Actions

Work Header

my words will wander (but my friendships will not)

Chapter 5: Regarding the Iron Hills and healing

Summary:

Post "a new morn hides in the darkest of storms".

Chapter Text

To the King of Erebor,

May this letter find you in good health and peace. You will need both at your side for what I am about to tell you.

Dain is heading to Erebor to speak with you. I entreat you, nephew, to hear him out. He traveled all the way to the Shire for no other reason than to seek peace with myself and Bilbo, to offer his apologies and to beg for aid. He fears treason amidst his Council, and, after he shared his story, I am inclined to agree with him. It took your uncle to get me to accept it, though.

I did not want to forgive him. He once spoke harshly and wrongly of not just Bilbo, but of Dernwyn and Legolas, two whom I hold dearly. Yet your uncle, as he does far too often, forgave Dain for his wrongdoing against him. Yes, I was as thrilled as you might imagine. Dain did not deserve forgiveness, no matter his reasons or his own admittance to acting foolishly in fear and pride.

But Bilbo reminded me that once, twenty years ago, I did the same. I spoke treacherous words that nearly lost me my heart, all for the foolish love of gold and a thrice-cursed stone. And it was Bilbo’s forgiveness that, while not deserved, was still given easily. I was grateful for it then. I cannot deny Dain the same.

He will need your aid, Fili. The Council has been dictating his moves for far too long, and even as he traveled here, he feared his own guards, that they might have orders to strike him down.

I cannot tell you to forgive him. That is entirely up to you, and up to Kili, Legolas, Dernwyn, and all whom he has offended. I can only tell you that Dain and I have reconciled, and it was I who urged him to stop in Erebor to speak with you. If nothing else, hear him out. That is the only thing I can ask of you, my son. You must make the choice that is best for Erebor and your family, as I know that you will.

Frodo wanted to send you a fruit of some kind. I’m not quite certain what his fascination is with fruit lately, but I have a feeling that when we go to market to mail this letter, we will be returning with various fruits. So know that you have been well thought of by Frodo. Elodie merely sends her greetings and wishes you to pass them on to her unmet cousins.

Your other uncle told me to tell you to not let guilt dictate your move, but rather the urge to be freed from stress. Because he always has to have the last word.

With our love,

Thorin

 

To my uncles and little cousins in the Shire,

Your letter arrived two days before Dain did. Actually, it arrived five minutes before Dain’s caravan was spotted making its way to Erebor. So it was well received and greatly appreciated to find your scroll detailing things.

Currently Dain is making his way back to the Iron Hills. He will be speaking with the two Council members I have come to know and speak to through the years, and I can only hope that they will aid him.

When you made mention of his troubles with the Council, I had assumed there was arguing against his rule. What Dain laid out was a great deal worse and in no way as simple as your letter dictated. I have to assume that you did that on purpose, in order to ensure I listened and listened well. I can assure you that I did. We all did. We also listened to his apology, and I was stunned to find how sincere he was and how worried he was. Not for himself, but for Legolas, that his words had caused a grievance.

Legolas also has the distinct problem of forgiving where he ought to condemn. It must be an elvish or hobbity thing. In either case, Legolas was swift to forgive and assure him that no lasting damage had been done, and of course if Legolas was happy, so was Kili. Dernwyn, too, assured him that she forgave him, though thankfully she kept a distance until she was certain he was holding true to his word. My wife is as intelligent as she is cunning, and I was proud to see her father’s blade at her side at all times.

Hildili, true to form, was eager to speak with him and make friends, with Holdred reluctantly being hauled along for the ride and Baldrin amicably toddling after them. I suppose the word ‘toddling’ isn’t accurate, anymore, given his age, but he will always be my youngest and Dernwyn’s babe.

At any rate, once my children insisted on meandering their way in as they are wont to do, the tension in the room dropped like a weight off of our shoulders. Dain, it seems, is incredibly good with children. And it was through my three that we were all able to speak with one another.

You were right. I didn’t want to forgive him, either. But I did, all the same, and not because he is in dire trouble. No, I forgave him because he needed it, and so did I. I don’t want estranged kin. I don’t want to constantly worry about the Iron Hills.

And because I was forgiven by Bilbo twenty years ago, too. Kili and I were both forgiven in Rohan for turning him away after you banished him. I still remember the relief of being so easily forgiven, of being told it was already forgotten, that I was still held high and dear in his eyes. I could not deny that to anyone, especially someone in desperate need of aid. The need to forgive is greater than the need to be right. I learned that from Bilbo many years ago. It is, perhaps, one of the greatest lessons my hobbit uncle has ever indirectly taught me.

Please tell my hobbit uncle thank you for what he said. Also, please send my thanks to Frodo and tell him that he can keep his fruits; I highly doubt they’d last all the way from the Shire. Holdred, Hildili, and Baldrin eagerly send their greetings to Elodie.

And Uncle? You can stop thrashing yourself for what happened after we reclaimed Erebor. Uncle Bilbo’s long since forgiven you, and not one of us holds it against you.

With my thanks and love,

Fili, King of Erebor, Proud sister-son of Thorin Oakenshield

 

To my dearest kingly nephew,

I’m mailing this to you while your uncle’s off at the forge. Some sort of project that he won’t tell me about. He kept fiddling with my pin, as if measuring it, so I have absolutely no idea what he’s up to.

But I wanted to give you a quick message: thank you. Not for forgiving Dain, or even for listening to me, but rather for what you wrote to Thorin.

I wish I could send you my memory of the moment he opened your letter and read it through. Relief, certainly, that you were able to reconcile with Dain, that there will be aid given to the Iron Hills. Understanding, given that you fought to see through Dain’s eyes in order to give yourself peace. And then the last part of the letter, your little throwaway line regarding the whole Arkenstone nonsense. I don’t know if you sat for a long time when composing those words, or if they were simply an afterthought of obviousness. It IS obvious to us and anyone who isn’t Thorin, but your uncle has always been more hard headed and denser than the usual dwarf.

The look on his face when he read your words, though…however much time you put into it, it was worth it. Thank you. Perhaps your uncle will eventually truly forgive himself. We can only hope.

And as for you and Kili, neither of you truly needed my forgiveness. I understood why you did what you did. To be honest, I was more concerned that you wouldn’t want anything to do with ME. So I think we evened out well, and the past can well be forgotten.

Please pass on my words to your brother, and wish them my best with our love.

Your hobbit uncle