Actions

Work Header

An Unexpected Pilgrimage

Chapter 26: Yevon

Notes:

So much talking once again, so many plot bombs dropped, so please let me know if something doesn't make sense. Again it's based on what happened in the game, with some additions of my own, so I wonder.

Chapter Text

“I am ready,” Thorin announced in the morning, though his hands were tightly clenched, belying his words.

As one, the company rose, and entered the door Luthien had indicated. Bilbo’s palms were sweaty, and he found himself clutching the ring to keep them steady. He needed to keep it together. And if in the end Gandalf was wrong, he needed to steel himself for that too.

The door did not lead deeper into the temple, but outside, onto the top of the dome. The whole of the ruined city was laid out beneath them, but for once Bilbo did not have the heart to admire ruins. Was this what Luthien’s shade looked at every day, for thousands of years, as she led summoners to their deaths? She was there now, staring out at the city. A dead summoner, waiting in the ruins of her dead city, unable to defeat the creature that destroyed it.

Bilbo found himself pitying Luthien as they approached her. She had not always accepted such sacrifices in stride. There was no way that her husband becoming a fayth had been easy for her. If it had been, it wouldn’t have been a sacrifice. It wouldn’t have worked. If it seemed that her emotion and compassion had dried up over the ages, who could really blame her? Her presence there was proof that she hadn’t really wanted to die. That she had not become a fiend was proof that she still wanted to save the living, even if she had long since given up on finding another way to do it. If he could reach that part of her, maybe she would help them.

“Have you decided?” Luthien asked, turning toward them slowly. “Have you chosen the person who will renew Spira’s hope?”

They all turned to Thorin, but he didn’t answer immediately. The turmoil in his eyes was obvious, and Bilbo wanted to shake him, but he just waited with the others. His chance would come. But Thorin had to allow it. If he didn’t, there was no point in trying to save him.

“I have decided,” Thorin repeated at last. “I love my people. If dying would save them from Sin, I would do it instantly and without hesitation. But I will not ask that of another without knowing if there is another way, a more permanent way. I won’t choose a final aeon.”

The first trace of emotion appeared on Luthien’s face, sadness creasing the corners of her eyes. “If there were another way, do you think I would not have found it ages ago? Sin was born of two beings of great power, two Maia locked in battle. Their battle raged on for days, weeks, months, until eventually the power involved was too great. They became one being, always fighting for dominance within itself. Against that, only an aeon can prevail, even if in the end it becomes Sin’s armor, drawn into the battle and wrapped around it to prevent further interference.”

Thorin frowned, but Bilbo saw his opportunity. This was new information, and she had just volunteered it, in the hope of pushing a summoner back onto his path. Maybe he had a chance to learn something useful after all.

“Er, how do you know, though?” Bilbo asked, doing his best not to flinch when Luthien turned her piercing gaze on him. He had seen worse, after all. “I’ve never heard anyone talk about what Sin really is before, or what exactly a ‘Maia’ is.”

Luthien sighed this time, and he knew he’d won. She was going to answer.

“One of the beings within Sin is my mother,” she said. “The other is a servant of the great evil that once threatened this land. Together, they comprise the entity known as Yevon, the heart of Sin. Maiar are beings of great power, falling just below the Valar.”

“Yevon?” Fili breathed. “Yevon is the heart of Sin?”

Suddenly Glorfindel’s words about the corrupted fayth made sense. While elves became fayth through the power of the Valar, other races were able to due to the birth of Yevon, he had said. Most likely the result of the power of two Maia, and the will of the good soul comprising Yevon, to give her daughter a weapon against them. It was different from how fayth had generally been born before, and there was a dark power involved as well as the ones of light, resulting in ‘corrupted’ aeons. Then others followed in Luthien’s footsteps, and eventually it became ‘the way things are done.’

“Is there no way to separate the being of light from the being of darkness?” Balin asked, surprising Bilbo. The floodgates had opened, apparently, and now their private doubts were coming to light. “If she were able to gain control of the battle, would that not be the end of Sin?”

Luthien shook her head, her eyes looking fiercer and less dull by the minute. “It was the first thing I tried. To help my mother cast down Mairon must prevent the cycle from continuing, or so I hoped But you cannot get close to where they fight. The aeon that becomes Sin protects them, and without an aeon of equal power it cannot be defeated. Then, it will be drawn into their battle and protect them. There is nothing that can be done.”

The ring throbbed in Bilbo’s pocket at the mention of the name ‘Mairon,’ and he remembered his original question.

“What about when Gil Galad and Elendil fought Sin?” Bilbo asked. “Everyone says Sin was weakened permanently by that fight.”

“It was, but how, I do not know,” Luthien admitted. “I was not there, and despite what you might think, I am not omnipotent. They must have influenced the battle somehow, but I cannot imagine how.”

Now it was Bilbo’s turn to be disappointed, the ring a comforting weight in his hand. There had to be a way, and now they had some clues, but was it enough to turn Thorin aside? Looking at the dwarf, his brow was furrowed in deep thought, his fingers toying with his short beard. Unconsciously, Bilbo moved closer to him, noticing how the deep furrows in Thorin’s forehead smoothed out a little as a result. They were so close to saving Thorin, and he felt like he had to remind him to keep thinking, to keep fighting for another way out.

“If there is a way to defeat the aeon being used as armor without creating a final aeon, I see no reason to waste our lives giving it new armor,” Thorin said at last, with a slight smile. “If we can do that, we should be able to get near the battle. That is where other summoners made their mistakes.”

“But what would you do then?” Luthien pointed out, apparently still invested in their success despite Thorin’s unwillingness to do things her way. “In a battle between such beings, you can play no part except to be killed quickly.”

“Gil Galad and Elendil did something inside Sin,” Thorin reminded her with a grateful look at Bilbo. “They must have influenced the battle in some way. I find that more promising than sacrificing one of my nephews or cousins to give Sin another shield, even if I do not know what they did.”

Luthien shook her head again. “The stubbornness of dwarves has always been your downfall. Sin cannot be destroyed just by guessing blindly.”

“But isn’t that what you did?” Bilbo realized. “You assumed that nothing but an aeon could stop them, and you just gave them another weapon in the process. At least if we fail, Sin won’t be any stronger.”

Luthien’s eyes widened, and Bilbo could feel the eyes of the company on him as well. It had certainly been a very Tookish thing to say, but well, wasn’t Luthien just as responsible for this mess as the people who made up Sin, in her way? He didn’t mean to twist the knife; she was dead already after all. And she’d only been trying to protect her people, but that didn’t change the damage she’d done. Without armor, without absorbing aeons, what else could have been tried? Even now, how many summoners could have done more had they known what really lurked inside Sin? More than likely, ignorance had wasted their lives just as surely as anything else.

“Go, then,” Luthien said, her expression closing off. “I will be here when you realize that you were wrong.”

“That won’t happen,” Thorin said with more confidence than he probably felt. On instinct, Bilbo took his hand, and Thorin responded with an immediate comforting squeeze. He could barely believe it. It had worked. Thorin had changed his mind. They might all still die, but at least it wasn’t a foregone conclusion.

Luthien frowned, but then her eyes narrowed on Bilbo, as if seeing him for the first time. “What is that you carry?” she asked, striding forward with far more speed than she’d demonstrated before.

Bilbo recoiled instinctively, his retreat halted by Thorin’s grip on him. The ring in his other hand felt like a lead weight. He was trapped, and he couldn’t explain why he felt that way.

“Open your hand,” Luthien ordered, something swirling in her eyes, animating her lovely features with a strange light. He had always known she was dead, but now she seemed even farther from mortal.

“Do it,” Gandalf advised him softly.

It took tremendous effort to pry his fingers open, revealing the ring to the dead woman. He had an irrational fear that she would try to take it, but why would she want it, or why would it matter? It was just a little gold ring, and she was dead. What did a dead woman need jewelry for?

“Where did you find this?” she asked, searching his eyes.

“In Isildur’s cave,” Bilbo told her faintly. “He said he found it inside Sin, and something about it changed him. Even when his fayth was stolen, the one who stole him took this too.”

“And Isildur let you take it?” Luthien asked, her eyes never leaving his face. It calmed his fear a little. She was more interested in the truth than in the ring.

“He said it didn’t affect him anymore, but it drew dangerous fiends into his cave. The whole place had a very sick feeling,” Bilbo admitted.

“It drove my father mad,” Thorin added grimly.

Luthien’s displeasure with them was replaced by determination. Her mouth was set in a thin line, and Bilbo wondered what she saw in this little golden band that could change her mind so much.

“Keep it close,” she advised Bilbo. “Perhaps your quest is not as doomed as I had supposed.”

“My lady, is this-” Gandalf began, and Luthien cut him off with a shake of the head.

“I do not know,” she admitted. “But if you bring this inside Sin, it may give you a chance. Do not mistake me,” she added with a warning look. “If I am right, there is a place inside Sin where you will have to destroy it. If I am right, you will be able to influence the outcome of the battle. But if I am wrong, you will die just as surely as I said.”

“With so small a thing, we can change the outcome of the battle?” Thorin asked, clear skepticism in his voice.

Luthien actually smiled at that, her expression nearly blinding. “Some have made the mistake of calling hobbits small,” she said with a significant look. “I am told they often have cause to regret it.”

Thorin made no reply to this, shifting uncomfortably and tightening his grip on Bilbo.

“We are grateful for your advice, my Lady,” Gandalf said, breaking the silence. “I know this is not how things are generally done.”

“The way things are generally done has not worked,” Luthien replied wryly. “Perhaps it is time for me to fade, and leave these matters to others. It is clear that I have grown too set in my ways to see what is right in front of me.”

“If that was true, we wouldn’t know what we have to do now,” Kili pointed out with a wink.

Luthien gave a short laugh. “Perhaps. If you are successful, Thorin son of Thrain, in casting down Sin, never to rise again, return here. With Sin gone, I will require a Sending, along with those of my people who remain here as Unsent.”

Thorin nodded, and Bilbo glanced at Gandalf without meaning to. He gave a small nod as well, though none of the dwarves noticed.

“There is an airship coming this way,” Luthien told them with a distant look. “Coming for you, I would imagine. Go, and may the Valar protect you.”

Bilbo bowed, and the dwarves followed suit, before turning and running back into the temple.

“What changed your mind?” Bilbo asked Thorin as they ran. “Why did you decide to give this a chance, after everything I said?”

Thorin smiled at him. “Sin was an unknown quantity before. No one knew what it really was, only that it kills everything that gets in its way. But dwarves are good at finding weaknesses, once we know what something is.”

“Oh, is that all?” Bilbo said dryly. It seemed optimistic to suggest that they could have any impact on a battle between beings that were close to gods. No matter what Luthien might say about the ring.

“There is one other thing,” Thorin admitted, his gaze unwavering. “Of my guardians, I asked three things: loyalty, honor, and a willing heart. I did not ask for their lives. I did not ask for your life either, and I will not take it.”

With a pang, Bilbo remembered that his life was bound to the fayth, bound to their dreams. What would happen if they did manage to affect the battle raging inside Sin? Would the fayth continue to dream? Would they even be able to? Thorin might have been convinced to live, but now Bilbo had to resign himself to the possibility of his own death. He had known it was a possibility before, but it felt more real now, with what might be a real solution in their hands.

When they reached the outside of the dome, the airship was waiting, hovering a safe distance above the courtyard. Around it, fiends growled and menaced, trying to reach the ship, and they had to clear a path through them before it could fly low enough for them to board. As Dwalin, the last to board, reached the stairs, he paused, as if listening for something.

“Brother, the fiends are returning,” Balin urged him.

Dwalin frowned. “The ground is shaking.”

“The mountain,” Thorin breathed, running to the other side of the ship in search of a window.

Smoke was rising from the mountain, and Bilbo realized they were out of time. “The Crusaders have begun their operation! We need to get out of here, now!”

Bifur and Bofur were already having a shouted exchange in dwarvish, and the unmistakable sound of the engine kicking into gear sounded. Dwalin appeared in the cockpit, and then the airship was flying as fast as it could out of the way.

“We must go back!” Thorin urged. “This is our chance to destroy Sin!”

“The falling rock will knock us out of the air,” Dwalin argued. “We can’t get close, not until the smoke clears.”

But wasn’t the smoke part of Sin? Bilbo thought back to when Sin had attacked the Shire. He remembered very little of the attack aside from fire and screams, but Sin had looked almost like a fiery cloud to him. What they saw as Bifur brought the ship around, keeping a safe distance and hovering over the Calm Lands, was not a cloud at all.

“A dragon,” Bilbo breathed, as the beast burst out of the mountain.

The Crusaders hadn’t succeeded in bringing the mountain down. Part of the front section had collapsed, but the beast that emerged from the wreckage did not look hurt. It just looked angry. More importantly, it was not Sin, and no one else seemed to realize it.