Actions

Work Header

And in the Darkness Bind Them

Chapter 10: An Expert Burglar

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

CHAPTER NINE


 

FRODO



 

 

GRIEF HAD BECOME FAMILIAR to Frodo. He managed well enough, though it was bittersweet to see Bilbo’s long-stemmed pipe on the mantle or his precise handwriting on the papers strewn across his desk. Their parting, after all, was only temporary. He would see his uncle again when he passed to the Pastures of Yavanna himself, and this surety tempered the worst of his pain.

Their cottage was so quiet. Bilbo's death left behind a great void, an echoing silence that seemed at each moment to remind Frodo of his absence. When the mourning visits from their neighbours finally slowed, Frodo cast himself into his writing, sorting through his papers and allowing himself to feel the weight of his loss when he marked a passage for his uncle's opinion only to recall that Bilbo would never read it. Still, he gathered the half-finished stories and poems faithfully and arranged them into some semblance of order, filling his afternoons with copying and drafting. Elrond had expressed an interest in having some of Bilbo's work for Valmar's Great Library. The thought that his uncle's tales might be told forever in the Undying Lands was a comforting one, and the task distracted him from the stillness of his home and his increasing worry for the cottage's other occupant.

Thorin's despair was silent and absolute. His carving knife lay untouched on the table, and he seemed not to care if the garden he had laboured so hard to keep in bloom for Bilbo withered to dust. He had taken to wandering the shore like a shadow. He slept and ate when coerced and listened if Frodo spoke to him, but the forge-fire had been extinguished within him. He seemed neither sorrowful nor angry, and he did not weep; indifference had consumed him. Often he did not speak a single solitary word from sunrise to sunset and at night sat motionless by the hearth like a stone statue.

Gandalf came by frequently to see how they fared, bringing covered platters of elvish delicacies to tempt Frodo's appetite and news from the city to entertain him. He pestered Thorin, several times attempting to provoke an argument, but his needling was no more effective than Frodo's kindness, for the dwarf simply left the room.

"Look at yourself, son of Thráin," Gandalf said on one such occasion, so sharply that Frodo nearly dropped the soup tureen he'd been carrying to the table. "What would Bilbo think of you, a useless lump moping about the house, your braids half-undone and your beard unoiled, looking like a common vagabond?"

Thorin's eyes flamed. His hands clenched into fists at his side, and his jaw worked. It was more emotion than Frodo had seen from him for weeks, but then he turned away and stomped out the door.

Gandalf sighed.

"That was cruel," Frodo said angrily.

"It is worse than I thought," Gandalf murmured. He rubbed at his temples, frowning, and then took up his staff. "I think I shan't stay for tea after all."

"If you mean to go after Thorin I wouldn't advise it. He can be very stubborn."

A small measure of the grim worry in Gandalf's face eased as he chuckled. "I think I know that well enough by now." He bent and gave Frodo's cheek a gentle nudge. "I am sorry that you should have to bear this all on your own."

Frodo drew back, taking up his dish to put it back on the hearth. "I can manage."

"My dear boy, I know you can." Taking his white cloak from its peg, Gandalf threw it over his shoulders and pulled his hat low on his forehead. "I will come tomorrow, unless I am called away." He opened the door. "If you should, perchance, in a few minutes happen to hear any alarming sounds from the proximity of the woods I would not trouble yourself unduly about them."

"Wh--- Gandalf!"

By the time Frodo hastened to the threshold, the wizard had already vanished. The yard and the garden were empty, and Thorin and Gandalf were nowhere in sight. For a moment Frodo was miffed at being left without a word. Blight and bother, he was done with the both of them! He needed a warm bed and a nap, and maybe a bit of luncheon. As he turned to go back inside, his eye was caught by something gleaming dully in the grass by the edge of the gate.

It was Thorin's harp, the beautiful wooden bow cracked cleanly down the middle and the strings frayed on their ends, like they'd been ripped from their moorings in a heedless rage. With great care, Frodo gathered all the pieces together and bore them back to the cottage. He folded them in a soft tea-towel and took the bundle into Bilbo’s library.

For a moment, Frodo simply stood in the little room, with its shelves of well-worn books and stacks of uncut paper, empty glass ink-pots lining one of the window sills. He closed his eyes and inhaled the scent of binding-leather and ink and the faintest whiff of brewed tea. Sighing, he went to the large ash box in the corner, where Bilbo had kept his bits and bobs, trifles that meant something only to him -- fragments of broken pottery, bird feathers, an unusual stone, polished seashells from the shore. Taken by whimsy, Frodo spent a minute or two sorting through the cache. Inside a tin filled with mismatched buttons, he found Thorin’s hewn braid, wrapped in a handkerchief of fine blue silk. Very gently he resettled the tin and cleared a space at the chest’s centre for the broken harp.

Thorin returned later that evening in a contemplative mood, his left eye blackened. As they ate their supper quietly at the table, Frodo saw him unsuccessfully attempting to conceal skinned and bloodied knuckles under the hem of his sleeve. Frodo bit his lip and said nothing. The next morning, when Thorin went out into the yard to his customary perch, his hair was neatly brushed and braided.

Gandalf did not return the next day, nor the next, but on the third morning he arrived at the cottage and brought with him Lady Galadriel. They arrived just after second breakfast, while Frodo was tidying up the dishes and Thorin was fiddling with the window sill in the parlour that had been damaged by a torrential rain.

Pushing through the door without so much as a knock, Gandalf shook the water from his hat and set his staff against the wall. “Beastly weather,” he groused. “I don’t suppose you still have the kettle on?”

Frodo tensed a bit as he came inside, remembering Thorin’s split knuckles, but the dwarf nodded to Gandalf with no apparent grudge and the wizard merely looked amused. Whether or not that was the end of the exchange, Frodo was never to know, for his attention was quickly diverted. Galadriel, after hanging her blue travelling cloak by the fire, came at once to Frodo. She caught his face delicately in her hands and turned his head this way and that, observing him with her piercing, all-seeing eyes. Seeming satisfied, she released his chin. "How do you fare, little one?"

“Mostly well,” he said truthfully, for there was no point in attempting to deceive her. “Will you take some tea? We just finished eating, but there’s leftover bread and cold meat, and there might be a boiled egg or two."

Her pale hand on his arm silenced him more effectively than a shout. “Thank you, but I require nothing. Come and sit with me.”

He sat. Gandalf poured himself a steaming cup from the kettle but did not drink. If he had seemed like himself earlier -- though perhaps a little tired -- his good humour had fled from him. He looked very serious indeed.

Frodo swallowed past a sudden dryness in his mouth. “What brings you out in the rain?”

"News." Galadriel glanced over at Thorin, who was resolutely nailing a new panel into the window sill and giving every appearance of not paying her a smidgen of attention. "For both of you. The past three nights I dreamt of you, Frodo, and of Bilbo, and I felt a great need to walk in the Gardens. I went this very morning and tread the path of dreams in solitude. Lórien granted me a vision."

The sound of the hammer stopped.

"I walked in a beautiful garden, green and good, stretching the length of the world," she said, her voice slipping into something dreamy and faraway. "I walked in a land rich with plenty, peaceful beyond measure and blooming with a hundred thousand flowers. I saw you, Frodo, treading the path before me with your brave Samwise fast at your side." She pressed his hand, and Frodo managed an uncertain smile for her.  "I saw you happy and free, among those whom you love, with a face like sunbeams. But as I walked, I felt an absence. Bilbo did not dwell in those beautiful gardens.”

A hundred horrors sprang to Frodo's mind. Had they done something wrong, somehow barred Bilbo from passing into Yavanna's Pastures by giving him the river’s water? Had they been mistaken, and the shades of the Ring had not been truly lifted?

"Calm your thoughts,” Galadriel said. “Listen. Believing I must be mistaken, I sought him beyond the bounds of that sacred land. I passed through walls of polished stone, lit with the fires of a thousand forges, set with precious gems and tiles of gold."

From where he knelt by the window, Thorin let out a choked cry. "It cannot be."

Galadriel seemed not to hear him. “I passed through carven halls to a chamber that I recalled from an Age long past, its arches flaming with jewels and ancient runes. Do you wish to know what I saw there, Durin’s son? I saw the great silver throne of the lost Erebor, and on it a hobbit with a mithril crown on his brow. I saw the consort of the king, wearing your braid in his hair."

Thorin bowed his head, and his shoulders shook.

Frodo half-rose from his seat in alarm. He looked to Galadriel, his bewilderment tempered by a growing, panicked suspicion. "Erebor?”

She was silent. It was Thorin who spoke. "The forges, the carven walls of tiled gold -- they are the Halls of my fathers."

Frodo struggled for words. "He is in Aulë's Halls." There was no disagreement. "How?"

"By some power beyond us all," Galadriel said. "How it was done I cannot say. I was not granted that knowledge. In my dream I saw well enough its consequences. Bilbo made the choice of Lúthien -- the choice of my Arwen -- and to Yavanna’s green gardens he shall not return."

"Oh," he murmured. He felt Gandalf's hand on his shoulder, a solemn weight. "Oh."

He lifted his eyes to Galadriel’s. Her beautiful face was sorrowful, soft, and the smile on her lips spoke of understanding and the tenderest pity.

I will never see him again, will I?

No, dear one.

Gandalf eased onto the bench with care, drawing Frodo down with him. Frodo hid his face in his friend's robes and wept.

 

****

 

WHEN GALADRIEL AND GANDALF had departed, Frodo went immediately to Bilbo’s study, rifling through the papers like a creature possessed. There must be some sign, some note, some word of instruction that Bilbo had left. For all his eccentricities and whims, Bilbo never did anything without a meticulous, painstaking plan -- surely he would not have made such a choice without recording some hint of it somewhere.

He read long into the afternoon, making quite a mess of his neatly-sorted stacks, but he found nothing worth noticing in the half-finished poems and household reminders and market-day lists. A noise from the door startled him from his reading. Thorin hovered uncertainly in the threshold, a porcelain teacup and a bowl of gingerbread in his hands.

“You missed dinner,” he said, offering Frodo the cup.

Frodo looked down at the syrupy red liquid and gave it a lackluster sniff. “This is fire-wine.”

“I thought you might welcome something stronger.”

Downing the entire cup in one swallow did not necessarily make him feel better -- the peppery burn in his throat teetered too far on the edge of painful -- but the warmth that spread in his belly a moment later soothed him. He set the empty glass aside.

Thorin was watching him with a clarity and awareness in his eyes that Frodo had not seen in weeks. "I am sorry," he said lowly.

Frodo put away the account book he had been reading and reached for a thick slice of gingerbread. It was heavily spiced and a trifle too sweet. “The night he died, when you were away in the kitchen, Bilbo apologized to me,” he said. “I didn’t know what he was on about then, but he asked me to forgive him for being selfish. He must have already had something planned. He truly didn’t tell you anything?”

Thorin came to sit on the chair in front of the window. “I swear to you, he didn’t breathe a word of any plan to me.”

“Maybe he didn’t wish to shore up your hopes in case it couldn’t be done.”

“Maybe.” He leaned forward on his elbows, and lowered his head, rubbing brusquely at his temples. “I confess I am at a loss.”

“Hmm?”

“I am still banished,” Thorin said quietly. “I cannot go back. What a sorry ending for our tale, if he lives forever in the dwarf halls and I in Valinor.”

“No. No, Bilbo always has a trick. He must have some notion of how to bring you to the Halls as well.”

“I have the utmost faith in his abilities,” Thorin said then, after a pause. “I have seen him face troll and dragon and orc alike, and triumph over them all. But I think this beyond even his wit. I offered Mahal mortal insult in choosing to abandon the Halls. I willfully abandoned my kin and my history, the sacred holding of my ancestors. Mahal allowed me to make my choice, and I made it. I have turned it over and over in my head, but I fear there is no way to evade its consequences.”

“You mustn't give up hope.”

“Do not concern yourself with me. I will go on, as I ever have.” He drew one hand over the desk, putting a few stray papers to order, his eye lingering on the elegant script. “I ask your pardon for my behaviour these past weeks. I laid too many burdens upon you in my grief.”

“It’s already forgotten.”

“So hasty to forgive.”

Frodo reached for another slice of gingerbread, now aware of how tired he was, and what a crick he’d developed from sitting hunched at the desk for so long. “I don’t see why I shouldn’t.”

Thorin huffed out a chuckle. “As you say. Manwë bid me remember that Mahal loves his children. Perhaps Bilbo and I shall be permitted to meet again when the world has been remade.”

“Well, I won’t give up hope.” Frodo brushed his palms against his trousers, uncaring of the crumbs that fell, and opened another account book. He glanced up at Thorin, and what he saw in the dwarf’s face gave him pause. “You’re leaving, aren’t you?”

Thorin looked genuinely taken aback.

“I don't believe that a dwarf who left his home on just the hope of reclaiming Erebor -- a dwarf who left his Maker’s keep on the hope of saving an old friend -- would be content to sit and wait for forgiveness.”

“Sensible. I should have expected nothing less from a Baggins. I do mean to leave if I can. I have no idea what supplications I can offer to Mahal, but I intend to try.”

“Will you go right away?”

Thorin’s look was kind, and Frodo thought he hadn’t spoken as calmly as he hoped. “Not yet. Soon, but not yet.” He hesitated. “I feel as if I have stolen him from you, somehow.”

“Bilbo belongs to himself.”

For a moment, Thorin was silent. “I have a promise for you: even if I should be turned away from the Halls, I know he will be loved and attended there. My kin will see to it that he is embraced as family. I give you my oath on that.”

“I never feared him being abandoned, not for an instant.”

“I dislike the thought of you going on to your Pastures alone. If one hobbit was able to enter the Halls, perhaps another might as well.”

“No,” Frodo said firmly. “Thank you, but no. Bilbo may find happiness there, but it is not meant for me. And you needn’t feel guilty. You should go home. I can see that you miss it.”

Thorin inclined his head gravely. “It is beautiful, this land.” A small, wry smile flickered around his mouth. “But it is not meant for me.” He rose and took up the empty bowl and teacup, and made as though to leave Frodo to his thoughts. When he reached the door, however, Frodo called him back.

“Thorin? Promise me one more thing.”

“You need only name it.”

“Promise me that you won’t leave without saying goodbye. A proper goodbye, not just a note.”

Thorin’s face, so harsh and forbidding in lamplight, softened. “You have my word.”

 

********************

 

“I HAD WONDERED WHEN you would visit again.”

Frodo smiled, stepping out onto the warm brick of the terrace, and sniffed appreciatively -- a delightful luncheon spread was arranged on a low table. “I think you knew.”

Elrond’s elegant brows rose, but he poured a glass of brown ale and held it out for Frodo. “Or perhaps I simply wished to dine out-of-doors today.”

“And dine on my favourite meat pie?”

“I had a taste for coney.”

“You detest coney. Arwen told me, and hobbits never forget about food. We’d offend all our neighbours at tea if we did.” Frodo accepted the glass and a plate already laden with a generous slice. “Thank you.”

Elrond dipped his head with a half-smile. He collected thin wedges of cheese and candied fruit for himself, and they talked as they ate. The pie was delectable, as always, and Frodo took his time savouring the rich gravy and hot crust, buttery and perfectly crisp.

“Your appetite has returned,” Elrond said, sounding pleased. Frodo merely nodded and accepted another generous slice. Only the food was mostly gone and they had begun an idle game of chess did Elrond carefully say, “I was sorry to hear the news.”

“Lady Galadriel told you about Bilbo.”

“She did. It must have been a tremendous shock.”

“It was and it wasn’t. I ought to have known that he would find some way around it. We Bagginses can be very stubborn.”

Elrond looked fond. “Yes, I know. Your uncle especially. That iron will was all the more startling for being embedded in such a demure form.”

Frodo covered a laugh with his napkin. “Bilbo? Demure? I think we’re speaking of different hobbits.”

“You did not know him in those days. He was so painfully polite, the first time I met him, and so distressed that his companions were not. His hunger for adventure was so great as to overcome his propriety eventually, but I can assure you it was a very fierce battle between Baggins and Took.” He took a long sip of ale. “Does Thorin intend to return to the Halls to plead his case with Aulë?”

“He says he does.”

“Does it distress you, his going away?”

“I suppose not, though I’ve grown fond of him in the last two years. I’m feeling very philosophical about it.” Frodo gave him a small smile. “There is nothing that can resolve the situation to everyone’s satisfaction, and I believe I’ve made my peace with that. It was an impossible choice. How could I be angry at Bilbo?” He shuffled the pieces in his hand and then made his move, capturing one of Elrond’s rooks. “I sailed here, and my friends forgave me. Their love was not enough to keep me in Middle-earth, but it does not mean that what we felt wasn’t honest and true. I love them as I ever did, and I would like to think that it’s the same for them. If an afterlife of dwarves makes Bilbo happy, then I can forgive him and wish him well.”

“You are a very wise hobbit.”

Frodo shifted his tokens uncomfortably. “Well, Bilbo never was made for the Shire, you know. He often said so himself. I suppose it's fitting that he does not go to the Pastures.” The thought of what their relatives would say when they learned what Bilbo had done was enough to have him chuckling to himself. It was fitting too, that his uncle should thumb his nose at their stuffy relations even in death. “Perhaps I’ve realized that love is not always enough.”

Elrond looked momentarily pained. “I believe that I much preferred your way of looking at it.”

Frodo only smiled.

“Here, let us talk of pleasanter things. I have a proposition for you, Frodo, and though I do not pretend that it any great solace, I offer it all the same. Bilbo approached me many months ago and asked me if I would see to you once he was gone. It would be my honour if you would consent to join my household and live here in Valmar.”

“I -- that’s very kind of you.” There was a polite refusal on his tongue, but Elrond grasped his shoulder and gave it a fatherly press.

“Come and stay with us in the city, mellon nín. I would have offered had Bilbo never broached the subject. Your friends would see you happy and among those who care for you until it is time for you to join your kin in the Pastures.”

“Then I will come gladly,” Frodo said, and he was treated to a rare smile from the elven lord.

“I told you he would come.” The sudden timbre of Gandalf’s voice surprised them both, though Elrond was too poised to jump in his seat. “You were fretting over nothing, my friend.”

“Only because you would push him into it whether he liked it or not.”

“One does as one must,” Gandalf said agreeably. “Lindir is searching for you. The poor fellow looks frantic, or as frantic as he ever does, which is not very much.”

“If I should go only to find that Lindir is not looking for me and you sent me away so that you could finish my plate, I shall be very cross with you.” The elf rose and gave Frodo’s shoulder another warm clasp. “Let me know when you wish to come, and I will arrange for your furnishings to be moved.”

Frodo thanked him earnestly, and he departed. As soon as his footsteps faded in the hall, Gandalf took up his plate and bit into a wedge of cheese with particular relish. Frodo groaned out a laugh and offered him a cup of ale. “You’re incorrigible.”

“It is too late now, my boy. You have already agreed and now you shall never be rid of us.”

“That suits me fine.” Pleasantly stuffed and assured of the welcome of his friends, Frodo wandered over to the balcony, leaning on its rail to gaze out at the gardens. “Do you think Thorin will be able to get into the Halls?”

“I think he is determined to, which is about the same thing by my measure. I would not worry for him, Frodo. Dwarves are a staunch sort, and he is stauncher than most.” Gandalf poured himself an ale. “And you? Do I need to worry for you?”

Frodo took a moment to consider it honestly. “Not anymore. I can wait, and I won’t be alone when it’s my time. I’ll have Sam and Merry and Pip and Mum and Pa . . . “ He trailed off when the wizard began to chuckle. “Gandalf?”

“How cross Bungo will be when he finds out what his son has done! He always was convinced that Bilbo’s Tookishness would get the better of him. You will assure him the dwarves are a good sort, Frodo? Belladonna will understand, and she’ll talk him ‘round eventually, but it would not hurt to put in a kind word for them.” Gandalf shook his head, still chortling, and put down Elrond’s plate in order to bring out his pipe. “I have been thinking, my lad -- if we grow bored with our lives of leisure, we might do a little travelling. There is more of Aman to see.”

“I thought we were done with adventures.”

“The day one ceases to have adventures is the day one ceases to be.” He tamped down his pipe and lit it. “Hmm, I’m rather proud of that one. Quite profound.”

Frodo laughed, looking up toward the sky. “I think I should like to see Manwë’s mountain again. And perhaps we might meet Ulmo someday and hear his songs. Ori spoke of them so highly.”

Gandalf came to stand beside Frodo at the edge of the terrace and blew a silver smoke-ring over the railing. They watched it drift lazily across the garden and float up and up and up until it vanished into the clouds.

“We shall fumble along quite merrily,” Gandalf murmured.

“Yes,” Frodo said. He felt the sun’s light on his face, the sweet wind in his hair, and Valinor stretched beyond the reach of his sight, beautiful and ageless as a dream. “As we always have.”

 



 

THORIN


 

 

AS THE DAYS PASSED, Thorin’s resolution to leave strengthened. The overwhelming fog of his grief had dissipated, and with a clear mind he began to prepare himself for his journey. Whether he succeeded or not, he would go and plead his case. His own dignity was of no consequence. For the first time in months he felt hope -- if his own hardened heart could be touched by pity, surely too could his Maker’s -- and that was worth any injury to his pride.

He longed to be among his kin again, to feel the heat of the forges and the cool shelter of stone. He missed his mother and father, his sister and his brother. He missed Balin and his sister-sons and Dáin. He missed his grandfather. He missed them with an ache that seemed so rooted in his heart that every week without them lodged the spines deeper.

Desperately he missed Bilbo. Their two years together had spoiled him for being alone; the hobbit’s absence had not been nearly so painful in the decades they had spent parted by death, for Thorin’s love then had been an unfulfilled longing with no hope of return. He had grown used to Bilbo’s smiles and clever words, the rare but thrilling flare of his temper, the warmth of his body close by at night. Knowing now that his affections were returned and knowing what it was to dwell together in happiness, having Bilbo beyond his reach was unbearable.

Yet he could not simply leave. He had duties and responsibilities here that must be attended to before he went; he could not think of only himself. With his eyes open once more, he felt shame for having obliged young Frodo to bear so much. His tools in hand, he went through every inch of the cottage, fixing and mending, replacing old boards and rusted nails, polishing and cleaning. He spent long hours at the table with his carving knife, listening attentively as Frodo cooked and chattered -- the lad hardly needed conversation so much as he needed someone to hear him, the comfort of another soul nearby.

It came as a great relief to learn that Frodo would join Elrond’s household when Thorin was gone; the thought of the softhearted lad living all alone by the Sea had niggled fearfully at Thorin’s conscience. What regard would he have shown Bilbo in abandoning his grieving kin? In any matter, Frodo seemed excited at the prospect and spoke eagerly of the city and his friends. Thorin’s respect for Elrond grew, and he felt not a twinge of discomfort in acknowledging it.

Thorin planned and plotted, recovering his knapsack from the closet and gradually filling it with what few effects he had, leaving it in easy reach by the foot of his bed. Everything he had made or collected since arriving in Valmar he would leave to Frodo. Frodo too was gathering his things together, packing Bilbo’s papers away and clearing out the larder; his elf-friends often came over to help sort and box up the many books. On the last such occasion, when the day’s work had been done, Tauriel approached Thorin with a request.

“Before you go, Thorin Oakenshield, I would beg a favour of you,” the elf said, firm and resolute. “Please, bear this message to Kíli.” She held out a letter sealed with red wax.

He took it, giving her a piercing look. “I could throw it into the river.”

“You could,” she agreed. “But you will not.”

“No.” He tucked the packet safely inside his coat. “I would not.”

She bowed her head to him, albeit a little mockingly, but there was real grief in the shadows of her eyes. Thorin felt a moment’s pity for her, and he was moved to say, “I will bear my sister-son’s greetings back to you, Mistress Tauriel, if we should ever meet again.”

A thin smile curled her lips. “We certainly shall,” she said, and without another word she turned round and left.

The days were busy and filled with many things, the nights still and tense with anticipation. The time of their departures was nearing, and soon Thorin was left with just one final task. He travelled the road to Valmar, seeking out the workshop of the master blacksmith. The elf proved amenable to the use of one of his smaller forges in exchange for a dwarvish-made axe. Over the course of three days, Thorin subsumed himself in steam and fire, the pleasing, familiar labour of strength against iron and steel. He made the axe-head with the expert ease of long practice and took his time with his own project. On the last day, he left the forge with two rectangular silver-iron beads in his pocket, wrought with the crown of Durin's sigil.

 

***

 

Thorin awoke one morning with a quiet knowledge in his heart. He rose and bathed his face, dressed in his best tunic, and spent an hour carefully brushing and braiding his hair, giving every bead he had a place of prominence. He re-wove Fârfil’s knot above his ear and bound back the fall of his hair so that its wooden sunflower bead might be visible to all.

He tidied the bedchamber and took up his satchel. Frodo he found in the kitchen, reading at the table. The lad glanced up, a ‘good morning’, no doubt, on his lips, and stilled.

“You’re leaving.”

“Yes.” Thorin placed his knapsack on the table and went to fetch his boots from the alcove. Dragonsbane stood propped next to his cloak, hardly touched in months, and he strapped it across his back, feeling the rightness of the sword’s weight once more.

Frodo had abandoned his book and now lingered at the threshold of the foyer, wringing his hands a little. “Will you take breakfast? I can make eggs and sausage, or honey porridge.”

Thorin declined and sat to lace his boots. Another hour spent here was one less on the road. He could not afford to wait. Frodo, not to be deterred, wrapped a round of cheese, a half-loaf of brown bread, and an apple into a rag and put the bundle in Thorin’s knapsack. “For later,” he said stoutly, and he went away to his room with a promise to soon return. When he did, he bore in his hands Thorin’s harp.

"I asked Tauriel to help me fix it,” he said, “and she gave me the name of a master carpenter in the city."

Thorin accepted it, shamed to remember how he had smashed it in his grief, and ran his hands over the smooth woodgrain. There was hardly a noticeable seam or bump, it was so expertly mended. “A kindly gift,” he said, stricken with resigned sorrow. He would miss this steadfast little lad, who had the spirit of his uncle and a goodness all his own. “I will play it proudly and remember you.” He bore it over to his pack and wrapped it in his fur mantle before tucking it inside.

"I have a gift for you as well," he said, and from his pocket he brought out one of the beads he had crafted at the elvish forge. He placed it in Frodo's palm, the silver bright against his skin. "It bears the mark of Durin. Any dwarf who sees it will know what you are to me and my kin."

Frodo's eyes were wide as he closed his small fingers around the bead. “Thank you.”

Thorin nodded and slung his satchel over his shoulder. Frodo stuffed the bead in his pocket and held out both of his hands -- Thorin took them, and with great solemnity he bent to touch their foreheads together. “Mahal tadnani astû, sanzigil tamkhihi astû. Mahal guide you and mithril find you. Farewell, my nephew.”

When Frodo drew back, his eyes were damp, but he smiled. “Farewell, Uncle.”

Thorin left the cottage by the Sea, where he had known happiness, and paused only once at the gate to look back. Frodo stood in the threshold, watching him go, his little face solemn. Thorin raised his hand, and Frodo waved, and they parted forever.

The road stretched long before him, but Thorin walked at a steady pace. He passed over the sandy dunes and into the forest, past the lake and the city walls. He crossed golden fields and flowering grasses, his footsteps stirring birds from their hedges. He followed the river on its green banks and turned his face to the West.

Undisturbed by elf or beast, he walked until the sun fell and then made camp in the shelter of the trees. He built no fire. He ate bread and cheese and slept wrapped in his cloak. In the early hours before dawn, he rose to continue on by moonlight. The land he passed was unfamiliar, but he was not afraid of losing his way. He kept close to the river and left an offering or two for the Lady of Mercy to guarantee his safe passage. As he travelled, he sang to himself, choosing walking songs that spoke fondly of home. When he ran out of verses, he composed several new melodies for his harp, and determinedly did not think of what he would say when he arrived at the Keep. He would speak from his heart, and he could only hope that it would be enough.

For five days and nights Thorin walked, stopping only to eat and take a few hours’ rest. In all his life, he had never travelled by himself -- it was strange and lonely, hearing no voice but his own. As a boy the royal guard had been his constant companions and he could not set foot from the mountain without a full retinue on his grandfather’s orders. After Erebor’s fall, he had journeyed with Frerin and Dís or Balin, and Dwalin, ever-vigilant friend and kingsguard, had been his constant shadow. Even in death, he had not journeyed to the afterlife alone.

Without Kíli’s mischief and Ulmo’s winds to blow him off course, Thorin reached the Outer Sea on the sixth afternoon, the wind as warm and the sand as white and desolate as he remembered. He bathed in the waves and made a fire on the shore, sitting by its light to brush the dried salt from his hair and beard. He stayed long enough to re-braid his hair and play a simple melody on his harp -- the water didn’t stir, but Thorin was quite sure he heard a fluting whistle on the wind in reply.

By dawn Thorin had passed into the valley, but as he crested the great hill, it was to find his path blocked.

His beard as red as fire in the sunlight, Lord Mahal stood before him with Bekhaz, Hammer of the Dwarrows, hefted on his shoulder. On his arm was the Green Lady, her vine-braids blooming with bright turquoise flowers.

“A good morning to you,” Lady Yavanna said.

Thorin’s pulse leapt, and for a moment, he feared it was a fever-dream brought on by too many sleepless nights. He hastily shuffled back, dropping to one knee. His heart pounded. He felt the cool press of a hand under his jaw, and he lifted his head.

Yavanna’s river-water eyes pinned his own as they had that day in Durin’s Keep. This time, however, she seemed pleased with what she found, for she drew back with a smile. “I will tell Sister Nienna that she need not weep for you anymore.”

Thorin closed his eyes. “Please, my lady -- the hobbit?”

“He dwells in Durin’s Keep,” Yavanna said.

Lifting his hand to his mouth, Thorin bowed his head again. “I thank you, Father, with all my soul, for allowing him passage into your Halls.”

Mahal huffed. “I did not let the impertinent little lad in! He stole his way inside, and I have not the heart to cast him out again.”

“His reputation as an expert burglar has proven unexaggerated,” the Lady said. As he caught her gaze, he saw a hint of satisfaction and secret mischief in the flicker of her eyes. Thorin felt a half-wild urge to laugh but mercifully was able to contain himself.

“What have you to say for yourself, son of Thráin?” Mahal said then, impatiently. “Your banishment must have incurred some regret in you, if you came here.”

“I miss the Halls. I miss my kin. Yet I cannot regret those years spent with him.”

Mahal did not seem angry. He sighed, and he looked then to Yavanna with a frown beneath his moustache. “I concede that you were right.”

Yavanna dipped her head graciously.

“It seems that my lady wife knows my children as well as I -- or better. Perhaps we are too much alike, Thorin Oakenshield. Perhaps I hewed you too closely to my own soul.”

Thorin took a steadying breath. “I am sorry to have brought you any grief or insult with my leaving. I did not leave because I was dissatisfied with my home, or for any reason but my wish to see Bilbo well again.”

“Do you think me made of stone? I know what it is to love.” He gazed at Thorin with hard eyes. “Do you wish to return?”

“I do.”

There was a moment of tense silence before Mahal heaved another great sigh. “My temper may have led me to make you choose. But I am capable of being merciful. I take no pleasure in being cruel.”

Yavanna laughed, the sound as sweet as cool rainwater. She plucked a flower from her braid and tucked it into Mahal’s flaming hair. She said to Thorin, “Your kin troubled my lord husband day in and day out with offerings and supplications for your return.”

Colour rose in Mahal’s face until his cheeks were as ruby-red as his beard, but he looked resigned. “My folk are unbreakable as diamond and stubborn as ancient granite. I made them that way. And your brother is the most hard-headed and persistent of them all; I had not a moment’s peace from his witless nattering.”

Dear Frerin! Thorin did not know whether he wanted to kiss or throttle his brother when they met again.

Mahal sobered then. “I would have an oath from you now. Will you return willingly to the Halls of your fathers, and dwell there in contentment until all should end?”

With no hesitation, Thorin laid his fingers in the massive, gauntleted palm of his Maker. “I will, if you grant me the honour.”

“So be it. It pained me like an open wound to have one of my own missing from my Halls.” Mahal clasped his hand in both of his own with a gentleness that restrained tremendous might, a dam before a rushing river. “Be welcome, son of Thráin, and come home.”

In a blink the great marble door of Mahal’s keep was before them. Thorin greedily drank in the sight of the runes and sweeping arches, his heart leaping with a delight that was uncontainable. Oh, to be home! To be among dwarrows once more, to see his kin and hold them close!

And Bilbo -- Bilbo was somewhere beyond those doors.

Mahal hefted high Bekhaz. The door unsealed, the stone swinging forward without so much as a groan. Yavanna took her husband’s arm, and together they walked inside, though she paused to look round at Thorin. “Come,” she said warmly, and Thorin ran up the low staircase.

No sooner had he reached the threshold than he was driven back by two bodies slamming into his chest. For a moment the world was a tangle of braids and beards and excited shouts, and Thorin clutched his sister-sons with disbelieving joy.

“Fíli! Kíli!” he cried, clasping their dear faces one by one. Scarcely had they pulled back before his arms were full of Frerin, and then Dís. His father wept loudly on his shoulder and patted his cheeks as though he weren’t entirely certain Thorin was real.

His mother grabbed his chin and pressed a teary kiss to his forehead. “Never again,” she said firmly. “Do you hear me, Thorin?”

“Never,” he promised.

“Brother,” Frerin said, tugging Thorin away by the hand. He pulled him toward the threshold, through the throng of dwarrows, and gave him a nudge. “Look over there.”

Thorin looked, and felt his breath catch in his throat. Standing between Balin and Dáin was Bilbo. He looked just as he had the day they met in Bag End, plump and healthy and strong, his face unlined, curls thick and shining red-gold once more. He wore his breeches and vest with a dwarvish coat, and one of Freís’s moonstone rings. On his brow glittered the oak leaf and lily-of-the-valley circlet. Their eyes met, and Bilbo beamed.

Thorin went to him at once, catching him up and kissing him fiercely. Over the quick pulse of his heart, he faintly heard the sound of Fíli and Kíli chortling and then yelping in the distance -- no doubt Dís had pulled them away by their hair -- and he felt Bilbo grin against his cheek.

“You are here,” he breathed.

“Well spotted.” Bilbo bussed his cheek, half-laughing, and then stretched up onto his toes to rest his head against Thorin’s shoulder.

Thorin threaded his fingers into soft curls and stroked smooth, young skin, unable to stop touching for fear that Bilbo might melt away, a figment of a dream. “You impossible creature.”

“You’ll never be rid of me now, I’m afraid.” His tone was flippant, but his hands clutched Thorin’s back with a desperation he couldn’t quite conceal, and Thorin held him closer.

“Good.”

They stood for a moment in perfect contentment, uncaring of the noise and bustle around them, but at length Bilbo turned his cheek against Thorin’s throat and slowly loosed his arms from Thorin’s shoulders.

“Your grandfather’s arranged a banquet in the Keep to welcome you home,” he murmured.

Thorin let him draw away, ghosting his fingers reverently over the crown he had forged in the depths of his loneliness, and he thought of the bead in his coat-pocket, waiting to be braided into Bilbo’s bright hair. “I’ve no need for food.”

Bilbo’s warm, merry laugh seemed to settle around him. “Well, I do.”

“Far be it from me to keep a hobbit from a feast.” Thorin kissed his smiling mouth once more, and hand-in-hand they crossed into the halls of his Maker.



 


 

Notes:

[1] - All credit for the bits of Khuzdul goes to the lovely Neo-Khuzdul dictionary, courtesy of The Dwarrow Scholar.
[2] - I can’t begin to thank all of you guys for the amount of encouragement and support I’ve gotten -- I honestly cannot believe the response this fic has received. So thank you! Each and every one of your comments and kudos made me smile.
[3] - There will be a one-shot sequel (and yes, it will be E-rated) that should show up in a week or two from Bilbo’s POV so we can find out exactly how he burgled his way into the Halls of Aulë and cover a bit of the fallout from Thorin’s homecoming. I’m not even going to pretend that it’s anything but gratuitous fluff and nonsense.

Series this work belongs to: