Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 13: Snags, Promises, Good News, and Honesty in the Dark

Chapter Text

Despite Bilbo's fears, they made it safely across the black river. The boat did not sink and the river did not rise up and attempt to swallow them whole. Even so, he remained abnormally quiet and pale with a haunted look in his eyes even once his feet were firmly on the ground once more. Thorin had released him once they disembarked however he remained abnormally close to the traumatized hobbit while Fíli and Kíli did their level best to get a smile from him while he anxiously watched as the others pulled back the boat to begin the crossing.

"So you can't swim at all?" Kíli asked trying to draw Bilbo into a conversation. "Did you never learn or do hobbits not float?" When no answer came, the young dwarf continued talking. "Dwarves float, when we aren't too heavily armored. Even so, most of us can swim before we can walk. I would almost think that hobbits would float better than we do. Less density if you catch my drift. What do you think, brother?"

"I think you should pick a different topic," Fíli replied, seeing that not only had Bilbo's face become even more pinched as he realized that if they fell in the others would be greatly encumbered by their packs and weapons. The hobbit was beginning to turn an interesting shade of green, but as interesting as it was it could hardly be healthy.

"I agree," Thorin weighed in. So far nothing—not even his overly harsh treatment of him—had managed to dampen the hobbit's spirits and this was not a dampening but a breaking. They did not need to remind him of his lack of skills at this time. There would be time later to rectify the burglar's inability to swim when he wasn't already terrified.

"No more of this for now," Thorin said placing a hand on Bilbo's shoulder that was both protective and possessive. With his hand there, he could feel the hobbit's shoulders rising and falling with his rapid breathing: too rapid and far too shallow. He was still panicked.

"I have something," Fíli said, his voice bright. "You'll like this, Bilbo." The hobbit turned to look at the blonde dwarf, a slight curious tilt to his head. He had no idea what Fíli could say that he thought that Bilbo would like at the moment.

"This river, dark and loathsome as it is, is actually a good sign," Fíli said, a smile on his face. Thorin growled slightly. Hadn't he just told his nephews to leave off with the river? "You'll like this too, Uncle," Fíli said, his voice edging towards impatience that his uncle didn't seem to realize that he knew what he was doing.

"I will?" Thorin asked skeptically. He couldn't see where anything that Fíli had to say about that blasted river could be a good thing. What could possibly be good about a river that not only would put any who so much as touched it into a sleep and was thereby undrinkable—especially when they needed water—and that had also managed to upset his hobbit so severely?

"You will," Fíli promised before turning his attention to Bilbo. "When we were staying at Master Beorn's home we spent some time looking at maps, do you remember?" The hobbit nodded, wondering where Fíli was going with this. "Do you remember the map of Mirkwood? There was only one river on the map."

"What's your point?" Kíli asked. "Are you saying that he should be glad that we just have to cross the one?"

"No," Fíli replied shooting a mock glare at his brother. "I swear I wonder if we're actually related sometimes."

"Mother says we are," Kíli replied with a shrug, "Though sometimes I wonder about you, with your golden hair. I think you were switched at birth."

"He wasn't," Thorin said with a small sad smile. "I was there when they brought him out to us. The blonde hair was a bit of a surprise but not overly so. Your father was blonde, as was my brother. Blonde hair is not unheard of. He's your brother and my nephew, though some days I despair at having to claim either of you." Bilbo gave a small laugh at the indignant sounds Fíli and Kíli made at their uncle's words, and even Thorin had to chuckle.

"What were you going to tell us before Kíli sidetracked you, Fíli?" Thorin asked. If his heir was so sure that it was good news, he wanted to hear it. He could use something pleasant with all the unpleasantness that the quest had consisted of so far . . . and all that was sure to follow. He could never forget that at the end of it all a live dragon might await them.

"I was going to say that the river on the map marked the midpoint of the forest," Fíli said. "If the map was correct we are now halfway through Mirkwood."

"Did you just say that we're only halfway through this blasted forest?" Dwalin grumbled as he and Balin climbed from the boat.

"I heard that we only have half left to go," Balin replied smiling up at his dour brother. "So in three days, more or less, we should be out."

"Just three more days," Bilbo said, a smile back on his face for the first time since he and Thorin had argued earlier that day. "Three more days and I will get to see the sunlight again."

"It's only been three days since you last did, Hobbit," Dwalin said looking at him in confusion. Three days was not that long. And it hadn't been that dark either. The lighting was subdued, that was true enough, but it wasn't dark by any means.

"I've never been so long without the sun or the open sky before," Bilbo said honestly, the relief clear in his voice. "I think if it was going to be much longer I might have gone mad."

At his words a pang went through Thorin. Bilbo needed sunlight and open sky to be happy. Even though the King had never forgotten, he was reminded once again that Bilbo was not a dwarf: he was a hobbit. Even supposing that they were successful and everyone survived the quest, Bilbo needed things that he could not provide him. Sunlight; open sky; that garden that he had been so fond of; those were things that Bilbo would not have ready access to in Erebor. Once again, Thorin realized that things between them were complicated by more than just their races. The prospect that his own happiness would make the cause of it miserable caused him pain and again he questioned whether he was within his rights to attempt to woo the hobbit when in the end it would only cause them both anguish.

He glanced around quickly to see if the others had noticed his discomfort, but they—along with the newest arrivals of Dori, Nori, Ori, and Bofur—were still debating the relative merits of viewing the forest as half-crossed and half-left-to-go and had noticed nothing. Only Kíli had seen it and was looking at Thorin with a silent, worried question in his eyes. Thorin tried to smile reassuringly at him, but Kíli could see the pain underneath it. It was almost surprising that the youngest would be the one to see Thorin's anguish, but Kíli had always been perceptive of his uncle's moods and knew him better than most.

"It'll be alright, Uncle," Kíli whispered, a gentle smile on his face that comes from being young and naïve. "We'll find a way to let him see sunlight. You just worry about not scaring him off." Before Thorin could tell Kíli that it was not his place to give him instructions and to worry about his own business and not Thorin's, they were startled by the sound of hooves and a large body crashing through the undergrowth.

Thorin glanced around quickly, checking the positions of the various members of the company and seeing that Bilbo had been pushed behind Bofur and Dwalin while Glóin and Fíli stood a little to the side of them, weapons drawn and prepared for battle. Beside him, Kíli drew his bow and set an arrow on the string, his face showing surprise when his uncle did the same with one of the bows that Beorn had given them. He had never seen his uncle with a bow.

"You're not the only archer in this family," Thorin said with a laugh, his eyes back on the forest in the direction that the sound was coming from. Suddenly a giant black stag burst from the undergrowth, bowling Fíli over before continuing to run in the direction of the black river. Kíli and Thorin both loosed their arrows as it reached the edge and leaped. Though they both hit their mark, the stag did not fall when it hit the other side but rather continued on into the forest a ways before the sound of hooves faltered and stopped.

"Damn," Kíli muttered. Thorin felt a half-smile cross his face at his nephew's language. He might have expected it from Fíli, but Kíli was the sweeter of the two and rarely swore in Khuzdul or the Common Tongue. Rather than chastise him for his choice of words, since Thorin figured that if he was old enough to risk his life on a quest he was old enough to swear, Thorin tried to comfort him . . . sort of.

"We brought it down," Thorin said his humor apparent. It was clear to him that the fact that the stag had not died where it landed was what had upset Kíli. His nephew prided himself on his archery and with good reason. He rarely missed. This time had been no different. The stage just took longer to succumb to blood loss than they would have liked.

"Yes," Kíli replied, his tone showing that he didn't appreciate his uncle's merriment in light of their failure to bring it down where they could then eat it, "in the forest where we can't follow and find it."

"Don't worry Kíli," Fíli said, laughing at his brother. He too knew that it bothered Kíli that he hadn't made a clean kill. "Remember the squirrels? It probably would have tasted awful anyway."

"I doubt even Bombur could have eaten it," Bofur agreed with a laugh. "Not without the aid of the weed you boys disposed of so injudiciously, eh Bilbo?" Bilbo flushed to the roots of his hair at the reminder of him and Thorin eating that vile tree-rat while under the influence.

"I was hungry," Bilbo defended weakly, knowing that hunger, while the best seasoning, was a poor excuse for what they had done. Never before he came on this quest would he have ever dreamed of eating a squirrel any more than he would have eaten any other rat.

"So was Bombur," Bofur replied looking for his brother and not seeing him immediately. "He's always hungry and even he couldn't eat it. Right Bombur? Bombur?!" Panic flooding his veins, he searched the company desperately for his brother. The last place that he had seen him before the stag came had been by the river. Oh Mahal no! Had Bombur fallen in? He ran right up to the banks, looking for any sign of his brother and seeing none.

"Bombur!?" he called desperately, knowing that if he had fallen in the enchanted river it was in vain but unable to resist the urge to do it.

"Bofur!" He glanced frantically to the side as he heard his name in his brother's voice. He couldn't see him, only the boat. The boat! Rushing towards it, he saw that his brother had not fallen into the river, but rather into the boat.

"I can't get up," Bombur said with an apologetic smile. "I fell when the stag came, and now I can't get back out."

"That's because you eat too much," Bofur said his own smile fond and no heat behind the words. He was too relieved that his brother was still alive to seriously criticize his eating habits. "Don't worry, we'll figure out a way to get you from the boat. May take the whole company to lift you, but we'll manage it, right lads?"

The others grumbled a bit at the idea of having to lift Bombur bodily from the boat, but came over all the same to attempt to free him—the notable exceptions being Bilbo (who refused to go any nearer the river than he was but shouted encouragement) and Thorin (who felt that it would be best to remain near Bilbo and offer pointers of his own to the others). The major problem came in the fact that there was no way they could gain the leverage to lift him from the boat with it in the water without stepping in the water themselves and they couldn't get the boat out of the water due to the same problem. In the end, they decided that the only thing to do would be free the boat enough to let the rear end swing around and dump him onto dry land by tipping the boat. It worked well and soon all of the company was on dry land and prepared to continue the last half of the trek through Mirkwood.

ooOO88OOoo

The rest of the day's march was uneventful though the spirits of the company were lighter than they had been since before they entered Mirkwood. Thanks to Fíli and Bilbo's study of the maps, they knew that they were nearly done with the dank place. Even if it would be three more days before they were rid of it. Every step they took brought them one step closer to that goal and their ultimate goal of the mountain. Rather than the King's will to continue being the only thing that carried them forward, that evening Thorin had to repeat the order to stop after they begged to continue the first time he suggested it.

He finally decided that they would not march any farther, no matter what the company said, when more than one of them began stumbling with weariness and Bilbo began to trip forward rather than walk.

"We'll stop here for the night," Thorin said, his tone showing that he would accept no argument this time. With a sigh that was equal parts frustration and relief, the company began setting up a camp for the night. Thorin didn't miss the way that Bilbo's sigh was only one of relief or the weariness that was apparent as he sank to the ground next to where they were preparing a fire and began helping with the meal. With a sigh of his own Thorin sat beside the hobbit. It was apparent, in the way he glanced sidelong at the king, that Bilbo was still a bit agitated with him for his behavior earlier. Rather than apologize directly—as he had been in the right in his opinion—Thorin tried a different strategy to appease the hobbit.

"That was a good thing you did today," Thorin said, the words stilted. He wasn't used to offering praise, even when it was deserved, and especially not as an apology. "Spotting that boat," he clarified.

Bilbo only snorted in response. He still didn't see where spotting the boat had been all that wonderful. True he had gotten them across the river, but they had had to use a boat. He had been on the water with only a few wooden planks separating him from death. That was not a good thing.

"I regret that it was so uncomfortable for you," Thorin offered quietly. "Had I have known that you cannot swim, I would have rectified that in one of the smaller safer streams that we have passed."

"No you wouldn't have," Bilbo replied a touch of bitterness in his voice and a wry smile on his face once more as he glanced up at the dwarf beside him. "Until recently you would have stood by and let me drown."

"I would have done no such thing!" Thorin snapped. He knew that he had been less than cordial to the hobbit, but he would not have let him die if it was in his power to prevent it. And not only because that would have left them with an unlucky number once more. Despite what he had told Gandalf, the hobbit, by joining the company, had been entitled to some level of protection: a level that had increased when he had agreed to allow Thorin to court him.

" Thorin," Bilbo said, his smile falling slightly, "you may not have let me drown, but you would not have taught me to swim and we both know it. Perhaps you would have asked one of the others to do it, but you would not have done it personally."

"Perhaps that is true," Thorin replied softly. "Even so I would not have stood by and watched you drown. Rescuing you from a river would have posed much less danger than rescuing you from the side of a cliff had and I did that."

"You did," Bilbo agreed with a soft smile at the memory of Thorin rescuing him. "That was when I realized that I loved you, you know," Bilbo added a bit of humor back in his voice.

"When I threw you back up the cliff?" Thorin asked watching as Bilbo's nimble fingers prepared vegetables to go in the pot with fascination as he wondered what else those fingers could do. Despite hisdistracting thoughts, he did have to admit that he was surprised. He hadn't realized that Bilbo had harbored feelings for him for so long. He had thought that they were a more recent acquisition.

"No," Bilbo replied with another wry smile. "It was when you yelled at me afterwards." At Thorin's confused expression he continued the explanation. "The words hurt. More than they should have. It was then that I knew that I cared too much about pleasing you and what that meant. That was why I almost left that night. It wasn't what you had said. Not really. It was more that I knew . . . I knew that you could never—a simple hobbit—I had no right to feel like that about you. So I decided to leave so that I wasn't forced to see you every day and know that I could never have you."

"So if we hadn't have been captured . . ."

"I would be back in the Shire pining for a dwarf King that I would never see again," Bilbo replied honestly. He let the conversation lapse into silence. He had nothing else that he needed to say and Thorin seemed to have nothing more to say either, having slipped into one of his contemplative silences once more. Bilbo smiled at him, seeing the faraway look in the King's blue eyes as he thought. The hobbit had known that Thorin would most likely not follow his declaration with one of his own, the King was too close-mouthed for that, but didn't regret that he had said it all the same.