Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 18: A Dwarf Asks a Question and Regrets It

Chapter Text

They stopped that night well after it had grown too dark for Bilbo to see to travel. Though it hurt his pride to do so, the only way that he could carry on was to hold the back of Thorin’s coat and stumble blindly along. He knew that he should just admit to them that he could not see and ask them to stop, but he had already been the cause of so many delays that day that he had no desire to be the cause of another. So rather than admit his weakness, he followed blindly along, concentrating on not tripping.

Eventually, however, he did make a mistake and his feet wound up tangled with Thorin’s and nearly brought them both down. After a brief apology and explanation from the hobbit, the King called a halt for the night. Though he didn’t say it, it troubled him that Bilbo hadn’t felt comfortable telling him that he was unable to see well enough to travel. It wasn’t as though he would have been angry with the hobbit for the fact that his eyes were not adapted to seeing in the dark as well as those of the dwarves. The company would not have begrudged him his inability either. In fact, they would have understood this better than they had breakfast and lunch breaks. Traveling blind was dangerous, not only for him but for them all, while traveling while peckish was nothing more than an inconvenience.

And unlike the other times that day that Thorin had called a halt for Bilbo’s sake, the company offered no complaint this time. Despite their fine words about traveling as far as their legs would carry them to speed their passage through the forest, they were more than ready for a rest. They were weary, hungry and more than satisfied with the progress they had made that day. They all dropped their packs to the ground gratefully before beginning to set up camp for the night. Only Balin was immune from having to help, having received a task from the King earlier that day. With a deep sigh, Balin put the finishing touches on the contract before walking over to Thorin.

“It’s done,” the white-haired dwarf said gravely. “Now, what you do with it is your own affair, however I won’t have you blaming me if he reacts badly.”

“Nonsense!” Thorin replied reading through the contract as he spoke and seeing that all was in order. “He won’t react badly. As soon as they have gotten a fire lit I will give it to him to look over and see what he objects to.”

“Thorin, I really think that you should—“

“Uncle,” Kíli said quietly cutting Balin’s suggestion off. “I need to ask you something.” Kíli hadn’t meant to interrupt, but he had been working all day to screw up his courage to do it and now that he had, he wasn’t about to wait. He knew that if he didn’t do it he wouldn’t do it and he had to know.

“Can it wait, laddie?” Balin asked. “Your uncle and I are discussing something very important.”

“No,” Thorin said with a soft smile for his youngest nephew. Any other dwarf that had interrupted such a private conversation would have been a smoldering pile of ash from the heat his gaze would have contained but Kíli . . . Thorin had always had a soft spot for the lad. For Fíli as well. They were allowed leeway that no others could expect—save, perhaps, Bilbo.

“We’re done, Balin,” Thorin continued. “Your concerns are noted and I will consider them. Thank you for your help in this matter.” Balin offered Thorin a small bow and walked away shaking his head and muttering to himself about foolish, mulish dwarves that were about to do foolish things through ignoring sound advice. Thorin shook his head indulgently at his old friend. He understood that Balin was worried, but it was baseless. Bilbo would be pleased with the contract. He was sure of it.

“What did you want to ask me that was urgent enough that you were willing to interrupt Balin midsentence, Kíli?” Thorin asked with a bit of censure in his tone. Even if he cared for the boy, Kíli really couldn’t go about interrupting meetings once they were successful in reclaiming Erebor. The young dwarf at least had the decency to look ashamed of his actions but still sat next to his uncle with a resolved expression on his face and a blush on his cheeks. It was when he began shuffling his feet that Thorin grew anxious about what had happened. Surely no one had been being cruel to his nephew. He could think of no other reason Kíli would be so embarrassed.

“What is it lad?” Thorin asked, gently placing a hand on Kíli’s shoulder and offering his nephew a small smile to encourage him to talk. He regretted it when he saw determination and embarrassment warring for dominance in Kíli’s brown eyes. This was about him and Bilbo. He knew it. He hoped that he was wrong, but he knew that was what Kíli wanted to talk about. The second he opened his mouth Thorin regretted sending Balin away, the other dwarf would have been better at explaining such a thing than Thorin was.  

“I have a question, well more than one actually, about what happened today between you and Bilbo,” Kíli said abruptly the words coming out so quickly that it was almost impossible for Thorin to hear where one ended and the next began even after years of talking with his excitable nephew.

“You have questions?” Thorin breathed. Even though he had known that was what Kíli wanted to talk about he had hoped—no prayed—that he had been mistaken. Even now he hoped that he had misheard. He had to have misheard. Kíli was seventy-seven! Surely Dís had talked with the boys about sex. As soon as the thought crossed his mind he rejected it. He knew his sister: she hadn’t.

“Yes. Questions,” Kíli agreed. “Mr. Dwalin explained what you were doing, but how does something like that work? I mean, how do you manage to get your p—“

“Kíli,” Thorin cut him off with a strangled cry that was almost a moan. He couldn’t do this! He looked around desperately for someone who he could compel to do this for him. Rampaging hordes of Orcs he could handle but for something so clearly stated and so crass to come from Kili, his sweet little Kíli . . . he couldn’t do it. Sadly, everyone else was deeply engrossed in their various tasks.

“What?” Kíli demanded with a bit of a whine in his tone. “No one will tell me anything! I asked Fíli but he just turned green and told me to ask someone else. I don’t know who else to ask, Uncle.” Thorin closed his eyes and vowed that when he next saw his sister he would have words with her for forcing this on him. She had birthed the lad. She should have been the one to explain this.

“Kíli, please tell me that you at least know where dwarflings come from,” the King asked in a pained voice, unknowingly echoing Dwalin from earlier.

“Well,” Kíli said slowly, his eyebrows pulling together as he thought. “I know that a male and a female dwarf do what you and Bilbo did and sometimes dwarflings result. But I don’t know how that works either.” Thorin wanted to weep! Why did this fall to him? Kíli had no idea where dwarflings actually came from . . . especially not if he thought that what Thorin and Bilbo had done would result in dwarflings even if he and Bilbo were a male and female. Thorin amended his plans for his sister. He wasn’t going to yell at her: he was going to murder her.

“Not exactly,” Thorin sighed trying to figure out how to explain to Kíli that sex had different facets, different flavors, that . . . he couldn’t even find the words that he wanted within his own mind. Once again he looked around desperately for someone to rescue him from this: there was no one. He was alone. Why had Bilbo saved him from that Orc? Death would have been preferable to this.

“What do you mean?” Kíli asked, his confusion obvious even though Thorin couldn’t bring himself to look at his nephew. “Dwarflings come from sex, you and Bilbo had sex. How is it not the same thing?”

“Bilbo’s a male, Kíli,” Thorin said, his mind scrambling as he tried to think of how to explain the differences between males and females to Kíli since the lad obviously had no idea about anything to do with sex. He only hoped that he wouldn’t have to explain female versus male anatomy to his nephew. He wasn’t sure that he could survive that. He suddenly wished that one of the lads had been a girl and then he wouldn’t have had to explain this part of it. While he knew more of the female anatomy that Kíli obviously did, he couldn’t claim that he was an expert by any means. Especially not in how to explain it to one who had never seen it. He briefly entertained the idea of enlisting Ori’s help with a couple of sketches before he discarded that idea. Not only would Dori not appreciate that, he doubted that Ori had seen a woman without her clothes before either. Perhaps Óin . . .

“I know that, Uncle,” Kíli said exasperatedly breaking into Thorin’s nearly frantic thoughts about who to push his nephew off on. “I don’t see why that’s important. He’s a male. You’re a male. You had sex. Why does it matter what you both are? Sex is sex, isn’t it?” Thorin—though he was perfectly fine discussing all manner of filthy things with Bilbo—found that Kíli’s casual use of the word “sex” embarrassed him to no end. His nephew was still a child for Mahal’s sake! He shouldn’t be able to say such a word without it affecting him somehow! He should . . . Thorin didn’t know! He should stutter over the word, blush, something to show that he was affected by it! Not just blurt it out!

“Kíli,” Thorin begged, his blue eyes tortured as he stared at his youngest nephew, “can you please not use that word.” Kíli looked at him in confusion at his request. His uncle had almost sounded as though he were in pain.

“What word, Uncle?” Kíli asked innocently not understanding why a word would upset his uncle so. He was only curious after all. It wasn’t as though he was asking Thorin for a demonstration! “Sex?” Kíli offered for clarification and saw as his uncle visibly flinched as it left his mouth.

“Yes,” Thorin snapped. “That word.” The innocence in Kíli’s tone had only made it worse for his poor traumatized uncle. It almost seemed as though Kíli had no idea just how inappropriate a topic this was! Thorin decided that he might have to have a word with his company about some of the bawdy humor that permeated the air. Obviously it had been a bad influence on his young, impressionable nephew.

“Then what should I call it?” The question took Thorin by surprise. He wasn’t sure what Kíli should call it. And if they were going to talk about it they had to call it something. He scoured his brain for an appropriate term for Kíli to use. He could think of a few terms for that act, but most of them were actually worse. He knew that he would die of embarrassment if his nephew used the word “rutting” for example. And while “fornicating” was appropriate for what he and Bilbo had done it carried too much condemnation. It wouldn’t do to have Kíli talking about “making love” either.

“What if we call it “having relations”?” Thorin suggested uncomfortably. It was perfect, or as perfect as a word to be used by his nephew to ask about sex could be. Descript enough to get the point across and vague enough that he could almost pretend that they were discussing something else entirely.  Or at least that is what he thought before Kíli spoke again.

“Fine,” his nephew said with a shrug. It didn’t matter to him what they called it as long as he got his answers. “So how are the relations that you and Bilbo are having different from the relations that led to me and Fíli, or any of the dwarves here . . . or Bilbo for that matter?” Thorin felt a flush rise up his face at the question. Did the lad have no shame? How in Durin’s name could the boy talk about Bilbo and Thorin having relations and his own mother and father doing the same in the same sentence? It was too much.

“Kíli, please,” Thorin begged for what felt like the hundredth time since this conversation had begun, “can we please not discuss your mother, and my sister’s sex life. Please!” He adamantly hoped that Kíli would agree. That would be too much for Thorin to bear. His nephews were proof that his beloved little sister was a creature of passion, but he didn’t want to think about it. Just the idea of Dís in the throes of passion with anyone—even her husband—was enough to make Thorin want to break something. The idea that someone would do that to his baby sister . . . Thankfully Kíli dropped that subject.

“Ok,” Kili agreed beginning to get frustrated as he realized that his Uncle was never going to answer his questions. “Now how are they different?” He wasn’t sure what he would do if Thorin tried to hedge around it again. As it was now, the conversation was so inhibited that even if his uncle answered the question Kíli wasn’t sure that he would understand the answer.

“What do you know of women?” Thorin asked, closing his eyes and breathing through his nose as he dreaded the answer. Kíli barely restrained his sigh as his uncle answered his question with a question yet again and tried to give the answer that his uncle was wanting so that he might get the answer he wanted.

“I know there are less of them than there are us,” Kíli offered with a smile. Thorin sighed in defeat. Kíli wasn’t going to make this easy. He still couldn’t understand how such a sweet child that didn’t even know the differences between men and women could ask him such a crude question with a straight face. But perhaps his lack of embarrassment was due to his innocence.

“What else?” Thorin fished, hoping that Kíli was just being vague on purpose to keep how much he knew himself out of trouble and that the more questions he asked the more honest Kíli would be. He knew that that wasn’t the case, there was too much innocence in Kíli’s wide brown eyes, but he could still hope.

“That’s it really,” his nephew said. “I don’t know much else. There are fewer of them.” He was worried when his uncle placed his head in his hands and moaned. He had never heard Thorin make that sound before. Was Thorin sick or injured?

“Uncle? Are you alright? Are you unwell?” Kíli’s voice was louder than he had intended and Bilbo looked up from the food he was preparing at the fire before deciding that it was chopped enough and dropping in into the pot and walking over to his lover and his lover’s nephew, a small concerned frown on his face. He had never seen Thorin in that position before, even after he had been wounded by the white orc.

“Thorin?” Bilbo said quietly, placing a hand on the dwarf’s shoulder. “Is everything alright?” Bilbo nearly flinched away from the blind panic in Thorin’s eyes as he looked up at the hobbit: panic that shifted nearly instantly to relief and hope. He grasped Bilbo’s spare hand between both of his and looked up at the hobbit with love, and what almost looked like desperation.

“Help me,” Thorin pleaded. “I . . . I can’t do this, Bilbo.” Bilbo was shocked. Thorin was admitting that he couldn’t do something and was asking him for help. Thorin was begging him! There was only one thing that he could say in response to such a plea.

“Of course,” Bilbo said with a small smile. How bad could it be? He didn’t miss the bright smile that crossed Thorin’s face or the way that his shoulders relaxed as though Bilbo had just taken a great weight from them. He was proud that he could help his lover in such a way. He had never seen such a happy expression on Thorin’s face before and he was responsible for it! Bilbo could have walked on air!

“I knew I could count on you,” Thorin said as he stood and briefly embraced the hobbit before he walked away a bit quicker than was strictly necessary to talk with Dwalin about what he had started by only telling Kíli a fraction of what he wanted to know. The way Thorin saw it, if the warrior intended to start an explanation of private things with his youngest nephew, he needed to finish them.

“What are you wanting me to do?” Bilbo called after him, confused by what looked to him to be a hurried retreat. Was Thorin fleeing from his own nephew? What had Kíli done to his uncle?

“Talk to Kíli,” Thorin called over his shoulder. That only confused Bilbo more. He knew that Thorin’s nephews could be a bit of a handful but Thorin had helped to raise them. Surely he was immune to them by now. Was it really more than Thorin could handle just to talk with Kíli?

“What do you want to talk about?” the hobbit asked, turning to face Kíli with confusion still burning in his hazel eyes. The dwarf looked at him with an inscrutable expression on his face. It seemed like a mix between determination and frustration. Bilbo shifted uncomfortably under the young dwarf’s gaze. He didn’t know what Kíli wanted, but he did know that Kíli intended to get it.

“I want to know about sex,” Kíli replied matter-of-factly. “How it works, and what Uncle meant by his statement that what the two of you did differs from what a male and a female do to conceive a dwarfling. And you will tell me.” Bilbo felt his shoulders droop. Blast Thorin for pushing this off on him! He now understood why the dwarf was fleeing. He had never taken Thorin for a coward, but to be routed by his nephew with a question about sex . . . that was cowardly . . . and to push it off on him . . . that was low. But Bilbo had agreed to do it and do it he would. Even if Thorin would hear about it later. Loudly, shrilly and perhaps with a few choice words thrown into the mix. But for now, Kíli would get his answers.

“What do you know about the differences between males and females?” Bilbo asked with a resigned sigh. At least this was something that he knew something about.

ooOO88OOoo

A half hour later, Kíli was regretting that he had ever wanted to know about sex. He had learned things that, quite frankly, disturbed him. Including the very marked and graphic difference between sex to produce dwarflings and the kind of sex that Bilbo and his uncle had engaged in. Kíli now understood why simply the word “sex” had caused his uncle to twitch. Bilbo’s rather frank explanations on anatomy and functionality . . . Kíli was more than a bit traumatized. Even though Dwalin had told him what was happening, Bilbo’s explanation, for all that he used much less crude words, was worse because he spoke of lubrication, pleasure points and—Kíli shuddered at the word—stimulation. The idea that Bilbo had let Thorin do that to him—or that his uncle had wanted to—was more than Kíli could handle and his disgust only grew worse when he realized that his father had done the other thing to his mother! Not only once but at least twice since there were two of them. He had been begging Bilbo to stop at that point, that he knew enough to go on, but Bilbo had been merciless.

“Kíli, my lad,” Bilbo had said with a laugh, “you asked and it would be remiss of me to leave you only partially educated. Now stay there and let me finish.” Kíli had turned a shade of green that put Fíli’s earlier color to shame as Bilbo’s explanation drew on. Eventually, the hobbit decided that he had traumatized the young heir of Durin sufficiently and stood, patting the dwarf consolingly on the shoulder before leaving to search for the eldest heir or Durin to give him a piece of his mind. Kíli sat alone in the dark staring into the ground as he had earlier that day. Only this time it was worse because he had clearer images to go with the vague ideas Dwalin had given him and much more graphic ideas from Bilbo—as the hobbit had even gone into positions the act could be committed in depending on the flexibility of the participants.

“I told you not to ask, Kíli,” Fíli said dropping down beside his distraught brother. “I told you that you didn’t want to know. Why don’t you ever believe me?”

“I thought I did,” Kíli said miserably leaning his head against Fíli’s shoulder. “And why should I believe you? You didn’t know either.” Kíli gave a shudder at some of the things that Bilbo had said. “Not as much as Bilbo, anyway. How do you suppose he learned all of that?”

“Kíli, no,” Fíli said desperately. “No. I can’t. No.” Kíli agreed with him. With how blasé Bilbo had been about describing sexual acts, he had no desire to ask just how the hobbit knew what he knew. Vague—and even not so vague—stories and songs from the company he could handle, but Bilbo’s matter-of-fact way of saying things . . . Kíli knew that any questions about Bilbo’s past would haunt him for the remainder of his life.