Chapter Text
CHAPTER EIGHT
THORIN
ON THE EVE OF HIS guests’ departure, Elrond hosted a lavish banquet that the dwarrows might part with Bilbo and Frodo with the memory of one last evening together.
Thorin did not have it in him to be suspicious of the elf-lord’s motives, nor did he take offense at the ill-concealed pity in Elrond’s eyes. Their hosts had been gracious, providing all manner of luxuries and accommodations, though doubtless it was done mostly out of respect for Bilbo -- on several occasions Thorin had seen carefully veiled distaste in elvish faces as they wandered the streets of Valmar.
It had been a long time since Thorin's waking hours had been marked by such gladness or such sorrow. Six brief days could not contain all the conversations of seventy years of separation, but valiantly did he and Bilbo try. They drank in the unearthly beauty of Valinor, walking together as they once had. Bilbo spoke of faraway lands he had seen and people he had known. He spoke of the Fellowship and watching Frodo march away with them to his doom. He spoke of his poems and songs and histories, stories collected painstakingly from across Middle-earth and translated into as many tongues as he could learn. He spoke of Bag End, and how lonely he had been before Frodo had come to him. In turn, he plumbed Thorin for stories of the Ever-lands: the majesty of Manwë’s mountain, the terrible beauty of the Green Lady, the music of the Watchman of the Seas, the magnificence of the Halls. Thorin was no storyteller, but Bilbo listened as though he were.
With a self-effacing bit of ceremony, he brought Thorin to his chamber one evening to show him the book he had written, bound in dyed leather and penned in that familiar neat hand. After some coaxing, Bilbo was cajoled into reading it for him, and for the first time Thorin found he was able to laugh at their misadventures.
“Did I truly seem so pompous to you?”
“Yes, but you do cut a grand figure. I was in awe of you at first, you know.”
Thorin frowned around the biscuit in his mouth. “At first?”
Bilbo sipped primly at his tea, but there was a smile in the curve of his cheek. He cleared his throat and returned his attention to the open book on his lap. “Now where did I leave off? Right after the goblin tunnels, I think.”
“I do not make speeches.”
“Yes, you do,” Bilbo said fondly, and turned the page.
Thorin did his best to engrave these moments in his memory. They would not be enough once he was again sealed away in Mahal’s keep, but they were all he could take with him. He was not alone in this resolve. As their time drew to its end, they were joined on their walks by Bifur and Bofur, Balin and Óin and Ori and the lads. Thorin was not so selfish that he could resent their company, nor the attention they were given. He had no cause to be jealous of Bilbo's love any longer.
As the sixth day dawned, Thorin woke to a curious calm. He stared at the canopy above his bed, rippled with shafts of light from the window. All through the night he had pondered what the next day would bring, prodding cautiously at the thought like one might poke at a rotten tooth. Again and again one notion came to him insistently, though he tried to ignore it, and the thought took root in his heart.
He and Bilbo spent the day wandering the bank of the lake and sitting on the high hills where the shimmering Sea was barely visible on the horizon. Thorin realized that they hadn’t finished his book and asked if they might, but Bilbo shook his head and said that perhaps it was best that they had not reached the end.
When dusk fell they returned to Elrond’s house, where lanterns were being hung and tables were being laid for the banquet. Soon the chamber was full of conversation and songs and good food, and if the conversation was quieter and the songs not so merry, it could not be helped. Thorin took a plate but found he could not eat; Bilbo’s appetite seemed to have fled from him as well. Through the whole evening he was subdued, and his hand gripped Thorin’s with a fierceness that spoke more clearly than his airy reassurances. Perhaps they had accepted that they must say goodbye -- perhaps Bilbo could be philosophical with so many long years behind him -- but their hearts were not so wise as their heads.
As troubled as he was, Bilbo tired quickly. Despite his faint protests, Frodo kindly but firmly persuaded him to retire before midnight. Thorin rose as the hobbit did and took his arm, but Bilbo waved him away.
“Please, no goodbyes tonight,” he said. “I’ll see you lot in the morning.”
Thorin cast his eyes over the table, cluttered with empty dishes and ringed with the faces of his kin, and hardened his resolve.
With their journey looming before them, Óin and Bifur soon excused themselves to catch what rest they could, and after wiping down his fiddle, Bofur joined them. Frerin rose to follow, but Thorin came to his feet. “Frerin, Dís,” he said, “stay here a moment. Balin, you as well.” He drove Fíli and Kíli to the fireside with a hand at each of their backs, and he heard his brother and sister fall into step behind him. The door creaked softly as Balin closed it.
“What is it?” Dís asked. “Thorin?”
Balin was gripping the door handle, his eyes closed, and Thorin realized then that he knew.
“Forgive me,” he said. Balin’s jaw clenched.
“Uncle Thorin?” Kíli ventured, but Fíli’s eyes were already widening.
“I am staying,” Thorin said.
There was no outcry, no commotion, no angry shouts or exclamations. An awful silence descended upon them all.
Fíli was the first to break it, with just a breath of a sound. “Please.”
It wrenched Thorin’s heart. “There is no other choice for me. Forgive me.” He couldn't bear to look at Fili's face any longer; he turned helplessly to Dís, who stared into the fire. "Sister." She jerked, and her gaze flew to meet his. Her eyes were wet.
“Dís ---”
She shook out her tunic and began to walk away; Thorin reached out and caught her wrist. “Sister!”
“You’re a fool,” Dís said coldly, and she wrested her hand away. Kíli was fast on her heels as she pushed furiously through the door, and Fíli, after a hesitation, followed.
Frerin was still, so still. He set his goblet on the mantle and his hand rose to his mouth. He turned away and left without a word.
Only Balin remained, still propped against the door-jam.
“Will you walk away too?” Thorin asked wearily.
“How many times are we to lose you, Thorin?”
His eyes burned. “I must do this. I must. Tell me you understand.”
“I do. It would be better if I didn’t.” Balin haltingly took him by the shoulders. “Bilbo won’t thank you for this. If I know him at all, he’ll be very angry at you. Are you absolutely certain?”
“I am.”
Balin clasped Thorin too tightly and for once seemed to have no words of wisdom to give.
***
Thorin sought out Bilbo at dawn the next morning and found him in Frodo’s rooms, taking before-breakfast tea. Frodo greeted him warmly and made as if to leave, but Thorin bid him stay and confessed all. It was a scene, for true to Balin’s prediction, Bilbo was furious, his shouts giving way to tears when he realized that Thorin would not be swayed.
“I will die,” he cried, “and then what will you do? You will be trapped here -- among elves, for mercy’s sake! -- with no kin or comfort! Would you do this to me, Thorin? Would you have me die with your fate weighing on me?” He made as though to storm away, but his rage had drained his strength; he fell back onto his chair with a huff or a sob. Thorin caught him up and held him until his enraged tears were spent.
“I have made my choice,” he said, and he felt Bilbo quiver against him. "I will see it through, though it may be selfish. That has ever been my weakness.”
Once they had calmed themselves a little, Frodo -- who had been lingering uneasily by the window, watching their argument unfold with anxious eyes -- brought them a fresh pot of tea. “Are the others still leaving this morning?” he asked Thorin softly, his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder.
“Yes.”
“Goodbyes are always difficult,” the little lad said with a sorrowful, faraway look. He poured more tea into Thorin’s cup and offered him the sugar bowl. “A friend once told me to think of them as promises to meet again.”
“Another elf friend?”
Frodo smiled. “A dwarf friend, actually.”
Bilbo’s voice startled them both, soft and strained though it was. “Please don’t do this.”
Thorin cupped his palms around the mug and let its warmth ground him. He would not be moved. He would be as granite in the water. “Do you not wish for me to stay?”
“They are your family. This is forever.”
“I know.”
Bilbo uttered a hoarse, strangled noise of frustration. “I have nothing to offer you, not even my company. I cannot promise that I will be here tomorrow.”
“Do you love me still?”
“Thorin.”
“Do you love me?”
Bilbo covered his face and sighed. “You know I do.”
“Then you offer me everything.” He reached across the table and tugged Bilbo’s hands away, cradling them between his own. “If I am to watch them leave today, I need your help.”
***
As Manwë had promised, three small ships bobbed on the waves of the Bay of Eldamar, their prows whittled into eagles with proud wooden beaks lifted to the sky. White sails fluttered in a wind that grew stronger as Thorin walked down the beach to the water where his Company were silently loading their packs into the crafts.
He paused to glance back at the rise where Bilbo, Frodo, and Tauriel stood, their faces drawn and solemn; behind them, at a respectful distance, were Gandalf and Elrond. Thorin turned to the shining sea and his kin, those whom he loved, and whom he should never see again.
I cannot, he thought, and despair caught him by the throat. His steps faltered. His eyes fell shut, and he felt the cool wind brush against his face like a gentle touch. I must.
“Go on,” Bilbo said quietly, and Thorin did.
Kíli saw him first. He dropped his pack, running clumsily up the sand and throwing himself in Thorin’s arms. His eyes were limned in red and his face was flushed. Around his neck the elf’s star-pendant glowed. He opened his lips to speak, mouthed wordlessly for a moment, and then buried his face against Thorin’s neck. As always, Fíli was just behind him, tucking his golden head under Thorin’s chin.
One-by-one, goodbyes were said, embraces shared, and not even Bofur could muster a smile. The stifled sobs of Fíli and Kíli were heartrending, and Frerin wept bitterly. Thorin kissed his brother’s forehead, smoothed his disheveled braid for the last time, and pulled away. Dís stood behind him.
“Dís, I --”
Reaching up into her hair, she withdrew her first-craft, a golden bead forged by her own hand when she came of age. With steady fingers, she wove a small braid in Thorin’s hair and clasped it with the bead. “So you will not forget your family,” she said, “and your sister, who loves you more than all the mithril in Erebor.”
Thorin grabbed her up and held her, pretending he did not feel tears on his neck. “Look after Amad and Adad,” he said, and her arms tightened. “Tell them . . . tell them . . . “ The words would not come.
All too soon, the ships were readied and boarded. The sails filled and the winds rose, and Thorin Oakenshield watched his Company depart one last time, standing alone at the water’s edge until their ships faded beyond the stretch of the Sea.
***
The little cottage on the bay was comfortable, though as far removed from the stone labyrinth of the Halls as it was possible to be. How strange were the delicate furnishings and cheerful curtains and the flowers that seemed to decorate every available surface; yet after a time Thorin came to enjoy the way the whole house seemed to warm in the sunlight.
It was good to be removed from the commotion of Valmar. The shores were barren, save for the occasional craft sailing into the bay. The woods were calm and undisturbed, and their cool stillness reminded Thorin of the forested slopes of Ered Luin. He spent many mornings wandering through the trees with Bilbo or Frodo, or by himself, and he took comfort in the small familiarity. Still, there were no dwarvish songs in the air, no steaming forges, no drum-beat of hammer on metal -- all the sounds that he had come to associate with home were absent. Yet with the constant music of the Sea and two talkative hobbits to fill the silences when they stretched too long, it was not a desolate place.
On one of his visits, Gandalf came bearing a gift for Thorin: a hand-harp, exquisitely crafted. Where he had gotten it, he would not say, but Bilbo, after inspecting it carefully, murmured discreetly to Thorin that he believed he had seen Elrond’s daughter play it once or twice, many years before. The sound of the harp -- a sound of home -- became a regular attendant to evenings by the fire.
Thorin's days were full and kept him well-occupied, and there was at last time and privacy enough for he and Bilbo to begin to learn each other again. Apart from the fleshly wear of age, Bilbo was different, in subtle but definite ways, from the halfling Thorin had known. He was more self-assured, vastly more playful, with a forthrightness that would have horrified the fussy green grocer Thorin had met in Bag End -- the years had evidently worn away his patience for nonsense and sharpened his wit. Yet there was kindness still, and the same cleverness and compassion that had once so intrigued him. For all the things that separated them still, Thorin’s love was as strong as it had ever been. He could have made no other choice. They were neither of them the same creatures they had been then, and as the days passed into weeks and they began to settle into this new, odd little life, Thorin could only suppose that it was for the better.
Both he and Frodo were much relieved to see Bilbo retain his new vigour, and they marked with pleasure the brightness that had returned to his eyes. The years did not turn back, for they could not, but he seemed younger in his bearing, and his old energy animated his voice once more.
For his part, Frodo seemed happier as well, different altogether from the forlorn hobbit Thorin had met in Smaug’s cave. As he stirred the house with his youthful bustle and came back from the city red-cheeked and telling stories of market gossip, it was easy for Thorin to see why Bilbo loved him so.
“He’s a good lad,” Thorin remarked as they sat in the garden and watched Frodo select a proper bouquet under his uncle’s exacting direction. “You raised him well.”
“I shan’t disagree with that first bit, but I can’t take credit for it. I looked after him now and then for Prim when he was a wee thing, but he didn’t come to stay with me until he was nearly grown.” Bilbo examined the hole he’d dug with a critical eye before setting aside his spade. “Hand me a few of those carrot seeds, would you?”
The preeminence of gardening in his new lifestyle had been one more adjustment to bear. Thorin found himself so often wrist-deep in the loamy black soil of the vegetable patch that he began to fear that he would never be able to prise all the dirt from under his fingernails. He had no talent for nurturing the fragile buds and bulbs, but Bilbo and Frodo were patient tutors. When his temper flared over a broken stalk, they hid their smiles -- poorly, but it was a kind thought -- and helped him salvage what he could. He would readily admit that there was some satisfaction to be found in uncovering the ensuing crop of potatoes and beets and sugar-sweet peas.Less appealing was the gathering of the flower arrangements that filled their cottage. It was apparently an art much prized by hobbits. Thorin could not say that he understood it, though the blooms wafted a pleasant fragrance around the house and the colours were pretty enough to look at. It seemed foolish to expend so much time and energy on something that would wither and fade within the week. A good, strong blade, well-made, or an emerald necklace would last years, decades -- generations, if the quality were particularly fine -- and that Thorin could understand. This manner of craftsmanship was admittedly beyond him. There was a master blacksmith in Valmar, with a forge that was said to be expansive, but Thorin could notbring himself to go. In time, perhaps, when the wound was less fresh.
With his harp and his walks, the homely cottage, the garden, and the company of hobbits, Thorin was for the most part content. If, in the stillness of the night, he longed to hear his father’s voice and see the beautiful stone arches of Durin’s Keep, he kept such thoughts to himself.
***
Bilbo was making his mother’s tea biscuits, demonstrating the tricks she had used and gladly making use of Thorin’s strength for the kneading -- his own hands had grown too unsteady to do it properly. Under the guise of ‘helping’, Frodo had perched himself by the hearth, reading a book and happily sampling each of the batches they produced.
Later, Thorin could not say what it was that drove him to speak at that moment. It may have been the sugar-scented warmth of the kitchen, or the brightness of the sunlight through the window, or the bit of flour that dotted the end of Bilbo’s nose as he cut the flattened dough into neat squares.
“Marry me,” Thorin said.
Bilbo’s hands froze. There was a strangled sound from the hearth as Frodo choked on his biscuit. He coughed wildly, cleared his throat, and gathered up his book before uttering a hasty excuse and scurrying out into the garden.
“Do try not to kill my nephew, Thorin! He is the only one I have.”
Thorin reached for the hobbit’s hand, stirring a puff of flour between them. “I have long wished us to be bound together in all ways.”
The look Bilbo gave him then was very dry indeed. “At my age? You would speed me to my grave. My heart would give out.”
To his horror, Thorin felt the blushing heat in his cheeks. “That is not . . . that’s not what I meant.” He waited until Bilbo’s laughter tapered away, and he coughed meaningfully. “A simple ceremony is all I desire. There need not be even guests, apart from Frodo, and maybe the wizard if he insists on it. I wish to call you mine. Will you not grant me this?”
Bilbo’s amusement was tempered by a warm affection that soothed Thorin’s injured pride. “I always suspected that there was a streak of sentimentality hidden beneath all that hair.” He gave one of Thorin’s braids a playful tug. “I would feel rather dastardly, you know, a decrepit old creature like me snapping up a bright young thing like you.”
Thorin snorted. “I haven’t been a ‘bright young thing’ in over two hundred years. And I am still older than you.”
With a shake of his head, Bilbo took up his knife and began patiently slicing the dough again. “Ask me again later.”
“Bilbo ---”
Bilbo’s smile was rueful. “Later, Thorin.”
FRODO
ONE YEAR PASSED INTO ANOTHER, and all was well in the cottage by the Sea.
This adventure, thankfully, had ended more pleasantly than the last for Frodo. Before vanishing again into who-knew-where, Gandalf had left a sheaf of crisp paper and a bottle of fine black ink on Frodo’s writing desk. On those pages, Frodo told what he felt was his last story: tales of the Valar, the wonders of the Ever-lands, and the reunion of friends long after death had parted them.
He would give this book to Sam, he decided, when they met again.
The little turquoise stone from Nienna’s river he kept with him nearly at all times. There was a jeweller in Valmar who was happy to set it in a silver pendant for him, and Frodo wore it on a length of chain around his neck, as a reminder. To his eternal gratitude, this weight was not a heavy one to bear.
It was difficult to accept that their small family of two had become three. Frodo was not used to having another to help with Bilbo’s care, nor to take a share of his attention, and at first they all struggled a little to find their places. Thorin was not accustomed to a confined, provincial life -- this much was apparent nearly from their first day back in the cottage -- but he did try, and in time they struck upon an arrangement that suited them all. With this uncertainty settled, comfort and ease soon followed. Thorin took particular care not to step upon the responsibilities that Frodo had long held in their household, and Frodo came to think warmly of him for it. Brusque and rough he was, but Thorin could be kind when the mood struck him. He doted on Bilbo, and though their quarrels could be alarmingly loud and fierce, Frodo would have expected nothing less from two such strong and disparate personalities.
It was, in many respects, a curious relationship. Bilbo was hardly at a marriageable age, but Thorin was determined to have him properly. He asked several times, formally and on the spur of the moment, at tea, out in the garden, late in the evening by the fireside, and each time Bilbo smiled, told him he loved him, and said no. Thorin did not press him, but he was not deterred from asking again later. Frodo thought it a little hard of Bilbo, for Thorin’s disappointment was evident with each rejection, but he knew that it was not done out of callousness. There must be some reason for this game, even if that reason made sense only to Bilbo himself. In honesty, Frodo found them equally bewildering. Perhaps it was just as well that he had never fallen in love.
When he wasn’t with Bilbo or helping in the garden, Thorin sat in the yard, carving and whittling. He was not, he told Frodo, much of a woodworker, but it was something to keep himself busy without taking him too far from the cottage. His earliest attempts at furniture were pitiful, and his figurines grotesque. Still, with a stubbornness that seemed innate to the dwarves, he kept practicing until he was able to produce a passable bowl or ornament, which he promptly made gifts of -- the top of Frodo’s chest-of-drawers had become cluttered with lopsided jewel boxes that he had nowhere else to put and very little to put in. Bilbo seemed tremendously amused by the whole business.
If nothing else, Thorin was very good at fixing up the house. He had the varied knowledge of a tinkerer due to many years of labour in rented forges and travelling markets. (Folk were willing to pay more if one could provide more services than expected, and Men above all valued the jack-of-all-trades -- though Men were also, Thorin added with some disgust, the shiftiest with their coin.)
With Thorin’s woodworking and Bilbo’s gardening and Frodo’s writing, the cottage was busy and active from morning till night. They received many visitors, and if Thorin was not always entirely cordial with their elven guests, he seemed resigned to them. He tolerated Elrond best and had softened towards Tauriel, who often came to spend an idle afternoon with Frodo. One morning he had even found the two of them arguing, with evident mutual enjoyment, about the correct method of disemboweling orcs.
Frodo did not always stay close to home. He went out into the woods with Tauriel to practice his archery, dined with Elrond and his sons, and joined Galadriel on walks through the Gardens of Lórien. He began to spend more time in the markets and the dining halls, learning the histories of his neighbours and striking up conversations with strangers. He had kept himself distant before, as a guest might attend without engaging; whether he wished it or not, Valmar was now his home. It was a home that could not be lost or soured by the passing of time and distance. Here, in the land always changing and yet never changed, he could return from a journey to find the cottage in the Bay unaltered, its gardens still blooming -- home to his favourite uncle and a sullen dwarf-king of whom he was growing fond. And perhaps, if he were very lucky, he could be happy here until Yavanna called him home to the Pastures.
It was a lovely hope, one that Frodo clung to until he began to feel that he believed it. Valmar had become familiar, its streets filled with friends, and the cottage was always there when he returned from his rambles. He had stability, and he had a home, and gradually it became easier to push aside the lingering feeling of loss. They were comfortable, the three of them, and if Thorin occasionally watched the Sea with something wistful in his eyes, Frodo understood too well to remark upon it.
***
A frantic shout startled Frodo in the night, and he tumbled halfway out of his bed before he realized what had woken him. His heart beat like a rabbit’s as he cast his eyes around the dark room for danger, a hidden enemy or a drawn blade -- the door flew open, and there was Thorin in his nightshirt, his chest heaving like a bellows, hair in a careless knot over his shoulders.
Frodo did not even have to wonder. He shrugged on his robe, snatched up a candle, and ran down the hall with Thorin fast at his heels.
Amid a mountain of bedding, Bilbo was flushed and damp, shaking, his thin hands clutching the blankets to his chest. Every coughing breath was laboured, and his complexion was colourless in the candlelight. He turned his head fitfully on his pillow, and he met Frodo’s eyes. In his face, behind the discomfort, was quiet resignation.
Oh, Bilbo, no.
He crawled onto the bed and took Bilbo's wrist; the papery skin was waxy and hot to the touch. “How long has he been like this?” he demanded.
“I don’t know,” Thorin said in great distress. “I only woke a few moments ago.” He crossed to the other side of the bed and knelt over Bilbo, stroking his hair soothingly before laying a palm against his forehead. “He said he felt a little warm earlier, but he was not feverish.”
“Tea,” Bilbo rasped. “Thorin.”
Thorin leapt up with a haste that might have been amusing in any other circumstance; his bare feet thundered on the floorboards as he stomped away to the kitchen. The faint sound of pots clattering echoed down the hall.
“What can I do?” Frodo straightened the twisted bedding anxiously. “What can I do for you? Are you in pain?”
Bilbo stopped his fussing, prising away his hand with a startling strength. “Look after him, won’t you?” He paused to catch his breath. “Don’t let him do anything foolish until I come back.”
“Bilbo . . . .”
“None of that, now -- no tears.” He lifted one hand to Frodo’s cheek and caressed it. “My dear boy, my Frodo. Oh, how I shall miss you.”
Frodo’s sight blurred. He scrubbed miserably at his eyes and screwed them shut. “Please,” he began, and trailed off helplessly.
Bilbo grasped his neck and gave him a little shake; Frodo opened his stinging eyes and found his uncle smiling a weak smile. “Come now,” he murmured. “I’m old and tired, and she’s come for me.” His smile quivered and slipped, and his eyes gleamed with unshed tears. “I’m so sorry.”
Frodo took a breath and reached for his hands again. “I’ll see you again soon,” he whispered. “We’ll all be together then: you and I and Mum and Pa and Aunt Belladonna, Sam and Hamfast and Merry and Pip . . . .”
But Bilbo was not comforted. His lips trembled. “No,” he said. “I’m sorry. What a good lad you are. Forgive me for being so selfish.”
Heavy footsteps pounded back up the hall, and Thorin appeared with a teacup in hand. “Here, Bilbo, drink.” Thorin helped him take a few sips, but the effort seemed to exhaust him.
Once the cup was set aside, Bilbo closed his eyes and sank into the pillows. “I’m sorry,” he murmured again. “I don’t want to leave you.”
Thorin pressed Bilbo’s hand fervently to his lips. Frodo rested his head on his uncle’s breast, feeling the sluggish heartbeat beneath his ear as it stuttered and slowed. They spoke to him quietly, bathing his face with cool water, and kept watch as he faded from listless, shivering sleep into silent insensibility.
Thorin touched Bilbo’s twitching shoulder, and then his cheek, but there was no response. His face was stoic, but when he looked up at Frodo, there was something desperate and half-wild in his eyes. “If we called for Elrond . . . .”
Though it pained him to do it, Frodo shook his head. If Yavanna had come for Bilbo, no elvish magic would bring him back.
They didn’t speak another word that night.
***
The morning dawned cool and sunny, and Frodo stood on the doorstep, blinking sore eyes against the light as a cloaked figure approached the gate.
It was Tauriel, her face full of sorrow. “Lord Elrond will be here soon, mellon nín,” she said as she hastened up the path to join him. “He will be buried with every honour, and songs will be sung of him in Valinor for Ages. We share in your grief.” She touched his chest fleetingly. “Where is Thorin?”
“Inside.” Frodo took a deep breath and rubbed his eyes. “He’s saying prayers over . . . over the body.”
She took his hand, and there on the front step they kept their vigil. Thorin’s voice rose and ebbed unbroken, a low, moaning chant; Frodo didn’t know the Khuzdul, of course, but he understood the meaning all the same. Hobbits had their own funeral dirges to help souls safely find the path to the Pastures, and he felt a sudden fierce longing for Pippin, who would have sung the sweetest for Bilbo.
Some time after Thorin’s song had ceased, two more figures came up the path. Frodo nearly sobbed with his relief. Gandalf’s arms held him tightly, and he said nothing when Frodo could not bring himself to let go. Elrond went inside, braving Thorin’s wrath to see that the body was properly tended. No shouts or curses followed, and Frodo supposed that the shock of loss was keeping the dwarf’s temper in check. The thought was no comfort.
Bilbo was laid out, and though it was Frodo’s duty to prepare the body for burning, he found that he could not bear to look at him so still and lifeless. Instead he sat with Thorin in numb silence by the hearth while the others saw to the arrangements. The hands of Tauriel and Elrond were reverent and gentle as they bathed and bound the body in soft linen, and if the wizard shed a tear or two as he bid farewell to his old friend, no one drew attention to it.
"We have lost a great soul," Elrond said as he smoothed the shroud over Bilbo's head. He bent and pressed his lips solemnly to the cloth. "Rest well, Wanderer, Child of the West, Teller of Tales, Friend of elf and dwarf and Man alike."
At Frodo's side, Thorin shuddered. His chest heaved, but he kept his silence. Frodo drew closer to him as Gandalf carried the body away.
The burial was arranged in the traditional hobbit fashion. No tomb or casket would be built, for Bilbo would be returned to the earth as dust. The funeral was held at dusk on a hilltop overlooking the Sea. To Frodo it seemed that nearly every elf in Valmar came to see the elf-friend’s ashes buried, and overwhelmed with grief though he was, his chest swelled with pride. Galadriel spoke her blessings over the grave, her golden hair bound up in a white veil. With Gandalf and Thorin beside him, Frodo tipped the ashes from their wooden bowl and watched them mingle with the good, rich earth of Valinor.
Farewell, Bilbo, he thought, and his tears fell unchecked.
Haunting elvish songs of love and remembrance rose and fell on the wind long into the night.
