Actions

Work Header

A Most Sensible Idea

Chapter Text

Frodo had come back from the lower mines full of excitement, and was still talking about them several days later at breakfast. Bilbo’s fever had abated by then, and there was only the occasional sniffle.

‘And there are these spires going up from the ground towards the ceiling. Some of them are taller than twenty hobbits put on top of each other.’ Frodo stretched up his hands, but they were a poor substitute for the marvel he was describing. Instead he took another bite of his sausage.

‘You have to see them, Uncle Bilbo,’ Frodo continued, still chewing.

Bilbo nodded. He didn’t exactly relish the thought of going even more underground. But there was something in him that longed to see the sights Frodo was describing. Maybe it was his Tookish side coming out.

‘Alright,’ he said slowly, ‘When can we go?’

Frodo grinned. ‘I’m glad you said that, because we’re meeting Fíli, Kíli and King Thorin down there today.’

‘Frodo Baggins! Are you making appointments to meet your intended behind your chaperone’s back? What if I’d refused to go down to the mines? Would you have gone alone?’ Bilbo exaggerated his worry to impress upon his nephew the seriousness of the situation.

Frodo rolled his eyes. ‘We wouldn’t have been alone. Fíli and Kíli would have been there.’

‘And the two young princes obviously have an excellent sense of what is right and proper. Last time I saw them, they were rolling celeriac roots down the hallway by the kitchens, seeing who could get them the farthest!’

Frodo giggled. ‘Really? They have to show me that game!’

Bilbo crossed his arms and gave his nephew a look. Frodo ducked his head, but he couldn’t stop smiling.

Bilbo sighed. There was a possibility of seeing the King again. He still remembered those quiet moments in front of the fire in his room. But King Thorin’s blunt farewell also flashed through his mind. Maybe he would be different today…

‘Well, you’re very lucky, my lad.’ He said as he took a final bite of his toast. ‘Because I’m coming with you.’

 

X—X

 

‘Watch your step, it’s slippery down here.’ King Thorin held out his hand for Frodo to grab while he was descending the final steps of the stairs into the lower mines. Youthful swagger made the hobbit ignore the outstretched hand and jump that last step. He grinned when Fíli and Kíli, who were waiting in front of them, laughed in approval.

Bilbo shook his head. One day that lad is going to split his head in two and then what’ll he do? His own walk was more careful and measured, keeping his head down to watch the steps in front of him. Suddenly a large hand entered his field of vision.

‘Master Baggins?’ The King looked up at him.

Bilbo quickly licked his lips. ‘Thank you,’ he said as he lightly grabbed the outstretched fingers. There was a temptation to slide his hand in to rest in the palm of that strong one, but Bilbo ruthlessly ignored it. He could feel a heavy iron ring on one of King Thorin’s fingers. It had been warmed by his Majesty’s skin.

Once he was safely down, Bilbo quickly drew away from the King. He reflexively put his right hand in his pocket, trying to preserve some of that heat.

King Thorin turned around to their three young companions. ‘Master Frodo,’ he said. ‘I know my nephews have shown you the Echo Cave, but I bet they haven’t shown you the Cave of Stars.’

Frodo shook his head.

‘Allow me to show it to you then.’ King Thorin gestured down a small passageway along an underground lake. Frodo glanced back at his two friends but stayed at his Majesty’s side as they walked away.

‘Well,’ Fíli said. ‘We’d better keep up so we don’t get lost down here’

Bilbo walked with a brother on either side of him. They kept their eyes peeled ahead of them, trying to keep track of Frodo and the King through the twisting passages. Fíli and Kíli each carried a torch, as did King Thorin. Otherwise there was no source of light this far underground.

‘Is it true that you can hear nine different echoes in a cave down here?’ Bilbo smiled politely at the young dwarves.

‘Oh yes!’ Kíli nodded. ‘You should have heard Frodo shouting when he was down here. He knew a lot of great words!’ He grinned conspiratorially at his brother over Bilbo’s head.

The hobbit rolled his eyes. He couldn’t remember the last time a rude word had excited him like it did these young dwarves.

‘Do you like being around Frodo then?’ Bilbo asked.

‘Frodo’s great!’ Kíli said while Fíli added, ‘It’s going to be so much fun when he and Uncle get married. Then we can be together all the time!’

‘You know, it’s not certain that they’ll get married.’ Bilbo said slowly.

‘We know.’ Kíli said, ‘But we hope they will. We always talk up Uncle’s good qualities when we’re around Frodo.’

‘Though there aren’t many to speak of!’ Fíli laughed

‘What do you mean?’ Bilbo looked down at the cave floor as he frowned.

Kíli stopped grinning and paused. ‘Well, he’s a bit grumpy, isn’t he? Doesn’t talk a lot and he’s always busy.’

‘He’s in charge of an entire kingdom. I can’t think of anything more demanding.’ Bilbo flexed his fingers at his sides.

‘So was grandpa Thrain, but he still had time to put us on his knee and tell us stories.’ Fíli said. Bilbo smiled as he was reminded of Thora and her dragon.

‘And was married and had three children.’ Kíli supplied.

‘That’s why we want Frodo to marry Uncle,’ Fíli concluded. ‘Maybe he’ll tempt the old dwarf away from his office and get him out more. This courtship has already done a world of difference to Uncle’s mood.’

‘Yes,’ Kíli said. ‘He’s less…snappish these days.’

Bilbo took all this in. Was this true? Was being around Frodo making his Majesty a more calm and sociable dwarf? Maybe the courtship was moving in the right direction then. He drew a deep breath. That should be a good thing. So why did it make him feel like he just had the wind knocked out of him?

He looked ahead, trying to find King Thorin’s torch in the darkness, but it was no where to be seen.

‘Where’s the King? Where’s Frodo?’ He turned to his two companions with worry in his eyes.

‘Oh,’ Fíli frowned. ‘They must be near by. Let’s hurry.’

The two dwarves and the hobbit didn’t speak as they walked quickly through the winding passageways. There was no sound but their laboured breathing and the slap of Bilbo’s feet against the bare stone. But no matter how fast they moved, they couldn’t catch a glimpse of the other pair.

‘Maybe they turned off further back.’ Kíli said. ‘I think we should turn around.’ He gestured with his torch behind them.

‘No, I’m sure the Cave of Stars is just up ahead.’ Fíli replied. ‘We have to keep going forward.’ He put his hand on Bilbo’s back, imploring the hobbit to come with him.

‘Listen!’ Bilbo interrupted them. He could hear a faint sound of music coming from the other side of a wall. ‘People!’ He smiled at the brothers.

They followed the noise of laughter and song until they reached a small clearing. It was a group of miners in a circle, taking a break from their work and puffing on pipes. All of them were covered in dust, their brows glistening with sweat. A few had struck up an impromptu band. There was a dwarf blowing a cheerful tune through a harmonica, while others slapped their thighs and stomped their feet. And in the middle was Bofur, singing a bawdy tavern song as he moved back and forth inside the circle.

Bilbo and the two brothers stood at the edge of the gathering unnoticed until Bofur, having completed a verse of the song, spotted them.

‘Bilbo Baggins!’ He called out and pushed aside two dwarves in the circle to get to him. The music kept going round and round.

‘Bofur!’ Bilbo shouted to be heard over the din of harmonica playing and general chatting.

Bofur was bobbing up and down to the beating tempo. He grinned at the hobbit. ‘Come on!’ he said and grabbed Bilbo’s hand. He was pulled into the circle to the wild applause and hooting from the other miners. Before he knew what was happening, Bofur had him in a firm embrace and moved him about to the rhythm of the music.

Bilbo felt like he was being constantly spun around, and the light from the torches and the faces of the dwarves around him seemed to converge into a single blur filling his vision. He thought he could make out the stunned faces of the princes at one point, but he wasn’t sure.

The music finally stopped, and he pushed away from the dwarf. Bofur grinned and bowed at his loud audience, but when he caught sight of Bilbo’s knitted brow, he halted his performing persona.

He stooped to whisper in the hobbit’s ear, trying to ignore the way Bilbo flinched slightly away. ‘Sorry, Bilbo. Just thought it’d be a bit o’ fun.’

Bilbo crossed his arms. ‘Well, ask next time before you do something like that.’

Bofur gave him a cautious smile, but it wasn’t returned. He cleared his throat. ‘What are ye doin’ down here anyway?’ Several of the other miners stopped their chats to hear Bilbo’s answer.

‘I’m lost,’ he glanced over his shoulder to Fíli and Kíli. ‘We’re lost.’

The two princes moved closer to the light of the circle, and the talk completely stopped. There were whispers of ‘the princes…’, ‘something wrong…’, and ‘…doing inspections’.

Fíli went to stand next to Bilbo. ‘We’re looking for the Cave of Stars,’ he said, ‘Do any of you know how to find it from here?’ His tone of voice had changed from his normally playful one, and for the first time Bilbo could imagine him as an heir to a great kingdom.

An older miner with a bent nose from many breaks stood up. ‘I know where it is,’ he said, while rolling the head of his pipe between his fingers.

Fíli nodded. ‘Will you show us the way?’

The miner sucked his teeth. ‘Alright.’ He walked out of the circle, the others quickly moving out of his way, and started down the path from which Fíli, Kíli, and Bilbo had come.

Bofur grabbed Bilbo’s hand before he left. ‘Is everything, you know, alright?’ He chewed his lip as he waited for the hobbit’s answer.

Bilbo sighed. Bofur sometimes had sudden, exasperating urges to do or say whatever he felt, but Bilbo couldn’t stay mad at him.

The hobbit gave a small, reassuring smile to his friend and squeezed his hand before turning away from him and following the miner and the two princes.

The trip was quick but quiet. The miner had no torch but led the group through the narrow passages with no hesitation. Bilbo was at the back of the group, and all he could see of their guide was the glow from the pipe clenched between his teeth.

The path widened, and they were in a large, empty cave. The dwarves stopped.

‘Here it is,’ the miner turned and made to walk back the way he came.

Kíli called after him. ‘Are you sure? But there’s nobody here!’

The older dwarf shrugged. ‘In all my years, this has been the Cave of Stars. Now, unless any of your highnesses have decided to move it, it’s still the Cave of Stars.’ He bit down on his pipe once more and left.

Bilbo wrung his hands. Some chaperone he turned out to be. For all his talk of propriety and manners, he had left his young nephew completely alone with a courting dwarf. And now they were both missing in an underground maze.

Kíli straightened. ‘I’ll go look for them.’

‘No,’ Fíli stood in front of him. ‘You don’t know this part of the mines well enough to find them, and then I’ll have to go look for you. And I know these mines even less than you.’ He smiled, ‘And where would that leave poor Master Baggins?’

‘He’s right,’ Bilbo said, ‘The King said, that we were going to this cave. We have to treat it like a meeting place and wait for their return.’ He sat down on a large rock.

Kíli sighed and started moving restlessly throughout the open space. Fíli stood next to entrance, shining his torch into the passageway, signalling their presence.

Bilbo drew shapes in the dirt with his toes. Frodo would be alright. Of course, he would be alright. He thought back to how King Thorin had looked in front of the fire that night in his rooms, his hair lit up from behind by the flames. How he had smiled gently as he had handed Bilbo that small pile of books. That was not how a despoiler of young hobbits looked.

He glanced down, and noticed that he had been drawing a row of eight-pointed stars. He went over them with his foot, erasing the shapes in the dirt.

Bilbo didn’t know how long they had waited when Fíli suddenly called out, ‘I think that’s them,’ and there was a definite sound of footsteps in the dark.

He stood up and waited. The light in the opening grew stronger, and then Frodo was standing at the mouth of the cave with the King behind him holding a torch aloft.

‘Frodo!’ Bilbo stood up and moved to his nephew. ‘Are you alright?’ He grabbed Frodo’s arms and studied his face closely.

‘I’m alright, Uncle Bilbo. After all, I’m not the one who got lost.’ He looked over his uncle’s shoulder at Fíli and Kíli.

Frodo smiled at his friends. ‘I thought you said you knew these mines like the back of your hands.’ They laughed and gave him a welcoming slap on the back, as he went to stand next to them.

‘Maybe we stopped for lunch on the way,’ Kíli said. He couldn’t stop smiling at Frodo.

Bilbo shook his head fondly at their carefree ways. Maybe he would mention to Frodo later how Kíli hadn’t been able to stop moving from nerves, or how Fíli had constantly licked his lips while shining a light into the darkness.

‘I went looking for you.’ King Thorin’s deep voice sounded as he stopped next to Bilbo. The torch in his right hand shaded the other side of his face, and the hobbit couldn’t read his expression.

‘You found us.’ Bilbo didn’t know what else to say.

Frodo glanced between his uncle and his friends. ‘What happened to you? One minute you were just behind us and then you were gone.’

Fíli shrugged. ‘We must have taken a wrong turn.’ He glanced at Bilbo. ‘And it didn’t help that we suddenly had to attend a party with Master Bilbo’s friends.’

Frodo smiled. ‘Friends?’ He turned to his uncle. ‘Is Bofur down here as well?’

Bilbo felt the King stiffening slightly beside him.

‘We met some miners on a break,’ he explained, ‘and one of them helped us find this place.’

King Thorin shifted slightly. ‘Well, now that we’re all here, we might as well explore the cave.’

He walked to the centre, where a large iron cauldron was situated. There, the King threw down his torch with more force than strictly necessary, and whatever was in that container caught fire immediately.

The light spread throughout the cave within a blink of an eye, and the darkness that had flattened everything around them seemed to be brought to life. Above them thousands of stars glinted and the curved stone seemed at once soft and warm.

‘Oh,’ Bilbo breathed out. He walked to the nearest wall, expecting to see gems embedded in the rock. But close up it looked like ordinary grey stone.

‘It’s odd, isn’t it?’ King Thorin said behind him. ‘The dwarves who discovered this cave thought they had found a new and valuable jewel to mine and to sell.’

The King stretched out a hand over Bilbo’s shoulder and brushed against the wall. ‘But when they cut out a piece of the rock and brought it back up to the surface, the star light gradually faded from the separated part, and all they had left was a worthless piece of stone.’

Bilbo looked at those strong fingers feeling the rock in front of him. The King continued, ‘It was like it could only shine down here in the darkness, and any attempt to part it from its foundation would destroy whatever made it beautiful.’

Bilbo dipped his head back, looking up again at the starry heaven above them. The top of his curls brushed against the King’s shoulder before the dwarf quickly moved back. Bilbo’s cheeks felt warm. He didn’t realize they had been standing so close.

‘Uncle Bilbo, look here.’ Frodo waved him over.

‘Doesn’t that look like the Burning Briar?’ he said as he pointed to seven bright points on the arched ceiling.

Bilbo squinted. ‘I believe it does. How extraordinary that constellations of the sky are mirrored down here.’

‘And I still say it looks like Durin’s Crown,’ Kíli huffed.

Bilbo smiled. ‘They’re one and the same. It’s just that hobbits don’t need to name everything after themselves!’

Fíli laughed behind him. ‘No, hobbits just walk around with evidence of their latest amorous encounter left on their very nice jacket!’ He nudged Kíli who joined in the giggling.

‘What?’ Bilbo made a half-turn where he stood, trying to catch a glimpse of what they were seeing on him.

King Thorin came up behind his nephews. ‘You have dirty handprints on your jacket, Master Hobbit.’ His tone was carefully neutral but when Bilbo looked back at him, his lips were pressed firmly together.

‘Oh dear,’ he said, as he quickly shed his jacket and slapped the thick fabric, trying to dislodge some of the dust and the dirt.

Kíli snickered. ‘That’s why we were always warned against consorting with miners; they get so awfully handsy!’

Fíli continued, ‘Yes, better check your trousers as well, Master Baggins. We don’t know where else that Bofur fellow might have grabbed you!’ The brothers both dissolved into loud guffaws as Bilbo’s cheeks flushed.

‘Fíli! Kíli! Behave yourselves!’ King Thorin’s voice echoed throughout the cavern. He made a sound almost like a growl and marched to the iron cauldron. He picked his torch up and went to the opening of the cave.

‘We’re going back,’ was all he said before striding away. The four others quickly scrambled after him, and wound up walking in silence behind the unwavering king.

‘Don’t mind him, Frodo,’ Fíli whispered to the young hobbit. ‘He gets like that sometimes, but it soon passes.’

‘It’s alright,’ Frodo whispered back.

‘But there’s usually a reason,’ Kíli murmured next to him. ‘And Uncle normally knows how to recognize a harmless joke.’

Both of the young dwarves glanced at Bilbo walking behind them. He ignored their looks and craned his head to watch the King in front of them. His Majesty walked with purpose though his shoulders seemed unnaturally stiff, like he was trying to restrain every single movement of his body.

Bilbo looked down at King Thorin’s hands and swallowed nervously. They were clenched into tight, unyielding fists.