Chapter Text
Thorin struggled against his captors as they led him through the halls of the Palace of Mirkwood. He knew that it was futile—he had tried to escape from the all the way from the clearing and had been unable to do so—but he could not bring himself to submit willingly to the degradation that was being led complacently before the Elf King bound. So instead of saving his energy and walking calmly between them, he struggled and cursed and swore vengeance against them and their descendants for their treatment of him even if his heart was not truly in it. His concern was not his own safety at the moment but rather on Bilbo and his nephews and his company who were still in the forest condemned to a slow death by starvation.
He knew that would not be his fate. Thranduil was capable many things but even he would not starve Thorin to death in his dungeons. Instead he would keep the dwarf alive as long as possible if for no other reason than to make him suffer. And suffer Thorin would. He would spend the rest of his life wondering what would have happened had he have made different choices. Every one of his mistakes would haunt him. He briefly wondered if Thranduil would take pleasure in his pain before his musings were cut off as he was forced to his knees before a dais.
He glanced up and did not have to fake a sneer as he had faked his indignation earlier. On a throne on the dais sat Thranduil with an almost smug smile on his face. At his expression rage boiled within Thorin and his words fell from his mouth before he had time to still them.
“What is the meaning of this, Thranduil!?” Thorin demanded angrily. “Why have you accosted me in the forest and had me bound before being brought before you as nothing more than a common ruffian?! What right did you have?”
“What right did I have?” Thranduil asked calmly as he surveyed the bound dwarf before him with a bored expression that bordered on disinterest. “Tell me, Thorin Oakenshield, what right did you and your war band of dwarves have to accost my people in the midst of their revelry.”
“I accosted no one!” Thorin snapped. “And I have no war band of dwarves. Merely a small group of friends that are traveling with me.”
“Friends?” Thranduil scoffed. “I was unaware that you had friends, Thorin. In fact, I am surprised that any of them were willing to travel with you. Your temper and foolish pride are quite well known. But that is beside the point. Why did you accost my people?”
Thorin sighed harshly before he spoke, knowing that the Elf King would just love the explanation he was about to give for their travel into the clearing.
“We were starving and came seeking aid,” Thorin replied in a surly tone staring at the foot of the dais once more, unable to see the smug satisfaction that he knew would twist Thranduil’s features at his own failed planning efforts. “It has been days since we have eaten and we have young ones with us. They cannot . . . We. Needed. Help.”
“You mean that you came to beg me and mine for aid after all the harsh words you have had for us over the years?” Thranduil said, his voice practically dripping with pleasure at Thorin’s discomfort. He was not a cruel person but he had long believed that Thorin’s pride would be his undoing and perhaps the undoing of them all and seeing that even a dwarf had a limit to the foolishness of pride pleased him. It was not Thorin’s suffering, or that of his companions, that gave Thranduil pleasure but rather that he was finally getting to see humility from the proud King of the Dwarves.
“What would you have done in my position?” Thorin countered harshly, glaring up at the elf once more. “Would you have done nothing in the face of the fate of watching you friends and kin die a slow painful death by starvation? Would you not have begged if that was what it took to save them or would you have passed up a chance at aid knowing that if you did so it would be kinder to turn your own blade on your kin and kill them quickly rather than watch them suffer before they died?” Thorin paused and pain washed across his features for a moment before it was shoved away. Now Thranduil watched with interest. Something had changed in the dwarf since last they met. Something had tempered him and Thranduil knew that it was not time. No, time was not enough to soften dwarves, in fact it often hardened them. Something, or someone, had tempered the pride of the King of Durin’s folk. Thranduil could only wonder what it was.
“So, yes, I did come to your people to beg,” Thorin continued anger in his tone once more. “And just as you always have you refused to help us. Instead you have condemned them to death and prohibited me from saying my final goodbyes to them.”
“I condemned no one, Thorin,” Thranduil replied wondering what reaction his next words would garner: just how deeply changed Thorin truly was. “Their fate was decided by your choices, not mine.” He was shocked as pain rather than anger flashed across Thorin’s face before it was concealed.
“Be that as it may,” Thorin replied, his voice choked with unshed tears, “your decision not to aid them will be the final stroke that fells them. I may have brought them to the arena but it is you that will kill them. You could save them if only you would. I did everything in my power to do so. Their blood is now on your hands.”
“No, Thorin,” Thranduil argued. “I will give you one more chance to save them. Tell me what you were doing in my lands with heavily armed dwarves in the first place and not only will I aid them, but I will free you and reunite you with them to be on your way.”
“You lie!” Thorin spat. “You have no intention of doing as you say! Even if I was to tell you the reason for our travel you would not allow us to go on our way in peace. It is not in your nature to help dwarves and we both know it! I still remember, Thranduil. I still remember when you refused to aid us when we most needed your help.”
“No,” Thorin said firmly. “Do not take me for a fool. I will tell you nothing.” Thranduil turned his attention from the livid dwarf before him as an elf leaned in to whisper in his ear. He nodded solemnly before turning back to the dwarf before him.
“Then their fate is on your hands now, Thorin Oakenshield,” Thranduil replied. “I am not as heartless as you believe. I will not allow them to starve to death in the forest, though this is also for the safety of my own people. It would not do to have ravenous dwarves with weapons roaming the woods where they could possibly injure us. All twelve of them have already been captured and are being brought to us.”
“Twelve?” Thorin breathed despite himself. At Thranduil’s raised eyebrow Thorin continued. The safety of his company more important than keeping such insignificant information from the elf. “There should be thirteen.”
“What do you mean?” Thranduil asked. “We captured twelve dwarves. Not including yourself.”
“There . . . there was a . . . a hobbit,” Thorin breathed in shock before desperation took its place. “A. . . a hobbit made the fourteenth member of our company. Did they capture a hobbit as well?” Thorin’s reaction shocked the Elf King and he wondered if there was more between the dwarf and Halfling than Thorin was letting on. Thranduil looked to the elf that had come to tell him of their capture hoping for once that they had gone beyond his orders and brought the Halfling as well. The elf shook his head and Thranduil felt his heart go out to the dwarf as pain flashed across his face once more.
“We could not find the Halfling,” he replied. “We searched however he eluded us.” Thorin felt panic grip his chest. Bilbo was lost alone in the forest. If he was alone. . . Bilbo was intelligent but . . . he was so small and Thorin felt a wave of regret wash through him as he berated himself for never teaching Bilbo how to defend himself.
“Search for him again,” Thranduil ordered seeing the vulnerable, broken look on the dwarf’s face at the news that the hobbit had not been found. He had not meant to break Thorin, only to test him and from the looks of things the loss of the hobbit would devastate the Dwarf King.
“I am afraid that we cannot, My King,” the elf replied. At Thranduil’s raised eyebrow the elf sighed. “A few of the younger dwarves protested our decision to leave the Halfling and their shouts drew the spiders. By the time it is safe to return . . . there will be no point. I am sorry, My King.” Thranduil nodded sadly. He turned to Thorin with a sad sigh.
“I am afraid that your company now numbers thirteen, Thorin,” Thranduil said. “My condolences for your loss.”
“Your . . . your condolences!?” Thorin asked incredulously. “How dare YOU OFFER ME YOUR CONDOLENCES! This is your fault, Thranduil! His blood is on your hands!”
“I disagree, Thorin,” Thranduil said trying to feign disinterest in the anger of the dwarf, though he did have to admit that the sheer force of the dwarf’s rage shocked him. It shocked him that Thorin was more upset about the loss of a Halfling than he had been at the indignity of his own capture. “I was not the one that led him into the wilds.”
“I may have led him here,” Thorin replied, his voice quiet and filled with more emotion than Thranduil had ever thought him capable of. “And I will bear the guilt of that for the rest of my days but . . . you were the one abandoned him in the forest to be left to the spiders. You forcibly removed me from him and then the rest of my company from him as well. You were the one that left him defenseless. You as good as killed him.”
“Thorin,” Thranduil said quietly feeling true remorse for his part in the dwarf’s grief, “I truly am sorry for your loss. Do not now compound it with your stubbornness. Tell me what business you had in my kingdom and I will let you and your remaining company continue on your way.” Thorin glared up at him but said nothing. It was clear from his expression that he would say no more.
“Take him to a cell,” Thranduil ordered sadly. “Give him food and water. We can only hope that another member of his company has more sense.” Thorin said nothing, but the defeated set of his shoulders and the way that he did not even struggle against his captors spoke more of his grief than his tears could have. It was a sight that Thranduil had never thought to see and took no pleasure in: Thorin Oakenshield was well and truly defeated.
Thorin walked in a daze unaware of his surroundings as he was led through the halls of the palace and into a dungeon. He did not even react when he was walked into a cell and the door locked behind him. Despite his own hunger, he did not even move to claim it when food and water were pushed through the hole in the door for him. He was numb. There were no thoughts in his mind save for the fact that he had failed. He had promised to protect Bilbo and he had failed. Some mate he was.
ooOO88OOoo
Once they were out of the woods, the elves seemed to relax. The dwarves, however were only growing more tense. Now, not only were they prisoners but even if they did manage to escape they would be trapped within the elf city. Their only hope was that they would soon be reunited with Thorin and that he would have a plan. All of them except for Balin.
He knew that it was weak of him, but he had no desire to face Thorin ever again. He had been the one that forced Bilbo to hang back. If he hadn’t have done that, Bilbo would have been captured with them and not been abandoned to death in the forest. He had killed Bilbo. He knew that Thorin would be beside himself in his grief at the newest loss and couldn’t bear the thought of being the one to tell Thorin of Bilbo’s death. How was he to tell his old friend that he had been responsible for the death of his mate?
As they were led into a large throne room it was with both relief and horror that Balin noticed that Thorin was not there. He was relieved that Thorin was not there and that he would not have to break the news to his friend, but he was also horrified because if Thorin was not there it meant that he was most likely dead as well. At a signal from the Elf King, Bofur, Kíli and Fíli were ungagged.
“What could bring twelve armed dwarves into my kingdom?” Thranduil asked calmly.
“Do I speak or should Fíli?” Balin asked quickly in Khuzdul. Fíli gazed at him in shock. Before shaking his head, eyes wide in horror. The only reason that he would be the one to speak would be if Thorin was dead and he refused to give his uncle up for dead. In his mind Thorin was still alive and Balin was his second-in-command and therefor in charge.
“No,” Fíli breathed staying in the same language. “I . . . We do not know that he is dead yet. You are Thorin’s second-in-command. Until we know for sure, he is still our King. You will speak.” Balin smiled at him sadly, pity in his dark eyes, before he turned to Thranduil.
“We were traveling,” Balin replied. “Simply passing through.”
“If that is the case, why did you attack my people as they dined?” Thranduil countered.
“Our intent was not to attack your people,” Balin said calmly. “We merely sought aid. The crossing took more time than we believed it would and our supplies were depleted. And instead of helping us your people denied us and caused us to lose two of our number to your forest. At least one of them through the conscious intervention of your people and the other . . . we do not know what has become of him.”
“I have been told of the fate of your Halfling,” The Elf King said sadly. “I apologize for his loss.”
“What do you mean you apologize for his loss?!” Kíli demanded speaking out of turn from his anger at the callousness of the Elf King in the face of Bilbo’s death by his decisions. “You were the one that gave the order to abandon him to death! How dare you apologize for it!” Kíli stopped speaking, his chest heaving and his eyes bright with unshed tears.
“You killed him,” Kíli whispered, his voice broken with the force of his grief over the loss of his friend, “as surely as if you ran him through yourself. You murdered Bilbo.” Thranduil’s heart broke anew for the fate of the Halfling. It was clear that all of the dwarves had been fond of the creature. They were all showing signs of grief but not so clearly as Thorin had or as clearly as the dark-haired youngling was. Suddenly Thorin’s words about his kin came to mind and Thranduil wondered if the angry young dwarf before him was related to the King. That would also explain the Dwarf King's desperation to find food for the young ones.
“That is a fair enough assessment,” Thranduil replied quietly. “And I do regret my contribution to his death. I should have included the Halfling in the capture order rather than ignoring his presence. I do bear fault for his death. But I can do nothing to change my decisions now. I can only offer you a choice: tell me what business brought you through my lands and receive aid to continue your travels or keep your secrets and remain here until such a time as you wish to prove to me that you pose no threat to me or my people.” Though none of the dwarves said anything, the glares that they leveled at him told them that they did in fact pose a threat to him and that any of them would gladly kill him if given the opportunity.
He waited a bit longer but none of them said anything else. Eventually he sighed. “Take them to the East dungeons. Give them food and water. When they do decide to talk, bring them back to me.” Unlike Thorin, these dwarves did not go quietly. They left much as he had entered, struggling, swearing, threatening retribution . . . after their protests faded, Thranduil allowed his head to fall into his hands with a sigh. He hated that it had come to this: that he was jailing dwarves that were little more than children and making decisions that led to the death of an innocent Halfling. He wished that he had another option but he could see where he could do anything else if he was to protect his people.
