Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 20: Hunger, Tempers, and Broken Pride

Chapter Text

Balin had been right. Thorin’s anger dissipated before dinner was finished. By the time it was time to bed down for the night, he was as cheerful as he ever was, even going as far as to tease his nephews about the brilliant shades of crimson they took on when he gave Bilbo a chaste kiss on the lips when the hobbit finished off a braid he had been repairing. It was this shift in his mood that gave Bilbo the courage to ask the question that he had wanted to ask since Thorin had stormed off.

“Thorin?” Bilbo asked quietly in the darkness, unsure if the dwarf was still awake. The only response he received was a low hum that he felt more than heard. “May I ask you something?”

“You need not ask my permission to ask me a question, my dear hobbit,” Thorin replied his voice soft. “You may ask me whatever you would like.”

“How old were you?” Bilbo whispered knowing that he might be about to condemn himself to a cold and lonely night. “How old were you when you finally grew a beard?” The stiffness and stillness of his lover told him clearly that he should have left it for another day when the memory of his embarrassment was not quite so fresh.

“I’m sorry,” Bilbo sighed. “I’ll just go bed down over there and give you some space, shall I?” He tried to sit up by Thorin’s arm only wrapped more tightly around his waist and held him in place.

“I do not wish you to go,” Thorin sighed. “If you truly wish it I will allow you to, but . . . I would like you to stay. As to your question . . .” he gave a small mirthless laugh before he continued. “I was eighty. I was an adult before I had a beard. I was the shame of the line of Durin.”

“I doubt that,” Bilbo replied, leaning back against Thorin and stroking his chest absently. “I doubt that you were ever the shame of your line. Weren’t you already famous for your prowess in battle? There is no way that anyone would ever be ashamed of you.”

“It is kind of you to say that,” Thorin said with a smile. “But I can promise you that the day my beard came in was the proudest day for my father. His heir had finally grown a true beard.”

“I . . . I am sure that he was proud of you before,” Bilbo comforted. “What of the other thing Balin said.”

“Which thing?” Thorin asked with another small laugh. “That I challenged Dwalin to a fight to the death to avenge my honor? That was true. I wasn’t always the level-headed dwarf you love.” Bilbo snorted. Even now Thorin was far from level-headed.

“No,” Bilbo clarified. “The bit about you looking like Kíli. I’ve always wondered what you would have looked like as a young dwarf and . . .” Bilbo shrugged. “I just wondered. That’s all.” Thorin smiled at Bilbo’s awkward explanation. It was clear that Bilbo expected that question to make him jealous—as it was about his similarities with a younger dwarf who was closer to Bilbo’s age—but it didn’t. Rather, Thorin was flattered that Bilbo had thought so much about him.

“Near enough,” Thorin replied. “There are differences, especially in our outlooks on life, but I did look rather similar to my nephew. I was a bit too thin and gangly as well. I had no beard, and my features were a bit too angular and thin for a dwarf—hence Dwalin’s joke about me being too pretty. I have heard the same thing said to Kíli. It upsets him, as it did me, but Kíli . . . he will grow out of it as well. Other than his continued thinness, he looks strikingly similar to his mother when she was younger. And she is a very handsome dwarf now. He will be fine. Just as I was. Hopefully it does not take him quite as long to find love as it did me.”

“As selfish as it is of me,” Bilbo said, snuggling more deeply into Thorin’s furs, “I am glad that it took you as long as it did. If not . . . well, I would never have been able to have you. Even I know that dwarves only take one mate in their lifetimes. I’m just glad that you were saved for me.”

“So am I, my dear Bilbo, so am I,” Thorin whispered before pressing a kiss to the hobbit’s curly hair. “Now sleep. Tomorrow will be another hard march and I fear a mutiny if I try to slow them up again.”

“We can’t have that, can we?” Bilbo asked with a smile. “Sleep well, my king.”

ooOO88OOoo

Thorin had been right about the mood of the company. The next morning they were up and moving again before it was even light enough for Bilbo to see comfortably and he began that day as he had ended the previous one—clinging to Thorin’s coat. Thorin had offered to force them to wait until the path was a bit brighter, but Bilbo had turned him down with a shake of his head. The dwarf king had wanted to protest, but Bilbo’s smile had been so soft and sincere that he could not deny him this. So instead, he offered his hobbit his arm and led him forward.

Eventually the path lightened and Thorin’s help was no longer required. Even so, Bilbo remained near him for a time in an attempt to demonstrate the dwarf that his desire for him was not predicated on need before he drifted off to speak with the other members of the company that he had been neglecting in the past couple of days. Soon laughter was drifting up from the rear of the company as Bofur, Bilbo, Fíli and Kíli each tried to tell a more humorous tale than the other.

Thorin felt a soft smile creep up his face at the high, light sound of his hobbit’s laughter. It, much like his singing voice, was easy for the king to pick out among the lower timbres of the dwarves. His smile turned wistful as he wondered if that laugh would ever be directed at him. He knew that he was no longer as humorous as the younger members of the company, but once . . . once he, Frerin and Dís had been a team to rival Fíli and Kíli when it came to wit and mischief. Perhaps . . . perhaps that mischievous dwarfling was still in there somewhere under the King he had become. He silently vowed to himself that he would try to find it if only so that he could hear that beautiful laugh directed at him.

ooOO88OOoo

They made good time that day and the next despite the fact that the terrain had grown rather hilly. The path was still smooth, but now it was no longer quite so level. Instead it seemed that they were in large foothills or even small mountains. Thorin did not remember these from his first trip through Mirkwood, nor did Balin, and Fíli and Bilbo were not sure if there had been any indication of hills on the map. All any of them knew was that if the map was correct they should have made it out of Mirkwood by darkness the day before and they were still walking with no end in sight.

It was midway through the fourth day since the river that Thorin was faced with a difficult decision. The company was growing restless and nervous. Despite the hills they should have been long past the eves of the forest. Their provisions were beginning to run low. Expecting to be able to hunt once more they had been a bit injudicious in their rationing and . . . it was beginning to look as though they would not make it to the river before they were out of food. They needed to know how much more of the forest was left. To do that, someone would have to climb a tree in an attempt to rise above the canopy and see where the forest ended.

There were truly only two choices: Kíli and Bilbo. The rest of the company were too heavy to reach the top of a tree and didn’t have the sharp vision of those two. He was faced with the most difficult decision he had yet had to make on the quest. Was he to send his nephew or his mate up a tree? Which of them would be the best able to do the task? His mind knew that Bilbo was truly the best choice. He was smaller, lighter, more nimble, but . . . Thorin feared for him. He knew that hobbits lived their entire lives on or in the ground and was not certain how comfortable Bilbo would be in a tree. Kíli, while heavier and larger, was nearly as agile and Thorin knew for a fact that Kíli was comfortable in trees having been ambushed by his nephews more than once when they were younger. In the end, he let the decision pass from him to the members in question.

“Kíli, Bilbo, a word?” Thorin said drawing them aside. “I need one of you to do something for me. We need to know how much more of this blasted forest is left and . . .”

“You want one of us to climb a tree,” Bilbo finished wryly. He and Kíli shared a grin. They had known that this was coming. Thorin had been glaring up at trees all day and glancing at the two of them.

“I do,” Thorin sighed. “I hate to ask this of either of you. The thought of either of you falling out . . . I cannot bear it. I would do it myself if . . .”

“No, Uncle,” Kíli cut him off with a gentle smile. “We’re younger and lighter. It only makes sense that you would send one of us. We’ve already talked about it. I volunteered.”

“So you will be the one to climb?” Thorin breathed. The brief, vivid, mental image of his youngest nephew lying broken underneath a tree flashed and nearly took his breath away.

“No,” Bilbo replied with a smile. “I will. I am lighter and can get higher. It only makes sense.” Thorin felt as if his heart stopped as Bilbo’s broken body took the place of Kíli’s in his vision, Bilbo’s empty blue eyes staring up at him in accusation.

“Don’t worry,” the hobbit said as he gently pulled Thorin into an embrace. “I’ve climbed a few trees in my younger days. I was far too wild for a hobbit, if you remember. This I can handle. There are worse things in store for me before this is over. I think a tree pales in comparison to a dragon.”

“That is a horrible attempt at humor, Bilbo,” Thorin muttered into the hobbit’s hair.

“It was only the truth, my love,” Bilbo replied. “We can never forget that if we survive to make it to the mountain I have to walk into the den of a dragon.”

“Please, do not remind me,” Thorin sighed before pushing Bilbo away gently. “If you are intent on doing this, up that tree with you!” Bilbo smiled before standing on his toes to brush his lips against Thorin’s.

“I’ll be back,” Bilbo whispered. “I promise.”

“I’ll hold you to that,” Thorin threatened half-heartedly as he watched Bilbo strip himself of his pack and Dwalin boost him into the tree. He kept his eyes on the hobbit until Bilbo disappeared into the foliage. He only looked back down when he felt two strong hands grasp his own. He looked to the sides in shock only to see his nephews smiling gently at him.

“He’ll be fine, Uncle,” Fíli promised giving Thorin’s hand a gentle squeeze. “It’s only a tree.”

“It’s a big tree,” Thorin replied. “And he’s so small.”

“Was that what you were thinking when you were doing lewd things to him in the woods?” Kíli asked with a cheeky grin that only increased as his uncle flushed and began to stutter indignantly. Thorin was beyond traumatized! Kíli should not be saying such things to him. But before he could berate his nephew for his comment, Kíli’s smile had softened.

“He will be fine, Uncle,” Kíli promised. “He may be small but he is sturdy. It will take more than a tree—even a big one—to separate Bilbo Baggins from you. He is quite stubborn, after all.” Thorin said nothing but gave Kíli’s hand a squeeze to show his thanks before they lapsed into silence to await Bilbo’s return.

After what seemed like an eternity—but was truly only a few moments—Bilbo returned. Rather than allow Dwalin to help Bilbo to the ground, Thorin was there, scooping the hobbit into his arms and nearly crushed him with the force of his relief.

“It’s nice to see you again too, Thorin,” Bilbo laughed at the enthusiastic greeting. “But would you mind terribly if I asked you to return my feet to the ground. I may be willing to climb a tree but nothing can compare to solid ground.” With a slightly sheepish expression the King returned Bilbo to solid ground though he did not release him.

“So,” Dwalin asked breaking into their moment, “what did you see. Are we almost out?”

“Afraid not,” Bilbo replied with a shrug. “I climbed all the way to the top. There were some very beautiful butterflies and the sun was quite pleasant but I’m afraid that there was no end to the trees in sight.” There was a bit of an outcry at his pronouncement as all of the dwarves turned to Fíli indignantly.

“You told us that there were only three days left!” Nori snapped while Dwalin muttered darkly to Balin saying “See, this is why I don’t bother with maps.” Fíli held up his hands in defeat and looked to his uncle for help. He was not accustomed to having so much displeasure directed at him from so many sources at any given time and was unsure of what to do.

“Enough,” Thorin said, his voice quite but authoritative and cutting through the din. “Clearly the map was in error. Regardless, we will press on. There have been no forks in the path so we can clearly not have gone astray. We must continue. This arguing will accomplish nothing. Move out.” There were a few grumbles, but no one could argue against his logic and soon they were on the move once more. He nodded to Fíli as his nephew looked at him in silent thanks before he turned to continue down the path.

ooOO88OOoo

That night, dinner was a sparse affair and there was no laughter or singing. The discovery that the forest was no where near cleared while the rations were nearly gone had destroyed company morale. If they were frugal with them, they would be out of food tomorrow or the next day. If they ate as they had been . . . that night would have polished it off. That night, it was not just Bilbo who went to bed feeling the pangs of hunger. While they would still be fighting fit for quite some time, Thorin and the older dwarves knew that as their belts grew tighter so too would their tempers grow shorter. That would be a risk long before starvation.  

There was no breakfast the next morning and by the time lunch came around more than one stomach could be heard as their meager portions were passed out. Thorin saw the way that Bilbo’s face contorted in discomfort even once his meal was eaten and knew that it had not been near enough. He had long known that the hobbit was accustomed to eating more than he had on the quest, he had seen how quickly he had grown lean and knew that it could not be all due to his increases in exertions. Bilbo could not long survive on so little. With that in mind, he broke off half of his own honey cake and pressed it into Bilbo’s hand.

“Thorin?” Bilbo asked, looking at him with confusion in his blue eyes. “What?”

“Eat it,” Thorin ordered gently. “Do not worry, I am not digging into the company stores. It is my own.”

“But—“ the king silenced him with a gentle kiss before resting his forehead against Bilbo’s to keep their conversation intimate.

“You are already so small, Bilbo,” Thorin muttered. “I worry that if you grow any slighter the winds will carry you away from me once we do leave the forest. Trust me, I have survived for far longer on much less. Eat it.” Bilbo tried to give it back, but Thorin staunchly refused to take it and in the end Bilbo relented and ate it.

“You are eating all of your dinner,” Bilbo said, his voice holding a steel that Thorin knew he would not be able to combat. Instead of argue, he nodded, even though he knew that there would be no dinner for him that night. He and the older dwarves were abstaining so that Bilbo, Fíli and Kíli would be better fed. The lads were still growing and would need the nourishment. Bilbo’s portion was to have been Thorin’s but . . . the king knew that the hobbit would need it more than he would.

Placated, and ignorant of the plans for the evening, Bilbo smiled at him before whispering a thank you and pressing himself against his mate.

ooOO88OOoo

The next day, the food ran out. There was not even enough for the young ones. None of them complained, there was no point to it as no one could do anything to fix it, but it did not mean that they were pleased with it. All of them could remember being hungry before, Bilbo included. Winters had never been easy for the homeless dwarves and there had been some that were leaner than others. For Bilbo, he could remember a fell winter when he was a child that there had been no food and the wargs had come into the Shire over the frozen waters of the Brandywine. Even with it having happened before, it did not make the hunger any easier to endure.

As Thorin and Balin had feared, tempers grew short as the food ran out. The second day without food—the sixth day since the river—small things that would have ended with a crude hand gesture only days before now ended in cross words and hurt feelings. And sadly, many of those cross words were directed at Fíli. His words had been the ones that had given them hope and had led to their looseness with the food and their current lack. Nothing that he, or anyone, said in his defense was accepted. When Thorin tried to step in and stop the cruelty, he too was shouted down. They claimed that he was biased because Fíli was his nephew and heir and that if any of them had done that he would be calling for punishment.

In the end, he had had no choice but to back down from the argument or face mutiny. The only thing that he could do to alleviate his nephew’s discomfort was to keep Fíli tucked against his side under his arm. Even if they believed that he was playing favorites, they were reluctant to say cruel things to Fíli right under his nose. Thorin was still their king after all. Fíli was more than pleased to stay next to his uncle. Thorin, Kíli and Bilbo were the only ones that seemed to be able to look at him without anger.

“Don’t worry, Fíli,” Thorin whispered into his ear as Fíli sat beside him feeling distraught at the hand he had had in ruining the morale of the company. “This will blow over once we get out of the forest. It is very oppressive and they are growing hungry. Once we find game their moods will improve and they will apologize. You’ll see.”

“What if we don’t?” Fíli asked innocently. “What if we don’t find food soon, Uncle?” Thorin could not answer him. If they did not find food soon there were two possible outcomes: the company would come to blows and either dissolve or kill one another or they would die of starvation. It was a dark fate and it pained Thorin to write in the log book that they had run out of food.

ooOO88OOoo

It was the next day that they first saw the lights in the woods. At first, Bilbo believed them to be a hallucination. He had never been so hungry before in his life. He felt lightheaded and as though his stomach was trying to gnaw through his spine. He was trying to push it from his mind but it seemed that the more he tried to forget it the more that it haunted him. And he could tell from the grimaces and placement of hands of the rest of the company that they fared no better. Even Thorin, through the set of his jaw, was clearly experiencing hunger pangs.

Because of this, it was only once the one of the others commented on the lights that Bilbo realized they were truly there. They could now hear the sound of music and laughter of fair voices in the woods. Bilbo almost believed that he could smell food.

“Elves,” Thorin snarled at the sounds from the clearing.

“They have food,” Kíli countered. “I don’t know about you, Uncle, but I would rather dine with elves than starve in the woods.” He made to walk towards the clearing but was stopped by Fíli’s hands on his arm. He turned to glare at his brother.

“We were told not to leave the path,” Fíli reminded him. “Beorn said we would never find the way back.”

“You would say that,” Dori groused.

“What are you implying?” Fíli demanded rounding on the older dwarf. “Do you think that I would wish us dead? I stand to gain much more from our continued survival than most of you do. Why would I want us to die?”

“Then why would we not seek help where we can get it?” Nori asked, siding with his brother. “Elves or not, if they have food I think we should talk with them. Trade for it.”

“Steal it, you mean?” Dwalin snapped. “That is something that you are good at, after all.”

“Not all of us had the favor of the King to fall back on during lean times,” Nori replied unabashedly. “Yeah, I stole. But it was either that or starve. And I never stole from our people. I do have some morals.”

“I worked for everything I ate,” Dwalin retorted, stepping forward so that he and Nori were toe-to-toe and glaring down at the other dwarf. “My friendship with Thorin gave me nothing. Do you think that he and his sister and the lads were immune to the hardships of our people? They suffered with us.”

“Aye,” Bofur agreed. “I remember when I thought that the lads would starve. Such thin things they were! But Dís never resorted to stealing to feed them. And neither did we.”

“You don’t know what happened so you stay out of it!” Dori cut in in defense of his brother. While he disagreed with Nori’s choices, he did admire him for being willing to risk it for their sake. “Not all of us can mine and make toys!”

“This is unnecessary!” Bilbo squeaked trying to end the argument before it came to blows. “Please stop this!” Bilbo looked to Thorin to help him, but the King was currently preoccupied with attempting to keep Kíli from attacking Glóin for something that he had said about Fíli’s worthiness to rule if he was unable to read a map.

“And just what is wrong with making toys?” Bofur snapped, while Bifur glared angrily at Dori and Nori. “I would think that it would have less stigma than working as a thief. At least I am still a master of a trade.” Just as Nori opened his mouth to reply, it was cut off but Bilbo’s shout.

“THAT IS ENOUGH OF THIS!” Bilbo yelled in his loudest and shrillest voice, cutting through the deeper tones of the arguing dwarves with ease. They all turned to look at the panting hobbit in the middle of the path in shock. Bilbo glared at each of them in turn before he spoke.

“Thank you,” he said in a more level voice. “Now, I know that I can’t actually tell you how to do things, but I agree with Kíli.” A few grumbles met his words and he only spoke louder to be heard over them. “I AM NOT DONE! Fíli is correct as well. We cannot leave the path without some kind of a plan. We’ll never find the way back. Now, I have a plan.”

“Glóin,” Bilbo said, looking levelly at the red-headed dwarf that was still shooting furious glares as Kíli, “you have rope, yes?” The dwarf nodded warily. “Good. Tie it to a tree next to the path. We can bring it with us and follow it back.” There were appreciative mumbles at that suggestion and some of the tense atmosphere dissipated.

“That fixes that problem,” Thorin agreed, pleased yet again with his hobbit’s mind. Bilbo was an asset to the quest and the next time he saw the wizard he fully intended to thank him for suggesting the hobbit. “What do you propose we do about the fact that we are dwarves and they are elves? Mirkwood elves at that. They have turned their backs on me before, what makes you think that they will aid us this time?”

“Thorin,” Bilbo sighed. “What do we have to lose? If they refuse we are no worse off than we are now. What will it hurt?” Thorin sighed. He could see the logic of Bilbo’s statement but it hurt his pride to ask for help from the very people that had abandoned him before. As he looked at the weary faces of his company, in particular those of his nephews and Bilbo, he could see no other option. They would have to beg for aid. From the elves. Durin’s beard had it truly come to this? With a deep sigh that spoke of great defeat Thorin nodded and preparation to venture into the Elf clearing began.