Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 22: Disquiet in the Ranks and an Unfortunate Decision.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

For half a moment after the truth of Fíli’s words sank in the company was silent. Then all hell broke loose. Everyone was suddenly on their feet, shouting suggestions and accusations—the loss of their King having given them a task to focus on other than their impending death. Glóin and Dwalin in particular were in a heated row over which of them was responsible for Thorin’s disappearance. Until Glóin said something that shifted their focus, that is.

“And just how did you expect me to keep an eye on the King while I was busy watching after the burglar?” Glóin snapped. “Besides, you were the one that was closest to Thorin. He was your responsibility.”

“Uncle was no one’s responsibility,” Fíli cut in angrily. He could not believe that they were talking about both Bilbo and his uncle as though they were children in need of babysitting. Thorin was a skilled warrior and Bilbo . . . well even if he wasn’t a warrior, the hobbit was cunning. Neither of them needed a keeper.

“If Uncle is not here, it is not because he got lost,” Fíli continued.

“Are you sure of that, lad?” Bofur asked with a weak smile as he tried to diffuse the situation. “Thorin’s sense of direction is rather infamous. Or rather his sheer lack of it.” Fíli leveled a glare at him that Thorin himself would have been proud of that caused the toymaker to hold his hands up in apology.

“If Uncle is not here,” Fíli stated again more firmly this time, “it is because he was prohibited from coming here by something.”

“Or someone,” Kíli muttered darkly. He looked around at the shocked faces of his companions with furry burning in his eyes. In reality, their shock was not in what he had said but rather that Kíli had been the one to say it. Kíli, the bright, happy nephew of their king saying such dark things in such an angry tone. It shocked them. As did his anger at their shock.

“What!?” Kíli snapped, his glare intensifying. “Why are you looking at me like that? We’re all thinking it! That clearing was a trap and we fell for it. They knew that we were coming and rather than turn off their lights to discourage us they lured us in only to shut off the lights and abduct our King.” There were angry grumbles of agreement that moved through the company before Dwalin’s voice rose above the others.

“What are we waiting for?” he demanded. “Let’s charge in there and reclaim our king before those tree-shaggers have a chance to spirit him away forever.” There were loud calls of agreement at his words and the dwarves began readying themselves to storm the forest and do battle with the elves.

“Wait!” Bilbo called trying desperately to be heard over the din of peptalks and promises of vengeance. “WAIT! We can’t just go blundering into the woods! We need a plan first or—“

“Trust the hobbit to want to sit here and plan while the elves take Thorin further from us every moment,” Dori muttered darkly to Ori. “I doubt that he even ca—“

“DON’T YOU DARE SAY THAT I DO NOT CARE ABOUT THORIN!” Bilbo yelled, turning to Dori with murder burning in his eyes. “Don’t you dare! I care a more about him than I have ever cared for any other person on this planet. I want nothing more than his safe return to us. But I also know that we will do him no good if we are all lost to the forest as well. We need a plan. I am not suggesting that we abandon him, only that we take a moment and think this through first. We have to find him but we cannot lose ourselves in the process.” After his initial burst of anger Bilbo had deflated, seeming to shrink in on himself as the reality of the situation truly hit home. Thorin had been taken from him. Part of Bilbo’s mind wondered what it mattered when they were all going to die anyway but even though he couldn’t put a why to it . . . it mattered. He felt tears begin to sting his eyes and before he knew what had happened, Fíli and Kíli were both there, offering him what little comfort they could and seeking comfort in return.

Bofur glared at Dori—a totally foreign expression on his jovial face—before reaching into the mass of dwarf and hobbit to pat Bilbo on the shoulder gently before clapping Fíli and Kíli firmly in the same manner and saying, “Don’t worry, lads. We’ll get Thorin back if we have to cut the whole bloody forest down. You mark my words.”

“Aye, we will. But Bilbo’s right,” Balin said suddenly, placing a comforting arm around the distraught hobbit and heirs. “We need a plan. Dwalin, did you pull the rope back with you?”

“No,” Dwalin replied. “That was to be Thorin’s job.”

“Good,” Balin said with a sharp nod. “We can follow it back to the clearing where Thorin disappeared.”

“What good with that do?” Glóin demanded. “I don’t know about you but I couldn’t see a thing in that ink. I doubt that even Kíli, with his sharp young eyes, could and I know for a fact that Bilbo couldn’t.”

“It’s somewhere to start,” Balin replied, his tone hard. “From there we can fan out. Search for him just in case he did get lost. No offence, lad,” Balin said turning to Fíli with a small smile. “Mahal himself knows that I love your uncle like a second brother but . . . Thorin does have the worst sense of direction of any dwarf that I have ever met. He could have gotten lost.”

“No,” Bilbo disagreed looking up at Balin with sad blue eyes. “He had the rope in his hand. Fíli is correct. The only way that Thorin would not have made it back to the path is if he was somehow prevented from coming. Even with a terrible sense of direction, Thorin would not have lost himself with a rope to guide him.”

“The Halfling’s right,” Nori added quietly. “Thorin is many things; a fool is not one of them and it would take a fool to get lost with a rope to follow. No, he was prohibited from returning, whether by injury in the dark or something more sinister . . . “ he trailed off and allowed the others to think through what he had actually meant.

“No,” Fíli sighed. “Uncle would not have allowed injury to stop him. He’s quite stubborn. He must have been captured.”

“Even an elf would have a difficult time getting the drop on your uncle,” Dwalin said gruffly. “Thorin has been fighting since before you were born. His skills are even sharper than his blade. We would have heard the sounds of a struggle if one had occurred. He is either lost or injured, not captured.”

“What does it matter why he’s gone?!” Kíli snapped suddenly, startling them all with his outburst. “What does it matter? He’s missing. We need to find him. Hurt, lost, taken? What does it matter? All that matters to me is that we get him back.”

“Well said, lad,” Balin encouraged patting his back gently. “It does not matter. Now, back down the rope, lads. We have a king to find. Dwalin, you first, Brother. If they did manage to take Thorin by surprise . . . well, you’re our best bet to stop them from doing the same again.” Dwalin nodded grimly and set off back down the rope, one hand wrapped firmly around the rope and the other around the handle of his war hammer. If it was a fight that the elves wanted . . . well, he would give it to them. Bilbo made to follow him only to be stopped by Balin’s hand on his arm.

“Bilbo,” the dwarf said gently, “I understand that you are eager to find Thorin but . . . do you even know how to use your letter-opener, lad?”

“No,” Bilbo replied honestly. “No one has taken the time to teach me. I mean . . . I . . . well I have managed well enough so far but . . .”

“It would be best if you bring up the rear of the group,” Balin said. “That way we are sure you are safe and perhaps you will be able to hear Thorin without the rest of us blundering about and making noise.” Bilbo nodded sadly having read between the lines to realize that what Balin had actually meant to say was ‘Thorin will murder me if we find him at the cost of losing you.’ It was in that moment that Bilbo decided that when they found Thorin he would request that the king teach him how to use his sword. He knew that Thorin wanted to teach him to swim but . . . he foresaw no circumstance that would require him to have that skill. But the ability to use a sword . . . he could see where he might need that in the near future.

“Thank you,” Balin said with a relieved sigh. He had been afraid that Bilbo would be intractable and that he would have to waste more precious time trying to convince the stubborn lad: a task Balin wasn’t quite sure that he was up to. Bilbo could hold his own against Thorin, after all, and he was the most stubborn dwarf Balin had ever met.

“Stay with me lad,” Balin continued. “I may be old but . . . I can still hold my own in battle.”

“You’re not that old,” Bilbo countered as they awaited their turn to go down the rope—the dwarves spreading out a bit to give them room to wield weapons without fear of cutting friend and foe alike. “Thorin is older than you are and he’s still quite active.”

“He told you, did he?” Balin said with a laugh. Bilbo nodded, a small smile on his face as he remembered the quiet peace of the night they had had their conversation of the ages of dwarves. It had been less than a week but it seemed like a lifetime ago.

“Yes,” he agreed. “I’m sorry, Balin, but I would never have guessed it. It’s not that . . . well, you don’t seem old exactly but . . .”

“It’s the hair,” Balin supplied with a laugh. “The white hair always confuses people. Did Thorin tell you that my white hair and Dwalin’s baldness are his fault?”

“No,” Bilbo replied with a laugh. “How did he manage that?” Bilbo felt sorry that Balin and Dwalin had to permanently wear the result of one of a young Thorin’s pranks but . . . he couldn’t help but be amused. Bilbo loved to hear stories of Thorin’s escapades as a young dwarf. He sounded like he would have been a great deal of fun—or an infernal annoyance—but for some reason Bilbo could not seem to reconcile that carefree prankster with the majestic creature Thorin had become. He wondered idly if Kíli was doomed to the same fate. Would his light temperament darken with age?

“I’m not sure,” Balin said honestly breaking Bilbo from his thoughts. “And he’s never admitted to having done anything. But . . . well, let’s just say that it is mighty suspicious that the same summer he finally grew his beard . . . well, Dwalin went bald and I . . . well,” he gestured at his own head with a wry smile. “I have no doubt in my mind that Thorin had something to do with it.”

“I can try to find out for you, if you’d like,” Bilbo offered brightly. “I can ask him once we’ve found him.”

“I would appreciate that, Bilbo,” Balin said quietly, his smile falling at the offer. He knew that their odds of finding Thorin were slim, if he was even still alive. “If you do, see if there’s a way to reverse it. Dwalin may not act like it, but he is actually rather vain and would love to have his hair back.”

“When I do, I will see if there’s a way to reverse it,” Bilbo replied. Balin nodded before heaving a deep sigh and grabbing the rope.

“Well, it’s our turn, lad,” he said sadly. “Shall we?” Bilbo nodded and followed Balin into the gloom of Mirkwood, wrapping one arm around the rope so that one of his hands was on the hilt of his little sword and the other in his pocket fiddling with his magic Ring prepared to slip it on at the first sign of trouble.

At the quiet sound of a scuffle in front of them, Balin placed a hand on Bilbo’s chest, silently telling him to wait before the dwarf crept forward as quietly as he was able. Rather than obey, Bilbo slipped on the Ring and crept after Balin a good deal more quietly. No sooner had the dwarf cleared the trees than he was grabbed and bound before being pressed towards the rest of the company—who were also bound (which Bilbo could see by the light of lanterns that sprang to life at Balin’s capture).

“He was the twelfth,” one of the elves said doing a quick head count of bound dwarves. “That is all of them.”

“But what of the Halfling that was with them,” replied another. “We have not captured him. Should we not wait?”

“We were told to bring the twelve dwarves,” the first replied. “The Halfling was not seen as a threat to our people. He may remain free.” There was a cry of pain from the elf who had had his hand over Kíli’s mouth before Kíli’s voice rang clear.

“You can’t leave him out here alone!” Kíli snapped. “He’ll die alone. He has no food, no water and no skill with—Ow! Damn it, Fíli, don’t kick me! It was bad enough when Uncle—OW!”

“The Halfling’s fate is a sad one,” the first elf replied as the two brothers were separated. “And it greives me that such an innocent creature will die. However like all things that are born to this world save for the first-born he must eventually pass from this world. If he would have remained safe in his homeland it might have been many years from now but he would pass all the same.”

“So what?” Fíli demanded, having bitten his own guard to ask his question. “Since he was foolish enough to travel with dwarves you will condemn him to death?”

“It is not I who has condemned him,” the elf replied calmly. “He was condemned to die the moment he was born. I simply will not interfere with the death that Eru has destined for him.”

“You bast—“ Fíli’s oath was cut off as a gag was slid into place. He could hear Kíli’s muffled protests as he was subjected to the same treatment. Fíli glared up at the elf with murder in his blue eyes at the mistreatment of himself and his brother and the elves complete disregard for Bilbo’s continued existence.

“We did not wish to resort to such tactics,” the elf said glancing apologetically at the two brothers, “however, as you both seem intent on causing us physical harm we will do what we must to protect ourselves. I know that you do not see the harm in speaking in such loud voices but there are dangers in these woods that are drawn to noises. The spiders come to mind. It would go well for all of us if you will just be silent. I have no desire to fight the giant spiders but if you call them down on us know this, my people come first. I will not allow any of us to be killed to save you.”

“Giant spiders!?” Bofur asked following Fíli and Kíli’s example. “And you want to leave Bilbo out here for them!? They will eat him ali—“ And like Fíli and Kíli, Bofur was silenced as well. It was with heavy hearts that the allowed themselves to be led away knowing that they were condemning Bilbo and perhaps Thorin to death but unable to do anything to stop it.

Little did they know that Bilbo was following them on invisible and silent feet. He briefly considered staying to look for Thorin before rejecting the idea. He knew now that Thorin had been captured. There was no other explanation. That and the thought of the giant spiders made his blood freeze. So rather than stay and search for his lover, Bilbo followed his friends as they were led through the forest and into the underground fortress of the Elf King of Mirkwood. He only hoped that he had made the right decision.

Notes:

This time I have a QUESTION for you: For the next two weeks I am going to be writing like a madwoman to try to get as much done on these stories as I can before school starts up the first week of June. After it does updates will become much more sporadic (it’s an accelerated program that compresses 2 years of study into 9 months. What would be a normal semester is now crammed into 8 weeks and well . . . that’s a lot to do and very little time to do it) Here’s where the question comes in. Do you want me to post as I get it done and get a mass amount of uploads in the next two weeks and then potentially silence for a while or would you rather that I hold them and give out a chapter (or two) a week? I think I prefer the spread out method but will do it whichever way is the most popular on each of my stories. I do want happy readers after all ;D. So vote for you choice in the comments!