, have you ever used a bow?”

When he confirmed that he had not, she asked him if he would like to try. He agreed, and she went away for a half-hour or so, only to return with a small bow in her hands, unembellished and crudely carved. “I used one of my spare strings, so it is not of the quality I would like it to be, but it may suit you for now."

Frodo took it. It fit easily in his hands, the wood sun-warmed and rough. After several rounds of demonstration, some adjustments to the bow to suit his arm length, and some practice, Frodo was able to hit their makeshift targets with an accuracy that was equally surprising to both of them.

“Are you sure you have never shot before?” Tauriel asked again as they plucked the arrowheads from a tree-trunk.

“Quite sure. Uncle was always very good at conkers, and he was the one who taught me. Perhaps that has something to do with it?”

Tauriel looked at him over her shoulder, one slender eyebrow arched skeptically. “Conkers?”

Their archery lesson devolved into an impromptu conkers match. Tauriel was good at it -- he was not too astonished given that Legolas had excelled at the game as well, much to Gimli’s disappointment -- but Frodo, with the advantage of years of practice, won the contest handily. To reward himself for his labours, he produced a crisp red apple from his pack and sat on the grass to watch as the sky flushed the warm golden-orange of dusk. Tauriel collected her scattered arrows and the acorns they’d used for their game and then joined him.

“You’re very good at archery,” Frodo began, attempting to peel his apple in one long strand, like Sam did, and failing rather spectacularly. “But I don’t think I’ve ever met an elf who wasn’t.”

“I learned young, as is the custom for our kind,” she said. “My mother was a great archer and taught me as soon as I could hold a bow steady.”

“I’m afraid we aren’t taught anything of battle in the Shire, especially not as fauntlings. Not very sensible, but getting bitten by one of Farmer Maggot’s hounds is probably the worst thing to befall young hobbits there. My cousin Pippin was bit once, stealing pears.” Pip’s love of sweets had always triumphed over what little sense he possessed. “Is your family here in Valinor?”

She shook her head. “It was only ever my mother and I,” she said, and she resumed restringing her bow with such avid attention that Frodo was sure he had offended her. He had just opened his mouth to apologize when she added, “She is not in Valinor. She was killed on the roads of the Greenwood, and so she has passed into the Halls of Mandos. We will be parted until Arda is remade.”

It was impossible to find the correct words to respond to that, so Frodo did not try. He offered her instead a slice of apple from his knife, and they ate in companionable silence, watching the sun set and the first stars begin to rise. So absorbed was he in searching for patterns in the sky that Frodo jumped when Tauriel spoke again.

“Do hobbits have stories about the stars?”

“A few,” Frodo said. “Sam’s old Gaffer told us that a star appeared for the arrival of every hobbit, and that the brightest star in the sky on the night after your birth was your very own. The brighter it shone, the happier and longer your life. And if you and another hobbit were born under the same star, you were fated to meet.” He glanced over at her. “I know elves have many stories about stars.”

“We do. There is nothing so beautiful as watching the stars from the canopy of the Greenwood, with nothing in sight but the stretch of the sky.”

“I should have liked to see that.”

“I do not know that you could have, for the Greenwood was different in those days. We lived in the forest itself, among the trees and the open clearings.” Her eyes were full of wistful remembrance, and Frodo spared a thought to wonder if he looked the same when he spoke of the Shire. “It was a beautiful place.”

“My friend Legolas was raised in Greenwood. Did you know him?”

Tauriel smiled then, a flicker of warmth, and Frodo was glad to see it. “I ought to know him well, for I was captain of his father’s guard for over five centuries."

Legolas had not often spoken of his father. He had told them tales of his youth in the Greenwood and many legends beloved of the elves, but of his own family he had been reluctant to speak. “You must have known the king well to have served him so long,” Frodo prodded.

Something hardened in her face. “I have not seen him in a long time.”

“I . . . oh, I’m very sorry, I didn’t mean ---”

“Let us speak of it no more. I should like to hear what news you have of Legolas. He is as dear as a brother to me, and I often think of him. Last I heard he was dwelling in Gondor.”

Frodo was quick to assure her that the elf was very well indeed and had been enjoying a leisurely journey around Middle-earth when the last ship had sailed. “I think he and Gimli meant to go to Fangorn Forest next, and I’ve no doubt that they made it there if they had their hearts set on it.”

“Gimli?”

Not entirely certain how she would react, Frodo nevertheless told her about the Three Hunters. Tauriel threw back her head and laughed aloud when Frodo described Legolas and Gimli's irreverent competition, which had still been ongoing after the quest's end. She seemed extraordinarily amused by the idea of their friendship but would not say why.

When the sky deepened into the full darkness of night and Gandalf still had not appeared, they decided to make camp before the lack of light hindered them. As they gathered their things, Tauriel asked him if he would be willing to share the tale of his adventure, as she had heard only brief accounts from the other elves and was interested in hearing the true story.

The request sent a dreadful shudder through him, and the violence of his reaction frightened him. She must have seen a sudden pallor in his face, for she immediately said, “You need not tell me if it distresses you so.”

The feeling of inexplicable panic receded then, but he was left unsettled and faintly ashamed. “I don’t know why I cannot speak of it.”

“I understand,” she assured him, but there was a certain stiffness about her as they returned to camp that told him that she was a little wounded nonetheless.

 

*****************

 

Gandalf appeared as they were gathering scraps of wood for the evening fire, and Frodo did not trouble himself to hide his relief or his annoyance. “Where have you been? You said you would return by sundown!”

“The sun is down, is it not?” Gandalf plucked the bundle of branches from Frodo’s grasp and carried them over to their makeshift pit. With a murmur and a flick of his fingers, a large bonfire roared cheerily to life.

“Is it wise to draw attention to ourselves?” Frodo asked, thinking of Merry and Pippin’s cooking-fire on the hilltop. He had no desire for another encounter with the wolves tonight.

“We are perfectly safe. Oromë may be a poor host, but he would not harm a visitor to his forest. He meant to frighten us away, nothing more.” He stirred the kindling with the tip of his staff and sat down with a groan and a weary creak. Tauriel did not look reassured, but Frodo sat gladly in front of the warmth and used his dagger as an impromptu toasting fork -- he had discovered a few days before that a decent crisping vastly improved the taste of lembas.

“I was conferring with Galadriel,” Gandalf said, accepting a hot slice from Frodo with a murmur of thanks. “She has had another vision in the Gardens. The dwarves must have altered their path, for they will encounter the Firedrakes sooner than we had planned for.”

“Do you know which dwarves are in the company?” Tauriel asked, with an edge of sharpness that had Frodo glancing up at her.

“I’m afraid not -- only that Thorin is among them.” He too turned an evaluating eye upon the elf, but she lifted her chin as if challenging him to pry. He gave her a wry look and stretched out comfortably by the fire.

Bolstered by their earlier friendliness, Frodo took up his bowl of lembas toast and felt bold enough to sit next to her. “Are you well?’ he asked quietly, for she looked deeply unhappy.

She gave him a tired half-smile and lifted her eyes to sky. It took her some time to answer. “Have you never looked up at the night-sky, Frodo, and felt that the world was too small for you? I look at Elbereth’s stars, and I feel that if only I could walk among them, I might be free to roam where I please and never want for unseen places.” She folded her arms across her breasts and stared into the fire. “I left the Greenwood for Lothlórien because I could not be happy. I left Lothlórien for Valinor because I could not find happiness there either. And now I am leaving Valinor.” She shook her head. “I begin to wonder if I am of the Hollow Ones, doomed to wander forever.”

“That is a gloomy perspective to take, my dear,” said Gandalf.

Tauriel shifted a bit closer to him, and it occurred to Frodo for the first time that she might be as wary of the wizard as Frodo had been of her.

“I have found that having a home of one’s own is a rather confining notion,” Gandalf continued. “Who is to say that a hobbit or elf or Man may find more fulfillment in a life spent in one place or many? I would hardly think that a lonely life whiled away in the comfort of a home is to be preferred to a life spent travelling from one friend to another. But then I have always been a wanderer myself -- I can hardly be unbiased in these matters.”

Tauriel gave no hint as to what she thought of this, but she did accept a few slices of lembas.

“Will you tell a story, Gandalf?” Frodo asked.

Gandalf hummed thoughtfully around his pipe. “Did I ever tell you that I once travelled with Lady Nienna?”

“You know very well that you didn’t.”

The wizard harumphed. “When I was a spritely young thing, I dwelled in her realm as her . . . apprentice, I suppose you could say. I was sent to her to learn all that I could, and my time with her is a memory I have treasured all these long years.” He puffed out a ring of smoke. “I hope that we will have time to visit on our way. You would like her very much, I think.

“Now, the Lady Nienna is not often regarded as the greatest of the Valar, but for myself, I believe I learned more from her than I did from all the others together. She is the Lady of Mercy -- the Weeper, the Mistress of Mourning, the Bringer of Tears. Aulë builds his mountains and Varda fills her bright stars with light, but Nienna weeps for a fallen tree and sings a mourning song for the nest of sparrows’ eggs that fell with it. To walk with her is to remember that we all bear our sorrows, great and small.”

“When we reach the end of this forest, Frodo, there will be a river on its borders. It is her river, made of great loss. As the Valar built life under Ilúvatar’s guiding hand, so Melkor sought to tear it down. His gifts were wasted abominably in wanton destruction, and when Nienna saw what he who had once been her brother had done, she wept and wept -- out of sorrow, but also out of pity for him and what he had become. She cried, and her tears swelled and pooled until they became a mighty river that crossed Aman from one sea to the other.”

He paused then, and there was something distant in his eyes. “I have seen many things and known many beings, and through it all, I have come to realize that the most enduring power is in acts of compassion, of mercy, of shared tender sorrows. Forests fall and kingdoms crumble, but grief and love remain together, for one cannot exist without the other. And that is why I call Nienna chief among the Ainur, for she is grief, and she is love, and there exists no higher power than those.”

No one spoke when the story was finished. Tauriel drew her blankets around her and turned away without another word. Gandalf sighed, offered Frodo a sad little smile, and extinguished his pipe before settling against the nearest tree.

Frodo sat for a moment longer before crawling over to bed down beside Gandalf. He burrowed into his cloak and closed his eyes, though sleep did not find him for a long time. Despite the strength and cleverness of his companions, despite the dagger on his hip and the new bow strapped to his pack, he felt too young and too old and very, very small indeed.

 

 


 


 

 

Notes:

[1] "Baruk Khazâd! Khazâd ai-mênu!" - "Axes of the dwarves! The dwarves are upon you!"

Again, thank you all for your kind comments -- I really do value your feedback.