Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 19: Confrontations, Personal Questions and Contracts

Chapter Text

It did not take Bilbo long to locate Thorin. The dwarf was sitting beside Dwalin and looking mighty pleased with himself while the warrior was looking as chagrinned as Bilbo had ever seen him. The others that were nearby flinched at the look on the hobbit’s face. However, Thorin didn’t notice when Bilbo walked up and stood glaring down at him with his hands on his hips, but merely continued speaking with Balin about whatever it was that they were discussing. It was only when Bilbo cleared his throat loudly that the King turned to look at him. Thorin seemed oblivious to his lover’s obvious displeasure and greeted him with the widest smile Bilbo had even seen on his face. He was positively beaming.

 “Ah, Bilbo,” Thorin said brightly, “have you finished your discussion with Kíli?”

“Don’t you “ah, Bilbo” me, Thorin Oakenshield!” Bilbo snapped glaring more fiercely at the dwarf. “That was a dirty trick you just pulled on me. Pushing something like that off on me! Just how old is Kíli anyway? Nearly eighty if I remember correctly. I know that you dwarves age differently than hobbits and that he is not quite an adult just yet but do you truly mean to tell me that in eighty years no one thought to explain sex to him?”

“Now, Bilbo—“

“Don’t you “now, Bilbo” me either! I’ve not finished with you just yet!” Bilbo snapped cutting Thorin off mid word.

“Now see here!” Thorin replied in kind, standing to glare down at his lover. “I am the leader of this company and a king besides. I am well within my rights to delegate—“

“Delegate?!” Bilbo scoffed. “That wasn’t a delegation! It was a retreat! You fled leaving me to deal with the mess that you created.”

“Mess I created?” Thorin thundered. “If I remember correctly, which I do, you were the one that started the actions that led to his needing to be educated.” Bilbo scoffed and Thorin only spoke more loudly to cover any protests he might have. “And Dwalin was the one who told him just enough to make him more curious.” Bilbo instantly rounded on Dwalin with a glare that had the warrior holding his hands up in surrender.

“Don’t pull me into this,” he said with a nervous laugh. “I told him enough to keep him from walking in on the two of you. He was very determined to “rescue” you from his uncle.” Bilbo glared between the two of them for a moment as he attempted to decide which of them he was more angry with before he decided to ask another question to help him narrow it down.

“So which of you was responsible for the fact that he believed that what we did was the same kind of sex that would be used to produce dwarflings?” Bilbo demanded. He was surprised to see Thorin shift a bit uncomfortably at the question but before he could confront him on the stupidity of allowing Kíli to believe that, Dwalin drew his attention once more.

“And what do you know about making dwarflings?” The warrior asked with a snort. The fact that Bilbo was rutting in the woods with Thorin called Bilbo’s credibility as a teacher of heterosexual sex into question. No matter how worldly the hobbit believed himself to be, Dwalin would never believe that he had bedded enough females to be an expert if he had even bedded one. No, current evidence led Dwalin to believe that Bilbo knew nothing about sex for procreation purposes. At least not from first-hand experience.

“A good deal more than you lot, apparently!” Bilbo retaliated. “I wasn’t the one that gave Kíli the idea that anal sex could produce offspring. Imagine if I hadn’t straightened the poor lad out! What would his poor wife have thought on their wedding night! Why he would have tried to stick his—“

“Stop!” Thorin snapped cutting Bilbo off with a gentle hand over his mouth before he could say something traumatizing. “Bilbo Baggins, the last thing that I wish to hear you speak on is what my youngest nephew will do in his wedding night. Or where he would have been putting anything.” It was a prospect that Thorin did not even want to begin to contemplate. Kíli was far too young to be having sex . . . if Thorin had his way, Dís would still be too young to be having sex. There was no way that he was going to discuss his nephew’s potential sex life with his mate.

“He wouldn’t have done anything on his wedding night if it was up to you lot,” Bilbo replied pulling away from Thorin’s hand and glaring at the dwarf once more. “Poor lad didn’t even know how to go about it. He barely knew anything about masturb—“

“And how do you know about how to bed a woman well enough to give Kíli pointers,” Dwalin asked cutting off the hobbit’s protests about Kíli’s lack of knowledge since Thorin had gone abnormally pale at even the hint of the word “masturbation.” “Had a few women in your time, have you? Wouldn’t really surprise me. I’ve always said that Thorin was too pretty for a dwarf.” At the last sentence, Thorin, who had been looking at his old friend in thanks, began to stutter indignantly while Bilbo flushed a brilliant
crimson color.

“Well, no,” Bilbo stammered. “Not exactly. I mean . . . I’ve never actually . . . well, not with a female . . . or-well . . .”

“Thorin was your first?” Bofur asked incredulously. He was too shocked by the revelation to try to stay out of the argument. “And you allowed him to bed you in the woods? You must really love him.”

“I . . . well, I” Bilbo stuttered, trying to say that ‘yes, he did care very much for Thorin and that it was truly none of their business, thank you very much.’ But he never managed it. His words stopped in his throat as an even deeper flush rose up his face at Dwalin’s next question.

“If you’ve never bedded a lass how did you know anything to tell Kíli about it?” Bilbo squeaked indignantly at the question. This hadn’t been what he had had in mind when he had decided to confront Thorin about his cowardice. He hadn’t known that it would spark more question, especially not such personal questions. He had never expected that dwarves that were too embarrassed to explain sex to a child would be capable of prying into the details of his sex life before he was their King’s mate. How was he supposed to explain that all of his knowledge had come from books and that he had no idea if he had actually give Kíli good advice? He was trying to decide how to answer the question when he was saved.

“Bilbo’s sexual past is no concern of yours,” Thorin said suddenly, “nor is the source of any sexual knowledge he may have.” His words effectively ended the conversation and spared poor Bilbo further mortification. “He and I have discussed this already and there is no need for it to be revisited outside of our own relationship. Now, I would suggest that you leave our burglar in peace and allow the matter to drop. Permanently.” Though they were disappointed that they would never get the answer, they now had no choice but to let it drop. They could not disobey a direct order from Thorin, no matter how great their curiosity.

Despite his anger at Thorin for pushing Kíli off on him, Bilbo did not struggle when Thorin put a hand around his shoulder and led him towards the light of the cook fire. He was glad of it, in fact, as it meant that the others would leave him in peace. Even if they intended to ask him about it later when Thorin wasn’t around, they would never do it with him right there. For a while, Bilbo would be free of uncomfortable personal questions. Even so, Bilbo had not forgiven his lover enough to be the first to speak and the silence was a bit uncomfortable.

“I . . . I wish to apologize to you,” Thorin said suddenly from beside him. “You were correct. It was wrong of me to push my familial duty off onto you. I should have been the one to explain it to Kíli. And perhaps Fíli while I was doing it. I doubt that my sister ever explained it to either of them.”

“Why did it fall to you?” Bilbo asked gently. He knew that it was likely to be a painful subject but he had never heard anything about the boy’s father and wondered why he hadn’t been the one to explain it to them and why Thorin should have been the one to do it.

“Because Dís would never have wanted to explain sex to her boys,” Thorin replied with a laugh at the mental image of his sister trying to discuss sex with her sons. The color she would turn might just have put Bilbo’s latest display to shame.

“What of their father?” Bilbo prompted. “Surely he should have been the one to do it.” He instantly regretted his words as the humor that had been on Thorin’s face vanished abruptly.

“You . . . they never told you? They never explained what happed to their father?” the King breathed. He knew that Bilbo had been close to the boys at the start of the journey and figured that it had come up in one of their discussions.

“They never said anything about a father. Until I heard Kíli call you “Uncle” I thought that they were yours. Kíli does look like you and Fíli does have your eyes. What should they have told me?” Bilbo asked, he was confused. Thorin closed his eyes with a sigh.

“Their father died before Kíli was born,” Thorin explained. “It was a mining accident. They are rare in dwarven mines, but they do still happen. Fíli . . . he doesn’t remember him. Not really. All he can remember is the color of his father’s hair. It was light gold. Lighter than his own. That is all. Kíli . . . he never even met him. Dís did not even know that she was with child when her husband died. She always said that Kíli was Gíli’s last gift to her. His final surprise. You would have liked him. He was much like his sons. So full of life and light. He was a good dwarf.” Thorin said no more, thinking of how disconsolate his poor sister had been at her husband’s death. For a time she had retreated within herself and left him to raise her boys as best he could. But he couldn’t fault her for it. He hadn’t even before he understood what true love felt like. Even the thought of losing Bilbo . . . he now believed that his sister may have underreacted.

“I’m sorry,” Bilbo said quietly, placing a hand on Thorin’s arm and offering him a sad smile. “It seems that I always ask questions that lead to painful memories. I don’t mean to.”

“My dear hobbit,” Thorin said returning Bilbo’s sad smile with one of his own and gently stroking along Bilbo’s cheekbone with the back of his index finger, “I have been alive a very long time and I have many painful memories. I know that you do not mean to hurt me with your questions and I do not hold you responsible for any pain an innocent question may cause. If I held everything that anyone said that evoked a painful memory against them I would never be able to speak to another person.”

“All the same, I am sorry,” Bilbo replied. “So what were you and Balin talking about before I interrupted?” Thorin smiled at the segue. It was perfect because Balin had once again been attempting to dissuade him from presenting Bilbo with the contract.

“I asked him to do something for me earlier today and he was giving it to me,” Thorin answered.

“What did you ask him to do in the middle of Mirkwood,” Bilbo asked thinking of the paper that Balin had been writing on earlier that he had told Bilbo that he would find out about later in such an ominous tone. Was he working on Thorin’s request then?

“Do you remember when we were discussing the rules of courtship yesterday?” Thorin replied with a soft smile on his face. He was certain that Bilbo would be pleased with the contract.

“I do,” Bilbo replied warily. “But what does that have to do with Balin?” He had a feeling that he knew where this was going and hoped that he was wrong. Surely Thorin hadn’t had Balin draw up the rules for Bilbo to read and agree to, had he? No. Even at his most insufferable he would never have done that.

“I asked him if he would be willing to write them down for you. For us,” Thorin explained, that same smile still in place. He hadn’t noticed that Bilbo was no longer flustered but that he was begging to puff up with anger. “I figured that we could look them over, cross out the ones that were intolerable and add in a few hobbit rules to make up the difference.”

“Like a contract?” Bilbo demanded sarcastically. An irritated expression on his face. Thorin’s eyes widened at the change and he began trying to think of a way to spin it in a more favorable light.

“Not a contract,” Thorin countered. “More like a list of the expectations from each party and the rules that we both will agree to follow.”

“Like a contract,” Bilbo said more forcefully, his voice growing in volume as he processed the fact that his lover wanted him to sign a contract detailing what he would and would not be able to do.

“No,” Thorin repeted. “Not like a contract. It is just the standard rules of dwarven courtship written out for you and me to look over and decide which ones we wish to adhere to and which are mutually unbearable and would be better substituted for hobbit rules. It is just an agreement between lovers so that we both know what to expect.”

“Just like negotiating a contract,” Bilbo repeated standing up with an exasperated sigh. He stood up and began pacing. “Is this standard practice in dwarven courtships?” For half a moment Thoirn considered lying to Bilbo as a way out of the situation. If it was normal practice Bilbo could not fault him for it. He quickly rejected the idea. Not only was there the very real possibility that Bilbo could discover his deception, but the idea of lying to his hobbit displeased him.

“No,” Thorin sighed. “It is not. Most dwarves only court other dwarves. In that case, both parties know exactly what is expected of them and there is no need for negotiation. But in this case . . .”

“I’m entirely ignorant of you ways and need a blasted contract!” Bilbo snapped glaring at Thorin once more with tears beginning to pool in his blue eyes. “Why are you making this so difficult, Thorin? I . . . I don’t understand. I love you. I trust you. I want to be with you. Why does there need to be something official between us?  Do you really doubt my word to the point that you need to see me agree to court you in writing? If that’s what it will take to make you happy . . . I . . . I’ll do it but . . .” Bilbo trailed off with a small sob and Thorin realized that he had made a mistake. Balin had been right. He had forgotten that hobbits were simple folk. They viewed the world much more kindly than he did and he now saw that Bilbo would see a contract as a lack of trust rather than the sign of respect that Thorin had meant for it to be. He stood slowly and closed the distance between them, pulling Bilbo against his chest gently.

“I am sorry,” Thorin whispered, stroking the curls at the back of Bilbo’s head gently. “I did not mean to upset you. It . . . I had thought . . . you seemed so upset about the fact that you did not know the rules of dwarven courtship that I believed you would appreciate having them written down for you to read. I also knew that there would be some that you would not like—such as the touch restrictions—and felt that I would like to know which ones you were intent on ignoring. I believed that it would eliminate the need for us to argue about it. I see now that I was mistaken and I offer you my sincerest apologies.”

“Do you mean that?” Bilbo asked quietly, pulling back just enough to look up at his lover. “Was that really why you did it? It wasn’t to bind me to you contractually; it was to reassure me?”

“My dear Bilbo,” Thorin replied with a small laugh, “you are already contractually bound to me. I do not need another contract from you. I only sought to help. I did not realize how it would appear to you. I would never knowingly do something that would hurt you. If you would like, I will toss it onto the flames at this moment and we never need speak of it again.”

“No,” Bilbo replied with a wry smile. “Balin worked hard on it. It would be a shame if I was never even to read it. I am not saying that I will sign it, but I would like to read it.”

“Then we shall read it,” Thorin replied shifting Bilbo so that he could retrieve the contract from his pocket before he setteled them on the log once more and handed it to Bilbo. The hobbit read the first line with a snort.

“For something that is not a contract, it more than reads like one,” he said with a laugh before he began to read it aloud. “I, Bilbo Baggins, do hereby promise and swear that I will follow the terms that have been agreed upon in this document to the best of my abilities. Failure to comply with these terms will potentially result in the termination of the unofficial courtship that has been established between myself and my beloved, Thorin II Oakenshield, son of Thráin, son of Thror, King of Durin’s Folk in Exile and future King Under The Mountain. By my signature at the bottom of the document, I show my willingness to abide by the terms laid out herein.”

“You mean to tell me that that is not a contract?” Bilbo asked, mirth dancing in his blue eyes. Thorin only shrugged. There was no need to deny the truth that was written there for Bilbo to read. It was a contract.

“Perhaps it is,” Thorin agreed with a wry half-smile. “However, if you read on, I have a paragraph that is almost identical to yours. Balin is very thorough, however, and included an extra clause in mine about me not doing any harm to your person if you decide that this arrangement is no longer mutually desirable. He is very fond of you.”

“Perhaps we should sign it then,” Bilbo said with a grin. “I would love to have it in writing that you are not permitted to do harm to me for deciding that you truly are an insufferable dwarf and that I can suffer you no longer.”

“Is that a real possibility,” Thorin breathed going unnaturally pale once more at the thought that Bilbo was serious about the probability of him growing tired of Thorin and ending what was growing between them.

“No,” Bilbo replied leaning in to kiss him on his stunned lips. “I don’t believe it is. I am quite fond of you, you silly dwarf. It was only a joke.”

“If that was a joke it was not amusing,” Thorin replied grouchy. He didn’t appreciate Bilbo toying with his emotions in such a way for his own amusement.  

“It was amusing,” Bilbo countered. “However, you have no sense of humor. I’m sure that the others would have liked it very much.”

“Insufferable hobbit,” Thorin muttered darkly. Bilbo shook his head indulgently at his lover’s moodiness.

“You are more than happy to suffer me,” Bilbo replied. “Elsewise we would not be here now looking over a courtship contract, would we?” Thorin could find no words to argue against his logic and before he could think of something to say Bilbo was speaking once more.

“Thorin, if you wouldn’t mind, hand me that ink bottle,” Bilbo said. “This passage here about appropriate places for a king’s consort to dance . . . it needs to go. I will concede many things, but hobbits love to dance and sing. It even forbids dancing with you at our wedding—if it occurs. That won’t do at all. In fact, I would like to change it to the hobbit rule that you have to dance with me at our wedding, if that is agreeable.” Thorin simply handed Bilbo the ink and quill with a nod of agreement. And the two of them passed their time until dinner in just that way. Thorin telling Bilbo which things he would not budge on and Bilbo doing the same. At times the debate became rather heated but in the end they came to an agreement that was mutually pleasing.

Balin blinked owlishly at them as they dropped it back into his lap to reread once they were done with it. The paper, that had been so neatly written before now contained large areas of brutally crossed out text and small cramped chunks of writing both in Bilbo’s spidery hand and Thorin’s bold penmanship each annotation marked with a tiny “B.B.” and Thorin’s name rune.

“What do you expect me to do with this?” Balin asked with a scoff. “I do not intend to rewrite it to include your changes. I wrote it once. If you wish it rewritten you two can do it yourselves. Half of what Bilbo wrote is nearly illegible.”

“Initial the changes to make them official and then witness the signing,” Thorin explained with a laugh. “We have already made all the changes that we desire and are prepared to sign it as is.” Balin looked both of them over with a critical eye. Bilbo did not seem to be under any duress and seemed to be signing it of his own free will. It made no sense. Balin had been certain that Bilbo would never sign a courtship contract.

“You do know that you don’t have to do this, right laddie?” Balin asked shrewdly. “Thorin didn’t tell you that it was required, did he?”

“He told me nothing of the sort,” Bilbo promised. “In fact, he told me that this is by no means normal. However, I feel that he was correct that it was a good idea in our case. Hobbit and dwarf cultures are vastly different after all and as you can see, there were many things that we needed to iron out. This was a good idea, even if he should have asked me before he dropped a contract in my lap a second time.”

“Aye,” Balin agreed with a laugh. “That he should have. You will have to be patient with Thorin, lad. He’s quite stubborn and quite used to getting his own way. He was even like that as a child. Oh! The trouble he and I got into when we were younger! There were times that even his parents despaired of getting him to do as they wanted . . . such a stubborn dwarfling! He got us both into trouble more times than I can count. Every time my father scolded me for something that we had gotten up to together he reminded me that even if stubbornness was an admirable trait in a dwarf, there was a point where it became excessive and that “young prince Thorin” may have crossed the line and that I was under no circumstance to follow him across it.”

“Really?” Bilbo asked, his eyes brightening at the idea of Thorin as a child. “Has he always been so irritable?”

“This is the tame version,” Balin replied with a laugh. “Dwalin, do you remember the time that Thorin challenged you to a duel because you . . . what was it that you made fun of?”

“Of course I remember!” Dwalin laughed. “I made fun of the way that he had dressed Dís.”

“It wasn’t that bad,” Thorin argued rehashing the dispute from years before. “She was fully clothed and even if she hadn’t been, she was—“

“She had more frills on her than I knew that a body could hold!” Dwalin snapped. “I still don’t know how you managed to find someone willing to make a dress like that. You couldn’t have ordered it. You weren’t king yet.”

“How old was he?” Bilbo asked with a laugh at the image of a young angry Thorin glaring at Dwalin.

“He was seventy-seven,” Balin barked. “Not even an adult and challenging my baby brother to a duel over a perceived slight to his sister’s honor.”

“I haven’t heard this story before!” Kíli called. He loved hearing tales from when his uncle was younger. Thorin had been quite mischievous before the cares of his position forced sobriety on him. And tales involving his mother and uncle together were always good. They, and their brother, had done things that Fíli and Kíli could never hope to compare to.

“Yes we have,” Fíli replied with a laugh. “Mother told it one day. But she told it a bit differently. In her version, she was the one to make fun of her dress, Dwalin only laughed in agreement. When Uncle retaliated against Dwalin since he was afraid of his baby sister—her words, not mine, Uncle. I swear it!—Dwalin made a snide comment about people who didn’t have facial hair not being able to join the conversation and which point it became a duel.”

“Oh!” Kíli laughed. “Now I see why I didn’t recognize it. It’s almost not the same story, is it?”

“You never told me that you commented on his beard,” Balin said turning to Dwalin with a glare. “You told me that you had done nothing more than comment on Dís’ dress. No wonder he wanted to kill you.” Shaking his head at his brother he turned to Bilbo to explain. “You see, Bilbo, when Thorin was younger he looked much like young Kíli here. He had no beard just fuzz. And Dís . . . well, she had a mighty fine beard, much like Fíli’s only dark. And she is fourteen years younger than her brother.”

“When did Thorin grow a beard?” Bilbo asked in curiosity wondering just how long it would take Kíli to do the same.

“He was—“

“Enough,” Thorin snapped. “This is more than enough of my personal history for one night! Just initial the changes and sign it so that we can be done with this.” With that said he stalked off and dropped back onto the log he and Bilbo had been sitting on only moments before.

“Oh dear,” Bilbo said, frowning at Thorin’s back. “Perhaps I should—“

“Give him some space, lad,” Balin offered. “Thorin . . . well, we just touched a sore spot for him. We knew better. But this’ll blow over. It always does. Just  . . . just leave him in peace for a bit.” Bilbo sighed. It felt wrong to him to leave Thorin to wallow in peace, but if that was what his oldest friend said was the right thing to do he would listen. So rather than going to sit beside his moody mate, Bilbo sat down between Bofur and Ori and challenged them to a rematch of the game that Fíli and Kíli had disrupted earlier. A challenge they gladly accepted.

ooOO88OOoo