Chapter Text
Thus began a routine that could have been called domestic if not for their surroundings. Bilbo suggested they move their small campsite to the platform above the treasury, as for a multitude of reasons he was wary of remaining so close to the gold and it hardly made a comfortable resting place. Thorin grumbled at this but complied. Once there, Bilbo set aside the foodstuffs in neat piles and selected from the hoard a beautifully wrought iron tripod, carved with knotwork patterns and mysterious dwarven runes, to serve as their fireplace. Thorin helped drag it up the stairs, and together they placed it in the center of the camp.
He had just laid out the bedrolls when Thorin returned, depositing an armful of tinder and a wide-mouthed bucket of black rocks at the edge of the living space Bilbo had prepared for them.
“Charcoal?” Bilbo said, peering into the bucket and brushing his finger over one of the rocks. It came away black with coal dust.
“From the forges,” Thorin said shortly, taking a seat on one of the bedrolls. “Far more efficient than broken furniture. Once I get it started they will burn for days.”
“If we can get them hot enough. I seem to recall forge coals require a great deal more heat to light,” Bilbo said. “I should have a tinderbox here somewhere. I hope it will be enough” He turned back to the mostly empty pack, and sure enough there was a simple copper box hiding at the bottom, which he handed it to Thorin.
Thorin snorted. “Getting them hot enough will be no great task. A dwarven infant could have these white hot before he knew how to walk.”
“Oh course, how silly of me to forget for even a moment that you’re all obsessed with smithing,” Bilbo said, rolling his eyes. “Just let me know if I can be of help.”
“Thanks to our obsession, as you put it, I have lit and probably built more forges than you have days in your life. I doubt there is much you can do aid me,” Thorin said, turning his attention to the brazier, dumping the charcoal into the basin and setting to work with the tinder and thus did not see Bilbo making a face at him behind his back. Bilbo sobered though, as a thought occurred to him.
“Even here in Erebor?” Bilbo said. “All those seemed fairly well constructed to me.”
“No, not here,” Thorin said as he struck the flint and steel together. They sparked immediately and the tinder branches caught within a matter of seconds, Bilbo noted with some admiration. It usually took him several attempts when getting his own hearth going. “Lighting the forge is the first job of a blacksmith when he begins his day. But in Erebor…” Thorin paused, exhaled, and some of the tension bled out of him as he remembered where they stood. “Here, the forges were never cold except for repairs. And there were hundreds at work, at all hours. The hammers of our smiths fell day and night, like ringing bells.” There was reverence in Thorin’s voice as he spoke. Then his expression hardened. “No, the forges of Erebor needed little help from me. It was the forges of Men, poor things barely hot enough for pig iron, that were my lot in the years of our exile. I wrung what craft I could from them, but for little purpose but to mend crude pots, nails, horseshoes…” Thorin fairly snarled the last. The fire was spreading beneath his hand with remarkable speed, though the forge coals had not yet caught.
“Even if you left the mountain in haste, wouldn’t you have had some gold and jewels with you? Even the smallest of these gems would be enough to set up any hobbit for years, if he could find anyone with enough gold to buy it from him,” said Bilbo.
“Hardly,” Thorin said, and seemed to be biting back a further retort, possibly regarding the lives of Hobbits. Instead he took a moment to blow more heat into the kindling. “Much went to buying food and shelter in those first years, at exorbitant prices. There were thousands of us, and our need was obvious, so in all places we were overcharged. My family did what we had to to keep our people alive.” Bilbo went quiet as he absorbed this, imagining long trains of dwarves, their raiment still blackened from the dragon fire, crossing the landscape with their wagons, bringing with them what belongings had been on hand during the attack.
“Still, with so many of you on the road I shouldn’t think a prince would need to stoop to such work,” Bilbo said. “I remember the wandering dwarven smiths that came to the Shire when I was lad. They seemed a rough bunch. I find it hard to imagine you among them.”
“I may well have been,” said Thorin with a grimace. His voice grew harsh with memory. “We always needed more hands. They were dark times, when all beauty was robbed from us, leaving only drudgery.”
Bilbo thought of his warm hobbit hole, where no danger or want had ever touched him. He had once ventured out from there when the lock on the door jammed, hoping to bring it to one of the dwarven smiths passing through the town. Tinkers, the Hobbits called them, and he had rushed to and from their shop as quickly as possible, not even looking them in the eye when he paid the fee for their work. They had been a fearsome bunch, with wild beards and piercing gazes. Or so he had imagined, he had been too afraid to look them in the eye. Had one of those dwarves been Thorin all those years ago? The lock had worked beautifully after that, and never jammed again. He had never really taken the time to admire the marvelous craftsmanship that had gone into it, only felt relief that it meant he’d never have to interact again with those big, fearsome folk. In truth he felt a rush of shame now at the memory, and reached out without thinking to pat Thorin on the shoulder. “All in the past now.”
Bilbo’s brow furrowed. The fire had not yet caught, yet heat radiated through the fabric draped over Thorin's shoulders. It was an intense heat at that, more than feverish, akin touching the door of a stove. Bilbo pulled his hand back and only then saw Thorin’s expression.
The dwarf was hunched over the fire and his hands…his hands were clutching the edges of the tripod, though the metal must be searing hot. Thorin’s eyes were wide, wild, and unseeing, and his breath came in great panting gasps. The muscles in his arms spasmed as if he would tear the iron apart with his bare hands. Then before Bilbos’s eyes, Thorin’s fingers clenched and there was the shriek of metal as his claws tore deep furrows into the iron. Bilbo’s head jerked up to gaze on Thorin’s face. His teeth were gritted in a silent snarl. Had Bilbo been mistaken before when he thought the black scales went only to Thorin’s brow? Now they ran in a jagged line up the left side of his face, all the way to his hairline.
“Thorin, Thorin!” Bilbo said in alarm, dashing around the brazier to stand in front of Thorin, the fire flickering between them. “It’s all right, it’s over! You’re home now, you’re safe!”
“Over?” Thorin said. His voice held the grate of cracking stone. “Vultures sit before our gates, waiting to pick over the corpses of our dead, they who only hindered us in our quest, and would not raise a finger to aid us when we wandered in starvation and poverty, and you would tell me it’s over?” The tripod trembled beneath his hands and Bilbo took a step back, thinking it would be torn asunder in a shower of fire and charcoal. Yet a greater heat seemed to radiate from Thorin himself and the blue of his gaze burned with its own flame. The black scales of his forearms caught the light as the gray flesh at the edges cracked and flaked. “You, you…!”
A change came over Thorin’s face, and rage gave way to nausea. His face turned a peculiar shade of green beneath the ruddy cast of the flames. “Get away from me,” he choked.
“Thorin, what are you…?” Bilbo said.
“I said, get away!” Thorin reached over the flames, grabbing Bilbo by the collar then jerked his arm, flinging Bilbo across the polished stone floor where he skidded, stopping just feet from the edge of the platform. Bilbo scrambled away from the edge on his hands and knees, sputtering protests, but Thorin wasn’t listening. He was hunched over the flames, his eyes squeezed shut, sweat glinting on his forehead. Then without warning he doubled over and fire exploded from his lips, whirling across the coals. They flared white with heat as they caught, raising a gout of black smoke into the air.
Thorin tumbled back, falling to the floor, and curled in on himself as he was wracked by a coughing fit. When the storm passed he looked up, eyes red-rimmed from the exertion, gazing over the flames at Bilbo. For a moment there was only the cheerful crackling of the fire as they stared at one another.
“Well, that is one way to start a fire,” Bilbo remarked. And well, what else could he do? For if he started screaming now, he was fairly certain he would never stop.
Thorin tilted his head at Bilbo’s words and gave him a look of stunned incredulity, mouth slightly agape and brow furrowed. He appeared to be struggling for words to respond to what appeared to be the most inane sentence he had ever heard. As he could not see his own expression, he likely did not understand the reason why Bilbo swiftly clamped a hand over his own mouth, or the choked sounds that escaped as a hysterical giggle.
“I’m sorry, it’s just… this really is a fine mess, and no mistake,” Bilbo said. Thorin bristled, pulling the hood of the cloak over his head from where it had fallen back during his convulsions, then rose to his feet, walking towards the stairs.
“No, wait, Thorin I didn’t mean…” Bilbo said, grabbing Thorin by the arms and stopping him as he tried to walk past.
“This is not your burden,” Thorin said, wrenching his arm back but Bilbo held on.
“I say,” Bilbo said, drawing himself straighter, “it most certainly is! And I can hardly be expected to do nothing. Besides, a burden shared is a burden halved. Thorin,” he said as the dwarf looked away and again tried to free himself. “I will help you find a cure for this.”
“Where did you think I was going?” Thorin said.
“Oh, I don’t know, probably to go sit in a corner somewhere and brood, though I’m sure you’d look quite majestic as you did so. Was I entirely wrong?”
Thorin’s hardened lips drew to a thin line that told Bilbo he had not missed his mark. “If you must know, I thought to go first on my own to search the archives. I see no more point in waiting.”
“A likely story,” Bilbo said. “Very well, it is a good plan and quicker accomplished with two. In the meantime though, I imagine you’re hungry after emptying your stomach like that. Let me make us up a packed lunch first.”
“I’m not hungry,” Thorin said. “And you cannot read Khuzdûl. It would be a pointless exercise.”
“First of all, I don’t believe you. You’ve been down here for days with only a cup of tea in you, unless Smaug had a hidden larder somewhere. Second, who says all the books will be in dwarvish? I speak Westron, and know some Sindarin from my mother; it may be that the other races know more of this malady than yours.” Thorin glowered and Bilbo interrupted him with a flap of his hands. “Or not! But I won’t wait here while you go wandering off into the dark. Besides, you would actually have to tie me up in a sack to stop me,” Bilbo reminded him.
“A tempting offer,” Thorin said, and Bilbo might have huffed in annoyance if not for the faint smile teasing the corner of his lips. “Very well, pack your lunch and let us be off.”
Bilbo nodded, then dashed over to the now empty pack, tossing in a few apples, cheese, bread and cured sausages, remembering the dwarven distaste for any food that didn’t involve meat. He might make some sandwiches once in the library, he did not risk making them now for fear Thorin might take off. Only at the last minute did he remember to include a few candles along with the tinderbox. He did not fancy the idea of having to wander the vast caverns of Erebor on his own, or waiting around an empty camp for Thorin to return when the dwarf had already shown a talent for disappearing for days on end.
“Ready,” he said. Thorin nodded and together they set off into the dark, passing out of the gold treasure room of Thrór into the winding caverns of the underground city.
The halls were dark, almost too dark for Bilbo to navigate but Thorin moved through them unerringly. When Bilbo lagged behind, uncertain where to step without tumbling into the fathomless distance below, and could not help but wonder why dwarves seemed so averse to railings, Thorin grabbed him by the wrist and pulled him onward without looking back. His hand was warm, too warm by Bilbo’s thinking, and together they navigated what felt like miles past great bronze doors and pillared halls. There were even some fountains that still trickled, adding the silvery pling of water to the underground breeze that seemed to come from everywhere and nowhere at once. Bilbo tried not to look too closely at the scattered mounds of cloth and dust, though whether out of fear for what he might see or respect for the dead he could not bear to examine.
“We’re here,” Thorin said, stopping before a great arch that once held double doors, before they had been torn from their hinges and smashed to kindling on the floor. Bilbo stepped gingerly around the wreckage, and coughed as dust assaulted his nose on the other side, waving his hand to clear the air.
Then he stopped, mouth falling open as his eyes adjusted to the better light. Somewhere high above tiny holes like stars had been drilled into the ceiling then covered with glass, allowing natural light to filter down. It caught the dust motes hanging in the air, making them appear as chains of golden light, solid enough to touch. And beyond, beyond…
Books. Shelves climbing to the ceilings, and stretching away from his as far as the eye could see, stacks of scrolls and tablets too. The walls were covered in intricate patterns and engraved runes, while solemn statues of dwarves held the ceilings above on their shoulders, and smaller statues of marble and alabaster filled the alcoves. Unlike all the other statues Bilbo had seen, these did not carry axes or swords. The one closest to the door had a forked beard and in one hand held a scroll and in the other a tablet. Further down a statue of what he thought might be a dwarven woman held a hammer and tongs. Between them was an empty alcove, deep claw marks like knife wounds scrawled into the stone. Bilbo thought he might guess what had once stood there: statues of gold and precious metal, looted by Smaug to be added to the greater hoard.
“Thorin,” Bilbo breathed as his head tilted back and he looked up, up, up to the dome above. “This is magnificent!”
“Yet much diminished since last I saw it,” Thorin murmured. Bilbo turned to him and saw his face was shadowed by a deep, abiding grief. When Bilbo looked back to the library he saw it then, that which had been hidden by glory on his first glimpse. Fallen shelves, shattered tablets, manuscripts torn and scattered across the floor. Dust coated every surface, and there were black scorch marks upon the walls.
“I’m sorry,” Bilbo said quietly. “It must have been truly glorious. I never would have guessed.”
“What do you mean?” said Thorin turning to him, puzzled.
“Well, except for Balin and Ori, none of you seemed a very scholarly bunch. But this library is bigger even than Lord Elrond’s!”
Thorin snorted and looked back to the shelves. “You would judge a people by their lowest point and think you have the measure of them? Erebor has one of the greatest libraries east of the sea; the only one greater was in Khazad-dûm, before it was lost. Even the cities of Men cannot compare.” There was no mistaking the pride in his voice. “We record everything: our histories, building techniques, art, engineering… Unlike Elves, we cannot depend on memory or long lives to protect our knowledge. When the last dwarf falls he will do so with a book in hand, recording the names and deeds of all who fell before him.”
Bilbo shivered at the image. “It’s just…when I said I would help you I did not, could not imagine it would be so huge! I have one of the largest libraries in the Shire and it would not fill one of these shelves. How will we begin to find what we need? Do you know the author’s name?” he said looked out over the ruined expanse with dismay.
Thorin looked at him askance. “We won’t need it, the library has its own organization system of which the author’s name is only a small part. So long as it has not been destroyed, we should have no trouble.” He shook his head. “Honestly, organizing a library by author? No wonder Men cannot keep any decent records, they must always be losing what they’ve wrought.” With that he wandered over to a corner Bilbo had not heretofore noticed, and pulled out a set of shelves filled with…tablets? There were runes inscribed on them that Bilbo could not read. Thorin skimmed them once, then opened a second shelf reading whatever was written there quickly, before shutting both and setting off towards the stacks.
“Wait, aren’t you going to look at the others too?” Bilbo said, trotting after him.
“No need. The information could only be amongst the histories, specifically those accounts which deal with the sacking of dwarven cities by dragons.”
“You could tell all of that with one look?” Bilbo exclaimed.
“It is a numeric system, each subject is divided by number, with subcategories within based on the era or topic. I needed only to refresh my memory. For that matter, what histories we have in the language of Elves and Men are on the way, so you may set to work as well,” said Thorin without breaking stride.
“A numeric system, imagine that! I have never heard of such a thing,” Bilbo marveled. For he was in fact a scholar at heart and found himself strangely excited by the idea. Why, how efficient it would be for larger collections! All that he had seen were done by the name of the author, or of the work if none was known, which meant beyond a certain point it became impossible to find anything if one didn’t already know what they were looking for. He had tried introducing a few different organization systems, which only made matters worse. To think the dwarves had come up with something so clever! Well, he supposed he should not be surprised.
Many of the shelves had tumbled with time or by Smaug’s destruction, their contents scattered over the floor, but a remarkable number remained standing and untouched save for a thick layer of dust. Thorin stopped before of one of them. “Here lie the histories of Elves and Men. I wish you luck.”
“For your sake I hope I have it,” Bilbo replied, and squared his shoulders as he looked to the great carven shelf that carried mostly scrolls, some of them with silken tassels hanging from the ends, or wrapped around ornate carven rods. There was an elvish feel to it that set the works apart from the rest of the library.
“You are certain you won’t have any trouble?”
“I’ll be fine,” Bilbo said, and cracked his knuckles.
“Some of those are very high up, would you like me to find you something to stand on? A stool, perhaps, or a box?”
“I climbed higher than I like to remember up a burning pine tree, I imagine a bookshelf should pose no difficulty,” said Bilbo dryly.
He heard a soft whuffing sound and was glad his face was turned so that Thorin could not see how hard he was grinning in response to the dwarf’s quiet chuckling. “There are quite a lot of books,” Thorin observed.
“Which means that for the first time in this whole blasted journey, I am actually set to a task at which I have some experience. You have more to go through than I, shouldn’t you be going?”
“Indeed,” Thorin laughed, and strode off down the hall and out of sight.
These do not appear:
There, the eyes are
Sunlight on a broken column
There, is a tree swinging
