Actions

Work Header

Inside Out

Chapter 14: We Didn't Start The Fire

Summary:

Max realises that hindsight is a bitch, and Billy really needs a nap.

Chapter Text

Billy had passed out not even two minutes into the drive, slumped limply in the front passenger seat of Steve’s car. Maxine sat directly behind him, both of her knees bouncing anxiously as she studied the uncomfortable looking angle of his neck, wincing every time the car jostled and his forehead bounced against the window. Her brother wasn’t usually a deep sleeper, so the fact that he’d yet to wake even once was a pretty good indicator of how completely exhausted he was.

 

Eyes burning with the threat of tears again, Max tore her gaze from her brother and forced herself to watch the dark scenery outside blur past. Billy had said in no uncertain terms that he wouldn’t ever talk about the horrible scene she’d witnessed in the front yard of the Byers house – and every dreadful thing it meant – but not talking about it didn’t mean that she wouldn’t think about it. Since it had happened, she couldn’t stop thinking about it.

 

Her mind mercilessly conjured up memories of every bruise and cut she’d ever seen marring Billy’s skin, and her ribs squeezed tighter around her thundering heart when she thought about all the lies he’d told her to excuse them, lies that Max wouldn’t have ever believed for even a second if she wasn’t so stupidly blind. How could she not have realised? How? All the signs had been right there in front of her for four years, and somehow she’d missed what hindsight was making abundantly obvious. The way that Billy shut down whenever Neil was around, becoming someone who was quiet and obedient and so completely unlike himself. How he never let her and Neil be alone together if he could help it, always coming up with excuses to put himself between them. Maxine had to bite back a sob when she thought back to all the times he’d covered for her – taking the blame for things that she’d always thought were so inconsequential at the time – and how more often than not he’d come to breakfast the next morning with a bruised cheek or a split lip.

 

God, how many times had Max inadvertently made his abuse worse? All those times she’d run away like some kind of petty little idiot, or didn’t do her chores right, or gave Neil attitude. Billy had made her swear to keep her mouth shut about the fire being her fault when she’d finally summoned the courage to confess to him, gaze deathly serious as he stared her down. The black eye he’d walked into her grandparents’ house with a few days later had been bad enough to last weeks, and he’d moved gingerly for even longer, like his entire body was in pain. Billy’s close encounter with death via hit-and-run had only made things worse, and now that Max was thinking about it, maybe the police hadn’t been coming around solely to follow up on the incident report. If they’d suspected Neil of being the abusive piece of shit that he undoubtedly was, then their abrupt move across the country suddenly made a lot more sense. Max’s stomach churned at the revelation, and the familiar burning in her eyes strengthened. She hadn’t understood why he’d been so insistent that she maintain her silence back then – unable to fathom why Billy hadn’t immediately snitched on her to Neil – but she did now, and that knowledge was ripping at her insides.

 

Billy had told her only hours ago that he wouldn’t always be around to take the hits for her, and now she knew that he’d been speaking literally.

 

Max clamped a hand over her mouth when a hitching breath turned into a quiet sob, squeezing her eyes shut as tightly as she could in a vain attempt to hold back the tears in her eyes. Billy had been protecting her from his monster of a father for years – silently bearing the pain of his abuse for her sake – and she’d been nothing but oblivious and ungrateful in return. The realisation of just how much of a bratty, shitty little sister she’d been to him made her absolutely furious with herself, which only served to redden her face further and make it harder to not break down crying in the back of Steve’s car.

 

“Oh shit, is she crying?” Dustin asked nobody in particular, panic in his voice.

 

There was the unmistakable sound of a smack, followed by a pained yelp. “Shut up, Dustin.” Mike scolded.

 

Lucas, who was sitting between her feet, reached up and hesitantly patted her knee. “Are… are you okay, Max?”

 

“I’m fine.” She replied quickly, aggressively wiping at her wet cheeks and sniffling back the snot that was beginning to block her nose. She hid her splotchy face in her hands, mortification joining the guilt and self-hatred swirling in her gut. “Just- just ignore me.”

 

“I’ll turn this car around right now, Max. Just say the word. We don’t have to-“

 

Max whipped her head up, red-rimmed eyes wide, “No! No, it’s not that.” She snapped, keeping her voice hardly above a whisper despite the sudden lurch of panic in her gut. She’d throw herself out of the car while it was still moving if she woke Billy up from his much needed rest. “I’m not worried about the demo-dogs, it’s just…” Max trailed off, once again staring at the side of her brother’s lax face. The cut through his eyebrow had almost completely healed, leaving behind only a pink line and very faint bruising around his temple. The thought of one of Neil’s fists leaving that mark left her seething, making her want to beat the man over the head with Steve’s wicked baseball bat until she knew that he would never touch Billy again.

 

Steve cast her a doubtful glance, though his expression cleared into something more understanding when he followed her tear-bright gaze. “Oh,” He said, brows lowering into a severe frown before he faced forwards once again. “Your brother’s the toughest guy I’ve ever met, Max. He’ll be okay.”

 

Dustin nodded seriously, dark blue eyes bright with enthusiasm. “Billy’s crazy, but he’s also a certified badass of the highest order. I mean, in terms of pure psychic power-“

 

“That’s not what they’re talking about, Dustin.” Lucas interrupted quietly, looking up at Max with serious dark eyes. “You’re upset about what his dad did to him when he showed up, right?”

 

The reminder of what she’d seen made her heart squeeze uncomfortably tight, her ears ringing with the harsh echo of Neil’s backhand against Billy’s cheek. The hit had been hard, but Billy had taken it without flinching, staggering only slightly beneath the force of it. Trying vainly to banish the images from her mind, Max mutely shook her head, unwilling to betray whatever small shred of trust that Billy still had in her by talking about him while he was unconscious. 

 

“Drop it, Sinclair.” Steve said sternly, fingers clenching and unclenching around the steering wheel. “It’s not our business.”

 

Mike glared at the back of the senior’s head, “Isn’t he your friend? We should tell Hop-“

 

“No!” Max whisper-shouted, breath catching in her throat when she imagined how furious Billy would be if they went blabbing his personal business to someone who he clearly didn’t trust. He’d never forgive her. “No way. Just- nobody say anything, to anyone. I don’t want to talk about this anymore.”

 

“Whatever,” Mike huffed, casting a narrow eyed look at Billy’s slumped form before turning his attention to the crudely drawn map in his hands. “Take the next-“

 

“Right. I know where we’re going, shithead.”

 

Mike grumbled some rude things about Steve beneath his breath before falling quiet, and nobody said another word until they arrived at the dark expanse of foul smelling field that was Merrills Pumpkin farm.

 

~

 

Something was shaking insistently at his right shoulder, pulling Billy from the blissful abys of unconsciousness with a suddenness that left him scrambling to make sense of the abrupt assault on all of his senses. Something smelled fucking terrible, the low buzzing noise coming at him from somewhere on his right made him think someone might be speaking, and his entire body felt like one giant bruise. Billy dared to squint open his eyes, blinking sluggishly at the ugly flannel covering his left arm. He lifted his head with a miserable groan, stretching his neck and rubbing at his eyelids until they no longer felt glued shut before conducting a more comprehensive examination of his surroundings.

 

He was still sitting in Steve’s BMW, its headlights illuminating the rotting farmland they were currently parked in the middle of. Steve himself was still occupying the driver’s seat, hand resting on Billy’s shoulder as he gave him a pinched, searching look. “Billy, you with me now?”

 

“Yeah,” Billy rasped, the dryness in his throat launching him into a coughing fit that hurt his bruised ribs and jostled his mangled leg. He swallowed down bloody phlegm and breathed carefully to avoid hacking up an entire goddamned lung, flexing his split knuckles in a weak attempt to distract himself from the deeper, more punishing aches pulsing through him. “We’re here?”

 

“Man, maybe we shouldn’t do this. You’re… You really don’t look okay, Billy. I don’t think you should-“

 

“Don’t bitch out on me now, Steve.” Billy said tiredly, curling his fingers around the door handle and bracing himself for the effort it was going to take for him to get up off his lazy ass. Steve’s fancy BMW’s seats were ridiculously comfortable. “C’mon, we’ve got some arsonists to babysit.”

 

Steve blew out an explosive breath, running an anxious hand through his hair. “Alright, let’s do this. Jesus.”

 

Smirking at the disbelief making the senior’s voice go up a few octaves, Billy forced himself out of the car. Standing up made him pathetically breathless and nauseatingly dizzy, but he managed to keep his feet under him until his vision cleared and his lungs decided to start working again. Max and her nerd friends were gathered around the BMW’s open trunk, shoddily wrapping bits of cloth around the lower halves of their faces and clamping goggles over their eyes. After roughly shoving one of their gas cans into his backpack Wheeler moved to the front of the car with a loop of rope in one hand, kneeling down in the dirt and beginning to tie one end around the front left tyre when he failed to find anything else to use as an anchor point.

 

Maxine cleared her throat pointedly to gain Billy’s sluggishly wandering attention, holding out a pair of orange goggles and a dark green bandana. What looked like a cut up piece of curtain was obscuring her nose and mouth, and her voice came out muffled when she spoke. “Here.”

 

Noting her lack of eye protection, Billy didn’t move to take either of the offerings. “Where’re your goggles?”

 

“In my pocket.” She lied.

 

Billy clicked his tongue, ignoring her indignant protests as he grabbed her shoulders and spun her around, plucking a pair of fucking sunglasses from the back pocket of her jeans. The nerds must have only been able to find five pairs of goggles during their raid of the Byers household, and now his little sister was stupidly trying to give him the last pair instead of taking them for herself. Frustration swiftly overpowering any gratitude he might have felt, Billy hooked the sunglasses over the collar of his shirt and spun Maxine back around. He gave her a severely unimpressed look, yanking the bandana out from between her clenched fingers. “Put the damn goggles on, Maxine.”

 

“But-“

 

“I don’t want to hear it. Put them on, now.”

 

Surprisingly, Maxine didn’t start bitching or stomping her feet in the face of his blunt demand. She put the ugly orange goggles around her neck before snapping them over her eyes, wordlessly adjusting the straps at the back of her head. Disturbed by her uncharacteristic compliance, Billy lightly flicked her in the centre of her forehead, lips twitching up into a weak smirk when she hissed like a pissed off kitten. “Matches your hair.”

 

Though he couldn’t make out her expression beneath the botched curtain and wide goggles, Billy could almost feel her scowl. “They do not.”

 

“Uh-huh.”

 

A low whistle drew their attention to Steve, who was walking over to join the three dweebs standing around a decently sized hole in the ground. “Woah. Hopper must’ve been digging for hours.”

 

Maxine stayed close by his side as Billy limped forwards, hands lifting to hover anxiously near his arm as he staggered over the mound of dirt the Chief had displaced while digging. Wheeler and Sinclair both had their flashlights pointed down into the slimy-edged hole that Hopper had carved in the outer wall of the demo-dog’s tunnel, and Billy grimaced at the sickeningly sweet stench of rot wafting up from the blackness inside. He reluctantly folded his bandana in half and went about tying it over his face, knowing that the thick, stale air would be even more difficult for him to breathe through his makeshift mask. Billy hated feeling suffocated, but he also hated the thought of inhaling toxic filth and keeling over on the spot, so. Shitty bandana it was.

 

Wheeler dropped the rope down into the tunnel, moving like he was about to follow.

 

Billy reached out and snagged the back of his collar before he had the chance, scoffing when the kid tried to glare at him through the snorkelling goggles obscuring his sharp features and making him look like a fucking idiot. “Not so fast, sourpuss. I’m going first.”

 

“Do you sense something?” Sinclair asked quietly, eyeing the hole like a demo-dog might jump out at any moment. He was definitely the most level-headed out of all the overenthusiastic nerds, though with the bar so low that wasn’t saying much.

 

“Nah,” Billy answered, his dull headache ramping up a few notches as he cautiously stretched out his psychic radar. Being this close to the tunnels gave him a disconcerting sense of vertigo and he was having a hard time not thinking about his most recent nightmare, but at least he couldn’t sense any demo-dogs lurking nearby.

 

Shaking his head and ordering himself to stop being such a pussy, Billy planted his ass in the dirt and swung his legs down into the hole, digging his hands as securely as he possibly could into its slime covered edges before unceremoniously dropping down. He hung suspended a couple of feet from the uneven floor, hands and shoulders already straining under the effort of holding up his weight. Wheeler and Sinclair’s torches did a decent enough job of lighting up his dark surroundings, and he craned his neck to try and take in as many details as possible before allowing himself to fall. The subtly shifting, mucus covered vines that had carved places for themselves amongst the dirt and exposed roots lining the tunnel immediately gave Billy the heebie-jeebies, and he decided then and there that touching them was a very bad fucking idea. They practically reeked of the oily darkness that surrounded everything that originated from the Upside-Down, pulsing coldly against Billy’s senses and worsening his headache. The filthy air – flecked with countless bits of black shit that he’d bet the Camaro was toxic as all hell – made him glad he’d decided to endure a bit of mild suffocation via bandana in the name of not breathing it in.

 

Once he was fairly certain that nothing within his immediate vicinity was going to kill him, Billy double checked that there were no vines in his landing zone before letting himself drop. He landed on one foot with a quiet thud, shivering as he tipped his head back to meet all of the expectant stares digging into him from above. “Alright, c’mon down Stevie.”

 

Long-suffering, Steve adjusted his backpack and followed him down, muttering under his breath all the while about how much of a terrible idea this was. Agreeing wholeheartedly, Billy generously didn’t call him out on how much of a stick-up-the-ass rich boy he was being. Instead, he steadied the older boy when he failed to stick his landing and quietly demanded he help catch the incoming dweebs.

 

Steve finally seemed to notice his lack of eye protection as he helped Sinclair find his footing, brows furrowing over the yellow rimmed goggles circling his brown eyes. “Hey, why aren’t you wearing any goggles?”

 

Billy shrugged a shoulder, motioning impatiently for Henderson to drop next. So far he hadn’t experienced anything except some mild irritation when the shit in the air caught in his eye lashes, which was only a vague annoyance. The sunglasses he’d taken from Maxine were shit quality, and he sure as hell wasn’t about to start trying to navigate the dark as fuck tunnels with his vision tinted even darker, not if it wasn’t absolutely necessary. “Not enough for everyone, pretty boy. It’s fine.”

 

“Just-“ He sighed, shaking his head. “Just let me know if your eyes start hurting, or your vision goes all screwy, or something. We can take turns wearing mine.”

 

“Sure.” Billy replied easily, having absolutely no intentions of doing so.

 

Maxine was the last one to enter the tunnel, and she looked around with anxious, twitchy movements. Billy watched her for a moment before flicking his gaze over the other nerds, looking for any signs of regret. “Anyone having second thoughts?”

 

Steve’s instantaneous yes was drowned out by four very firm no’s, which was good enough for Billy. “Don’t step on the vines, and nobody leave my sight unless you want to get lost and die a slow and painful death, alone. That includes you, Harrington.”

 

Everyone except Wheeler were quick to nod their heads, sufficiently cowed. Billy narrowed his eyes at the gangly brat, who was apparently too focused on his crayon drawn map to pay attention to anything else. When Wheeler moved to step past him the junior didn’t hesitate to once again pull the kid up by his collar. “Where the fuck are you going, sourpuss?”

 

Wheeler tried vainly to pry himself out of his grasp, glaring at him through the ridiculous goggles he was wearing. “Let me- ugh.” He held up his shitty map, like that explained anything. “I’m pretty sure it’s this way!”

 

“You’re pretty sure, or you’re certain?” Henderson asked pointedly.

 

“I’m one hundred percent sure! Just follow me and you’ll know!”

 

“Yeah, no.” Billy scoffed, snatching the map from Wheeler’s spindly fingers and handing it off to Steve. “This is how it’s gonna work from here on out, dipshit. Steve’s got point, then it’ll go you, Maxine, Sinclair, and Henderson. Got it?”

 

“What about you?”

 

“I’m bringing up the rear. Now hurry the fuck up and get in line, I wanna be out of here in ten minutes.”

 

“You heard him. A little hustle, guys, come on.” Steve backed him up, motioning impatiently for the nerds to get in line between them. Once they were ready the senior met Billy’s eyes over their heads, the furrow of his brows indicating that he was frowning under his bandana. “Tell me if we need to slow down.”

 

“Whatever.” Billy replied somewhat snappily, frustrated by his current handicap and thrown off by the seemingly genuine concern. Keeping up was Billy’s problem, not Steve’s. “Let’s get a move on already.”

 

Steve took off at a fast walk down the long stretch of tunnel they’d descended into, long legs eating up the distance and forcing the kids into a light jog. Gritting his teeth against the sharp pain that shot up his leg with every step, Billy lengthened his own limping strides and kept pace. The uneven ground quicky proved itself to be one giant tripping hazard, and navigating it with only three flashlights to share between them was fraying at Billy’s already paper-thin sense of patience. To his credit, Henderson was trying to aim his light at an angle that would benefit both of them, but after jarring his bad leg on an unseen root and nearly twisting his good ankle on a rock, Billy’d had enough. “Give me your flashlight, Curly.”

 

“But-“

 

“No. Give it here.”

 

Letting out an aggravated sigh, Henderson handed it over. “If I trip and die I’m holding you accountable.”

 

Billy snorted, holding the flashlight at a low angle and easily lighting the way for the both of them. “Like I give a shit, nerd. Keep moving.”

 

They reached an intersection after about a minute or two of walking, Steve and Wheeler both studying their crayon map to try and figure out which way to go next. Ruthlessly cutting off the relieved sigh that tried to escape from his throat, Billy leaned his shoulder on a vine-free section of dirt wall and took the opportunity to rest his throbbing leg. The pain was getting worse, and while that didn’t surprise him in the slightest, it did piss him off.

 

“Ugh,” Maxine grunted in disgust, waving her hands in front of her face. The toxic filth blurring the air had thickened, forcing Billy to squint in order to avoid getting it in his eyes. “What is this place?”

 

Impatient and wary of lingering too long in one location, Billy ignored his sister and asked, “Which way, Wheeler?”

 

Wheeler pointed resolutely towards the tunnel branching off to the right, “This way. Let’s go!”

 

They continued forwards, though Billy hadn’t quite made it to the centre of the small intersection they were occupying before being forced to stop, lest he run into Henderson’s stalled back. He followed the boy’s intent stare upwards, frowning when he spotted the pulsing thing embedded almost directly above them in the tunnel’s ceiling. At first glance it looked like some kind of deformed flower, but then it shrunk back up into the slimy vines surrounding it and more resembled a cat’s puckered asshole. It spat out a thick gust of rot-scented something before either of them had the chance to duck out from beneath it, and Henderson’s startled shriek immediately drowned out Billy’s disgusted cursing.

 

The kid tripped backwards, knocking roughly into Billy’s bad leg on the way down. Blinded both by the unexpected jolt of intense pain and the flecks of filth clinging stubbornly to his eyelashes, Billy gritted his teeth hard enough to make his jaw ache in an effort to keep his agonised shout from escaping.

 

“Shit, shit! Help me! Help! Ugh, it went in my mouth!”

 

Too winded to demand that Henderson shut the fuck up, Billy rubbed harshly at his teary eyes and did his best to breathe through the dizziness threatening to put him on his ass right alongside the clumsy little shit. Steve and the other brats rushed back from the tunnel they’d started down, their panicked questions driving daggers into Billy’s pounding head.

 

“Billy, are you okay?” Maxine asked frantically, her voice barely registering above the cacophony echoing around the confined space. Blinking his stinging eyes open, he gave her a thoughtless nod before directing his gaze towards Henderson, who was on all fours and gasping dramatically between bouts of hacking up spit.

 

Steve hovered uncertainly in the middle, shifting his focus between Billy and Henderson so rapidly it was a surprise that he didn’t accidently snap his own neck. “What the hell happened?”

 

“That thing spat some funky shit at us.” Billy rasped weakly, pointing an accusing finger up at the pulsing cat’s ass in the ceiling. “We should move before it happens again.”

 

Henderson finally ceased his panicked spitting, pushing himself up onto his knees and staring into the bright beams of light that his friends were shining in his face. “Oh. I’m okay.”

 

Maxine and the nerds all reacted to Henderson’s anticlimactic declaration with varying degrees of exasperated annoyance, groaning and rolling their eyes. Swallowing down the urge to start tearing into the stupid kid for freaking the hell out over absolutely nothing – and fucking his mauled leg up even further – Billy took a limping step forward, intent on escaping the firing range of the weird as fuck geyser above them.

 

He really should have expected it, but when Billy’s bad leg gave out it came as a complete shock. Making use of the impressive reaction time he’d displayed on the basketball court, Steve caught him before he hit the ground, holding tightly to Billy’s upper arms until he got his feet back under him. Breathing heavily under his bandana, Billy determinedly blinked black spots from his vision. “I’m good, I’m good.”

 

“Bullshit.” Steve snapped, fingers tightening around his biceps. “Can you keep going?”

 

Frustrated and ashamed and very fucking aware of everyone’s eyes cutting into him, Billy shoved at the taller boy’s chest until he reluctantly let go. “I’m fine, Harrington.”

 

The senior scoffed, hands flexing at his sides in a way that had Billy instinctively bracing for a hit. “Jesus, you’re stubborn.” He turned towards the kids, waving his arms impatiently. “Follow me, shitheads.”

 

They continued on, and Billy resolutely ignored the narrow eyed looks that the three nerds kept throwing at him over their shoulders. Maxine refused to leave his side – a hand clenched tightly but unobtrusively in his borrowed flannel – and he didn’t have the energy to order her back to her place in the middle of their potentially deadly game of follow the leader. Instead he focused his energy towards not falling on his face as they traversed the uneven ground, which was becoming increasingly difficult as his right foot became disturbingly numb.

 

Steve’s low whistle snapped Billy’s attention away from where he was planting his feet, and his eyes widened when he saw the large, cavern-like space that the tunnel they were standing in opened up to. He limped forwards until he was standing on Steve’s left, slowly sweeping his gaze over the dreary expanse and rubbing at his temple when his head gave a particularly painful throb. It was cold here, and a sense of impending danger hung in the toxic air like an unrealised but very viable threat.

 

“Alright, Wheeler.” Steve said quietly. “I think we found your hub.”

 

Billy swallowed thickly, reaching back and grasping Maxine’s closest shoulder in a thoughtless bid to reassure himself that she was still standing behind him, alive and well. This wasn’t going to end like his nightmare had – with lifeless ice-blue eyes and a torn open corpse – it just wasn’t. Billy wouldn’t allow it to.

 

There were eight more tunnels aside from the one they’d just walked through, all feeding into Wheeler’s so-called hub, and Billy eyed each of their dark openings warily. The vines coiling over every available surface were denser than the ones they’d been walking over for the past five minutes, coiling like snakes and quietly pulsing with a vileness that Billy was getting well and truly fucking sick of feeling. They all seemed to feed into the strangely shaped organic platform in the centre of the cavern, and Billy grimaced as it shot a gust of noxious gas into the already barely breathable air.

 

“Let’s drench it.” Wheeler snapped.

 

Billy shifted on his feet, wincing beneath his bandana when pain shot up his leg. Running sounded fucking impossible right now, but they’d already made it this far, and like hell was Billy going to be the reason that they turned back without doing what they’d come to do. “You’ve got one minute, and don’t step on any fucking vines.”

 

Sinclair, Wheeler and Henderson all knelt down, pulling gas cans out of their backpacks and quickly unscrewing the caps. Within moments all three of them were carefully making their way around the cavern, dousing the floor and walls with liberal splashes of gasoline. Billy divided his attention between the kids and the dark tunnels surrounding them, keeping a close eye on their progress while staying vigilant of any potential dangers. It didn’t take them long to run out of gas, and they made quick work of discarding the cans before returning to huddle behind Billy and Steve. The senior produced a lighter from one of the pockets in his bomber jacket once the nerds were well clear of the gasoline-soaked ground, though he hesitated to light it.

 

Feeling nauseated by the mixture of gasoline and Upside-Down rot burning his nostrils, Billy impatiently knocked their shoulders together. “Hurry the fuck up, pretty boy.”

 

“Alright,” Steve snapped anxiously, spreading his arms out and waving for everyone to back up. “Everybody get ready to run.”

 

The senior flicked on his lighter before throwing it into the centre of the vine-infested cavern, and the world exploded into fire and screaming. Billy hardly noticed himself collapsing to his knees, the pain radiating up from his mauled leg barely registering above the all-encompassing agony threatening to break his skull apart. He curled forward and clamped his hands over his ears in a useless bid to protect himself from the heat-pain-fear-rage-pain-pain-heat-pain threatening to deafen him, wondering deliriously if this was how he died.

 

Hands grasped roughly at his shoulders, and Billy was too weak to protest when they pulled and pushed and forced him to stand.