Chapter Text
As expected, dawn brought the return of Bard and the Elf King. They came with banner and fanfare that would have alerted the dwarves of their presence even had they not been keeping watch. As it was, however, their guards had seen the approaching envoy long before they were within range of speech with men. The events of the day before had served one purpose, Thorin had come to see reason, at least as far as Bilbo's presence was concerned. He had insisted that the hobbit wear his Ring. Bilbo had thought that it was unnecessary but had conceded to Thorin's request.
So that day he was standing beside his lover and felt him stiffen as the Elf King crested the rise.
"He can't touch you," Bilbo murmured, taking Thorin's larger hand in his own. "You're safe. You'll never be in a dungeon again." Despite Bilbo's words, at the sight of Thranduil the cloth bandages around his wrists suddenly felt far too tight and heavy. He could almost swear that when he raised his hands he could hear the clink of chains once more. He wanted to curl in on himself, knowing that what he felt was not truly there to matter how real it felt, but he forced down the impulse and stood tall, thankful that the distance between the two groups might mask the fear he could feel in his own eyes.
As soon as they were within earshot, Thorin raised his voice hailing the approaching group.
"So," he called, thankful that his voice came out strongly and sounded condescending rather than haunted. "You come to my gates once more with the . . . elf."
"Of course I do," Bard replied. "You made it abundantly clear that you would offer us no aid yesterday. I must keep the allies that I have."
"Thranduil is a terrible ally," Thorin replied. "Once he was Erebor's ally as well. He left us to burn and starve and then imprisoned us when we came to claim what was ours. What proof do you have that he will treat you differently?"
"None," Bard answered while Thranduil scoffed at Thorin's allegations. "But he wasn't the one that brought the dragon down on our head, O King Under the Mountain." The title was just this side of spat out.
"That is true," Thorin admitted sadly. "We were the ones that chased the dragon from the mountain and into your town. And for this and for your hospitality we do we you. It is with this in mind, and through a dislike of abandoning refugees that I offer you the opportunity to winter your people within the walls of the mountain. On the condition that you send away the elf."
"And what of after winter, Thorin," Bard demanded. "What will we do when the snows melt? Will we be cast out of the mountain and left with nothing? That is why I need the gold. Dale or Esgaroth must be rebuilt and we will need funds to purchase food until we can grow it. That is why I cannot do as you ask where the Elf King is concerned. He offers us trade. What do you offer, Thorin Oakenshield?"
"I . . . I offer you one sixteenth of the gold within the mountain," Thorin said, the very words seeming to grate his throat as they passed. "Courtesy of my mate, BIlbo Baggins. He is willing to pay what you are owed out of his fourteenth."
"And what of my claim?" Thranduil asked.
"You have no claim," Thorin replied coldly.
"I assure you, I do," Thranduil replied. "Not only from you but from your grandfather of old."
"You lost any claim you had on Thror when you refused to aid his people," Thorin ground out, livid that that creature would dare speak his grandfather's name. "And you have never had a claim on me. Never have we entered into any agreement."
"What of the supplies you and your men consumed while you were our guests?" Thranduil asked. Well, this last question was too much for poor Bilbo. Though he knew that he shouldn't, he pulled the Ring from his finger and stood on his toes to see over the wall, fixing the Elf King with the glare he reserved for Lobelia when she attempted to steal his silver or the butcher if he attempted to cheat one of the less educated hobbits.
"Guests?!" he snapped. "You dare to imprison them and call them guests? Clearly that word means something entirely different in the Shire. Forgive me if I am less cultured in the ways of the wise and have never chained my guests in the dark and fed them irregularly."
"And you are?" the elf asked, raising one eyebrow and wondering not only who but what the strange creature that dared to speak to him so was.
"Bilbo Baggins, of the Shire," Bilbo replied pointedly leaving out the part where he was at the elf's service.
"Thorin's mate," Thanduil snorted. "And judging by the mark on your face, you know precisely why I had to chain him. Funny, Thorin, I didn't know that dwarves ever laid hands on their mates." Thorin and Bilbo has opposite reactions to these words, the dwarf going pale below his dark beard at being confronted once more with the severity of what he had done and Bilbo going red in embarrassment at their private domestic squabble being made so public.
"Well . . . I . . . that is," Bilbo stuttered trying to think of a way to explain his bruise while not giving away just how fragile Thorin's state of mind was at the moment to one who was undoubtedly an enemy. It didn't matter, however because there was truly nothing he could say to salvage that situation, and the smirk on Thranduil's face showed that he knew it.
"Is that bruise the reason my claim is not being honored, perhaps?" Thranduil asked. "I have heard that hobbits are fair creatures."
"No," Bilbo snarled, and expression on his face that none of the dwarves had ever seen there before, or in all honesty ever hoped to see again, as he grabbed Thorin's arm and raised it before pulling back the dwarf's sleeve and ripping off the bandages, revealing the livid scabs that stood out there. "These marks are the reason you will never receive anything from us. And hobbits are fair creatures, and peaceable until riled. And let me tell you something your majesty, you have riled this hobbit."
"Tell me this, halfling," Thranduil replied, his tone revealing that he knew the moniker to be a non-preferred title, "are you riled enough for war? Refusal of my terms will result in nothing less. Can Erebor truly afford to be at odds with the neighbor who controls the route to the west? It would be a shame if all the dwarves that came through my woods had to be seen as spies." Bilbo was speechless at the threat. Was Thranduil really attempting to extort gold for safe passage of the refugees returning to Erebor? Everyone seemed equally shocked at these words, shock was soon followed by anger, however, and soon insults were flying from the battlements. The only ones not participating were Thorin—to whom this was no shock, but rather a reaffirmation of what he had previously known—and Bard, who was standing beside the Elf King with an openly shocked expression. Eventually Thorin had enough and raised his hand. It took a moment but the company fell silent, though their glares did not lessen.
"You've heard where he stands, Bard," Thorin said quietly. "I know you to be an honorable man, willing to help those in need, for a price at least. Do you still ally yourself with him? Will you go to war with us over a claim that is neither yours nor just or will you do what is right by your people? Make your decision. The gates of Erebor remain open if you desire it."
Bard closed his eyes. This was the exact reason he had never sought the position his blood afforded him. He hated to make such decisions. The elves of Mirkwood had been good to the people of Lake Town, to side with Thorin now would break that alliance and put him in no better place than the dwarves but to side with someone who would extort gold at such a cost . . . he couldn't fault the Elf King for the initial imprisonment, to hear Thranduil tell it, the dwarves had attacked his people during their feasts and then refused to explain why they were in the wood in the first place. No, any leader would have jailed such trespassers, though the chaining of the dwarf King did make him uncomfortable, even if the bruise on his mate's face, which he hadn't denied had come from the dwarf, gave hint as to a loose hold on a temper. It all came down to one question: who was a better ally, one who would stoop to such low tactics for a bit of wealth when they were not in dire need, or one who would raise a hand to one he professed to love?
"May I have tonight to decide?" Bard asked, feeling decades older than he had before he had come to the gate that day.
"Of course," Thorin nodded, his eyes showing he understood the difficulty of the decision he placed at the man's feet. And he did, he had had to make difficult calls as a king and almost pitied that Bard would have to learn the art. "My offer will still stand in the morning. We will await your decision."
Thranduil seemed less pleased with the man's desire to weigh the decision, hoping that Bard would have sided with him instantly out of old allegiances, but he too nodded his agreement and went back to their encampment.
"Send ravens to Dáin," Thorin ordered, never taking his eyes off the retreating elves. "We may have need of reinforcements before this is over."
"War?" Bilbo asked quietly, his stomach sloshing uncomfortably at the thought now that some of his rage had returned to a dull ember rather than the raging inferno it had been.
"If that's what it takes," Thorin replied sadly. He did not want a war either. He had seen far too many of them in his long life and had seen the cost on all sides. "We cannot cave to his demands under such a threat, and we cannot allow such a threat to go unanswered. We must have safe passage to the west."
"Hopefully Mahal can help Bard can talk sense into the Elf," Balin whispered. While Thorin hoped for such an outcome, he knew better than to rely on in. Thranduil would not back down, not now. He could only hope that Bard would come down on their side and Dáin's travel was swift. With enough of a force they could, perhaps, end this conflict without it coming to bloodshed. Even as the thought crossed his mind, he realized that it was the idealistic hope of a dwarfling, not the logic of a king. There was no way around it. Whether he willed it or not, the dwarves of Erebor were at war.
