Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 14: Log Books and More Braids

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

While Thorin brooded and Bilbo chopped vegetables for Bombur, Fíli decided that it was his turn to complete the log and took it from Bilbo's pack before settling himself on the ground beside his uncle to write. He read over what he brother had written the night before, adding a few things and amending others, before he began on the day's entry. Knowing that Gandalf had asked for a detailed log, Fíli included everything: from Thorin and Bilbo's spat to the river and the stag almost causing Bombur to fall in.

"Did you have to write that," Thorin asked suddenly looking down at the book on his nephew's knees. "The old wizard didn't need to know about that."

"He asked for details, Uncle," Fíli responded with a shrug. "How many times have you told me that as your heir my personal life needs to be conducted in a manner beyond reproach since it is not truly personal? Even if that wasn't true, in this case it is relevant. Anything that sours your mood could potentially cloud your judgment. If we fail, and Gandalf finds this, the log might just tell him what went wrong."

"If we fail the why won't matter," Kíli said grimly from beside Fíli where he was redoing his brother's blonde braids while he wrote. "There is no one else to attempt it. Either we succeed or Erebor is forever lost."

"May I see the book?" Thorin asked ignoring Kíli's rare moment of seriousness. It wasn't truly a request, rather an order to hand it over masquerading as a request. With another shrug Fíli handed it to his uncle. Thorin flipped through it quickly, skipping the portions that he himself had written in favor of the entries by Ori, Fíli and Kíli. He bit back a groan as he did. All three of them had taken Gandalf's request for detailed entries quite literally.

Ori's had been the most detailed by far. He had recorded all of the little interactions and bickering that had taken place in the company—including Fíli and Kíli's prank and subsequent punishment—and Bilbo and Thorin's actions under the influence. Despite his embarrassment that Gandalf would read of what had happened, Thorin had to laugh. The dwarf had even included an apology for writing the log even though he wasn't Bilbo or Thorin.

Kíli's entry had focused more on his uncle and the hobbit, though he did mention that morale was low—which he attributed to Thorin's foul mood due to his prank the night before. While it made sense that Kíli would focus on people he cared the most for, it was not the purpose of a quest log. It should not detail the interactions between two members, but rather how far they had gotten, if any injuries had occurred, things of that sort. Not a reconciliation between the King and the burglar (no matter how it related to company morale).Kíli had stopped before the kiss occurred—as he had fallen asleep—but Fíli's handwriting had picked up the tale and completed it (including the kiss).

Fíli's entry, while a bit more professional than his brother's still held far too many personal details for Thorin's taste. Why did Gandalf need to know that he was unofficially courting the hobbit or that it had led to a spat? What business was it of his? And he had no doubt that the wizard was already aware of Bilbo's fear of water; did it need to be preserved forever in writing? He glanced to the end and saw that Fíli had completed the log before it was taken from him so rather than give it back to his nephew he stored the book in his own pack knowing that the boys would not dare to venture in after it.

"I'll be taking care of this from here on out," Thorin said, his tone inviting no argument on the matter. And none was forthcoming. The boys had little interest in writing a log every night and no one else felt that it was in their job description, save Bilbo who knew that depending on if they could get a fire or not he may or may not be able to do it.

Silence followed Thorin's words and Bilbo finished the vegetables and had just added them to the pot when the sound of a scuffle nearby startled him. The hobbit turned in the direction of the noise, his shaking hand falling to his little sword, to see Fíli pinning Kíli beneath him with a comb clutched in the older brother's hand. The others had already begun taking bets on which of the brothers would be victorious this time. Fíli and Kíli's epic battles over Kíli's hair were infamous in Ered Luin.

"What—" Bilbo began looking up at Thorin with wide blue eyes. He had never seen the boys roughhouse before, especially not with a comb. And it had happened so suddenly. Until a moment ago they have been sitting peacefully while Kíli finished Fíli's hair. What had happened to cause Fíli to attack Kíli so? Had Kíli pulled Fíli's hair?

"What are they doing?" Bilbo asked, inching closer to the wrestling brothers. It almost looked like Fíli was trying to comb Kíli's hair, but that made no sense. Such things were much more easily accomplished when the participants were not rolling on the ground. But Thorin's words confirmed his suspicions about what was happening.

"Fíli wants to try to arrange Kíli's hair," Thorin said with a laugh, shaking his head slightly. "He should know better by now. They have done this every so often since Fíli was old enough to want to practice braiding. Kíli hates it."

"If he hates it then why—"

"Because he should have braids," Fíli grunted, trying to restrain his brother and run the comb through his hair while answering Bilbo at the same time. "Even if he doesn't want them normally, on the road he should wear them. Even the hobbit has braids, Kíli!"

"I don't—OUCH!" Kíli protested. "That hurt! Don't pull so hard!"

"If you would let me at least comb it more often or wouldn't fight me it wouldn't hurt!" Fíli argued, now sitting in the middle of Kíli's back with his legs wrapped around his still thrashing brother. "Now hold still!"

"Uncle please," Kíli begged turning his head to look at Thorin with wide brown eyes. "Don't let him do this. Not here. Not in front of everyone!"

"If you don't want him to hold you down," Thorin replied calmly, his eyes twinkling with mirth, "then sit up and allow him to comb out the tangles like an adult. I don't disagree with Fíli. Just like with Bilbo, your hair being in your eyes is dangerous. If he has to restrain you to braid you, so be it."

"Uncle!" Kíli tried again. "This is not dignified." He hoped that appealing to the pride of the line of Durin would make Thorin see his side and have him telling Fíli to free him. It backfired.

"No," Thorin agreed. "Not dignified in the least. Now sit up and allow him to do as he must. Enough of this." Kíli gave a growl of frustration, but stopped his struggles and allowed Fíli to lead him back to the place they had occupied only moments before.

His wasn't the only growl. The rest of the company grumbled as they passed yet more gold to Dwalin who had bet that neither boy would win because Thorin would put a stop to it. They were quickly deciding that when Dwalin participated in a bet—especially if it involved the heirs of Durin—they would decline to participate. If things kept up at this rate, they would be broke before they reached Erebor.

Kíli was beyond unhappy. He glared at his uncle and brother like they wanted to use him as dragon bait, not braid his hair. Thorin, especially, was subjected to his nephew's disapproval. Never before had he taken a side. In the past he had always been content to sit by and watch as the boys fought for dominance. Kíli felt betrayed. A sentiment that was intensified when Thorin—having seen Kíli's sour looks—asked Fíli to fetch Kíli's comb from his pack so that they could be done more quickly.

"This is for your own good, lad," Thorin whispered as he took the comb and began to gently untangle Kíli's wild hair. "Don't worry; it'll just be a few little braids. Nothing too elaborate." When Kíli said nothing, Thorin sighed. His nephew was sulking.

"Would you prefer them to match Fíli's or mine?" Thorin asked hoping for an answer. "Or do you want something else entirely?" With a sigh, Kíli responded.

"You choose," the young dwarf replied, defeated. "I don't care."

"Do you mind—that is to say . . . may I watch?" Bilbo said suddenly. He felt his face grow hot as all three of them turned to look at him. "I know that braiding is a private thing, very personal, and I wouldn't dare to intrude so far as to ask to participate, but may I watch. I don't know the first thing about how to do it." Thorin and Fíli shifted uncomfortably at the question. Neither of them objected to Bilbo watching, but it wasn't their place to invite him—not even Thorin's—as it was Kíli's head that was being braided and they weren't sure how he would take it.

"Of course you can watch," Kíli said smiling warmly at the hobbit. Bilbo hadn't been the one to force this on him after all. There was no need to be angry with him. And with him watching, Kíli could almost pretend that he was helping to integrate the hobbit into dwarf culture not being assaulted by his relatives.

"And if you'd like," Kíli offered, "I wouldn't mind if you participated. I trust you and you're nearly family after all, what with you and Uncle courting."

"Well thank you but I couldn't possibly," Bilbo tried to protest only to have it waved away by the youngest Durin. "I'll just make a mess of it. And—"

"Yes you can. I insist," Kíli replied cutting off the hobbit's protests. "We can't have Uncle walking around with lopsided braids, can we? Mine won't stay in long enough to matter so there's no harm in you practicing on me. Unless Uncle objects."

Thorin thought about it a moment. While he wasn't sure that he wanted Bilbo to braid another dwarf's hair, Kíli would be a good candidate if it had to happen. And this way he could guide the hobbit's hand through the braids rather than just instruct him. Also, any knots that Bilbo tied in his attempts to learn would be in his nephew's hair rather than his own. No, he had no objections.

"Come, Halfling," Thorin said with a smile, standing to offer Bilbo his place beside Kíli and standing over Bilbo with his arms around the hobbit and his hands over his.

"The first step to braiding," Thorin said quietly into Bilbo's ear—the warm breath over the sensitive flesh causing the hobbit to shiver—while they worked together on Kíli's mats, "is to get all the tangles out of the hair you're working with. If there are knots, it can ruin the tension or even the smoothness of the weave." Thorin said nothing more, but simply guided Bilbo's hands in Kíli's hair until the dark locks were free of tangles and laying more-or-less smoothly.

"Next, you must select the site and style of the braid," Thorin explained as he sectioned off some hair at Kíli's temple. "Since this is your first time we will do something simple. Three strands, with no additional hair added as it comes back. Give me your hands." Thorin took Bilbo's hands in his own, lining up their fingers and guiding the hobbit through the act of subdividing the section he had already created into three equal parts.

"It's also important to know where you intend to go with the braid," Fíli explained. "If you want it to lay along his head, you will need to braid it in that direction otherwise it will stick out oddly when you are done." Bilbo nodded to show that he understood and then he and Thorin began braiding. It was simple really, once he understood the pattern and soon he had reached the end of the braid, feeling mighty proud of himself.

Proud of himself that is until Fíli saw it and laughed. Bilbo looked at it in confusion. What had he done wrong? There weren't any gaps and the hair was holding together. Wondering what Fíli's looked like, he looked at the other side of Kíli's head and saw the difference. Where Fíli's braid was sleek and uniform, braided tightly enough that it seemed to be carved into the hair rather than separate strands woven together, Bilbo's was loose in places and tight in others, with an obvious scalloping on the sides. He'd failed.

"It's not bad for a first attempt," Thorin said patting the hobbit. "If I recall, Fíli's first attempt at a braid left a knot in my hair that it took the combined efforts of Dís and me hours to remove. I'm still not sure how he did it. You'll eventually learn tension with practice. If you would like another try, my braids could probably use redoing as well."

At the offer, Bilbo shook his head vehemently. "I can't," he said his voice high and panicked. "I can't do it. I failed such a simple task and as Kíli said, you can't be seen in lopsided braids. You don't want me to do it."

"No one here will comment, Bilbo," the King said gently as he undid the clasps on his own braids while Fíli gathered both of his brothers and clasped them at the back of his head, leaving Bilbo's lumpy braid as it was rather than replacing it with a smooth one of his own. Bilbo felt a wave of regret. Kíli already hated having braids and now he had one beautiful dwarf braid and one clumsy hobbit braid. He was lopsided. He would never consent to be braided again once the others were through making fun of him.

"But—"

"It'll be alright," Thorin promised. "Even if you do manage to tie my hair in knots. You will only get better through practice. I don't mind a few bad braids. Besides, most of mine are concealed. It will be fine." With a sigh, Bilbo began to undo the plaits in Thorin's hair. Again he was struck by the texture of it, surprised by the softness. Once all the clasps were in one of Thorin's hands and all the braids undone, the King handed him a comb. Bilbo began trying to comb the tangles out as he had seen Fíli and Thorin do for Kíli, but stopped when the King winced.

"I'm sorry!" Bilbo cried releasing the comb, which remained in Thorin's hair having become ensnared in a persistent knot.

"It is fine" Thorin said. "Try starting at the ends. It should help avoid pulling." Bilbo sighed and fought the comb free of the knot before beginning at the ends. It was strangely soothing, the repetitiveness of the combing and soon Bilbo found himself talking. For the first time, he now understood the intimateness of the act. There was a good deal of trust in it. With the way you had to grasp the hair to keep it from pulling, it would be too easy for someone standing behind you to grab a handful of hair and slit your throat before you even knew it. Even as his mind shied away from the mental image with revulsion, he had to smile. It was nice to be trusted, to be allowed so close. It filled him with warmth and the warmth gave him the daring to ask a question he had been meaning to ask all day.

"I have a question," Bilbo said with no lead up or preamble. Thorin hummed in response but said nothing. "Why? Why did you react the way you did today? I don't understand what we did to upset you. I mean, I know that he touched me, but why did that upset you so?"

Thorin took a deep breath to tamp down his jealously once more. He didn't appreciate the reminder of what Bilbo and Bofur had done. Bilbo was his after all. But the question had been so soft. So innocent. Perhaps Bilbo truly didn't know what he had done. The thought had never occurred to the King and it alone tempered his anger.

"What do you know of dwarvish courtship customs?" Thorin asked quietly instead of answering Bilbo's questions.

"Nothing," the hobbit replied sadly and honestly. "That was why I went to Bofur. I hoped that he could explain them to me so you didn't think me worthless."

"I could never think that," Thorin said, hurt that Bilbo could think that he was capable of that, even as part of his mind remided him that he had said as much in the past and that until recently it had been clear that he had detested Bilbo's presence. Though it hadn't been for the reason Bilbo thought. He hadn't though him worthless, rather the converse. He couldn't stand the thought of seeing something so small and so sheltered marred by the world. He had wanted him to get discouraged and go home before he got hurt. It just hadn't come across that way. Thorin knew that he should tell the hobbit the truth, but he couldn't bring himself to do it. So instead he let Bilbo think that his mind had changed about his worth as a person not his ability to cope with the world.

"You did," Bilbo reminded him. "Even said it on numerous occasions, remember? I didn't want to revisit that so I figured that I would ask someone else. Balin was busy, Fíli and Kíli . . . I decided not to use them." Thorin didn't blame him. If he needed a straight answer his nephews would not be the first person he would go to if he were anyone other than their uncle or their mother.

"So you went to Bofur," Thorin said, feeling slightly ashamed at his actions. Bilbo had sought help from a friend and he had gotten jealous, which Bilbo hadn't known to expect. He should have explained it to Bilbo himself rather than assume that courtship customs were the same between the races. He might owe the hobbit a true apology.

"Yes," Bilbo replied his voice distracted as he worked at a rather stubborn knot. "So how do dwarven courtship customs lead to the reaction you had to Bofur and my interaction?"

"Dwarves," Thorin began, searching for the right words to explain this to a hobbit. "Dwarves are jealous creatures. We guard our secrets and those that we care about with a passion. There are certain actions, intimacies, that are reserved only for family and lovers. A touch like the one Bofur used today is one of those things. Intentional body contact, it is reserved for siblings, parents or lovers, neither of which you are to him despite your friendship."

"That's why I've never seen dwarves hug!" Bilbo exclaimed. "I'd wondered about that. Other than the hug that you gave me and one that I witnessed between Balin and Dwalin I've never seen it. Not even Fíli and Kíli and they're the touchiest of the dwarves."

"Yes," Thorin agreed. "Until I asked you to court me I should never have hugged you the way I did, or lifted you from the stream and tried to carry you back to camp. I overstepped myself and for that I apologize."

"No you didn't," Bilbo replied. "Not in my book. Hobbit's don't do casual contact the way that dwarves do, with your little brushes and small touches, but hugging is not frowned upon among friends. It's almost expected. I was shocked that it was you that hugged me—I wasn't aware that we were friends—but the hug itself did not upset me."

"So, what else does dwarven courtship entail?" Bilbo asked wondering what else he had agreed to. He could curb his need to touch others if he needed to but what else would Thorin expect of him. He knew that he would have to submit to their traditions as he was with them, but he hoped that it would be nothing too trying.

"Official or unofficial?" Thorin asked. "The rules are slightly different between the two."

"Let's stick with unofficial, shall we?" Bilbo said with a wry smile as he ran his fingers experimentally through Thorin's thick hair trying to see if there were more tangles he couldn't see and gently working one out when his fingers snagged. "We'll worry about the other rules when we come to them."

"Unofficial courtship rules are fairly simple," Thorin said, his voice falling into a lecture pattern that he had used many times when Fíli and Kíli were growing up. "The underlying idea behind all of them is commitment to the other. There is an understanding that even though we are not married, we are together and that neither of us will seek another while the courtship continues. Courtship, unofficial or official, is a thing of mutual possession."

"How far does this extend?" Bilbo asked. "Are you going to get angry and jealous if I, say, smile at Ori? Or would it take a hug or other body contact to spark it?" Thorin pinched the bridge of his nose at the question. What did Bilbo want, for him to have Balin draw up a contract with what could and could not happen during their courtship? Perhaps it would be easier . . .

"How do hobbits court?" Thorin asked suddenly cutting off another scenario Bilbo was coming up with as he attempted to see just how much of an imposition dwarvish courtship would be on the hobbit and if they should perhaps reach a compromise of sorts, some hybrid courtship ritual that would be agreeable to them both.

"Pardon me?" Bilbo asked, having not heard the question as he had been in the middle of a rant before Thorin cut him off.

"Hobbits," Thorin repeated. "How do you court?"

Bilbo laughed in response and began to attempt to section off a chunk of Thorin's hair as the King had done for Kíli. It was more difficult than he had thought it would be. "Hobbit courting is nothing like dwarf courting," Bilbo replied. "We're not so much about possession as mutual trust. Most hobbits court a few times before marriage happens, experimenting and finding the right partner before settling down. And at no point, even at the ceremony itself, is a courtship unable to be dissolved."

"And you," Thorin asked quietly not sure if he truly wanted the answer. He suspected that Bilbo had courted many times before. "Have you courted before?"

"No," Bilbo replied sadly. "I was never interested in courting." Thorin sighed, even though that was the answer his heart wanted, it ached to hear the sadness in Bilbo's voice.

"Why?" the King asked. "If you don't mind."

"I don't mind," Bilbo said. "I don't truly know. I guess I was never that interested. Could have had something to do with a lack of mutual attraction. At any rate, I had contented myself to remain a bachelor forever until you lot showed up."

The king had no reply to that and before he could attempt to think of one, Bilbo let out a little noise of frustration. "So stupid!" Bilbo muttered darkly."I can't believe . . . I'm hopeless."

"What are you murmuring about?" Thorin asked wanting to turn his head to look at the hobbit but unable to move due to the hold Bilbo had on his hair.

"I'm a fool," Bilbo replied with a sigh. Thorin raised an eyebrow to encourage the hobbit to elaborate before realizing that Bilbo couldn't see his face and that he would have to ask.

"Why do you say that?" Thorin asked.

"You're going to laugh," Bilbo said with a wry laugh, "or perhaps be angry, but I have no idea where your braids go and I know that you dwarves are particular about your braids. I'll just get one of your nephews, shall I?"

Rather than get angry, Thorin did laugh. Bilbo truly knew nothing of dwarven courtship. "It is fine, hobbit," the king promised. "As my mate you are allowed to arrange my hair as you see fit. Changing braids your mate has always worn is one of the signs of a successful courtship. Place them wherever you would like. All I will ask is that you secure the hair in the front out of my face. Outside of that, the choice is yours."

Rather than reassure the hobbit, Thorin's words upset him. The king wanted him not to duplicate but to create? He couldn't even manage the simplest braid and Thorin wanted him to . . . he couldn't do it! It was too much pressure and he felt panic begin to seize him. Kíli might not care what his hair looked like, but he was young and the butt of many jokes anyway but Thorin . . . he was a king, a cool, distant figure. Majestic even and he wanted Bilbo to . . . he never should have agreed to this. It was beyond him.

"Bilbo," Thorin said gently, having heard the hobbit's sharp intake of breath and his now panicked breathing. "Halfling! It will be alright. You are not stuck with the style you choose tonight forever. Would it help if for tonight I guide you like I did with Kíli's braid?" Bilbo nodded and Thorin took the hobbit's hands in his own again before he sectioned off a chunk of his own hair and began to braid it.

"You-you seem practiced at this," Bilbo said with a weak laugh.

"I've been braiding my own hair since I was thirty, Halfling," Thorin replied. "I should be practiced."

"Can you not do that?" Bilbo asked suddenly, his tone strange. He was slightly uncomfortable with asking the king not to do something, but this had been bothering him since the moment Thorin had walked through his door and he could keep silent no longer.

"Do what?" Thorin replied. He wasn't aware that he had done anything wrong.

"Call me 'Halfling'," Bilbo replied. "I don't mind if you want to call me 'hobbit' or even 'burglar', though I do prefer Bilbo, but not 'Halfling'."

"Does the term offend you?" Thorin asked. He hadn't realized that 'Halfling' was an offensive term. He had thought that it was what they were called. That was what he had always heard them called, when they were spoken of at all.

"A bit," Bilbo replied. "We prefer to be called hobbits, or Shirefolk."

"I wasn't aware that it was offensive," Thorin replied, his hands stilling on the braid. "I will try to not use it again. I'm sorry."

"It's fine," Bilbo replied brusquely. "You didn't know and now you do. Come! Let's finish these braids so that we can eat dinner. It should be ready soon." With a slight nod, Thorin resumed the act of guiding Bilbo through the braid, pausing briefly as he felt what he almost thought were the hobbit's lips press against the back of his hand. He thought Bilbo had kissed him, but the sensation was gone so quickly that he couldn't be sure.

Notes:

I have no idea what happened to this chapter. It turned into a giant ball of fluff and dialogue . . . nearly 5000 words and nothing really happened—plot wise anyway. At any rate, I hope you enjoyed it.

 

Well, that's all for now folks! I hope you enjoyed it and would love to hear what you thought (even if you hated it) so please leave me a review if you have time and/or feel so inclined.

Stickdonkeys