Chapter Text
Within an hour Bilbo had gathered enough pieces of broken furniture to start a small fire and prop the copper kettle from the pack atop the coals, filled with water from one of the skins. It really was abysmally dark down there, perhaps not so for a dwarf, but Bilbo’s eyes were having difficulty adjusting. The cheerful little campfire was a relief even if it meant he lost what night vision he had gained.
Thorin was settled just beyond the immediate reach of the firelight, his eyes two glowing points in the darkness. Bilbo had found him a cloak from amongst the packs, a lovely thing of dark blue with a silver tassel, and Thorin now wore it with the hood pulled up, concealing the horrid black scars that covered his face and body.
Once ready, Bilbo poured the tea into a pair of tin travel cups and passed one to Thorin, who accepted it without a word. As his hands emerged from the long sleeves of the cloak, one meant for Men and so too long even for so tall a dwarf as Thorin, Bilbo caught a glimpse of curved black talons at the end of Thorin’s fingers and gulped silently, hiding his reaction under the guise of blowing on his tea. The water had just finished boiling and was far too hot to drink. Thorin brought the cup to his lips.
“Oh, Thorin!” Bilbo exclaimed, putting out a hand to stop the dwarf.
Thorin downed the scalding liquid in one long swallow before looking up. “What is it?”
Bilbo lowered his hand, his mouth agape. Thorin watched him from beneath his hood, one black eyebrow raised. Bilbo shook his head and subsided. “Nothing, it’s nothing. Just…I thought it a bit too hot to drink, didn’t you?”
Thorin inspected the bottom of the cup. “Not particularly.” A strange expression crossed his face and he set the cup aside.
Bilbo’s fingers drummed against his own steaming mug. Thorin shifted his position, sitting with one knee drawn to his chest, his arm draped flat across it while his other hand lay on his knee. Black scales trailed up his hand and disappeared into the sleeves and Bilbo cast his gaze about trying to find something, anything, to look at besides the claws glinting in the firelight. Thorin must have read his movement, because he folded in on himself then, drawing his hands out of sight under the cloak.
Bilbo cleared his throat. “So, are we going to talk about this?” he said.
“This?” Thorin echoed coldly.
“This,” Bilbo said and made a circular gesture towards Thorin. “All of this.”
Thorin looked away, his face falling into shadow under the blue hood. He must have closed his eyes too, for the faint glow winked out.
“No, I didn’t mean…!” Bilbo stopped. His voice softened. “Thorin, how did this happen?”
The silence stretched long before Thorin spoke again. “I do not know. I awoke like this.”
“What, all at once?” Bilbo exclaimed.
Thorin must have opened his eyes, for the lights returned and from the tone of his voice he was rolling them at Bilbo at the moment. “No. There were early signs. Marks on the skin, as if this new flesh was growing beneath my own. The gold… I must have fallen asleep on the gold, and when I woke it had spread.” His voice lowered to a growl, but weighed down more by shame than anger. “I don’t know what to do.”
“But... why didn’t you come to us for help?” Bilbo said.
Thorin stilled, and looked down at his hands. The scales glinted in the firelight. “How could I?”
Silence fell between them again, the only sound the crackle of the fire and the rustle of cloth as Thorin pulled himself deeper into the folds of the cloak, vanishing but for glimpse of gray flesh at his throat, shadowed by his hood.
“You know,” Bilbo said, clearing his throat before he continued. His voice was strangely hoarse, and there was a weight in his chest as if someone had hung a stone where his heart should be. “I don’t think they would resent you, the company that is, if you asked for help.” He poked at the fire with one of the spare sticks. “They would have forgiven you.”
“And who is to say that I have forgiven them?” Thorin said, his voice grave while uttering words that would have been childish in another, but from him held the dreadful grimness of an oath. “Or that I should seek their aid who have stolen from me and betrayed me?”
The fire sparked at Bilbo’s prodding, along with the flickers of his own anger. “They didn’t steal the Arkenstone, Thorin,” Bilbo said, and the flames bathed his face in red light as he looked up at Thorin. “I did. In case you have forgotten.”
“Never,” Thorin said, his voice low and taking on the edge of flint on steel. “Not if I should live a thousand years.”
“Good. For a moment I thought I must fear for your mind as well as your skin,” Bilbo said, and turned back to the fire. “There was no need to drag them into this.”
“They took the side of thieves against their king. If they wanted my goodwill, they should have done more to keep it,” Thorin snapped.
Bilbo jabbed the fire, hard, and sparks showered into the air, dropping embers upon them like fireworks. Bilbo jumped, and as he did he saw that he gripped the makeshift poker like a sword. Thorin had looked up at the sparks but did not move to avoid them. The blue light gleamed in his eyes. Bilbo’s heart thundered in his chest, and he opened his mouth to apologize before the reason caught up to him.
Why, his blood was as hot as the fire itself! And he realized he was angry, yes, very angry in fact, at the nerve of the dwarf before him and quite prepared to tell him so!
“Oh, that’s nice. Very nice indeed. They follow you across fire and water when none of your other kin would come, get chased, beaten, and oh yes, nearly eaten, twice, to help you regain your homeland and this is how you repay them? Toss them out the door because they dared to speak their minds? Well do you know what, Thorin Oakenshield?”
At some point Bilbo had leapt to his feet and now he stood holding the poker pointed at Thorin and staring down it along the length of his arm. Blue light glinted beneath the hood but Thorin only watched him, saying nothing. Bilbo deflated, the tip of the stick bouncing on the stone floor as he lowered it. He raked his fingers through his hair, catching and holding it as he stared blankly forward and the enormity of it all crashed down around him. “I…I just thought better of you, Thorin. I really did. I’m sorry I was wrong.”
Bilbo tossed the stick aside and turned, staring back the way he had come up the tunnel while his breathing eased from its frantic rush and his chest loosened. Then his shoulders drooped further, this time in despair. He could not very well go back the way he had come, not with Thorin like this, but the memory of the wall was rising like a pair of hands clasped around his throat and he wondered at how foolish he had been, denying Fíli and Kíli’s help, allowing Gandalf leave.
What good was he at reasoning with Thorin? Bilbo didn’t even know him, not anymore, and what was worse, he felt just as much to blame that it had come to this. Stealing the Arkenstone had been the right thing to do, he still believed that, had to, but oh, that gulf between them seemed insurmountable now and how was he ever supposed to reach across it with all this lying between them? How had he even thought to try?
“Why did you do it, burglar?” Thorin’s voice was so heavy, so replete with weariness that Bilbo found himself turning before he could even begin to think better of it, as unable to stop himself as he would have been had Thorin cried out in pain.
Thorin watched him, eyes half-lidded as he looked down. Exhausted. The black streak of scale on his left cheek seemed only a shadow that had fallen across his face and there was something there, something familiar, as if the last of the beast that attacked Bilbo in these halls had fallen away and Thorin was, if not completely himself, then at least closer to the person Bilbo remembered from before than he had been in some time. Poor fool that he was, Bilbo knew he could not have resisted that question if he tried and all pride and outrage drained from him. He sighed and sat back down, propping his cheeks in his hands as he stared into the depths of the fire.
“It is a very pretty gem, isn’t it? I’d be lying if I said that played no part,” Bilbo began. Thorin settled back, listening, and Bilbo’s voice fell into the even cadence of their many evenings by the fire, as if he related no more than the passing weather and not whys and wherefores of a betrayal that nearly had Thorin cast him to the rocks. “Mostly I was afraid, I think. We were low on food,” Thorin snorted derisively at this; Bilbo chose to ignore it, “and Bard had a point, even if I could not agree with his methods. All those poor people in Laketown… Smaug only attacked them because of us, and if a bit of the gold would help, it seemed wrong to keep it from them. It wasn’t mine to give, I know— well, except that it was, my share at least. But you hardly seemed ready to let them into the mountain to retrieve it. A couple tons of treasure… it’s hardly portable, you know. Come to think of it, I’m not sure how I was expected to get any of it home without drawing every brigand for a thousand leagues.”
Thorin gave him a measured, impatient look. Bilbo cleared his throat and hurried on. “I knew it was important to you, but there didn’t seem to be any other way. And I—I feared for you, Thorin. The way you looked at me when you asked after it was unsettling, to say the least and I, uh, I’m not sure I was entirely wrong.” Bilbo lifted his chin. “In fact I know I wasn’t. Maybe there was a better way, but we’ll never know for certain and at least all of you are alive. If being banished from the mountain is the worst I suffer, well, then so be it, but I can’t think of a better use for my share.”
“A pretty gem,” Thorin remarked, his voice taking on an edge. “You have no idea of its worth. You other races never do, thinking only that we dwarves are driven mad by gold and greed.” Bilbo raised an eyebrow and could not help but make a gesture that took in Thorin’s current state, then point to treasure that surrounded them.
Thorin snarled and rose to his feet. Bilbo fell back, and he was ashamed to think of it, but his hand strayed to the hilt of Sting as Thorin loomed above him. “The Arkenstone grants its wielder the powers of kingship, among those the right to summon the armies of the dwarves. The very armies I had sent for that day.”
“Am I supposed to believe your kin need a gem as an excuse to come help you?” Bilbo interrupted, glaring up at Thorin, who returned the look with equal venom.
“I gave Dáin assurances that the Arkenstone was in my possession when I sent for him, asking for his aid against the armies of Bard and Thranduil,” Thorin retorted, ignoring Bilbo’s question. “Little did I know that it had been stolen by the burglar I hired to retrieve it!”
“Then I am all the more glad I stole it!” Bilbo said. “I don’t want Dáin fighting Thranduil and Bard anymore than I wanted you fighting them!”
“Do you understand nothing of politics?” Thorin growled. “When Dáin arrives he will learn that I have lied to him and I will stand foresworn before my kin. Worse, as the leader of the Company, I will be held responsible for the Arkenstone falling into the hands of the very enemies I summoned them to fight!”
“But what does any of this matter, Thorin, when the fighting is already over!” Bilbo shouted. This time it was Thorin’s turn to recoil, his eyes snapping wide at Bilbo’s words.
“Over? It will be days more before Dáin arrives from the Iron Hills. How can it be over?” Thorin said.
This drew Bilbo up short and his breath left him in a rush as he stared at Thorin, remembering the dwarf’s earlier words of how long he’d slept. “Thorin,” he said cautiously, “do you have any idea how long you’ve been down here?”
“Three days, no more,” Thorin said, but the rage that had leant him size and might was failing him, and his voice was tight as he looked to Bilbo for confirmation.
Bilbo’s eyebrows rose and he puffed out his cheeks as he exhaled. “Oh...oh dear.” He looked back up to Thorin, at the black scales climbing his cheek and his blue eyes burning from within the hood. “Oh dear, oh dear… Thorin, you may want to sit down for this one. I’m not even sure where to begin.”
“Dáin… is already here?” Thorin said. The anger drained from Thorin entirely then, and Bilbo would have been heartened at this if he did not suspect it could easily return if he was not very, very careful with what he said next.
“Here? Yes, you could say that, he has been for almost a week,” Bilbo said. At this Thorin did sit down, and put out a hand to steady himself on an ornamental vase that lay upended upon the gold. “We were wondering when you’d come out and uh, would have sent someone to look for you sooner if not for the battle.”
“There was a battle?” Thorin said, and it seemed the healthy skin of his face had gone even paler than the gray, diseased flesh.
“Yes,” Bilbo said, and began unconsciously wringing his hands. “A terrible one. When Dáin arrived we all feared he and Thranduil would come to blows, everyone was squabbling over how they would get into the mountain. To be honest, with the door collapsed I’m not sure anyone knew what they were doing there anymore. Well, then Azog arrived with an entire army, if you can believe it. Who knows for certain why they came to Erebor, probably to get at you. Of course, Bard, Thranduil, and Dáin had no choice but to take up arms together to fight off the orcs. Then the Eagles appeared, oh and Beorn. I have no idea where he came from.” As he spoke, Thorin’s face shifted through an array of emotions starting at shock and moving on to horror and then bewilderment, before he seemed to give up entirely on trying to understand and just stared wide-eyed at the floor. “They’re already calling it the Battle of the Five Armies and such a mess I’ve never seen in my life. Nearly didn’t survive it myself, when Azog found Fíli and Kíli…”
Thorin sucked in a breath, his face expression twisting and growing, if possible, even more sickened.
“They’re fine!” Bilbo exclaimed when he caught sight of it. “Goodness, you think I wouldn’t tell you straightaways if any harm had come to them? I spoke to them in the infirmary before I left. They’re a bit the worse for wear— Fíli took a nasty blow to the head— but I’ve been assured they will recover quickly. Fortunately, they come from a line of hard skulls.” He offered a faint grin at the last but Thorin appeared to take no notice.
“What else?” Thorin said. He gave Bilbo a look that could pierce stone. “Tell me everything. What was the outcome?”
“Oh, well,” Bilbo stuttered, taken aback to be pinned thus by his gaze. “The orcs were defeated, obviously, or I wouldn’t be here. I’m afraid I missed how it was accomplished, took a blow to the head myself while I was trying to keep Azog away from Fíli and Kíli. Luckily Dáin showed up just before then and killed him, I think. By the time I came to it was all over. There were,” Bilbo gave a shuddering breath, “many deaths. Not just orcs but elves and Men and dwarves. No one from the company, but it was… hard… to see so many strewn about.”
Bilbo gulped and realized with horror that he was choking back tears. His first sight of the battlefield had been like a dream, and had not penetrated the daze brought on by his head wound and general bewilderment. Now, with a little distance and clearer mind, he gagged at the force of the memory, of the piles of dead, their forms twisted in agony, their bodies…not entirely intact. He quickly blotted the image of their broken forms from his mind, of the things that had come spilling out, else indeed he would be sick.
“H-hard to believe it was only this morning,” Bilbo continued with a weak laugh, realizing he had been staring at the fire and feeling very cold despite it.
“This morning?” Thorin echoed. His expression had changed as Bilbo spoke, losing some of its severity. He no longer watched Bilbo as if challenging him, but rather with something closer to concern. “You were wounded, yet did not take any time to rest before coming here?”
“Oh, one of Dáin’s folk patched me up well enough. It was only a little bump. The worst of it was lying on the battlefield all night, terribly uncomfortable that was. If I never smell orc blood again it will be too soon,” Bilbo said with a dismissive wave, relieved to have moved on to safer topics. “Actually, I was glad to have something to do. There’s not much use for a hobbit on a battlefield, before, during or after. I suppose I could have helped with the wounded, but quite frankly it’s a dreadful business and most likely I would have only been in the way. With the Arkenstone squared away, there would not have been anything left to do but wait and worry about you, and from the look of it we would have been waiting quite some time.”
Thorin frowned, shaking his head as if driving away a bothersome fly. “You’re doing it again,” he said irritably.
“I beg your pardon, doing what?” Bilbo said, startled.
“You speak of great deeds as if they are of little account, then go on about your own unworthiness even as you fling yourself into dangers even the bravest would not dare, you impossible, infuriating… burglar!” Thorin said. His eyes seemed clearer as he spoke, the blue glow dimmed, though he still looked as if he could chew through rocks in his annoyance.
“Well!” Bilbo said. “I suppose I learned from the best in that regard, Master Oakenshield. If I fling myself into danger it is only because a certain leader of our company did so at the slightest provocation, and seemed to expect nothing less of those who followed him. Goodness knows you never commented on my deeds before, why should I expect them to be of any import now?”
“And why should my comment have ever mattered? Your deeds during the quest will already be the subject of dwarven song for an Age, to say so aloud would be to repeat the obvious,” Thorin growled, but looked away as his own words seemed to catch up with him, and along with it the first tinge of shame in the downward flicker of his eyes.
“It still would have been nice to hear from time to time,” Bilbo said softly. “To have done anything that impressed the mighty Thorin Oakenshield, why, that would have been a feather in my cap and no mistake. They’d never believe it back home.”
Thorin studied Bilbo, searching for some sign of mockery, then shifted and turned away. There was agitation in the set of his frame, some restless energy, and he cast several glances back at Bilbo, his mouth working as if preparing a response. Only then did it occurred to Bilbo what he had neglected to mention, why it was the very purpose of his errand!
“Oh, but you likely don’t care about any of that!” Bilbo exclaimed. “But you should be pleased to hear that the Arkenstone has been retrieved and returned to dwarven hands, even if Thranduil did try to kick up a fuss over it.”
“The Arkenstone?” Thorin said, and if Bilbo didn’t know any better he’d think from Thorin’s tone he’d forgotten it entirely, which was of course impossible. “How was this accomplished?”
“It was mostly Gandalf, I must admit, goodness knows I couldn’t convince those three to put themselves out if they were on fire. But I did suggest that it be returned to Fíli in your absence, what with him being your heir and us, ah, not knowing when or if you’d be back. I knew it belonged to your father and grandfather after all, even if I did not know its full importance at that time, maybe because someone never bothered to tell me. It seemed too important an heirloom to have bartered about like an old sofa, and really what use would Bard have had for it? He certainly could not have traded it for food and he is the only one who can be called even slightly deserving, as far as I’m concerned. And... Thorin?” The dwarf did not appear to be paying attention.
“I should have been there,” Thorin muttered. “For all of it, the negotiations, the battle, Fíli and Kíli. I should have been fighting with them on the front lines, not lying in some stupor—!” He dashed his hands over the gold, sending coins dancing and pinging into the dark.
“Well, I for one am glad you weren’t there,” Bilbo retorted. “In the state you were in, you would have made some suicidal charge, probably at the elves instead of the orcs, and gotten us all killed.” He sighed. “Please just…come out of here, and let us help you. Then I’ll be on my way and you need not see me again.”
Thorin regarded him silently and when he finally spoke he tilted his head up but would not meet Bilbo’s eyes. “After all that has happened... why did you come back?”
Bilbo blinked. “I—I should think that would be obvious? We were worried about you. But I suppose you mean after the…unpleasantness, on the wall.” He huffed a sigh, but felt his insides clench uncomfortably even at the memory of all that dizzying space yawning behind him. “Because there was no one else. Because you might have been hurt, or sick, or starving alone down here. Because… because in the end I know I wronged you, and thought to make up for it at least in part. I’d rather we parted in kindness, Thorin, though I know some things cannot be forgiven.”
At each word, Thorin's face twisted until finally he said, “Enough!” He paused at Bilbo’s flinch, and held up a mollifying hand, his manner softening. “You shame me with your words, Master Baggins. For all the ill that has come between us I… realize I have wronged you. I cannot say I am not angry with you still, likely I will be for many years hence. This anger it… is like a living thing inside of me, like nothing I have ever known.” Thorin frowned to himself, as if troubled by his own words. “But know that as much as I can, I forgive you for any wrong you may have brought me or my house, and can only hope that one day you might find it in yourself to forgive me in turn.”
Bilbo blinked, unsure of what he was hearing. But Thorin did indeed look properly ashamed, hunched in on himself under his cloak. He was a far cry from the terror that had shaken Bilbo on the parapet and called him a descendent of rats. Why, Bilbo had seen children caught with their hand in the cookie jar that were less miserable. He seemed barely strong enough to hold himself upright at the moment. Still.
“You were terribly rude up there, you know. I was frightened quite out of my wits, ” Bilbo said. “But, all things considered, I… suppose you had your reasons. I too could have had a bit more tact, and there really is no excuse for stealing. I should know, having been a victim many times myself from certain relatives. A far as I’m concerned the matter is forgiven and forgotten, and if we never need to bring it up again, it will be too soon.”
“So easily?” Thorin said with a frown. “I expected it would take many years for you to forgive the harm I might have caused you up there and…just now.”
Bilbo huffed out a sigh. “Well, we Hobbits are not one to hold grudges.” Relatively speaking, he added mentally.
“A soft and fickle people, then,” Thorin muttered, but immediately seemed guilty at his own words.
“Practical, and not prone to throwing our lives and health away on old disputes better left in the past,” Bilbo retorted. “Certainly we are not as stubborn as certain dwarves I could name, though some of my kind make a good attempt at it.” Bilbo looked down at his teacup, noting with some annoyance that it had gone cold long ago, and he without tasting a drop. “Seems a bit hypocritical in any case: you just forgave me quickly enough.”
“You’ve done enough to earn a lifetime of forgiveness, Master Baggins,” Thorin said softly. “I’m only sorry that I ever forgot that.”
“I…yes, well,” Bilbo began. Thorin was looking up at him now from beneath dark lashes; his head tilted so the black scales up his cheek were hidden in shadow. The blue light shining from his eyes seemed to have faded, or perhaps been overpowered by the firelight and Thorin’s skin had taken on a ruddier glow, less the ghostly pallor that had been there when Bilbo first saw him. Bilbo felt himself blush to be looking so closely. “Does this mean I’m no longer banished from Erebor?’
“It’s already a poor exile if you can walk in by the back door,” Thorin said, with a faint smile that made Bilbo wonder if he should move away from the fire, it was indeed quite warm.
“Then might we not walk out of it now?” Bilbo said, feeling a bit reckless and Tookish, but the prospect of the errand proving far simpler than he expected caused a rush of giddiness. He offered his hand to Thorin.
And, wonder of wonders, Thorin looked at Bilbo’s hand and his own appeared from within the folds of the cloak, hovering above Bilbo’s. Then he paused. The snap and pop of the fire filled the silence. Thorin was staring down at his own hand, the black scales wrapped around his wrists and trailing up his hand like a choking vine. Talons glinted in the firelight at the end of his fingertips. Then he retracted his hand and it sank back to his side, and Bilbo’s heart sank with it. Thorin shook his head. “I cannot.”
“Thorin, you have been ill, the others will understand,” Bilbo said with a sigh. “No one is going to blame you.”
“An illness? That’s all you think this is?” Thorin said incredulously. He stood then and pushed back the hood and tossed the edge of his cloak from his shoulders. He wore only black trousers beneath it, his feet were bare, and if Bilbo made a somewhat undignified squeaking sound it was quickly swallowed by his subsequent gasp of alarm. The flickering light cast deep shadows over gleaming scales scratched in a jagged line from above Thorin’s left eye, down his cheek and throat where it spread out in great ragged patches across hard plains of his bare chest, the skin dry and curled at the edges like burnt paper. In his rush to grant Thorin a cloak, Bilbo had not noticed how far the diseased flesh had spread.
He moved closer, probing at the Thorin’s chest with the tip of his fingers and found the scales dry and smooth, like snakeskin, and the deep black of their hue perfectly matched Thorin’s hair, as if the scales were an extension of his coloring. Thorin’s own pale flesh was dry at the edges and…hot, fevered even and it was only when this thought registered that he realized his face was inches from Thorin’s chest and that Thorin was watching him but had done nothing to stop Bilbo’s inspection.
“If it’s not an illness, what is it?” Bilbo said, and was quite proud that he did not stutter as he pulled away.
“A curse. Some parting gift from Smaug to ensnare any who tries to reclaim the gold,” Thorin said. He pulled the cloak back over his shoulders in a strangely self-conscious move, concealing his body again, though the hood remained down. “I know not for certain, I know only that I lacked the strength to resist it. I cannot face my people like this. Twisted, rotting from within…” Helpless frustration contorted Thorin’s face. “And if it is a punishment? For my crimes against you, and against my kin. Like a dragon I have behaved, so a dragon I have become?” The distant look had returned to Thorin’s eyes, panic that seemed to take him far away, and he stared as if contemplating some unimaginable horror.
Bilbo’s heart twisted, for it seemed wrong that one who had always been so fearless should wear such a look of terror. “Listen to me. Listen, Thorin. There is a cure for this, I’m sure of it. You think this is a curse? Then we should go to Gandalf, he will know what to do.”
Thorin jerked away at Gandalf’s name, the lost look instantly replaced by fury. The glow of his eyes snapped alight, bathing his face in its ghostly pallor. “I will not go begging on my knees for aid from that old traitor.”
“No one said anything about begging,” Bilbo said. “But, unless you’ve forgotten, he is the only wizard for hundreds of miles.”
“He sent my father to his death on a hopeless quest to regain our home, and abandoned us to the mercy of the Elves, twice. What purpose he had in in aiding us I know not, but it was not for our benefit. Even now he takes the side of our enemies against us. No, I have been blind too long to the wiles of that wizard, I will not seek him now,” Thorin snapped.
“Thorin, that’s insane,” Bilbo sighed. But at his words Thorin’s back stiffened and something passed over his face that looked like…fear. And Bilbo remembered then a conversation overheard long ago, about the strain of madness that ran in Thorin’s family, and backpeddled frantically. “If you will not see Gandalf, then what do you propose? We only have supplies for a fortnight after all.”
“We?” Thorin said. But the fear had been replaced by relief, and some of the shadow and anger left his face, which in turn calmed Bilbo immensely.
“Of course! I was sent here with a job to do, after all, and I think you have been down here alone long enough,” Bilbo said. He meant it all quite matter-of-fact but trailed off at Thorin’s expression, for he was staring as if Bilbo had said something quite extraordinary. It was all the hobbit could do to keep from fidgeting beneath that gaze. Then Thorin seemed to catch himself and looked back over his shoulder at the hoard.
“This cannot be the first time such a malady has afflicted my kind. There may be some record of it in our archives,” Thorin said then a memory seemed to occur to him for he snuck a glance back at Bilbo and continued sheepishly “Unless you wish to rest first?”
“Well, if we’re going to be down here for some time, it would make sense to form a more permanent camp,” Bilbo said, nodding to the sea of gold on which their small campfire sat haphazardly. “And it has been a long day, a bit of rest would not go amiss.”
“Then that is what we will do,” Thorin said with a nod to himself. He hesitated and Bilbo nearly jumped out of his skin as Thorin patted a hand against his shoulder. “Thank you.”
And perhaps in that moment the memory finally fell away, of Thorin’s face twisted in anger, of the cold wind and the stone whirling beneath his feet, and took its place firmly in the past. Bilbo smiled tentatively back. “Think nothing of it.”
II
Eyes I dare not meet in dreams
In death's dream kingdom
