Actions

Work Header

A Most Sensible Idea

Chapter Text

The King didn’t speak much to Bilbo after that day in the lower mines.

In the following weeks, Frodo still got regular invitations to outings and meetings with King Thorn, and Bilbo still followed his nephew like a shadow on all of these. But whenever Bilbo made a comment to the King, maybe even tried to start a conversation, he was met with polite, monosyllabic responses and nothing more.

The latest appointment between King Thorin and his intended had been in Lady Dís’s chambers, where Bilbo and Frodo had enjoyed tea with the Lady and her brother.

They had been sitting there for over an hour, making well mannered conversation, while the plate of sliced cake had been reduced to crumbs. Bilbo could feel Frodo moving about impatiently in his seat next to him. He gave a quick glance to the two dwarves on the other side of the table, hoping they hadn’t noticed his nephew’s restlessness.

Cups clinking against saucers was the only sound in the room. Bilbo took a final sip of tea and looked up, noticing King Thorin’s gaze moving away from him to rest on Frodo.

‘Master Frodo,’ he said, ‘I hear from my nephews that your fighting skills are improving.’

‘Yes,’ Frodo nodded eagerly, ‘They even found a real sword for me to use. Well, it’s a dagger they bought in Dale, but it looks like a sword.’

‘Master Dwalin is also teaching him how to sharpen and care for his weapon,’ Bilbo interjected, but the King’s eyes remained fixed on Frodo. The only sign that he had even heard Bilbo, was a tightening of his lips.

‘I’d like to see how far you’ve come in your training.’ The King said, leaning back in his seat and crossing his arms. ‘I train with my sister at sunrise before our work begins. Would you join us one morning?’

‘Oh.’ Frodo paused ‘Will Fíli and Kì- I mean, will the princes be there as well?’

‘Not likely!’ Lady Dís laughed. ‘Only a pack of wild wargs would force them out of bed that early! And even then Kíli would try to keep them away with his bow and arrow as long as possible before being forced to leave his warm blanket.’

Bilbo looked down at his empty plate and gave a small smile. Yes, the lads were a bit silly and irresponsible, more so than Frodo, even though they were older than him. But he loved seeing his nephew in their company. Frodo laughed more freely with them, and they shared his curiosity and thirst for adventure. Bilbo was glad that his nephew had found someone to have fun with in this mountain, instead of sitting on a soft chair with his uncle all day, waiting for a king to pay his attentions.

Frodo hadn’t given his answer yet, so Bilbo cleared his throat to say, ‘We would be happy to join your Majesty and you, my Lady, in your training.’ He looked at the King who took a long, slow sip from his cup. Bilbo continued, ‘Any morning in particular?’

Lady Dís glanced at her brother expectantly but when no reply came, she said, ‘Come on any day you like. We’re always there. You see, I need to keep this one fit to fight,’ gesturing to the King, ‘So he can handle his council of advisors when they’re being too demanding!’ She grinned, inviting her brother to share in the joke, but he remained stone-faced next to her.

Bilbo pursed his lips. What was the matter with King Thorin? After the princes’ jokes about Bilbo, Bofur, and grabby miners, The King had coldly walked away without saying a word to him. He had reacted similarly that night Bofur had brought soup to Bilbo.

A sudden thought entered Bilbo’s head that made him frown. Maybe his Majesty didn’t want to stay in the company of a simple miner any longer than necessary. He had been so talkative and, well, nice when Bilbo had been alone with him. But at the first sight of Bofur, the King had grown cold, almost growling his greeting to Bilbo’s friend.

And now King Thorin was ignoring Bilbo completely.

Maybe he was reconsidering this courtship entirely? Maybe he didn’t want to be tied to a family of hobbits who enjoyed the company of miners and labourers? Bilbo exhaled a short breath in annoyance. Well, good riddance! He wouldn’t want his favourite nephew tied to such a snobby, old king.

But every time he thought about never seeing or talking to King Thorin again, there was this gnawing feeling behind his ribs. He swallowed, trying to push it down into his stomach.

‘Frodo, I wanted to show you something,’ Lady Dís said, and she stood up from the table. ‘Come with me.’

Frodo followed her quickly, obviously grateful that he was no longer confined to his seat at the table.

After they left the room, the King quickly stood up and moved to look out of a window.

Bilbo took out his favourite handkerchief and started folding it again and again. The fabric seemed softer every time he touched it, and he let it glide through his fingers in silence.

‘I think we’re going to get more snow tonight.’ Bilbo said. He may be puzzled by this king’s behaviour, but he still had the good manners of a gentle-hobbit.

‘Hm.’ King Thorin folded his hands behind his back.

Let’s see if I can provoke him a little, Bilbo thought. ‘We might even get a blizzard one of the coming days. At least that’s what Bofur says.’ Bilbo paused, waiting for a reaction, as he still played with his handkerchief.

The King stood straighter. ‘Did he?’ His tone was neutral.

Bilbo was now desperate for some kind of reaction. ‘Do you remember Bofur? I introduced you to him some weeks ago?’

‘I do.’ King Thorin flexed his fingers.

Bilbo spread the handkerchief out on the table in front of him. The entirety of the green border was visible, and he brushed one finger lightly over the embroidered leaves.

‘Yes, I’m glad I have Bofur here in Erebor,’ he murmured, ‘Otherwise, it would be very easy to feel lonely so far away from my home.’ Please talk to me, Bilbo thought, as he looked at the back of the King’s head. I miss our talks…

King Thorin turned around and stared at Bilbo with eyes full of heat. ‘Is he going back with you to the Shire? To Bag End?’ He glanced at the handkerchief on the table.

Bilbo blinked rapidly. ‘I don’t-’

‘Because if he is, I will need to send word to the Iron Mountains, asking them to give Erebor more of their miners.’ The King straightened and looked away from Bilbo.

‘Or maybe you’re staying here in Erebor?’ He turned back to lean against the window sill. His head drooped a little between his tense shoulders.

Bilbo wrinkled his forehead. What was this dwarf talking about? ‘Why do you think I-’

‘Uncle Bilbo, look at this.’ Frodo hurried into the room clutching a small frame in his hands, and placed it on top of Bilbo’s handkerchief.

Bilbo tore his eyes away from King Thorin and turned his gaze to the painting in front of him. It was a small family portrait of four dwarves, two children and two adults. He recognized Lady Dís immediately and could guess that the two dwarflings – one light, one dark – were Fíli and Kíli. But he hadn’t seen the male dwarf before.

Lady Dís came up behind him. She leant on the table and gently brushed her fingers along the frame of the picture.

She spoke quietly. ‘It’s odd how much my memory of him is slowly matching this picture. I know he had larger braids and more wrinkles around his eyes when he died, but I think of him more and more as that carefree, young father you see here.’ She sighed and sat down.

Bilbo studied the portrait of the Lady’s husband. He was sitting with Kíli on his lap, a broad hand around the lad’s waist holding him securely against his father’s chest. Though father and son were of different colouring, they had matching, mischievous expressions. Fíli stood next to them, a serious expression on his young face; though Bilbo thought he could see a smile almost breaking through. Dís was standing behind her son with a hand on his shoulder.

‘You have a lovely family, my Lady.’ Bilbo murmured.

She gave a small smile. ‘Yes, I do.’ They sat in silence for a while, and Bilbo pretended not to notice the glistening of the Lady’s eyes.

The King had moved to stand behind his sister, slowly moving a hand down her long hair. His gaze was soft as he looked at the painting. Bilbo had missed that gentle blue colour. He hadn’t seen it since that evening in front of the fireplace, and he wanted to say something - anything - just to have the light of those eyes rest on him for one moment.

‘Do you have any paintings of yourself, your Majesty?’ Bilbo shook his head the moment he said it. Stupid! Why did he say that? Of course, a great king would have paintings of himself. He probably has one for every year of his life!

But the King didn’t notice the hobbit’s agitation. At the sound of Bilbo’s voice, he closed his eyes, banishing the view of the happy family picture. His forehead knotted as if he was in great pain, and his voice was rough and low. ‘Yes, I do.’

King Thorin squeezed his sister’s shoulder once, and silently returned to the window, his back to the other people in the room.

Bilbo stared after him and swallowed drily. He had driven the King away. How had he driven the King away? Bilbo sighed. They would never more share silly chats about flowers or fairy tales or anything. King Thorin kept him at such a distance now, that he would never feel the almost-touch of that deep voice on his sensitive ears, nor allow himself to breathe in the King’s scent when walking beside him.

His chest felt hollow, and he was suddenly very tired. The King would never notice him again. Bilbo sat quietly in his chair, still holding the frame of the painting.

He felt a light touch on his hand. It was Frodo. He gave his uncle a questioning look, but it was returned with a slight shake of the head.

Frodo turned his attention to Lady Dís, affecting a cheery manner. ‘I didn’t know dwarves grew beards that young,’ he said, pointing at the young Fíli and Kíli.

She quickly wiped her eyes and looked up from her perusal of the painting. ‘Oh, yes,’ she said, ‘We’re born with small, wispy beards. Though some take a bit longer growing a full beard than others.’ She caressed the picture of Kíli slowly.

‘Dís.’ The King’s voice came from the window. ‘Remember tomorrow night.’

‘Yes.’ She frowned slightly at her brother, and turned to the hobbits. ‘Yes, we’re having a small dinner tomorrow night, where most of the high ranking officials and their husbands and wives will be attending.’

She smiled at Frodo. ‘I would like it if you could come as well. It would be easier if they were all presented to the King’s intended simultaneously.’

Frodo looked unsure, his hand still grabbing his uncle’s on the table. The Lady glanced at it and seemed to understand.

‘My sons will be there as well. So you won’t be left alone with the old and the infirm like your uncle and me.’ She winked at Bilbo who returned it with a polite smile.

Frodo grinned at her. He knew when he was being teased. ‘Thank you, my Lady. We’ll be delighted to attend your dinner.’

That was a bit of an exaggeration, Bilbo thought. He already dreaded the prospect of spending an evening making small talk with self-important diplomats and officers, while Frodo could joke around with his friends.

No, that wasn’t even the worst part. The absolute worst was to spend an evening looking at his Majesty from afar, wishing he could do something to make the King smile at him again.

 

X—X

 

‘Why is King Thorin ignoring you?’

Frodo ruffled a hand through his curls. Bilbo had completely given up on taming the lad’s locks before any important social event and now just concentrated on making himself presentable.

‘He isn’t.’ Bilbo looked away from his nephew and straightened his jacket once more.

‘Then why does he only say “yes” or “no” anytime you talk to him?’ Frodo slumped down in the nearest chair. ‘Most of the time he just says nothing at all.’

‘Well, he doesn’t need to talk to a chaperone. I really should just sit quietly in the corner of the room whenever you two meet.’ Bilbo’s voice was strained and he kept pulling on his waistcoat. Why wouldn’t the blasted thing lie flat?

‘But you like talking to King Thorin’

‘This isn’t about what I like.’ Bilbo gave up on the waistcoat, but he started moving around the room, his eyes looking at anything but his nephew. ‘Do you like talking to him?’

‘He’s alright. You know, nice if a bit formal.’ Frodo sat forward, his hands dangling between his knees. ‘It’s sort of like being placed next to a distant uncle at a family party. People expect you to have a special connection, even if you know very little about each other and don’t have very much in common.’

Bilbo stopped circling the room. ‘That’s how you describe being courted by Thorin Oakenshield? Like being forced to chat with an ageing relative?’

‘Yes.’ Frodo sat up straighter. ‘And it’s duller when he’s ignoring you, Uncle Bilbo. You used to distract him with talk when I had to meet with him.’

Bilbo rubbed his forehead and sighed. Distract him… ‘Maybe we should just leave. Go back to Bag End and tell Fortinbras that the courtship didn’t succeed.’ And then I can finally relax again, he thought.

‘What?!’ Frodo bolted out of his chair. ‘We can’t!’

Bilbo finally looked at his nephew again. ‘Why not? Don’t tell me you’ll miss his Majesty?’

Frodo tried to stare his uncle down. ‘No, not King Thorin. But Fíli? And Kíli? I’ve only just met them and now you want to force me away from the best friends I’ve ever had?’

‘You have friends back in the Shire.’ Bilbo looked away. He felt like a tyrant from a fairy tale, kidnapping the hero away from his companions.

Frodo crossed his arms in front of him, and Bilbo was seized by the feeling that he was looking into a mirror. ‘We promised we’d stay until I came of age. We have to keep our promises. We have to!’

Bilbo felt angry. ‘Why? So you can go through the motions of a courtship with the King, while escaping as soon as possible to play games with your friends? So I can spend the next months pretending that everything is fine when nothing’s fine?!’

‘Why are you overreacting?!’ Frodo was shouting as well. ‘Just because some stupid old dwarf has stopped talking to you, you think you have the right to force me back to the Shire. Well, I’m not going!’ Frodo stomped off to his bedroom and slammed the door behind him.

Bilbo collapsed into the nearest chair. He hadn’t had a fight like this with Frodo for a long time.

Being in Erebor seemed to make his feelings more heightened. He was a proper and restrained hobbit in the Shire. Bilbo rubbed his eyes. Yes, he never felt anything this intensely back in Bag End.

There was a knock at the door. Time for dinner.

 

X—X

 

Frodo didn’t speak one word to his uncle as they followed a servant to the smaller dining hall. Bilbo tried to catch his gaze, tried to communicate some form of goodwill to his nephew, but the young hobbit kept his eyes fixed straight ahead until they reached their destination.

They entered and were at once overwhelmed with the sounds and sights of a multitude of dwarves. Gold and jewels glinted from hair, beard and clothes all around them. Bilbo looked down at his own plain jacket and waistcoat with nary a piece of embroidery in sight.

All this for a small dinner? If Bilbo didn’t think better of Lady Dís, he would have thought this was a surprise wedding between Frodo and King Thorin.

As the door closed behind them, there was an audible hush in the room as several dwarves turned around to peer at the two hobbits. Bilbo pressed his lips together in annoyance and craned his neck, trying to get a glimpse of anyone familiar.

He soon got his wish, when he saw Balin hurrying through the gathering towards the new arrivals.

‘Master Frodo and Master Baggins,’ he said, ‘Welcome.’ He gave a satisfied nod. ‘We are starting to sit down to dinner, so please allow me to take you to your seats.’

‘Thank you,’ Bilbo gave a polite smile and they followed the advisor.

There were three long tables placed in a sort of horseshoe shape. People were beginning to find their places, and Bilbo noticed the princes sitting at the table in the middle. Well, at least Frodo will be happy, he thought grudgingly.

Balin stopped by a seat at the table on the right. ‘This is your place, Master Baggins.’ Bilbo made to say something but was interrupted by the dwarf. ‘Will you follow me, Master Frodo?’

The advisor and the young hobbit walked away. Bilbo tried calling after his nephew, but he received no response. He reluctantly sat down and followed their progress up to the middle table where Frodo was placed to the right of the King’s empty seat.

Bilbo swallowed. This whole affair suddenly felt a lot more official and important than he had expected. He tried to establish eye contact with Frodo, worried that his nephew was in over his head much more than he realized, but the other hobbit was currently leaning over the King’s chair, chatting with Fíli and Kíli on the other side.

Bilbo crossed his arms in front of him, looking about the room. He felt a dwarf sitting down on his right side, but Bilbo only gave them a quick glance. Except there was something very familiar about that dwarf. He looked back.

The hat was missing, the clothes were a little less worn, and the braids were no longer sticking out in a jaunty angle. But it was definitely Bofur sitting next to Bilbo with a sheepish smile.

‘Hello.’ That was all Bilbo was able to say at first.

‘Hello,’ Bofur ducked his head. ‘Bet ye didn’ think ye’d see me here.’

Bilbo could only nod. ‘But why are you here?’ He thought about it. ‘Are you the representative of the miners?’

Bofur laughed. ‘Nah, I don’ think the lads would trust me to fetch lunch, let alone represen’ ‘em at a posh dinner!’

He sobered again. ‘I’m here to keep you company.’

‘Keep me company? But I’ve been to several of these dull dinners without you showing up.’ Bilbo looked back at the head table and noted that King Thorin still hadn’t entered the room.

‘I don’ know what changed, but the clerk who invited me said I was to come as your “special companion”.’ Bofur raised his eyebrows at the hobbit.

‘My spe-’ Bilbo didn’t know what to make of this. And his train of thought was disrupted by the arrival of King Thorin and Lady Dís. The guests all stood up, Bofur trailing a little behind the others, and watched brother and sister take their places on either side of Frodo. Before the King sat down, he took Frodo’s right hand and kissed it shortly. There’s was a murmuring of approval all around the room, but Bilbo could see the embarrassed flush in Frodo’s cheeks even from where he was sitting. He wrung his hands under the table.

As dinner moved along, Bilbo tried to divide his attentions between Bofur on his right, the dwarf on his left with the ineffectual ear trumpet (‘I’m from the Shire! I’m not for hire!’), and staring at the conversation between Frodo and King Thorin.

Though there wasn’t a lot to see. The two at the head table seemed to pass small comments back and forth between each other, while Frodo kept his eyes on his plate and the King gazed out into the room. At one point King Thorin placed his right hand on the table next to Frodo’s. A bit later they shared a smile.

Bilbo turned away from the head table. It shouldn’t bother him. It didn’t bother him. He’d given Frodo the chance to get away from this courtship, and the boy had thrown it back in his face. Frodo was on his own now. Alone with King Thorin.

‘Ye worry too much about ‘im.’ Bofur speared a piece of potato with his fork.

‘What? No, I don’t. I hardly think about the King.’ Bilbo put his cutlery down a little too hard.

Bofur gave him a look. ‘I meant Frodo.’

‘Oh,’ He tried to straighten a wrinkle in the table cloth. ‘Well, I’m here to look out for him.’

‘I don’ think the King is goin’ to throw ‘im across the table ‘n’ ravish ‘im in front o’ all these respectable dwarves.’ Bofur grinned. ‘Or maybe he is. I’m jus’ a simple miner; I’ve never been invited to this kinda party before.’

‘That’s not funny, Bofur.’ Bilbo held eye contact with his friend.

‘No, I’m sorry.’ Bofur smoothed down his braids. ‘But it’s also not funny to be yer “special companion” and see ye stare at someone else the whole evening.’

Bilbo ducked his head and paused while he thought about what Bofur had said. ‘Why do you think the clerk used that term?’

Bofur looked away. ‘Special companion? Don’ know. She said she came from that grand advisor’s office.’

Bilbo looked across the room then to see Balin moving along the tables.

‘Excuse me,’ Bilbo murmured, as he quickly stood up and waylaid the elderly advisor on his walk through the room.

‘Master Baggins,’ Balin smiled. ‘Are you enjoying the food?’

‘Yes, thank you.’ Bilbo licked his lips. ‘Master Balin, why has Master Bofur been invited to this dinner?’

‘You mean the miner? Well, after I heard about you and him, I thought it would please you to have him with you on such an important day for you nephew.’

Bilbo frowned. ‘Me and him?’

‘Yes,’ Balin’s smile faded as he studied the hobbit. ‘Oh, have things already turned sour between you two?’ Bilbo blinked rapidly at this turn in the conversation.

The dwarf continued, ‘I did hope that you having a special connection to Erebor would have encouraged Master Frodo to forge one as well. Maybe you can patch things up with the miner?’

Balin patted Bilbo encouragingly on the back and moved on to talk to another dwarf.

The hobbit looked back at Bofur. The dwarf seemed to be deliberately avoiding his gaze, his eyes fixed on his plate. Bilbo felt cold and the tips of his fingers were numb.

Bilbo closed his eyes shortly. He had never felt so alone in his life. His friendship with Bofur, which had been a constant source of comfort, had become something else, something confused. Something which Bilbo was too frightened to face right now.

He heard a laugh behind him, and he turned to witness Fíli gesturing wildly, while his brother, Frodo, and the King laughed loudly. Frodo was leaning on the King’s armrest to hear the story, his face close to King Thorin’s.

As if he felt the heat of Bilbo’s gaze, the King turned his face towards the hobbit, a smile still curving his lips. But when he noticed Bilbo standing as if frozen in the middle of the floor, the smile dropped. The dwarf sat straighter and returned to the conversation going on around him.

But that brief acknowledgment and then rejection had shook the hobbit to his very core. The feelings it brought out in him were at once strange and familiar.

Bilbo had unconsciously cut up King Thorin into manageable parts that he could allow himself to admire: his voice, his eyes, his smile, his hands, his kindness, and…

And now all the parts gathered together before Bilbo’s eyes, and it showed him one thing: love. He hadn’t noticed it before, but now it was blindingly obvious. It was the very absence of the King’s regard which showed him how deeply he craved it.

Love. Bilbo wanted to laugh, but the hollow feeling in his chest wouldn’t let him. What a ridiculous moment to finally fall in love.

Because there they were: the dwarf and the hobbit, the king and his intended, Bilbo’s beloved and Bilbo’s nephew. Two people who the entire world wanted to see together. Two dark beauties with blue eyes against pale skin. Being together, laughing together, belonging together.

Bilbo would fade into the background next to them. He was all brown and always would be.

He was in a fog as his feet moved him towards the door of the dining room. Behind him he heard an unknown dwarf call out a toast to ‘the King and Master Frodo! May their love be as everlasting and unchanging as the peak of Erebor itself!’ Shouts of dwarven blessings greeted the speaker, as Bilbo shut the door behind him.

There was a nondescript balcony across the hall. Bilbo tried the door handle and, finding it unlocked, slipped silently outside.

It had started snowing again, and the cold air stung his cheeks. As Bilbo looked up, he could spot a few stars between the bluish clouds. One stood out in particular. It was the bright light of Eärendil.

That star will be shining on the Shire tonight, Bilbo thought. His hand went to his jacket pocket, looking for his favourite handkerchief. But it grabbed nothing but air. Had he lost it? Frantically, he searched his other pocket, then the pockets in his trousers and finally in his waistcoat. All empty. Nothing.

His cheeks felt wet, but he let the strong winds from the west dry them as he looked up at the sky once more.

Bilbo’s hands clenched around the cold air and he remembered Bofur’s weather prediction.

There would definitely be a storm tonight.