Actions

Work Header

my words will wander (but my friendships will not)

Chapter 6: Regarding completely hypothetical questions

Summary:

Takes place after "in need of a hand to hold".

Notes:

No you didn't read that update email wrong. Yes I actually updated. Yes it's been forever. Yes I'm a horrible author please forgive me. Life...has been very good but incredibly stressful all at the same time. For a multitude of reasons.

And YES, I am mucking with canon again. Which you shouldn't be surprised about at this point, but a friendly disclaimer is everyone's friend.

This is sort of a part 1 of sorts. I promise it's supposed to end where it does.

Chapter Text

Uncle Thorin,

Sending you merry thoughts from Erebor! Hopefully my page will have warmed some along the travels; it’s absolutely frigid at the moment, the coldest winter we’ve ever had. I can’t help but be thankful that Uncle Bilbo isn’t here. His ankle would suffer fiercely for it. (And I hope that it’s been better now that he’s in the Shire.) All of us are looking forward to spring, which is supposed to soon be upon us.

The nature of my letter isn’t really anything special, just simply greetings to send to you and Uncle Bilbo and Elodie and Frodo, the latter two I imagine to be growing every day! My three are also doing quite well in that regard. Quite.

…Well, I suppose, since I’m writing the letter and all, I could ask you a simple question. A very small, simple question. Nothing incredible or different or odd about it, truly. Merely hypothetical.

…What, exactly, would one do if, hypothetically, their eldest heir wanted absolutely nothing to do with the crown and wanted to become, say - hypothetically of course - a healer instead?

Your nephew,

Fili

 

To my King of Erebor, my dearest nephew and son,

Holdred is still young, yet. He is only 34 years of age which, while an acceptable age for men to be fully grown, may not yet be for him, given his dwarven ancestry. He is still growing, still very young. He may yet change his mind. Kili was determined to live off of sweets and bugs for the rest of his life, if you will recall, when he was also 34. He changed his mind swiftly enough.

But, if Holdred has made up his mind, then I will warn you that you will be forced to reckon with the stubbornness that is inherent in the line of Durin. Banging your head against a rock in order to move it will do nothing to the rock and only succeed in giving you a massive ache. It is much the same with those in the line of Durin. And, especially, your children, who also have the stubbornness stemming from their mother’s side to contend with.

Do not fret. If he chooses a path of healing, then he will be known far and wide for his talents. Of this I have no doubt. Let him continue to learn his healing from Oin, who ages every year. Erebor will need someone with wise healing prowess in years to come.

Your other uncle and I are in complete agreement on this, however: speak to Holdred about what he wishes. Tell him he is always free to change his mind, but also do not fear encouraging him to follow the path that he wishes. It will only strengthen your relationship with your son.

Your Uncle Bilbo would also like to point out that you are not short on heirs, and perhaps speaking to Hildili and Baldrin about the crown would be in your best interests.

Please let us know what transpires.

With love from the Shire,

Thorin

 

Greetings Bilbo and Thorin,

Fili wanted to send you the update on our unique situation himself, but Dain called for aid in the Iron Hills, and he left immediately with a host of dwarves. Given the rapidly sent raven all but written in code, Fili thought it best to depart as swiftly as possible. I was almost tempted to go with him, but he took Holdred instead, and thus left me with more time to pen a response.

Holdred wants nothing to do with the crown. He feels no call to rule and lead, and as a result has been doing quite poorly in his political lessons from Dis and Dori. Fili was all flustered about it – of course he was, you know how he can be – but your letter encouraged him to speak with Holdred directly. Which then resulted in Hildili and Baldrin poking their heads in, given that none of my children seem to have any sense of privacy when it comes to their siblings.

Which of course meant nearly the entire company wound up there. And a good thing too, because if we’d had no witnesses, it would’ve been difficult to explain what transpired next.

Holdred said quite clearly that he wanted to be a healer and not a king, and went on to explain that it had nothing to do with your ruling or Fili’s ruling; he simply didn’t feel that it was a good path for him to take, and he wasn’t disposed to ruling over the lives of many. He wanted to help people, just not on a throne.

Which was when Hildili raised her hand and said, “All right, I’ll do it.”

Given that this has never really happened in Ereborian history, apparently, Ori went diving off for the books while we tried to figure out the ramifications of how to leave the throne to Hildili and not dismiss or disown Holdred in the process. As it turns out, there is a way, which Ori found and had to explain three times to the rest of us.

Apparently, there were twins in the histories once, and as they could not both rule at the same time, one had to be chosen, and no one could remember which birth had come first. So both were consulted about it at long last, and one of them agreed to rule while the other wanted to pursue a leadership over the mining, which, interestingly enough, is how the Guilds began. At any rate, he was still very much royalty, but preferred the term “Guildmaster” and left his brother to do the ruling. It was a very official ceremony in which one brother handed the crown to the other in the sight of all witnesses and declared that he would never try to take it back, and would instead work to aid his sibling in bearing the royal duty as best he could.

The Council was…surprised, to say the least, when Fili brought it up with them. Given that all of them know our children, they weren’t particularly surprised about Holdred pursuing his apprenticing more, nor were they particularly surprised about Hildili wanting the crown. They were more surprised that it has happened before and that Fili is determined to see it done again. One of them may have grumbled that it was “all that hobbit’s fault” before giving a wry grin and saying it was for the best. I thought Bilbo might enjoy knowing that he was “being blamed” in the best of ways.

So at the moment, Holdred will continue to apprentice under Oin, though Oin is considering giving him a title of his own. Hildili has begun political lessons alongside Holdred, who has suddenly and remarkably improved now that the weight of the crown no longer hangs about his neck. And Baldrin? Baldrin seems content to follow his siblings around with no real mark in any direction at the moment. Only time will tell what happens next.

But for now, things are well enough. I can only hope that Fili will be able to aid Dain as promised at long last, and perhaps restore some sort of order and peace to the Iron Hills.

You are well missed and very much loved by all,

Dernwyn, Queen of Erebor

 

To King Elessar of Gondor,

I call upon your aid in a most desperate of times. The Iron Hills have fallen into civil war, and without an outside force, I fear for the innocents and for my kin, Dain Ironfoot.

If you have any men to spare, I beg you to send them north. The urgency of this plea will hopefully have been apparent from the raven it was sent with. I would not call upon you for help if it was not desperately needed.

With hope,

King Fili of Erebor

 

To my friend and brother in arms,

I depart Gondor immediately with the best of my men. Denethor, Captain of Dol Amroth, rides with me.

To arms!

Aragorn