Actions

Work Header

Prayers to Broken Stone

Chapter 9

Notes:

More terms for your perusal and entertainment! I do believe this is the last set:

People
Túrin Turambar, son of Húrin - Elu Thingol, King of Doriath

Places
Gondolin

This is also as good a place as any for a quick reminder to the audience: neither the characters nor the written accounts in this story are omniscient, and sometimes the accurate historical events of Middle-Earth are twisted and/or misunderstood by characters. I promise I know what I'm doing ;)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Nightmares plagued Thorin’s sleep. Waves of gold crashed against the rocks of Erebor like a tide, receding from him whenever he moved to touch them. Shadows flitted at the edge of his vision. He saw Fíli and Kíli, their faces drawn and white in death, and when he looked down and saw himself in broken armor, torn by many wounds, and the stench of blood in the air. Armies clashed, roaring their defiance as they fell upon one another, and a monstrous, pale figure tore a path through the heart of the mêlée, twisted iron replacing the stump of a hand, and death in his eyes.

Thorin’s throat dried and his stomach burned. He cried out and thought he heard Bilbo’s voice call back but the hobbit was nowhere to be seen, though he sounded near. Then Azog appeared before him and the great mace came crashing down...

Thorin jerked awake to the smell of fire and burning flesh. Panic seized him by the throat and he wrestled against bindings that trapped his arms to his sides. His head struck the ground as he struggled, finally forcing his eyes open and he looked up to see… the ceiling of Erebor. Thorin tilted his head to the side in puzzlement.

“Ah, you’re awake! I was beginning to worry,” Bilbo said cheerfully. There was the clink of iron against iron that set off every warning in Thorin’s head then—

Bilbo set a plate of sausages beside him.

“I can keep them warm next to the fire if you need a little time to wake up,” Bilbo said.

In that moment, Thorin’s true position became clear to him. He was wrapped up, true, but in a bedroll, and beneath that his blue cloak had tangled around his arms, and trapped them against his body. The smell of flames came from the iron brazier where Bilbo was currently cooking more food, what looked like sausages thrown together with sliced potatoes, mushrooms, tomatoes and turnips, mixed with some spice he could not identify.

“Wonderful stuff, these coals. Barely had to touch them and they stayed alive all while we slept and well into the day. I just added a few now to get it hot enough for the fry-up,” said Bilbo.

“You had to add more?” Thorin said incredulously. “Those coals should have burned unaided half a day. How long have I slept?” For he could not have slept that long, drowsiness still tugged at him. He felt as though he could sleep several more hours simply by closing his eyes.

Bilbo glanced up as he made a quick calculation. “Twelve—maybe fourteen hours?” Thorin’s eyes widened. “Almost half the day again has gone since I woke up, but I thought it best to let you sleep. After breakfast, I retraced our steps back to the archives earlier and brought back the rest of the books I had my eye on. I’ve been reading those most of the day.” As he spoke, Bilbo made a flicking motion with his wrist that tossed the chopped vegetables and sausages in the frying pan, then looked at Thorin out of the corner of his eye. “You know, if you’ve been sleeping like this lately it’s no wonder you missed the battle. I’ve been walking around, banging pots and pans all day and you never stirred. I had to check your breathing a few times to make sure you were still alive.”

Thorin grunted and untangled himself from the winding cloth, catching sight of his arms as he pulled them free. The scales had spread no further in the night; though the dead skin had flaked away so the entire top of his forearm was armored. It seemed the sickness had halted, not traveling while he slept as it had the last time.

He propped himself up in his bedroll, sitting cross-legged as he took up the plate from where Bilbo had left it on the floor. The hobbit had given him the lion’s share of the meat, but there were some vegetable portions in there as well, tucked underneath as if Bilbo hoped he would not notice. Thorin felt no appetite in any case but shrugged, idly picking over the pieces with his fork before taking his first bite.

Flavor exploded over his tongue: salt, grease and fat, spices of fennel and pepper. His eyes widened and he made short work of the rest of the plate, unable to slow himself for even a moment. His stomach, which he had long ignored and only now realized just how long, felt like an empty pit. For the first time in days, warmth flooded him, and not the warmth of fire or the chemical burn of its alchemy, but a reviving energy that banished the emptiness that had hollowed him since the first days of the itching.

Bilbo watched him as he ate, a fond smile at the edge of his lips, and refilled Thorin’s plate without prompting. “Hardly fit for a palace such as this, but winter stores being what they are I did my best to make it palatable. It occurred to me that something hearty would not go amiss: you have not eaten for some time.”

Thorin at least remembered himself enough to swallow before he responded, “Winter stores? This may be the finest meal I’ve ever had.”

“Hmph, there you go with the flattery again,” Bilbo said, taking some of the leftover vegetables for himself and passing the remainder to Thorin. “We have a saying that hunger is the best sauce. That’s probably more to do with the flavor than any craft of my own.”

Thorin made a skeptical sound and returned to his meal. His hunger lead him to wonder if there would be enough to satiate it, but the hobbit had judged well enough and there was no lingering want once he finished his plate. He felt he could face the day, even the world, with more vigor. The horror of the previous day was receding from his mind, and even the curse that corrupted his skin no longer seemed insurmountable.

“I fetched us some water as well from those fountains in the hall, so you can go have a wash. Once you’re done I’ll show you what I found,” Bilbo said. “Oh, and I had a thought.” He took out a stoppered vial of green glass from the second of the packs, handing it to Thorin.

“What is this?” Thorin said, holding the bottle to the firelight and giving it a shake. It was a clear, viscous liquid, some kind of oil.

“One of Óin’s ointments. He labeled it for the treatment of burns and rashes. Once you’ve cleaned yourself up, you might put some of that on your skin to slow the breakage,” said Bilbo.

Thorin’s eyebrows rose. “You came remarkably well prepared for your errand.”

“Oh, well,” Bilbo said, dismissing his words with a wave of his hand. “With you gone so long we didn’t know what might have happened, and there are a lot of ways for a body to become injured down here. I’m sure Ga—I’m sure it only made sense to cover all eventualities. I’ve also got some bandages in here, willow bark tea, wood for splints.” He frowned. “None of which are of much use, unless you’re suffering a headache?”

“Nothing so severe that I would welcome the taste of willow bark tea,” Thorin said dryly.

“That being said, more tea is not so bad an idea, I’ll make some up while you wash,” Bilbo said, and went to get the kettle from the row of cooking implements he had set up lining the wall as if it were a kitchen shelf.

Thorin took the opportunity to pick up the water bucket, washcloth, oil vial and the soap beside it and had only just reached the top of the stairs when Bilbo’s voice came from behind him. “Not down there, Thorin, I’d like to keep an eye on you if at all possible.”

Thorin turned, giving Bilbo a frank look as he put down the bucket and unclasped the cloak with one hand. It fluttered to the floor, leaving him bare-chested, and he was rewarded by the sight of the hobbit turning bright red and spinning on his heels with a muffled squeak. Bilbo stared up at the ceiling with his back turned as he said, “The top of the steps will do! Just don’t go wandering off.”

With a satisfied smirk, Thorin turned back to the staircase. Nevertheless, he accepted Bilbo’s request and only went far enough down so that he as out of the hobbit’s immediate sight. The gold of the treasury unfurled like a sea below, calling to him, but he turned away, taking a seat and lathering the washcloth with soap and water. Like the hot meal, it was a wonder he had forgotten how good it was to feel clean once again, even if it did mean a sponge bath with frigid water.

Thorin stripped, then sloughed off the dead skin that peeled at the edges of the scales, cleaned his face and released the braids ragged from days of slumber, washing his hair as best he could before re-braiding it. There were bathhouses in Erebor that drew their heat from the forges, and he could not help but think longingly of them. But to go there would mean crossing the sea of gold, and it was unlikely in any case that the plumbing was still functioning after all these years. Furthermore, revitalized as he was by food and rest, he had to admit that he had made a promise to Bilbo. To go back on it for so trivial a reason would be unfair to one who had already done much for him.

Thorin finished his washing, putting back on the smallclothes and loose black trousers that were the only fabric he could bear to have against his peeling skin, when he recalled the vial of Óin’s ointment. He poured an experimental drop into his hand and instantly felt its cooling effects, the scent of mint biting and sharp in the air. Perhaps treating his skin thus would slow the breakage, perhaps it would not, but at least its touch was soothing. He rubbed the oil into the seam between scales and skin, his face, arms, chest, and feet, and the cool liquid brought instant relief to his heated flesh.

Only when he finished the spots he could reach and the bottle was half empty did he realize he had a slight problem. Thorin probed the back of his neck, feeling the hard ridges that went down his spine. He still had no idea how bad the damage was on his back, and flinched at the memory of when he first awoke, and the awful tearing sound.

When Bilbo arrived, the hobbit’s horror had been instant at the sight of Thorin’s shirtless form. He had gone from pale to bright red, babbling as he burrowed through his pack to find Thorin the blue cloak he wore now. As a result, Thorin had given the hobbit no time to see or comment on the damage to his back, and ever since had hidden it behind the cloak. There was really only one thing for it, though his stomach churned strangely at the thought of Bilbo probing at his ruined flesh. Thorin collected the bucket, vial and washcloth, and mounted the steps back to the campsite.

Bilbo was sitting cross-legged by the fire, his chin propped up on one hand as he read over a scroll draped on his opposite knee. The plates were cleaned and stacked beside him, but he appeared to have paused in the middle of making the tea and forgotten all about it as he became engrossed in the text. His eyebrows were drawn together, and one of his furred feet tapped rhythmically against the floor as his eyes scanned the paper. With a sigh he put the scroll aside, rolling it up with great care before selecting another from the stack.

Thorin paused, arrested by the sight, and withdrew into the shadows beyond the firelight. There was something calming about watching Bilbo read, something he did not wish to lose so quickly. Often Bilbo had a frantic energy to him that Thorin had taken for fussiness, but in retrospect may have been simple anxiety as he adjusted, day after day, to tasks at which he had little familiarity. It had been frustrating at first for him to deal with one who had such poor skills at living on the road, it had not occurred to Thorin at the time that Bilbo may have no training at all, and was in fact a very fast learner, picking up what was needed to be at least mediocre in a remarkably short time.

Yet with books Bilbo was, as he had said, in his element, and it showed in the air of calm that surrounded him now. For the first time since he sat at the heart of the treasure, Thorin felt a strange sort of… warmth fill him, that was nothing like that which came from the gold. It calmed him and, in the quiet of his mind, he thought that he might watch the hobbit read for many hours and not grow restless.

As he watched, Thorin’s mind drifted back to the early days of their acquaintance, and he wondered if the hobbit knew what power he wielded over the company and their quest. That he was the fourteenth member, the luck of the party. When Thorin had asked Gandalf to find such a one, only to be presented a hobbit, and on who appeared so weak, so frankly ridiculous, it had been a slap in the face. Thorin knew he held the hearts of the company by a thread, that the entire journey was like staring into the sun, damaging, doomed, and over the moment one of them blinked. But Gandalf, curse him, would not be swayed even though his “burglar’s” heart seemed so fragile with homesickness that there was no hope of him making it out of his sleepy little village, let alone across the wide world. What was worse, if Bilbo fell he would act as a domino, raising doubts in those who had their own homes to think of, their own families, who would again look at the odds and find them wanting. Thorin could clearly imagine the little burglar disappearing in a huff, and the ties that bound the company failing behind him. And for what? Why risk all on a wizard’s say-so, on a lucky number?

So he had pushed the burglar, spurned him, pointed out his flaws for all to see, dared him to abandon the quest. For the moment would inevitably come when Bilbo would leave. Let the others see that it was the frailty of hobbits, not the value of Erebor, that caused his heart to fail.

Then Bilbo had left as predicted, or tried to, if not for Bofur, and Thorin had not known why he felt only shame at the thought that he had caused this, that he had driven their luck away. But sure enough Bilbo vanished in the ensuing chaos and Thorin had cursed his own sense of shame, that he had allowed that little hope in for even a moment, a glimpse of the very disappointment he had tried to forestall. For they were a doomed party, hollow, pushed forward by fire and hatred and a desperate, painful longing to face the greatest calamity of their age. They had only a fool’s hope of survival, let alone success, and yet they forged on, defying the very laws of nature, flying and daring not to look down lest they inevitably fall.

Then Bilbo had stayed. Leapt out from behind a tree when only a moment before Thorin had cursed him. He could not help but have heard Thorin’s words, certainly Thorin heard his after. How, wonder of wonders, he would stay. Not for treasure or power or fame, only because he was homesick and he wished to end the homesickness in Thorin’s company, in his people… and in Thorin.

In that moment Thorin saw what it truly meant to have luck with them, for that terrible blistering hope came back ten times over, and he saw a quest not running on hollow hopes and empty longing, but honor and faith and loyalty. All those things he had dreamed of, all that had been denied them by their allies and by their own kin. And this…burglar, this frustrating impossible hobbit had brought it to them?

It was almost unimportant after that how Bilbo defended him with sword and body against Azog. Thorin was lost. He was lost to the vision of hope gifted to him by a stranger, one who wanted nothing for himself, who only saw a wrong that must be righted, who saw Thorin’s people and loved them as he did and would work to protect and aid them. To whom he was not even a king to command loyalty, only a friend in need.

How and when had that changed in Thorin’s mind? His brow crinkled as watched Bilbo bent over the scroll. The firelight caught the mithril shirt Bilbo wore under his blue coat, the one Thorin had gifted him so that he may be safe from harm. He had not counted on the harm Bilbo would bring to himself, or that he… He frowned, for that niggling annoyance that so easily turned to rage was back in the corner of his mind. It whispered that Bilbo had deserved it, that Thorin would have done the same to anyone who stole from him, as was his right as king. But threatening to throw him from the ramparts? It was…extreme, even for such a betrayal. And that shame was back, the shame he had felt when Bilbo had almost turned back to Rivendell. After all Bilbo had done for Thorin, and for his people, why had he leapt so quickly to such terrible rage? Why had he….?

Thorin lowered the pail to the ground, and pressed his freed hand to his temple. He wondered if a storm had kicked up beyond the hidden door, for there was the distant rushing sound like a blast of wind, like a distant hurricane, and he could not pinpoint its source. He squinted against the distant pounding sound of the wind, pressing his hand to his face and feeling the intense, feverish heat that built there, and as he did he looked at the hobbit. The rushing sound dimmed in his ears.

Bilbo had not shifted, did not even seem aware of the wider world while he read. He was utterly engrossed by the search for Thorin’s cure, still bearing hope even when Thorin had all but collapsed into despair. Bilbo had easily dismissed his fears with logic and kindness, helped him to his bedroll and done everything short of tuck him in before seeking rest himself. Even now he did not seem the least perturbed to be alone in a kingdom of ghosts, alongside one who had almost killed him.

Bilbo read quickly, his lips drawn to a thin, unmoving line as he did so. Silent reading, the mark of a scholar. He must have learned from early childhood to have mastered the art. His shoulders were relaxed as he lounged, as perhaps he had many nights back in his home in the Shire. He would need only his pipe to complete the picture, as he had so often related on their journey, and no sooner had Thorin thought this than Bilbo patted his breast pocket, then turned to look through the pack.

It was then that Bilbo espied Thorin. And as he did, the rushing died entirely, the pounding sound fading to silence, and once again Thorin remembered that he stood at the edge of the firelight like a recalcitrant child. He suddenly felt rather foolish to be caught watching Bilbo thus, and he quickly picked up his pail and stepped from the shadows as if nothing had happened. “I’m afraid I must beg a favor, Bilbo.”

Bilbo opened his mouth and Thorin waited patiently for his reply. Yet no sound came out but a strangled squeak. That deep red blush was back, staining his cheeks and travelling down to his collar, but then Bilbo was sitting closer to the fire in order to better read by its light, which could be the only explanation.

With a pang of realization, Thorin looked down at his exposed torso, covered as it was in foul black scales. So far the scales had not interfered with the hair on his body— neither his beard, the hair on his chest, nor the trail between navel and groin. There was no telling how much longer that would be true, before muscle and sinew broke and twisted into reptilian form and the transformation robbed him of all signs he was ever a dwarf. The thought alone brought a rush of humiliation, and with an inarticulate mumble he snatched up the cloak from the ground where he had dropped it before his bath and draped it over his arm. He considered tossing it back over his shoulders then and there, to retreat once more into the shadow of its fold, only to be reminded by the flash of firelight on scales of the necessity of his request.

He took a deep breath, and steeled himself, ignoring how Bilbo’s eyes traveled up and down a body that no doubt repulsed him. Thorin cleared his throat, “The corruption is spreading. I’ve treated it with the ointment where I could, but I must beg your assistance in the places beyond my reach.”

“Excuse me, where?” Bilbo said in a strangled yelp as he jerked his eyes from Thorin’s chest to his face.

Thorin frowned. “My back? If you would please check for any damage there, it would be a kindness.”

“Oh…oh! Your back, but of course!” Bilbo said. The scroll fell from his lap as he jumped to his feet. Thorin mentally retracted the thought that Bilbo was no longer so nervous as he had once been. The hobbit was positively twitchy now, tapping his fingertips together and looking at every part of the room except where Thorin stood in front of him.

Best to get the ordeal over with, for he did not like to admit even to himself the sick feeling that curled in his stomach at the thought that Bilbo could not even look at him without his cloak. Thorin nodded his thanks and knelt down beside the fire, angling the light to his back. He closed his eyes and tried to lose himself in the play of its warmth on his skin, for a chill had followed him of late when he did not lie at the heart of the treasure. What was worse, nerves at how Bilbo saw him now had chased away the pleasant glow of earlier.

Then he heard the sharp intake of breath from behind him.

Thorin’s spine went rigid and he gritted his teeth against the image of Bilbo recoiling in horror from what he saw. There was no pain, so it could not be a wound that caused such a reaction, only whatever fell transformation the curse had wrought. “Stop. It’s not important, I should not have troubled you,” Thorin said and began to rise.

“Oh, no you don’t!” Bilbo said, and seized Thorin by the shoulder, shoving him back down.

Thorin shivered as a gentle touch traced the back of his neck and he felt Bilbo’s fingers brushing his hair, gathering it up, and then carefully laying it over his shoulder. Then the light touch moved again, probing Thorin’s side, and he jerked away with a hiss.

“Would you stop that?” Bilbo snapped. Then Bilbo sighed and said, “I’m sorry, it’s just… There’s a lot going on here, Thorin, and it’s worse than I thought.”

“How bad?” Thorin said, as a wash of cold wash of dread swept through him.

“Do you feel that?” Thorin waited. There was nothing, no brush of air or pressure of touch. He shook his head.

“I was afraid of that,” Bilbo said. “The scales are much thicker back here.” Thorin heard a tapping sound. “Do you hear that? There’s a raised ridge over your spine, and scales to either side of it are hard as rocks. It’s all segmented, which may be why you can still stand as usual. It stops right here,” Thorin felt a light touch against the base of his neck, then Bilbo traced a narrow oval on either side of the spine from shoulder blade to hip. “The pattern is shaped a bit like a cat’s eye, the scales cover you from your neck to your, uh, lower back. No wonder you couldn’t see it.” Bilbo paused, his hands resting on Thorin’s hips. “There are no other injuries as such, though I imagine there wouldn’t be. You might as well be wearing armor.”

“Thank you,” Thorin murmured and exhaled. He closed his eyes and covered them with one shaking hand as he imagined the transformation Bilbo described.

There was a quiet plink and the gentle touch returned. The scent of mint filled the air and a pleasant chill spread across the edges of Thorin’s back. It took him a moment to realize that Bilbo was applying the ointment to the seams between skin and scales. “There’s no need,” Thorin protested.

“Please,” Bilbo said, cutting him off, and Thorin stilled at the pleading in his voice. “Just…let me do what I can.”

Thorin subsided, sitting in silence as Bilbo spread the ointment over his skin. He could feel Bilbo’s breath stir at the back of his neck, and shivered more at that than the cool touch of the ointment. Even if the ointment did nothing it was…pleasant, to feel another’s hand after weeks—no, months of the road, of isolation and command, of keeping himself aloof and clear-headed throughout the quest. More than pleasant, he all but melted at the touch, losing himself in the quiet minutes that passed between them, in how good it felt to simply be touched, in forgetting for a little while the reason for it. His mind drifted into vague imaginings that there was another reason, a happier one, for the gentle brush of hands over his shoulders, trailing down the back of his neck and along his sides. He sighed when it ended, inhaling the scent of mint that hung thick in the air. Bilbo stoppered the bottle, excusing himself with a murmur as he went to wash the oil from his hands.

Thorin opened his eyes slowly, only to be hit with the jarring reality. He snatched up the blue cloak from where it lay on the ground beside him, tossing it back over his shoulders, and by the time Bilbo returned he had pulled the hood up to shadow his face. “My apologies again that you had to see that,” Thorin said without turning to look at Bilbo.

Bilbo harrumphed from behind him. “Well, I’m afraid I cannot accept that.” Thorin’s stomach dropped and he looked resolutely forward, unwilling to meet the hobbit’s eyes. Little good it did him, as Bilbo walked around to face Thorin with his arms crossed. A scroll dangled from one hand. At the sight of Thorin’s closed expression Bilbo rolled his eyes and sat down across from him. “Call it what you will, but the fact is that you are ill, Thorin. I can no more blame you for this illness than I could if you caught a fever. And if I refuse to forgive you it is because there is nothing to forgive, at least not when it comes to this.”

Something unknotted in Thorin’s chest at Bilbo’s words and he gave a slight nod of acknowledgement. Though in his heart he could not find that he agreed he was…grateful, for the thought.

“Now, if you’re ready,” Bilbo continued, unraveling the scroll and placing it on the ground between them. “This to me seems the most promising text, since it’s the only one that carries any mention of dwarves.”

“Trust the Elves to have no care for the history or the suffering of my people,” Thorin said with a grimace.

“Well excuse me, I only got through one shelf before you went tearing out of there,” said Bilbo.  “But you’re right, they are mostly Elvish texts, so it’s Gondolin this, and Túrin that, everywhere you look. Now, are you going to listen to what I found or should I get comfortable while you go off on another rant about the elves?”

Thorin was preparing to do just that when he caught himself, or rather caught what Bilbo had said. “Do I really spend so much time talking about them?”

“To put it mildly? If you wrote as much as you talked, you’d already have several volumes on the subject. Indeed, if I hadn’t met any elves along our journey I would have assumed they were worse than orcs by your account.”

“And who is to say they are not?” Thorin said. Bilbo openly gaped, then caught sight of the tiny smirk at the edge Thorin’s lips.

“Remember what I said about how you might have charged the elves instead of the orcs had you been at the battle? I take it back: it’s not a possibility, it’s a certainty.” Bilbo laughed. “And if I didn’t know any better, I would say you made another joke just then. You know how I feel about those, I’m not sure my heart can take the shock any further.”

“Then it was clearly your imagination,” Thorin said loftily, and turned the scroll around so that he could see the Westron letters right-side up. “Nevertheless, talking of elves seems a habit I must break. They do not warrant the breath it takes to name them.”

Bilbo gave an exasperated chuckle, and leaned over the scroll. “Oh I don’t know; I may even miss it. Without elves to complain about you may never speak again.” Thorin snorted and with a grin Bilbo inclined his head and pointed to the scroll.

“Fortunately, this account has nothing to do with elves, rather it deals with a Lord of the Éothéod, by the name of Fram. Apparently he made a deal with some dwarves to hunt a dragon called Scatha.”

“I know of Fram,” Thorin interrupted. “We have another name for him, one he shares with Thingol, for those who refuse to pay the agreed price.”

“Elves again,” Bilbo muttered under his breath, then said louder, “And what word would that be?”

Thorin shook his head. “I cannot teach it to you. Suffice to say it is not a pleasant one. To bear such a name is to be marked for death by any dwarf who comes upon him.”

“Well, that does make sense,” Bilbo said, tapping a paragraph. “They dealt with him quickly enough. Fram and the dwarves agreed he would turn the hoard over to them once the dragon was dead, instead he gave them a necklace of Scatha’s teeth. They killed him soon thereafter.”

Thorin gave a grim chuckle. “He should have expected no less. None may be allowed to give such insult and live to tell of it. But what does this have to do finding a cure?”

“I was thinking,” Bilbo said, “that maybe it had something to do with the teeth? If perhaps it was this…dragon sickness, for lack of a better word, that drove Fram mad enough to deny the dwarves their pay?”

“Even if that were true, there is still no reason to believe that the race of Men suffers from this curse as we do. And if they did, why would you think it the teeth and not the gold itself?” Thorin said, frowning.

“Because if that’s the case there’s not much we can do other than to take the entire hoard and toss it down the nearest mine shaft, either that or wall it off until the corruption fades,” Bilbo said. Thorin’s eyes widened, his breath froze in his throat and his whole body seized as if he had been stabbed. “And since I gather that’s not a solution you would find acceptable, I began looking for other possibilities.”

“Then you are not a hopeless judge of character,” Thorin said once he caught his breath, though his heart still hammered in his chest at the mere thought of destroying all the great works in the room with them. He took a second to collect himself before continuing, “Yet even if the curse could pass to Fram, he only acted as a dragon, he did not become one.”

“Who is to say?” Bilbo said. “Perhaps he was killed too quickly for anyone to find out. Before you… found me in the library, I was thinking that there might be a curse put on whoever kills the dragon. But that cannot be true, otherwise it would have fallen upon Bard. So if we assume Fram was suffering the earlier stages: irrational acts, overwhelming greed, hoarding the treasure to himself, and…” Bilbo trailed off then slowly, as if he could not stop himself, his gazed climbed to Thorin’s face.

“Go on,” Thorin said flatly.

Bilbo cleared his throat. “Uh, that is, if we take Fram as a possible example, then the teeth he carried with him might have had some impact on his behavior when he went to the dwarves. If there was an enchantment, it didn’t lift when he distanced himself from the treasure. So maybe it wasn’t the gold itself, but something that was in the gold?”

“Then you believe there may be something, some piece of Smaug that remains, and exudes the disease?” Thorin said. He considered this. After all, that a physical piece of the dragon was what ultimately corrupted the gold did not necessarily contradict Mîm’s account. And there was the possibility that Bilbo was right earlier when he said that Mîm may not fully know or understand all aspects of the curse, for by his own admission he had not been in the pits of the Angband when the first dragon came forth.

Bilbo shrugged. “Smaug lived here for over a century, there could well be bits of him still lying about, teeth and toenail clippings. I should imagine every piece of that creature would be foul with magic.”

“So we find it where it lies and destroy it,” Thorin said. He found the idea…intriguing. Warmed by the food he had eaten, washed and feeling himself for the first time in days—weeks really, since they had first entered by the hidden door— he found himself nodding at the possibility as he leaned in closer to Bilbo.

“Yes,” Bilbo said. “And if that doesn’t work, we go to Gandalf for help.”

“Gandalf again,” Thorin muttered. “I have already said I will have no dealings with that charlatan.”

“If we destroy this piece of Smaug and nothing happens, then we’ll be right back where we started,” Bilbo said impatiently. “Unless you’ve got a better idea, this is where I put my foot down.” Bilbo tilted his chin up and looked Thorin in the eye, as if daring to be contradicted.

“Then perhaps I should be clearer: I will not go to Gandalf for aid ever again,” Thorin said.

“Well I’m open to suggestions.” Bilbo spread his hands wide. “Anything at all, and we’ll try it.” Thorin met his gaze with stony silence. “Thorin,” Bilbo continued, dropping his voice lower and leaning in, “this is serious. How long do you think it will be before this is irreversible? We only have one shot at doing it your way, and even this may take too long. I understand your misgivings about Gandalf, I really do.” He didn’t, to Thorin’s ears. “But it’s only fair that if we try it your way first we must next try it mine.”

“I do not recall this being a negotiation,” Thorin growled.

“It must be, as far as I’m concerned, or we’ve no hope of working together at all. I may not be a dwarf to kill people who break bargains with me, I’d have no relatives left if I did, but let me promise you that if you go back on this I will be quite upset with you.”

“And if I do not agree at all?” Thorin said. That twisting anger was waking, surging through his veins like living flame.

“It’s this or I fetch Gandalf right now, Thorin. I am a hobbit, not one of your subjects, and if I’m still here it’s out of friendship. I—”

Thorin’s claws flexed, and Bilbo’s head moved slowly as he turned to look down at them. It would be an easy thing to do, to be sure he would never leave this hall carrying tales…Thorin saw flashes of blood so clear he could taste it. Revulsion followed closed behind.

“Very well, I agree to your terms,” Thorin said quickly, and the anger flashed again but this time he pushed it ruthlessly aside. The image played still at the back of his mind, of silencing Bilbo forever and walling the last passage up against intruders. The image rode on anger that refused to be suppressed, that resisted as he tried to bury it. He could not recall being so easily enraged before the quest, but then there had been less at stake.

Or not, another portion of his mind reminded him, there had been many more worries in Ered Luin, and in their exile, but now it felt like every day was a gamble, there was still so much at stake and there was….

His life, and Bilbo’s life. What else was there? It was simple, the world narrowed to two beating hearts. And for the first time it occurred to Thorin what terrible danger Bilbo had risked in coming here, as he tasted the memory of blood in his mouth, hot and coppery, and set his teeth against it. What did it matter that he did not think Bilbo’s plan would work? What choice did he have if that were true, save to end it all or throw himself on the mercy of his enemies?

It may have been worth it in any case for the look of relief that dawned over Bilbo’s face, along with a slow smile. Shame flooded Thorin, so biting and sharp that he had to look down because he could not bear to look Bilbo in the eye, and see the hobbit’s simple happiness that he be allowed to help, when Thorin had done nothing but curse Bilbo and nearly kill him.

“Bilbo, there is something I must tell you,” Thorin said. Bilbo perked up, looking at Thorin askance. Thorin’s heart thundered in his ears and he exhaled to release the last of his nerves at what he was to say. It was a horrifying thought, and part of him rebelled at the very idea of it, at all which it entailed, but the possibility had plagued him since the first day of the itching. He paused to slide the scroll away as he gathered his words, and moved closer to Bilbo. “I think— I fear this illness may have begun some time ago. When we first entered the mountain.”

Bilbo’s breath left him in a rush. “Thorin, even if it’s been that long it doesn’t mean there isn’t a cure.”

Thorin shook his head. “That is not my meaning. I recognize now that my behavior since then has been…erratic; my treatment of you and the others has not been… as I would have wished it to be. I thought only that it was the effects of seeing my home once more, of having all so close within my grasp, and so I did not check myself, did not recognize it as I should have for—for the illness of my line."

"I do not say this to excuse myself, or because I believe I can change it now. I think… it will only get worse as this progresses, for I cannot say always what is my own will and what is not. I know only that every day it becomes stronger, and there may soon be a time when I can no longer pull myself back from this brink. Where I began, or how the intentions I had when we first set out for our home became so confused in the taking of it, is lost to me. I am adrift, so far from where I once was that if there is a way back I no longer see it.”

Bilbo opened his mouth to protest but Thorin held up a hand to silence him, and finally looked up, giving a pleading look. “I have already asked too much of you, taken you far from your home and threatened your life through my choices and by my own hand. I have no right to ask more, but I do not know how this will end, even if you are right and we find a cure, my behavior may grow worse before then. Much worse. So all I can do is beg you to understand: this is not who I am. This is not who I wish to be. If all fails please, remember that, and remember me as I once was. Not this. Not how I have acted since we entered here, or what I have done to you since then.” Thorin released a shuddering sigh. “I know it is a great deal to ask, and it would be well within your right to refuse—”

Thorin was cut off by impact, enough that were he not braced he might have toppled over. Stunned, he looked down to see Bilbo’s arms wrapped around him, his face buried in the crook of Thorin’s neck, scales and all, for Thorin’s stomach twisted at the thought of Bilbo pressed close to the corruption of his flesh, and he moved to disentangle him, but his clawed fingers hovered over Bilbo’s shoulders, hesitating.

Bilbo’s arms tightened around him, and Thorin stiffened as he felt dampness against his throat. Bilbo held on for a long, silent moment that was punctuated only by the hobbit’s harsh breathing. Then as if sensing Thorin’s shock, Bilbo gave a shaky, tearful laugh, “I’m sorry,” his grip loosened. “I suppose I’ve been a bit on edge myself. These past weeks have been quite stressful, and I just mean I… of course. Of course I forgive you, Thorin,” Bilbo sniffed, fighting to bring his breathing under control as he loosened his grip, and pulled away enough to look down. “I’m sorry, that really was a bit much. I promise I am not usually so… so… Anyway, forgive me, I know you do not like to be touched,” Bilbo said, and moved to pull away.

Something like panic welled up in Thorin’s heart, for he felt Bilbo tremble against him as he withdrew, could feel the reluctance with which he did so in the stiffness of his arm and the way his fingers trailed along Thorin’s arm. It struck him like a bolt through the heart just how much he had misjudged Bilbo. That he may not be disgusted by the change, but merely respecting Thorin’s space, while feeling as isolated and cut off as Thorin himself. That Thorin in turn had denied him the comfort and reassurance that Bilbo had so freely granted him.

He remembered Bilbo’s words, that it would have been nice to hear praise from time to time, to be thanked or acknowledged for his deeds. Thorin marveled that he had not seen it sooner: that he had failed to do something so simple as show Bilbo that he was wanted and appreciated. The entire realization passed through him between one breath and the next.

On its heels came a wave of desperation, knowing he could never put it all into words, and with that desperation in his heart, Thorin seized Bilbo before he could pull away and dragged him close. Bilbo started, but Thorin must have guessed aright for Bilbo melted against him, clutching him in return. After a moment his trembling slowed, then ceased altogether.

For a long time they only held one another, as if touch alone could anchor them in place, in this moment where there was still a glimpse of light. For beyond it, as far as Thorin could see, was only darkness.

 



In a field
Behaving as the wind behaves
No nearer—

Not that final meeting
In the twilight kingdom

 

Notes:

I also wrote an alternate, explicit version of this chapter that you can find in chapter 1 of Lips that would kiss.

 

This chapter has fanart!
Moment in Time by akahime4
Thorin by Drakyrna