Chapter Text
The Unsent led them into a round, high-ceilinged room not unlike the entryways of many of the temples. There was a staircase with a door at the top, and there an ethereal woman waited. Like the Unsent leading them, she was fuzzy around the edges, suggesting she was Unsent as well. But she seemed both more solid and yet more airy than the other Unsent, as if she had not been fully solid in life either. Her long dark hair seemed to float, as if she had her own personal wind flowing around her head. There was really no question about who this was.
“The Lady Luthien,” the Unsent announced with a flowery bow. Gandalf and Bilbo followed suit more sedately, and the dwarves reluctantly followed their lead.
“You are very welcome here, Summoner Thorin,” Luthien said, her voice deeper and more melodic than expected. Somehow after been dead for so long, Bilbo had expected something of her to degrade.
Thorin, for his part, was obviously biting back some of his ruder thoughts. His jaw was clenched far too tight to be comfortable, but something told Bilbo to leave it alone. Thorin was afraid, though of what he couldn’t say.
“Where is the fayth?” Thorin asked brusquely, after a perfunctory greeting of his own.
“It is as you saw,” Luthien said simply. “That fayth was my husband, Beren. He defeated Sin, and then in time became a new Sin. Summoners came forth to defeat him, one of their guardians becoming a fayth, and eventually one succeeded. They too became a new Sin in time, changing Sin. Making it take a new form. So the cycle began, so it has continued.”
It was like they had all been struck in the chest. Bilbo felt the breath go out of him, and Thorin looked similarly stricken. He had been prepared to die, but to ask another to go with him, and to become Sin until the next High Summoner came along? Maybe they had just misunderstood. How could something so awful be true?
“One of my guardians… has to become the final aeon?” Thorin asked, as if forcing the words from his body.
Luthien nodded. “The stronger the bond between summoner and guardian, the stronger the aeon. The better chance you have of defeating Sin. Your chosen guardian will become Spira’s hope, banishing the darkness for a time.”
Suddenly the conversations they had witnessed between shades of summoners and guardians made complete sense. Captain Bard’s guardian had been his wife, and who would really want to repeat the tragedy of Beren and Luthien, both dying for nothing, all things considered? No wonder he had said that he had to think of his children. Captain Bard had quit being a summoner, but what had become of his wife in the end?
Bilbo grimaced. That wasn’t what he was here to ask about, upsetting as it was. Not only did Thorin have to choose someone to sacrifice, but the stronger the bond, the better it would be. Not that anyone here wasn’t precious to Thorin in some way, but to sacrifice the dearest of them…
“We’ll do it,” Fili said without any hesitation. Kili nodded in agreement, though it didn’t escape Bilbo’s notice that he was shaking. “Kili and I. You can take two people, right?”
Luthien nodded. “Few are willing to sacrifice even the one required, let alone two. But I can turn as many as want to into fayth. Perhaps it would be easier to become Spira’s hope together.”
Thorin swallowed thickly, looking positively torn. He had promised his sister that he wouldn’t let anything happen to her sons, and here they were offering to become his final aeon!
“A moment,” Thorin interrupted, one hand massaging his temples. “I need a moment.”
“Take your time,” Luthien assured him, her eyes full of understanding that seemed out of place given the choice she was presenting. Shouldn’t she of all people have tried to find another way under the circumstances? “I will wait beyond this door for your answer. Rest here. No fiends will trouble you. You shall have peace and quiet to make your decision.”
There would be quiet maybe, but the haunted look in Thorin’s eyes suggested there would be no peace. Not when his nephews had been the first to offer their lives. But then, what other choices did Thorin have? Balin and Dwalin were both his cousins, sword-brothers since youth. Gandalf had been through all of this so many times, and though his help was valued, the bond there would not do the job. As for Bilbo, well… He couldn’t pretend that he would be a better choice than any of the others. Putting aside how short a time they’d known each other, would it even work? He wasn’t real. Could a dream become a fayth? Did he even want to? It almost felt like settling; if he couldn’t save Thorin, he could at least die with him.
Luthien faded, and Thorin sank to the ground heavily.
“Let us do it,” Kili insisted, finding his voice at last. “We want to defeat Sin as much as you do!”
“But then you would become a new Sin in turn,” Thorin reminded him, looking into his nephew’s eyes. “You would stay that way until someone else managed to defeat you. It could be a centuries long wait, and by then, your souls would be stained with blood.”
“But at least Sin would be out of the mountain,” Fili argued. “We’ve never been inside it. We wouldn’t miss it.”
“You lads have much to live for,” Balin argued, earning a grateful look from Thorin for his intervention. “And if you die with Thorin, the succession will be thrown into chaos. Think of your mother! I could not enter a Travel Agency again without fearing death at her hands if I didn’t try to stop you.”
That had some of the desired effect, Fili and Kili both looking down sheepishly. Dwalin saw his chance and took it.
“You love Thorin,” he said simply. “We all do. But it should be me.”
There was something to admire about the way Dwalin offered no justifications. He said it like it was true, and maybe it was. Dwalin probably would make the strongest final aeon, just based on his physical strength and bond with Thorin.
It was Dwalin’s turn to argue with Thorin, though they switched to their native language to do it. That only left Bilbo and Gandalf unable to understand, though Bilbo got the impression that maybe Gandalf understood more than he was letting on. Then Dwalin gave Bilbo a look, and he understood too. Dwalin was telling him to keep quiet. To live through all of this, and tell everyone the truth, something Gandalf hadn’t been able to do. But then, defying their expectations was something Bilbo was becoming practiced at these days.
“Wait just a second,” he said, interrupting Thorin and Dwalin. “Thorin, you said you would let me talk to Lady Luthien, remember?”
“I did, but-”
“No buts,” Bilbo insisted. “Why are you all getting twisted up over who is going to die with Thorin when there still might be another way? Save those kinds of decisions for when we really know it has to happen.”
The dwarves all wore pitying expressions, even Fili and Kili who had apparently given up at last, despite their earlier optimism. Now, faced with the true weight of the sacrifice he was expected to make, Thorin no longer had much hope of doing anything else, it seemed, though he would do it very unwillingly. It was as if Luthien’s words had made it all real to him, and his life so far had just been a dream. Unexpectedly, it was Gandalf who backed Bilbo up.
“Bilbo is right,” he said. “I have walked many summoners to exactly this same point, and faced with the decision you now have, none of them truly thought to try something else. They thought that because an ancient Unsent told them to do it, there must truly be no other way. Such a terrible thing must be true and utterly unavoidable, they told themselves. To question that, to take advantage of such a long memory, never even occurred to them.”
“Gandalf, are you saying there’s another way?” Thorin asked, eyebrows raised in surprise. “You said nothing before.”
“I don’t know if there is another way,” Gandalf admitted. “But I believe there must be, and so I wouldn’t have you line up your guardians for execution just yet. I thought you believed that if anyone could find out, it would be Bilbo.”
“I do believe that,” Thorin replied stubbornly. “I have always believed it. But that does not mean another way exists.”
“Then let us continue to believe it, and do our best not to fall into the trap of ‘there is no other way,’” Gandalf said with a satisfied nod. “Many summoners have faced Sin in the same way, believing that this time might just be the last one. But some say the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over while expecting a different result.”
“You would know,” Thorin observed, crossing his arms. Bilbo wanted to march right over there and demand Thorin apologize for his rudeness, but to everyone’s surprise, Gandalf just sighed. It was like watching the weight of all of the pilgrimages he’d been on had finally caught up with him, and something clicked in Bilbo’s mind, like he’d just been given the last piece of the puzzle that was Gandalf.
“Yes,” the so-called legendary guardian admitted. “I would.”
Thorin decided they would spend the night below the stairs, and face Luthien in the morning. He needed time to think, he claimed, and when pressed insisted that he wasn’t trying to decide which of his guardians would become the fayth. If not for the long look Thorin gave Bilbo as he said this, Bilbo might not have believed him. Thorin was conflicted. For the first time, it seemed like he might be willing to give up rather than let someone die along with him. Normally, Bilbo might have taken the opportunity to add his own voice to Thorin’s thoughts, encouraging him to value the lives of his kin, particularly his nephews, but this time he kept silent.
Bilbo remembered the shades of the summoners and guardians, and some of them still swirled about the room, snatches of conversation audible. With these long dead souls debating the merits of the sacrifice they would inevitably make, what else was left for them to say? If Thorin wanted to think, let him. When they went through that door, Bilbo would ask Luthien what had happened when Gil-Galad and Elendil had fought Sin. He would demand she explain what the difference had been, because she of all people had to know. And there, maybe, there would be some hint for what else they could do. He didn’t expect Luthien to have all of the answers. Who could say when the last time she had left the ruins of Doriath had been? But she had to know something.
And what if she didn’t? Would he let one of the dwarves become a fayth, just to take advantage of what all the fayth knew? They weren’t elves. Once they became a fayth, there could be no return. To save Thorin, would he let one of the others sacrifice themself? It felt like such a zero sum game, this business of saving Spira while saving the summoners.
Bilbo sighed and ran his hands through his hair in frustration. Maybe it was time to actually have a talk with Gandalf, he thought with a look at the legendary guardian. Gandalf, as was often the case, sat off to one side, slightly apart from the rest of them. Having carried the secrets they had just learned for so long, of course he wouldn’t feel welcome. Though, would Thorin have even set out on a pilgrimage had he known that he wouldn’t be the only casualty? If he had known that fighting Sin this way could never lead to the desired outcome?
Gandalf noticed his attention, and nodded slightly. An invitation to join him that Bilbo would not refuse.
“There are a few things I should tell you,” Gandalf admitted. “Now that I think you will believe them.”
“Such as?” It was unlike Gandalf to just volunteer information unless it served his purpose in some way. Not that he was complaining.
“I believe you are wondering how I managed to enter the Shire in the first place, how a real person managed to enter the dream world,” Gandalf offered, eyebrows raised in a silent question.
Of course he had wondered it, wondered if that information could be useful in dealing with Sin somehow, though at the moment it was the farthest thought from his mind. It had felt too much like a dead end to be worth pursuing. Still, Bilbo glanced back at the dwarves to see if any of them could hear before answering.
“Or how a dream person managed to leave it,” Bilbo added.
“Well, that part is easier than you might suppose,” Gandalf said. “When Sin entered the dream in order to defend it from me, it touched you. Sin’s power is great enough that you became somewhat more real. Real enough that you could not stay in the dream.”
“That doesn’t make any sense at all,” Bilbo pointed out. “How can anything just make someone real?”
“If you ask Lady Luthien the right questions, I believe she may know the answer. I do not,” Gandalf said with visible regret. “But as for how I made it into the dream, well… I believe a demonstration would be more illustrative.”
At first nothing seemed to happen, and they sat there in silence. Then, Bilbo hear the faint moan of pyreflies, growing louder and louder, until they were floating around Gandalf’s body. Again Bilbo glanced back to see if the dwarves had noticed, but their minds were on their own concerns, and they had turned away.
“You’re dead?” Bilbo hissed in disbelief. “How long has this been going on?”
“A long, long time,” Gandalf admitted. “Not as long as Lady Luthien, but long enough, certainly.”
“But… you’re a Legendary Guardian! You’ve accompanied High Summoners! Were you dead that entire time?” Bilbo struggled to keep his voice down. He’d known Gandalf for most of his life, and he’d never noticed that his mother’s old friend was dead!
“I have been dead for most of that time, yes,” Gandalf said. “It is not that different from being alive, if you have the strength of will to endure it. Though, my memory is not what it used to be. I suspect it will not be long before I must insist on being Sent, to avoid becoming a fiend. This is likely my last pilgrimage, and I wanted it to be a significant one.”
“But-! If you’ve been doing this for so long, even through death itself, and even you don’t know of another way…” Bilbo felt like the ground had dropped out from under him. Gandalf always had a plan. But where had that been for the other summoners he’d brought to their deaths?
“My plan was a long time coming together,” Gandalf told him. “And the machinations of Yevon, led by Saruman, often impeded me. The fayth will not speak to just anyone, you know. If another summoners guardian had entered their chamber, demanding questions of them, that summoners pilgrimage might have been doomed by it.”
“Really?” It was rather alarming to realize that he really had risked Thorin’s success all those times.
“They are used to doing the asking, and after so much time set in stone, they are not always open to change,” Gandalf explained. “But, the residents of the dream world are precious to them, and the fayth view them all as their children. In some cases, as the children they were never able to have while alive. When I learned about the ancient dream of the fayth, I knew that one of the inhabitants would be the key, somehow. You have certainly enriched Thorin’s bonds with his aeons, if nothing else.”
“But what am I supposed to do? They haven’t told me anything useful so far. Nothing I can use to help Thorin,” Bilbo reminded him bitterly, turning over the ring in his pocket. “And Luthien isn’t a fayth.”
“No,” Gandalf agreed. “But you have good manners, and compared to Thorin, certainly, that is an advantage. And, I believe you found something in Isildur’s cave.”
Bilbo’s blood chilled. He hadn’t thought anyone but Thorin knew about it.
“I don’t know what-”
“Isildur was an avaricious fayth, and yet you convinced him to part with something,” Gandalf continued. “What he parted with doesn’t matter. I believe your powers of persuasion will be enough.”
That remained to be seen, as well as why Gandalf couldn’t just bargain with her himself. They were both dead after all, why couldn’t they just come to an agreement? Bilbo could add that to the list of things he never would have expected to think before leaving the Shire. The list was getting long.
