Actions

Work Header

Prayers to Broken Stone

Chapter 8

Notes:

This chapter, like the previous one, makes mention of several events, people, places, and stories from the wider Tolkien canon. Below you can find a list of these terms, including a link to their LotR Wiki article.

People
Fram, Lord of the Éothéod - Scatha the Dragon

Events
The Fall of Gondolin

Other Works
The  Children of Húrin - a tale that has as much to do with inspiring this fic as The Hobbit itself. I highly recommend the audiobook, read by Christopher Lee. 

Not referenced specifically in this chapter, but this is as good a place as any to mention it: the idea of dwarves becoming dragons originally appears in The Volsunga Saga, which was one of Tolkien's inspirations for The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings. In it, a dwarf named Fáfnir is transformed into a dragon by his love of gold, and this in turn was part of the inspiration for the idea that dwarves may be to dragons what elves are to orcs in this fic. 

As a final note, I intend to post a music playlist for this fic at some point, but the song "Little Talks" by Of Monsters and Men, as covered by Alexi Blue & Corey Gray was really instrumental for me in writing this portion of Thorin and Bilbo's relationship, and in general it's an amazing song, so I highly recommend a listen.

Chapter Text

The conversation with Thorin had been so pleasant that Bilbo momentarily forgot the reason for their presence here: namely, that of Thorin’s alarming transformation. Instead, he was excited at the prospect of finally being tasked with work at which he had some skill. He first began by sorting out which titles were likely to contain any history of dragons, careful to mark their locations so they may be properly returned. He did not wish to earn the wrath of the next librarian of Erebor, for if all went well he’d like to spend considerable time amongst these shelves, perhaps one day even adding a book of his own to the hallowed collection. A tempting thought, but he was getting ahead of himself.

He started first with the lowest section of the shelves, for despite his bravado to Thorin, he would rather put off climbing to the highest ones if it could at all be avoided. Unfortunately, the dwarves’ efficient system seemed to have broken down somewhat in this section, and there was no rhyme or reason to the sorting as far as language went. They all seemed to be arranged first only as “Not Khuzdûl” and then based on subject, so Westron, Sindarin, and even Quenya works sat side by side. He lit the candles and set to work, skimming the pages and unraveling scrolls, his eyes scanning for key words like “drake”, “dragon”, or “wyrm” in the books in Westron, and “lhûg” and “amlug” in the Sindarin works. Many times he had to stop himself from reading them cover-to-cover, for they held such a wealth of information that he could hardly contain himself.

Still, after a few minutes he would inevitably put the book or scroll aside with a sigh and return to his search. He found more than one account on the Fall of Gondolin, in which dragons had played a major role, various translations on the tragedy of the Children of Húrin, and a reference in a Gondorian work about the Rohirrim to a Lord of the Éothéod, Fram, who was killed by dwarves over a dispute regarding the dragon Scatha’s hoard. He marked that one as of special interest and set it aside.

It seemed no time at all had passed, indeed, the sun still poured through the chinks of glass in the ceiling, when he heard the tread of feet. Looking up from what was proving to be an unhelpful book of Sindarin poetry, wherein a rather self-important poet distinguished his own love of silver from a dragon’s love of gold, Bilbo espied Thorin walking toward him.

“Oh, Thorin! So soon? I only have a few promising leads. You know, we should have brought our packs with us; it makes far more sense to set up camp here as we work, and…my goodness, I imagine you must be hungry! I had completely forgotten in the excitement. I should have at least sent you along with a few of those apples; what in the world was I thinking? Thorin…Thorin?” Bilbo trailed off, for Thorin was hunched over and shivering within his cloak.

“Bilbo?” Thorin said as if coming out of a dream. “How are you here?”

The dwarf was drawn and pale, not just from the graying effect of the curse, and he flinched when Bilbo moved. Bilbo set aside the scroll and slowly stood, approaching Thorin with his hands open and visible, as if he were a wild animal that might bolt.

“I’m here to help you. We came to the library looking for a cure, remember?” Thorin met Bilbo’s eye. The blue glow was back and stronger than ever, washing his cheeks in a ghostly light. While the black scars had grown no worse, a greater swath of the skin visible beneath his cloak had taken on the grayish hue that preceded the emergence of scales.

“I have to go back,” Thorin said in a hiss. Bilbo realized with a start that the hiss was because Thorin’s teeth were chattering so hard he could barely speak, though sweat glinted on his brow.

“Fine, fine, we’ll go back, just let me put these away. Did you manage to find anything in your section?” But Thorin was already moving past him, towards the door. With a muttered curse, Bilbo blew out the candles, leaving them on the floor, and tossed the most promising books and scrolls into the pack. He winced at their ill treatment, but if Thorin got out of his sight he might not be able to find his way back to their camp. Once packed, Bilbo took off after Thorin, bare feet slapping against the polished stone as he ran. For all that Thorin was only going at a brisk walk, his stride was longer than Bilbo’s and he had nearly vanished out the crumbling door before Bilbo caught up to him.

Thorin seemed not to notice he was there, neither pausing nor acknowledging Bilbo at all as he drew alongside, and no attempt to get his attention succeeded. For a long stretch there was only silence and a clicking sound that Bilbo soon realized were the hooked talons that had sprouted in place of Thorin’s toenails. For some reason, that was the most unsettling part of it all. The scales, the glowing eyes, even the fire Bilbo had been able to take in stride. Perhaps because, all things considered, it rather resembled a bizarre bout of the flu. Bilbo had tended the ill before: discolored skin and vomiting were all part of the unpleasant package.

But to see Thorin without his heavy boots, his feet so pale and delicate compared to those of hobbits? And then to see them end in dark talons that clicked upon the ground with every step? The combination of the unseen with the unbelievable twisted Bilbo’s gut and somewhere higher in what felt like heartbreak. It was wrong, terribly wrong, to see Thorin so exposed and yet so twisted beyond recognition at the same time.

It struck Bilbo then, all at once, what he had been trying to avoid thinking about since he first came down into Erebor: the horrible, aching pit of worry and fear that opened inside him when he first saw Thorin like this. To see him trapped in a prison of his own body, that final place of refuge stolen from him… it was more than he could bear. He felt sick at the sight, worse even than the rage in Thorin’s eyes on the wall, when Bilbo had looked at him and seen no trace of the person he knew.

They burst into the treasure chamber, and Thorin slouched against the doorframe with a groan of relief at the sight of the gold and gems reflecting the light back a thousand times. It was like the moment at the hidden door all over again, when the very sight and smell of Erebor bled years of tension from Thorin all at once. Yet even while this moment appeared as fair, it felt foul. True, the sight of the treasure eased Thorin, but as it did something predatory came over him. He moved forward with the powerful, slinking motions of a stalking cat as he descended the stairs and stepped out onto the dunes of gold, climbing them with surprising stealth. Bilbo bit his lip, torn between following straightaways after Thorin and returning to their campsite, from where he might be able to survey the whole room.

His heart won out over his head, and he took off after Thorin. Bilbo scrambled over gold and around fallen pillars as he stumbled after the dwarf, who moved over the treasure as if it were no more shifting or treacherous than the stone floor. Thorin seemed to have some destination in mind, for he moved straight and sure.

“Oh for pity’s…!” Bilbo cried, thinking the dwarf had given him the slip as Thorin mounted the top of one of the steeper piles and vanished. But when Bilbo managed to climb the top of the dune himself, he looked down to see a crater that had formed amongst the gold. In that moment, he recalled when Smaug had awakened, and the great bowl left when he dragged his bulk free of the treasure. This may well be the same place, for Bilbo recognized some angles of the room from that vantage point, made sharp in his memory by the terror he had felt on seeing a great yellow eye peering at him from under the hoard.

Thorin was at the center of the crater, fallen to all fours. His hands were drawn into fists, gold coins spilling out from between his fingers, and his chest heaved as if from some great exertion. With some care, Bilbo set himself on the lip of the crater and skidded down on his heels, coins pinging off one another as he slid.

Thorin looked up at his arrival. The tension was gone from his bearing, the harsh lines of his face smoothed. A beatific smile spread across his lips and had Bilbo not known any better, he would have said Thorin was drunk, or drugged. The sight was wholly unsettling; for Bilbo had never seen Thorin breach that tight control he kept over himself, always remaining sober and aloof even while the rest of the company drank and made merry.

“Do you feel it, Halfling?” Thorin purred.

“I would thank you to not call me that. My name will do well enough,” Bilbo grumbled, but anxiety surged through him as he looked about the crater. There was indeed a feeling here, a miasma. He felt a flush rising to his cheeks, but not a pleasant one. It was a feeling like sitting too close to a stove, as if the gold itself radiated heat.

“It is warm here.” Thorin sighed, sweeping his hands over the coins. They jingled against one another as he did so, and Thorin smiled at the sound.

“I imagine it is. After all, if I don’t miss my guess,” Bilbo said, with another exaggerated look around the crater, “this is where Smaug slept. We should move away from here. I think this place may be cursed.”

Thorin’s eyes narrowed and the smile fell. “Move away?”

“Well, I once heard that the gold of a dragon’s bed may carry,” Thorin fixed him with so ferocious a glare that Bilbo’s voice trembled and he nearly sputtered over his words, “many fell enchantments.”

“I will not abandon the gold of my forefathers,” Thorin said, and something snapped in Bilbo.

“But this isn’t the gold of your forefathers!” Bilbo hissed, and pointed at their feet. “It’s gold that has sat under the belly of a dragon for over a hundred years. It’s the reason you’re turning into a monster!”

The words hung in the air between them, gone beyond recall. And Thorin looked at him, as if seeing him now for the first time, as if something had clicked back into place within him. He stared about with some bewilderment, as if not knowing where he was or how he got there. Bilbo watched with rising panic as his words filtered into Thorin’s consciousness. Monster.

 “I-I’m sorry, Thorin, I didn’t mean…”

“But it’s true,” Thorin said. Bilbo could have kicked himself then because he had finally wandered right into it, blabbing aloud what they had both been so carefully avoiding this past day. For naming it only made it so much worse, it dropped all pretense that this was a simple malady that could be cured. A monster?

“You are afraid of me. There is no need to disguise it,” Thorin continued. Bilbo’s face fell, and in him keened that screaming kettle feeling, that Thorin was slipping away from him and would soon retreat into himself beyond recall, and all his locked-up words came out in a rush.

“Of course I’m afraid! You’ve got bloody great talons at the end of your fingers, and you spit fire when you’re angry, literally now! It was only luck that you didn’t roast me up or tear me to pieces when I walked in the door!” But Thorin was withdrawing into himself with every word and it all broke upon Bilbo at once: in his fright he was babbling all the wrong things. He stopped, and took a deep breath, then crouched down so that he was facing Thorin on the same level. He stilled his breath and forced his voice to softness. The truth, just the truth, that’s what was needed here. “But… but more than any of that, I’m afraid for you, Thorin. How could I not be?”

“A simple matter,” Thorin said, without meeting Bilbo’s probing look. “You could leave this place, return to your home and think nothing further of it. It would be the better option, when there is no hope.”

Bilbo thought he might become frantic with frustration then, that they must rehash this argument of whether he should stay or go, that he must have yet another face-off with Thorin’s stubbornness, only now when he has said something truly unforgivable. Then he caught himself. The growl in Thorin’s voice that he had taken for anger, leveled at him again but this time for good reason, had an edge to it that was wholly unfamiliar. He looked closer at Thorin and saw then the tremble in his jaw, the way his hands opened and closed compulsively around the gold in a self-comforting gesture, the tiny shivers that wracked him. Bilbo’s heart sank as the picture came together in a flash of insight.

This was not about him, not even about what he had said. Bilbo had touched on something deeper, something that was tearing Thorin apart from the inside, and as usual Thorin was trying to hide it beneath that stoic veneer rather than simply ask for help. Bilbo settled fully onto the ground, and edged closer. “Thorin, what happened in the library?”

“You cannot possibly understand,” Thorin said, but there was no scorn in his voice, only anguish, and desperation.

“Just tell me,” Bilbo said soothingly. “I promise I will believe you.”

Thorin released an explosive gasp that ended in a shudder. He pressed a hand to his temple, looking away as he gathered his composure, and Bilbo saw that if Thorin had any calm left it hung by a thread, and that was fraying. “How can you when I do not believe it myself? I… saw things. Heard things. I…Bilbo.” Thorin looked up, eyes wide with naked terror. “I think I’m losing my mind.”

“No. No,” Bilbo said automatically, “you’re not, it’s… just tell me what you saw, alright? We’ll just talk this through. There are quite enough strange things happening in this place that we need not jump to conclusions.”

“You weren’t there,” Thorin said, and at first Bilbo thought he meant in the library, which he was about to assure Thorin he most certainly had been, when Thorin continued, as if each word was dragged from his body. “You weren’t there, you were somewhere…far away. I could not find you. There was only the mountain, and the gold, and… shadows. I could hear them, across all these years I could hear them screaming in the dark as he broke and remade them, and I could feel that touch in my mind.”

A chill swept through Bilbo that felt as if all the hair from the back of his neck down to his furry feet stood on end, and his hand went reflexively to the ring in his pocket, though he stilled it quickly. There was no use for invisibility here; how odd that he should seek it at a time like this. He swallowed, and said in as steady and measured a tone as he could manage, “Thorin, this is… a little difficult to follow. I need you to start from the beginning. Who…who was screaming?”

“The Nauglath,” Thorin said, and Bilbo’s brow crinkled at the unfamiliar word. “This happened to them first, there, in the pits. And they welcomed it. They were weak and he made them strong, even though he broke them, though he destroyed them. It was better than dying in disgrace and poverty, and they knew the end would come whatever they did. But their rage…there is no end to it, it will live a thousand-thousand years and what is worse… what is worse…” Thorin gave a shudder that rocked him crown to toe. “I cannot blame them for it.”

Bilbo tried to keep his bewilderment from his face, for Thorin was agitated, almost maddened by the words he spoke. Yet the hobbit could not follow the thread of Thorin’s words at all, save that some great crime had been committed and Thorin sympathized with the wronged party. But all this talk of breaking and dying and rage… it sent a wave of horror through him even as he struggled to understand.

“They were our kin,” Thorin groaned. “And we did nothing. We turned our back on them while they died in droves, and we can never make amends. Don’t you see?” he said, fixing wild eyes on Bilbo. “The sickness of my line is their curse. Without a dragon's presence it cannot break us, it only drives us mad with sickness. But it waits, it waits in our blood and bone, it waits for them. Then they find us, in our mountains and fortresses, they chase us forth and curse our treasure with their touch. In our wanderings we are made to understand their loss, pursued as they were from place to place. But it’s the gold, the gold is where they fulfill their curse, that is where they steal from us the beauty crafted by our hands, as it was stolen from them. That is how they make us like them, like this,” he cried and pressed one clawed hand against his chest, the curved points biting deep into his graying skin.

Bilbo winced and found he had scooted closer before he even realized what he did, pulling Thorin’s hand back from where it dug into his flesh. He gently clasped Thorin’s wrist between both hands, keeping the sharp points away from both of them.

“Careful with those,” Bilbo murmured absently as his mind whirled, searching for the right words for so delicate a situation. “Now Thorin, please, you must calm down. This is…this is good. I think. What you’re saying is that you now know the source of this?” Bilbo said, tapping at the scales that ran up Thorin’s hand. “That’s very good news. Look at me. I know it was terrible, and I’m very sorry it happened. But now that we know what this is, we can start looking for a cure.”

Thorin hunched over and would have pulled away entirely if not for Bilbo’s hands wrapped around his wrist. “Do you not understand? There is no cure.” 

Thorin’s words struck Bilbo like a blow to the stomach, rocking him back, but swiftly in its wake came a second wave, one of resolve. “No,” he said, and dropped the hand to take Thorin firmly by the shoulders, turning the dwarf to face him. Thorin stilled beneath his touch, some of his anguish giving way to simple surprise. “No, absolutely not. I did not follow you across a thousand leagues of mountains, rivers, goblins, and other nonsense for you to give up here. Do you understand me, Thorin Oakenshield? I simply will not have it.” Thorin blinked. “Now, I don’t know where you read… whatever it is that has you so upset, and I likely wouldn’t understand it if I did. Maybe it’s true, maybe it isn’t, but it is only the first lead we have and I would be a very poor scholar indeed if I let us take it at face-value.”

“Mîm’s account is thousands of years old. It is the only account,” Thorin protested.

“Then there have been thousands of years since for someone to find a cure. Years this Mîm fellow would know nothing about. Why, just look at how few dragons there are in the world. If it really spread as easily as you say, then we should be swarming with them. Mark my words, there is a cure out there somewhere, even in these very halls, and we will find it, or my name isn't Baggins.”

Thorin stilled at this, considering Bilbo’s words. As he did, his breathing eased and was no longer the harsh, frantic beat of a hunted animal. So too did the hard lines of stress in his shoulders ease. A long moment passed until he finally calmed and he said in a soft, halting voice, “Then… let us hope we will not have to find you another name.”

Bilbo blinked, mouthing the words back as they clicked into place. He looked at Thorin incredulously and saw that there was the faintest echo of a smile teasing the edge of his lips. The remaining healthy flesh of his face was bathed in sweat, and his whole body bore the frail, transparent quality of one who has not slept in days, but he seemed aware and present for the first time since they parted ways in the library. Bilbo gave his own shaky, joyful chuckle at the sight, but ended it with a fond groan. “Oh, goodness. If you’re delirious enough to make jokes than matters truly are worse than I realized.”

“Even I know it was a poor one,” Thorin admitted, his voice barely above a whisper. His head nodded, and he seemed on the edge of collapse.

“All the same, perhaps it would be best if we rested. It has been a long day for both of us,” Bilbo said. He released Thorin’s shoulders then, having only just realized he still held them, so natural did it seem to hold Thorin steady when he was afraid. Surely it was a thought he would have found shocking only a few months prior. Bilbo rose to his feet, offering his hand to Thorin. “Not here though, if it’s all the same to you. I rather miss our warm little campfire, and I’d hate to leave the food unattended any longer.”

“As if there was anyone to steal it. Only you,” Thorin said in a worn but bemused voice, “could sit in the middle of the greatest treasury in the world and value food more than hoarded gold.”

“My word, sarcasm as well as jokes?” Bilbo said, but Thorin shook his head.

“It was no mockery. There is some… goodness, and wisdom in you… that our situation makes all the more clear,” Thorin said. He took Bilbo’s hand and stood before the little flutter in Bilbo’s chest at his words had time to be acknowledged, much less to subside, and Bilbo found himself staring at Thorin longer than might be strictly appropriate. Thorin raised an eyebrow in return and said, “Shall we go?”

“Oh! Yes, but of course!” Bilbo said and, flustered, took off in the wrong direction. He only realized he still held Thorin’s wrist when he jerked them both back onto the right course, stammering apologies at the whiplash and saying over his shoulder, “Sorry, sorry! Sense of direction aside, we will find a way out of this, Thorin. Of that I am certain.”

His back turned, he did not see as the small, fond smile Thorin had worn at his stammering melt away. If he had, he would have seen the shadow that fell over Thorin’s face, and read in it clearly that he did not share Bilbo’s certainty.

 


Let me be no nearer
In death's dream kingdom
Let me also wear
Such deliberate disguises
Rat's coat, crowskin, crossed staves