Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 44: Conversations and Decisions

Chapter Text

Later that night Bilbo was sitting outside the gates of Erebor and looking up at the stars. The cool night air felt good on his bruised cheek. He still couldn’t believe that Thorin had struck him. How had the dwarf that had been such a gentle lover and companion suddenly become so . . . violent? He turned his head at the sound of footsteps on the rubble, expecting to see one of the others bringing him dinner, as he had come out here before it was done. Instead, it was Thorin himself standing there holding a plate of food.

“I thought you might be hungry,” Thorin said, his tone quiet, apologetic. “I heard that you did not come to dinner.”  Bilbo turned his head away from the king. Even though this sounded like his Thorin, he wasn’t sure that he could deal with seeing either personality at the moment. Especially as there was little warning that a change was coming. He wasn't sure his nerves could take it.

“I’m not,” Bilbo replied sharply. “So you can take it back with you.” Thorin flinched at his tone. It was colder than the night air. He knew that he deserved it. After he had left the chamber, the severity of what he had done had struck him. He had actually hit Bilbo over nothing more than a well-deserved insult and that after he'd sworn to himself that nothing would harm his hobbit again. He couldn't believe that he'd done it, but the sight of Thranduil had roused something within him that even he hadn't known was there—not that the reason mattered. What bothered him the most was that he had done it. He had raised his hand to his lover. He'd felt the sting as their flesh had connected, heard his cry as he'd fallen. The very memory of it disgusted him.  

“You should eat,” Thorin said gently, holding the plate as far from himself as he could in hopes that Bilbo would take it. “You will need your strength for what may come.”

“I don’t intend to fight a battle,” Bilbo said still not looking at the king. “And if you insist on doing so I will pack up my things and return home.”

“How will you get there?” Thorin asked wondering if Bilbo would really go through with his threat. Would the hobbit truly leave? Not that he didn't believe that he had the right, after all their contract had been violated and Bilbo was well within his rights to do so. And sane creature would.

“The same way I got here,” Bilbo replied. “On foot.”

“You intend to travel back across Middle Earth . . . on foot . . . with one fourteenth of the gold in Erebor?” Thorin asked incredulously. The mental image of the hobbit carting that much gold on his person—not that he could—as he trudged across the mountains and streams between there and the Shire causing him to smile slightly despite himself.

“I don’t want it,” Bilbo scoffed turning to glare at the King. “I didn’t come on this adventure for gold. I came . . . I don’t even know why I came, but it wasn’t for that.” He almost said that he wasn't the one who had been destitute before the quest but bit that bit back. He could gain nothing from striking where he knew it would hurt. Even after what had just happened, he didn't want to hurt Thorin. Not like that.

“So you don’t want it?” Thorin asked. “What do you want us to do with it? None of us will take what is yours.”

“Give it to Bard,” Bilbo said sarcastically. As the words left his mouth he realized that that was the solution to this situation. If he gave his share of the gold to Bard, his claim would be satisfied and there need be no war. It was perfect.

“That will not happen,” Thorin snarled. Bilbo was being ridiculous! He understood that he was mad, but that level of sarcasm was not called for. It wasn't like he was being entirely unreasonable in refusing to treat with Bard until his armies were gone. That was just good politics.

“Thorin,” Bilbo snapped rounding on the King causing Thorin to flinch at the sight of the purple bruise marring his pale skin. He had caused that. He'd hoped . . . with his hand showing no sign of the blow . . . but of course it wouldn't have with the hobbit being made of softer material than a dwarf. He'd hoped there would be no mark all the same. “You’re being ridiculous!”

“How do you figure that?” Thorin scoffed, his tone harsher than he meant with his shame at marking his mate in such a manner. “Why should I agree to give a portion of the gold that we fought for and bled for to those that did not? What right have they to lay any claim to the gold in Erebor? What right have they to come with armies to demand it?”

“You deny that Bard has a claim?” Bilbo insisted in a quieter voice. “I don’t disagree with you about the Elf King, but Bard? Thorin, he was the one that slew Smaug. His entire town was destroyed because we flushed the dragon out of the mountain. He has a claim.”

“Perhaps,” Thorin agreed, his tone one of grudging agreement. “Perhaps he does. And I would have honored it had he not have come to our gates like a thief planning to take what he “deserves” since we were surely dead.”

“He didn’t come like a thief!” Bilbo yelled, exasperated by the stubbornness of the King. He had known dwarves were stubborn, but this seemed excessive even to him, though after what had happened that day nothing would surprise him.

“He brought an army!” Thorin roared causing the hobbit to flinch. “If it was an honest endeavor, why does he have an army?”

Bilbo sighed. “I. . . I don’t know,                Thorin” he finally said his tone defeated. Thorin looked at him triumphantly. He thought that he would win this battle. “I do know that you owe him. And I know you well enough to know you do not like to be indebted to anyone.”

“I owe him nothing,” Thorin snarled. “That Man has no claim to the gold of the dwarves. It was mined and forged by dwarves and it will remain with dwarves.” When he finished speaking he turned to leave, casting a final disdainful look at Bilbo. He loved him, but this was a matter in which Bilbo was not qualified to speak. When he wanted someone to tell him which flowers to grow or what herb to use he would consult the hobbit. This was a matter of the state, of which Bilbo knew nothing. He stopped, and his anger faded at the quiet, tear-filled voice behind him.

“And what of me?” Bilbo asked.

“What?” Thorin asked turning to face the hobbit, the hurt on his face piercing the King to the bone. No knife wound had ever hurt him so much.

“What of me?” Bilbo repeated, anger making his voice harsh. “I’m not a dwarf. Do I have no claim either? ‘Cause I seem to remember signing a contract that gave me a fourteenth’s share of the treasure. Is that claim no good?”

“Of course it is still good,” Thorin replied confused at the sudden mood swing. He knew that Bilbo was no dwarf. What had caused this? “I told you as much not five minutes ago. None will deprive you of what is yours.”

“Really?” Bilbo asked angrily. “I was worried. I didn’t know if you would honor that debt since “dwarven gold should stay with dwarves.” At his words understanding dawned in Thorin’s eyes. He hadn’t meant it that way. He hadn’t thought Bilbo would take it that way either. He thought that the hobbit knew how much he meant to him. Striking him was a rather funny way of showing it, his conscience whispered.

“I didn’t mean that,” Thorin said his voice filled with regret both for what he had said and for what he had done. “Not about you. You are a member of this Company. You have earned it. I would never seek to deprive you of what you have earned.”

“Good,” Bilbo replied. “And I may do with my share what I wish?”

“Of course,” Thorin replied wondering where Bilbo was going with this. It was his reward, what he did with it was none of his concern.

“I thought as much,” Bilbo said, a shockingly smug look on his face. “I know what I would like to do with it.”

“Really?” Thorin asked, a smile on his face. He had thought that Bilbo didn’t care about the gold. That he was making plans for it was a pleasant surprise, even if his smile was unnerving.

“Yes,” Bilbo replied his smile fading and his eyes growing hard. “I want you to give it to Bard.” He ignored the protests of the King and spoke over him. “You said that I can do what I will with it and that is what I want to. I will give my reward to save your foolish neck. I have no interest in the gold and it is not worth a war. Give my share to them and send them on their way.”

“No,” Thorin replied. “I will not do that.”

“Then you’ll deny me my reward?” Bilbo asked. He knew that he had caught the King in a technicality. There was no way that Thorin could refuse and still keep his word, and Thorin never broke his word.

“No,” Thorin said with a sigh, his shoulders slumping in defeat. “Bard hasn’t asked for an entire fourteenth. You can still keep a portion of your reward.”

“Fine,” Bilbo nodded. “I’ll keep the extra.”

“What of Tharanduil?” Thorin asked, his voice hard as he remembered the indignities he had suffered at the hands of the Elf King.

“Hang him,” Bilbo said with a shrug. “As I said, I don’t see where we owe him anything. If anything he owes us. If Bard wants to share with him, he can. I see no need to give him anything, except perhaps a piece of my mind. Despite what you said earlier, I still haven't forgiven him for chaining you or imprisoning you and the others.” At his words Thorin laughed humorlessly and moved to sit next to the hobbit, the plate of food still in his hands. He was pleased when Bilbo did not move away from him.

“I’m glad that you feel that way,” Thorin said with a sad smile. “At least we can agree on that.” The dwarf took a deep breath and reached over to gently stroke Bilbo’s bruised cheek, his finger stopping just short of touching it. The hobbit looked at him and saw such sadness and regret in his blue eyes that it took his breath away.

“Bilbo, I . . . I am so sorry about what I did to you earlier,” Thorin said. “I should never have struck you. I am a fool. I know I have no right to ask for it, but I sincerely beg you for your pardon.”

“You are a fool,” Bilbo agreed. Thorin’s face fell at the pronouncement. He had known that Bilbo would never forgive him.

“But,” Bilbo continued. “You are my fool. And for some reason that even I don’t understand, I love you still. But I swear, if you ever strike me again, I don’t care if you are a king, you will regret it.”

“And I swear to you that it will never happen again,” Thorin promised. Rather than say anything Bilbo leaned his head against Thorin’s shoulder before he flinched and repositioned himself so that his bruise was not in contact with the dwarf. The dwarf in question flinched at the same time. And once Bilbo had found a comfortable position rested his chin in the curly hair atop his lover’s head. For a time they sat together in silence watching the stars and wondering what dawn would bring.